By Author [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Title [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Language
all Classics books content using ISYS

Download this book: [ ASCII ]

Look for this book on Amazon

We have new books nearly every day.
If you would like a news letter once a week or once a month
fill out this form and we will give you a summary of the books for that week or month by email.

Title: Flemington
Author: Jacob, Violet
Language: English
As this book started as an ASCII text book there are no pictures available.
Copyright Status: Not copyrighted in the United States. If you live elsewhere check the laws of your country before downloading this ebook. See comments about copyright issues at end of book.

*** Start of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "Flemington" ***

This book is indexed by ISYS Web Indexing system to allow the reader find any word or number within the document.

Public Library, the HathiTrust Digital Library, and Google.







THIS book has no claim to be considered an historical novel, none of
the principal people in it being historic characters; but the taking
of the ship, as also the manner of its accomplishment, is true.
     V. J.



CHAPTER                            PAGE

    I.  PROLOGUE                      1
   II.  JETSAM                       16
  III.  A COACH-AND-FIVE             30
   IV.  BUSINESS                     46
    V. "THE HAPPY LAND"              64
  VII. TREACHERY                     84
 VIII. THE HEAVY HAND               100
   IX. "TOUJOURS DE L'AUDACE"       124


    X. ADRIFT                       135
   XI. THE GUNS OF MONTROSE         150
  XII. INCHBRAYOCK                  161
   XV. WATTIE HAS THEORIES          200
 XVII. SOCIETY                      222


  XIX. THE WINTER                   251
  XXI. HUNTLY HILL                  280
 XXII. HUNTLY HILL (_continued_)    288
XXIII. THE MUIR OF PERT             299
 XXIV. THE VANITY OF MEN            313
  XXV. A ROYAL DUKE                 327
XXVII. EPILOGUE                     346





MR. DUTHIE walked up the hill with the gurgle of the burn he had just
crossed purring in his ears. The road was narrow and muddy, and the
house of Ardguys, for which he was making, stood a little way in front
of him, looking across the dip threaded by the water. The tall white
walls, discoloured by damp and crowned by their steep roof, glimmered
through the ash-trees on the bank at his right hand. There was
something distasteful to the reverend man's decent mind in this homely
approach to the mansion inhabited by the lady he was on his way to
visit, and he found the remoteness of this byway among the grazing
lands of Angus oppressive.

The Kilpie burn, travelling to the river Isla, farther west, had
pushed its way through the undulations of pasture that gave this
particular tract, lying north of the Sidlaws, a definite character;
and the formation of the land seemed to suggest that some vast
ground-swell had taken place in the earth, to be arrested, suddenly,
in its heaving, for all time. Thus it was that a stranger, wandering
about, might come unwarily upon little outlying farms and cottages
hidden in the trough of these terrestrial waves, and find himself,
when he least awaited it, with his feet on a level with some humble
roof, snug in a fold of the braes. It was in one of the largest of
these miniature valleys that the house of Ardguys stood, with the
Kilpie burn running at the bottom of its sloping garden.

Mr. Duthie was not a stranger, but he did not admire the unexpected;
he disliked the approach to Ardguys, for his sense of suitability was
great; indeed, it was its greatness which was driving him on his
present errand. He had no gifts except the quality of decency, which
is a gift like any other; and he was apt, in the company of Madam
Flemington, to whose presence he was now hastening, to be made aware
of the great inconvenience of his shortcomings, and the still greater
inconvenience of his advantage. He crossed the piece of uneven turf
dividing the house from the road, and ascended the short flight of
stone steps, a spare, black figure in a three-cornered hat, to knock
with no uncertain hand upon the door. His one great quality was
staying him up.

Like the rest of his compeers in the first half of the seventeen
hundreds, Mr. Duthie wore garments of rusty blue or grey during the
week, but for this occasion he had plunged his ungainly arms and legs
into the black which he generally kept for the Sabbath-day, though the
change gave him little distinction. He was a homely and very
uncultured person; and while the approaching middle of the century was
bringing a marked improvement to country ministers as a class,
mentally and socially, he had stood still.

He was ushered into a small panelled room in which he waited alone for
a few minutes, his hat on his knee. Then there was a movement outside,
and a lady came in, whose appearance let loose upon him all those
devils of apprehension which had hovered about him as he made his way
from his manse to the chair on which he sat. He rose, stricken yet
resolute, with the cold forlorn courage which is the bravest thing in
the world.

As Madam Flemington entered, she took possession of the room to the
exclusion of everything else, and the minister felt as if he had no
right to exist. Her eyes, meeting his, reflected the idea.

Christian Flemington carried with her that atmosphere which enwraps a
woman who has been much courted by men, and, though she was just over
forty-two, and a grandmother, the most inexperienced observer might
know how strongly the fires of life were burning in her still. An
experienced one would be led to think of all kinds of disturbing
subjects by her mere presence; intrigue, love, power--a thousand
abstract yet stirring things, far, far remote from the weather-beaten
house which was the incongruous shell of this compelling personality.
Dignity was hers in an almost appalling degree, but it was a quality
unlike the vulgar conception of it; a dignity which could be all
things besides distant; unscrupulous in its uses, at times rather
brutal, outspoken, even jovial; born of absolute fearlessness, and
conveying the certainty that its possessor would speak and act as she
chose, because she regarded encroachment as impossible and had the
power of cutting the bridge between herself and humanity at will. That
power was hers to use and to abuse, and she was accustomed to do both.
In speech she could have a plain coarseness which has nothing to do
with vulgarity, and is, indeed, scarcely compatible with it; a
coarseness which is disappearing from the world in company with many
better and worse things.

She moved slowly, for she was a large woman and had never been an
active one; but the bold and steady brilliance of her eyes, which the
years had not faded, suggested swift and sudden action in a way that
was disconcerting. She had the short, straight nose common to feline
types, and time, which had spared her eyes, was duplicating her chin.
Her eyebrows, even and black, accentuated the heavy silver of her
abundant unpowdered hair, which had turned colour early, and an
immense ruby hung from each of her tiny ears in a setting of small
diamonds. Mr. Duthie, who noticed none of these things particularly,
was, nevertheless, crushed by their general combination.

It was nine years before this story opens that Christian Flemington
had left France to take up her abode on the small estate of Ardguys,
which had been left to her by a distant relation. Whilst still almost
a child, she had married a man much older than herself, and her whole
wedded life had been spent at the Court of James II. of England at St.
Germain, whither her husband, a Scottish gentleman of good birth in
the exiled King's suite, had followed his master, remaining after his
death in attendance upon his widow, Mary Beatrice of Modena.

Flemington did not long survive the King. He left his wife with one
son, who, on reaching manhood, estranged himself from his mother by an
undesirable marriage; indeed, it was immediately after this latter
event that Christian quitted her post at Court, retiring to Rouen,
where she lived until the possession of Ardguys, which she inherited a
few months later, gave her a home of her own.

Different stories were afloat concerning her departure. Many people
said that she had gambled away the greater part of her small fortune
and was forced to retrench in some quiet place; others, that she had
quarrelled with, and been dismissed by, Mary Beatrice. Others, again,
declared that she had been paid too much attention by the young
Chevalier de St. George and had found it discreet to take herself out
of his way; but the believers in this last theory were laughed to
scorn; not because the world saw anything strange in the Chevalier's
alleged infatuation, but because it was quite sure that Christian
Flemington would have acted very differently in the circumstances. But
no one could be certain of the truth: the one certain thing was that
she was gone and that since her retreat to Rouen she had openly
professed Whig sympathies. She had been settled at Ardguys, where she
kept her political leanings strictly to herself, for some little time,
when news came that smallpox had carried off her son and his
undesirable wife, and, as a consequence, their little boy was sent
home to the care of his Whig grandmother, much against the will of
those Jacobites at the Court of St. Germain who were still interested
in the family. But as nobody's objection was strong enough to affect
his pocket, the child departed.

'Madam' Flemington, as she was called by her few neighbours, was in
correspondence with none of her old friends, and none of these had the
least idea what she felt about her loss or about the prospect of the
child's arrival. She was his natural guardian, and, though so many
shook their heads at the notion of his being brought up by a rank
Whig, no one was prepared to relieve her of her responsibility. Only
Mary Beatrice, mindful of the elder Flemington's faithful services to
James, granted a small pension for the boy's upbringing from her
meagre private purse; but as this was refused by Christian, the matter
ended. And now, in the year of grace 1727, young Archie Flemington was
a boy of eight, and the living cause of the Rev. William Duthie's
present predicament.

