By Author [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Title [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Language
all Classics books content using ISYS

Download this book: [ ASCII ]

Look for this book on Amazon

We have new books nearly every day.
If you would like a news letter once a week or once a month
fill out this form and we will give you a summary of the books for that week or month by email.

Title: 7 to 12 - A Detective Story
Author: Green, Anna Katharine
Language: English
As this book started as an ASCII text book there are no pictures available.
Copyright Status: Not copyrighted in the United States. If you live elsewhere check the laws of your country before downloading this ebook. See comments about copyright issues at end of book.

*** Start of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "7 to 12 - A Detective Story" ***

This book is indexed by ISYS Web Indexing system to allow the reader find any word or number within the document.

produced from images generously made available by The
Internet Archive)

                                WORKS OF
                          ANNA KATHARINE GREEN

     I——THE LEAVENWORTH CASE. A Lawyer’s Story.
        4to, paper, 20 cents; 16mo, paper, 50 cents; 16mo, cloth,  $1 00

        4to, paper, 20 cents; 16mo, paper, 50 cents; 16mo, cloth,  $1 00

        4to, paper, 20 cents; 16mo, paper, 50 cents; 16mo, cloth,  $1 00

    IV——THE SWORD OF DAMOCLES. A Story of New York Life.
        16mo, paper, 50 cents; cloth                               $1 00

     V——X. Y. Z. A Detective Story.
        16mo, paper                                                   25

    VI——THE DEFENCE OF THE BRIDE, and other Poems.
        16mo, cloth                                                $1 00

        16mo, paper, 50 cents; cloth                               $1 00

        16mo, cloth                                                $1 00

    IX——7 to 12. A Story.
        16mo, paper                                                   25

                     G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, PUBLISHERS,
                            NEW YORK AND LONDON.

                                 7 to 12
                            A DETECTIVE STORY

                          ANNA KATHARINE GREEN

                           NEW YORK AND LONDON
                           G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS
                         The Knickerbocker Press

                              COPYRIGHT BY
                           G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS

                                Press of
                          G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS
                                New York


        7 TO 12, A DETECTIVE STORY                                1

        ONE HOUR MORE                                            79

7 TO 12.



“Yes, sir.”

“Another entrance through a second-story window. A detective wanted
right off. Better hurry up there, —— East Seventy-third Street.”

“All right, sir.”

Clarke turned to go; but the next moment I heard the Superintendent
call him back.

“It is Mr. Winchester’s, you know; the banker.”

Clarke nodded and started again; but a suppressed exclamation from the
Superintendent made him stop for the second time.

“I’ve changed my mind,” said the latter, folding up the slip of paper
he held in his hand. “You can see what Halley has for you to do; I’ll
attend to this.” And giving me a look that was a summons, he whispered
in my ear: “This notification was written by Mr. Winchester himself,
and at the bottom I see hurriedly added, ‘Keep it quiet; send your
discreetest man.’ That means something more than a common burglary.”

I nodded, and the affair was put in my hands. As I was going out of the
door, a fellow detective came hurriedly in.

“Nabbed them,” cried he.

“Who?” asked more than one voice.

“The fellows who have been climbing into second-story windows, and
helping themselves while the family is at dinner.”

I stopped.

“Where did you catch them?” I asked.

“In Twenty-second Street.”


“Not two hours ago.”

I looked at the Superintendent. He gave a curious lift of his brows,
which I answered with a short smile. In another moment I was in the

My first ring at the bell of No. —— East Seventy-third Street brought
response in the shape of Mr. Winchester himself. Seeing me, his
countenance fell, but in another instant brightened as I observed:

“You sent for a detective, sir;” and quietly showed him my badge.

“Yes,” he murmured; “but I did not expect”——he paused. I was
used to these pauses; I do not suppose I look exactly like the
ordinary detective. “Your name?” he asked, ushering me into a small

“Byrd,” I replied. And taking as a compliment the look of satisfaction
which crossed his face as he finished a hasty but keen scrutiny of my
countenance and figure, I in turn subjected him to a respectful but
earnest glance of interrogation.

“There has been a robbery here,” I ventured.

He nodded, and a look of care replaced the affable expression which a
moment before had so agreeably illumined his somewhat stern features.

“Twenty-five thousand dollars’ worth,” he whispered, shortly. “Mrs.
Winchester’s diamonds.”

I started; not so much at the nature and value of the articles stolen,
as at the indefinable air with which this announcement was made by the
wealthy and potential broker and banker. If his all had been taken his
eye could not have darkened with a deeper shadow; if that all had been
lost through means which touched his personal pride and feelings, he
could not have given a sharper edge to his tones, business-like as he
endeavored to make them.

“A heavy loss,” I remarked. “Will you give me the details of the affair
as far as you know them?”

He shook his head and waved his hand with a slight gesture towards the

“I prefer that you learn them from such inquiries as you will make
above,” said he. “My wife will tell you what she knows about it, and
there is a servant or two who may have something to say. I would speak
to no one else,” he added, with a deepening of the furrow in his brow;
“at least not at present. Only,”——and here his manner became markedly
impressive,——“understand this. Those diamonds _must_ be found in
forty-eight hours, no matter who suffers, or what consequences follow
a firm and determined pursuit of them. I will stop at nothing to
have them back in the time mentioned, and I do not expect you to. If
they are here by Thursday night——” and the hand he held out with its
fingers curved and grasping actually trembled with his vehemence——“I
will give you five hundred dollars Friday afternoon. If they are here
without noise, scandal, or——” his voice sank further——“disquietude to
my wife, I will increase the sum to a thousand. Isn’t that handsome?”
he queried, with an attempt at a lighter tone, which was not altogether

“Very,” was my short but deferential reply. And, interested enough by
this time, I turned towards the door, when he stopped me.

“One moment,” said he. “I have endeavored not to forestall your
judgment by any surmises or conclusions of my own. But, after you have
investigated the matter and come to some sort of theory in regard to
it, I should like to hear what you have to say.”

“I will be happy to consult with you,” was my reply; and, seeing
that he had no further remarks to offer, I prepared to accompany him

The house was a superb one, and not the least handsome portion of it
was the staircase. As we went up, the eye rested everywhere on the
richest artistic effects of carved wood-work and tapestry hangings.
Nor was the glitter of brass lacking, nor the sensuous glow which is
cast by the light striking through ruby-colored glass. At the top was
a square hall fitted up with divans and heavily bespread with rugs. At
one end a half-drawn portière disclosed a suite of apartments furnished
with a splendor equal to that which marked the rest of the house, while
at the other was a closed door, towards which Mr. Winchester advanced.

I was hastily following him, when a young man, coming from above,
stepped between us. Mr. Winchester at once turned.

“Are you going out?” he asked this person, in a tone that lacked the
cordiality of a parent, while it yet suggested the authority of one.

The young gentleman, who was of fine height and carriage, paused with
a curious, hesitating air.

“Are you?” he inquired, ignoring my presence, or possibly not noticing
it, I being several feet from him and somewhat in the shadow.

“We may show ourselves at the Smiths for a few minutes, by and by,” Mr.
Winchester returned.

“No; I am not going out,” the young man said, and, turning, he went
again up-stairs.

Mr. Winchester’s eye followed him. It was only for a moment; but to
me, accustomed as I am to note the smallest details in the manner and
expression of a person, there was a language in that look which opened
a whole field of speculation.

“Your son?” I inquired, stepping nearer to him.

“My wife’s son,” he replied; and, without giving me an opportunity to
put another query, he opened the door before him and ushered me in.

A tall, elegant woman of middle age was seated before the mirror,
having the final touches given to her rich toilette by a young woman
who knelt on the floor at her side. A marked picture, and this not from
the accessories of wealth and splendor everywhere observable, but from
the character of the two faces, which, while of an utterly dissimilar
cast, and possibly belonging to the two extremes of society, were both
remarkable for their force and individuality of expression, as well as
for the look of trouble and suppressed anxiety, which made them both
like the shadows of one deep, dark thought.

The younger woman was the first to notice us and rise. Though occupying
a humble position and accustomed to defer to those around her, there
was extreme grace in her movement and a certain charm in her whole
bearing which made it natural for the eye to follow her. I did not
long allow myself this pleasure, however, for in another instant Mrs.
Winchester had caught sight of our forms in the mirror, and, rising
with a certain cold majesty, in keeping with her imposing figure and
conspicuous if mature beauty, stepped towards us with a slow step,
full of repose and quiet determination. Whatever _her_ feelings might
be, they were without the fierceness and acrimony which characterized
those of her husband. But were they less keen? At first glance I
thought not, but at the second I doubted. Mrs. Winchester was already a
riddle to me.

“Millicent,”——so her husband addressed her,——“allow me to introduce
to you a young man from the police force. If the diamonds are to be
recovered before the week is out, he is the man to do it. I pray you
offer him every facility for learning the facts. He may wish to speak
to the servants and to——” his eye roamed towards the young girl, who, I
thought, turned pale under his scrutiny——“to Philippa.”

“Philippa knows nothing,” the lady’s indifferent side-look seemed to
say, but her lips did not move, nor did she speak till he had left the
room and closed the door behind him. Then she turned to me and gave me
first a careless look and then a keener and more sustained one.

“You have been told how I lost my diamonds,” she remarked at length.

“They said at the station that a man had entered by your second-story
window while you were at dinner.”

“Not at dinner,” she corrected gravely. “I do not leave my jewel-box
lying open, while I go down to dinner. I was in the reception-room
below——Mr. Winchester had sent word that he wished to see me for an
instant——and being on the point of going to an evening party, my
diamonds were in their case on the mantel-piece. When I came back
the case was there, but no diamonds. They had been carried off in my

I glanced at the mantel-shelf. On it lay the open jewel-case. “What
made you think a burglar took them?” I asked, my eyes on the lady I was
addressing, but my ears open to the quick, involuntary drawing in of
the breath which had escaped the young girl at the last sentence of her

“The window was up——I had left it closed——and there was a sound of
scurrying feet on the pavement below. I had just time to see the forms
of two men hurrying down the street. You know there have been a series
of burglaries of this nature lately.”

I bowed, for her imperiousness seemed to demand it. Then I glanced at
Philippa. She was standing with her face half averted, trifling with
some object on the table, but her apparent unconcern was forced, and
her hand trembled so that she hastily dropped the article with which
she was toying and turned in such a manner that she hid it as well as
her countenance from view.

I made a note of this and allowed my attention to return to Mrs.

“At what time was this?” I inquired.

“Seven o’clock.”

“Late for a burglary of this kind.”

A flush sudden and deep broke out on the lady’s cheek.

“It was successful, however,” she observed.

Ignoring her anger, which may have arisen from sheer haughtiness and
a natural dislike to having any statement she chose to make commented
upon, I pursued my inquiries.

“And how long, madam, do you think you were down-stairs?”

“Some five minutes or so; certainly not ten.”

“And the window was closed when you left the room and open when you

“I said so.”

I glanced at the windows. They were both closed now and the shades

“May I ask you to show me which window, and also how wide it stood

“It was the window over the stoop, and it stood half-way open.”

I passed at once to the window.

“And the shade?” I asked, turning.

“Was——was down.”

“You are sure, madam?”

“Quite; it was by the noise it made as I opened the door that I noticed
the window was open.”

“Your first glance, then, was not at the mantel-piece?”

“No, sir, but my second was.” Her self-possession was almost cold.

This great lady evidently did not enjoy her position of witness,
notwithstanding the heavy loss she had sustained, and the fact that the
inquisition being made was all in her own interests. I was not to be
repelled by her manner, however, for a suspicion had seized me which
somewhat accounted for the words and method pursued by Mr. Winchester,
and a suspicion once formed, holds imperious sway over the mind of a
detective till it is either disproved by facts or confirmed in the same
manner into a settled belief.

