By Author [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Title [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Language
all Classics books content using ISYS

Download this book: [ ASCII | PDF ]

Look for this book on Amazon

We have new books nearly every day.
If you would like a news letter once a week or once a month
fill out this form and we will give you a summary of the books for that week or month by email.

Title: The Case of the Lamp That Went Out
Author: Groner, Auguste
Language: English
As this book started as an ASCII text book there are no pictures available.
Copyright Status: Not copyrighted in the United States. If you live elsewhere check the laws of your country before downloading this ebook. See comments about copyright issues at end of book.

*** Start of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "The Case of the Lamp That Went Out" ***

This book is indexed by ISYS Web Indexing system to allow the reader find any word or number within the document.


By Augusta Groner

Translated by  Grace Isabel Colbron


Joseph Muller, Secret Service detective of the Imperial Austrian police,
is one of the great experts in his profession. In personality he differs
greatly from other famous detectives. He has neither the impressive
authority of Sherlock Holmes, nor the keen brilliancy of Monsieur Lecoq.
Muller is a small, slight, plain-looking man, of indefinite age, and of
much humbleness of mien. A naturally retiring, modest disposition, and
two external causes are the reasons for Muller’s humbleness of manner,
which is his chief characteristic. One cause is the fact that in early
youth a miscarriage of justice gave him several years in prison, an
experience which cast a stigma on his name and which made it impossible
for him, for many years after, to obtain honest employment. But the
world is richer, and safer, by Muller’s early misfortune. For it was
this experience which threw him back on his own peculiar talents for
a livelihood, and drove him into the police force. Had he been able to
enter any other profession, his genius might have been stunted to a mere
pastime, instead of being, as now, utilised for the public good.

Then, the red tape and bureaucratic etiquette which attaches to every
governmental department, puts the secret service men of the Imperial
police on a par with the lower ranks of the subordinates. Muller’s
official rank is scarcely much higher than that of a policeman, although
kings and councillors consult him and the Police Department realises to
the full what a treasure it has in him. But official red tape, and his
early misfortune... prevent the giving of any higher official standing
to even such a genius. Born and bred to such conditions, Muller
understands them, and his natural modesty of disposition asks for no
outward honours, asks for nothing but an income sufficient for his
simple needs, and for aid and opportunity to occupy himself in the way
he most enjoys.

Joseph Muller’s character is a strange mixture. The kindest-hearted man
in the world, he is a human bloodhound when once the lure of the trail
has caught him. He scarcely eats or sleeps when the chase is on, he does
not seem to know human weakness nor fatigue, in spite of his frail body.
Once put on a case his mind delves and delves until it finds a clue,
then something awakes within him, a spirit akin to that which holds
the bloodhound nose to trail, and he will accomplish the apparently
impossible, he will track down his victim when the entire machinery of
a great police department seems helpless to discover anything. The high
chiefs and commissioners grant a condescending permission when Muller
asks, “May I do this? ... or may I handle this case this way?”
 both parties knowing all the while that it is a farce, and that the
department waits helpless until this humble little man saves its honour
by solving some problem before which its intricate machinery has stood
dazed and puzzled.

This call of the trail is something that is stronger than anything else
in Muller’s mentality, and now and then it brings him into conflict with
the department,... or with his own better nature. Sometimes his unerring
instinct discovers secrets in high places, secrets which the Police
Department is bidden to hush up and leave untouched. Muller is then
taken off the case, and left idle for a while if he persists in his
opinion as to the true facts. And at other times, Muller’s own warm
heart gets him into trouble. He will track down his victim, driven by
the power in his soul which is stronger than all volition; but when he
has this victim in the net, he will sometimes discover him to be a
much finer, better man than the other individual, whose wrong at this
particular criminal’s hand set in motion the machinery of justice.
Several times that has happened to Muller, and each time his heart got
the better of his professional instincts, of his practical common-sense,
too, perhaps,... at least as far as his own advancement was concerned,
and he warned the victim, defeating his own work. This peculiarity of
Muller’s character caused his undoing at last, his official undoing that
is, and compelled his retirement from the force. But his advice is often
sought unofficially by the Department, and to those who know, Muller’s
hand can be seen in the unravelling of many a famous case.

The following stories are but a few of the many interesting cases that
have come within the experience of this great detective. But they give
a fair portrayal of Muller’s peculiar method of working, his looking on
himself as merely an humble member of the Department, and the comedy
of his acting under “official orders” when the Department is in reality
following out his directions.



The radiance of a clear September morning lay over Vienna. The air was
so pure that the sky shone in brightest azure even where the city’s
buildings clustered thickest. On the outskirts of the town the rays
of the awakening sun danced in crystalline ether and struck answering
gleams from the dew on grass and shrub in the myriad gardens of the
suburban streets.

It was still very early. The old-fashioned steeple clock on the church
of the Holy Virgin in Hietzing had boomed out six slow strokes but a
short time back. Anna, the pretty blonde girl who carried out the milk
for the dwellers in several streets of this aristocratic residential
suburb, was just coming around the corner of the main street into a
quiet lane. This lane could hardly be dignified by the name of street as
yet, it was so very quiet. It had been opened and named scarcely a year
back and it was bordered mostly by open gardens or fenced-in building
lots. There were four houses in this street, two by two opposite each
other, and another, an old-fashioned manor house, lying almost hidden in
its great garden. But the quiet street could not presume to ownership of
this last house, for the front of it opened on a parallel street, which
gave it its number. Only the garden had a gate as outlet onto our quiet

Anna stopped in front of this gate and pulled the bell. She had to wait
for some little time until the gardener’s wife, who acted as janitress,
could open the door. But Anna was not impatient, for she knew that it
was quite a distance from the gardener’s house in the centre of the
great stretch of park to the little gate where she waited. In a few
moments, however, the door was opened and a pleasant-faced woman
exchanged a friendly greeting with the girl and took the cans from her.

Anna hastened onward with her usual energetic step. The four houses in
that street were already served and she was now bound for the homes of
customers several squares away. Then her step slowed just a bit. She
was a quiet, thoughtful girl and the lovely peace of this bright morning
sank into her heart and made her rejoice in its beauty. All around her
the foliage was turning gently to its autumn glory of colouring and the
dewdrops on the rich-hued leaves sparkled with an unusual radiance. A
thrush looked down at her from a bough and began its morning song. Anna
smiled up at the little bird and began herself to sing a merry tune.

But suddenly her voice died away, the colour faded from her flushed
cheeks, her eyes opened wide and she stood as if riveted to the ground.
With a deep breath as of unconscious terror she let the burden of the
milk cans drop gently from her shoulder to the ground. In following the
bird’s flight her eyes had wandered to the side of the street, to the
edge of one of the vacant lots, there where a shallow ditch separated
it from the roadway. An elder-tree, the great size of which attested its
age, hung its berry-laden branches over the ditch. And in front of this
tree the bird had stopped suddenly, then fluttered off with the quick
movement of the wild creature surprised by fright. What the bird
had seen was the same vision that halted the song on Anna’s lips and
arrested her foot. It was the body of a man--a young and well-dressed
man, who lay there with his face turned toward the street. And his face
was the white frozen face of a corpse.

Anna stood still, looking down at him for a few moments, in wide-eyed
terror: then she walked on slowly as if trying to pull herself together
again. A few steps and then she turned and broke into a run. When she
reached the end of the street, breathless from haste and excitement, she
found herself in one of the main arteries of traffic of the suburb, but
owing to the early hour this street was almost as quiet as the lane she
had just left. Finally the frightened girl’s eyes caught sight of the
figure of a policeman coming around the next corner. She flew to meet
him and recognised him as the officer of that beat.

“Why, what is the matter?” he asked. “Why are you so excited?”

“Down there--in the lane, there’s a dead man,” answered the girl, gasping
for breath.

“A dead man?” repeated the policeman gravely, looking at the girl. “Are
you sure he’s dead?”

Anna nodded. “His eyes are all glassy and I saw blood on his back.”

“Well, you’re evidently very much frightened, and I suppose you don’t
want to go down there again. I’ll look into the matter, if you will go
to the police station and make the announcement. Will you do it?”

“Yes, sir.”

“All right, then, that will gain time for us. Good-bye, Miss Anna.”

The man walked quickly down the street, while the girl hurried off in
the opposite direction, to the nearest police station, where she told
what she had seen.

The policeman reached his goal even earlier. The first glance told him
that the man lying there by the wayside was indeed lifeless. And the icy
stiffness of the hand which he touched showed him that life must have
fled many hours back. Anna had been right about the blood also. The dead
man lay on the farther side of the ditch, half down into it. His right
arm was bent under his body, his left arm was stretched out, and the
stiffened fingers... they were slender white fingers... had sought for
something to break his fall. All they had found was a tall stem of wild
aster with its purple blossoms, which they were holding fast in the
death grip. On the dead man’s back was a small bullet-wound and around
the edges of it his light grey coat was stained with blood. His face was
distorted in pain and terror. It was a nice face, or would have been,
did it not show all too plainly the marks of dissipation in spite of the
fact that the man could not have been much past thirty years old. He was
a stranger to the policeman, although the latter had been on this beat
for over three years.

When the guardian of the law had convinced himself that there was
nothing more to do for the man who lay there, he rose from his stooping
position and stepped back. His gaze wandered up and down the quiet lane,
which was still absolutely empty of human life. He stood there quietly
waiting, watching over the ghastly discovery. In about ten minutes the
police commissioner and the coroner, followed by two roundsmen with a
litter, joined the solitary watcher, and the latter could return to his

The policemen set down their litter and waited for orders, while the
coroner and the commissioner bent over the corpse. There was nothing
for the physician to do but to declare that the unfortunate man had been
dead for many hours. The bullet which struck him in the back had killed
him at once. The commissioner examined the ground immediately around
the corpse, but could find nothing that pointed to a struggle. There
remained only to prove whether there had been a robbery as well as a

“Judging from the man’s position the bullet must have come from that
direction,” said the commissioner, pointing towards the cottages down
the lane.

“People who are killed by bullets may turn several times before they
fall,” said a gentle voice behind the police officer. The voice seemed
to suit the thin little man who stood there meekly, his hat in his hand.

The commissioner turned quickly. “Ah, are you there already, Muller?”
 he said, as if greatly pleased, while the physician broke in with the

“That’s just what I was about to observe. This man did not die so
quickly that he could not have made a voluntary or involuntary movement
before life fled. The shot that killed him might have come from any

The commissioner nodded thoughtfully and there was silence for a
few moments. Muller--for the little thin man was none other than the
celebrated Joseph Muller, one of the most brilliant detectives in the
service of the Austrian police--looked down at the corpse carefully.
He took plenty of time to do it and nobody hurried him. For nobody ever
hurried Muller; his well-known and almost laughable thoroughness and
pedantry were too valuable in their results. It was a tradition in the
police that Muller was to have all the time he wanted for everything. It
paid in the end, for Muller made few mistakes. Therefore, his superior
the police commissioner, and the coroner waited quietly while the little
man made his inspection of the corpse.

“Thank you,” said Muller finally, with a polite bow to the commissioner,
before he bent to brush away the dust on his knees.

“Well?” asked Commissioner Holzer.

Muller smiled an embarrassed smile as he replied:

“Well... I haven’t found out anything yet except that he is dead, and
that he has been shot in the back. His pockets may tell us something

“Yes, we can examine them at once,” said the commissioner. “I have been
delaying that for I wanted you here; but I had no idea that you would
come so soon. I told them to fetch you if you were awake, but doubted
you would be, for I know you have had no sleep for forty-eight hours.”

“Oh, I can sleep, at least with one eye, when I’m on the chase,”
 answered the detective. “So it’s really only twenty-four hours, you
see.” Muller had just returned from tracking down an aristocratic
swindler whom he had found finally in a little French city and had
brought back to a Viennese prison. He had returned well along in the
past night and Holzer knew that the tired man would need his rest.
Still he had sent for Muller, who lived near the police station, for
the girl’s report had warned him that this was a serious case. And in
serious cases the police did not like to do without Muller’s help.

And as usual when his work called him, Muller was as wide awake as if
he had had a good night’s sleep behind him. The interest of a new
case robbed him of every trace of fatigue. It was he alone--at his own
request--who raised the body and laid it on its back before he stepped
aside to make way for the doctor.

The physician opened the dead man’s vest to see whether the bullet had
passed completely through the body. But it had not; there was not the
slightest trace of blood upon the shirt.

“There’s nothing more for me to do here, Muller,” said the physician, as
he bowed to the commissioner and left the place.

Muller examined the pockets of the dead man.

“It’s probably a case of robbery, too,” remarked the commissioner. “A
man as well-dressed as this one is would be likely to have a watch.”

“And a purse,” added the detective. “But this man has neither--or at
least he has them no longer.”

In the various pockets of the dead man’s clothes Muller found the
following articles: a handkerchief, several tramway tickets, a penknife,
a tiny mirror, and comb, and a little book, a cheap novel. He wrapped
them all in the handkerchief and put them in his own pocket. The dead
man’s coat had fallen back from his body during the examination, and as
Muller turned the stiffened limbs a little he saw the opening of another
pocket high up over the right hip of the trousers. The detective passed
his hand over the pocket and heard something rattle. Then he put his
hand in the pocket and drew out a thin narrow envelope which he handed
to the commissioner. Holzer looked at it carefully. It was made of very
thin expensive paper and bore no address. But it was sealed, although
not very carefully, for the gummed edges were open in spots. It must
have been hastily closed and was slightly crushed as if it had been
carried in a clenched hand. The commissioner cut open the envelope with
his penknife. He gave an exclamation of surprise as he showed Muller the
contents. In the envelope there were three hundred-gulden notes.

The commissioner looked at Muller without a word, but the detective
understood and shook his head. “No,” he said calmly, “it may be a case
of robbery just the same. This pocket was not very easy to find, and the
money in it was safer than the dead man’s watch and purse would be. That
is, if he had a watch and purse--and he very probably had a watch,” he
added more quickly.

For Muller had made a little discovery. On the lower hem of the left
side of the dead man’s waistcoat he saw a little lump, and feeling of it
he discovered that it was a watch key which had slipped down out of
the torn pocket between the lining and the material of the vest. A sure
proof that the dead man had had a watch, which in all probability had
been taken from him by his murderer. There was no loose change or small
bills to be found in any of the pockets, so that it was more than likely
that the dead man had had his money in a purse. It seemed to be a case
of murder for the sake of robbery. At least Muller and the commissioner
believed it to be one, from what they had discovered thus far.

The police officer gave his men orders to raise the body and to take
it to the morgue. An hour later the unknown man lay in the bare room in
which the only spot of brightness were the rays of the sun that crept
through the high barred windows and touched his cold face and stiffened
form as with a pitying caress. But no, there was one other little spot
of brightness in the silent place. It was the wild aster which the dead
man’s hand still held tightly clasped. The little purple flowers were
quite fresh yet, and the dewdrops clinging to them greeted the kiss of
the sun’s rays with an answering smile.


As soon as the corpse had been taken away, the police commissioner
returned to the station. But Muller remained there all alone to make a
thorough examination of the entire vicinity.

It was not a very attractive spot, this particular part of the street.
There must have been a nursery there at one time, for there were still
several ordered rows of small trees to be seen. There were traces of
flower cultivation as well, for several trailing vines and overgrown
bushes showed where shrubs had been grown which do not usually grow
without man’s assistance. Immediately back of the old elder tree Muller
found several fine examples of rare flowers, or rather he found the
shrubs which his experienced eye recognised as having once borne these
unusual blossoms. One or two blooms still hung to the bushes and the
detective, who was a great lover of flowers, picked them and put them in
his buttonhole. While he did this, his keen eyes were darting about the
place taking in all the details. This vacant lot had evidently been used
as an unlicensed dumping ground for some time, for all sorts of odds and
ends, old boots, bits of stuff, silk and rags, broken bottles and empty
tin cans, lay about between the bushes or half buried in the earth. What
had once been an orderly garden was now an untidy receptacle for waste.
The pedantically neat detective looked about him in disgust, then
suddenly he forgot his displeasure and a gleam shot up in his eye. It
was very little, the thing this man had seen, this man who saw so much
more than others.

About ten paces from where he stood a high wooden fence hemmed in the
lot. The fence belonged to the neighbouring property, as the lot in
which he stood was not protected in any way. To the back it was closed
off by a corn field where the tall stalks rustled gently in the faint
morning breeze. All this could be seen by anybody and Muller had seen it
all at his first glance. But now he had seen something else. Something
that excited him because it might possibly have some connection with
the newly discovered crime. His keen eyes, in glancing along the wooden
fence at his right hand, had caught sight of a little twig which had
worked its way through the fence. This twig belonged to a willow tree
which grew on the other side, and which spread its grey-green foliage
over the fence or through its wide openings. One of the little twigs
which had crept in between the planks was broken, and it had been broken
very recently, for the leaves were still fresh and the sap was oozing
from the crushed stem. Muller walked over to the fence and examined the
twig carefully. He soon saw how it came to be broken. The broken part
was about the height of a man’s knee from the ground. And just at this
height there was quite a space between two of the planks of the fence,
heavy planks which were laid cross-ways and nailed to thick posts. It
would have been very easy for anybody to get a foothold in this open
space between the planks.

It was very evidently some foot thrust in between the planks which had
broken the little willow twig, and its soft rind had left a green
mark on the lower plank. “I wonder if that has anything to do with the
murder,” thought Muller, looking over the fence into the lot on the
other side.

This neighbouring plot was evidently a neglected garden. It had once
worn an aristocratic air, with stone statues and artistic arrangement
of flower beds and shrubs. It was still attractive even in its neglected
condition. Beyond it, through the foliage of its heavy trees, glass
windows caught the sunlight. Muller remembered that there was a
handsome old house in this direction, a house with a mansard roof and
wide-reaching wings. He did not now know to whom this handsome old
house belonged, a house that must have been built in the time of Maria
Theresa,... but he was sure of one thing, and that was that he would
soon find out to whom it belonged. At present it was the garden which
interested him, and he was anxious to see where it ended. A few moments’
further inspection showed him what he wanted to know. The garden
extended to the beginning of the park-like grounds which surrounded
the old house with the mansard roof. A tall iron railing separated the
garden from the park, but this railing did not extend down as far as the
quiet lane. Where it ended there was a light, well-built wooden fence.
Along the street side of the fence there was a high thick hedge. Muller
walked along this hedge until he came to a little gate. Then crossing
the street, he saw that the house whose windows glistened in the
sunlight was a house which he knew well from its other side, its front

Now he went back to the elder tree and then walked slowly away from this
to the spot where he found the broken willow twig. He examined every
foot of the ground, but there was nothing to be seen that was of any
interest to him--not a footprint, or anything to prove that some one
else had passed that way a short time before. And yet it would have been
impossible to pass that way without leaving some trace, for the ground
was cut up in all directions by mole hills.

Next the detective scrutinised as much of the surroundings as would come
into immediate connection with the spot where the corpse had been found.
There was nothing to be seen there either, and Muller was obliged
to acknowledge that he had discovered nothing that would lead to an
understanding of the crime, unless, indeed, the broken willow twig
should prove to be a clue. He sprang back across the ditch, turned up
the edges of his trousers where they had been moistened by the dew and
walked slowly along the dusty street. He was no longer alone in the
lane. An old man, accompanied by a large dog, came out from one of the
new houses and walked towards the detective, he was very evidently going
in the direction of the elder-tree, which had already been such a
centre of interest that morning. When he met Muller, the old man halted,
touched his cap and asked in a confidential tone: “I suppose you’ve been
to see the place already?”

“Which place?” was Muller’s reserved answer.

“Why, I mean the place where they found the man who was murdered. They
found him under that elder-tree. My wife just heard of it and told me. I
suppose everybody round here will know it soon.”

“Was there a man murdered here?” asked Muller, as if surprised by the

“Yes, he was shot last night. Only I don’t understand why I didn’t hear
the shot. I couldn’t sleep a wink all night for the pain in my bones.”

“You live near here, then?”

“Yes, I live in No.1. Didn’t you see me coming out?”

“I didn’t notice it. I came across the wet meadows and I stooped to turn
up my trousers so that they wouldn’t get dusty--it must have been then
you came out.”

“Why, then you must have been right near the place I was talking about.
Do you see that elder tree there? It’s the only one in the street, and
the girl who brings the milk found the man under it. The police have
been here already and have taken him away. They discovered him about six
o’clock and now it’s just seven.”

“And you hadn’t any suspicion that this dreadful thing was happening so
near you?” asked the detective casually.

“I didn’t know a thing, sir, not a thing. There couldn’t have been a
fight or I would have heard it. But I don’t know why I didn’t hear the

“Why, then you must have been asleep after all, in spite of your pain,”
 said Muller with a smile, as he walked along beside the man back to the
place from which he had just come.

The old man shook his head. “No, I tell you I didn’t close an eye all
night. I went to bed at half-past nine and I smoked two pipes before I
put out the light, and then I heard every hour strike all night long
and it wasn’t until nearly five o’clock, when it was almost dawn, that I
dozed off a bit.”

“Then it is astonishing that you didn’t hear anything!”

“Sure it’s astonishing! But it’s still more astonishing that my dog
Sultan didn’t hear anything. Sultan is a famous watchdog, I’d have you
know. He’ll growl if anybody passes through the street after dark, and I
don’t see why he didn’t notice what was going on over there last night.
If a man’s attacked, he generally calls for help; it’s a queer business
all right.”

“Well, Sultan, why didn’t you make a noise?” asked Muller, patting the
dog’s broad head. Sultan growled and walked on indifferently, after he
had shaken off the strange hand.

“He must have slept more soundly than usual. He went off into the
country with me yesterday. We had an errand to do there and on the
way back we stopped in for a drink. Sultan takes a drop or two himself
occasionally, and that usually makes him sleep. I had hard work to bring
him home. We got here just a few minutes before half-past nine and I
tell you we were both good and tired.”

By this time they had come to the elder-tree and the old man’s stream of
talk ceased as he stood before the spot where the mysterious crime had
occurred. He looked down thoughtfully at the grass, now trampled by many
feet. “Who could have done it?” he murmured finally, with a sigh that
expressed his pity for the victim.

“Hietzing is known to be one of the safest spots in Vienna,” remarked

“Indeed it is, sir; indeed it is. As it would well have to be with the
royal castles right here in the neighbourhood! Indeed it would have to
be safe with the Court coming here all the time.”

“Why, yes, you see more police here than anywhere else in the city.”

“Yes, they’re always sticking their nose in where they’re not
necessary,” remarked the old man, not realising to whom he was speaking.
“They fuss about everything you do or don’t do, and yet a man can be
shot down right under our very noses here and the police can’t help it.”

“But, my dear sir, it isn’t always possible for the police to prevent a
criminal carrying out his evil intention,” said Muller good-naturedly.

“Well, why not? if they watch out sharp enough?”

“The police watch out sharper than most people think. But they can’t
catch a man until he has committed his crime, can they?”

“No, I suppose not,” said the old man, with another glance at the
elder-tree. He bowed to Muller and turned and walked away.

Muller followed him slowly, very much pleased with this meeting, for
it had given him a new clue. There was no reason to doubt the old man’s
story. And if this story was true, then the crime had been committed
before half-past nine of the evening previous. For the old man--he was
evidently the janitor in No.1--had not heard the shot.

Muller left the scene of the crime and walked towards the four houses.
Before he reached them he had to pass the garden which belonged to the
house with the mansard roof. Right and left of this garden were vacant
lots, as well as on the opposite side of the street. Then came to the
right and left the four new houses which stood at the beginning of the
quiet lane. Muller passed them, turned up a cross street and then
down again, into the street running parallel, to the lane, a quiet
aristocratic street on which fronted the house with the mansard roof.