Madam Flemington and the minister sat opposite to each other, silent.
He was evidently trying to make a beginning of his business, but his
companion was not in a mood to help him. He was a person who wearied
her, and she hated red hair; besides which, she was an Episcopalian
and out of sympathy with himself and his community. She found him
common and limited, and at the present moment, intrusive.

"It's sma' pleasure I have in coming to Ardguys the day," he began,
and then stopped, because her eyes paralyzed his tongue.

"You are no flatterer," said she.

But the contempt in her voice braced him.

"Indeed, that I am not, madam," he replied; "neither shall it be said
of me that I gang back from my duty. Nane shall assail nor make a mock
of the Kirk while I am its minister."

"Who has made a mock of the Kirk, my good man?"


The vision of her eight-year-old grandson going forth, like a young
David, to war against the Presbyterian stronghold, brought back Madam
Flemington's good-humour.

"Ye may smile, madam," said Duthie, plunged deeper into the vernacular
by agitation, "ay, ye may lauch. But it ill beseems the grey hair on
yer pow."

Irony always pleased her and she laughed outright, showing her strong
white teeth. It was not only Archie and the Kirk that amused her, but
the whimsical turn of her own fate which had made her hear such an
argument from a man. It was not thus that men had approached her in
the old days.

"You are no flatterer, Mr. Duthie, as I said before."

He looked at her with uncomprehending eyes.

A shout, as of a boy playing outside, came through the window, and a
bunch of cattle upon the slope cantered by with their tails in the
air. Evidently somebody was chasing them.

"Let me hear about Archie," said the lady, recalled to the main point
by the sight.

"Madam, I would wish that ye could step west to the manse wi' me and
see the evil abomination at my gate. It would gar ye blush."

"I am obliged to you, sir. I had not thought to be put to that
necessity by one of your cloth."


"Go on, Mr. Duthie. I can blush without going to the manse for it."

"An evil image has been set up upon my gate," he continued, raising
his voice as though to cry down her levity, "an idolatrous picture. I
think shame that the weans ganging by to the schule should see it. But
I rejoice that there's mony o' them doesna' ken wha it is."

"Fie, Mr. Duthie! Is it Venus?"

"It has idolatrous garments," continued he, with the loud monotony of
one shouting against a tempest, "and a muckle crown on its head----"

"Then it is not Venus," observed she. "Venus goes stripped."

"It is the Pope of Rome," went on Mr. Duthie; "I kent him when I saw
the gaudy claes o' him and the heathen vanities on his pow. I kent it
was himsel'! And it was written at the foot o' him, forbye that. Ay,
madam, there was writing too. There was a muckle bag out frae his mou'
wi' wicked words on it! 'Come awa' to Babylon wi' me, Mr. Duthie.' I
gar'd the beadle run for water and a clout, for I could not thole that
sic' a thing should be seen."

"And you left the Pope?" said Madam Flemington.

"I did," replied the minister. "I would wish to let ye see to whatlike
misuse Airchie has put his talents."

"And how do you know it was Archie's work?"

"There's naebody hereabouts but Airchie could have made sic' a thing.
The beadle tell't me that he saw him sitting ahint the whins wi' his
box of paint as he gae'd down the manse road, and syne when he came
back the image was there."

As he finished his sentence the door opened and a small figure was
arrested on the threshold by the sight of him. The little boy paused,
disconcerted and staring, and a faint colour rose in his olive face.
Then his glum look changed to a smile in which roguery, misgiving, and
an intense malicious joy were blended. He looked from one to the

"Archie, come in and make your reverence to Mr. Duthie," said Madam
Flemington, who had all at once relapsed into punctiliousness.

Archie obeyed. His skin and his dark eyes hinted at his mother's
French blood, but his bow made it a certainty.

The minister offered no acknowledgment.

If Archie had any doubt about the reason of Mr. Duthie's visit, it did
not last long. The minister was not a very stern man in daily life,
but now the Pope and Madam Flemington between them had goaded him off
his normal peaceable path, and his expression bade the little boy
prepare for the inevitable. Archie reflected that his grandmother was
a disciplinarian, and his mind went to a cupboard in the attics where
she kept a cane. But the strain of childish philosophy which ran
through his volatile nature was of a practical kind, and it reminded
him that he must pay for his pleasures, and that sometimes they were
worth the expense. Even in the grip of Nemesis he was not altogether
sorry that he had drawn that picture.

Madam Flemington said nothing, and Mr. Duthie beckoned to him to come

"Child," said he, "you have put an affront upon the whole o' the folk
of this parish. You have raised up an image to be a scandal to the
passers-by. You have set up a notorious thing in our midst, and you
have caused words to issue from its mouth that the very kirk-officer,
when he dichted it out wi' his clout, thought shame to look upon. I
have jaloused it right to complain to your grandmother and to warn
her, that she may check you before you bring disgrace and dismay upon
her and upon her house."

Archie's eyes had grown rounder as he listened, for the pomp of the
high-sounding words impressed him with a sense of importance, and he
was rather astonished to find that any deed of his own could produce
such an effect. He contemplated the minister with a curious detachment
that belonged to himself. Then he turned to look at his grandmother,
and, though her face betrayed no encouragement, the subtle smile he
had worn when he stood at the door appeared for a moment upon his

Mr. Duthie saw it. Madam Flemington had not urged one word in defence
of the culprit, but, rightly or wrongly, he scented lack of sympathy
with his errand. He turned upon her.

"I charge you--nay, I demand it of you," he exclaimed--"that you root
out the evil in yon bairn's nature! Tak' awa' from him the foolish toy
that he has put to sic' a vile use. I will require of you----"

"Sir," said Madam Flemington, rising, "I have need of nobody to teach
me how to correct my grandson. I am obliged to you for your visit, but
I will not detain you longer."

And almost before he realized what had happened, Mr. Duthie found
himself once more upon the stone steps of Ardguys.

Archie and his grandmother were left together in the panelled room.
Perhaps the boy's hopes were raised by the abrupt departure of his
accuser. He glanced tentatively at her.

"You will not take away my box?" he inquired.


"Mr. Duthie has a face like this," he said airily, drawing his small
features into a really brilliant imitation of the minister.

The answer was hardly what he expected.

"Go up to the cupboard and fetch me the cane," said Madam Flemington.

It was a short time later when Archie, rather sore, but still
comforted by his philosophy, sat among the boughs of a tree farther up
the hill. It was a favourite spot of his, for he could look down
through the light foliage over the roof of Ardguys and the Kilpie burn
to the rough road ascending beyond them. The figure of the retreating
Mr. Duthie had almost reached the top and was about to be lost in the
whin-patch across the strath. The little boy's eyes followed him
between the yellowing leaves of the tree which autumn was turning into
the clear-tinted ghost of itself. He had not escaped justice, and the
marks of tears were on his face; but they were not rancorous tears,
whose traces live in the heart long after the outward sign of their
fall has gone. They were tears forced from him by passing stress, and
their sources were shallow. Madam Flemington could deal out punishment
thoroughly, but she was not one of those who burn its raw wounds with
sour words, and her grandson had not that woeful sense of estrangement
which is the lot of many children when disciplined by those they love.
Archie adored his grandmother, and the gap of years between them was
bridged for him by his instinctive and deep admiration. She was no
companion to him, but she was a deity, and he had never dreamed of
investing her with those dull attributes which the young will tack on
to those who are much their seniors, whether they possess them or not.
Mr. Duthie, who had just reached middle life, seemed a much older
person to Archie.

He felt in his pocket for the dilapidated box which held his chief
treasures--those dirty lumps of paint with which he could do such
surprising things. No, there was not very much black left, and he must
contrive to get some more, for the adornment of the other manse
gatepost was in his mind. He would need a great deal of black, because
this time his subject would be the devil; and there should be the
same--or very nearly the same--invitation to the minister.