“Madam,” I remarked, “your loss is very great, and demands the most
speedy and vigorous effort on the part of the police, that it may not
result in a permanent one. Has it struck you”——and I looked firmly at
the young girl whom, by my change of position, I had brought again into
view——“that it was in any way peculiar that chance thieves working in
this dangerous and conspicuous manner should know just the moment to
make the hazardous effort which resulted so favorably to themselves?
These burglaries which, as you say, have been so plentiful of late,
have hitherto all taken place at the hour the family are supposed to be
at dinner, while this occurred just when the family would reasonably
be supposed to be returning up-stairs. Besides, the gas was burning in
this room, was it not?”


“And the shades down?”


“So that, till the stoop had been climbed and the room entered, the
thief had every reason to believe it was occupied, unless he had
notification to the contrary from some one better situated than

The lady’s eyes opened, and a slight, sarcastic smile parted her lips;
but I was not studying her at this moment, but the young Philippa.
Humble as she evidently was, and in a condition of mind that caused
her to place a restraint upon herself, she took a step forward as I
said this, and her mouth opened, as if she would fling some word into
the conversation that would neither bear the stamp of humility nor
sustain her previous rôle of indifference. But a moment’s thought was
sufficient to quell her passionate impulse, and in another instant she
was gliding quietly from the room, when I leaned toward Mrs. Winchester
and whispered:

“Request the young woman to wait in the hall outside, and suggest that
she leave the door open. I do not feel like letting out of my sight
just yet any person, no matter how reliable, who has listened to my
last remark.”

Mrs. Winchester looked surprised, and eyed me with something of the
expression she might have betrayed if I had begged her to stop a mouse
from escaping the conference we were holding. But she did what I asked
her, and that with a cold, commanding air which proved that, however
useful she found the deft and graceful Philippa, she had no real
liking for her or any interest in her beyond that which sprang from
the value of her services. Was this state of things the fault of Mrs.
Winchester or of Philippa? I had not time to determine. The docility of
the latter was not, perhaps, to be trusted too far, especially if, as
I half suspected, there was some tie between her and the thieves who
had carried off Mrs. Winchester’s jewels; and while she still lingered
where I could see her, I must put the question so evidently demanded by
the gravity of the situation.

“Mrs. Winchester,” I said, “is there any one in your house whom you
think capable of being in league with the robbers?”

The question took her by surprise; she started, and the flush
reappeared on her cheek. “I do not understand you,” she began; but,
speedily recovering her self-possession, she exclaimed, in a low but
emphatic tone, “No; how could you think of such a thing? It is the work
of professional burglars and of them alone.”

I made a slight but unmistakable gesture towards the hall.

“Who is that girl?” I asked.

“Philippa? My maid,” she answered, without the slightest token of
understanding, much less of sharing, the suspicion which I feared I
had, perhaps, too strongly suggested by my rather pointed inquiry. “Or,
rather,” she corrected, with some slight show of sarcasm, “she is what
is commonly called _a companion_; being sufficiently well educated to
read to me if I happen to be in the mood for listening, or even to play
on the piano, if music is required in the house.”

The chill indifference of this answer stamped Mrs. Winchester as a
woman of more elegance than feeling; but as that only made my rather
disagreeable task easier, it would be ungracious in me to criticise it.

“How long has she been with you?” I pursued.

“Oh, a year; perhaps more.”

“And you know her well; her antecedents and associates?”

“Yes; I know her; all that there is to know. She is not a deep person,
nor is she worthy your questions. Let us drop Philippa.”

“In one moment,” I returned. “In a case like this I must satisfy myself
thoroughly as to the character and past history of all who are in the
house. I have seen Philippa, and consequently push my inquiries in her
regard first. With whom did she live before she came to you, and where
does she spend her time when she is not with you in the house?”

Mrs. Winchester grew visibly impatient. “Follies!” she cried; then,
hurriedly, as if anxious to be done with my importunities, “Philippa is
the daughter of the clergyman who married my husband and myself. I have
always known her; she came from her father’s death-bed to my house. As
for associates, she has none; and the time she spends out of my rooms
is so small that I think it is hardly worth inquiring how or where it
is employed. Have you any further inquiries to make?”

I had, but I reserved them. “Will you let me speak to Philippa?” I

Her gesture was one of the utmost disdain, but it contained an
acquiescence of which I was not slow in availing myself. Stepping
rapidly into the hall, I approached the slight figure I had managed to
keep in view during this conversation.

But at my first movement in her direction the young girl started, and
before I could address her she had passed through the doorway of the
opposite room and disappeared in the darkness beyond.

I immediately stepped back to the lady I had left.

“Do those rooms communicate with a back staircase?” I inquired.

“Yes,” she returned, with uncompromising coldness.

I was baffled; that is, as far as Philippa was concerned. Accepting the
situation, however, with what grace I could, I bowed my acknowledgments
to Mrs. Winchester, and excusing myself for the moment, went hurriedly

I found her husband awaiting me with ill-concealed anxiety.

“Well?” he asked, at my reappearance.

“I have come to a conclusion,” said I.

He drew me into a remote corner of the room, where, without our
conversation being overheard, he could still keep his eye on the
staircase, visible through the half-open door.

“Let me hear,” said he.

I at once spoke my mind.

“The thief was no chance one; he not only knew that your house
contained diamonds, but he knew where to find them and when. Either a
signal was given him when to enter or the diamonds were thrown into his
hand out of the window. Does my conviction coincide with yours?”

He smiled a grim smile and waived the question.

“And who do you think gave the signal or threw the diamonds? Do not be
afraid to speak names; the case is too serious for paltering.”

“Well,” said I, “I have been in the house but a few minutes and have
seen but three persons besides yourself. I had rather not mention any
one as the possible accomplice of so daring a crime till I have seen
and conversed with every one here. But there is a girl up-stairs——you
yourself called my attention to her——about whom I should like to ask a
question or two. I allude to Philippa, Mrs. Winchester’s companion.”

He turned an eye full of expectancy towards me.

“Do you like her? Have you confidence in her? Is she a person to be
trusted?” I inquired.

His glance grew quite bright, and he bowed with almost a gesture of

“You could not have a better witness,” he remarked.

The answer was so unexpected, I hastily dropped my eyes.

“She will talk, then, if I interrogate her?” said I.

It was now his turn to look disconcerted.

“Then you have not done so?” he asked.

“I have not had the opportunity,” I rejoined.

“Ah,” he exclaimed, “I see.” And with a look and manner hard to
describe, he added, “Mrs. Winchester naturally kept the girl quiet. I
might have expected that.”

Astonished at this new turn, I ventured to speak the thought suggested
by an admission so extraordinary.

“And why should Mrs. Winchester wish to suppress any evidence
calculated to lead to the discovery of a thief who had so heavily
robbed her?”

The gleam of satisfaction which for the last few moments had lighted up
the countenance of the gentleman before me, faded perceptibly.

“I see,” he observed, “that our opinions on this matter are less in
accord than I supposed. But,” he continued more heartily, “you have, as
you very justly remarked just now, been but a few minutes in the house,
and have not had full opportunity to learn the facts. I will wait till
you have talked with Philippa. Shall I call her here?”

“Do,” I urged; “she is below, I think, though possibly she may still
be in the rooms above;” and I explained how she had started away at my
approach, hiding herself in apartments to which I felt I had not the
right of access.

He frowned, and moved hastily toward the door, but paused half-way to
ask me another question.

“Before I go,” said he, “I should like to inquire what word of Mrs.
Winchester led you to the conclusion that the theft was committed by
some one in the house?”

“Wait,” cried I, “you are going too fast; I do not say the theft was
committed by some one in the house. I merely speak of an accomplice.”

“Who flung the diamonds out of the window——”

“Or merely gave the signal that they were accessible, and for the
moment unguarded.”

He waved his hand impatiently.

“Let us not waste time,” he exclaimed. “I want to know what Mrs.
Winchester said——”

“She said nothing,” I interrupted, for my haste was as great as his;
“that is, nothing beyond the necessary relation of the facts——”

“Which were——”

“That the jewels were lying open in their case on the bureau; that
you called her from below; and that she hastened to respond by her
presence; was gone five minutes or so, and, returning, found the window
open and the diamonds gone. As she had left the window shut, she
naturally sprang to it and looked out, in time to see two men hurrying
down the street. Surely these facts you know as well as I.”

“I was curious,” he replied. “So those are the facts you received, and
it is from them alone you gathered the conclusion you have stated?”

“No,” said I, “there was Philippa.”

“But she said nothing.”

“I know, but she did not need to speak. I heard her heart beat, if I
may so express myself, and from its beatings came the conviction I have
given you.”

Mr. Winchester bestowed upon me an approving smile.

“You are all I thought you,” was his comment. “Philippa’s heart did
beat, and with most unwonted emotions, too. Philippa saw the person who
relieved Mrs. Winchester of her jewels.”

“What!” I cried, “and you——”

He did not wait to hear the end of my remonstrance. “I say so,” he went
on, “because while Mrs. Winchester was here, and before she ascended, I
saw Philippa go up. She had just time to reach the head of the stairs,
when the person whose step I had already detected crossing the floor
above, gained the hall——”

“The hall?” I cried.

“Yes. Can it be you really allowed yourself to dream for a moment that
the thief who stole this small fortune came in by the window?”

“Mr. Winchester,” said I, “when I left the police station it was with
some doubt, I confess, as to whether this theft had been committed in
just the way the man who brought your note said it had been. But after
hearing what Mrs. Winchester had to say——”

“Mrs. Winchester’s account of this occurrence is not to be depended
upon,” he broke in calmly, but determinedly. “Shall I give you a fact
or two? The window which my wife declares she found open when she went
up-stairs was not raised while she was down here, but after her return,
for _I heard it_. The step which crossed the floor above us while we
were talking together here, went out, not by any window, but by the
door leading into the hall; so that——”

“Mr. Winchester,” I interrupted, “do you realize that if what you say
is true, the diamonds are probably still in your house?”

“Just where I think they are, Mr. Byrd; just where I think they are.”

I began to have a strong notion of his suspicion.

“And Philippa,” I suggested.

“_Saw_ what I _heard_.”

I made no further effort to detain him. “Let us have her here,” I
cried. “If what you surmise is true, the mystery ought to be one of
easy solution. So easy,” I could not forbear adding, “that I wonder you
felt the need of sending for a detective.”

“You forget,” he observed, “that it is not so much the discovery of
the thief I am after, as the recovery of the jewels. The former I
might have managed without your assistance; but the latter requires an
authority backed by the law.” And merely stopping to call my attention
to the necessity of keeping a watch on the front door that no one
should escape from the house while he was gone, he hastily left me and
went up-stairs.

He was absent some twenty minutes, during which I heard him pass in and
out of his wife’s room. But when he came down he was alone, and his
countenance, which before had looked merely anxious and determined, now
bore the marks of anger and impatience.

“I do not know by what motive she is actuated,” cried he, “but I cannot
induce Philippa to speak. She insists she has nothing to say.”

“You saw her, then? I was afraid she had escaped by the back-stairs.”

“Hardly,” was the dry retort. “I caused the door leading to the rear
hall to be locked long ago.”

I bowed in admiration of his caution.

“No one can pass from the upper to the lower portion of this house
without going by this door; how else could I be sure the diamonds had
not already been smuggled out of the building?”

“And you are positively sure that, as it is, they are still here.”


“And that Philippa, although she will not speak, knows who took the
jewels, or at least who it was that entered the room above while Mrs.
Winchester was down here?”


“Then,” I declared, “our coast is clear. To find the diamonds it is
only necessary to search the house, and as for the culprit, Philippa
will find it difficult to keep silence when once the law has taken its
course, and duty as well as honor compels her to speak.”

He nodded and stood a moment thinking.

“You would search the house?” he repeated at last. “It is a large house
and its places of concealment innumerable; I do not think we should
recover them by that means——not in the time I have specified. Listen
to my plan. Mrs. Winchester and myself expected to go to a certain
reception to-night. It is a grand affair, and it is desirable that we
should be present. We will go there, but before going I will make it
known throughout the house that you are a detective, and say that it
is your intention to search the house for the missing jewels as soon as
you can get the necessary assistance from your office. This will alarm
the guilty, and if I am not very much mistaken, lead to the endeavor of
some one person in this house to leave it. If this should prove true,
do not hinder the attempt, for that person will have the diamonds in
his possession, and if followed, as you will take measures he shall be,
their recovery must be a matter of an hour or two; for a man is more
easily searched than a house.”