A carriage stood in front of this house, two great trunks piled up on
the box beside the driver. A young girl and an old man in livery were
placing bags and bundles of rugs inside the carriage. Muller walked
slowly toward the carriage. Just as he reached the open gate of the
garden he was obliged to halt, to his own great satisfaction. For at
this moment a group of people came out from the house, the owners of it
evidently, prepared for a journey and surrounded by their servants.

Beside the old man and the young girl, there were two other women, one
evidently the housekeeper, the other possibly the cook. The latter
was weeping openly and devoutly kissing the hand of her mistress. The
housekeeper discovered that a rug was missing and sent the maid back for
it, while the old servant helped the lady into the carriage. The door
of the carriage was wide open and Muller had a good glimpse of the pale,
sweet-faced and delicate-looking young woman who leaned back in her
corner, shivering and evidently ill. The servants bustled about, making
her comfortable, while her husband superintended the work with anxious
tenderness. He was a tall, fine-looking man with deep-set grey eyes and
a rich, sympathetic voice. He gave his orders to his servants with calm
authority, but he also was evidently suffering from the disease of
our century--nervousness, for Muller saw that the man’s hands clenched
feverishly and that his lips were trembling under his drooping

The maid hastened down with the rug and spread it over her mistress’s
knees, as the gentleman exclaimed nervously: “Do hurry with that! Do you
want us to miss the train?”

The butler closed the door of the carriage, the coachman gathered up the
reins and raised his whip. The housekeeper bowed low and murmured a few
words in farewell and the other servants followed her example with tears
in their eyes. “You’ll see us again in six weeks,” the lady called
out and her husband added: “If all goes well.” Then he motioned to the
waiting driver and the carriage moved off swiftly, turning the corner in
a few moments.

The little group of servants returned to the courtyard behind the high
gates. Muller, whom they had not noticed, was about to resume his walk,
when he halted again. The courtyard of the house led back through a
flagged walk to the park-like garden that surrounded it on the sides and
rear. Down this walk came a young woman. She came so quickly that one
might almost call it running. She was evidently excited about something.
Muller imagined what this something might be, and he remained to
hear what she had to say. He was not mistaken. The woman, it was Mrs.
Schmiedler, the gardener’s wife, began her story at once. “Haven’t you
heard yet?” she said breathlessly. “No, you can’t have heard it yet or
you wouldn’t stand there so quietly, Mrs. Bernauer.”

“What’s the matter?” asked the woman whom Muller took to be the

“They killed a man last night out here! They found his body just now
in the lane back of our garden. The janitor from No.1 told me as I was
going to the store, so I went right back to look at the place, and I
came to tell you, as I didn’t think you’d heard it yet.”

Mrs. Bernauer was evidently a woman of strong constitution and of an
equable mind. The other three servants broke out into an excited hubbub
of talk while she remained quite indifferent and calm. “One more poor
fellow who had to leave the world before he was ready,” she remarked
calmly, with just the natural touch of pity in her voice that would come
to any warm-hearted human being upon hearing of such an occurrence. She
did not seem at all excited or alarmed to think that the scene of the
crime had been so near.

The other servants were very much more excited and had already rushed
off, under the guidance of the gardener’s wife, to look at the dreadful
spot. Franz, the butler, had quite forgotten to close the front gate in
his excitement, and the housekeeper turned to do it now.

“The fools, see them run,” she exclaimed half aloud. “As if there was
anything for them to do there.”

The gate closed, Mrs. Bernauer turned and walked slowly to the house.
Muller walked on also, going first to the police station to report what
he had discovered. Then he went to his own rooms and slept until nearly
noon. On his return to the police station he found that notices of the
occurrence had already been sent out to the papers.


The autopsy proved beyond a doubt that the murdered man had been dead
for many hours before the discovery of his body. The bullet which had
struck him in the back had pierced the trachea and death had occurred
within a few minutes. The only marks for identification of the body were
the initials L. W. on his underwear. The evening paper printed an exact
description of the man’s appearance and his clothing.

It was about ten o’clock next morning when Mrs. Klingmayer, a widow
living in a quiet street at the opposite end of the city from Hietzing,
returned from her morning marketing. It was only a few little bundles
that she brought with her and she set about preparing her simple dinner.
Her packages were wrapped in newspapers, which she carefully smoothed
out and laid on the dresser.

Mrs. Klingmayer was the widow of a street-car conductor and the little
pension which she received from the company, as well as the money she
could earn for herself, did not permit of the indulgence in a daily
newspaper. And yet the reading of the papers was the one luxury for
which the simple woman longed. Her grocer, who was a friend of years,
knew this and would wrap up her purchases in papers of recent date,
knowing that she could then enjoy them in her few moments of leisure.
To-day this leisure came unexpectedly early, for Mrs. Klingmayer had
less work than usual to attend to.

Her little flat consisted of two rooms and a kitchen with a large closet
opening out from it. She lived in the kitchen and rented the front
rooms. Her tenants were a middle-aged man, inspector in a factory,
who had the larger room; and a younger man who was bookkeeper in an
importing house in the city. But this young man had not been at home
for forty-eight hours, a fact, however, which did not greatly worry his
landlady. The gentleman in question lived a rather dissipated life
and it was not the first time that he had remained away from home over
night. It is true that it was the first time that he had not been home
for two successive nights. But as Mrs. Klingmayer thought, everything
has to happen the first time sometime. “It’s not likely to be the last
time,” the worthy woman thought.

At all events she was rather glad of it to-day, for she suffered from
rheumatism and it was difficult for her to get about. The young man’s
absence saved her the work of fixing up his room that morning and
allowed her to get to her reading earlier than usual. When she had put
the pot of soup on the fire, she sat down by the window, adjusted her
big spectacles and began to read. To her great delight she discovered
that the paper she held in her hand bore the date of the previous
afternoon. In spite of the good intentions of her friend the grocer,
it was not always that she could get a paper of so recent date, and she
began to read with doubled anticipation of pleasure.

She did not waste time on the leading articles, for she understood
little about politics. The serial stories were a great delight to
her, or would have been, if she had ever been able to follow them
consecutively. But her principal joy were the everyday happenings of
varied interest which she found in the news columns. To-day she was so
absorbed in the reading of them that the soup pot began to boil over
and send out rivulets down onto the stove. Ordinarily this would have
shocked Mrs. Klingmayer, for the neatness of her pots and pans was the
one great care of her life. But now, strange to relate, she paid no
attention to the soup, nor to the smell and the smoke that arose from
the stove. She had just come upon a notice in the paper which took her
entire attention. She read it through three times, and each time with
growing excitement. This is what she read:

                       MURDER IN HIETZING

  This morning at six o’clock the body of a man about 30 years
  old was discovered in a lane in Hietzing.  The man must have
  been dead many hours.  He had been shot from behind.  The dead
  man was tall and thin, with brown eyes, brown hair and moustache.
  The letters L. W. were embroidered in his underwear.  There was
  nothing else discovered on him that could reveal his identity.
  His watch and purse were not in his pockets: presumably they had
  been taken by the murderer.  A strange fact is that in one of
  his pockets--a hidden pocket it is true--there was the sum of
  300 guldens in bills.

This was the notice which made Mrs. Klingmayer neglect the soup pot.

Finally the old woman stood up very slowly, threw a glance at the stove
and opened the window mechanically. Then she lifted the pots from the
fire and set them on the outer edge of the range. And then she did
something that ordinarily would have shocked her economical soul--she
poured water on the fire to put it out.

When she saw that there was not a spark left in the stove, she went into
her own little room and prepared to go out. Her excitement caused her to
forget her rheumatism entirely. One more look around her little kitchen,
then she locked it up and set out for the centre of the city.

She went to the office of the importing house where her tenant, Leopold
Winkler, was employed as bookkeeper. The clerk at the door noticed the
woman’s excitement and asked her kindly what the trouble was.

“I’d like to speak to Mr. Winkler,” she said eagerly.

“Mr. Winkler hasn’t come in yet,” answered the young man. “Is anything
the matter? You look so white! Winkler will probably show up soon, he’s
never very punctual. But it’s after eleven o’clock now and he’s never
been as late as this before.”

“I don’t believe he’ll ever come again,” said the old woman, sinking
down on a bench beside the door.

“Why, what do you mean?” asked the clerk. “Why shouldn’t he come again?”

“Is the head of the firm here?” asked Mrs. Klingmayer, wiping her
forehead with her handkerchief. The clerk nodded and hurried away to
tell his employer about the woman with the white face who came to ask
for a man who, as she expressed it, “would never come there again.”

“I don’t think she’s quite right in the head,” he volunteered. The head
of the firm told him to bring the woman into the inner office.

“Who are you, my good woman?” he asked kindly, softened by the evident
agitation of this poorly though neatly dressed woman.

“I am Mr. Winkler’s landlady,” she answered.

“Ah! and he wants you to tell me that he’s sick? I’m afraid I can’t
believe all that this gentleman says. I hope he’s not asking your help
to lie to me. Are you sure that his illness is anything else but a case
of being up late?”

“I don’t think that he’ll ever be sick again--I didn’t come with any
message from him, sir; please read this, sir.” And she handed him the
newspaper, showing him the notice. While the gentleman was reading she
added: “Mr. Winkler didn’t come home last night either.”

Winkler’s employer read the few lines, then laid the paper aside with a
very serious face. “When did you see him last?” he asked of the woman.

“Day before yesterday in the morning. He went away about half-past eight
as he usually does,” she replied. And then she added a question of her
own: “Was he here day before yesterday?”

The merchant nodded and pressed an electric bell. Then he rose from his
seat and pulled up a chair for his visitor. “Sit down here. This thing
has frightened you and you are no longer young.” When the servant
entered, the merchant told him to ask the head bookkeeper to come to the
inner office.

When this official appeared, his employer inquired: “When did Winkler
leave here day before yesterday?”

“At six o’clock, sir, as usual.”

“He was here all day without interruption?”

“Yes, sir, with the exception of the usual luncheon hour.”

“Did he have the handling of any money Monday?”

“No, sir.”

“Thank you, Mr. Pokorny,” said the merchant, handing his employee the
evening paper and pointing to the notice which had so interested him.

Pokorny read it, his face, like his employer’s, growing more serious.
“It looks almost as if it must be Winkler, sir,” he said, in a few

“We will soon find that out. I should like to go to the police station
myself with this woman; she is Winkler’s landlady--but I think it will
be better for you to accompany her. They will ask questions about the
man which you will be better able to answer than I.”

Pokorny bowed and left the room. Mrs. Klingmayer rose and was about
to follow, when the merchant asked her to wait a moment and inquired
whether Winkler owed her anything. “I am sorry that you should have had
this shock and the annoyances and trouble which will come of it, but I
don’t want you to be out of pocket by it.”

“No, he doesn’t owe me anything,” replied the honest old woman, shaking
her head. A few big tears rolled down over her withered cheeks, possibly
the only tears that were shed for the dead man under the elder-tree. But
even this sympathetic soul could find nothing to say in his praise. She
could feel pity for his dreadful death, but she could not assert that
the world had lost anything by his going out of it. As if saddened by
the impossibility of finding a single good word to say about the dead
man, she left the office with drooping head and lagging step.

Pokorny helped her into the cab that was already waiting before the
door. The office force had got wind of the fact that something unusual
had occurred and were all at the windows to see them drive off. The
three clerks who worked in the department to which Winkler belonged
gathered together to talk the matter over. They were none of them
particularly hit by it, but naturally they were interested in the
discovery in Hietzing, and equally naturally, they tried to find a few
good words to say about the man whose life had ended so suddenly.

The youngest of them, Fritz Bormann, said some kind words and was about
to wax more enthusiastic, when Degenhart, the eldest clerk, cut in with
the words: “Oh, don’t trouble yourself. Nobody ever liked Winkler here.
He was not a good man--he was not even a good worker. This is the first
time that he has a reasonable excuse for neglecting his duties.”

“Oh, come, see here! how can you talk about the poor man that way when
he’s scarcely cold in death yet,” said Fritz indignantly.

Degenhart laughed harshly.

“Did I ever say anything else about him while he was warm and alive?
Death is no reason for changing one’s opinion about a man who was
good-for-nothing in life. And his death was a stroke of good luck that
he scarcely deserved. He died without a moment’s pain, with a merry
thought in his head, perhaps, while many another better man has to
linger in torture for weeks. No, Bormann, the best I can say about
Winkler is that his death makes one nonentity the less on earth.”

The older man turned to his desk again and the two younger clerks
continued the conversation: “Degenhart appears to be a hard man,” said
Fritz, “but he’s the best and kindest person I know, and he’s dead right
in what he says. It was simply a case of conventional superstition. I
never did like that Winkler.”

“No, you’re right,” said the other. “Neither did I and I don’t know why,
for the matter of that. He seemed just like a thousand others. I never
heard of anything particularly wrong that he did.”

“No, no more did I,” continued Bormann, “but I never heard of anything
good about him either. And don’t you think that it’s worse for a man
to seem to repel people by his very personality, rather than by any
particular bad thing that he does?”

“Yes. I don’t know how to explain it, but that’s just how I feel about
it. I had an instinctive feeling that there was something wrong about
Winkler, the sort of a creepy, crawly feeling that a snake gives you.”


Meanwhile Pokorny and Mrs. Klingmayer had reached the police station and
were going upstairs to the rooms of the commissioner on service for the
day. Like all people of her class, Mrs. Klingmayer stood in great awe
and terror of anything connected with the police or the law generally.
She crept slowly and tremblingly up the stairs behind the head
bookkeeper and was very glad when she was left alone for a few minutes
while Pokorny went in to see the commissioner. But as soon as his errand
was known, both the bookkeeper and his companion were led into the
office of Head Commissioner Dr. von Riedau, who had charge of the
Hietzing murder case.

When Dr. von Riedau heard the reason of their coming, his interest was
immediately aroused, and he pulled a chair to his side for the little
thin man with whom he had been talking when the two strangers were
ushered in.

“Then you believe you could identify the murdered man?” asked the

“From the general description and the initials on his linen, I believe
it must be Leopold Winkler,” answered Pokorny. “Mrs. Klingmayer has not
seen him since Monday morning, nor has she had any message from him. He
left the office Monday afternoon at 6 o’clock and that was the last time
that we saw him. The only thing that makes me doubt his identity is that
the paper reports that three hundred gulden were found in his pocket.
Winkler never seemed to have money, and I do not understand how he
should have been in possession of such a sum.”

“The money was found in the dead man’s pockets,” said the commissioner.
“And yet it may be Winkler, the man you know. Muller, will you order a
cab, please?”

“I have a cab waiting for me. But it only holds two,” volunteered

“That doesn’t matter, I’ll sit on the box,” answered the man addressed
as Muller.

“You are going with us?” asked Pokorny.

“Yes, he will accompany you,” replied the commissioner. “This is
detective Muller, sir. By a mere chance, he happened to be on hand to
take charge of this case and he will remain in charge, although it may
be wasting his talents which we need for more difficult problems. If you
or any one else have anything to tell us, it must be told only to me
or to Muller. And before you leave to look at the body, I would like
to know whether the dead man owned a watch, or rather whether he had it
with him on the day of the murder.”

“Yes, sir; he did have a watch, a gold watch,” answered Mrs. Klingmayer.

Riedau looked at the bookkeeper, who nodded and said: “Yes, sir; Winkler
had a watch, a gold watch with a double case. It was a large watch, very
thick. I happen to have noticed it by chance and also I happen to know
that he had not had the watch for very long.”

“Can you tell us anything more about the watch?” asked the commissioner
of the landlady.

“Yes, sir; there was engraving on the outside cover, initials, and a
crown on the other side.”

“What were the initials?”

“I don’t know that, sir; at least I’m not sure about it. There were so
many twists and curves to them that I couldn’t make them out. I think
one of them was a W though, sir.”

“The other was probably an L then.”

“That might be, sir.”

“The younger clerks in the office may be able to tell something more
about the watch,” said Pokorny, “for they were quite interested in it
for a while. It was a handsome watch and they were envious of Winkler’s
possession of it. But he was so tactless in his boasting about it that
they paid no further attention to him after the first excitement.”

“You say he didn’t have the watch long?”

“Since spring I think, sir.”

“He brought it home on the 19th of March,” interrupted Mrs. Klingmayer.
“I remember the day because it was my birthday. I pretended that he had
brought it home to me for a present.”

“Was he in the habit of making you presents?”

“Oh, no, sir; he was very close with his money, sir.

“Well, perhaps he didn’t have much money to be generous with. Now tell
me about his watch chain. I suppose he had a watch chain?”

Both the bookkeeper and the landlady nodded and the latter exclaimed:
“Oh, yes, sir; I could recognise it in a minute.”


“It was broken once and Mr. Winkler mended it himself. I lent him my
pliers and he bent the two links together with them. It didn’t look very
nice after that, but it was strong again. You could see the mark of the
pliers easily.”

“Why didn’t he take the chain to the jeweler’s to be fixed?” asked the

The woman smiled. “It wouldn’t have been worth the money, sir; the chain
wasn’t real gold.”

“But the watch was real, wasn’t it?”

“Oh, yes, sir; that was real gold. I pawned it once for Mr. Winkler and
they gave me 24 gulden for it.”

“One question more, did he have a purse? And did he have it with him on
the day of the murder?”

“Yes, sir; he had a purse, and he must have taken it with him because he
didn’t leave it in his room.”

“What sort of a purse was it?”

“A brown leather purse, sir.”

“Was it a new one?”

“Oh, no, sir; it was well worn.”

“How big was it? About like mine?” Riedau took out his own pocketbook.

“No, sir; it was a little smaller. It had three pockets in it. I mended
it for him once, so I know it well. I didn’t have any brown thread so I
mended it with yellow.”

Dr. von Riedau nodded to Muller. The latter had been sitting at a little
side-table writing down the questions and answers. When Riedau saw this
he did not send for a clerk to do the work, for Muller preferred to
attend to such matters himself as much as possible. The facts gained in
the examination were impressed upon his mind while he was writing them,
and he did not have to wade through pages of manuscript to get at what
he needed. Now he handed his superior officer the paper.

“Thank you,” said Riedau, “I’ll send it out to the other police
stations. I will attend to this myself. You go on with these people to
see whether they can identify the corpse.”

Fifteen minutes later the three stood before the body in the morgue and
both the bookkeeper and his companion identified the dead man positively
as Leopold Winkler.

When the identification was made, a notice was sent out to all Austrian
police stations and to all pawnshops with an exact description of the
stolen watch and purse.

Muller led his companions back to the commissioner’s office and they
made their report to Dr. von Riedau. Upon being questioned further,
Pokorny stated: “I had very little to do with Winkler. We met only when
he had a report to make to me or to show me his books, and we never met
outside the office. The clerks who worked in the same room with him, may
know him better. I know only that he was a very reserved man and very
little liked.”

“Then I do not need to detain you any longer, nor to trouble you further
in this affair. I thank you for coming to us so promptly. It has been of
great assistance.”

The bookkeeper left the station, but Mrs. Klingmayer, who was now quite
reassured as to the harmlessness of the police, was asked to remain
and to tell what she knew of the private life of the murdered man. Her
answers to the various questions put to her proved that she knew very
little about her tenant. But this much was learned from her: that he
was very close with his money at times, but that again at other times
he seemed to have all he wanted to spend. At such times he paid all his
debts, and when he stayed home for supper, he would send her out for
all sorts of expensive delicacies. These extravagant days seemed to have
nothing whatever to do with Winkler’s business pay day, but came at odd

Mrs. Klingmayer remembered two separate times when he had received a
postal money order. But she did not know from whom the letters came,
nor even whether they were sent from the city or from some other town.
Winkler received other letters now and then, but his landlady was not of
the prying kind, and she had paid very little attention to them.

He seemed to have few friends or even acquaintances. She did not know
of any love affair, at least of nothing “regular.” He had remained
away over night two or three times during the year that he had been
her tenant. This was about all that Mrs. Klingmayer could say, and she
returned to her home in a cab furnished her by the kind commissioner.

About two hours later, a police attendant announced that a gentleman
would like to see Dr. von Riedan on business concerning the murder in
Hietzing. “Friedrich Bormann” was the name on the card.

“Ask him to step in here,” said the commissioner. “And please ask Mr.
Muller to join us.”

The good-looking young clerk entered the office bashfully and Muller
slipped in behind him, seating himself inconspicuously by the door. At a
sign from the commissioner the visitor began. “I am an employee of Braun
& Co. I have the desk next to Leopold Winkler, during the year that he
has been with us--the year and a quarter to be exact--”

“Ah, then you know him rather well?”

“Why, yes. At least we were together all day, although I never met him
outside the office.”

“Then you cannot tell us much about his private life?”

“No, sir, but there was something happened on Monday, and in talking it
over with Mr. Braun, he suggested that I should come to you and tell you
about it. It wasn’t really very important, and it doesn’t seem as if it
could have anything to do with this murder and robbery; still it may be
of some use.”

“Everything that would throw light on the dead man’s life could be of
use,” said Dr. von Riedau. “Please tell us what it is you know.”

Fritz Bormann began: “Winkler came to the office as usual on Monday
morning and worked steadily at his desk. But I happened to notice that
he spoiled several letters and had to rewrite them, which showed me
that his thoughts were not on his work, a frequent occurrence with him.
However, everything went along as usual until 11 o’clock. Then Winkler
became very uneasy. He looked constantly toward the door, compared his
watch with the office clock, and sprang up impatiently as the special
letter carrier, who usually comes about 11 with money orders, finally

“Then he was expecting money you think?”

“It must have been so. For as the letter carrier passed him, he called
out: ‘Haven’t you anything for me?’ and as the man shook his head
Winkler seemed greatly disappointed and depressed. Before he left to go
to lunch, he wrote a hasty letter, which he put in his pocket.

“He came in half an hour later than the rest of us. He had often been
reprimanded for his lack of punctuality, but it seemed to do no good. He
was almost always late. Monday was no exception, although he was later
than usual that day.”

“And what sort of a mood was he in when he came back?”

“He was irritable and depressed. He seemed to be awaiting a message
which did not come. His excitement hindered him from working, he
scarcely did anything the entire afternoon. Finally at five o’clock a
messenger boy came with a letter for him. I saw that Winkler turned
pale as he took the note in his hand. It seemed to be only a few words
written hastily on a card, thrust into an envelope. Winkler’s teeth were
set as he opened the letter. The messenger had already gone away.”

“Did you notice his number?” asked Dr. von Riedau.

“No, I scarcely noticed the man at all. I was looking at Winkler, whose
behaviour was so peculiar. When he read the card his face brightened.
He read it through once more, then he tore both card and envelope into
little bits and threw the pieces out of the open window.

“Then he evidently did not want anybody to see the contents of this
note,” said a voice from the corner of the room.

Fritz Bormann looked around astonished and rather doubtful at the little
man who had risen from his chair and now came forward. Without waiting
for an answer from the clerk, the other continued: “Did Winkler have
money sent him frequently?”

Bormann looked inquiringly at the commissioner, who replied with a
smile: “You may answer. Answer anything that Mr. Muller has to ask of
you, as he is in charge of this case.”

“As far as I can remember, it happened three times,” was Bormann’s

“How close together?”

“Why--about once in every three or four months, I think.”

“That looks almost like a regular income,” exclaimed Riedau. His eyes
met Muller’s, which were lit up in sudden fire. “Well, what are you
thinking of?” asked the commissioner.