EIGHTEEN years after the last vestige of Archie's handiwork had
vanished under the beadle's 'clout' two gentlemen were sitting in the
library of a square stone mansion at the eastern end of the county of
Angus. It was evening, and they had drawn their chairs up to a
fireplace in which the flames danced between great hobs of polished
brass, shooting the light from their thrusting tongues into a lofty
room with drawn curtains and shelves of leather-bound books. Though
the shutters were closed, the two men could hear, in the pauses of
talk, a continuous distant roaring, which was the sound of surf
breaking upon the bar outside the harbour of Montrose, three miles
away. A small mahogany table with glasses and a decanter stood at Lord
Balnillo's elbow, and he looked across at his brother James (whose
life, as a soldier, had kept him much in foreign countries until the
previous year) with an expression of mingled good-will and patronage.

David Logie was one of the many Scottish gentlemen of good birth who
had made the law his profession, and he had just retired from the
Edinburgh bench, on which, as Lord Balnillo, he had sat for hard upon
a quarter of a century. His face was fresh-coloured and healthy, and,
though he had not put on so much flesh as a man of sedentary ways who
has reached the age of sixty-two might expect to carry, his main
reason for retiring had been the long journeys on horseback over
frightful roads, which a judge's duties forced him to take. Another
reason was his estate of Balnillo, which was far enough from Edinburgh
to make personal attention to it impossible. His wife Margaret, whose
portrait hung in the dining-room, had done all the business for many
years; but Margaret was dead, and perhaps David, who had been a
devoted husband, felt the need of something besides the law to fill up
his life. He was a lonely man, for he had no children, and his brother
James, who sat opposite to him, was his junior by twenty-five years.
For one who had attained to his position, he was slow and curiously
dependent on others; there was a turn about the lines of his
countenance which suggested fretfulness, and his eyes, which had
looked upon so many criminals, could be anxious. He was a considerate
landlord, and, in spite of the times in which he lived and the bottle
at his elbow, a person of very sober habits.

James Logie, who had started his career in Lord Orkney's regiment of
foot with the Scots Brigade in Holland, had the same fresh complexion
as his brother and the same dark blue eyes; but they were eyes that
had a different expression, and that seemed to see one thing at a
time. He was a squarer, shorter man than Lord Balnillo, quicker of
speech and movement. His mouth was a little crooked, for the centre of
his lower lip did not come exactly under the centre of the upper one,
and this slight mistake on the part of Nature had given his face a not
unpleasant look of virility. Most people who passed James gave him a
second glance. Both men were carefully dressed and wore fine cambric
cravats and laced coats; and the shoes of the judge, which rested on
the fender, were adorned by gilt buckles.

They had been silent for some time, as people are who have come to the
same conclusion and find that there is no more to say, and in the
quietness the heavy undercurrent of sound from the coast seemed to
grow more insistent.

"The bar is very loud to-night, Jamie," said Lord Balnillo. "I doubt
but there's bad weather coming, and I am loth to lose more trees."

"I see that the old beech by the stables wants a limb," observed the
other. "That's the only change about the place that I notice."

"There'll be more yet," said the judge.

"You've grown weather-wise since you left Edinburgh, David."

"I had other matters to think upon there," answered Balnillo, with
some pomp.

James smiled faintly, making the little twist in his lip more

"Come out to the steps and look at the night," said he, snatching,
like most restless men, at the chance of movement.

They went out through the hall. James unbarred the front door and the
two stood at the top of the flight of stone steps.

The entrance to Balnillo House faced northward, and a wet wind from
the east, slight still, but rising, struck upon their right cheeks and
carried the heavy muffled booming in through the trees. Balnillo
looked frowning at their tops, which had begun to sway; but his
brother's attention was fixed upon a man's figure, which was emerging
from the darkness of the grass park in front of them.

"Who is that?" cried the judge, as the footsteps grew audible.

"It's a coach at the ford, ma lord--a muckle coach that's couped i'
the water! Wully an' Tam an' Andrew Robieson are seekin' to ca' it
oot, but it's fast, ma lord----"

"Is there anyone in it?" interrupted James.

"Ay, there was. But he's oot noo."

"Where is he?"

"He'll na' get forward the night," continued the man. "Ane of the
horse is lame. He cursin', ma lord, an' nae wonder--he can curse
bonnie! Robieson's got his wee laddie wi' him, and he gar'd the loonie
put his hands to his lugs. He's an elder, ye see."

The judge turned to his brother. It was not the first time that the
ford in the Den of Balnillo had been the scene of disaster, for there
was an unlucky hole in it, and the state of the roads made storm-bound
and bedraggled visitors common apparitions in the lives of country

"If ye'll come wi' me, ma lord, ye'll hear him," said the labourer, to
whom the profane victim of the ford was evidently an object of

Balnillo looked down at his silk stockings and buckled shoes.

"I should be telling the lasses to get a bed ready," he remarked
hurriedly, as he re-entered the house.

James was already throwing his leg across the fence, though it was
scarcely the cursing which attracted him, for he had heard oaths to
suit every taste in his time. He hurried across the grass after the
labourer. The night was not very dark, and they made straight for the

The Den of Balnillo ran from north to south, not a quarter of a mile
from the house, and the long chain of miry hollows and cart-ruts which
did duty for a high road from Perth to Aberdeen plunged through it at
the point for which the men were heading. It was a steep ravine filled
with trees and stones, through which the Balnillo burn flowed and fell
and scrambled at different levels on its way to join the Basin of
Montrose, as the great estuary of the river Esk was called. The ford
lay just above one of the falls by which the water leaped downwards,
and the dense darkness of the surrounding trees made it difficult for
Captain Logie to see what was happening as he descended into the black
well of the Den. He could distinguish a confusion of objects by the
light of the lantern which his brother's men had brought and set upon
a stone; the ford itself reflected nothing, for it was churned up into
a sea of mud, in which, as Logie approached, the outline of a
good-sized carriage, lying upon its side, became visible.

"Yonder's the captain coming," said a voice.

Someone lifted the lantern, and he found himself confronted by a tall
young man, whose features he could not see, but who was, no doubt, the
expert in language.

"Sir," he said, "I fear you have had a bad accident. I am come from
Lord Balnillo to find out what he can do for you."

"His lordship is mighty good," replied the young man, "and if he could
force this mud-hole--which, I am told, belongs to him--to yield up my
conveyance, I should be his servant for life."

There was a charm and softness in his voice which nullified the brisk
impertinence of his words.

"I hope you are not hurt," said James.

"Not at all, sir. Providence has spared me. But He has had no mercy
upon one of my poor nags, which has broken its knees, nor on my
stock-in-trade, which is in the water. I am a travelling painter," he
added quickly, "and had best introduce myself. My name is Archibald

The stranger had a difficulty in pronouncing his _r's_; he spoke them
like a Frenchman, with a purring roll.

The other was rather taken aback. Painters in those days had not the
standing in society that they have now, but the voice and manner were
unmistakably those of a man of breeding. Even his freedom was not the
upstart licence of one trying to assert himself, but the easy
expression of a roving imagination.

"I should introduce myself too," said Logie. "I am Captain James
Logie, Lord Balnillo's brother. But we must rescue
your--your--baggage. Where is your postilion?"

Flemington held up the lantern again, and its rays fell upon a man
holding the two horses which were standing together under a tree.
James went towards them.

"Poor beast," said he, as he saw the knees of one of the pair, "he
would be better in a stall. Andrew Robieson, send your boy to the
house for a light, and then you can guide them to the stables."

Meanwhile, the two other men had almost succeeded in getting the
carriage once more upon its wheels, and with the help of Flemington
and Logie, it was soon righted. They decided to leave it where it was
for the night, and it was dragged a little aside, lest it should prove
a pitfall to any chance traveller who might pass before morning.

The two gentlemen went towards the house together, and the men
followed, carring Flemington's possessions and the great square
package containing his canvases.

When they entered the library Lord Balnillo was standing with his back
to the fire.

"I have brought Mr. Flemington, brother," said Logie, "his coach has
come to grief in the Den."

Archie stopped short, and putting his heels together, made much the
same bow as he had made to Mr. Duthie eighteen years before.

A feeling of admiration went through James as the warm light of the
house revealed the person of his companion, and something in the
shrewd wrinkles round his brother's unimpressive eyes irritated him.
He felt a vivid interest in the stranger, and the cautious old man's
demeanour seemed to have raised the atmosphere of a law-court round
himself. He was surveying the new-comer with stiff urbanity.

But Archie made small account of it.