“An admirable scheme,” I exclaimed, wondering at an acumen I certainly
should not have looked for in the wealthy broker. “I see but one flaw
in it. If Mrs. Winchester heard that her house was to be ransacked in
her absence, would she consent to go to the reception?”

“Mrs. Winchester will be in her carriage when I make the announcement.
I shall certainly see to that.”

“Very well, then,” said I, “it only remains for me to procure from the
police-station the man I want for the pursuit you mention.”

“I will call there on my way to the reception with any note you may
choose to write.”

I scribbled two names on a card.

“Either of those men will answer,” said I. “Let him take his station in
the area next to this, and when posted there give _the call_. He will
understand. Will the guilty person be likely to lead him a long chase?”

“That it is as impossible for me to know as you. I have no conception
where the thief will go upon leaving this house. To some place
favorable for the concealment of his booty, of course, but where, time
and the skill of his pursuer must determine.”

“I will just add a line of caution to that pursuer,” said I, and taking
the card I scribbled a few directions on its back, after which I gave
it to Mr. Winchester.

In exchange he handed me two keys.

“This one unlocks the door leading to the back-stairs, and this the
front door of the basement.” After which explanation he left me, and in
another moment I heard him go up-stairs and enter his wife’s room.

The programme we had agreed upon was carried out to the letter. In
less than a half hour Mr. and Mrs. Winchester came down, he looking
pale and stern, she haughty and imperturbably calm. The carriage, which
I had heard drive up a moment before, stood at the door and they passed
immediately out, but not before I had time to observe that she wore
the same dress I had seen her in above, a rich mauve-colored velvet
made high in the throat and heavily loaded with what I believe they
call a _passementerie_ of pearl beads enriched with lace; a species
of garniture which in my eyes obviated the necessity of any further
adornment more pretentious than the simple cluster of pearls she wore
in her ears.

“A noble and a dignified presence,” I thought as she passed, and
wondered if the heart under that violet robe beat any faster than her
appearance betokened, or whether she was indeed one of that class of
women in whom the ills and exigences of life stir but faint chords and
produce but slight emotions.

The bang of the carriage door was followed by the almost immediate
reappearance of Mr. Winchester.

“Now,” said he, “to business!” And looking up the stairs, he hailed,
with a glance of satisfaction, the descending figure of the young man
whom we had before met on the landing above, and whom he had designated
to me as his wife’s son.

“Ah, Lawrence,” said he, “come down. I sent for you and Miss Irwin——by
the by, where is she? Oh, I see, looking over the banisters above——that
I might introduce to you Mr. Byrd, a detective from the police force,
whose business here, as you may judge, is to recover for us your
mother’s diamonds. It is necessary for you to know him, for he, as well
as myself, has come to the conclusion that your mother is mistaken
in believing that the jewels were stolen by some one entering from
without. Indeed, he is sure that not only is the thief a member of
this household, but that the diamonds are still on the premises, and
can be found by a thorough and systematic search. He is, therefore,
going to take advantage of your mother’s absence to put his theory to
the test, and as soon as suitable assistance can be procured from the
police station, will begin a search that will stop at no receptacles,
be balked by no place of concealment, however personal or private. I
say this, because I do not wish you or Miss Irwin to feel irritated
if he is obliged to enter your rooms, there being, as you know, one
or two old servants with us whose feelings might justly be wounded if
their persons or belongings were subjected to an examination that was
not shared in by every individual in the house. You will, therefore,
be ready with your keys, and, by setting an example to the servants,
make the efforts of this officer as light as possible. Am I understood,

“Certainly, sir.”

The answer was as nonchalant as the question, which was put with
an easy and light good-nature, calculated to deceive every ear but
that of a detective. Indeed Mr. Lawrence Sutton——I learned his name
afterwards——seemed to be awakening from a dream——and the moment his
step-father was gone,——for Mr. Winchester did not linger after saying
the above,——he turned and went immediately up-stairs just as if I had
not been standing there.

His conduct was so unexpected, I paused, irresolute. This was the man
Mr. Winchester suspected, I felt sure, and here he was going, for aught
I knew, straight to the spot where the valuable articles lay concealed
whose recovery and delivery into Mr. Winchester’s hands would bring
me what I was fain to consider in these days of my poverty, a small
fortune. Should I follow him, or should I trust to Mr. Winchester’s
judgment and wait for him to re-descend? The conviction that I would
only defeat my own ends by surprising him too soon, decided me at last
to remain below, and, withdrawing into the reception-room, I waited,
with indescribable anxiety, first for the peculiar call which would
notify me that my colleague had arrived on the scene, and, secondly,
for the returning step of Mr. Sutton. But before either of these sounds
assailed my ears there came another which aroused my keenest curiosity.
This was a noise of whispering on the floor above, followed by a short,
sharp cry of joy in a voice I felt sure belonged to the young gentleman
I had seen. Then all was silence, during which came the call without,
then a rush above as of hurrying feet, after which I heard no more
till——yes, the eagerly expected sound of a descending step awakened
all my energies, and glancing through the crack of the door near which
I stood, I saw Mr. Sutton coming down with his overcoat on.

More satisfied than I could say, not at this evidence of the truth
of Mr. Winchester’s suspicions,——for Mr. Sutton had a fine air and
a countenance which, if it bore the unmistakable signs of a life
of dissipation, had yet an expression that was not without its
attraction,——but at the result of an experiment which was almost daring
in its nature, I waited to hear the front door open and close. But I
had not calculated on Mr. Sutton being a gentleman of great courtesy
and many resources, and before I was fully aware of his presence, he
was at my side, bowing with extreme urbanity, and holding out a chain
from which I saw several keys hanging.

“Mr. Winchester has requested me to give you these. By their aid you
will be enabled to open every box and drawer that _I_ own. As for the
others, you must find your own way of entrance and examination. I have
an important engagement out which will keep me, perhaps, an hour. On my
return I will lend you all the assistance I can; for I am naturally as
anxious as any one that so valuable a treasure as my mother’s diamonds
should not be lost to the family.”

I bowed and he drew back, taking out a pair of new gloves, which, to
my unbounded astonishment, he stopped to fit on with great nicety and
precision. Then he moved towards the door, but even there he paused and
looked up the stairs before finally putting on his hat and going out.

“A consummate actor!” thought I, and sprang to the window, through
which I rather incautiously peered. He was descending the steps, still
slowly, but with more of an air of determination than he had shown
within. In another moment he was on the side-walk, and in an instant
later was walking rapidly down the street. Hurrying from the window,
I went to the front door and opened it. A man was leaving the area
next door, and, before I turned to come in, I had the satisfaction of
seeing Mr. Sutton’s tall form closely shadowed by the most knowing and
discreet assistant we have on the force.

“Now for hours of dreary patience,” mused I, sinking into a large easy
chair near a table of inviting-looking books.

But scarcely had I uttered this thought than I sprang to my feet in
fresh excitement. Another step was on the stair, another presence in
the room.

Turning in the full expectation of seeing Miss Irwin, I encountered the
gaze of an old and feeble woman. Surprised, I bowed with respect; upon
which she immediately said:

“I hear that Mr. Winchester has decided to have a search made through
the house for the diamonds that Mrs. Winchester has lost. Is it going
to be done to-night?”

“It will have to be done to-night if at all,” I returned with
pardonable prevarication. “There would be but little satisfaction in
undertaking it after any communication had been established between its
inmates and the world without.”

“Then,” said she, with little or no heed to the latter part of my
sentence, “may I ask as a favor that you will make it convenient to
go through my room first? I am Mrs. Winchester’s aunt; and I am sure
she would not wish me to be kept out of my bed any later than is
necessary. My room is small and——”

Poor old lady! it was really cruel. I made haste to relieve her mind.

“There can be no necessity for searching your room——” I began.

But she interrupted me with prompt decision.

“You are mistaken,” said she. “If there is a room in this house which
ought to be looked into, it is mine. For the very reason that it is the
last one a detective would examine, makes it possibly the very one a
thief would choose for the purpose of concealment. I prefer you to go
through my room, sir.”

I was astonished and not a little perplexed. The old lady looked so
determined it was evident she was not to be trifled with. But I was
not ready to explain to her that the threatened search was but a
_ruse de guerre_, which had already produced its desired result; and
yet, if I did not do so, how was I to account for a delay that would
inconvenience her so materially? I could see but one way out of the
difficulty, and that was to make a superficial examination of her room
and her effects, after which I would proclaim myself satisfied with my
scrutiny, in the hope that she would be so too. I accordingly answered
her that I appreciated her position perfectly, and that if she would
consent to it, I would go to her apartment at once.

She signified that she would be only too happy; whereupon I immediately
led the way up-stairs. She followed me up the two flights, and
earnestly pointed out the door of her room. But as I approached it
I heard a suspicious sound on the floor below, and looking over the
banisters, beheld the lithe and agile figure of Philippa gliding down
the stairs to the front door. She was dressed for the street, and had
evidently taken advantage of my position to escape from the house.

Instantly a throng of doubts and suspicions passed through my mind. I
was the victim of a plot, and the old lady was neither so innocent nor
so disinterested as she appeared. When she persuaded me to go up-stairs
it was with the direct intention of giving Philippa the opportunity
to reach the street unhindered. I knew it even before I noticed how
her feeble and panting form filled the narrow passage at the head of
the stairs, necessitating some slight rudeness on my part to pass her.
But rudeness, even to an aged and decrepit lady, was of small account
in an exigency like this. Twenty-five thousand dollars were in all
probability slipping from my grasp, to say nothing of my reputation as
an astute and not readily deceived detective. And yet, was it now and
in this way the diamonds were leaving the house, or had they already
been carried away, as I formerly believed, by Mr. Sutton? Either might
be true, or, as I had time to think before I was half-way down the
first flight, neither might be true. His departure, and now hers, might
be equally a ruse to withdraw attention from the house and the real
concealer of these valuable gems; and, pausing just one instant in
my descent, I looked back at the place where I had left the old lady
tottering from the push I had been obliged to give her in my anxiety
to pass. She was standing there still, but the look with which she
followed me was one of ill-concealed satisfaction, and though she drew
back at my first glance, I had time to observe that a smile had crept
into the corners of her mouth that augured poorly for the success of
any design that I might entertain.

Meanwhile Philippa’s hand was on the knob of the front door, and she
would have been out of the house in another instant if she had not
stopped to glance at the hat rack, with the deliberate purpose, as I
believe, of hindering me in my pursuit by appropriating my hat if it
hung there. But fortunately for me I had carried it with me into the
reception-room, so her glance as well as her delay was but momentary.
Before I was well at the top of the first flight I heard the front door
close, and knew I had to decide in a breath, as it were, whether to
follow her and so forsake the building and it might be the very gems I
was seeking to recover, or to allow her to go her way unhindered, in
face of the equal possibility of her bearing them away to some place of
safer concealment.

The thought of Mr. Winchester decided me instantly. If I failed in
recovering the gems by following Philippa, I would but lose my reward
and possibly a little of my prestige as a detective; but if I failed
in the same undertaking by not following her, Mr. Winchester would
have the right to reproach me with a manifest disregard of his orders.
For had he not said, “Watch who it is who endeavors to leave this
house after your threat to search it, and follow him, for that person
will have the diamonds.” To be sure Mr. Sutton had already gone and
was being followed, but if a dozen left after him, especially after
resorting to subterfuge to elude pursuit, would it not be my duty
to see that they were also followed and that with the same care and
circumspection I had thought proper to have employed in his case? There
could be no doubt on the matter; so flinging all other consideration
to the winds, I gave myself up to the pursuit of this flying sprite,
closing the front door after me without a suspicion but that my first
glance down the street would show me in what direction she had started.