“A woman,” answered Muller; and continued more as if thinking aloud than
as if addressing the others: “Winkler was a good-looking man. Might he
not have had a rich love somewhere? Might not the money have come from
her, the money that was found in his pocket?” Muller’s voice trailed
off into indistinctness at the last words, and the fire died out of his
eyes. Then he laughed aloud.

The commissioner smiled also, a good-natured smile, such as one would
give to a child who has been over-eager. “It doesn’t matter to us where
the money came from. All that matters here is where the bullet came
from--the bullet which prevented his enjoying this money. And it is
of more interest to us to find out who robbed him of his life and his
property, rather than the source from which this property came.”

The commissioner’s tone was friendly, but Muller’s face flushed red, and
his head dropped. Riedau turned to Bormann and continued: “And because
it is of no interest to us where his money came from--for it can
have nothing whatever to do with his murder and the subsequent
robbery--therefore what you noticed of his behaviour cannot be of any
importance or bearing in the case in any way. Unless, indeed, you should
find out anything more. But we appreciate the thoughtfulness of yourself
and your employer and your readiness to help us.”

Bormann rose to leave, but the commissioner put out a hand to stop him.
“A few moments more, please; you may know of something else that will
be of assistance to us. We have heard that Winkler boasted of his
belongings--did he talk about his private affairs in any way?”

“No, sir, I do not think he did.”

“You say that he destroyed the note at once, evidently realising that no
one must see it--this note may have been a promise for the money which
had not yet come. Did he, however, tell any one later that he expected a
certain sum? Do you think he would have been likely to tell any one?”

“No, I do not think that he would tell any one. He never mentioned
to any of us that he had received money, or even that he expected to
receive it. None of us knew what outside resources he might have, or
whence they came. If it had not been that the money was paid him by the
carrier in the office two or three times--so, that we could see it--we
would none of us have known of this income, except for the fact that he
was freer in spending after the money came. He would dine at expensive
restaurants, and this fact he would mention to us, whereas at other
times he would go to the cheap cafe.”

“Do you know anything about the people he was acquainted with outside
the office?”

“No, sir. I seldom met him outside of the office. One evening it did
happen that I saw him at Ronacher’s. He was there with a lady--that is,
a so-called ‘lady’--and it must have been one of the times that he had
money, for they were enjoying an expensive supper. At other times, some
of the other clerks met him at various resorts, always with the same
sort of woman. But not always with the same woman, for they were
different in appearance.”

“He was never seen anywhere with other men?”

“No, sir; at least not by any of us.”

“He was not liked in the office?”

“No.” Bormann’s answer was sharp.

“For what reason?”

“I don’t know; we just didn’t like him. We had very little to do with
him at first because of this, and soon we noticed that he seemed just as
anxious to avoid us as we were to avoid him.”

The commissioner rose and Bormann followed his example. “I am very
sorry, sir, if I have taken up your time to no purpose,” said the latter
modestly, as he took up his hat.

“I am not so sure that what you have said may not be of great value to
us,” said a voice behind them. Muller stood there, looking at Riedau
with a glance almost of defiance. His eyes were again lit up with
the strange fire that shone in them when he was on the trail. The
commissioner shrugged his shoulders, bowed to the departing visitor, and
then turned without an answer to some documents on his desk. There was
silence in the room for a few moments. Finally a gentle voice came from
Muller’s corner again: “Dr. von Riedau?”

The commissioner raised his head and looked around. “Oh, are you still
there?” he asked with a drawl.

Muller knew what this drawl meant. It was the manner adopted by the
amiable commissioner when he was in a mood which was not amiable. And
Muller knew also the cause of the mood. It was his own last remark, the
words he addressed to Bormann. Muller himself recognised the fact
that this remark was out of place, that it was almost an impertinence,
because it was in direct contradiction to a statement made a few moments
before by his superior officer. Also he realised that his remark had
been quite unnecessary, because it was a matter of indifference to the
young man, who was only obeying his employer’s orders in reporting what
he had seen, whether his report was of value or not. Muller had simply
uttered aloud the thought that came into his mind, a habit of his which
years of official training had not yet succeeded in breaking. It was
annoying to himself sometimes, for these half-formed thoughts were mere
instinct--they were the workings of his own genius that made him catch
a suspicion of the truth long before his conscious mind could reason it
out or appreciate its value. But that sort of thing was not popular in
official police life.

“Well,” asked the commissioner, as Muller did not continue, “your tongue
is not usually so slow--as you have proved just a few moments back--what
were you going to say now?”

“I was about to ask your pardon for my interruption. It was unnecessary,
I should not have said it.”

“Well, I realise that you know better yourself,” said Riedau, now quite
friendly again, “and now what else have you to say? Do you really think
that what the young man has just told us is of any value at all for this

“It seems to me as if it might be of value to us.”

“Oh, it seems to you, eh? Your imagination is working overtime again,
Muller,” said the commissioner with a laugh. But the laugh turned to
seriousness as he realised how many times Muller’s imagination
had helped the clumsy official mind to its proudest triumphs. The
commissioner was an intelligent man, as far as his lights went, and he
was a good-hearted man. He rose from his chair and walked over to where
the detective stood. “You needn’t look so embarrassed, Muller,” he said.
“There is no cause for you to feel bad about it. And--I am quite willing
to admit that my remark just now was unnecessary. You may give your
imagination full rein, we can trust to your intelligence and your
devotion to duty to keep it from unnecessary flights. So curbed, I know
it will be of as much assistance to us this time as it always has been.”

Muller’s quiet face lit up, and his eyes shone in a happiness that made
him appear ten years younger. That was one of the strange things about
Joseph Muller. This genius in his profession was in all other ways a
man of such simplicity of heart and bearing, that the slightest word of
approval from one of the officials for whom he worked could make him as
happy as praise from the teacher will make a schoolboy. The moments when
he was in command of any difficult case, when these same superiors would
wait for a word from him, when high officials would take his orders or
would be obliged to acknowledge that without him they were helpless,
these moments were forgotten as soon as the problem was solved and
Muller became again the simple subordinate and the obscure member of the
Imperial police force.

When Muller left the commissioner’s room and walked through the
outer office, one of the clerks looked after him and whispered to his
companion: “Do you think he’s found the Hietzing murderer yet?” The
other answered: “I don’t think so, but he looks as if he had found a
clue. He’ll find him sooner or later. He always does.”

Muller did not hear these words, although they also would have pleased
him. He walked slowly down the stairs murmuring to himself: “I think I
was right just the same. We are following a false trail.”


It was on Monday, the 27th of September, that Leopold Winkler was
murdered and robbed, and early on Tuesday, the 28th, his body was found.
That day the evening papers printed the report of the murder and the
description of the dead man, and on Wednesday, the 29th, Mrs. Klingmayer
read the news and went to see Winkler’s employer. By noon of that day
the body was identified and a description of the stolen purse and watch
telegraphed to police headquarters in various cities. A few hours later,
these police stations had sent out notices by messenger to all pawnshops
and dealers in second-hand clothing, and now the machinery of the
law sat waiting for some news of an attempt on the part of the
robber-and-murderer to get rid of his plunder.

On this same Wednesday, about the twilight hour, David Goldstamm, dealer
in second-hand clothing, stood before the door of his shop in a side
street of the old Hungarian city of Pressburg and watched his assistant
take down the clothes which were hanging outside and carry them into the
store. The old man’s eyes glanced carelessly up and down the street and
caught sight of a man who turned the corner and came hurrying towards
him. This man was a very seedy-looking individual. An old faded overcoat
hung about his thin figure, and a torn and dusty hat fell over his left
eye. He seemed also to be much the worse for liquor and very wobbly
on his feet. And yet he seemed anxious to hurry onward in spite of the
unevenness of his walk.

Then he slowed up suddenly, glanced across the street to Goldstamm’s
store, and crossed over.

“Have you any boots for me?” he asked, sticking out his right foot that
the dealer might see whether he had anything the requisite size.

“I think there’s something there,” answered the old man in his usual
businesslike tone, leading the way into the store.

The stranger followed. Goldstamm lit the one light in the little place
and groped about in an untidy heap of shoes of all kinds and sizes until
he found several pairs that he thought might fit. These he brought out
and put them in front of his customer. But in spite of his bleary eyes,
the man caught sight of some patches on the uppers of one pair, and
pushed them away from him.

“Give me something better than that. I can pay for it. I don’t have to
wear patched shoes,” he grunted.

Goldstamm didn’t like the looks of the man, but he felt that he had
better be careful and not make him angry. “Have patience, sir, I’ll find
you something better,” he said gently, tossing the heap about again, but
now keeping his face turned towards his customer.

“I want a coat also and a warm pair of trousers,” said the stranger in a
rough voice. He bent down to loosen the shabby boot from his right
foot, and as he did so something fell out of the pocket of his coat. An
unconscious motion of his own raised foot struck this small object and
tossed it into the middle of the heap of shoes close by Goldstamm’s
hand. The old man reached out after it and caught it. It was just an
ordinary brown leather pocketbook, of medium size, old and shabby, like
a thousand others. But the eyes of the little old man widened as if in
terror, his face turned pale and his hands trembled. For he had seen,
hanging from one side of this worn brown leather pocketbook, the end of
a yellow thread, the loosened end of the thread with which one side of
the purse was mended. The thread told David Goldstamm who it was that
had come into his shop.

He regained his control with a desperate effort of the will. It took him
but a few seconds to do so, and, thanks to his partial intoxication,
the customer had not noticed the shopkeeper’s start of alarm. But he
appeared anxious and impatient to regain possession of his purse.

“Haven’t you found it yet?” he exclaimed.

Goldstamm hastened to give it back. The tramp put the purse in his
pocket with a sigh of relief. Goldstamm had regained his calm and his
mind was working eagerly. He put several pairs of shoes before his
customer, with the remark: “You must try them on. We’ll find something
to suit you. And meanwhile I will bring in several pairs of trousers
from those outside. I have some fine coats to show you too.”

Goldstamm went out to the door, almost colliding there with his
assistant who was coming in with his arm full of garments. The old man
motioned to the boy, who retreated until they were both hidden from the
view of the man within the store.

“Give me those blue trousers there,” said Goldstamm in a loud voice.
Then in a whisper he said to the boy: “Run to the police station. The
man with the watch and the purse is in there.”

The boy understood and set off at once at a fast pace, while the old man
returned to his store with a heavy heart. He wondered whether he would
be able to keep the murderer there until the police could come. And he
also wondered what it might cost him, an old and feeble man, who would
be as a weak reed in the hands of the strong tramp in there. But he knew
it was his duty to do whatever he could to help in the arrest of one who
had just taken the life of a fellow creature. The realisation of this
gave the old man strength and calmness.

“A nice sort of an eye for size you have,” cried the tramp as the old
man came up to him. “I suppose you’ve brought me in a boy’s suit? What
do you take me for? Any girl could go to a ball in the shoes you brought
me to try on here.”

“Are they so much too small?” asked the dealer in an innocent tone.
“Well, there’s plenty more there. And perhaps you had better be trying
on this suit behind the curtain here while I’m hunting up the shoes.”

This suggestion seemed to please the stranger, as he was evidently in a
hurry. He passed in behind the curtain and began to undress. Goldstamm’s
keen eyes watched him through a crack. There was not much to be seen
except that the tramp seemed anxious to keep his overcoat within reach
of his hand. He had carefully put the purse in one of its pockets.

“We’ll get the things all together pretty soon,” said the dealer. “I’ve
found a pair of boots here, fine boots of good quality, and sure to

“Stop your talk,” growled the other, “and come here and help me so that
I can get away.”

Goldstamm came forward, and though his heart was very heavy within
him, he aided this man, this man about whom so many hundreds were now
thinking in terror, as calmly as he had aided his other poor but honest

With hands that did not tremble, the dealer busied himself about his
customer, listening all the while to sounds in the street in the hope
that his tete-e-tete with the murderer would soon be over. But in spite
of all his natural anxiety, the old man’s sharp eyes took cognizance
of various things, one of which was that the man whom he was helping to
dress in his new clothes did not have the watch which was described in
the police notice. This fact, however, did not make the old man’s heart
any lighter, for the purse mended with yellow thread was too clearly the
one stolen from the murdered man found in the quiet street in Hietzing.

“What’s the matter with you, you’re so slow? I can get along better
myself,” growled the tramp, pushing the old man away from him. Goldstamm
had really begun to tremble now in spite of his control, in the fear
that the man would get away from him before the police came.

The tramp was already dressed in the new suit, into a pocket of which he
put the old purse.

“There, now the boots and then we’re finished,” said the dealer with an
attempt at a smile. In his heart he prayed that the pair he now held in
his hand might not fit, that he might gain a few minutes more. But the
shoes did fit. A little pushing and stamping and the man was ready to
leave the store. He was evidently in a hurry, for he paid what was asked
without any attempt to bargain. Had Goldstamm not known whom he had
before him now, he would have been very much astonished at this, and
might perhaps have been sorry that he had not named a higher sum. But
under the circumstances he understood only too well the man’s desire to
get away, and would much rather have had some talk as to the payment,
anything that would keep his customer a little longer in his store.

“There, now we’re ready. I’ll pack up your old things for you. Or
perhaps we can make a deal for them. I pay the highest prices in the
city,” said Goldstamm, with an apparent eagerness which he hoped would
deceive the customer.

But the man had already turned towards the door, and called hack over
his shoulder: “You can keep the old things, I don’t want them.”

As he spoke he opened the door of the store and stood face to face with
a policeman holding a revolver. He turned, with a curse, back into the
room, but the dealer was nowhere to be seen. David Goldstamm had done
his duty to the public, in spite of his fear. Now, seeing that the
police had arrived, he could think of his duty to his family. This duty
was plainly to save his own life, and when the tramp turned again to
look for him, he had disappeared out of the back door.

“Not a move or I will shoot,” cried the policeman, and now two others
appeared behind him, and came into the store. But the tramp made no
attempt to escape. He stood pale and trembling while they put the
handcuffs on him, and let them take him away without any resistance.
He was put on the evening express for Vienna, and taken to Police
Headquarters in that city. He made no protest nor any attempt to escape,
but he refused to utter a word on the entire journey.


The evening was already far gone when Muller entered Riedau’s office.

“You’re in time, the man isn’t here yet. The train is evidently late,”
 said the commissioner. “We’re working this case off quickly. We will
have the murderer here in half an hour at the latest. He did not have
much time to enjoy the stolen property. He was here in Vienna this
morning, and was arrested in Pressburg this afternoon. Here is the
telegram, read it.”

Dr. von Riedau handed Muller the message. The commissioner was evidently
pleased and excited. The telegram read as follows: “Man arrested here in
possession of described purse containing four ten gulden notes and
four guldens in silver. Arrested in store of second-hand clothes dealer
Goldstamm. Will arrive this evening in Vienna under guard.”

The message was signed by the Chief of the Pressburg police.

Muller laid the paper on the desk without a word. There was a watch on
this desk already; it was a heavy gold watch, unusually thick, with the
initials L. W. on the cover. Just as Muller laid down the telegram, a
door outside was opened and the commissioner covered the watch hastily.
There was a loud knock at his own door and an attendant entered to
announce that the party from Pressburg had arrived He was followed by
one of the Pressburg police force, who brought the official report.

“Did you have any difficulty with him?” asked the commissioner.

“Oh, no, sir; it was a very easy job. He made no resistance at all,
and he seems to be quite sober now. But he hasn’t said a word since we
arrested him.”

Then followed the detailed report of the arrest, and the delivery of the
described pocketbook to the commissioner.

“Is that all?” asked Dr. von Riedau.

“Yes, sir.”

“Then you may go home now, we will take charge of the man.”

The policeman bowed and left the room. A few moments later the tramp was
brought in, guarded by two armed roundsmen. His guards remained at the
door, while the prisoner himself walked forward to the middle of the
room. Commissioner von Riedau sat at his desk, his clerk beside him
ready to take down the evidence. Muller sat near a window with a paper
on his lap, looking the least interested of anybody in the proceedings.

For a moment there was complete silence in the room, which was broken
in a rather unusual manner. A deep voice, more like a growl, although
it had a queer strain of comic good-nature in it, began the proceedings
with the remark: “Well now, say, what do you want of me, anyway?”

The commissioner looked at the man in astonishment, then turned aside
that the prisoner might not notice his smile. But he might have spared
himself the trouble, for Muller, the clerk, and the two policemen at the
door were all on a broad grin.

Then the commissioner pulled himself together again, and began with his
usual official gravity: “It is I who ask questions here. Is it possible
that you do not know this? You look to me as if you had had experience
in police courts before.” The commissioner gazed at the prisoner with
eyes that were not altogether friendly. The tramp seemed to feel this,
and his own eyes dropped, while the good-natured impertinence in
his bearing disappeared. It was evidently the last remains of his
intoxication. He was now quite sober.

“What is your name?” asked the commissioner.

“Johann Knoll.”

“Where were you born?”

“Near Brunn.”

“Your age?”

“I’m--I’ll be forty next Christmas.”

“Your religion?”

“Well, you can see I’m no Jew, can’t you?”

“You will please answer my questions in a proper manner. This
impertinence will not make things easier for you.”

“All right, sir,” said the tramp humbly. “I am a Catholic.”

“You have been in prison before?” This was scarcely a question.

“No, sir,” said Knoll firmly.

“What is your business?”

“I don’t know what to say, sir,” answered Knoll, shrugging his
shoulders. “I’ve done a lot of things in my life. I’m a cattle drover
and a lumber man, and I--”

“Did you learn any trade?”

“No, sir, I never learned anything.”

“Do you mean to tell me that without having learned any trade you’ve
gotten through life thus far honestly?”

“Oh, I’ve worked hard enough--I’ve worked good and hard sometimes.”

“The last few days particularly, eh?”

“Why, no, sir, not these last days--I was drover on a transport of pigs;
we brought ‘em down from Hungary, 200 of ‘em, to the slaughter house

“When was that?”

“That was--that was Monday.”

“This last Monday?”

“Yes, sir.

“And then you went to Hietzing?”

“Yes, sir, that’s right.”

“Why did you go to Hietzing?”

“Why, see here, sir, if I had gone to Ottakring, then I suppose you
would have asked why did I go to Ottakring. I just went to Hietzing.
A fellow has to go somewhere. You don’t stay in the same spot all the
time, do you?”

Again the commissioner turned his head and another smile went through
the room. This Hietzing murderer had a sense of humour.

“Well, then, we’ll go to Hietzing again, in our minds at least,” said
the commissioner, turning back to Knoll when he had controlled his
merriment. “You went there on Monday, then--and the day was coming to an
end. What did you do when you reached Hietzing?”

“I looked about for a place to sleep.”

“Where did you look for a place to sleep?”

“Why, in Hietzing.”

“That is not definite enough.”

“Well, in a garden.”

“You were trespassing, you mean?”

“Why, yes, sir. There wasn’t anybody that seemed to want to invite me
to dinner or to give me a place to sleep. I just had to look out for

“You evidently know how to look out for yourself at the cost of others,
a heavy cost.” The commissioner’s easy tone had changed to sternness.
Knoll felt this, and a sharp gleam shot out from his dull little eyes,
while the tone of his voice was gruff and impertinent again as he asked:
“What do you mean by that?”

“You know well enough. You had better not waste any more time, but tell
us at once how you came into possession of this purse.”

“It’s my purse,” Knoll answered with calm impertinence. “I got it the
way most people get it. I bought it.”

“This purse?” the commissioner emphasised both words distinctly.

“This purse--yes,” answered the tramp with a perfect imitation of
Riedau’s voice. “Why shouldn’t I have bought this purse just like any

“Because you stole this purse from the man whom you--murdered,” was the
commissioner’s reply.

There was another moment of dead silence in the room. The commissioner
and Muller watched intently for any change of expression in the face
of the man who had just had such an accusation hurled at him. Even the
clerk and the two policemen at the door were interested to see what
would happen.

Knoll’s calm impertinence vanished, a deadly pallor spread over his
face, and he seemed frozen to stone. He attempted to speak, but was not
able to control his voice. His hands were clenched and tremors shook his
gaunt but strong-muscled frame.

“When did I murder anybody?” he gasped finally in a hoarse croak.
“You’ll have to prove it to me that I am a murderer.”

“That is easily proved. Here is one of the proofs,” said Riedan coldly,
pointing to the purse. “The purse and the watch of the murdered man are
fatal witnesses against you.”

“The watch? I haven’t any watch. Where should I get a watch?”

“You didn’t have one until Monday, possibly; I can believe that. But you
were in possession of a watch between the evening of Monday, the 27th,
and the morning of Wednesday, the 29th.”

Knoll’s eyes dropped again and he did not trust himself to speak.

“Well, you do not deny this statement?”

“No, I can’t,” said Knoll, still trying to control his voice. “You must
have the watch yourself now, or else you wouldn’t be so certain about

“Ah, you see, I thought you’d had experience with police courts before,”
 said the commissioner amiably. “Of course I have the watch already.
The man whom you sold it to this morning knew by three o’clock this
afternoon where this watch came from. He brought it here at once and
gave us your description. A very exact description. The man will be
brought here to identify you to-morrow. We must send for him anyway, to
return his money to him. He paid you fifty-two gulden for the watch. And
how much money was in the purse that you took from the murdered man?”

“Three gulden eighty-five.”

“That was a very small sum for which to commit a murder.”

Knoll groaned and bit his lips until they bled.

Commissioner von Riedau raised the paper that covered the watch and
continued: “You presumably recognised that the chain on which this watch
hung was valueless, also that it could easily be recognised. Did you
throw it away, or have you it still?”

“I threw it in the river.”

“That will not make any difference. We do not need the chain, we have
quite enough evidence without it. The purse, for instance: you thought,
I suppose, that it was just a purse like a thousand others, but it is
not. This purse is absolutely individual and easily recognised, because
it is mended in one spot with yellow thread. The thread has become
loosened and hangs down in a very noticeable manner. It was this yellow
thread on the purse, which he happened to see by chance, that showed the
dealer Goldstamm who it was that had entered his store.”

Knoll stood quite silent, staring at the floor. Drops of perspiration
stood out on his forehead, some of them rolling like tears down his

The commissioner rose from his seat and walked slowly to where the
prisoner stood. He laid one hand on the man’s shoulder and said in a
voice that was quite gentle and kind again: “Johann Knoll, do not
waste your time, or ours, in thinking up useless lies. You are almost
convicted of this crime now. You have already acknowledged so much, that
there is but little more for you to say. If you make an open confession,
it will be greatly to your advantage.”

Again the room was quiet while the others waited for what would happen.
For a moment the tramp stood silent, with the commissioner’s right hand
resting on his shoulder. Then there was a sudden movement, a struggle
and a shout, and the two policemen had overpowered the prisoner and held
him firmly. Muller rose quickly and sprang to his chief’s side. Riedau
had not even changed colour, and he said calmly: “Oh, never mind,
Muller; sit down again. The man had handcuffs on and he is quite quiet
now. I think he has sense enough to see that he is only harming himself
by his violence.”

The commissioner returned to his desk and Muller went back to his chair
by the window. The prisoner was quiet again, although his face wore a
dark flush and the veins on throat and forehead were swollen thick. He
trembled noticeably and the heavy drops besprinkled his brow.

“I--I have something to say, sir,” he began, “but first I want to beg
your pardon--”

“Oh, never mind that. I am not angry when a man is fighting for his
life, even if he doesn’t choose quite the right way,” answered the
commissioner calmly, playing with a lead pencil.