"Sir," said Balnillo, with condescension, "if you will oblige me by
making yourself at home until you can continue your road, I shall take
myself for fortunate."

"My lord," replied Archie, "if you knew how like heaven this house
appears to me after the bottomless pit in your den, you might take
yourself for the Almighty."

Balnillo gave his guest a critical look, and was met by all the soft
darkness of a pair of liquid brown eyes which drooped at the outer
corners, and were set under thick brows following their downward
lines. Gentleness, inquiry, appeal, were in them, and a quality which
the judge, like other observers, could not define--a quality that sat
far, far back from the surface. In spite of the eyes, there was no
suggestion of weakness in the slight young man, and his long chin gave
his olive face gravity. Speech and looks corresponded so little in him
that Balnillo was bewildered; but he was a hospitable man, and he
moved aside to make room for Archie on the hearth. The latter was a
sorry sight, as far as mud went; for his coat was splashed, and his
legs, from the knee down, were of the colour of clay. He held his
hands out to the blaze, stretching his fingers as a cat stretches her
claws under a caressing touch.

"Sit down and put your feet to the fire," said the judge, drawing
forward one of the large armchairs, "and James, do you call for
another glass. When did you dine, Mr. Flemington?"

"I did not dine at all, my lord. I was anxious to push on to Montrose,
and I pushed on to destruction instead."

He looked up with such a whimsical smile at his own mishaps that
Balnillo found his mouth widening in sympathy.

"I will go and tell them to make some food ready," said the captain,
in answer to a sign from his brother.

Balnillo stood contemplating the young man; the lines round his eyes
were relaxing a little; he was fundamentally inquisitive, and his
companion matched no type he had ever seen. He was a little disturbed
by his assurance, yet his instinct of patronage was tickled by the

"I am infinitely grateful to you," said Archie. "I know all the inns
in Brechin, and am very sensible how much better I am likely to dine
here than there. You are too kind."

"Then you know these parts?"

"My home is at the other end of the county--at Ardguys."

"I am familiar with the name," said Balnillo, "but until lately, I
have been so much in Edinburgh that I am out of touch with other
places. I am not even aware to whom it belongs."

"It is a little property, my lord--nothing but a few fields and a
battered old house. But it belongs to my grandmother Flemington, who
brought me up. She lives very quietly."

"Indeed, indeed," said the judge, his mind making a cast for a clue as
a hound does for the scent.

He was not successful.

"I had not taken you for a Scot," he said, after a moment.

"I have been told that," said Archie; "and that reminds me that it
would be proper to tell your lordship what I am. I am a painter, and
at this moment your hall is full of my paraphernalia."

Lord Balnillo did not usually show his feelings, but the look which,
in spite of himself, flitted across his face, sent a gleam of
entertainment through Archie.

"You are surprised," he observed, sighing. "But when a man has to mend
his fortunes he must mend them with what tools he can. Nor am I
ashamed of my trade."

"There is no need, Mr. Flemington," replied the other, with the
measured benevolence he had sometimes used upon the bench; "what you
tell me does you honour--much honour, sir."

"Then you did not take me for a painter any more than for a Scot?"
said Archie, smiling at his host.

"I did not, sir," said the judge shortly. He was not accustomed to be
questioned by his witnesses and he had the uncomfortable sensation of
being impelled, in spite of a certain prejudice, to think moderately
well of his guest.

"I have heard tell of your lordship very often," said the latter,
suddenly, "and I know very well into what good hands I have fallen. I
could wish that all the world was more like yourself."

He turned his head and stared wistfully at the coals.

Balnillo could not make out whether this young fellow's assurance or
his humility was the real key-note to the man. But he liked some of
his sentiments well enough. Archie wore his own hair, and the old man
noticed how silky and fine the brown waves were in the firelight. They
were so near his hand as their owner leaned forward that he could
almost have stroked them.

"Are you going further than Montrose?" he inquired.

"I had hoped to cozen a little employment out of Aberdeen," replied
Flemington, "but it is a mere speculation. I have a gallery of the
most attractive canvases with me--women, divines, children,
magistrates, provosts--all headless and all waiting to see what faces
chance and I may fit on to their necks. I have one lady--an angel, I
assure you, my lord!--a vision of green silk and white
roses--shoulders like satin--the hands of Venus!"

Balnillo was further bewildered. He knew little about the arts and
nothing about artists. He had looked at many a contemporary portrait
without suspecting that the original had chosen, as sitters often did,
an agreeable ready-made figure from a selection brought forward by a
painter, on which to display his or her countenance. It was a custom
which saved the trouble of many sittings and rectified much of the
niggardliness or over-generosity of Nature.

"I puzzle you, I see," added Archie, laughing, "and no doubt the hair
of Van Dyck would stand on end at some of our modern doings. But I am
not Van Dyck, unhappily, and in common with some others I do half my
business before my sitters ever see me. A client has only to choose a
suitable body for his own head, and I can tell you that many are
thankful to have the opportunity."

"I had no idea that portraits were done like that," said Lord
Balnillo; "I never heard of such an arrangement before."

"But you do not think it wrong, I hope?" exclaimed Flemington, the
gaiety dying out of his face. "There is no fraud about it! It is not
as if a man deceived his sitter."

The half-petulant distress in his voice struck Balnillo, and almost
touched him; there was something so simple and confiding in it.

"It might have entertained your lordship to see them," continued
Archie ruefully. "I should have liked to show you the strange company
I travel with."

"So you shall, Mr. Flemington," said the old man. "It would entertain
me very greatly. I only fear that the lady with the white roses may
enslave me," he added, with rather obvious jocosity.

"Indeed, now is the time for that," replied Archie, his face lighting
up again, "for I hope she may soon wear the head of some fat town
councillor's wife of Aberdeen."

As he spoke Captain Logie returned with the news that dinner was

"I have been out to the stable to see what we could do for your
horses," said he.

"Thank you a thousand times, sir," exclaimed Archie.

Lord Balnillo watched his brother as he led the painter to the door.

"I think I will come, too, and sit with Mr. Flemington while he eats,"
he said, after a moment's hesitation.

A couple of hours later Archie found himself in a comfortable bedroom.
His valise had been soaked in the ford, and a nightshirt of Lord
Balnillo's was warming at the fire. When he had put it on he went and
looked at himself in an old-fashioned mirror which hung on the wall.
He was a good deal taller than the judge, but it was not his own image
that caused the indescribable expression on his face.



ARCHIE sat in his bedroom at a table. The window was open, for it was
a soft October afternoon, and he looked out meditatively at the
prospect before him.

The wind that had howled in the night had spent itself towards
morning, and by midday the tormented sky had cleared and the curtain
of cloud rolled away, leaving a mellow sun smiling over the Basin of
Montrose. He had never been within some miles of Balnillo, and the
aspect of this piece of the country being new to him, his painter's
eye rested appreciatively on what he saw.

Two avenues of ancient trees ran southward, one on either side of the
house, and a succession of grass fields sloped away before him between
these bands of timber to the tidal estuary, where the water lay blue
and quiet with the ribbon of the South Esk winding into it from the
west. Beyond it the low hills with their gentle rise touched the
horizon; nearer at hand the beeches and gean-trees, so dear to Lord
Balnillo's heart, were red and gold. Here and there, where the gale
had thinned the leaves, the bareness of stem and bough let in glimpses
of the distant purple which was the veil of the farther atmosphere. To
the east, shut out from his sight by all this wood, was the town of
Montrose, set, with its pointed steeple, like the blue silhouette of
some Dutch town, between the Basin and the North Sea.

A pen was in Flemington's hand, and the very long letter he had just
written was before him.



"I beg you to look upon the address at the head of this letter, and to
judge whether fortune has favoured your devoted grandson.

"I am _on the very spot_, and, what is more, seem like to remain there
indefinitely. Could anything in this untoward world have fallen out
better? Montrose is a bare three miles from where I sit, and I can
betake myself there on business when necessary, while I live as
secluded as I please, cheek by jowl with the very persons whose
acquaintance I had laid so many plots to compass. My dear grandmother,
could you but have seen me last night, when I lay down after my
labours, tricked out in my worshipful host's nightshirt! Though the
honest man is something of a fop in his attire, his arms are not so
long as mine, and the fine ruffles on the sleeves did little more than
adorn my elbows, which made me feel like a lady till I looked at my
skirts. Then I felt more like a highlandman. But I am telling you only
effects when you are wanting causes.