But neither my glances down the street nor up revealed to me Philippa,
and agitated by my first fear that I had possibly undertaken more
than I could accomplish, I dashed down to the corner, which was that
of Madison Avenue, and looking hastily this way and that, saw on
the block below the supple and delicate form of a female which I had
barely decided was hers, when a car stopped and she stepped aboard and
was carried away before I could get breath to cry stop! to the rather
obtuse conductor who assisted her.

Happily the next car was not many blocks off, and when I boarded it and
found the driver a man I knew, I felt that the case was not so hopeless
as first appeared. With but little persuasion he consented to urge the
horses on a little faster than the schedule called for, so that in a
few minutes we had drawn up close enough to the car in front for me to
see each figure as it descended. In this way I was enabled to follow
Miss Irwin with more satisfaction than if I had got into the same car
with her; and as her ride was short, I soon was stepping lightly behind
her down Forty-fifth Street. She did not walk two blocks before she
stopped, ran up a stoop, rang the bell and was admitted.

I hastened quickly after her, looked at the number and paused
confounded. Why, this was a house I well knew; one which many people
visited,——though not often on the same errand as Miss Irwin, I must
believe,——one which I had sometimes visited myself; the home of the
well-known minister, Mr. Randall.

Nonplussed for the moment, I stood hesitating, when to add to my
astonishment a man stepped up to me from behind, and tapping me
familiarly on the back, said:

“Well, what do _you_ make of it?”

It was Hawkins.

“What! you here?” I exclaimed.

“Certain!” he cried, “and my man, too.”

It was inexplicable. Fortunately there was hope of solving the mystery.

“I think I will go in,” said I. “I know Mr. Randall quite well. If one
or both of them come out before I do, follow. I will not be gone any
longer than is necessary.”

He nodded and fell back into his hiding-place. I rang the bell and
asked for Mr. Randall.

“He is busy just now, sir,” explained the neat servant girl who
answered my summons. “But if you will step into his study, he will soon
be ready to see you.”

I needed no second invitation. In a few moments I was ensconced in
the cosy back parlor, listening to the low murmur of voices that came
from the room in front through the heavy folding-doors that separated
the two apartments. Of these voices I could distinguish two; the heavy
bass of Mr. Randall, and the lighter, smoother tones of the young man
who had brought me his keys in Seventy-third Street. Suddenly both
voices ceased, and there was a slight bustle, then a solemn silence,
then——could it be the sound of Mr. Randall’s voice again, not in
the conversational tone he had previously used, but in the measured
accent he was accustomed to use in the pulpit. “The enigma increases,”
thought I, and, regardless of appearances, I crept to the folding-doors
and glued my ear against the narrow crack that marked their line of
division. What I heard only increased my curiosity to the fever point.
At all risks, and in despite of all ordinary proprieties, I must see
whom the clergyman was addressing; so, exerting all my skill and no
little of the caution of a professional detective, I pried the doors
the least bit apart and saw,——what I certainly had not come there to
see, and yet a very pretty sight for all that——Mr. Sutton and Philippa
Irwin kneeling before Mr. Randall, and that gentleman pronouncing over
them the marriage benediction.

There was another lady and two gentlemen in a group about them, but
beyond noting that the lady was Mrs. Randall, and the gentlemen members
of the same family, I did not bestow a thought upon them, my whole
attention being given to the man and woman, whom I had been following
under so sinister a suspicion, only to find myself a witness of the
most serious act of their lives.

The surprise of the occasion and the touching nature of the whole
scene, made me for the instant forget the diamonds and what my very
presence in that spot implied. But, when the final words had been said,
and the few congratulations offered, the young people faced about
and I caught a glimpse of the bride’s countenance, I remembered with
a shock the gloomy nature of the shadow which surrounded them; and
while I could not help but give my sympathy to a condition of things
at once so novel and so interesting, I also felt my determination as
a detective return. For Philippa’s face wore not the look of a happy
bride, but that of a woman who has just dared everything that some
cherished scheme might be fulfilled or some dreadful ill averted.
Indeed, there was terror in the eye with which she regarded her
husband; a terror so mixed with love and the light of something like
hope as she met his glance of triumphant satisfaction, that I felt I
must probe the matter of the diamonds to the bottom if only to solve
the mystery of her action, and the motives by which she had been
governed in this gift of herself at a moment so manifestly unpropitious
to happiness and honor.

Meanwhile, Mr. Randall was saying some words of courtesy and farewell,
and, seeing that in another moment his steps might be turned in my
direction, I pushed to the doors at which I was standing, with even a
greater caution than that with which I had separated them, and falling
back to my old station on the sofa, I awaited with equal interest and
impatience his entrance and the sound of the young couple’s departure.

Mr. Randall appeared and the front door closed at the same time.
Resigning Mr. Sutton and his bride to the care of the man without, I
turned my attention to the clergyman. I knew enough of his character
and life to be certain he had not married them without knowing
something of their history and condition, and that knowledge I meant to

Some of my readers may not need to be told that I, Horace Byrd, was
not always on the detective force; that I had had my bringing up in
different circles, and that I was by birth and education what is called
a gentleman. I speak of this here to account for the affability with
which Mr. Randall greeted me, and his readiness to satisfy what, under
ordinary circumstances, might have been considered a most impertinent
and inexcusable curiosity. He was my father’s friend, and he listened
with respect while I made my excuses, and opened at once upon the
subject that occupied my thoughts.

“Mr. Randall,” said I, “the errand with which I approach you is of a
most singular nature. The couple you have just married——pardon me, my
ears are good and my presence here is in connection with that same
couple——lie under a suspicion of wrong-doing that may or may not lead
to consequences of the most serious nature. What that wrong-doing is I
had rather not state, since it is as yet merely a suspicion from which
they may be able to clear themselves. But what I will say is, that you
will be furthering their welfare and assisting at the unravelment of
a most mysterious occurrence if you will tell me what you know about
them, and the causes which led to this evidently hasty and clandestine

“I am greatly astonished,” were his first words; “and feel strongly
inclined to ask you what these poor young folks could have done beyond
loving each other and marrying in despite of the pride and ambitious
projects of Mr. and Mrs. Winchester. But curiosity pure and simple is
unworthy of a clergyman, so I will merely say if they are doing or
have done anything that could be called really wrong I was in complete
ignorance of it, and that their marriage is but the culmination of an
intention long known to me if not to the world and that society to
which the groom if not the bride belongs.”

“Now,” returned I, “you astonish me. They were engaged, then, and you
knew it; something which I can scarcely believe his own mother did.”

“Very likely,” was the quiet retort. “Mrs. Winchester is not one whom
a proud man would take into his confidence if he meant to make what is
called a poor and unequal match.”

“Still,” I began——

“Still,” he interrupted, “a son should show a certain consideration
and respect to the mother who bore him and who always has displayed,
as he himself declares, forbearance to his faults and sympathy for the
weakness that caused them. I know all this,” Mr. Randall continued,
“and I agree with you in your opinion; but there were certain
peculiarities in this special case which offer at least some excuse
for his action and my sympathy with it. Lawrence Sutton was not always
a respectable member of society. He was a wild boy, an extravagant
youth, and a more than dissipated man. His mother loved him but could
not control him, powerful and determined spirit though she is. Nor
had his step-father’s position and enormous wealth any influence in
controlling passions that partook almost of the recklessness of the
foreign fast society amongst which he was more or less unfortunately
cast. He seemed to be without aspiration, and yet he was not shallow,
nor ungenerous, nor mean. His mother, whose thoughts few can penetrate,
looked on and was silent; his step-father, who had not nature to help
him to a consideration for his faults, showed his anger and threatened
to show him his door but never did. He lived an outcast from the best
and showed no prospect of amendment till suddenly——it was a year
ago——the greatest and most startling change took place in his habits
and general style of living; and from being a careless man about town,
he became the courteous, careful gentleman, alive to the place of
honor he had lost in society and active in his endeavor to regain it.
His mother, always hopeful for her boy, naturally attributed to her
own quiet influence and unbroken faith this wonderful restoration to
manhood and honor: but I knew better; I to whom human nature has been
an open book for twenty-five years, knew that something fresher and
more ideal than any influence Mrs. Winchester was capable of exerting
had led this young man to reject a course which had become almost a
second nature to him.

“Frequent and prolonged visits at Mr. Winchester’s house did not serve
to explain the mystery to me. I found Mr. Sutton sitting with the
family,——something which I had not seen him do for years,——but how was
I to connect this fact with the presence now and then of the quiet
young woman, without any special attraction, whom Mrs. Winchester once
rather carelessly introduced to me as Miss Irwin; and yet this girl
with the subdued look and meek, almost humble aspect, was the force
which had acted on this man’s nature and turned its impulses, as it
were, completely about. To him she was the manifestation of all that
was ideal and desirable in womanhood; and from the first moment he saw
her, as he afterwards told me, he made up his mind to win her for his
wife if it cost him all and every indulgence of his hitherto much to
be reprobated life. That he cherished this hope in his heart and did
not make a confidant of either of his parents is not to be wondered
at. Mrs. Winchester looks upon Philippa as a dependent; a being too
insignificant to be regarded, much less admired or feared. Nothing, not
even the change in her son’s moral life, would ever have convinced her
that this girl possessed influence; or if by any means that belief was
forced upon her, that it arose from any merit or powers she was bound
to acknowledge or respect. A handsome, elegant, worldly-wise woman
herself, she sees no excellence that is not linked to those qualities,
and would rather, I verily believe, have seen her son thrown back into
his old course than owe his redemption to a source so insignificant
in appearance and out of all accord with her own views of what was in
keeping with her son’s prospects and her own social position.

“At least, this is the judgment I have formed of her, and this the
explanation which young Sutton gave me of his conduct, in an interview
he held with me some six months ago. ‘She’——that is, his mother——‘shall
know nothing of what Philippa is to me till she sees her at my side
as my wife,’ was his remark to me at that time. ‘And that I look to
you to make her,’ he continued, ‘when by perseverance and a proper
probation I have induced this pure and uncontaminated being to trust me
with her fate and make me what I now believe I am capable of becoming,
a man of purpose, ambition, and social standing.’

“Such hopes, such resolution, and such spirit in a man of his type and
with his record could not but enlist my sympathy. A soul which I had
long thought lost had found its motive to better things, and though
this motive was not the highest, it was high enough to give hope for
the continuance of the good work to the end of all I could fondly wish
for him. I therefore entered into his plans with cordial interest,
and though I deprecated his taking any serious step without at least
acquainting his mother with his intentions, I promised and have kept
my word, that when he came to me with Philippa I would marry them,
trusting to his own sense of propriety and her discretion, that the
event would be for the honor and happiness of the family as well as
for their own mutual joy and satisfaction. But what you tell me now
disturbs me where I never thought to be disturbed. They are under
suspicion of some evil——what, I cannot imagine——and you know it; which
means that it is flagrant, and possibly makes them amenable to the law.”

I did not answer this, for I was full of thoughts. Could it be that
this pure and touching story of seemingly true love was destined to
be besmirched by the shadow of crime? Had Lawrence Sutton taken the
diamonds, and did Philippa Irwin know it; or was Mrs. Winchester’s
story correct, and the deed one of the common order of burglary?

“What adds to my concern,” the good clergyman went on, after waiting a
suitable time for me to speak, “is that some folks think——some members
of his own family in fact——that the change in his nature, to which I
allude, is not so thorough as I have made you understand. They insist
that he still carries on his old practices, but more secretly. And
they have a reason for this; for whereas, at one time, that is, in the
beginning of his acquaintance with Philippa, he used to remain at home
during the evening, he has for some months now confined his attentions
in that quarter to Sunday night merely, going out as regularly after
dinner as he used to do in his wildest days of dissipation. Only he
does not come home intoxicated any more, and his eyes, which once
looked bleared and heavy, are now clear and wide-awake. I——I wish we
knew where he is accustomed to spend his nights.”

“Well, we will find out,” I assured him, getting up and moving towards
the door; “and though I fear the result may not be all we could wish,
I will remember your anxiety and relieve as much of it as is possible
to-morrow. I must say good-night, now, for this matter is not one that
will keep.” And merely pausing to thank him for his goodness, I left
Mr. Randall and proceeded directly back to the house of Mr. Winchester.