Knoll’s expression was defiant now. He laughed harshly and began again:
“What I’m tellin’ you now is the truth whether you believe it or not. I
didn’t kill the man. I took the watch and purse from him. I thought he
was drunk. If he was killed, I didn’t do it.”

“He was killed by a shot.”

“A shot? Why, yes, I heard a shot, but I didn’t think any more about it,
I didn’t think there was anythin’ doing, I thought somebody was shootin’
a cat, or else-”

“Oh, don’t bother to invent things. It was a man who was shot at, the
man whom you robbed. But go on, go on. I am anxious to hear what you
will tell me.”

Knoll’s hands, clenched to fists and his eyes glowed in hate and
defiance. Then he dropped them to the floor again and began to talk
slowly in a monotonous tone that sounded as if he were repeating a
lesson. His manner was rather unfortunate and did not tend to induce
belief in the truth of his story. The gist of what he said was as

He had reached Hietzing on Monday evening about 8 o’clock. He was
thirsty, as usual, and had about two gulden in his possession, his wages
for the last day’s work. He turned into a tavern in Hietzing and ate and
drank until his money was all gone, and he had not even enough left to
pay for a night’s lodging. But Knoll was not worried about that. He was
accustomed to sleeping out of doors, and as this was a particularly fine
evening, there was nothing in the prospect to alarm him. He set
about finding a suitable place where he would not be disturbed by the
guardians of the law. His search led him by chance into a newly opened
street. This suited him exactly. The fences were easy to climb, and
there were several little summer houses in sight which made much more
agreeable lodgings than the ground under a bush. And above all, the
street was so quiet and deserted that he knew it was just the place for
him. He had never been in the street before, and did not know its name.
He passed the four houses at the end of the street--he was on the
left sidewalk--and then he came to two fenced-in building lots. These
interested him. He was very agile, raised himself up on the fences
easily and took stock of the situation. One of the lots did not appeal
to him particularly, but the second one did. It bordered on a large
garden, in the middle of which he could see a little house of some kind.
It was after sunset but he could see things quite plainly yet for the
air was clear and the moon was just rising. He saw also that in the
vacant lot adjoining the garden, a lot which appeared to have been
a garden itself once, there was a sort of shed. It looked very much
damaged but appeared to offer shelter sufficient for a fine night.

The shed stood on a little raise of the ground near the high iron fence
that protected the large garden. Knoll decided that the shed would make
a good place to spend the night. He climbed the fence easily and walked
across the lot. When he was just settling himself for his nap, he heard
the clock on a near-by church strike nine. The various drinks he had had
for supper put him in a mood that would not allow him to get to sleep
at once. The bench in the old shed was decidedly rickety and very
uncomfortable, and as he was tossing about to find a good position, a
thought came into his mind which he acknowledged was not a commendable
one. It occurred to him that if he pursued his investigations in the
neighbourhood a little further, he might be able to pick up something
that would be of advantage to him on his wanderings. His eyes and his
thoughts were directed towards the handsome house which he could see
beyond the trees of the old garden.

The moon was now well up in the sky and it shone brightly on the
mansard roof of the fine old mansion. The windows of the long wing which
stretched out towards the garden glistened in the moonbeams, and the
light coloured wall of the house made a bright background for the dark
mask of trees waving gently in the night breeze. Knoll’s little shed was
sufficiently raised on its hillock for him to have a good view of the
garden. There was no door to the shed and he could see the neighbouring
property clearly from where he lay on his bench. While he lay there
watching, he saw a woman walking through the garden. He could see her
only when she passed back of or between the lower shrubs and bushes.
As far as he could see, she came from the main building and was walking
towards a pretty little house which lay in the centre of the garden.
Knoll had imagined this house to be the gardener’s dwelling and as it
lay quite dark he supposed the inmates were either asleep or out for the
evening. It had been this house which he was intending to honour by a
visit. But seeing the woman walking towards it, he decided it would not
be safe to carry out his plan just yet awhile.

A few moments later he was certain that this last decision had been a
wise one, for he saw a man come from the main building and walk along
the path the woman had taken. “No, nothing doing there,” thought Knoll,
and concluded he had better go to sleep. He could not remember just how
long he may have dozed but it seemed to him that during that time he
had heard a shot. It did not interest him much. He supposed some one
was shooting at a thieving cat or at some small night animal. He did
not even remember whether he had been really sound asleep, before he was
aroused by the breaking down of the bench on which he lay. The noise of
it more than the shock of the short fall, awoke him and he sprang up in
alarm and listened intently to hear whether any one had been attracted
by it. His first glance was towards the building behind the garden.
There was no sound nor no light in the garden house but there was a
light in the main building. While the tramp was wondering what hour it
might be, the church clock answered him by ten loud strokes.

His head was already aching from the wine and he did not feel
comfortable in the drafty old building. He came out from it, crept along
to the spot where he had climbed the fence before, and after listening
carefully and hearing nothing on either side, he climbed back to the
road. The Street lay silent and empty, which was just what he was hoping
for. He held carefully to the shadow thrown by the high board fence over
which he had climbed until he came to its end. Then he remembered that
he hadn’t done anything wrong and stepped out boldly into the moonlight.
The moon was well up now and the street was almost as light as day.
Knoll was attracted by the queer shadows thrown by a big elder tree,
waving its long branches in the wind. As he came nearer he saw that part
of the shadow was no shadow at all but was the body of a man lying in
the street near the bush. “I thought sure he was drunk” was the way
Knoll described it. “I’ve been like that myself often until somebody
came along and found me.”

When he came to this spot in his story, he halted and drew a long
breath. Commissioner von Riedau had begun to make some figures on the
paper in front of him, then changed the lines until the head of a pretty
woman in a fur hat took shape under his fingers.

“Well, go on,” he said, looking with interest at his drawing and
improving it with several quick strokes.

Johann Knoll continued:

“Then the devil came over me and I thought I better take this good
opportunity--well--I did. The man was lying on his back and I saw a
watch chain on his dark vest. I bent over him and took his watch
and chain. Then I felt around in his pocket and found his purse. And
then--well then I felt sorry for him lying out in the open road like
that, and I thought I’d lift him up and put him somewhere where he could
sleep it off more convenient. But I didn’t see there was a little ditch
there and I stumbled over it and dropped him. ‘It’s a good thing he’s so
drunk that even this don’t wake him up,’ I thought, and ran off. Then I
thought I heard something moving and I was scared stiff, but there was
nothing in the street at all. I thought I had better take to the fields
though and I crossed through some corn and then out onto another street.
Finally I walked into the city, stayed there till this morning, sold the
watch, then went to Pressburg.”

“So that was the way it was,” said the commissioner, pushing his drawing
away from him and motioning to the policemen at the door. “You may take
this man away now,” he added in a voice of cool indifference, without
looking at the prisoner.

Knoll’s head drooped and he walked out quietly between his two guards.
The clock on the office wall struck eleven.

“Dear me! what a lot of time the man wasted,” said the commissioner,
putting the report of the proceedings, the watch and the purse in a
drawer of his desk. “When anybody has been almost convicted of a crime,
it’s really quite unnecessary to invent such a long story.”

A few minutes later, the room was empty and Muller, as the last of the
group, walked slowly down the stairs. He was in such a brown study that
he scarcely heard the commissioner’s friendly “goodnight,” nor did he
notice that he was walking down the quiet street under a star-gilded
sky. “Almost convicted--almost. Almost?” Muller’s lips murmured while
his head was full of a chaotic rush of thought, dim pictures that came
and went, something that seemed to be on the point of bringing light
into the darkness, then vanishing again. “Almost--but not quite. There
is something here I must find out first. What is it? I must know--”


The second examination of the prisoner brought nothing new. Johann
Knoll refused to speak at all, or else simply repeated what he had said
before. This second examination took place early the next morning, but
Muller was not present. He was taking a walk in Hietzing.

When they took Johann Knoll in the police wagon to the City Prison,
Muller was just sauntering slowly through the street where the murder
had been committed. And as the door of the cell shut clangingly behind
the man whose face was distorted in impotent rage and despair, Joseph
Muller was standing in deep thought before the broken willow twig, which
now hung brown and dry across the planks of the fence. He looked at it
for a long time. That is, he seemed to be looking at it, but in reality
his eyes were looking out and beyond the willow twig, out into the
unknown, where the unknown murderer was still at large. Leopold
Winkler’s body had already been committed to the earth. How long will
it be before his death is avenged? Or perhaps how long may it even be
before it is discovered from what motive this murder was committed. Was
it a murder for robbery, or a murder for personal revenge perhaps? Were
the two crimes committed here by one and the same person, or were there
two people concerned? And if two, did they work as accomplices? Or is it
possible that Knoll’s story was true? Did he really only rob the body,
not realising that it was a dead man and not merely an intoxicated
sleeper as he had supposed? These and many more thoughts rushed
tumultuously through Muller’s brain until he sighed despairingly under
the pressure. Then he smiled in amusement at the wish that had crossed
his brain, the wish that this case might seem as simple to him as it
apparently did to the commissioner. It would certainly have saved him a
lot of work and trouble if he could believe the obvious as most people
did. What was this devil that rode him and spurred him on to delve
into the hidden facts concerning matters that seemed so simple on the
surface? The devil that spurred him on to understand that there always
was some hidden side to every case? Then the sigh and the smile passed,
and Muller raised his head in one of the rare moments of pride in his
own gifts that this shy unassuming little man ever allowed himself. This
was the work that he was intended by Providence to do or he wouldn’t
have been fitted for it, and it was work for the common good, for the
public safety. Thinking back over the troubles of his early youth,
Muller’s heart rejoiced and he was glad in his own genius. Then the
moment of unwonted elation passed and he bent his mind again to the
problem before him.

He sauntered slowly through the quiet street in the direction of the
four houses. To reach them he passed the fence that enclosed this end of
the Thorne property. Muller had already known, for the last twenty-four
hours at least, that the owner of the fine old estate was an artist by
the name of Herbert Thorne. His own landlady had informed him of
this. He himself was new to the neighbourhood, having moved out there
recently, and he had verified her statements by the city directory. As
he was now passing the Thorne property, in his slow, sauntering walk,
he had just come within a dozen paces of the little wooden gate in the
fence when this gate opened. Muller’s naturally soft tread was made
still more noiseless by the fact that he wore wide soft shoes. Years
before he had acquired a bad case of chilblains, in fact had been in
imminent danger of having his feet frozen by standing for five hours
in the snow in front of a house, to intercept several aristocratic
gentlemen who sooner or later would be obliged to leave that house. The
police had long suspected the existence of this high-class gambling den;
but it was not until they had put Muller in charge of the case, that
there were any results attained. The arrests were made at the risk of
permanent injury to the celebrated detective. Since then, Muller’s step
was more noiseless than usual, and now the woman who opened the gate
and peered out cautiously did not hear his approach nor did she see him
standing in the shadow of the fence. She looked towards the other end
of the street, then turned and spoke to somebody behind her. “There’s
nobody coming from that direction,” he said. Then she turned her head
the other way and saw Muller. She looked at him for a moment and slammed
the gate shut, disappearing behind it. Muller heard the lock click and
heard the beat of running feet hastening rapidly over the gravel path
through the garden.

The detective stood immediately in front of the gate, shaking his head.
“What was the matter with the woman? What was it that she wanted to see
or do in the street? Why should she run away when she saw me?” These
were his thoughts. But he didn’t waste time in merely thinking. Muller
never did. Action followed thought with him very quickly. He saw a
knot-hole in the fence just beside the gate and he applied his eyes
to this knot-hole. And through the knot-hole he saw something that
interested and surprised him.

The woman whose face had appeared so suddenly at the gate, and
disappeared still more suddenly, was the same woman whom he had seen
bidding farewell to Mr. Thorne and his wife on the Tuesday morning
previous, the woman whom he took to be the housekeeper. The old butler
stood beside her. It was undoubtedly the same man, although he had worn
a livery then and was now dressed in a comfortable old house coat.
He stood beside the woman, shaking his head and asking her just the
questions that Muller was asking himself at the moment.

“Why, what is the matter with you, Mrs. Bernauer? You’re so nervous
since yesterday. Are you ill? Everything seems to frighten you? Why did
you run away from that gate so suddenly? I thought you wanted me to show
you the place?”

Mrs. Bernauer raised her head and Muller saw that her face looked pale
and haggard and that her eyes shone with an uneasy feverish light. She
did not answer the old man’s questions, but made a gesture of farewell
and then turned and walked slowly towards the house. She realised,
apparently, and feared, perhaps, that the man who was passing the gate
might have noticed her sudden change of demeanour and that he was
listening to what she might say. She did not think of the knot-hole
in the board fence, or she might have been more careful in hiding her
distraught face from possible observers.

Muller stood watching through this knot-hole for some little time. He
took a careful observation of the garden, and from his point of vantage
he could easily see the little house which was apparently the dwelling
of the gardener, as well as the mansard roof of the main building. There
was considerable distance between the two houses. The detective decided
that it might interest him to know something more about this garden,
this house and the people who lived there. And when Muller made such a
decision it was usually not very long before he carried it out.

The other street, upon which the main front of the mansard house opened,
contained a few isolated dwellings surrounded by gardens and a number of
newly built apartment houses. On the ground floor of these latter houses
were a number of stores and immediately opposite the Thorne mansion was
a little cafe. This suited Muller exactly, for he had been there before
and he remembered that from one of the windows there was an excellent
view of the gate and the front entrance of the mansion opposite. It was
a very modest little cafe, but there was a fairly good wine to be had
there and the detective made it an excuse to sit down by the window,
as if enjoying his bottle while admiring the changing colours of the
foliage in the gardens opposite.

Another rather good chance, he discovered, was the fact that the
landlord belonged to the talkative sort, and believed that the
refreshments he had to sell were rendered doubly agreeable when spiced
by conversation. In this case the good man was not mistaken. It was
scarcely ten o’clock in the forenoon and there were very few people in
the cafe. The landlord was quite at leisure to devote himself to this
stranger in the window seat, whom he did not remember to have seen
before, and who was therefore doubly interesting to him. Several
subjects of conversation usual in such cases, such as politics and
the weather, seemed to arouse no particular enthusiasm in his patron’s
manner. Finally the portly landlord decided that he would touch upon the
theme which was still absorbing all Hietzing.

“Oh, by the way, sir, do you know that you are in the immediate vicinity
of the place where the murder of Monday evening was committed? People
are still talking about it around here. And I see by the papers that the
murderer was arrested in Pressburg yesterday and brought to Vienna last

“Indeed, is that so? I haven’t seen a paper to-day,” replied Muller,
awakening from his apparent indifference.

The landlord was flattered by the success of the new subject, and stood
ready to unloose the floodgates of his eloquence. His customer sat up
and asked the question for which the landlord was waiting.

“So it was around here that the man was shot?”

“Yes. His name was Leopold Winkler, that was in the papers to-day too.
You see that pretty house opposite? Well, right behind this house is the
garden that belongs to it and back of that, an old garden which has
been neglected for some time. It was at the end of this garden where
it touches the other street, that they found the man under a big
elder-tree, early Tuesday morning, day before yesterday.”

“Oh, indeed!” said. Muller, greatly interested, as if this was the first
he had heard of it. The landlord took a deep breath and was about to
begin again when his customer, who decided to keep the talkative man
to a certain phase of the subject, now took command of the conversation

“I should think that the people opposite, who live so near the place
where the murder was committed, wouldn’t be very much pleased,” he said.
“I shouldn’t care to look out on such a spot every time I went to my

“There aren’t any windows there,” exclaimed the landlord, “for there
aren’t any houses there. There’s only the old garden, and then the large
garden and the park belonging to Mr. Thorne’s house, that fine old house
you see just opposite here. It’s a good thing that Mr. Thorne and his
wife went away before the murder became known. The lady hasn’t been well
for some weeks, she’s very nervous and frail, and it probably would have
frightened her to think that such things were happening right close to
her home.”

“The lady is sick? What’s the matter with her?”

“Goodness knows, nerves, heart trouble, something like that. The things
these fine ladies are always having. But she wasn’t always that way, not
until about a year ago. She was fresh and blooming and very pretty to
look at before that.”

“She is a young lady then?”

“Yes, indeed, sir; she’s very young still and very pretty. It makes you
feel sorry to see her so miserable, and you feel sorry for her husband.
Now there’s a young couple with everything in the world to make them
happy and so fond of each other, and the poor little lady has to be so

“They are very happy, you say?” asked Muller carelessly. He had no
particular set purpose in following up this inquiry, none but his usual
understanding of the fact that a man in his business can never amass too
much knowledge, and that it will sometimes happen that a chance bit of
information comes in very handy.

The landlord was pleased at the encouragement and continued: “Indeed
they are very happy. They’ve only been married two years. The lady comes
from a distance, from Graz. Her father is an army officer I believe, and
I don’t think she was over-rich. But she’s a very sweet-looking lady and
her rich husband is very fond of her, any one can see that.”

“You said just now that they had gone away, where have they gone to?”

“They’ve gone to Italy, sir. Mrs. Thorne was one of the few people who
do not know Venice. Franz, that’s the butler, sir, told me yesterday
evening that he had received a telegram saying that the lady and
gentleman had arrived safely and were very comfortably fixed in the
Hotel Danieli. You know Danieli’s?”

“Yes, I do. I also was one of the few people who did not know Venice,
that is I was until two years ago. Then, however, I had the pleasure of
riding over the Bridge of Mestre,” answered Muller. He did not add that
he was not alone at the time, but had ridden across the long bridge in
company with a pale haggard-faced man who did not dare to look to the
right or to the left because of the revolver which he knew was held in
the detective’s hand under his loose overcoat. Muller’s visit to Venice,
like most of his journeyings, had been one of business. This time to
capture and bring home a notorious and long sought embezzler. He did
not volunteer any of this information, however, but merely asked in
a politely interested manner whether the landlord himself had been to

“Yes, indeed,” replied the latter proudly. “I was head waiter at Baner’s
for two years.”

“Then you must make me some Italian dishes soon,” said Muller. Further
conversation was interrupted by the entrance of Franz, the old butler of
the house opposite.

“Excuse me, sir; I must get him his glass of wine,” said the landlord,
hurrying away to the bar. He returned in a moment with a small bottle
and a glass and set it down on Muller’s table.

“You don’t mind, sir, if he sits down here?” he asked. “He usually sits
here at this table because then he can see if he is needed over at the

“Oh, please let him come here. He has prior rights to this table
undoubtedly,” said the stranger politely. The old butler sat down
with an embarrassed murmur, as the voluble landlord explained that the
stranger had no objection. Then the boniface hurried off to attend to
some newly entered customers and the detective, greatly pleased at the
prospect, found himself alone with the old servant.

“You come here frequently?” he began, to open the conversation.

“Yes, sir, since my master and myself have settled down here--we
travelled most of the time until several years ago--I find this place
very convenient. It’s a cosy little room, the wine is good and not
expensive, I’m near home and yet I can see some new faces occasionally.”

“I hope the faces that you see about you at home are not so unpleasant
that you are glad to get away from them?” asked Muller with a smile.

The old man gave a start of alarm. “Oh, dear, no, sir,” he exclaimed
eagerly; “that wasn’t what I meant. Indeed I’m fond of everybody in the
house from our dear lady down to the poor little dog.”

Here Muller gained another little bit of knowledge, the fact that the
lady of the house was the favourite of her servants, or that she seemed
to them even more an object of adoration than the master.

“Then you evidently have a very good place, since you seem so fond of
every one.”

“Indeed I have a good place, sir.”

“You’ve had this place a long time?”

“More than twenty years. My master was only eleven years old when I took
service with the family.”

“Ah, indeed! then you must be a person of importance in the house if you
have been there so long?”

“Well more or less I might say I am,” the old man smiled and looked
flattered, then added: “But the housekeeper, Mrs. Bernauer, is even more
important than I am, to tell you the truth. She was nurse to our present
young master, and she’s been in the house ever since. When his
parents died, it’s some years ago now, she took entire charge of the
housekeeping. She was a fine active woman then, and now the young master
and mistress couldn’t get along without her. They treat her as if she
was one of the family.”

“And she is ill also? I say also,” explained Muller, “because the
landlord has just been telling me that your mistress is ill.”

“Yes, indeed, more’s the pity! our poor dear young lady has been
miserable for nearly a year now. It’s a shame to see such a sweet angel
as she is suffer like that and the master’s quite heart-broken over it.
But there’s nothing the matter with Mrs. Bernauer. How did you come to
think that she was sick?”

Muller did not intend to explain that the change in the housekeeper’s
appearance, a change which had come about between Tuesday morning and
Thursday morning, might easily have made any one think that she was
ill. He gave as excuse for his question the old man’s own words: “Why,
I thought that she might be ill also because you said yourself that the
housekeeper--what did you say her name was?”

“Bernauer, Mrs. Adele Bernauer. She was a widow when she came to take
care of the master. Her husband was a sergeant of artillery.”

“Well, I mean,” continued Muller, “you said yourself that when the
gentleman’s parents died, Mrs. Bernauer was a fine active woman,
therefore I supposed she was no longer so.”

Franz thought the matter over for a while. “I don’t know just why I put
it that way. Indeed she’s still as active as ever and always fresh and
well. It’s true that for the last two or three days she’s been very
nervous and since yesterday it is as if she was a changed woman. She
must be ill, I don’t know how to explain it otherwise.”

“What seems to be the matter with her?” asked Muller and then to explain
his interest in the housekeeper’s health, he fabricated a story: “I
studied medicine at one time and although I didn’t finish my course
or get a diploma, I’ve always had a great interest in such things, and
every now and then I’ll take a case, particularly nervous diseases. That
was my specialty.” Muller took up his glass and turned away from the
window, for he felt a slow flush rising to his cheeks. It was another
of Muller’s peculiarities that he always felt an inward embarrassment at
the lies he was obliged to tell in his profession.

The butler did not seem to have noticed it however, and appeared eager
to tell of what concerned him in the housekeeper’s appearance and
demeanour. “Why, yesterday at dinner time was the first that we began
to notice anything wrong with Mrs. Bernauer. The rest of us, that is,
Lizzie the upstairs girl, the cook and myself. She began to eat her
dinner with a good appetite, then suddenly, when we got as far as the
pudding, she let her fork fall and turned deathly white. She got up
without saying a word and left the room. Lizzie ran after her to ask if
anything was the matter, but she said no, it was nothing of importance.
After dinner, she went right out, saying she was doing some errands.
She brought in a lot of newspapers, which was quite unusual, for she
sometimes does not look at a newspaper once a week even. I wouldn’t have
noticed it but Lizzie’s the kind that sees and hears everything and
she told us about it.” Franz stopped to take a drink, and Muller said
indifferently, “I suppose Mrs. Bernauer was interested in the murder
case. The whole neighbourhood seems to be aroused about it.”

“No, I don’t think that was it,” answered the old servant, “because then
she would have sent for a paper this morning too.”

“And she didn’t do that?”

“No, unless she might have gone out for it herself. There’s a news stand
right next door here. But I don’t think she did because I would have
seen the paper around the house then.”

“And is that all that’s the matter with her?” asked Muller in a tone of
disappointment. “Why, I thought you’d have something really interesting
to tell me.”

“Oh, no, that isn’t all, sir,” exclaimed the old man eagerly.

Muller leaned forward, really interested now, while Franz continued:
“She was uneasy all the afternoon yesterday. She walked up and down
stairs and through the halls--I remember Lizzie making some joke about
it--and then in the evening to our surprise she suddenly began a great
rummaging in the first story.”