"I changed horses at Brechin, having got so far in safety just after
dark, and went on towards Montrose, with the wind rising and never a
star to look comfort at me through the coach window. Though I knew we
must be on the right road, I asked my way at every hovel we passed,
and was much interested when I was told that I was at the edge of my
Lord Balnillo's estate, and not far from his house.

"The road soon afterwards took a plunge into the very vilest place I
ever saw--a steep way scarcely fit for a cattle-road, between a mass
of trees. I put out my head and heard the rushing of water. Oh, what a
fine thing memory is! I remembered having heard of the Den of Balnillo
and being told that it was near Balnillo house, and I judged we must
be there. Another minute and we were clattering among stones; the
water was up to the axle and we rocked like a ship. One wheel was
higher than the other, and we leaned over so that I could scarcely
sit. Then I was inspired. I threw myself with all my weight against
the side, and dragged so much of my cargo of canvases as I could lay
hold of with me. There was a great splash and over we went. It was
mighty hard work getting out, for the devil caused the door to stick
fast, and I had to crawl through the window at that side of the coach
which was turned to the sky, like a roof. I hope I may never be
colder. We turned to and got the horses out and on to dry ground, and
the postilion, a very frog for slime and mud, began to shout, which
soon produced a couple of men with a lantern. I shouted too, and did
my poor best in the way of oaths to give the affair all the colour of
reality I could, and I believe I was successful. The noise brought
more people about us, and with them my lord's brother, Captain Logie,
hurrying to the rescue with a fellow who had run to the house with
news of our trouble. The result was that we ended our night, the coach
with a cracked axle and a hole in the panel, the postilion in the
servants' hall with half a bottle of good Scots whisky inside him, the
horses--one with a broken knee--in the stable, and myself, as I tell
you, in his lordship's nightshirt.

"I promise you that I thought myself happy when I got inside the
mansion--a solemn block, with a grand manner of its own and Corinthian
pillars in the dining-room. His lordship was on the hearthrug, as
solemn as his house, but with a pinched, precise look which it has not
got. He was no easy nut to crack, and it took me a little time to
establish myself with him, but the good James, his brother, left us a
little while alone, and I made all the way I could in his favour. I
may have trouble with the old man, and, at any rate, must be always at
my best with him, for he seems to me to be silly, virtuous and cunning
all at once. He is vain, too, and suspicious, and has seen so many
wicked people in his judicial career that I must not let him confound
me with them. I could see that he had difficulty in making my
occupation and appearance match to his satisfaction. He wears a
mouse-coloured velvet coat, and is very nice in the details of his
dress. I should like you to see him--not because he would amuse you,
but because it would entertain me so completely to see you together.

"James, his brother, is cut to a very different pattern. He is many
years younger than his lordship--not a dozen years older than myself,
I imagine--and he has spent much of his life with Lord Orkney's
regiment in Holland. There is something mighty attractive in his face,
though I cannot make out what it is. It is strange that, though he
seems to be a much simpler person than the old man, I feel less able
to describe him. I have had much talk with him this morning, and I
don't know when I have liked anyone better.

"And now comes the triumph of well-doing--the climax to which all this
faithful record leads. I am to paint his lordship's portrait (in his
Judge's robes), and am installed here definitely for that purpose! I
shall be grateful if you will send me my chestnut-brown suit and a
couple of fine shirts, also the silk stockings which are in the top
shelf of my cupboard, and all you can lay hands on in the matter of
cravats. My valise was soaked through and through, and, though the
clothes I am wearing were dried in the night, I am rather short of
good coats, for I expected to end in an inn at Montrose rather than in
a gentleman's house. Though I am within reach of Ardguys, and might
ride to fetch them in person, I do not want to be absent
unnecessarily. Any _important_ letters that I may send you will go by
a hand I know of. I shall go shortly to Montrose by way of procuring
myself some small necessity, and shall search for that hand. Its owner
should not be difficult to recognize, by all accounts. And now, my
dear grandmother, I shall write myself

     "Your dutiful and devoted grandson,


Archie sealed his letter, and then rose and leaned far out of the
window. The sun still bathed the land, but it was getting low; the
tree-tops were thrusting their heads into a light which had already
left the grass-parks slanting away from the house. The latter part of
his morning had been taken up by his host's slow inspection of his
canvases, and he longed for a sight of his surroundings. He knew that
the brothers had gone out together, and he took his hat and stood
irresolute, with his letter in his hand, before a humble-looking
little locked case, which he had himself rescued the night before from
among his submerged belongings in the coach, hesitating whether he
should commit the paper to it or keep it upon his own person. It
seemed to be a matter for some consideration. Finally, he put it into
his pocket and went out.

He set forth down one of the avenues, walking on a gorgeous carpet of
fallen leaves, and came out on a road running east and west, evidently
another connecting Brechin with Montrose. He smiled as he considered
it, realizing that, had he taken it last night, he would have escaped
the Den of Balnillo and many more desirable things at the same time.

As he stood looking up and down, he heard a liquid rush, and saw to
his right a mill-dam glimmering through the trees, evidently the goal
of the waters which had soused him so lately. He strolled towards it,
attracted by the forest of stems and golden foliage reflected in the
pool, and by the slide down which the stream poured into a field, to
wind, like a little serpent, through the grass. Just where it
disappeared stood a stone mill-house abutting on the highway, from
which came the clacking of a wheel. The miller was at his door. Archie
could see that he was watching something with interest, for the man
stood out, a distinct white figure, on the steps running up from the
road to the gaping doorway in the mill-wall.

Flemington was one of those blessed people for whom common sights do
not glide by, a mere meaningless procession of alien things.
Humanity's smallest actions had an interest for him, for he had that
love of seeing effect follow cause, which is at once priceless and
childish--priceless because anything that lifts from us the irritating
burden of ourselves for so much as a moment is priceless; and childish
because it is a survival of the years when all the universe was new.
Priceless yet again, because it will often lead us down unexpected
side-tracks of knowledge in a world in which knowledge is power.

He sat down on the low wall bounding the mill-field, for he was
determined to know what the miller was staring at. Whatever it was, it
was on the farther side of a cottage built just across the road from
the mill.

He was suddenly conscious that a bare-footed little girl with
tow-coloured hair had appeared from nowhere, and was standing beside
him. She also was staring at the house by the mill, but with
occasional furtive glances at himself. All at once the heavy drone of
a bagpipe came towards them, then the shrill notes of the chanter
began to meander up and down on the blare of sonorous sound like a
light pattern running over a dark background. The little girl removed
her eyes from the stranger and cut a caper with her bare feet, as
though she would like to dance.

It was evident that the sounds had affected Flemington, too, but not
in the same way. He made a sharp exclamation under his breath, and
turned to the child.

"Who is that playing?" he cried, putting out his hand.

She jumped back and stood staring.

"Who is that playing?" he repeated.

She was still dumb, scrubbing one foot against her bare ankle after
the manner of the shoeless when embarrassed.

Archie was exasperated. He rose, without further noticing the child,
and hurried towards the mill. When he had reached the place where the
stream dived through a stone arch under the road he found she was
following him. He heard the pad, pad, of her naked soles in the mud.

All at once she was moved to answer his question.

"Yon's Skirlin' Wattie!" she yelled after him.

But he strode on, taking no notice; fortune was playing into his hand
so wonderfully that he was ceasing to be surprised.

In the little yard of the cottage he found a small crowd of children,
two women, and the miller's man, collected round the strangest
assortment of living creatures he had ever seen. The name 'Skirlin'
Wattie' had conveyed something to him, and he was prepared for the
extraordinary, but his breath was almost taken away by the oddness of
what he saw.