My reflections on the way there were not of a wholly satisfactory
nature. If Mr. Sutton and his bride were in possession of the diamonds,
there was no telling what they would do or where they would go;
separate, possibly, and thus put Hawkins at his wits’ end as to which
of the two to follow. If they were not in possession of the diamonds,
I fully believed I should find them at the house before me. But that
was a contingency only satisfactory to my sympathy; for, if the gems
were not with them, where were they? Not in Mr. Winchester’s house by
this time; of that I could be perfectly sure.

So it was with anything but a light heart that I rang the bell this
time, and greeting Mr. Winchester’s countenance as before, entered
again into this dwelling of mystery.

“We have come back,” were his hurried words, uttered with feverish
intensity. “And you? Have you got the diamonds?”

I shook my head and hastened after him into the reception-room.

“But you followed him? You know where he is? And Philippa? What took
her out, too?”

“Wait,” I said, “have they come back?”

“Who? Lawrence and Philippa?”



“I fear they will not come, then,” said I.

“They? Why do you associate Lawrence’s name with Philippa’s?”

I was spared the answer. At that instant I heard the well-known call of
my colleague without, and simultaneously with this encouraging sound,
the click of the night-key in the door proclaiming the return of Mr.

“No,” cried I, “here they are; and as I am sure they will have
something to say to you which it would embarrass them to utter before a
stranger, I will just step out of sight for the moment.” And making a
dash for the portière behind me, I pulled it aside and stepped into the
darkness beyond.

Mr. Winchester made no effort to stop me; he was too much astonished
at the sight of his step-son entering with Philippa on his arm. And
I, who, without calculation, had stumbled into the first refuge I
espied, was equally surprised, not at what I saw, but at the quarters
in which I found myself; for the portière, instead of shutting off a
room, shielded a closet, and it was amongst a litter of bric-à-brac and
old pictures that I now drew myself up, prepared to listen and to see,
since this was all that was left to my indiscretion.

“Father,”——it was Mr. Sutton who spoke,——“will you call mother down?
There is something I wish to say to her before I take another step in
this house.”

“But——but no matter about your mother,” came in Mr. Winchester’s hasty
and now deeply agitated tones. “If you have the diamonds, give them to
me; give them to me quickly, and nothing more shall ever be said about
them. I am not hard on young folks, and——”

“The diamonds? I know nothing about the diamonds,” the other broke in,
with an impatience that was more startling than anger would have been.
“What I wish to say is on a wholly different subject.” And I judge that
he turned with a look towards Philippa, for the old man’s voice became
quite shrill as he cried:

“What do you want to say? That you and Philippa are friends? That she
did not see you come out of your mother’s room two minutes before the
diamonds were missed? That you are a saint and every one knows it, and


Was that the voice of a man stained by the meanest of crimes? I pushed
aside the portière and looked out. He was standing like a statue
of wrath between Mr. Winchester and the glowing, brilliant, almost
transformed Philippa.

“When you speak of her,” cried he, letting his hand fall on her arm,
with the pride of triumphant possession, “you are speaking of my wife.”

Mr. Winchester fell slowly back. It was the only surprise, perhaps,
that could have taken his mind off the diamonds.

“Your wife,” he repeated, and his eyes slowly traveled to Philippa’s
face, as if he found it difficult to take in a statement so unexpected.

Mr. Sutton took advantage of the moment to step to the foot of the

“Mother!” he called, “will you come here?”

She was already in the hall as he, doubtless, perceived, for he
hastened back and took Philippa by the hand, and was standing thus when
the stately woman crossed the threshold in all the splendor of the rich
garments I have hitherto endeavored to describe.

“My son!” was her first startled exclamation, quickly followed by an
indescribable murmur, as she saw whom he held by the hand, and noted
the fervor of that clasp, and the expression with which he regarded
her. “What does this mean?” she asked at length, her hauteur battling
with an anger that was yet new, but terrible in its promise of growth.

“Happiness, I hope,” was the steady reply. “If not, it at least means a
better life on my part and a less humble and dependent one on hers. We
are married, mother, and it is my wish——”

He did not finish; at that word _married_, the haughty woman, struck
in the full pride of her hopes and ambitious projects, tottered, and
before help could reach her, fell, laying her gray but queenly head at
the feet of her whom an hour back she would have scorned to associate
with herself in any higher connection than she did the inanimate
objects that surrounded her and ministered to her comfort.

There was a rush, a hurried murmur, a pause, then a sudden cry so
fraught with wonder and yet so surcharged with triumph, that I could
scarcely believe it proceeded from Mr. Winchester’s lips, till a sudden
swaying in the bended form of Philippa revealed to me Mrs. Winchester
lying with the neck of her dress thrown back, and on the throat thus
displayed, a glistening cordon of gems which by their brilliancy and
size could only be the famous and costly ones for which we had been

It was the culmination of the evening’s surprises.

“The diamonds, the diamonds!” exclaimed Mr. Winchester, and regardless
of the still insensible condition of his wife, he stooped and dragged
them from her neck, and stood holding them out and looking at them, as
if he could hardly credit his good fortune.

As for Mr. Sutton and Philippa, they gave one startled glance at the
jewels, another at each other, and then set about restoring their

I was the most thoroughly overcome of them all.

It took some few minutes to bring Mrs. Winchester back to
consciousness. Meanwhile, I employed myself in looking at her husband.
He had by this time thrust the gems into his pocket, and was gazing
at her with a half-sinister, half-pitying glance. But at the first
movement on her part he was all attention to her, while, on the
contrary, Mr. Sutton and Philippa drew back as if they dreaded to meet
her unclosing eye. They might well feel so; it was terrible, and so was
her gesture, as, rising from the sofa on which she had been laid, she
looked about on them all. But suddenly, and before she could speak,
she felt the wind on her throat, and, lifting her hand to it, a great
change passed over her.

“Who——who has presumed——” she began; but here she caught her husband’s
eye, and losing her self-possession, felt around for a chair and fell
into it.

“If you are looking for your jewels,” that husband remarked, “I have
them. It was a curious freak to wear them under instead of over your
dress, and then to forget where you had put them and imagine them

She lifted one thin, white hand as if in protest, but her regal spirit
seemed broken, and her eyes filled with something like tears.

“Lawrence!” she exclaimed brokenly, “what have I not done for you! and
this is how you repay me.”

“Mother,” said the young man, with a closer grip of Philippa’s hand,
“could you ask for any better repayment than the regenerate life I
offer you? A year ago I was the shame and disgrace of this family; a
man for whom the world had scorn and you only a pitying forbearance.
To-day I can walk the streets and drop my eyes before no man’s glance;
I am a man again, and this——this dear woman is the cause. Is it not
enough to make you overlook the trifling disadvantages which annoy your
pride but cannot affect your heart?”

But Mrs. Winchester’s nature was not one to be touched by any such
appeal as this. Indeed, it seemed to restore some of her former hauteur.

“Your mother’s love was then insufficient to recall you to a sense
of what you owed yourself and her? My sacrifices, my sympathy, my
endeavors to uphold you in face of the disapprobation of the whole
world were as nothing to you. You had to wait till a puny girl smiled
upon you, a waiting-woman, a——”

“Mother,” broke in the son, this time with severity in his tone,
“Philippa is a lady; she is, moreover, my wife, and so of equal social
station with yourself. Let us not be bitter but thankful. For me, an
angel has stepped into my life.”

It was not wise, but when was love ever wise? Mrs. Winchester’s face
hardened, and a reckless smile broke out on her lips.

“An angel that has brought ruin to me,” said she. “What confidence do
you suppose there can henceforth be between my husband and myself since
he has found I can deceive him, and deceive him for you?”

“For me?”

“Yes; you can play with my heart, trifle with my pride, marry my
waiting-maid before my eyes, never asking whence came the freedom which
enables you to do all these things, or what price your mother is paying
for the sins her forbearance was not sufficient to make you regret and

“Mother, what do you mean? I do not understand you at all. What price
have you been paying for sins of mine?”

She smiled ironically.

“It is time you showed some curiosity on the subject.” Then, with a
side glance at her husband, full of bitterness and despair, she went
on: “Did you ever ask yourself where the money came from with which I
paid your debts two years ago, in Paris?”

“No——that is, I supposed, of course, it came out of your own pocket.
Mr. Winchester is a rich man——”

“And I, his wife, must therefore be a rich woman. Well, I may be; but
even rich women do not always have a hundred thousand francs at their
disposal; and that sum I gave you, and you took from me. Where do
you think I obtained it? Not from him, as his face only too plainly

“Where, then, mother——where, then? Tell me, for I——”

But Mr. Winchester had taken a step forward, and his face was very

“Let her answer my questions,” said he. “You gave your son, that
scapegrace, a hundred thousand francs, two years ago, in Paris?”

She bowed her head, trembling with something more than wrath.

“It was a great sum,” he continued, “a great sum! I do not wonder you
hesitated to ask me for it. He would never have got it, never. I wonder
that you found any friend willing to throw so much money to the dogs.”

“It was not a friend,” she murmured. “O William!” she went on, with
almost a pleading sound in her voice, “we have never had any children,
and you do not know what it is to love a son. To see him in peril,
disgrace, or necessity, and not seek to relieve him, is impossible. You
must make allowances for a mother’s heart.”

“But this money——these thousands——where did they come from, where?”

She flushed, and her head drooped, but her natural haughtiness soon
lifted it again. Rising, she asked, in her turn——

“Mr. Winchester, why did you send for me to-night, as I was dressing
for the reception, and, after inquiring if I were going to wear my
diamonds, say it was your pleasure that I should do so, and then add,
that you wished to borrow them of me to-morrow as you desired to show
them to a dealer?”

“Why? because——” It was his turn to flush now——“because I do wish to
show them to a dealer.”

“And what has a dealer to do with my diamonds?”

“Nothing——a freak of mine. I took a notion to find out just what they
were worth.”

“And don’t you know?” Her voice was very low, her eyes burned on his

“Only approximately, madam, approximately.”

The glance she had fixed on him, fell. She took a step nearer, but did
not speak at once.

“What is it?” he cried. “Why do you hesitate to answer my questions?”

“William,” said she, “were it not more to the point to ask why I, who
have always been considered an honorable woman, should resort to the
subterfuge of stealing my own jewels in order to escape the delivery of
them up into other hands?”

“Perhaps,” he muttered; “but we will not go into that. No woman enjoys
parting with such gems as these even for a few days.”

She laughed. “But a woman does not resort to crime, run the risk of
police investigation and submit to such indignities as are inflicted
upon her by the so-called detective agent, for the mere sake of
retaining in her possession jewels of any price. She must have another
motive——a motive of terror lest an evil greater than these should come
upon her——the loss of her husband’s love or trust, the——the——”

“Madam, what have you been doing? What secret underlies all these

“A little one; only a little one. William, do you intend showing that
necklace to a dealer to-morrow?”

“Yes, to ascertain its value.”

“You had better not.”


“Because he would laugh in your face. William, the gems are
false——false; there is not a diamond amongst them; only glass,
worthless glass!”

He stared at her incredulously; he tore the jewels from his pocket
and held them up to the light. Their flash and brilliance seemed to
reassure him.

“You are making sport of me, madam. See how they sparkle and throw
back the light. Only diamonds shine like that. You do not wish me
to take them away from you. Perhaps you fear you may lose them

“I tell you they are false,” she insisted. “I had the exchange made in
Paris. I received a hundred thousand francs and these imitations for
the necklace. Had not the man who manufactured them been an expert,
do you suppose I should have dared the experiment of wearing them as
I have done, for a whole year now, at every large assemblage I have

“Millicent! Millicent, is this true?” He looked more than angry, more
than dismayed. She herself seemed astonished at the intensity of the
emotions she had aroused.

“Yes,” she returned, “it is true.” And her glance took in the face of
her son standing abashed and troubled beside his bride. “This I was
doing for you,” she declared. “While you were seeking inspiration and
delight from the smile of Philippa Irwin, I was meeting the eyes of the
world with a circle of false gems about my throat, and in my heart the
dread of such a scene as this, with its worse to-morrow.”