“Is that where she lives?”

“Oh, no; her room is in the wing out towards the garden. The rooms on
the first floor all belong to the master and mistress. This morning we
found out that Mrs. Bernauer’s cleaning up of the evening before had
been done because she remembered that the master wanted to take some
papers with him but couldn’t find them and had asked her to look for
them and send them right on.”

“Well, I shouldn’t call that a sign of any particular nervousness, but
rather an evidence of Mrs. Bernauer’s devotion to her duty.”

“Oh, yes, sir--but it certainly is queer that she should go into
the garden at four o’clock this morning and appear to be looking for
something along the paths and under the bushes. Even if a few of the
papers blew out of the window, or blew away from the summer house, where
the master writes sometimes, they couldn’t have scattered all over the
garden like that.”

Muller didn’t follow up this subject any longer. There might come a
time when he would be interested in finding out the reason for the
housekeeper’s search in the garden, but just at present he wanted
something else. He remembered some remark of the old man’s about the
“poor little dog,” and on this he built his plan.

“Oh, well,” he said carelessly, “almost everybody is nervous and
impatient now-a-days. I suppose Mrs. Bernauer felt uneasy because
she couldn’t find the paper right away. There’s nothing particularly
interesting or noticeable about that. Anyway, I’ve been occupying myself
much more these last years with sick animals rather than with sick
people. I’ve had some very successful cures there.”

“No, really, have you? Then you could do us a great favour,” exclaimed
Franz in apparent eagerness. Muller’s heart rejoiced. He had apparently
hit it right this time. He knew that in a house like that “a poor dog”
 could only mean a “sick dog.” But his voice was quite calm as he asked:
“How can I do you a favour?”

“Why, you see, sir, we’ve got a little terrier,” explained the old man,
who had quite forgotten the fact that he had mentioned the dog before.
“And there’s been something the matter with the poor little chap for
several days. He won’t eat or drink, he bites at the grass and rolls
around on his stomach and cries--it’s a pity to see him. If you’re fond
of animals and know how to take care of them, you may be able to help us

“You want me to look at the little dog? Why, yes, I suppose I can.”

“We’ll appreciate it,” said the old man with an embarrassed smile. But
Muller shook his head and continued: “No, never mind the payment, I
wouldn’t take any money for it. But I’ll tell you what you can do
for me. I’m very fond of flowers. If you think you can take the
responsibility of letting me walk around in the garden for a little
while, and pick a rose or two, I will be greatly pleased.”

“Why, of course you may,” said Franz. “Take any of the roses you see
there that please you. They’re nearly over for the season now and it’s
better they should be picked rather than left to fade on the bush.
We don’t use so many flowers in the house now when the family are not

“All right, then, it’s a bargain,” laughed Muller, signalling to the
landlord. “Are you, going already?” asked the old servant.

“Yes, I must be going if I am to spend any time with the little dog.”

“I suppose I ought to be at home myself,” said Franz. “Something’s the
matter with the electric wiring in our place. The bell in the master’s
room keeps ringing. I wrote to Siemens & Halske to send us a man out
to fix it. He’s likely to come any minute now.” The two men rose, paid
their checks, and went out together. Outside the cafe Muller hesitated
a moment. “You go on ahead,” he said to Franz. “I want to go in here and
get a cigar.”

While buying his cigar and lighting it, he asked for several newspapers,
choosing those which his quick eye had told him were no longer among the
piles on the counter. “I’m very sorry, sir,” said the clerk; “we have
only a few of those papers, just two or three more than we need for our
regular customers, and this morning they are all sold. The housekeeper
from the Thorne mansion took the very last ones.”

This was exactly what Muller wanted to know. He left the store and
caught up with the old butler as the latter was opening the handsome
iron gate that led from the Thorne property out onto the street.

“Well, where’s our little patient?” asked the detective as he walked
through the courtyard with Franz.

“You’ll see him in a minute,” answered the old servant. He led the way
through a light roomy corridor furnished with handsome old pieces in
empire style, and opened a door at its further end.

“This is my room.”

It was a large light room with two windows opening on the garden. Muller
was not at all pleased that the journey through the hall had been such a
short one. However he was in the house, that was something, and he could
afford to trust to chance for the rest. Meanwhile he would look at the
dog. The little terrier lay in a corner by the stove and it did not take
Muller more than two or three minutes to discover that there was nothing
the matter with the small patient but a simple case of over-eating.
But he put on a very wise expression as he handled the little dog and
looking up, asked if he could get some chamomile tea.

“I’ll go for it, I think there’s some in the house. Do you want it made
fresh?” said Franz.

“Yes, that will be better, about a cupful will do,” was Muller’s answer.
He knew that this harmless remedy would be likely to do the dog good and
at the present moment he wanted to be left alone in the room. As soon
as Franz had gone, the detective hastened to the window, placing himself
behind the curtain so that he could not be seen from outside. He himself
could see first a wide courtyard lying between the two wings of the
house, then beyond it the garden, an immense square plot of ground
beautifully cultivated. The left wing of the house was about six windows
longer than the other, and from the first story of it it would be quite
easy to look out over the vacant lot where the old shed stood which had
served as a night’s lodging for Johann Knoll.

There was not the slightest doubt in Muller’s mind that this part of the
tramp’s story was true, for by a natural process of elimination he knew
there was nothing to be gained by inventing any such tale. Besides
which the detective himself had been to look at the shed. His well-known
pedantic thoroughness would not permit him to take any one’s word for
anything that he might find out for himself. In his investigations on
Tuesday morning he had already seen the half-ruined shed, now he knew
that it contained a broken bench.

Thus far, therefore, Knoll’s story was proved to be true--but there was
something that didn’t quite hitch in another way. The tramp had said
that he had seen first a woman and then a man come from the main house
and go in the direction of the smaller house which he took to be the
gardener’s dwelling. This Muller discovered now was quite impossible.
A tall hedge, fully seven or eight feet high and very thick, stretched
from the courtyard far down into the garden past the gardener’s little
house. There was a broad path on the right and the left of this green
wall. From his position in the shed, Knoll could have seen people
passing only when they were on the right side of the hedge. But to reach
the gardener’s house from the main dwelling, the shortest way would be
on the left side of the hedge. This much Muller saw, then he heard the
butler’s steps along the hall and he went back to the corner where the
dog lay.

Franz was not alone. There was some one else with him, the housekeeper,
Mrs. Bernauer. Just as they opened the door, Muller heard her say:
“If the gentleman is a veterinary, then we’d better ask him about the

The sentence was never finished. Muller never found out what was the
matter with the parrot, for as he looked up with a polite smile of
interest, he looked into a pale face, into a pair of eyes that opened
wide in terror, and heard trembling lips frame the words: “There he is

A moment later Mrs. Bernauer would have been glad to have recalled her
exclamation, but it was too late.

Muller bowed before her and asked: “‘There he is again,’ you said; have
you ever seen me before?”

The woman looked at him as if hypnotised and answered almost in a
whisper: “I saw you Tuesday morning for the first time, Tuesday morning
when the family were going away. Then I saw you pass through our street
twice again that same day. This morning you went past the garden gate
and now I find you here. What-what is it you want of us?”

“I will tell you what I want, Mrs. Bernauer, but first I want to speak
to you alone. Mr. Franz doesn’t mind leaving us for a while, does he?”

“But why?” said the old man hesitatingly. He didn’t understand at all
what was going on and he would much rather have remained.

“Because I came here for the special purpose of speaking to Mrs.
Bernauer,” replied Muller calmly.

“Then you didn’t come on account of the dog?”

“No, I didn’t come on account of the dog.”

“Then you--you lied to me?”


“And you’re no veterinary?”

“No--I can help your dog, but I am not a veterinary and never have

“What are you then?”

“I will tell Mrs. Bernauer who and what I am when you are
outside--outside in the courtyard there. You can walk about in the
garden if you want to, or else go and get some simple purgative for this
dog. That is all he needs; he has been over-fed.”

Franz was quite bewildered. These new developments promised to be
interesting and he was torn between his desire to know more, and his
doubts as to the propriety of leaving the housekeeper with this queer
stranger. He hesitated until the woman herself motioned to him to go. He
went out into the hall, then into the courtyard, watched by the two in
the room who stood silently in the window until they saw the butler pass
down into the garden. Then they looked at each other.

“You belong to the police?” asked Adele Bernauer finally with a deep

“That was a good guess,” replied Muller with an ironic smile, adding:
“All who have any reason to fear us are very quick in recognising us.”

“What do you mean by that?” she exclaimed with a start. “What are you
thinking of?”

“I am thinking about the same thing that you are thinking of--that I
have proved you are thinking of--the same thing that drove you out into
the street yesterday and this morning to buy the papers. These papers
print news which is interesting many people just now, and some people a
great deal. I am thinking of the same thing that was evidently in your
thoughts as you peered out of the garden gate this morning, although you
would not come out into the street. I know that you do not read even one
newspaper regularly. I know also that yesterday and today you bought
a great many papers, apparently to get every possible detail about a
certain subject. Do you deny this?”

She did not deny it, she did not answer at all. She sank down on
a chair, her wide staring eyes looking straight ahead of her, and
trembling so that the old chair cracked underneath her weight. But this
condition did not last long. The woman had herself well under control.
Muller’s coming, or something else, perhaps, may have overwhelmed her
for a moment, but she soon regained her usual self-possession.

“Still you have not told me what you want here,” she began coldly,
and as he did not answer she continued: “I have a feeling that you
are watching us. I had this feeling when I saw you the first time and
noticed then--pardon my frankness--that you stared at us sharply while
we were saying goodbye to our master and mistress. Then I saw you pass
twice again through the street and look up at our windows. This morning
I find you at our garden gate and now--you will pardon me if I tell the
exact truth--now you have wormed yourself in here under false pretenses
because you have no right whatever to force an entrance into this house.
And I ask you again, what do you want here?”

Muller was embarrassed. That did not happen very often. Also it did not
happen very often that he was in the wrong as he was now. The woman
was absolutely right. He had wormed himself into the house under false
pretenses to follow up the new clue which almost unconsciously as yet
was leading him on with a stronger and stronger attraction. He could not
have explained it and he certainly was not ready to say anything about
it at police headquarters, even at the risk of being obliged to continue
to enter this mysterious house under false pretenses and to be told
that he was doing so. Of course this sort of thing was necessary in his
business, it was the only way in which he could follow up the criminals.

But there was something in this woman’s words that cut into a sensitive
spot and drove the blood to his cheeks. There was something in the
bearing and manner of this one-time nurse that impressed him, although
he was not a man to be lightly impressed. He had a feeling that he had
made a fool of himself and it bothered him. For a moment he did not know
what he should say to this woman who stood before him with so much quiet
energy in her bearing. But the something in his brain, the something
that made him what he was, whispered to him that he had done right, and
that he must follow up the trail he had found. That gave him back his
usual calm.

He took up his hat, and standing before the pale-faced woman, looking
her firmly in the eyes, he said: “It is true that I have no right as yet
to force my way into your house, therefore I have been obliged to enter
it as best I could. I have done this often in my work, but I do it
for the safety of society. And those who reproach me for doing it are
generally those whom I have been obliged to persecute in the name of
the law. Mrs. Bernauer, I will confess that there are moments in which I
feel ashamed that I have chosen this profession that compels me to
hunt down human beings. But I do not believe that this is one of those
moments. You have read this morning’s papers; you must know, therefore,
that a man has been arrested and accused of the murder which interests
you so much; you must be able to realise the terror and anxiety which
are now filling this man’s heart. For to-day’s papers--I have read them
myself--expressed the public sentiment that the police may succeed in
convicting this man of the crime, that the death may be avenged and
justice have her due. Several of these papers, the papers I know you
have bought and presumably read, do not doubt that Johann Knoll is the
murderer of Leopold Winkler.

“Now there are at least two people who do not believe that Knoll is the
murderer. I am one of them, and you, Mrs. Bernauer, you are the other.
I am going now and when I come again, as I doubtless will come again,
I will come with full right to enter this house. I acknowledge frankly
that I have no justification in causing your arrest as yet, but you are
quite clever enough to know that if I had the faintest justification I
would not leave here alone. And one thing more I have to say. You may
not know that I have had the most extraordinary luck in my profession,
that in more than a hundred cases there have been but two where the
criminal I was hunting escaped me. And now, Mrs. Bernauer, I will bid
you good day.”

Muller stepped towards the window and motioned to Franz, who was walking
up and down outside. The old man ran to the door and met the detective
in the hall.

“You’d better go in and look after Mrs. Bernauer,” said the latter, “I
can find my way out alone.”

Franz looked after him, shaking his head in bewilderment and then
entered his own room. “Merciful God!” he exclaimed, bending down in
terror over the housekeeper, who lay on the floor. In his shock and
bewilderment he imagined that she too had been murdered, until he
realised that it was only a swoon from which she recovered in a moment.
He helped her regain her feet and she looked about as if still dazed,
stammering: “Has he gone?”

“The strange man? ... Yes, he went some time ago. But what happened to
you? Did he give you something to make you faint? Do you think he was a

Mrs. Bernauer shook her head and murmured: “Oh, no, quite the contrary.”
 A remark which did not enlighten Franz particularly as to the status
of the man who had just left them. There was a note of fear in the
housekeepers’s voice and she added hastily: “Does any one besides
ourselves know that he was here?”

“No, Lizzie and the cook are in the kitchen talking about the murder.”

Mrs. Bernauer shivered again and went slowly out of the room and up the

If Franz believed that the stranger had left the house by the front
entrance he was very much mistaken. When Muller found himself alone in
the corridor he turned quickly and hurried out into the garden. None
of the servants had seen him. Lizzie and the cook were engaged in an
earnest conversation in the kitchen and Franz was fully occupied with
Mrs. Bernauer. The gardener was away and his wife busy at her wash
tubs. No one was aware, therefore, that Muller spent about ten minutes
wandering about the garden, and ten minutes were quite sufficient for
him to become so well acquainted with the place that he could have drawn
a map of it. He left the garden through the rear gate, the latch of
which he was obliged to leave open. The gardener’s wife found it that
way several hours later and was rather surprised thereat. Muller walked
down the street rapidly and caught a passing tramway. His mood was
not of the best, for he could not make up his mind whether or no this
morning had been a lost one. His mind sorted and rearranged all that
he knew or could imagine concerning Mrs. Bernauer. But there was hardly
enough of these facts to reassure him that he was not on a false trail,
that he had not allowed himself to waste precious hours all because he
had seen a woman’s haggard face appear for a moment at the little gate
in the quiet street.


Muller’s goal was the prison where Johann Knoll was awaiting his fate.
The detective had permission to see the man as often as he wished to.
Knoll had been proven a thief, but the accusation of murder against
him had not been strengthened by anything but the most superficial
circumstantial evidence, therefore it was necessary that Muller should
talk with him in the hope of discovering something more definite.

Knoll lay asleep on his cot as the detective and the warder entered the
cell. Muller motioned the attendant to leave him alone with the prisoner
and he stood beside the cot looking down at the man. The face on
the hard pillow was not a very pleasant one to look at. The skin was
roughened and swollen and had that brown-purple tinge which comes
from being constantly in the open air, and from habitual drinking. The
weather-beaten look may be seen often in the faces of men whose honest
work keeps them out of doors; but this man had not earned his colouring
honestly, for he was one of the sort who worked only from time to time
when it was absolutely necessary and there was no other way of getting
a penny. His hands proved this, for although soiled and grimy they had
soft, slender fingers which showed no signs of a life of toil. But even
a man who has spent forty years in useless idling need not be all bad.
There must have been some good left in this man or he could not have
lain there so quietly, breathing easily, wrapped in a slumber as
undisturbed as that of a child. It did not seem possible that any man
could lie there like that with the guilt of murder on his conscience, or
even with the knowledge in his soul that he had plundered a corpse.

Muller had never believed the first to be the case, but he had thought
it possible that Knoll knew perfectly well that it was a lifeless body
he was robbing. He had believed it at least until the moment when he
stood looking down at the sleeping tramp. Now, with the deep knowledge
of the human heart which was his by instinct and which his profession
had increased a thousand-fold, Muller knew that this man before him
had no heavy crime upon his conscience--that it was really as he had
said--that he had taken the watch and purse from one whom he believed
to be intoxicated only. Of course it was not a very commendable deed for
which the tramp was now in prison, but it was slight in comparison to
the crimes of which he was suspected.

Muller bent lower over the unconscious form and was surprised to see a
gentle smile spread over the face before him. It brightened and
changed the coarse rough face and gave it for a moment a look of almost
child-like innocence. Somewhere within the coarsened soul there must be
a spot of brightness from which such a smile could come.

But the face grew ugly again as Knoll opened his eyes and looked up. He
shook off the clouds of slumber as he felt Muller’s hand on his shoulder
and raised himself to a sitting position, grumbling: “Can’t I have any
rest? Are they going to question me again? I’m getting tired of this.
I’ve said everything I know anyhow.”

“Perhaps not everything. Perhaps you will answer a few of my questions
when I tell you that I believe the story you told us yesterday, and that
I want to be your friend and help you.”

Knoll’s little eyes glanced up without embarrassment at the man
who spoke to him. They were sharp eyes and had a certain spark of
intelligence in them. Muller had noticed that yesterday, and he saw
it again now. But he saw also the gleam of distrust in these eyes, a
distrust which found expression in Knoll’s next words. “You think you
can catch me with your good words, but you’re makin’ a mistake. I’ve got
nothin’ new to say. And you needn’t think that you can blind me, I know
you’re one of the police, and I’m not going to say anything at all.”

“Just as you like. I was trying to help you, I believe I really could
help you. I have just come from Hietzing--but of course if you don’t
want to talk to me--” Muller shrugged his shoulders and turned toward
the door.

But before he reached it Knoll stood at his side. “You really mean to
help me?” he gasped.

“I do,” said the detective calmly.

“Then swear, on your mother’s soul--or is your mother still alive?”

“No, she has been dead some time.”

“Well, then, will you swear it?”

“Would you believe an oath like that?”

“Why shouldn’t I?”

“With the life you’ve been leading?”

“My life’s no worse than a lot of others. Stealing those things on
Monday was the worst thing I’ve done yet. Will you swear?”

“Is it something so very important you have to tell me?”

“No, I ain’t got nothin’ at all new to tell you. But I’d just like
to know--in this black hole I’ve got into--I’d just like to know that
there’s one human being who means well with me--I’d like to know
that there’s one man in the world who don’t think I’m quite

The tramp covered his face with his hands and gave a heart-rending sob.
Deep pity moved the detective’s breast. He led Knoll back to his cot,
and put both hands on his shoulders, saying gravely: “I believe that
this theft was the worst thing you have done. By my mother’s salvation,
Knoll, I believe your words and I will try to help you.”

Knoll raised his head, looking up at Muller with a glance of unspeakable
gratitude. With trembling lips he kissed the hand which a moment before
had pressed kindly on his shoulder, clinging fast to it as if he could
not bear to let it go. Muller was almost embarrassed. “Oh, come now,
Knoll, don’t be foolish. Pull yourself together and answer my questions
carefully, for I am asking you these questions more for your own sake
than for anything else.”

The tramp nodded and wiped the tears from his face. He looked almost
happy again, and there was a softness in his eyes that showed there was
something in the man which might be saved and which was worth saving.

Muller sat beside him on the cot and began: “There was one mistake in
your story yesterday. I want you to think it over carefully. You said
that you saw first a woman and then a man going through the neighbouring
garden. I believe that one or both of these people is the criminal
for whom we are looking. Therefore, I want you to try and remember
everything that you can connect with them, every slightest detail.
Anything that you can tell us may be of the greatest importance.
Therefore, think very carefully.”

Knoll sat still a few moments, evidently trying hard to put his hazy
recollections into useful form and shape. But it was also evident that
orderly thinking was an unusual work for him, and he found it almost too
difficult. “I guess you better ask me questions, maybe that’ll go,” he
said after a pause.

Then Muller began to question. With his usual thoroughness he began at
the very beginning: “When was it that you climbed the fence to get into
the shed?”

“It just struck nine o’clock when I put my foot on the lowest bar.”

“Are you sure of that?”

“Quite sure. I counted every stroke. You see, I wanted to know how long
the night was going to be, seein’ I’d have to sleep in that shed. I was
in the garden just exactly an hour. I came out of the shed as it struck
ten and it wasn’t but a few minutes before I was in the street again.”

“And when was it that you saw the woman in the garden next door?”

“H’m, I don’t just know when that was. I’d been in on the bench quite a

“And the man? When did you see the man?”

“He came past a few minutes after the woman had gone towards the little
house in the garden.”

“Ah! there you see, that’s where you made your mistake. It is more than
likely that these two did not go to the little house, but that they went
somewhere else. Did they walk slowly and quietly?”

“Not a bit of it. They ran almost... Went past as quick as a bat in the

“Then they both appeared to be in a hurry?”

“Yes indeed they did.”

“Ah, ha, you see! Now when any one’s in a hurry he doesn’t go the
longest way round, as a rule. And it would have been the longest way
round for these two people to go from the big house to the gardener’s
cottage--for the little house you saw was the gardener’s cottage. There
is tall thick hedge that starts from the main building and goes right
down through the garden, quite a distance past the gardener’s cottage.
The vegetable garden is on the left side of this hedge and in the middle
of the vegetable garden is the gardener’s cottage. But you could have
seen the man and the woman only because they passed down the right side
of the hedge, and this would have given them a detour of fifty paces or
more to reach the gardener’s house. Nov do you think that two people
who were very much in a hurry would have gone down the right side of the
hedge, to reach a place which they could have gotten to much quicker on
the left side?”

“No, that would have been a fool thing to do.”

“And you are quite sure that these people were in a hurry?”

“That’s dead sure. I scarcely saw them before they’d gone again.”

“And you didn’t see them come back?”

“No, at least I didn’t pay any further attention to them. When I thought
it wouldn’t be any good to look about in there I turned around and dozed

“And it was during this dozing that you thought you heard the shot?”

“Yes, sir, that’s right.”

“And you didn’t notice anything else? You didn’t hear anything else.”

“No, nothin’ at all, there was so much noise anyway. There was a high
wind that night and the trees were rattling and creaking.”

“And you didn’t see anything else, anything that attracted your

“No, nothing--” Knoll did not finish his sentence, but began another
instead. He had suddenly remembered something which had seemed to him of
no importance before. “There was a light that went out suddenly.”


“In the side of the house that I could see from my place. There was a
lamp in the last window of the second story, a lamp with a red shade.
That lamp went out all at once.”

“Was the window open?”


“There was a strong wind that night, might not the wind have blown the
lamp out?”

“No, that wasn’t it,” said Knoll, rising hastily.

“Well, how was it?” asked Muller calmly.

“A hand put out the lamp.”

“Whose hand?”

“I couldn’t see that. The light was so low on account of the shade that
I couldn’t see the person who stood there.”

“And you don’t know whether it was a man or a woman?”

“No, I just saw a hand, more like a shadow it was.”

“Well, it doesn’t matter much anyway. It was after nine o’clock and many
people go to bed about that time,” said Muller, who did not see much
value in this incident.

But Knoll shook his head. “The person who put out that light didn’t go
to bed, at least not right away,” he said eagerly. “I looked over after
a while to the place where the red light was and I saw something else.”

“Well, what was it you saw?”

“The window had been closed.”

“Who closed it? Didn’t you see the person that time? The moonlight lay
full on the house.”

“Yes, when there weren’t any clouds. But there was a heavy cloud over
the moon just then and when it came out again the window was shut and
there was a white curtain drawn in front of it.”