In the middle of the group was a stout wooden box, which, mounted on
very low wheels, was transformed into the likeness of a rough go-cart,
and to this were yoked five dogs of differing breeds and sizes. A
half-bred mastiff in the wheel of the team was taking advantage of the
halt and lay dozing, his jowl on his paws, undisturbed by the blast of
sound which poured over his head, whilst his companion, a large,
smooth-haired yellow cur, stood alert with an almost proprietary
interest in what was going on awake in his amber eyes. The couple of
collies in front of them sniffed furtively at the bystanders, and the
wire-haired terrier, which, as leader, was harnessed singly in advance
of the lot, was sharing a bannock with a newly-breeched man-child, the
sinister nature of whose squint almost made the dog's confidence seem

The occupant of the cart was an elderly man, whom accident had
deprived of the lower part of his legs, both of which had been
amputated just below the knee. He had the head of Falstaff, the
shoulders of Hercules, and lack of exercise had made his thighs and
back bulge out over the sides of his carriage, even as the bag of his
pipes bulged under his elbow. He was dressed in tartan breeches and
doublet, and he wore a huge Kilmarnock bonnet with a red knob on the
top. The lower half of his face was distended by his occupation, and
at the appearance of Flemington by the gate, he turned on him, above
the billows of crimson cheek and grizzled whisker, the boldest pair of
eyes that the young man had ever met. He was a masterly piper, and as
the tune stopped a murmur of applause went through the audience.

"Man, ye're the most mountaineous player in Scotland!" said the
miller's man, who was a coiner of words.

"Aye, dod, am I!" replied the piper.

"Hae?" continued the miller's man, holding out an apple.

The beggar took it with that silent wag of the back of the head which
seems peculiar to the east coast of Scotland, and dropped it into the

Archie handed him a sixpence.

"Ye'll hae to gie us mair noo!" cried the squinting child, whose eyes
had seen straight enough, and who seemed to have a keen sense of

"Aye, a sang this time," added its mother.

"Ye'll get a pucklie meal an' a bawbee gin' ye sing 'The Tod,'"*
[*Fox.] chimed in an old woman, who had suddenly put her head out of
the upper story of the cottage.

The beggar laid down his pipes and spat on earth. Then he opened his
mouth and gave forth a voice whose volume, flexibility, and extreme
sweetness seemed incredible, considering the being from whom it

    "There's a tod aye blinkin' when the nicht comes doon,
     Blinkin' wi' his lang een, and keekin' round an' roun',
     Creepin' by the farm-yaird when gloamin' is to fa',
     And syne there'll be a chicken or a deuk awa'.
        Aye, when the guidwife rises there's a deuk awa'!

    "There's a lass sits greetin' ben the hoose at hame,
     For when the guidwife's cankered she gie's her aye the blame,
     And sair the lassie's sabbin', and fast the tears fa',
     For the guidwife's tynt a bonnie hen, and it's awa'.
        Aye, she's no sae easy dealt wi' when her gear's awa'!

    "There's a lad aye roamin' when the day gets late,
     A lang-leggit deevil wi' his hand upon the gate,
     And aye the guidwife cries to him to gar the toddie fa',
     For she canna thole to let her chicks an' deuks awa'.
        Aye, the muckle bubbly-jock himsel' is ca'ed awa'!

    "The laddie saw the tod gae by, an' killed him wi' a stane,
     And the bonnie lass wha grat sae sair she sits nae mair her lane,
     But the guidwife's no contented yet--her like ye never saw,
     Cries she, 'This time it is the lass, an' she's awa'!'
        Aye, yon laddie's waur nor ony tod, for Jean's awa'!"

Archie beat the top rail of the paling with so much enthusiasm that
the yellow cur began to bark. The beggar quieted him with a storm of

The beldame disappeared from the window, and her steps could be heard
descending the wooden stair of the cottage. She approached the cart
with a handful of meal on a platter which Skirling Wattie tilted into
an old leather bag that hung on his carriage.

"Whaur's the bawbee?" cried the squinting child.

A shout of laughter went up, led by Archie.

"He kens there's nae muckle weicht o' meal, and wha' should ken it
better?" said the beggar, balancing the bag on his palm and winking at
the miller's man.

The latter, who happened to be the child's unacknowledged parent,
disappeared behind the house.

"One more song, and I will supply the bawbee," said Archie, throwing
another coin into the cart.

Skirling Wattie sent a considering glance at his patron; though he
might not understand refinement, he could recognize it; and much of
his local success had come from his nice appraisement of audiences.

"I'll gie ye Logie Kirk," said he.

    "O Logie Kirk, among the braes
     I'm thinkin' o' the merry days
     Afore I trod the weary ways
        That led me far frae Logie.

    "Fine do I mind when I was young,
     Abune thy graves the mavis sung,
     And ilka birdie had a tongue
        To ca' me back to Logie.

    "O Logie Kirk, tho' aye the same,
     The burn sings ae remembered name,
     There's ne'er a voice to cry 'Come hame
        To bonnie Bess at Logie!'

    "Far, far awa' the years decline
     That took the lassie wha was mine
     And laid her sleepin' lang, lang syne
        Among the braes at Logie."

His voice, and the wonderful pathos of his phrasing, fascinated
Archie, but as the last cadences fell from his mouth, the beggar
snatched up the long switch with which he drove his team and began to

"A'm awa'!" he shouted, making every wall and corner echo. "Open the
gate an' let me through, ye misbegotten bairns o' Auld Nick! Stand
back, ye clortie-faced weans, an' let me out! Round about an' up the
road! Just round about an' up the road, a' tell ye!"

The last sentences were addressed to the dogs who were now all on
their legs and mindful of the stick whirling in the air above them.

Archie could see that he was not included in the beggar's general
address, but, being nearest to the gate, he swung it open and the
whole equipage dashed through, the dogs guided with amazing dexterity
between the posts by their master's switch. The rapid circle they
described on the road as they were turned up the hill towards Brechin
seemed likely to upset the cart, but the beggar leaned outwards so
adroitly that none of the four wheels left the ground. As they went up
the incline he took up his pipes, and leaving the team to its own
guidance, tuned up and disappeared round the next bend in a blast of

Flemington would have given a great deal to run after him, and could
easily have overtaken the cart, for its pace was not very formidable.
But the whole community, including the tow-headed little girl, was
watching Skirling Wattie out of sight and speculating, he knew, upon
his own identity. So he walked leisurely on till the road turned at
the top of the hill, and he was rewarded at the other side of its bend
by the sight of the beggar halting his team by a pond at which the
dogs were drinking. He threw a look around and behind him; then, as no
human creature was to be seen, he gave a loud whistle, holding up his
arm, and began to run.

Skirling Wattie awaited him at the pond-side, and as Archie
approached, he could almost feel his bold eyes searching him from top
to toe. He stopped by the cart.

"My name is Flemington," said he.

"A've heard worse," replied the other calmly.

"And I have a description of you in my pocket," continued Archie.
"Perhaps you would like to see it."

The beggar looked up at him from under his bushy eyebrows, with a
smile of the most robust and genial effrontery that he had ever seen
on a human face.

"A'd need to," said he.

Archie took a folded paper from his pocket.

"You see that signature," he said, putting his forefinger on it.

The other reached up to take the paper.

"No, no," said Flemington, "this never goes out of my hand."

"That's you!" exclaimed the beggar, with some admiration. "Put it
back. A' ken it."

He unhooked his leather bag, which hung inside the cart on its front
board. This Archie perceived to be made, apparently for additional
strength, of two thicknesses of wood. Skirling Wattie slid the inner
plank upwards, and the young man saw a couple of sealed letters hidden
behind it, one of which was addressed to himself.

"Tak' yon," said the beggar, as the sound of a horse's tread was heard
not far off, "tak' it quick an' syne awa' ye gang! Mind ye, a gang
ilka twa days frae Montrose to Brechin, an a'm aye skirlin' as a

"And do you take this one and have it sent on from Brechin," said
Archie hurriedly, handing him the letter he had written to Madam

The other wagged the back of his head, and laid a finger against the
rim of his bonnet.

Archie struck into the fields by the pond, and had time to drop down
behind a whin-bush before an inoffensive-looking farmer went by on his
way between the two towns.

The beggar continued his progress, singing to himself, and Flemington,
who did not care to face the mill and the curious eyes of the
tow-headed little girl again, took a line across country back to

He hated the tow-headed little girl.



EVENTS seemed to Flemington to be moving fast.

Lord Balnillo dined soon after five, and during the meal the young man
tried to detach his mind from the contents of the letter lying in his
pocket and to listen to his host's talk, which ran on the portrait to
be begun next morning.