“No words now. I have done with you, Lawrence Sutton; let me see if I
am to lose a husband as well as a son.”

But Mr. Winchester was in no mood for sentiment. He had flung the
glittering bauble from him, and was standing with clenched hands and
working brow near the threshold of the door. As she spoke he flung the
door open, and when she ceased he gave her one look, and passing out
into the hall, disappeared from view.

She stood still and made no effort to follow him.

“It is the deception,” I heard her murmur. “He could not care for a
few thousands so much as this.” And then her haughty lip trembled, her
imperious air gave way, and tottering toward the door, she held her two
hands out in seeming forgetfulness of everything but her love for her
husband. “William!” she cried, “William!”

But her son was already between her and the door.

“Mother!” he exclaimed, “you shall hear me. Indifferent as you
consider me to have been, this debt I have owed you has weighed heavily
upon me. Of course I knew nothing of the sacrifice you had made in
giving me the large sum you did. I supposed it came, as you led me to
suppose, from your husband; but, even so, it has troubled me and caused
me many an anxious thought as to how I was to repay you. I did not
find a way. But to prove to you that my remorse did not expend itself
entirely in thought, I will now reveal to you the secret of my absence
night after night. I am working, mother, working like a slave, for a
position which, if once obtained, will give me support for my wife,
and a pretty sum over every year for my mother. There is a likelihood
that I shall get it, and if, in that event, I allow myself one luxury
or Philippa one gewgaw till those you parted with for my sake are paid
for, then say you are done with Lawrence Sutton, but not now, not while
there is any hope of his proving himself your son, indeed.”

But the barrier he had raised between them by his marriage was too
formidable to be overthrown in an instant; and with some parting words
of scorn she left him, and I heard her go up to her own room.

I hoped they would follow her, and so allow me to escape, but they had
too much to say to each other, too many explanations to make. I had to
be present at another confidential interview. Philippa, who, the moment
they were left alone, had assumed a totally different bearing from that
which seemed natural to her in Mrs. Winchester’s presence, waited for
her husband’s first emotion of grief to subside, then turned to him,
and taking his two hands in hers, drew him down beside her on the sofa.

“Lawrence,” said she, with a womanly sweetness inexpressibly winning
after the scene of stormy passions which had just passed, “do you think
you can ever forgive me?”

“Forgive _you_, my heart’s idol! What have I to forgive you for? The
consolation that you give me for my past, the hope that you bring me
for my future?”

“No, no,” she murmured; “for having married you; for having——”

“Philippa!” he cried, lifting her face with the tenderest touch, and
gazing long and earnestly into her eyes, “you are my wife. The holy
words that made us one have hardly ceased to echo. Do not let us mar
the moment, which can never come again, by any expression of doubt as
regards the wisdom or the happiness of what we have done. Let us enjoy
the delight of being all in all to each other, leaving to future hours,
perhaps, the grief of knowing that, in seeking our own welfare, we have
had to inflict disappointment upon others.”

“But——but——” she faltered, “you do not understand. I allude to my
marrying you to-night, in this haste, contrary to all my declarations
and every resolution I had formed.”

“And do you think I blame you for that? That my heart gave anything but
a leap of joy when you stopped me in the hall and whispered in my ear,
‘I am ready, Lawrence, ready to do what you so often have urged me to
do. I will marry you to-night if you say so’?”

“Oh!” she cried, and a flush of shame crept over her face, growing
lovelier with every moment that passed till I wondered I had not seen
at first glance that she was beautiful; “you reproach me with every
word; you make me feel that there is no one less deserving of such
faith and devotion than Philippa Irwin.”

“Philippa Sutton, darling; there is a difference,” he smiled.

The words seemed to strike her. She looked at him very earnestly for a

“Yes,” she assented. “What were wisdom in Philippa Irwin may not be
wisdom in Philippa Sutton. But truth is always wisdom, and I cannot
enter upon our married life with the shadow of a falsehood on my heart.
At the risk of losing your love, of seeing you turn away from me never
to come back, I must be frank with you and open to the very heart’s
core. Lawrence, I would not have married you to-night if——if it had not
been for the disappearance of those diamonds.”


“I know, I know I should have trusted you. That I should have seen
and felt that you were incapable of doing so mean and wicked a thing
as——as my suspicions suggested to me, but, coming up-stairs while your
mother was below, I had seen you pass into her room on tiptoe, stay
but a moment, and then come creeping out again, thrusting something
that glittered into your breast. I had seen this; and though I thought
nothing of it at the moment I——I did fear and tremble when from the
back room, into which I had stepped, I beheld her come back, walk
over to the mantel-piece where she stood for a moment gazing at her
jewel-case, and then, rushing to the window and throwing it open, run
out again into the hall crying that her diamonds were gone and that a
thief must have crawled in from the street and taken them while she was
below. For——it is my only excuse, Lawrence——I could not dream she had
taken advantage of that moment’s pause before the mantel to snatch the
jewels from their case and hide them in her own bosom. That would imply
a knowledge of facts and motives to which I was necessarily a stranger.
I could only think she was influenced in her action by a conviction
that one she loved had done this act, and this apparent conviction of
hers awakened mine; for she was a woman and a mother, and knew, as I
believed, her own son well, while I was but a simple girl who loved.
Yet see, yet see, she was the one who did the wrong, if wrong were
done, while you——” Philippa’s head sank on her breast and the tears

He let her weep for a moment; then with a slow and mechanical motion he
thrust his hand into his breast and took out a simple bracelet made of
silver coils and held it towards her.

“This is what I went for,” said he, “and this is what I brought out. I
had seen it lying on the sofa, Philippa, when I went in before dinner,
and my heart coveted it and my lips burned to kiss it, and——”

“O Lawrence!” was her cry, “my bracelet!” and then there was silence,
during which he sat with his eyes on her face in a mute reproach,
evidently worse to her than death. At last she could bear it no longer,
and lifting her head she gave him one look.

It seemed to recall him to himself. Grasping her hand, he uttered one
short sentence, but that was full of meaning. It was this: “And yet you
married me!”

The pallor of her cheek disappeared in a flush that made her absolutely

“I loved you,” she murmured, “and I knew, that is, I had heard, that a
wife could not be called upon to testify against her husband.”

He gave a sudden cry, and his arms closed passionately round her. He
did not tell her that that was an old and antiquated law, no longer in
force at this day; he only whispered words of love and consolation,
and when, ten minutes from that time, they left the room and I at last
succeeded in escaping from my hiding-place and from the house, it was
with the conviction that I had left two noble hearts behind me, whose
happiness, if not their worldly prosperity, was assured.

       *       *       *       *       *

Early the next morning I sent a line to Mr. Randall effectually
relieving him from all the doubts I had left in his mind as to Mr.
Sutton’s integrity and genuine change of character. This duty done I
thought the story ended, as far as outsiders were concerned. But it
was not so. Scarcely three days had elapsed when New York society was
startled and her business men confounded by the announcement that Mr.
Winchester had disappeared from town, leaving debts of an enormous
nature behind him and no assets wherewith to pay those debts. Then
and not till then did I understand his passionate anxiety about the
diamonds. To a man on the verge of ruin twenty-five thousand dollars
may hold out the promise of salvation. At all events it is a convenient
sum with which to facilitate flight, and its loss must have been a
heavy blow to him.

His wife, whose pride was perhaps phenomenal in its way, never
recovered from the shock thus given her. When the last load was driven
away from the house she was obliged to abandon, her indomitable spirit
broke, and it was a depressed and humiliated woman that at last
consented to take up her abode with the son she had cast off and the
woman she once looked upon with contempt.


I was walking along the Rue des Martins. I was thoughtful, for I had
just been witness to a sight that greatly moved me. My duties as a
reporter for one of the large Paris dailies had taken me to Havre just
as the ship came in which brought the Communists home from exile, and,
hardened as I confess myself to be to the more frequent aspects of
human suffering, the sight of those men crowding forward to catch the
first glimpse of the friends who had come to meet them, touched me
with a feeling that was not unlike compassion. I was thinking of them
and wondering what sort of fate awaited the older men I saw there,
when a sudden cry from over my head startled me from my musings, and
looking up, I saw a woman peering out of the top window of a wretched

She showed such signs of distress in her countenance that I at once
knew something terrible had occurred within, and foreseeing matter for
my next article, I immediately entered the house.

I found myself confronted by frightened faces everywhere. All the
inmates knew that something was wrong on the top floor, but no one knew
just what. They followed me when they saw me determined to find out.
The consequence was that a small crowd pressed behind me as I mounted
the last stair; a crowd that seemed to awe if not alarm the trembling
woman who awaited me at the top, for she started back as she saw it,
muttering to herself:

“_Mon Dieu!_ Elise never had so many visitors before!”

[Illustration: “THERE, STRETCHED ON HER BED.”]

A door swinging on its hinges at the right of this woman at once
attracted my attention. Advancing with small ceremony, I threw it open.
I found my expectations more than realized. On the bed before me lay
the outstretched form of a woman, the pallor and fixedness of whose
face bespoke death. Not a natural death either, for she was dressed as
if she had just come in from the street, with the exception of her
bonnet, which lay on the floor beside her, where it had evidently been
flung by a careless hand. Otherwise the room was in perfect order, I
may even say in holiday order. From the work neatly folded on the shelf
to the small bunch of fresh flowers that adorned a table set out with
an untouched meal——a meal which even in the hurried glance I gave it I
saw was arranged for two——all bespoke one of those rare days of rest
and relaxation which now and then enter a French working-woman’s life.

But the dead face on the pillow——what did it betoken? Had murder crept
into this humble dwelling or was it a suicide I beheld? Involuntarily
drawing nearer the bed, I looked at the face before me more closely. It
was that of a young and pretty woman, and while touchingly meagre and
sad was touchingly delicate also. It was almost a lady’s face, and had
it not been for the evidence of toil displayed by the hands I should
certainly have taken it for such. As it was I could not doubt that
a real working-woman lay there, though from the marks of refinement
observable in her dress and the presence of certain choice books
on the shelf over her head, she was evidently a woman of taste and

“It is a suicide!” I declared, seeing a bottle of well-known poison
protruding from under the pillow.

“Of course it is,” murmured a voice over my shoulder. “Don’t you see
what she has written on that paper near you?”

I glanced down at the table by which I was standing and saw a sheet of
common note paper, inscribed with these words:

  “My husband was a Communist and was exiled. He was all I had in
  the world, and since his departure I have only lived to see him
  again. But I have had no news, no letter. I have been patient,
  however, for I have waited for this day. But it has come, and
  it has not brought him. I went to the ship myself and looked at
  every man who left it. He was not amongst them. So now I know
  he is dead. That being so, there is no more reason why I should


Involuntarily I had read these words aloud. A murmur of almost
ferocious sympathy greeted them from the crowd that had gathered at
my back. The sound disturbed me, for my thoughts had flown at once to
the ship and that throng of pale and eager men I had myself seen in
the morning. I felt a strange inclination to be alone, and shouldering
my way out past the humble table set so touchingly with a meal never
destined to be eaten, I made my way into the hall.

But before I could reach the stairs a woman advanced and laid her hand
on my arm. It was the same who had given the first alarm.

“Would you mind stepping into my room a minute?” she asked. “There is
something I would like to show you.”

Naturally curious, I followed at once.

“What is it?” I inquired, when we were shut in an apartment of even
scantier proportions than the one we had just left.

[Illustration: “ONLY SOME LETTERS.”]

“Only some letters which Elise put into my hands a little while
ago——before——before she showed herself so tired of life. You see we had
been neighbors here, and Elise, though she was far above me——she was
born a lady, Monsieur——was kind to me, and told me many of her griefs.
I could not appreciate them all, for I never was educated; but I do
know what it is to love, for I had a good husband myself once, and so
when she spoke of him I could understand. And there was not a day she
did not speak of him. It was as if he always stood at her side. Her
very eyes had a far-away look, as if she was seeing something more than
the rest of us did. I used to have an awe of her, especially when she
smiled to herself.”