“How could you see that?”

“I could see it when the lamp was lit again.”

“Then the lamp was lit again?”

“Yes, I could see the red light behind the curtain.”

“And what happened then?”

“Nothing more then, except that the man went through the garden.”

Muller rose now and took up his hat. He was evidently excited and Knoll
looked at him uneasily. “You’re goin’ already?” he asked.

“Yes, I have a great deal to do to-day,” replied the detective and
nodded to the prisoner as he knocked on the door. “I am glad you
remembered that,” he added, “it will be of use to us, I think.”

The warder opened the door, let Muller out, and the heavy iron portal
clanged again between Knoll and freedom.

Muller was quite satisfied with the result of his visit to the accused.
He hurried to the nearest cab stand and entered one of the carriages
waiting there. He gave the driver Mrs. Klingmayer’s address. It was
about two o’clock in the afternoon now and Muller had had nothing to eat
yet. But he was quite unaware of the fact as his mind was so busy that
no mere physical sensation could divert his attention for a moment.
Muller never seemed to need sleep or food when he was on the trail,
particularly not in the fascinating first stages of the case when it
was his imagination alone, catching at trifles unnoticed by others,
combining them in masterly fashion to an ordered whole, that first led
the seekers to the truth. Now he went over once more all the little
apparently trivial incidents that had caused him first to watch the
Thorne household and then had drawn his attention, and his suspicion, to
Adele Bernauer. It was the broken willow twig that had first drawn his
attention to the old garden next the Thorne property. This twig, this
garden, and perhaps some one who could reach his home again, unseen and
unendangered through this garden--might not this have something to do
with the murder?

The breaking of the twig was already explained. It was Johann Knoll
who had stepped on it. But he had not climbed the wall at all, had
only crept along it looking for a night’s shelter. And there was no
connection between Knoll and the people who lived in the Thorne house.
Muller had not the slightest doubt that the tramp had told the entire
truth that day and the day preceding.

Then the detective’s mind went back to the happenings of Tuesday
morning. The little twig had first drawn his attention to the Thorne
estate and the people who lived there. He had seen the departure of
the young couple and had passed the house again that afternoon and the
following day, drawn to it as if by a magnet. He had not been able
then to explain what it was that attracted him; there had been nothing
definite in his mind as he strolled past the old mansion. But his
repeated appearance had been noticed by some one--by one person
only--the housekeeper. Why should she have noticed it? Had she any
reason for believing that she might be watched? People with an uneasy
conscience are very apt to connect even perfectly natural trivial
circumstances with their own doings. Adele Bernauer had evidently
connected Muller’s repeated passing with something that concerned
herself even before the detective had thought of her at all.

Muller had not noticed her until he had seen her peculiar conduct that
very morning. When he heard Franz’s words and saw how disturbed the
woman was, he asked himself: “Why did this woman want to be shown the
spot of the murder? Didn’t she know that place, living so near it, as
well as any of the many who stood there staring in morbid curiosity?
Did she ask to have it shown her that the others might believe she had
nothing whatever to do with the occurrences that had happened there? Or
was she drawn thither by that queer attraction that brings the criminal
back to the scene of his crime?”

The sudden vision of Mrs. Bernauer’s head at the garden gate, and its
equally sudden disappearance had attracted Muller’s attention and his
thoughts to the woman. What he had been able to learn about her had
increased his suspicions and her involuntary exclamation when she met
him face to face in the house had proved beyond a doubt that there was
something on her mind. His open accusation, her demeanour, and finally
her swoon, were all links in the chain of evidence that this woman knew
something about the murder in the quiet lane.

With this suspicion in his mind what Muller had learned from Knoll
was of great value to him, at all events of great interest. Was it the
housekeeper who had put out the light? For now Muller did not doubt for
a moment that this sudden extinguishing of the lamp was a signal. He
believed that Knoll had seen clearly and that he had told truly what he
had seen. A lamp that is blown out by the wind flickers uneasily before
going out. A sudden extinguishing of the light means human agency. And
the lamp was lit again a few moments afterward and burned on steadily
as before. A short time after the lamp had been put out the man had been
seen going through the garden. And it could not have been much later
before the shot was heard. This shot had been fired between the hours
of nine and ten, for it was during this hour only that Knoll was in the
garden house and heard the shot. But it was not necessary to depend upon
the tramp’s evidence alone to determine the exact hour of the shot. It
must have been before half past nine, or otherwise the janitor of No.1,
who came home at that hour and lay awake so long, would undoubtedly
have heard a shot fired so near his domicile, in spite of the noise
occasioned by the high wind. There would have been sufficient time
for Mrs. Bernauer to have reached the place of the murder between the
putting out of the lamp and the firing of the shot. But perhaps she may
have rested quietly in her room; she may have been only the inciter or
the accomplice of the deed. But at all events, she knew something about
it, she was in some way connected with it.

Muller drew a deep breath. He felt much easier now that he had arranged
his thoughts and marshalled in orderly array all the facts he had
already gathered. There was nothing to do now but to follow up a given
path step by step and he could no longer reproach himself that he might
have cast suspicion on an innocent soul. No, his bearing towards Mrs.
Bernauer had not been sheer brutality. His instinct, which had led him
so unerringly so many times, had again shown him the right way when he
had thrust the accusation in her face.

Now that his mind was easier he realised that he was very hungry. He
drove to a restaurant and ordered a hasty meal.

“Beer, sir?” asked the waiter for the third time.

“No,” answered Muller, also for the third time.

“Then you’ll take wine, sir?” asked the insistent Ganymede.

“Oh, go to the devil! When I want anything I’ll ask for it,” growled the
detective, this time effectively scaring the waiter. It did not often
happen that a customer refused drinks, but then there were not many
customers who needed as clear a head as Muller knew he would have to
have to-day. Always a light drinker, it was one of his rules never to
touch a drop of liquor during this first stage of the mental working out
of any new problem which presented itself. But soft-hearted as he was,
he repented of his irritation a moment later and soothed the waiter’s
wounded feelings by a rich tip. The boy ran out to open the cab door for
his strange customer and looked after him, wondering whether the man was
a cranky millionaire or merely a poet. For Joseph Muller, by name and by
reputation one of the best known men in Vienna, was by sight unknown
to all except the few with whom he had to do on the police force. His
appearance, in every way inconspicuous, and the fact that he never
sought acquaintance with any one, was indeed of the greatest possible
assistance to him in his work. Many of those who saw him several times
in a day would pass him or look him full in the face without recognising
him. It was only, as in the case of Mrs. Bernauer, the guilty conscience
that remembered face and figure of this quiet-looking man who was one of
the most-feared servants of the law in Austria.


When Muller reached the house where Mrs. Klingmayer lived he ordered the
cabman to wait and hurried up to the widow’s little apartment. He had
the key to Leopold Winkler’s room in his own pocket, for Mrs. Klingmayer
had given this key to Commissioner von Riedau at the latter’s request
and the commissioner had given it to Muller. The detective told the good
woman not to bother about him as he wanted to make an examination of the
place alone. Left to himself in the little room, Muller made a thorough
search of it, opening the cupboard, the bureau drawers, every possible
receptacle where any article could be kept or hidden. What he wanted
to find was some letter, some bit of paper, some memoranda perhaps,
anything that would show any connection existing between the murdered
man and Mrs. Bernauer, who lived so near the place where this man had
died and who was so greatly interested in his murder.

The detective’s search was not quite in vain, although he could not tell
yet whether what he had found would be of any value. Leopold Winkler had
had very little correspondence, or else he had had no reason to keep
the letters he received. Muller found only about a half dozen letters in
all. Three of them were from women of the half-world, giving dates for
meetings. Another was written by a man and signed “Theo.” This “Theo”
 appeared to be the same sort of a cheap rounder that Winkler was. And he
seemed to have sunk one grade deeper than the dead man, in spite of the
latter’s bad reputation. For this other addressed Winkler as his
“Dear Friend” and pleaded with him for “greater discretion,” alluding
evidently to something which made this discretion necessary.

“I wonder what rascality it was that made these two friends?” murmured
Muller, putting Theo’s letter with the three he had already read.
But before he slipped it in his pocket he glanced at the postmark. The
letters of the three women had all been posted from different quarters
of the city some months ago. Theo’s letter was postmarked “Marburg,” and
dated on the 1st of September of the present year.

Then Muller looked at the postmark of the two remaining letters which
he had not yet read, and whistled softly to himself. Both these letters
were posted from a certain station in Hietzing, the station which was
nearest his own lodgings and also nearest the Thorne house. He looked at
the postmark more sharply. They both bore the dates of the present year,
one of them being stamped “March 17th,” the other “September 24th.” This
last letter interested the detective most.

Muller was not of a nervous disposition, but his hand trembled slightly
as he took the letter from its envelope. It was clear that this letter
had been torn open hastily, for the edges of the opening were jagged and

When the detective had read the letter--it contained but a few lines and
bore neither address nor signature--he glanced over it once more as if
to memorise the words. They were as follows: “Do not come again. In a
day or two I will be able to do what I have to do. I will send you later
news to your office. Impatience will not help you.”--These words were
written hastily on a piece of paper that looked as if it had been torn
from a pad. In spite of the haste the writer had been at some pains to
disguise the handwriting. But it was a clumsy disguise, done by one not
accustomed to such tricks, and it was evidently done by a woman. All she
had known how to do to disguise her writing had been to twist and turn
the paper while writing, so that every letter had a different position.
The letters were also made unusually long. This peculiarity of the
writing was seen on both letters and both envelopes. The earlier letter
was still shorter and seemed to have been written with the same haste,
and with the same disgust, or perhaps even hatred, for the man to whom
it was written.

“Come to-morrow, but not before eight o’clock. He has gone away. God
forgive him and you.” This was the contents of the letter of the 17th of
March. That is, the writer had penned the letter this way. But the last
two words, “and you,” had evidently not come from her heart, for she had
annulled them by a heavy stroke of the pen. A stroke that seemed like a
knife thrust, so full of rage and hate it was.

“So he was called to a rendezvous in Hietzing, too,” murmured Muller,
then he added after a few moments: “But this rendezvous had nothing
whatever to do with love.”

There was nothing else in Winkler’s room which could be of any value to
Muller in the problem that was now before him. And yet he was very well
satisfied with the result of his errand.

He entered his cab again, ordering the driver to take him to Hietzing.
Just before he had reached the corner where he had told the man to stop,
another cab passed them, a coupe, in which was a solitary woman. Muller
had just time enough to recognise this woman as Adele Bernauer, and to
see that she looked even more haggard and miserable than she had that
morning. She did not look up as the other cab passed her carriage,
therefore she did not see Muller. The detective looked at his watch and
saw that it was almost half-past four. The unexpected meeting changed,
his plans for the afternoon. He had decided that he must enter the
Thorne mansion again that very day, for he must find out the meaning of
the red-shaded lamp. And now that the housekeeper was away it would be
easier for him to get into the house, therefore it must be done at once.
His excuse was all ready, for he had been weighing possibilities.
He dismissed his cab a block from his own home and entered his house

Muller’s lodgings consisted of two large rooms, really much too large
for a lone man who was at home so little. But Muller had engaged them
at first sight, for the apartment possessed one qualification which was
absolutely necessary for him. Its situation and the arrangement of its
doors made it possible for him to enter and leave his rooms without
being seen either by his own landlady or by the other lodgers in the
house. The little apartment was on the ground floor, and Muller’s own
rooms had a separate entrance opening on to the main corridor almost
immediately behind the door. Nine times out of ten, he could come and go
without being seen by any one in the house. To-day was the first
time, however, that Muller had had occasion to try this particular
qualification of his new lodgings.

He opened the street door and slipped into his own room without having
seen or been seen by any one.

Fifteen minutes later he left the apartment again, but left it such a
changed man that nobody who had seen him go in would have recognised
him. Before he came out, however, he looked about carefully to see
whether there was any one in sight He came out unseen and was just
closing the main door behind him, when he met the janitress.

“Were you looking for anybody in the house?” said the woman, glancing
sharply at the stranger, who answered in a slightly veiled voice: “No,
I made a mistake in the number. The place I am looking for is two houses
further down.”

He walked down the street and the woman looked after him until she saw
him turn into the doorway of the second house. Then she went into her
own rooms. The house Muller entered happened to be a corner house with
an entrance on the other street, through which the detective passed
and went on his way. He was quite satisfied with the security of his
disguise, for the woman who knew him well had not recognised him at all.
If his own janitress did not know him, the people in the Thorne house
would never imagine it was he.

And indeed Muller was entirely changed. In actuality small and thin,
with sparse brown hair and smooth shaven face, he was now an inch or two
taller and very much stouter. He wore thick curly blond hair, a little
pointed blond beard and moustache. His eyes were hidden by heavy-rimmed

It was just half-past five when he rang the bell at the entrance gate to
the Thorne property. He had spent the intervening time in the cafe,
as he was in no hurry to enter the house. Franz came down the path and
opened the door. “‘What do you want?” he asked.

“I come from Siemens & Halske; I was to ask whether the other man--”

“Has been here already?” interrupted Franz, adding in an irritated tone,
“No, he hasn’t been here at all.”

“Well, I guess he didn’t get through at the other place in time. I’ll
see what the trouble is,” said the stranger, whom Franz naturally
supposed to be the electrician, he opened the gate and asked the other
to come in, leading him into the house. Under a cloudy sky the day
was fading rapidly. Muller knew that it would not occur to the real
electrician to begin any work as late as this, and that he was perfectly
safe in the examination he wanted to make.

“Well, what’s the trouble here? Why did you write to our firm?” asked
the supposed electrician.

“The wires must cross somewhere, or there’s something wrong with the
bells. When the housekeeper touches the button in her room to ring for
the cook or the upstairs girl, the bell rings in Mr. Thorne’s room. It
starts ringing and it keeps up with a deuce of a noise. Fortunately the
family are away.”

“Well, we’ll fix it all right for you. First of all I want to look at
the button in the housekeeper’s room.”

“I’ll take you up there,” said Franz.

They walked through the wide corridor, then turned into a shorter,
darker hall and went up a narrow winding stairway. Franz halted before
a door in the second story. It was the last of the three doors in
the hall. Muller took off his hat as the door opened and murmured a

“There’s no one there; Mrs. Bernauer’s out.”

“Has she gone away, too?” asked the electrician hastily.

Franz did not notice that there was a slight change in the stranger’s
voice at this question, and he answered calmly as ever: “Oh, no; she’s
just driven to town. I think she went to see the doctor who lives quite
a distance away. She hasn’t been feeling at all well. She took a cab
to-day. I told her she ought to, as she wasn’t well enough to go by the
tram. She ought to be home any moment now.”

“Well, I’ll hurry up with the job so that I’ll be out of the way when
the lady comes,” said Muller, as Franz led him to the misbehaving bell.

It was in the wall immediately above a large table which filled the
window niche so completely that there was but scant space left for the
comfortable armchair that stood in front of it. The window was open and
Muller leaned out, looking down at the garden below.

“What a fine old garden!” he exclaimed aloud. To himself he said: “This
is the last window in the left wing. It is the window where Johann Knoll
saw the red light.”

And when he turned back into the room again he found the source of this
light right at his hand on the handsome old table at which Mrs. Bernauer
evidently spent many of her hours. A row of books stood against the
wall, framing the back of the table. Well-worn volumes of the classics
among them gave proof that the one-time nurse was a woman of education.
A sewing basket and neat piles of house linen, awaiting repairs, covered
a large part of the table-top, and beside them stood a gracefully shaped
lamp, covered by a shade of soft red silk.

It took Muller but a few seconds to see all this. Then he set about
his investigation of the electric button. He unscrewed the plate and
examined the wires meeting under it. While doing so he cast another
glance at the table and saw a letter lying there, an open letter half
out of its envelope. This envelope was of unusual shape, long and
narrow, and the paper was heavy and high-glossed.

“Your housekeeper evidently has no secrets from the rest of you,” Muller
remarked with a laugh, still busy at the wires, “or she wouldn’t leave
her letters lying about like that.”

“Oh, we’ve all heard what’s in that letter,” replied Franz. “She read it
to us when it came this morning. It’s from the Madam. She sent messages
to all of us and orders, so Mrs. Bernauer read us the whole letter.
There’s no secrets in that.”

“The button has been pressed in too far and caught down. That seems to
be the main trouble,” said Muller, readjusting the little knob. “I’d
like a candle here if I may have one.”

“I’ll get you a light at once,” said Franz. But his intentions, however
excellent, seemed difficult of fulfilment. It was rapidly growing dark,
and the old butler peered about uncertainly. “Stupid,” he muttered. “I
don’t know where she keeps the matches. I can’t find them anywhere. I’m
not a smoker, so I haven’t any in my pocket.”

“Nor I,” said Muller calmly, letting his hand close protectingly over a
new full box of them in his own pocket.

“I’ll get you some from my own room,” and Franz hurried away, his loose
slippers clattering down the stairs. He was no sooner well out of the
room than Muller had the letter in his hand and was standing close by
the window to catch the fading light. But on the old servant’s return
the supposed electrician stood calmly awaiting the coming of the light,
and the letter was back on the table half hidden by a piece of linen.
Franz did not notice that the envelope was missing. And the housekeeper,
whose mind was so upset by the events of the day, and whose thoughts
were on other more absorbing matters, would hardly be likely to remember
whether she had returned this quite unimportant letter to its envelope
or not.

Franz brought a lighted candle with him, and Muller, who really did
possess a creditable knowledge of electricity, saw that the wires in
the room were all in good condition. As he had seen at first, there was
really nothing the matter except with the position of the button. But it
did not suit his purpose to enlighten Franz on the matter just yet.

“Now I’d better look at the wires in the gentleman’s room,” he said,
when he had returned plate and button to their place.

“Just as you say,” replied Franz, taking up his candle and leading the
way out into the hall and down the winding stair. They crossed the lower
corridor, mounted another staircase and entered a large, handsomely
furnished room, half studio, half library. The wall was covered with
pictures and sketches, several easels stood piled up in the corner, and
a broad table beside them held paint boxes, colour tubes, brushes, all
the paraphernalia of the painter, now carefully ordered and covered for
a term of idleness. Great bookcases towered to the ceiling, and a huge
flat top desk, a costly piece of furniture, was covered with books and
papers. It was the room of a man of brains and breeding, a man of talent
and ability, possessing, furthermore, the means to indulge his tastes
freely. Even now, with its master absent, the handsome apartment bore
the impress of his personality. The detective’s quick imagination called
up the attractive, sympathetic figure of the man he had seen at the
gate, as his quick eye took in the details of the room. All the charm of
Herbert Thorne’s personality, which the keen-sensed Muller had felt so
strongly even in that fleeting glimpse of him, came back again here
in the room which was his own little kingdom and the expression of his

“Well, what’s the trouble here? Where are the wires?” asked the
detective, after the momentary pause which had followed his entrance
into the room. Franz led him to a spot on the wall hidden by a marquetry
cabinet. “Here’s the bell, it rings for several minutes before it

The light of the candle which the butler held fell upon a portrait
hanging above the cabinet. It was a sketch in water-colours, the
life-sized head of a man who may have been about thirty years old,
perhaps, but who had none of the freshness and vigour of youth. The
scanty hair, the sunken temples, and the faded skin, emphasised the look
of dissipation given by the lines about the sensual mouth and the shifty

“Well, say, can’t your master find anything better to paint than a face
like that?” Muller asked with a laugh.

“Goodness me! you mustn’t say such things!” exclaimed Franz in alarm;
“that’s the Madam’s brother. He’s an officer, I’d have you know. It’s
true, he doesn’t look like much there, but that’s because he’s not in
uniform. It makes such a difference.”

“Is the lady anything like her brother?” asked the detective
indifferently, bending to examine the wiring.

“Oh, dear, no, not a bit; they’re as different as day and night. He’s
only her half-brother anyway. She was the daughter of the Colonel’s
second wife. Our Madam is the sweetest, gentlest lady you can imagine,
an angel of goodness. But the Lieutenant here has always been a care
to his family, they say. I guess he’s quieted down a bit now, for his
father--he’s Colonel Leining, retired--made him get exchanged from the
city to a small garrison town. There’s nothing much to do in Marburg,
I dare say--well! you are a merry sort, aren’t you?” These last words,
spoken in a tone of surprise, were called forth by a sudden sharp
whistle from the detective, a whistle which went off into a few merry

A sudden whistle like that from Muller’s lips was something that made
the Imperial Police Force sit up and take notice, for it meant that
things were happening, and that the happenings were likely to become
exciting. It was a habit he could control only by the severest effort of
the will, an effort which he kept for occasions when it was absolutely
necessary. Here, alone with the harmless old man, he was not so much
on his guard, and the sudden vibrating of every nerve at the word
“Marburg,” found vent in the whistle which surprised old Franz. One
young police commissioner with a fancy for metaphor had likened this
sudden involuntary whistle of Muller’s to the bay of the hound when he
strikes the trail; which was about what it was.

“Yes, I am merry sometimes,” he said with a laugh. “It’s a habit I have.
Something occurred to me just then, something I had forgotten. Hope you
don’t mind.”

“Oh, no, there’s no one here now, whistle all you like.”

But Muller’s whistle was not a continuous performance, and he had now
completely mastered the excitation of his nerves which had called it
forth. He threw another sharp look at the picture of the man who lived
in Marburg, and then asked: “And now where is the button?”

“By the window there, beside the desk.” Franz led the way with his

“Why, how funny! What are those mirrors there for?” asked the
electrician in a tone of surprise, pointing to two small mirrors hanging
in the window niche. They were placed at a height and at such a peculiar
angle that no one could possibly see his face in them.

“Something the master is experimenting with, I guess. He’s always making
queer experiments; he knows a lot about scientific things.”

Muller shook his head as if in wonderment, and bent to investigate the
button which was fastened into the wall beneath the window sill. His
quick ear heard a carriage stopping in front of the house, and heard the
closing of the front door a moment later. To facilitate his examination
of the button, the detective had seated himself in the armchair which
stood beside the desk. He half raised himself now to let the light
of the candle fall more clearly on the wiring--then he started up
altogether and threw a hasty glance at the mirrors above his head. A ray
of light had suddenly flashed down upon him--a ray of red light, and it
came reflected from the mirrors. Muller bit his lips to keep back the
betraying whistle.

“What’s the matter?” asked the butler. “Did you drop anything?”

“Yes, the wooden rim of the button,” replied Muller, telling the truth
this time. For he had held the little wooden circlet in his hands at the
moment when the red light, reflected down from the mirrors, struck full
upon his eyes. He had dropped it in his surprise and excitement. Franz
found the little ring in the centre of the room where it had rolled,
and the supposed electrician replaced it and rose to his feet, saying:
“There, I’ve finished now.”

Franz did not recognise the double meaning in the words. “Yes, it’s all
right! I’ve finished here now,” Muller repeated to himself. For now he
knew beyond a doubt that the red light was a signal--and he knew
also for whom this signal was intended. It was a signal for Herbert
Thorne!--Herbert Thorne, whom no single thought or suspicion of Muller’s
had yet connected with the murder of Leopold Winkler.

The detective was very much surprised and greatly excited. But Franz did
not notice it, and indeed a far keener observer than the slow-witted old
butler might have failed to see the sudden gleam which shot up in the
grey eyes behind the heavy spectacles, might have failed to notice the
tightening of the lips beneath the blond moustache, or the tenseness of
the slight frame under the assumed embonpoint. Muller’s every nerve was
tingling, but he had himself completely in hand.