The judge had ordered his robes to be taken out and aired carefully,
and a little room with a north aspect had been prepared for the first
sitting. The details of Archie's trade had excited the household below
stairs, and the servant who waited appeared to look upon him with the
curious mixture of awe and contempt accorded to charlatans and to
those connected with the arts. Only James seemed to remain outside the
circle of interest, like a wayfarer who pauses to watch the progress
of some wayside bargain with which he has no concern. Yet, though
Archie's occupations did not move Logie, the young man felt
intuitively that he was anything but a hostile presence.

"With your permission I shall go early to bed to-night," said
Flemington to his host, as the three sat over their wine by the
dining-room fire and the clock's hands pointed to eight.

"Fie!" said the judge; "you are a young man to be thinking of such
things at this hour."

"My bones have not forgotten yesterday----" began Archie.

"And what would you do if you had to ride the circuit, sir?" exclaimed
Balnillo, looking sideways at him like a sly old crow. "Man, James,
you and I have had other things to consider besides our bones! And
here's Mr. Flemington, who might be your son and my grandson, havering
about his bed!"

Archie laughed aloud.

"Captain Logie would need to have married young for that!" he cried.
"And I cannot picture your lordship as anybody's grandfather."

"Come, Jamie, how old are you?" inquired his brother in a tone that
had a light touch of gratification.

"I lose count nowadays," said James, sighing. "I must be near upon
eight-and-thirty, I suppose. Life's a long business, after all."

"Yours has scarcely been long enough to have begotten me, unless you
had done so at twelve years old," observed Archie.

"When I had to ride the circuit," began Balnillo, setting down his
glass and joining his hands across his waistcoat, "I had many a time
to stick fast in worse places than the Den yonder--ay, and to leave my
horse where he was and get forward on my clerk's nag. I've been forced
to sit the bench in another man's wig because my own had rolled in the
water in my luggage, and was a plaster of dirt--maybe never fit to be
seen again upon a Lord of Session's head."

Logie smiled with his crooked mouth. He remembered, though he did not
mention, the vernacular rhyme written on that occasion by some
impudent member of the junior bar:

    "Auld David Balnillo gangs wantin' his wig,
     And he's seekin' the loan of anither as big.
     A modest request, an' there's naething agin' it,
     But he'd better hae soucht a new head to put in it!"

"It was only last year," continued his brother, "that I gave up the
saddle and the bench together."

"That was more from choice than from necessity--at least, so I have
heard," said Archie.

"You heard that, Mr. Flemington?"

"My lord, do you think that we obscure country-folk know nothing? or
that reputations don't fly farther than Edinburgh? The truth is that
we of the younger generation are not made of the same stuff. That is
what my grandmother tells me so often--so often that, from force of
habit, I don't listen. But I have begun to believe it at last."

"She is a wise woman," said Balnillo.

"She has been a mighty attractive one," observed Archie meditatively;
"at least, so she was thought at St. Germain."

"At St. Germain?" exclaimed the judge.

"My grandfather died in exile with his master, and my father too,"
replied Flemington quietly.

There was a silence, and then James Logie opened his mouth to speak,
but Archie had risen.

"Let me go, Lord Balnillo," he said. "The truth is, my work needs a
steady hand, and I mean to have it when I begin your portrait

When he had gone James took the empty seat by his brother.

"His grandfather with the King, and he following this womanish trade!"
he exclaimed.

"I should like to have asked him more about his father," said
Balnillo; "but----"

"He did not wish to speak; I could see that," said James. "I like the
fellow, David, in spite of his paint-pots. I would like him much if I
had time to like anything."

"I have been asking myself: am I a fool to be keeping him here?" said
the other. "Was I right to let a strange man into the house at such a
time? I am relieved, James. He is on the right side."

"He keeps his ears open, brother."

"He seems to know all about _me_," observed Balnillo. "He's a fine
lad, Jamie--a lad of fine taste; and his free tongue hasn't interfered
with his good sense. And I am relieved, as I said."

Logie smiled again. The affection he had for his brother was of that
solid quality which accepts a character in the lump, and loves it for
its best parts. David's little vanities and vacillations, his
meticulous love of small things, were plain enough to the soldier, and
he knew well that the bench and the bar alike had found plenty to make
merry over in Balnillo. He had all the loyal feeling which the Scot of
his time bore to the head of his family, and, as his sentiments
towards him sprang from the heart rather than from the brain, it is
possible that he undervalued the sudden fits of shrewdness which would
attack his brother as headache or ague might attack another man. The
fact that David's colleagues had never made this mistake was
responsible for a career the success of which surprised many who knew
the judge by hearsay alone. Drink, detail and indecision have probably
ruined more characters than any three other influences in the world;
but the two latter had not quite succeeded with Lord Balnillo, and the
former had passed him over.

"I wonder----" said James--"I wonder is it a good chance that has sent
him here? Could we make anything of him, David?"

"Whisht, James!" said the other, turning his face away quickly. "You
go too fast. And, mind you, if a man has only one notion in his head,
there are times when his skull is scarce thick enough to stand between
his thoughts and the world."

"That is true. But I doubt Flemington's mind is too much taken up with
his pictures to think what is in other men's heads."

"Maybe," replied Balnillo; "but we'll know that better a few days
hence. I am not sorry he has gone to bed."

"I will give him an hour to get between his blankets," said Logie,
drawing out his watch. "That should make him safe."

Meanwhile Flemington had reached his room and was pulling his great
package of spare canvases from under his sombre four-poster. He undid
the straps which secured them and drew from between two of them a long
dark riding-coat, thrusting back the bundle into its place. He changed
his clothes and threw those he had taken off on a chair. Then he took
the little locked box he had saved so carefully from the catastrophe
of the previous night, and, standing on the bed, he laid it on the top
of the tester, which was near enough to the ceiling to prevent any
object placed upon it from being seen. He gathered a couple of
cushions from a couch, and, beating them up, arranged them between the
bedclothes, patting them into a human-looking shape. Though he meant
to lock his door and to keep the key in his pocket during the absence
he contemplated, and though he had desired the servants not to disturb
him until an hour before breakfast, he had the good habit of preparing
for the worst.

He slipped out with the coat over his arm, turned the key and walked
softly but boldly down into the hall. He paused outside the
dining-room, listening to the hum of the brothers' voices, then
disappeared down the back-stairs. If he found the door into the
stable-yard secured he meant to call someone from the kitchen regions
to open it and to announce that he was going out to look at his
disabled horse. He would say that he intended to return through the
front door, by which Captain Logie had promised to admit him.

Everything was quiet. The only sign of life was the shrill voice of a
maid singing in the scullery as she washed the dishes, and the house
was not shut up for the night. Through the yard he went and out
unmolested, under the great arch which supported the stable clock, and
then ran swiftly round to the front. He passed under the still lighted
windows and plunged into a mass of trees and undergrowth which headed
the eastern approach.

Once among the friendly shadows, he put on the coat, buttoning it
closely about his neck, and took a small grey wig from one of its deep
pockets. When he had adjusted this under his hat he emerged, crossed
the avenue, dropped over the sunk wall dividing it from the fields,
and made down them till he reached the Montrose road. Through the
still darkness the sound of the Balnillo stable clock floated after
him, striking nine.

There was not enough light to show him anything but his nearest
surroundings. The wall which bounded the great Balnillo grass-parks
was at his left hand, and by it he guided his steps, keeping a
perpetual look out to avoid stumbling over the inequalities and loose
stones, for there were no side-paths to the roads in those days. He
knew that the town was only three miles off, and that the dark stretch
which extended on his right was the Basin of Montrose. A cold snap
played in the air, reminding him that autumn, which in Scotland keeps
its mellowness late, was some way forward, and this sting in the
breath of night was indicated by a trembling of the stars in the dark
vault overhead.

He hastened on, for time was precious. The paper which he had taken
from Skirling Wattie's hands had bid him prepare to follow Logie into
the town when dark set in, but it had been able to tell him neither at
what hour the soldier would start nor whether he would walk or ride.

His chance in meeting the beggar so soon had put him in possession of
James's usual movements immediately, but it had given him little time
to think out many details, and the gaps in his plans had been filled
in by guesswork. He did not think James would ride, for there had been
no sound of preparation in the stable. His intention was to reach the
town first, to conceal himself by its entrance, and when James should
pass, to follow him to his destination. He had a rough map of Montrose
in his possession, and with its help he had been able to locate the
house for which he suspected him to be bound--a house known by the
party he served to be one of the meeting-places of the adherents of
Charles Edward Stuart.