“It is very sad,” said I. “And did she never hear from him after he was
taken away?”

“No. She never doubted that he lived, though, and would come back. ‘I
feel it here,’ she used to say, laying her hand on her heart. ‘Why
else do I live?’ she would add. Only yesterday her face was like the
sunlight. ‘I am sure he will come home with the rest,’ she cried, ‘and
then I shall know why he did not write.’ Did you see how she had his
dinner ready? I went with her to market, and it was touching to hear
her say, ‘I must get this,’ or ‘I must get that; he used to like it so

“Did you go with her to the wharf?” I asked, willing to learn all I

“No, Monsieur. She didn’t seem to want me to. But I shall never forget
the look she gave me as she went out of the door. There wasn’t any
doubt in it. To my foolish mind it seemed to say, ‘I shall never be
lonely in this room any more.’ _Mon Dieu!_ when I think how that look
must have brightened when she saw the poor wanderers crowding forward
out of the ship, and then have faded away to what it was when she came
back alone, my heart is ready to break.”

“You saw her, then, after her return?”

“A moment. She came to my door with the letters you have there. As soon
as I saw her I knew what had happened, but I couldn’t speak. My tongue
seemed to cleave to the roof of my mouth. You see, I had been as sure
as she that he would be there with the rest.”

“Didn’t you say anything then?”

“Not a word; she didn’t give me a chance. ‘My husband is dead,’ was
her greeting as she opened the door. ‘I looked in the face of every
one of the exiles as they left the ship, and he was not there. I want
to leave these letters with you; they were meant for him.’ And without
looking me in the face she laid the package down with a slow stiff
movement, as if she were already half dead herself, then went out and
closed the door. There was something in her look which told me not to
follow her.”

“But weren’t you afraid of what she would do? Didn’t you fear she might
commit suicide?”

“No, sir. Yet if I had I don’t think I should have followed her.” Then
as I looked up surprised the good woman hastened to say:

“It is a sadder story than you think. If you care to hear——”

I did not wait for her to finish.

“Tell me all you know about her,” said I.

The woman eagerly complied. The facts which she gave me, together with
a few others afterwards gleaned by me from a different source, form
the basis of the following history, a history which I am sure you
will pardon me for giving in my own words rather than in those of my

Elise Lepage was not a beauty, yet in her earlier youth, at least, she
possessed a charm which always insured her the admiration and very
often the love of those with whom she came in contact. Her father, who
was a musician of somewhat mediocre talent, recognized this charm, and
in his simple way calculated upon its winning her a suitable husband,
notwithstanding his small means and her consequent lack of a dowry.
To him she was a paragon, and when, at the close of a long day of
unremitting labor at the piano, he saw her approaching him in a dainty
fresh robe ready for their usual walk on the boulevard, his face would
light up with such pride and joy that the loving girl who watched him
felt the tear gush to her eye at the same moment the smile rose to her

They lived in a plain but sufficiently comfortable apartment, and had
for neighbors two young men by the name of Picard,——brothers. These
two young men occupied the apartment above them; and one of them,
the youngest, having some taste for music, a natural acquaintance
had sprung up between him and M. Lepage, which presently involved
the older brother and Mlle. Lepage. The consequence was that Jean,
the elder brother, fell in love with the fresh, charming young girl,
and, being himself a man of no conventional prejudices——the future
Communist in fact——he offered to marry her without any other fortune
than that of her youth and many virtues. The old father was delighted.
First, because he felt himself failing in health and was anxious to
see his darling’s future secured; and secondly, because he liked this
man better than any one else in the world save and excepting always
his dear and much admired daughter. Why he felt this extraordinary
affection for a man of whom he was forced to acknowledge to himself
he knew but little, he could not have told had he tried. Certainly
it was not because he understood him, for he did not; neither was it
because the other possessed attractions of a peculiar or marked nature.
Jean Picard was not handsome, nor was he even gifted in manner or
conversation, yet old Mr. Lepage loved him and hailed the prospect of
his being his son-in-law with as much fervor as if he were the owner
of millions instead of being the physician of one of the poorest and
worst paying quarters in the whole city. He trusted him, and that fact,
perhaps, illustrates the character of the two men. For Jean Picard was
to be trusted in all matters of the heart and conscience; it was only
his head that was at fault, or, perhaps, I should say his temperament.
He had inherited traditions of the First Revolution, and believed
absolutely in the might of the people. But of this he had nothing to
say in those days, his head and his heart being joined in the one wish,
the one hope, the one purpose, to make Elise his wife.

The evening which he had chosen to speak to M. Lepage——he had never
breathed a word of his desires to Elise herself——was, as he afterwards
remembered, an especially beautiful one. The moon was shining, and as,
filled with the joy of a successful suit, he stepped from the apartment
of M. Lepage, something in the quiet beauty of this round and serene
orb touched the poetry that exists with all true love in the heart,
and drew him, in spite of his usually active ways, to a window opening
from the corridor on to a small garden belonging to the _concierge_. He
was looking from this window and dreaming of Elise, when his glance,
which had been mechanically fixed upon a leafy retreat beneath him,
became earnest, deep, and inquiring, and with a startled gesture of
surprise, he bent forward and listened as if his life depended upon
his hearing what went on in the garden below him. Had he seen anything
which threatened his happiness, and if so, what?

His firm and controlled countenance tells little, but his wandering
look and the unsteady step with which he leaves the window and betakes
himself to his own room bespeak strong agitation. If we follow him
and watch him as a half hour later he slowly rouses from the deep and
troubled brooding into which he had sunk immediately upon his entrance,
and turning towards the door, waits with a look not to be mistaken for
the advance of the step just becoming audible upon the stairs, we shall
undoubtedly learn from his own lips what it is that has disturbed him
so deeply at a moment he esteemed himself so profoundly blessed.

Yet is he going to speak? His lips have opened, his face has assumed
a terrible expression, he has even advanced two paces toward the door
to meet the expected comer, when suddenly he pauses. The face he sees
before him is not the one he anticipated. It is that of his brother, to
be sure, but it does not wear the look he had schooled himself to meet,
the triumphant look that goes with happy love, however wrongfully it
may be won. The surprise upsets him, and for a moment the words falter
on his tongue, then all his manhood re-asserts itself, and imperiously
beckoning his brother to enter, he closes the door and stands with the
handle still in his grasp, looking at Camille.

“You are in trouble,” said he shortly. “What is it?” Then as he saw his
brother start and uneasily drop his eyes, added bitterly: “Have you
told her what you are, and does she refuse to marry you?”

Camille, who was of a fiery nature, but who for certain reasons stood
somewhat in awe of his brother, looked for a moment as if he could have
leaped at his throat; but he restrained himself, and while the veins
swelled on his forehead and his face grew fiery red, he stammered:

“Whom do you mean by her? I do not understand you.”

“That is not true; you understand me perfectly,” was the rude but brave
Jean’s straightforward response. “But if you must have names I allude
to Elise, the pure, innocent, high-minded girl whom by arts I do not
profess to understand you have succeeded in pleasing, till, for aught I
know, she considers you a model of virtue and goodness.”

“And if she did?” broke in the other impetuously.

Jean drew a deep breath and stepped slowly back.

“I should undeceive her,” he declared, “if by the act I alienated her
good-will forever.”

Camille, who for some cause did not resent the first clause of this
sentence, started at the second, and gave his brother a sharp look.

“_Mon Dieu!_” exclaimed he, with as much wonder as jealousy in his
tone. “Do you love her too?”

The look which Jean turned upon his brother made that other’s weak and
selfish heart stand still.

“I love her,” said he, “I will not say _too_, for you do not love her.
Had you loved her you would have fled from her instead of using all
your arts secretly to win her. A criminal——”

“Hush!” exclaimed the other, with a terrified look around him that for
some reason made Jean quail with a sense of apprehension. “Do you want
to draw the police upon me?”

With a stride Jean advanced upon his brother, and, laying his strong
hand on his shoulders, uncompromisingly turned him towards the light.

“You tremble,” he muttered under his breath. “You shrink, and your face
is like marble. _Mon Dieu!_ Camille, is there anything new?”

With a suppressed cry Camille tore himself from his brother’s hands.

“Who has given you the right to question me?” he cried. “I will not
have it. I have had enough of your spying.” And flinging himself
violently towards the door of his own room, he was on the point of
disappearing from Jean’s presence, when the latter, with another
movement of his strong arm, drew him back and himself entered the

In an instant he came back. His face was like stone, and he had in his
hand a valise fully packed, which he set heavily down on the table
before Camille’s eyes.

“What does this mean?” he asked. “Where are you going and why have you
kept your departure a secret from me?”

For a moment the stricken Camille did not reply; then he broke down,
and flinging himself on his knees, burst forth with the cry:

“I am a ruined man, Jean; I——I tried it again, and this time it will be
found out. To-morrow, to-night, possibly, my employer will look over
his books, and——”

“How much is it?” broke in Jean, in a low, strained voice.

“Ten thousand francs,” murmured the other. “All gone.”

“Lost at play?”

Camille nodded his head.

Jean drew back, covering his face for a moment with his hands.

“I have just that amount,” he said, “saved up. Your employer shall have
it to-morrow. As for you,” he added bitterly, “I wash my hands of you.
This is twice.”

His voice broke, and he hurriedly withdrew to the window, as if the
sight of his brother’s face maddened him.

He returned almost instantly, however, and walking straight up to
Camille, demanded:

“What were you doing there?” pointing sternly below. “This bag shows
you intended to abscond to-night. Were you bidding her farewell or——”

He had not strength to finish, but his look filled up the hiatus left
in his speech.

Camille faltered beneath that glance. If he could have seen a way to
escape, his furtive, worried look showed he would have availed himself
of it. But his brother’s eye held him and would have the truth. With a
gasp he broke forth:

“I have bidden her farewell. She does not know why I go. She loves me
and she trusts me. I——I would have persuaded her to go with me if I
could. I love her, I say, whatever you may call it. I love her, do you
hear, and if I could have induced her to leave her father you would not
have caught me in this box. It was my despair.”

He stopped. There was something in Jean’s face which told him that
silence was better than speech at this moment. The first words of Jean
convinced him of it.

“You are a villain,” said he, “and the punishment of your villainy
shall be a confession. I hope to marry Elise Lepage,” he went on,
raising his hand for silence as he saw his brother about to protest,
“and I do not intend she shall waste her life in useless regrets
over the loss of one so unworthy as yourself. Come, then, and in her
presence, if not in that of her father, proclaim yourself the criminal
that you are or——”

“Or what?” asked the other, with a wild gleam, half of defiance, half
of fear.

“Or I keep my ten thousand francs and leave you to the tender mercies
of a man whose justice, you have reason to know, is stronger than his

A cold sweat broke out on Camille’s face. He looked at his brother with
great staring eyes as if he could hardly believe in the alternative
that was offered him. Seeing it, Jean continued:

“It is three years since the day I first awoke to the knowledge that I
had for my brother a man who had provoked the justice of the law, and
only escaped by the ignorance or blindness of those he had defrauded.
In those three years I have spared nothing, either in the way of money
or effort, to give you what you wanted and save you, if possible,
from the repetition of your dastardly crime. How have you repaid me?
By stealing the fancy of the woman I loved, or,” as Camille faintly
objected, “the fancy of a girl whom you knew I respected, and whom you
also knew would never have given you her regard had she known your
real character or suspected the shadow that hung above you. She thinks
you true, you say, and trusts you. That means she will remember you
lovingly in your absence, possibly wait for your return, when return
you never will. Elise is too fine a girl to be thus sacrificed,”
asserted Jean, “and if I did not love her I should still say, ‘Come
below, and show yourself to her for what you are.’ Better she should
suffer this one shock, that in itself carries healing, than linger on
for years a prey to a pain of longing that will be none the less keen
because it will be so bravely hidden.”

But Camille had sunk before this prospect.

“I cannot,” he murmured, “I would rather go to the galleys.”