“What do we owe you?” asked Franz.

“They’ll send you a bill from the office. It won’t amount to much. I
must be getting on now.”

Muller hastened out of the door and down the street to the nearest cab
stand. There were not very many cab stands in this vicinity, and the
detective reasoned that Mrs. Bernauer would naturally have taken her
cab from the nearest station. He had heard her return in her carriage,
presumably the same in which she had started out.

There was but one cab at the stand. Muller walked to it and laid his
hand on the door.

“Oh, Jimmy! must I go out again?” asked the driver hoarsely. “Can’t you
see the poor beast is all wet from the last ride? We’ve just come in.”
 He pointed with his whip to the tired-looking animal under his blanket.

“Why, he does look warm. You must have been making a tour out into the
country,” said the blond gentleman in a friendly tone.

“No, sir, not quite so far as that. I’ve just taken a woman to the main
telegraph office in the city and back again. But she was in a hurry and
he’s not a young horse, sir.”

“Well, never mind, then; I can get another cab across the bridge,”
 replied the stout blond man, turning away and strolling off leisurely
in the direction of the bridge. It was now quite dark, and a few
steps further on Muller could safely turn and take the road to his own
lodging. No one saw him go in, and in a few moments the real Muller,
slight, smooth-shaven, sat down at his desk, looking at the papers that
lay before him. They were three letters and an empty envelope.

He took up the last, and compared it carefully with the envelope of one
of the letters found in Winkler’s room--the unsigned letter postmarked
Hietzing, September 24th. The two envelopes were exactly alike. They
were of the same size and shape, made of the same cream-tinted, heavy,
glossy paper, and the address was written by the same hand. This any
keen observer, who need not necessarily be an expert, could see. The
same hand which had addressed the envelope to Mrs. Adele Bernauer on
the letter which was postmarked “Venice,” about thirty-six hours
previous--this hand had, in an awkward and childish attempt at disguise,
written Winkler’s address on the envelope which bore the date of
September 24th.

The writer of the harmless letter to Mrs. Bernauer, a letter which
chatted of household topics and touched lightly on the beauties of
Venice, was Mrs. Thorne. It was Mrs. Thorne, therefore, who, reluctantly
and in anger and distaste, had called Leopold Winkler to Hietzing, to
his death.

And whose hand had fired the shot that caused his death? The question,
at this stage in Muller’s meditation, could hardly be called a question
any more. It was all too sadly clear to him now. Winkler met his death
at the hand of the husband, who, discovering the planned rendezvous, had
misunderstood its motive.

For truly this had been no lovers’ meeting. It had been a meeting to
which the woman was driven by fear and hate; the man by greed of gain.
This was clearly proved by the 300 guldens found in the dead man’s
pocket, money enclosed in a delicate little envelope, sealed hastily,
and crumpled as if it had been carried in a hot and trembling hand.

It was already known that Winkler never had any money except at certain
irregular intervals, when he appeared to have come into possession
of considerable sums. During these days he indulged in extravagant
pleasures and spent his money with a recklessness which proved that he
had not earned it by honest work.

Leopold Winkler was a blackmailer.

Colonel Leining, retired, the father of two such widely different
children, was doubtless a man of stern principles, and an army officer
as well, therefore a man with a doubly sensitive code of honour and a
social position to maintain; and this man, morbidly sensitive probably,
had a daughter who had inherited his sensitiveness and his high ideals
of honour, a daughter married to a rich husband. But he had another
child, a son without any sense of honour at all, who, although also an
officer, failed to live in a manner worthy his position. This son was
now in Marburg, where there were no expensive pleasures, no all-night
cafes and gambling dens, for a man to lose his time in, his money, and
his honour also.

For such must have been the case with Colonel Leining’s son before his
exile to Marburg. The old butler had hinted at the truth. The portrait
drawn by Herbert Thorne, a picture of such technical excellence that it
was doubtless a good likeness also, had given an ugly illustration to
Franz’s remarks. And there was something even more tangible to prove it:
“Theo’s” letter from Marburg pleading with Winkler for “discretion and
silence,” not knowing (“let us hope he did not know!” murmured Muller
between set teeth) that the man who held him in his power because of
some rascality, was being paid for his silence by the Lieutenant’s

It is easy to frighten a sensitive woman, so easy to make her believe
the worst! And there is little such a tender-hearted woman will not do
to save her aging father from pain and sorrow, perhaps even disgrace!

It must have been in this way that Mrs. Thorne came into the power of
the scoundrel who paid with his life for his last attempt at blackmail.

When Muller reached this point in his chain of thought, he closed his
eyes and covered his face with his hands, letting two pictures stand out
clear before his mental vision.

He saw the little anxious group around the carriage in front of the
Thorne mansion. He saw the pale, frail woman leaning back on the
cushions, and the husband bending over her in tender care. And then he
saw Johann Knoll in his cell, a man with little manhood left in him, a
man sunk to the level of the brutes, a man who had already committed
one crime against society, and who could never rise to the mental or
spiritual standard of even the most mediocre of decent citizens.

If Herbert Thorne were to suffer the just punishment for his deed of
doubly blind jealousy, then it was not only his own life, a life full
of gracious promise, that would be ruined, but the happiness of his
delicate, sweet-faced wife, who was doubtless still in blessed ignorance
of what had happened. And still one other would be dragged down by this
tragedy; a respected, upright man would bow his white hairs in disgrace.
Thorne’s father-in-law could not escape the scandal and his own share
in the responsibility for it. And to a veteran officer, bred in the
exaggerated social ethics of his profession, such a disgrace means ruin,
sometimes even voluntary death.

“Oh, dear, if it had only been Knoll who did it,” said Muller with a
sigh that was almost a groan.

Then he rose slowly and heavily, and slowly and heavily, as if borne
down by the weight of great weariness, he reached for his hat and coat
and left the house.

Whether he wished it or not, he knew it was his duty to go on to the
bitter end on this trail he had followed up all day from the moment that
he caught that fleeting glimpse of Mrs. Bernauer’s haggard face at the
garden gate. He was almost angry with the woman, because she chanced to
look out of the gate at just that moment, showing him her face distorted
with anxiety. For it was her face that had drawn Muller to the trail, a
trail at the end of which misery awaited those for whom this woman had
worked for years, those whom she loved and who treated her as one of the

Muller knew now that the one-time nurse was in league with her former
charge; that Thorne and Adele Bernauer were in each other’s confidence;
that the man sat waiting for the signal which she was to give him, a
signal bringing so much disgrace and sorrow in its train.

If the woman had not spied upon and betrayed her mistress, this terrible
event, which now weighed upon her own soul, would not have happened.

“A faithful servant, indeed,” said Muller, with a harsh laugh.

Then maturer consideration came and forced him to acknowledge that it
was indeed devotion that had swayed Adele Bernauer, devotion to her
master more than to her mistress. This was hardly to be wondered at. But
she had not thought what might come from her revelations, what had come
of them. For now her pet, the baby who had once lain in her arms, the
handsome, gifted man whom she adored with more than the love of many a
mother for the child of her own blood, was under the shadow of hideous
disgrace and doom, was the just prey of the law for open trial and
condemnation as a murderer.

Muller sighed deeply once more and then came one of those moments
which he had spoken of to the unhappy woman that very day. He felt like
cursing the fatal gift that was his, the gift to see what was hidden
from others, this something within him that forced him relentlessly
onward until he had uncovered the truth, and brought misery to many.

Muller need not do anything, he need simply do nothing. Not a soul
besides himself suspected the dwellers in the Thorne mansion of any
connection with the murder. If he were silent, nothing could be proven
against Knoll after all, except the robbery which he himself had
confessed. Then the memory of the terror in the tramp’s little reddened
eyes came back to the detective’s mind.

“A human soul after all, and a soul trembling in the shadow of a great
fear. And even he’s a better man than the blackmailer who was killed. A
miscarriage of justice will often make a criminal of a poor fellow whose
worst fault is idleness.” Muller’s face darkened as the things of the
past, shut down in the depths of his own soul, rose up again. “No;
that’s why I took up this work. Justice must be done--but it’s bitter
hard sometimes. I could almost wish now that I hadn’t seen that face at
the gate.”


It was striking eight as Muller came out of a cafe in the heart of the
city. He had been in there but a few moments, for his purpose was merely
to look through the Army lists of the current year. The result of his
search proved the correctness of his conclusions.

There was a Lieutenant Theobald Leining in the single infantry regiment
stationed at Marburg.

Muller took a cab and drove to the main telegraph office. He asked for
the original of the telegram which had been sent that afternoon to the
address; “Herbert Thorne, Hotel Danieli, Venice.” This closed the circle
of the chain.

The detective re-entered his waiting cab and drove back to Hietzing. He
told the driver to halt at the corner of the street on which fronted the
Thorne mansion and to wait for him there. He himself walked slowly down
the quiet Street and rang the bell at the iron gate.

“You come to this house again?” asked Franz, starting back in alarm when
he saw who it was that had called him to the door.

“Yes, my good friend; I want to get into this house again. But not on
false pretenses this time. And before you let me in you can go upstairs
and ask Mrs. Bernauer if she will receive me in her own room--in her own
room, mind. But make haste; I am in a hurry.” The detective’s tone was
calm and he strolled slowly up and down in front of the gate when he had
finished speaking.

The old butler hesitated a moment, then walked into the house. When he
returned, rather more quickly, he looked alarmed and his tone was very
humble as he asked Muller to follow him.

When the detective entered Mrs. Bernauer’s room the housekeeper rose
slowly from the large armchair in front of her table. She was very pale
and her eyes were full of terror. She made no move to speak, so Muller
began the conversation. He put down his hat, brought up a chair and
placed it near the window at which the housekeeper had been sitting.
Then he sat down and motioned to her to do the same.

“You are a faithful servant, all too faithful,” he began. “But you are
faithful only to your master. You have no devotion for his wife.”

“You are mistaken,” replied the woman in a low tone.

“Perhaps, but I do not think so. One does not betray the people to whom
one is devoted.”

Mrs. Bernauer looked up in surprise. “What--what do you know?” she

Muller did not answer the question directly, but continued: “Mrs.
Thorne had a meeting recently with a strange man. It was not their first
meeting, and somehow you discovered it. But before this last meeting
occurred you spoke to the lady’s husband about it, and it was arranged
between you that you should give him a signal which would mean to him,
‘Your wife is going to the meeting.’ Mrs. Thorne did go to the meeting.
This happened on Monday evening at about quarter past nine. Some one,
who was in the neighbourhood by chance, saw a woman’s figure hurrying
through the garden, down to the other street, and a moment after this,
the light of this lamp in your window was seen to go out. A hand had
turned down the wick--it was your hand.

“This was the signal to Mr. Thorne. The mirrors over his desk reflected
in his eyes the light he could not otherwise have seen as he sat by his
own window. The signal, therefore, told him that the time had come to
act. This same chance watcher, who had seen the woman going through the
garden, had seen the lamp go out, and now saw a man’s figure hurrying
down the path the woman had taken. The man as well as the woman came
from this house and went in the direction of the lower end of the

“A little while later a shot was heard, and the next morning Leopold
Winkler was found with a bullet in his back. The crime was generally
taken to be a murder for the sake of robbery. But you and I, and Mr.
Herbert Thorne, know very well that it was not.

“You know this since Wednesday noon. Then it was that the idea suddenly
came to you, falling like a heavy weight on your soul, the idea that
Winkler might not have been killed for the sake of robbery, but because
of the hatred that some one bore him. Then it was that you lost your
appetite suddenly, that you drove into the city with the excuse of
errands to do, in order to read the papers without being seen by any
one who knew you. When you came home you searched everywhere in your
master’s room: you made an excuse for this search, but what you wanted
to find out was whether he had left anything that could betray him. Your
fright had already confused your mind. You were searching probably for
the weapon from which he had fired the bullet. You did not realise that
he would naturally have taken it with him and thrown it somewhere into
a ravine or river beside the railway track between here and Venice. How
could you think for a moment that he would leave it behind him, here in
his room, or dropped in the garden? But this was doubtless due to the
confusion owing to your sudden alarm and anxiety--a confusion which
prevented you from realising the danger of the two peculiarly hung
mirrors in Mr. Thorne’s room. These should have been taken away at once.
This morning my sudden appearance at the garden gate prevented you from
making an examination of the place of the murder. Your swoon, after I
had spoken to you in the butler’s room, showed me that you were carrying
a burden too heavy for your strength. Finally, this afternoon, you drove
to the main telegraph office in the city, as you thought that it would
be safer to telegraph Mr. Thorne from there. Your telegram was very
cleverly written. But you might have spared the last sentence, the
request that Mr. Thorne should get the Viennese papers of these last
days. Believe me, he has already read these papers. Who could be more
interested in what they have to tell than he?”

The housekeeper had sat as if frozen to stone during Muller’s long
speech. Her face was ashen and her eyes wild with horror. When the
detective ceased speaking, there was dead silence in the room for some
time. Finally Muller asked: “Is this what happened?” His voice was
cutting and the glance of his eyes keen and sharp.

Mrs. Bernauer trembled. Her head sank on her breast. Muller waited a
moment more and then he said quietly: “Then it is true.”

“Yes, it is true,” came the answer in a low hoarse tone.

Again there was silence for an appreciable interval.

“If you had been faithful to your mistress as well, if you had not
spied upon her and betrayed her to her husband, all this might not have
happened,” continued the detective pitilessly, adding with a bitter
smile: “And it was not even a case of sinful love. Your mistress had
no such relations with this Winkler as you--I say this to excuse
you--seemed to believe.”

Adele Bernauer sprang up. “I do not need this excuse,” she cried,
trembling in excitement. “I do not need any excuse. What I have done
I did after due consideration and in the realisation that it was
absolutely necessary to do it. Never for one moment did I believe that
my mistress was untrue to her husband. Never for one moment could I
believe such an evil thing of her, for I knew her to be an angel of
goodness. A woman who is deceiving her husband is not as unhappy as this
poor lady has been for months. A woman does not write to a successful
lover with so much sorrow, with so many tears. I had long suspected
these meetings before I discovered them, but I knew that these meetings
had nothing whatever to do with love. Because I knew this, and only
because I knew it, did I tell my master about them. I wanted him to
protect his wife, to free her from the wretch who had obtained some
power over her, I knew not how.”

“Ah! then that was it?” exclaimed Muller, and his eyes softened as he
looked at the sobbing woman who had sunk back into her chair. He laid
his hand on her cold fingers and continued gently: “Then you have really
done right, you have done only what was your duty. I pity you deeply
that you--”

“That I have brought suspicion upon my master by my own foolishness?”
 she finished the sentence with a pitifully sad smile. “If I could have
controlled myself, could have kept calm, nobody would have had a thought
or a suspicion that he--my pet, my darling--that it was he who was
forced, through some terrible circumstance of which I do not know, to
free his wife, in this manner, from the wretch who persecuted her.”

Mrs. Bernauer wrung her hands and gazed with despairing eyes at the man
who sat before her, himself deeply moved.

Again there was a long silence. Muller could not find a word to comfort
the weeping woman. There was no longer anger in his heart, nothing but
the deepest pity. He took out his handkerchief and wiped away the drops
that were dimming his own eyes.

“You know that I will have to go to Venice?” he asked.

Mrs. Bernauer sprang up. “Officially?” she gasped, pale to her lips.

He nodded. “Yes, officially of course. I must make a report at once to
headquarters about what I have learned. You can imagine yourself what
the next steps will be.”

Her deep sigh showed him that she knew as well as he. In the same
second, however, a thought shot through her brain, changing her whole
being. Her pale face glowed, her dulled eyes shot fire, and the fingers
with which she held Muller’s hand tightly clasped, were suddenly
feverishly hot.

“And you--you are still the only person who knows the truth?” she gasped
in his ear.

The detective nodded. “And you thought you might silence me?” he asked
calmly. “That will not be easy--for you can imagine that I did not come

Adele Bernauer smiled sadly. “I would take even this way to save Herbert
Thorne from disgrace, if I thought that it could be successful, and if
I had not thought of a milder way to silence a man who cannot be a
millionaire. I have served in this house for thirty-two years, I have
been treated with such generosity that I have been able to save almost
every cent of my wages for my old age. With the interest that has rolled
up, my little fortune must amount to nearly eight thousand gulden. I
will gladly give it to you, if you will but keep silence, if you will
not tell what you have discovered.” She spoke gaspingly and sank down on
her knees before she had finished.

“And Mr. Thorne also--” she continued hastily, as she saw no sign of
interest in Muller’s calm face. Then her voice failed her.

The detective looked down kindly on her grey hairs and answered: “No,
no, my good woman; that won’t do. One cannot conceal one crime by
committing another. I myself would naturally not listen to your
suggestion for a moment, but I am also convinced that Mr. Thorne, to
whom you are so devoted, and who, I acknowledge, pleased me the very
first sight I had of him--I am convinced that he would not agree for a
moment to any such solution of the problem.”

“Then I can only hope that you will not find him in Venice,” replied
Mrs. Bernauer, with utter despair in her voice and eyes.

“I am not at all certain that I will find him in Venice when I leave
here to-morrow morning,” said Muller calmly.

“Oh! then you don’t want to find him! Oh God! how good, how
inexpressibly good you are,” stammered the woman, seizing at some vague
hope in her distraught heart.

“No, you are mistaken again, Mrs. Bernauer. I will find Mr. Thorne
wherever he may be. But I may arrive in Venice too late to meet him
there. He may already be on his way home.”

“On his way home?” cried the housekeeper in terror, staggering where she

Muller led her gently to a chair. “Sit down here and listen to me
calmly. This is what I mean. If Mr. Thorne has seen in the papers that a
man has been arrested and accused of the murder of Leopold Winkler, then
he will take the next train back and give himself up to the authorities.
That he makes no such move as long as he thinks there is no suspicion
on any one else, no possibility that any one else could suffer the
consequences of his deed--is quite comprehensible--it is only natural
and human.”

Adele Bernauer sighed deeply again and heavy tears ran down her cheeks,
in strange contrast to the ghost of a smile that parted her lips and
shone in her dimmed eyes.

“You know him better than I do,” she murmured almost inaudibly, “you
know him better than I do, and I have known him for so long.”

A moment later Muller had parted from the housekeeper with a warm,
sincere pressure of the hand.

“Lieutenant Theobald Leining was here on a visit to his sister last
March, wasn’t he?” the detective asked as Franz led him out of the gate.

“Yes, sir; the Lieutenant was here just about that time,” answered the
old man.

“And he left here on the 16th of March?”

“On the 16th? Why, it may have been--yes, it was the 16th--that is our
lady’s birthday. He went away that day.” Franz bowed a farewell to this
stranger who began to appear uncanny in his eyes, and shutting the gate
carefully he returned to the house.

“What does the man want anyway?” he murmured to himself, shivering
involuntarily. Without knowing why he turned his steps towards Mrs.
Bernauer’s room. He opened the door hesitatingly as if afraid of what he
might see there. He would not have been at all surprised if he had found
the housekeeper fainting on the floor as before.

But she was not fainting this time. She was very much alive, for, to
Franz’s great astonishment, she was busied at the packing of a valise.

“Are you going away too?” asked Franz. Mrs. Bernauer answered in a voice
that was dull with weariness: “Yes, Franz, I am going away. Will you
please look up the time-tables of the Southern railroad and let me know
when the morning express leaves? And please order a cab in time for it.
I will depend upon you to look after the house in my absence. You
can imagine that it must be something very important that takes me to

“To Venice? Why, what are you going to Venice for?”

“Never mind about that, Franz, but help me to pray that I may get there
in time.”

She almost pushed the old man out of the door with these last words and
shut and locked it behind him.

She wanted to be alone with this hideous fear that was clutching at her
heart. For it was not to Franz that she could tell the thoughts that
came to her lips now as she sank down, wringing her hands, before a
picture of the Madonna: “Oh Holy Virgin, Mother of our Lord, plead for
me! let me be with my dear mistress when the terrible time comes
and they take her husband away from her, or, if preferring death to
disgrace, he ends his life by his own hand!”


Commissioner Von Riedau sat at his desk late that evening, finishing
up some important papers. The quiet of an undisturbed night watch had
settled down on the busy police station. An occasional low murmur of
whispering voices floated up from the guardroom below, but otherwise the
stillness was broken only by the scratching of the commissioner’s pen
and the rustle of the paper as he turned the leaves. It was a silence so
complete that a light step on the stair outside and the gentle turning
of the doorknob was heard distinctly and the commissioner looked up with
almost a start to see who was coming to his room so late. Joseph Muller
stood in the open door, awaiting his chief’s official recognition.

“Oh! it’s you, Muller. So late? Come in. Anything new?” asked the
commissioner. “Have you succeeded in drawing a confession from that
stubborn tramp yet? You’ve been interviewing him, I take it?”

“Yes, I had a long talk with Johann Knoll to-day.”

“Well, that ought to help matters along. Has he confessed? What could
you get out of him?”

“Nothing, or almost nothing more than he told us here in the station,

“The man’s incredibly stubborn,” said the commissioner. “If he could
only be made to understand that a free confession would benefit him more
than any one else! Well, don’t look so down-cast about it, Muller. This
thing is going to take longer than we thought at first for such a simple
affair. But it’s only a question of time until the man comes to his
senses. You’ll get him to talk soon. You always do. And even if you
should fail here, this matter is not so very important, when we think of
all the other things you have done.” Muller, standing front of the desk,
shook his head sadly.

“But I haven’t failed here, sir. More’s the pity, I had almost said.”

“What!” The commissioner looked up in surprise. “I thought you just said
that you couldn’t get anything more out of the accused.”

“Knoll has told us all he knows, sir. He did not murder Leopold

“Hmph!” The commissioner’s exclamation had a touch of acidity in it.
“Then, if he didn’t murder him, who did?”

“Herbert Thorne, painter, living in the Thorne mansion in B. Street,
Hietzing, now in Venice, Hotel Danieli. I ask for a warrant for his
arrest, sir, and orders to start for Venice on the early morning express

“Muller!... what the deuce does all this mean?” The commissioner sprang
up, his face flushing deeply as he leaned over the desk staring at the
sad quiet face of the little man opposite. “What are you talking about?
What does all this mean?”

“It means, sir, that we now know who committed the murder in Hietzing.
Johann Knoll is innocent of anything more than the theft confessed by
himself. He took the purse and watch from the senseless form of the just
murdered man. The body was warm and still supple and the tramp supposed
the victim to be merely intoxicated. His story was in every respect
true, sir.”

The commissioner flushed still deeper. “And who do you say murdered this

“Herbert Thorne, sir.

“But Thorne! I know of him... have even a slight personal acquaintance
with him. Thorne is a rich man, of excellent family. Why should he
murder and rob an obscure clerk like this Winkler?”

“He did not rob him sir, Knoll did that.”

“Oh, yes. But why should Thorne commit murder on this man who scarcely
touched his life at any point... It’s incredible! Muller! Muller! are
you sure you are not letting your imagination run away with you again?
It is a serious thing to make such an accusation against any man, much
less against a man in Thorne’s position. Are you sure of what you are
saying?” The commissioner’s excitement rendered him almost inarticulate.
The shock of the surprise occasioned by the detective’s words produced a
feeling of irritation... a phenomenon not unusual in the minds of worthy
but pedantic men of affairs when confronted by a startling new thought.

“I am quite sure of what I am saying, sir. I have just heard the
confession of one who might be called an accomplice of the murderer.”

“It is incredible... incredible! An accomplice you say?... who is
this accomplice? Might it not be some one who has a grudge against
Thorne--some one who is trying to purposely mislead you?”

“I am not so easily deceived or misled, sir. Every evidence points to
Thorne, and the confession I have just heard was made by a woman who
loves him, who has loved and cared for him from his babyhood. There is
not the slightest doubt of it, sir.”

Muller moved a step nearer the desk, gazing firmly in the eyes of the
excited commissioner. The sadness on the detective’s face had given way
to a gleam of pride that flushed his sallow cheek and brightened his
grey eyes. It was one of those rare moments when Muller allowed
himself a feeling of triumph in his own power, in spite of official
subordination and years of habit. His slight frame seemed to grow taller
and broader as he faced the Chief with an air of quiet determination
that made him at once master of the situation. His voice was as low as
ever but it took on a keen incisive note that compelled attention, as he
continued: “Herbert Thorne is the murderer of Leopold Winkler. Now that
he knows an innocent man is under accusation for his deed it is only
a question of time before he will come himself to confess. He will
doubtless make this confession to me, if I go to Venice to see him, and
to bring him back to trial.”

The commissioner could doubt no longer. Pedantic though he was,
Commissioner von Riedau possessed sufficient insight to know the truth
when it was presented to him with such conviction, and also sufficient
insight to have recognised the gifts of the man before him. “But why...
why?” he murmured, sinking back into his chair, and shaking his head in

“Winkler was a miserable scoundrel, sir, a blackmailer. Thorne did only
what any decent man would have felt like doing in his place. But justice
must be done.”

Muller’s elation vanished and a deep sigh welled up from his heart. The
commissioner nodded slowly, and glanced across the desk almost timidly.
This case had appeared to be so simple, and suddenly the hidden deeps
of a dark mystery had opened before him, deeps already sounded by
the little man here who had gone so quietly about his work while the
official police, represented in this case by Commissioner von Riedau
himself, had sat calmly waiting for an innocent man to confess to a
crime he had not committed! It was humiliating. The commissioner flushed
again and his eyes sank to the floor.

“Tell me what you know, Muller,” he said finally.

Muller told the story of his experiences in the Thorne mansion, told of
the slight clues which led him to take an interest in the house and its
inmates, until finally the truth began to glimmer up out of the depths.
The commissioner listened with eager interest. “Then you believed this
elaborate yarn told by the tramp?” he interrupted once, at the beginning
of the narrative.

“Why, yes, sir, just because it was so elaborate. A man like Knoll would
not have had the mind to invent such a story. It must have been true, on
the face of it.”

The commissioner’s eyes sank again, and he did not speak until the
detective had reached the end of his story. Then he opened a drawer in
his desk and took out a bundle of official blank-forms.

“It is wonderful! Wonderful! Muller, this case will go on record as one
of your finest achievements--and we thought it was so simple.”

“Oh, indeed, sir, chance favoured me at every turn,” replied Muller

“There is no such thing as chance,” said the commissioner. “We might as
well be honest with ourselves. Any one might have seen, doubtless
did see, all the things you saw, but no one else had the insight
to recognise their value, nor the skill to follow them up to such a
conclusion. But it’s a sad case, a sad case. I never wrote a warrant
with a heavier heart. Thorne is a true-hearted gentleman, while the
scoundrel he killed...”

“Yes, sir, I feel that way about it myself. I can confess now that there
was one moment when I was ready to--well, just to say nothing.

“And let us blunder on in our official stupidity and blindness?”
 interrupted the commissioner, a faint smile breaking the gravity of his
face. “We certainly gave you every opportunity.”

“But there’s an innocent man accused--suffering fear of death--justice
must be done. But, sir,” Muller took the warrant the commissioner handed
across the table to him. “May I not make it as easy as I can for Mr.
Thorne--I mean, bring him here with as little publicity as possible? His
wife is with him in Venice.”

“Poor little woman, it’s terrible! Do whatever you think best, Muller.
You’re a queer mixture. Here you’ve hounded this man down, followed hot
on his trail when not a soul but yourself connected him in any way with
the murder. And now you’re sorry for him! A soft heart like yours is a
dangerous possession for a police detective, Muller. It’s no aid to our

“No, sir, I know that.”

“Well take care it doesn’t run away with you this time. Don’t let
Herbert Thorne escape, however much pity you may feel for him.”

“I doubt if he’ll want to sir, as long as another is in prison for his

“But he may make his confession and then try to escape the disgrace.”

“Yes, sir, I’ve thought of that. That’s why I want to go to Venice
myself. And then, there’s the poor young wife, he must think of her when
the desire comes to end his own life...”

“Yes! Yes! This terrible thing has shaken us both up more than a little.
I feel exhausted. You look tired yourself, Muller. Go home now, and get
some rest for your early start. Good-night.”

“Good-night, sir.”


A wonderfully beautiful night lay over the fair old city of Venice
when the Northern Express thundered over the long bridge to the railway
station. A passenger who was alone in a second-class compartment stood
up to collect his few belongings. Suddenly he looked up as he heard a
voice, a voice which he had learned to know only very recently, calling
to him from the door of the compartment.

“Why! you were in the train too? You have come to Venice?” exclaimed
Joseph Muller in astonishment as he saw Mrs. Bernauer standing there
before him.

“Yes, I have come to Venice too. I must be with my dear lady--when--when
Herbert--” She had begun quite calmly, but she did not finish her
sentence, for loud sobs drowned the words.

“You were in the next compartment? Why didn’t you come in here with me?
It would have made this journey shorter for both of us.”

“I had to be alone,” said the pale woman and then she added: “I only
came to you now to ask you where I must go.”

“I think we two had better go to the Hotel Bauer. Let me arrange things
for you. Mrs. Thorne must not see you until she has been prepared for
your coming. I will arrange that with her husband.”

The two took each other’s hands. They had won respect and sympathy for
each other, this quiet man who went so relentlessly and yet so pityingly
about his duty in the interest of justice--and the devoted woman whose
faithfulness had brought about such a tragedy.

The train had now entered the railway station. Muller and Mrs. Bernauer
stood a few minutes later on the banks of the Grand Canal and entered
one of the many gondolas waiting there. The moon glanced back from
the surface of the water broken into ripples under the oars of the
gondoliers; it shone with a magic charm on the old palaces that stood
knee-deep in the lagoons, and threw heavy shadows over the narrow
water-roads on which the little dark boats glided silently forward.
In most of the gondolas coming from the station excited voices and
exclamations of delight broke the calm of the moonlit evening as the
tourists rejoiced in the beauty that is Venice.

But in the gondola in which Muller and Mrs. Bernauer sat there was deep
silence, silence broken only by a sobbing sigh that now and then burst
from the heart of the haggard woman. There were few travellers entering
Venice on one of its world-famous moonlit nights who were so sad at
heart as were these two.

And there were few travellers in Venice as heavy hearted as was the man
who next morning took one of the earliest boats out to the Lido.

Muller and Mrs. Bernauer were on the same boat watching him from a
hidden corner. The woman’s sad eyes gazed yearningly at the haggard
face of the tall man who stood looking over the railing of the little
steamer. Her own tears came as she saw the gloom in the once shining
grey eyes she loved so well.

Muller stood beside Mrs. Bernauer. His eyes too, keen and quick,
followed Herbert Thorne as he stood by the rail or paced restlessly up
and down; his face too showed pity and concern. He also saw that Thorne
held in his hand a bundle of newspapers which were still enclosed in
their mailing wrappers. The papers were pressed in a convulsive grip of
the artist’s long slender fingers.

Muller knew then that Thorne had not yet learned of the arrest of Johann
Knoll. At the very earliest, Thursday’s papers, which brought the news,
could not reach him before Friday morning. But these newspapers (Muller
saw that they were German papers) were still in their wrappings. They
were probably Viennese papers for which he had telegraphed and which
had just arrived. His anxiety had not allowed him to read them in the
presence of his wife. He had sought the solitude of early morning on the
Lido, that he might learn, unobserved, what terrors fate had in store
for him.

It was doubtless Mrs. Bernauer’s telegram which caused his present
anxiety, a telegram which had reached him only the night before when he
returned with his wife from an excursion to Torcello. It had caused him
a sleepless night, for it had brought the realisation that his faithful
nurse suspected the truth about the murder in the quiet lane. The
telegram had read as follows: “Have drawn money and send it at once.
Further journey probably necessary, visitor in house to-day. Connected
with occurrence in -- Street. Please read Viennese papers. News and
orders for me please send to address A.B. General Postoffice.”

This telegram told Herbert Thorne the truth. And the papers which
arrived this morning were to tell him more--what he did not yet know.
But his heart was drawn with terrors which threw lines in his face and
made him look ten years older than on that Tuesday morning when the
detective saw him setting out on his journey with his wife.

When the boat landed at the Lido, Thorne walked off down the road which
led to the ocean side. Muller and Mrs. Bernauer entered the waiting
tramway that took them in the same direction. They dismounted in front
of the bathing establishment, stepped behind a group of bushes and
waited there for Thorne. In about ten minutes they saw his tall figure
passing on the other side of the road. He was walking down to the beach,
holding the still unopened papers in his hand.

A narrow strip of park runs along parallel to the beach in the direction
towards Mala Mocco. Muller and Mrs Bernauer walked along through this
park on the path which was nearest the water. The detective watched the
rapidly moving figure ahead of them, while the woman’s tear-dimmed eyes
veiled everything else to her but the path along which her weary feet
hastened. Thorne halted about half way between the bathing establishment
and the customs barracks, looked around to see if he were alone and
threw himself down on the sand.

He had chosen a good place. To the right and to the left were high sand
dunes, before him was the broad surface of the ocean, and at his back
was rising ground, bare sand with here and there a scraggly bush or
a group of high thistles. Herbert Thorne believed himself to be alone
here... as far as a man can be alone over whom hangs the shadow of a
crime. He groaned aloud and hid his pale face in his hands.

In his own distress he did not hear the deep sigh--which, just above
him on the edge of the knoll, broke from the breast of a woman who was
suffering scarcely less than he; he did not know that two pair of sad
eyes looked down upon him. And now into the eyes of the watching woman
there shot a gleam of terror. For Herbert Thorne had taken a revolver
from his pocket and laid it quietly beside him. Then he took out a
notebook and a pencil and placed them beside the weapon. Then slowly,
reluctantly, he opened one of the papers.

A light breeze from the shining sea before him carried off the wrapping.
The paper which he opened shook in his trembling hands, as his eyes
sought the reports of the murder. He gave a sudden start and a tremor
ran through his frame. He had come to the spot which told of the arrest
of another man, who was under shadow of punishment for the crime which
he himself had committed. When he had read this report through, he
turned to the other papers. He was quite calm now, outwardly calm at

When he had finished reading the papers he laid them in a heap beside
him and reached out for his notebook. As he opened it the two watchers
saw that between its first pages there was a sealed and addressed
letter. Two other envelopes were contained in the notebook, envelopes
which were also addressed although still open. Muller’s sharp eyes could
read the addresses as Thorne took them up in turn, looking long at each
of them. One envelope was addressed in Italian to the Chief of Police of
Venice, the other to the Chief of Police in Vienna.

The two watchers leaned forward, scarcely three yards above the man in
whom they were interested. Thorne tore out two leaves of his notebook
and wrote several lines on each of them. One note, he placed in the
envelope addressed to the Viennese police and sealed it carefully. Then
he put the sealed letter with the second note in the other envelope, the
one addressed to the Italian police. He put all the letters back in his
notebook, holding it together with a rubber strap, and replaced it in
his pocket.

Then he stretched out his hand toward the revolver.

The sand came rattling down upon him, the thistles bent over creakingly
and two figures appeared beside him.

“There’s time enough for that yet, Mr. Thorne,” said the man at whom the
painter gazed up in bewilderment. And then this man took the revolver
quietly from his hand and hid it in his own pocket.

Thorne pressed his teeth down on his lips until the blood came. He
could not speak; he looked first at the stranger who had mastered him so
completely, and then, in dazed astonishment, at the woman who had sunk
down beside him in the sand, clasping his hand in both of hers.

“Adele! Adele! Why are you here?” he stammered finally.

“I want to be with you--in this hour,” she answered, looking at him with
eyes of worship. “I want to be with my dear lady--to comfort her--to
protect her when--when--”

“When they arrest me?” Thorne finished the sentence himself. Then
turning to Muller he continued: “And that is why you are here?”

“Yes, Mr. Thorne. I have a warrant for your arrest in my pocket. But I
think it will be unnecessary to make use of it in the customary official
way through the authorities here. I see that you have written to both
police stations--confessing your deed. This will amount to a voluntary
giving up of yourself to the authorities, therefore all that is
necessary is that I return with you in the same train which takes you to
Vienna. But I must ask you for those two letters, for until you yourself
give them to the police authorities in my presence, it is my duty to
keep them.”

Muller had seldom found his official duty as difficult as it was now.
His words came haltingly and great drops stood out on his forehead.

The painter rose from the sand and he too wiped his face, which was
drawn in agony.

“Herbert, Herbert!” cried Adele Bernauer suddenly. “Oh, Herbert, you
will live, you will! Promise me, you will not think of suicide, it would
kill your wife--”

She lay on her knees before him in the sand. He looked down at her
gently and with a gesture which seemed to be a familiar one of days long
past, he stroked the face that had grown old and worn in these hours of
fear for him.

“Yes, you dear good soul, I will live on, I will take upon myself my
punishment for killing a scoundrel. The poor man whom they have arrested
in my place must not linger in the fear of death. I am ready, sir.

“My name is Muller--detective Muller.”

“Joseph Muller, the famous detective Muller?” asked Thorne with a sad
smile. “I have had little to do with the police but by chance I have
heard of your fame. I might have known; they tell me you are one from
whom the truth can never remain hidden.”

“My duty is not always an easy one,” said Muller.

“Thank you. Dispose of me as you will. I do not wish any privileges that
others would not have, Mr. Muller. Here is my written confession and
here am I myself. Shall we go now?” Herbert Thorne handed the detective
his notebook with its important contents and then walked slowly back
along the road he had come.

Muller walked a little behind him, while Mrs. Bernauer was at his side.
As in days long past, they walked hand in hand.

With eyes full of pity Muller watched them, and he heard Thorne give his
old nurse orders for the care of his wife. She was to take Mrs. Thorne
to Graz to her father, then to return herself to Vienna and take care of
the house as usual, until his attorney could settle up his affairs and
sell the property. For Thorne said that neither he nor his wife would
ever want to set foot in the house again. He spoke calmly, he thought of
everything--he thought even of the possibility that he might have to pay
the death penalty for his deed.

For who could tell how the authorities would judge this murder?

It had indeed been a murder by merest chance only. Thorne told his old
nurse all about it. When she had given him the signal he had hurried
down into the garden, and walking quietly along the path, he had
found his wife at the garden gate in conversation with a man who was
a stranger to him. That part of their talk which he overheard told him
that the man was a blackmailer, and that he was making money on the fact
that he had caught Theobald Leining cheating at cards.

This chance had put the officer into Winkler’s power. The clerk knew
that he could get nothing from the guilty man himself, so he had turned
to the latter’s sister, who was rich, and had threatened to bring about
a disgraceful scandal if she did not pay for his silence. For more than
a year he had been getting money from her by means of these threats.
All this was clear from the conversation. The man spoke in tones of
impertinence, or sneering obsequiousness, the woman’s voice showed
contempt and hatred.

Thorne’s blood began to boil. His fingers tightened about the revolver
which he had brought with him to be ready for any emergency, and he
stepped designedly upon a twig which broke under his feet with a noise.
He wanted to frighten his wife and send her back to the house. This was
what did occur. But the blackmailer was alarmed as well and fled hastily
from the garden when he realised that he was not alone with his victim.
Thorne followed the man’s disappearing figure, calling him to halt. He
did not call loudly for he too wanted to avoid a scandal. His intention
was to force the man to follow him into the house, to get his written
confession of blackmail--then to finish him off with a large sum once
for all and kick him out of the place.

In this manner Herbert Thorne thought to free himself and his wife from
the persecutions of the rascal. His heart was filled with hatred towards
the man. For since Mrs. Bernauer had told him what she had discovered,
he knew that it was because of this wretch that his once so happy wife
was losing her strength, her health and her peace of mind.

He followed the fleeing man and called to him several times to halt.
Finally Winkler half turned and called out over his shoulder: “You’d
better leave me alone! Do you want all Vienna to know that your
brother-in-law ought to be in jail?”

These words robbed Thorne of all control. He pressed the trigger under
his finger and the bullet struck the man before him, who had turned
to continue his flight, full in the back. “And that is how I became a
murderer.” With these words Herbert Thorne concluded his narrative. He
appeared quite calm now. He was really calmer, for the strain of
the deed, which was justified in his eyes, was not so great upon his
conscience as had been the strain of the secret of it.

In his own eyes he had only killed a beast who chanced to bear the form
of a man. But of course in the eyes of the world this was a murder like
any other, and the man who had committed it knew that he was under the
ban of the law, that it was only a chance that the arm of justice had
not yet reached out for him. And now this arm had reached out for him,
although it was no longer necessary. For Herbert Thorne was not the man
to allow another to suffer in his stead.

As soon as he knew that another had been arrested and was under
suspicion of the murder, he knew that there was nothing more for him but
open confession. But he wished to avoid a scandal even now. If he
died by his own hand, then the first cause of all this trouble, his
brother-in-law’s rascality, could still be hidden.

But now his care was all in vain and Herbert Thorne knew that he must
submit to the inevitable. Side by side with his old friend he sat on the
deck of the boat that took them back to the Riva dei Schiavoni. Muller
sat at some distance from them. The pale sad-faced woman, and the pale
sad-faced man had much to say to each other that a stranger might not

When the little boat reached the landing stage, there were but a few
steps more to the door of the Hotel Danieli. From a balcony on the first
floor a young woman stood looking down onto the canal. She too was pale
and her eyes were heavy with anxiety. She had been pale and anxious even
then, the day when she left the beautiful old house in the quiet street,
to start on this pleasure trip to Venice.

It had been no pleasure trip to her. She had seen the change in her
husband, a change that struck deep into his very being and altered him
in everything except in his love and tender care for her. “Oh, why is
it? what is the matter?” she asked her self a thousand times a day.
Could it be possible that he had discovered the secret which tortured
her, the only secret she had ever had from him, the secret she had
longed to confess to him a hundred times but had lacked courage to do

For she had sinned deeply against her husband, she knew. Her fear and
her confusion had driven her deeper and deeper into the waters of
deceit until it was impossible for her to find the words that would have
brought help and comfort from the man whom she loved more than anything
else in the world. In the very earliest stages of Winkler’s persecution
she had lost her head completely and instead of confessing to her
husband and asking for his aid and protection, she had pawned the rich
jewels which had been his wedding present to get the money demanded
by the blackmailer. In her ignorance she had thought that this one sum
would satisfy him.

But he came again and again, demanding money which she saved from
her pin money, from her household allowance, thus taking what she had
intended to use to redeem her jewels. The pledge was lost, and her
jewels gone forever. From now on, Mrs. Thorne lived in a terror which
sapped her strength and drank her life blood drop by drop. Any hour
might bring discovery, a discovery which she feared would shake her
husband’s love for her. The poor weak little woman grew pale and ill.
She wrote finally to her step-brother, but he could think of no way
out; he wrote only that if the matter came to a scandal there would be
nothing for him to do but to kill himself. This was one reason more for
her silence, and Mrs. Thorne faded to a wan shadow of her former sunny

As she looked down from the balcony, she was like a woman suffering
from a deathly illness. A new terror had come to her heart because her
husband had gone away so early without telling her why or whither he had
gone. When she saw him coming towards the door of the hotel, pale and
drooping, and when she saw Mrs. Bernauer beside him, her heart seemed to
stand still. She crept back from the window and stood in the middle of
the room as Herbert Thorne and his former nurse entered.

“What has happened?” This was all she could say as she looked into the
distraught face of the housekeeper, into her husband’s sad eyes.

He led her to a chair, then knelt beside her and told her all.

“Outside the door stands the man who will take me back to Vienna--and
you, my dearest, you must go to your father.” He concluded his story
with these words.

She bent down over him and kissed him. “‘No, I am going with you,” she
said softly, strangely calm; “why should I leave you now? Is it not I
who am the cause of this dreadful thing?”

And then she made her confession, much too late. And she went with him,
back to the city of their home. It seemed to them both quite natural
that she should do so.

When the Northern Express rolled out of Venice that afternoon, three
people sat together in a compartment, the curtains of which were drawn
close. They were the unhappy couple and their faithful servant. And
outside in the corridor of the railway carriage, a small, slight man
walked up and down--up and down. He had pressed a gold coin into the
conductor’s hand, with the words: “The party in there do not wish to be
disturbed; the lady is ill.”

Herbert Thorne’s trial took place several weeks later. Every possible
extenuating circumstance was brought to bear upon his sentence. Five
years only was to be the term of his imprisonment, his punishment for
the crime of a single moment of anger.

His wife waited for him in patient love. She did not go to Graz, but
continued to live in the old mansion with the mansard roof. Her father
was with her. The brother Theobald, the cause of all this suffering to
those who had shielded him at the expense of their own happiness, had at
last done the only good deed of his life--had put an end to his useless
existence with his own hand.

Father and daughter waited patiently for the return of the man who had
sinned and suffered for their sake. They spoke of him only in terms of
the tenderest affection and respect.

And indeed, seldom has any condemned murderer met with the respect of
the entire community as Herbert Thorne did. The tone of the newspapers,
and public opinion, evinced by hundreds of letters from friends,
acquaintances, and from strangers, was a great boon to the solitary man
in his cell, and to the three loving hearts in the old house. And at
the end of two years the clemency of the Monarch ended his term of
imprisonment, and Herbert Thorne was set free, a step which met with the
approval of the entire city.

He returned to the home where love and affection awaited him, ready to
make him forget what he had suffered. But the silver threads in his dark
hair and a certain quiet seriousness in his manner, and in the hearts of
all the dwellers in the old mansion, showed that the occurrence of that
fatal 27th of September had thrown a shadow over them all which was not
to be shaken off.

Joseph Muller brought many other cases to a successful solution. But for
years after this particular case had been won, he was followed, as by
a shadow, by a man who watched over him, and who, whenever danger
threatened, stood over the frail detective as if to take the blow upon
himself. He is a clever assistant, too, and no one who had seen Johann
Knoll the day that he was put into the cell on suspicion of murder
would have believed that the idle tramp could become again such a useful
member of society. These are the victories that Joseph Muller considers
his greatest.

*** End of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "The Case of the Lamp That Went Out" ***

Doctrine Publishing Corporation provides digitized public domain materials.
Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians.
This effort is time consuming and expensive, so in order to keep providing
this resource, we have taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties,
including placing technical restrictions on automated querying.

We also ask that you:

+ Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Doctrine Publishing
Corporation's ISYS search for use by individuals, and we request that you
use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes.

+ Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort
to Doctrine Publishing's system: If you are conducting research on machine
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a
large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of
public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help.

+ Keep it legal -  Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for
ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because
we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States,
that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries.
Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we
can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is
allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Doctrine Publishing
ISYS search  means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world.
Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe.

About ISYS® Search Software
Established in 1988, ISYS Search Software is a global supplier of enterprise
search solutions for business and government.  The company's award-winning
software suite offers a broad range of search, navigation and discovery
solutions for desktop search, intranet search, SharePoint search and embedded
search applications.  ISYS has been deployed by thousands of organizations
operating in a variety of industries, including government, legal, law
enforcement, financial services, healthcare and recruitment.