Meantime, in her own little room below, Elise was bitterly weeping. She
had loved Camille almost unconsciously. Not till she saw him about to
leave her did she realize how deeply he had entered into her dreams and
hopes. Then the mystery of his departure heightened its effect. Though
the ready tale he told of the fine position which had been offered him
in a mercantile house in Peru was plausible enough, there was something
in his manner and the fact that he wished to carry her away with him
secretly that struck an icy doubt to her heart, and, devoted as she was
to him, she felt as if she would give all the world, were it hers, to
throw herself into her father’s arms and ask him for his sympathy and
counsel. But that was expressly forbidden. Her father must know nothing
of her sorrow or her love; her wilful lover would not have it. And
young as she was, innocent as her thoughts were of wrong or deception,
there was something in this ban laid between her and the father she
so idolized, that awakened strange doubts and fears in her otherwise
trusting bosom.

Her room adjoined that of M. Lepage, and more than once during her
grief and tears she had heard his restless foot approach the door of
communication, as though he were about to call her to him. But he did
not; she was so quiet he evidently thought she was asleep, and finally
all became as still in his room as it was deathlike in hers. And Elise
wept on.

Suddenly there came a tap, not on the door she had been so fearful
of seeing open, but on the one which led into the hall. Astonished,
frightened almost, she crept to it and faintly asked who was there. A
woman’s voice answered. It was the _concierge_, who handed her a small
note. Hurriedly lighting her candle, Elise unfolded it and read:

  “MADEMOISELLE——It is indispensable that I should have a few
  minutes’ conversation with you to-night. It is 10 o’clock,
  therefore your father has retired and your little sitting-room
  will be free. I shall not come alone.


A whirl of thoughts swept through Elise’s brain. She felt dizzy, almost
sick, but she did not hesitate. Opening the door into her father’s
room, she glided in. All was quiet. The good man was evidently asleep.
Hastily crossing the floor, she gained the little sitting-room beyond,
and, closing the door behind her, struck a light. Then, stopping but a
moment to regain breath and still the nervous beatings of her heart,
she approached the hall door and softly opened it. A low cry escaped
her as she did so, the two men standing on the threshold bore in their
countenances such signs of subdued agitation.

“What is it?” she faintly breathed, falling back with a slow step as
they entered. “Why are you here so late? And together?” she could not
help adding, as her eyes roamed from the one face to the other, both
so white, both so drawn, both so filled with that strange look which a
woman only sees on the countenance of the man who loves her.

As Camille did not answer, Jean replied:

“Mademoiselle,” said he, “I have come here on a very disagreeable duty.
I have come to hear my brother tell you the truth. Camille, speak.”

Camille, thus abjured, cast one glance of burning anguish at his
brother, then in a voice so unnatural Elise could scarcely believe it
his own, exclaimed bitterly:

“He wishes me to tell you I am a villain. It is not a pleasant thing
to say of one’s self, Mademoiselle, but it is true. I am a villain,
and——and I advise you to forget me.”

The deep misery expressed in his tones shook Jean a little, but he was
inexorable. Giving one glance at Elise, who, seemingly turned into
stone by the terrible nature of her lover’s words, stood breathless and
pale before them, he said:

“It is not enough, Camille; tell her why you go away to-night. Tell her
it is a flight.”

“You have said it,” murmured the other, half savagely; then as Jean
remained unchanged in look and attitude, cried harshly: “Mademoiselle,
I am unworthy of your attention. I——I am no longer an honest man.

“Stolen,” added a deep, firm voice.

The silence that followed this word was such as could be felt.

“And you wished to take me with you!” were the words that first
interrupted it.

“I love you,” murmured Camille in a broken, miserable tone.

Elise turned slowly away.

“My father! my father!” burst involuntarily from her lips, and she held
out her arms in dumb entreaty to the door that separated her from her
beloved parent.

Instantly and as if in answer to her appeal, a strange murmur arose
from that room, an inarticulate, almost an agonized murmur that struck
terror to the hearts of those who heard it.

“My father!” again cried Elise, and this time she rushed at the door
and tore it widely open. Her father lay stretched before her on the
floor, having evidently fallen in his efforts to answer her summons.

       *       *       *       *       *

It was midnight, two hours after the fatal event recorded in the above
lines. Around the bedside of M. Lepage were grouped a physician, a
priest, the _concierge_, Jean Picard, and his daughter. Camille was
already far away.

The physician had given them no hope. In an hour or less the poor
musician’s soul would be far away. He was sensible of it himself. Upon
his first return to consciousness he had said:

“This is death.”

Elise, overwhelmed as she was, could not weep. Her one thought seemed
to be: “Supposing I had listened to Camille’s entreaties, and had been
flying from Paris in this terrible hour!”

Jean Picard, on the contrary, shed more than one tear. Perhaps the
restraint he had put upon himself in the tragic scene which had
preceded this catastrophe was having its revenge upon him now, or
perhaps the look of peace with which the old man surveyed him and his
daughter, standing, as they were, side by side, struck him by its
contrast to the sad reality. It was midnight, as I have said, and the
clock was striking. As it ceased, the dying man spoke:

“May I not see your two hands joined?” he asked, gazing tenderly at
Jean and Elise.

As though a thunderbolt had fallen at her feet, Elise started and fell
back. Jean hastily cleared the room and then leading her gently up to
the bedside, he said solemnly:

“Mademoiselle, you must pardon your father. Three hours ago I had the
honor to ask of him your hand in marriage, and he had the goodness to
accord it to me. He does not know that we have had no conversation on
this matter since, and that therefore such words must fall upon you
with a shock.”

“Did you——were you——” she stammered, “thinking of this when you——”

“Mademoiselle,” interrupted Jean, “whatever I have ever done or said
has been more for your sake than my own; believe that.” And he threw a
glance at M. Lepage which she could not fail to understand.

Hiding her face in her hands, Elise knelt by the bedside. She could
feel her father’s hand fall on her head, caressingly, lingeringly. In a
minute more she heard him say:

“He is a good man; you will marry him, Elise?” Then as she did not
answer, he added softly, “I should die so happy.”

With a spring she stood upright. “Jean Picard,” she said, “do you wish
me for your wife?”

A great light which she could not help noticing in that solemn hour
settled slowly over all his face.

“There is nothing I wish so much,” he answered; “it has been my dream
for months.”

“After what you know of my heart?” she murmured, but so low the dying
man could not hear her.

“Elise,” was the equally low answer, “I do not expect you to love me
just yet, but you need a protector; let me be that protector. You need
some one to comfort you and provide you with a home; let me be that
friend, and I will trust my love to make you satisfied in the end.”

“You are a good man,” she murmured, in unconscious repetition of her
father’s words; and, scarcely knowing what she did, she laid her hand
in his, seeing more clearly the smile that parted her poor father’s
lips at the action than the solemn look above with which Jean Picard
accepted the trust thus imparted to him.

And so it was that Elise Lepage became the wife of Jean Picard, and a
tragedy of the heart was begun which ended, as we have seen, in her
death. For Elise was a conscientious woman, and once married set all
her hopes on the prospect of some day becoming as much a wife in heart
as she was now in name. But that heart was at first too sore with the
violent wrench it had sustained to experience much beyond gratitude,
and months rolled by without Jean Picard discovering in his young
wife’s studiously kind manner any token of that passion which informed
his own life. Yet the germ if not the flower of it was in her breast.
Unconsciously to herself her husband was becoming all in all to her,
but the feeling she experienced for him was so different from that she
had given to his unworthy brother that she did not recognize it for
what it was, and called it simply friendship.

The stirring events of the war and the opening days of the Commune
did not alter matters. A numbness seemed to settle upon Elise as she
saw her husband gradually identifying himself with a cause she both
mistrusted and feared. That her coldness drove him into the savage
warfare of the barricades she did not think. She knew him well enough
to perceive that, however it was with others, with him it was a matter
of conscience to uphold what he called the rights of the people. And
perceiving this, she did not lose her respect for him, though her
terrors accumulated and an element of dread came into her regard for
him which caused her less and less to suspect the true nature of the
emotions he inspired.

Nor did the culmination of his career and his subsequent downfall fully
awaken her. Like a dream the dreadful days passed in which he was
tried, condemned, and sentenced to exile; like a dream came the time
of parting. And not till she felt herself torn from his clasping arms
did she realize that life was ending for her, that the moment of death
had come and she had never told him she loved him. Making a vigorous
effort, for her senses seemed to be leaving her, she turned, all
tremulous with passionate feeling, and holding out her arms to him, was
about to utter what would have illumined his exile, when doubt, that
black shadow of the soul, glided again across her spirit, and, saying
to herself, “’Tis but a boundless regret at the loss of his goodness,”
she permitted herself only to cry:

“Good-by, Jean. I will be true to you in your absence, and work if need
be with my own hands, to sustain myself till you come back.”

His sad smile told her, when too late, what she had done, or rather
had omitted to do.

The memory of that smile never left her. It haunted her day and night.
The struggle into which she was forced for her daily bread only served
to perpetuate her remorse. From a somewhat practical woman she became
a dreamer of dreams. All her soul centred in the one wish, the one
hope of seeing him again, if only to whisper in his ear the truth that
was every day becoming more and more apparent in her own heart. She
dared not write it to him. The first few dutiful letters she had sent
had never been answered, and she was of a temperament that made it
impossible for her to risk the chance of her heart’s story falling into
alien or unsympathetic hands. But she could not entirely smother her
desire for utterance. So the letters came to be written, which, though
never sent, contained the beatings of her heart through that long and
dreary separation, letters which she evidently fully expected would
meet his eyes, and tell him in sweetest language what her own tongue
had failed to do on that memorable day of their parting.

But hope cherished to the last, went suddenly out like a candle
extinguished. The ship which was to bring the exiles home arrived in
safety, and she saw it and saw them, but did not see him. The blow was
fatal. Without asking a question, or doubting the doom which had fallen
upon him and therefore upon her, she returned home and put, as we have
seen, a desperate end to her own life. Love long repressed had had its
full revenge. She could not live without its object.

Such was the story of Elise Picard, told me in substance by the good
woman who had befriended her and in detail by the letters she had left
behind her in this same woman’s charge. I had scarcely reached the end,
that is, had scarcely laid the last letter down, when a sudden hubbub
rose in the hall without, followed by a pitiful low moan which somehow
or other awoke in me a peculiar apprehension. Springing to the door
I flung it open. Never shall I forget the picture that met my eyes.
Frozen each in his place by some great emotion, the eager crowd before
me stood silent, aghast, gazing at a figure that, emaciated almost
beyond the semblance of a man, crouched against the wall which led
towards the room of death.

The hush, the intolerable anguish expressed by that form, bent almost
double by the sudden weight of woe which had fallen upon it, touched me
to the quick. Grasping the hand of the first person I could reach, I

“Who is he? What does this mean?”

But I did not need an answer to my question; I knew without words that
Jean Picard stood before me.

       *       *       *       *       *

I learned afterwards that he was among the men that passed before her
eyes on the wharf, but he was so changed by disease and grief she had
not recognized him. He had been spending the last two hours in a search
for her.

  Transcriber's Notes

    Added a table of contents.

    Inconsistent punctuation corrected.

*** End of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "7 to 12 - A Detective Story" ***

Doctrine Publishing Corporation provides digitized public domain materials.
Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians.
This effort is time consuming and expensive, so in order to keep providing
this resource, we have taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties,
including placing technical restrictions on automated querying.

We also ask that you:

+ Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Doctrine Publishing
Corporation's ISYS search for use by individuals, and we request that you
use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes.

+ Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort
to Doctrine Publishing's system: If you are conducting research on machine
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a
large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of
public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help.

+ Keep it legal -  Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for
ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because
we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States,
that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries.
Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we
can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is
allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Doctrine Publishing
ISYS search  means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world.
Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe.

About ISYS® Search Software
Established in 1988, ISYS Search Software is a global supplier of enterprise
search solutions for business and government.  The company's award-winning
software suite offers a broad range of search, navigation and discovery
solutions for desktop search, intranet search, SharePoint search and embedded
search applications.  ISYS has been deployed by thousands of organizations
operating in a variety of industries, including government, legal, law
enforcement, financial services, healthcare and recruitment.