Archie's buoyancy of spirit was sufficient to keep at arm's length a
regret he could not quite banish; for he had the happy carelessness
that carries a man easily on any errand which has possibilities of
development, more from the cheerful love of chance than from
responsible feeling. His light-hearted courage and tenacity were
buried so deep under a luxuriance of effrontery, grace, and
mother-wit, and the glamour of a manner difficult to resist, that
hardly anyone but Madam Flemington, who had brought him up, suspected
the toughness of their quality. He had the refinement of a woman, yet
he had extorted the wonder of an east-coast Scotsman by his
comprehensive profanity; the expression, at times, of a timid girl,
yet he would plunge into a flood of difficulties, whose further shore
he did not trouble to contemplate; but these contrasts in him spoke of
no repression, no conscious effort. He merely rode every quality in
his character with a loose rein, and while he attempted to puzzle
nobody, he had the acuteness to know that his audience would puzzle
itself by its own conception of him. The regret which he ignored was
the regret that he was obliged to shadow a man who pleased him as much
as did James Logie. He realized how much more satisfaction he would
have got out of his present business had its object been Lord
Balnillo. He liked James's voice, his bearing, his crooked mouth, and
something intangible about him which he neither understood nor tried
to understand. The iron hand of Madam Flemington had brought him up so
consistently to his occupation that he accepted it as a part of life.
His painting he used as a means, not as an end, and the changes and
chances of his main employment were congenial to a temperament at once
boyish and capable.

The Pleiades rode high above Taurus, and Orion's hands were coming up
over the eastern horizon as he reached the narrow street which was the
beginning of Montrose. The place was dark and ill-lit, like every
country town of those days; and here, by the North Port, as it was
called, the irregularities of the low houses, with their outside
stairs, offered a choice of odd corners in which he might wait unseen.

He chose the narrowest part of the street, that he might see across it
the more readily, and drew back into the cavity, roofed in by the
'stairhead' of a projecting flight of steps which ran sideways up a
wall. Few people would leave the town at that hour, and those who were
still abroad were likely to keep within its limits. A wretched lamp,
stuck in a niche of an opposite building, made his position all the
more desirable, for the flicker which it cast would be sufficient to
throw up the figure of Logie should he pass beneath it. He watched a
stealthy cat cross its shine with an air of suppressed melodrama that
would have befitted a man-eating tiger, and the genial bellowing of a
couple of drunken men came down the High Street as he settled his
shoulders against the masonry at his back and resigned himself to a
probable hour of tedium.

Not a mile distant, James Logie was coming along the Montrose road. He
had trodden it many times in the darkness during the past weeks, and
his mind was roving far from his steps, far even from the errand on
which he was bent. He was thinking of Archie, whom he believed to be
snug in bed at Balnillo.

He had gone out last night and landed this fantastic piece of young
humanity from the Den, as a man may land a salmon, and he had
contemplated him ever since with a kind of fascination. Flemington was
so much unlike any young man he had known that the difference half
shocked him, and though he had told his brother that he liked the
fellow, he had done so in spite of one side of himself. It was hard to
believe that but a dozen years divided them, for he had imagined
Archie much younger, and the appeal of his boyishness was a strong one
to Logie, who had had so little time for boyishness himself. His life
since he was fifteen had been merged in his profession, and the
restoration of the Stuarts had been for many years the thing nearest
to his heart. There had been one exception to this, and that had long
gone out of his life, taking his youth with it. He was scarcely a sad
man, but he had the habit of sadness, which is as hard a one to combat
as any other, and the burst of youth and buoyancy that had come in
suddenly with Archie had blown on James like a spring wind. Archie's
father and grandfather had died in exile, too, with Charles Edward's
parents. And his eyes reminded him of other eyes.

The events that had taken place since the landing of the Prince in
July had made themselves felt all up the east coast, and the country
was Jacobite almost to a man. Charles Edward had raised his standard
at Glenfinnan, had marched on Edinburgh in the early part of
September, and had established himself in Holyrood on the surrender of
the town. After his victory over Cope at Preston Pans, he had
collected his forces on Portobello sands--thirteen regiments composed
of the Highland clans, five regiments of Lowlanders, two troops of
horse commanded by Lords Elcho and Balmerino, with two others under
Lord Kilmarnock and Lord Pitsligo. The command of the latter consisted
of Angus men armed with such weapons as they owned or could gather.

The insurgent army had entered England in two portions: one of these
led by Lord George Murray, and one by the Prince himself, who marched
at the head of his men, sharing the fatigues of the road with them,
and fascinating the imagination of the Scots by his hopeful
good-humour and his keen desire to identify himself with his soldiers.
The two bodies had concentrated on Carlisle, investing the city, and
after a few days of defiance, the mayor displayed the white flag on
the ramparts and surrendered the town keys. After this, the Prince and
his father had been proclaimed at the market cross, in presence of the

But in spite of this success the signs of the times were not
consistently cheering to the Jacobite party. There had been many
desertions during the march across the border, and no sooner had the
Prince's troops left Edinburgh than the city had gone back to the Whig
dominion. At Perth and Dundee the wind seemed to be changing too, and
only the country places stuck steadily to the Prince and went on
recruiting for the Stuarts.

Although he was aching to go south with the invaders, now that the
English were advancing in force, Logie was kept in the neighbourhood
of Montrose by the business he had undertaken. His own instincts and
inclinations were ever those of a fighter, and he groaned in spirit
over the fate which had made it his duty to remain in Angus, concerned
with recruiting and the raising of money and arms. He had not yet
openly joined the Stuarts, in spite of his ardent devotion to their
cause, because it had been represented to him that he was, for the
moment, a more valuable asset to his party whilst he worked secretly
than he could be in the field. The question that perplexed the coast
of Angus was the landing of those French supplies so sorely needed by
the half-fed, half-clothed, half-paid troops, in the face of the
English cruisers that haunted the coast; and it was these matters that
kept Logie busy.

James knew the harbour of Montrose as men know the places which are
the scenes of the forbidden exploits of their youth. This younger son,
who was so far removed in years from the rest of his family as to be
almost like an only child, was running wild in the town among the
fisher-folk, and taking surreptitious trips across the bar when the
staid David was pursuing his respectable career at a very different
kind of bar in Edinburgh. He was the man that Montrose needed in this
emergency, and to-night he was on his way to the town; for he would
come there a couple of times in the week, as secretly as he could, to
meet one David Ferrier, a country gentleman who had joined the
regiment of six hundred men raised by Lord Ogilvie, and had been made
deputy-governor of Brechin for the Prince.

Ferrier also was a man well calculated to serve the cause. He owned a
small property and a farm not far from the village of Edzell, situated
at the foot of a glen running up into the Grampians, and his perfect
knowledge of the country and its inhabitants of all degrees gave him
an insight into every turn of feeling that swept through it in those
troubled days. The business of his farm had brought him continually
into both Brechin and Montrose, and the shepherds, travelling
incessantly with their flocks from hill to strath, formed one of his
many chains of intelligence. He had joined Lord Ogilvie a couple of
months earlier, and, though he was now stationed at Brechin with a
hundred men of his corps, he would absent himself for a night at a
time, staying quietly at Montrose in the house of a former dependent
of his own, that he might keep an eye upon the movements of an English

The Government sloop-of-war _Venture_ had come into the harbour,
carrying sixteen guns and about eighty men, and had anchored south of
the town, in the strait made by the passage of the River Esk into the
sea. Montrose, apparently, was to suffer for the work she had done as
a port for Stuart supplies, for the _Venture_, lying at a convenient
distance just under the fishing village of Ferryden, had fired heavily
on the town, though no Jacobite troops were there. The commander had
unrigged the shipping and burned two trading barques whose owners were
townsmen, and he had landed a force at the fort, which had captured
the town guns and had carried them on board a vessel lying at the

Ferrier looked with complete trust to James Logie and his brother
Balnillo. The old man, during his judicial career, had made some
parade of keeping himself aloof from politics; and as his retirement
had taken place previous to the landing of the Prince, he had sunk the
public servant in the country gentleman before the world of
politicians began to divide the sheep from the goats. For some time
few troubled their heads about the peaceable and cautious old Lord of
Session, whose inconspicuous talents were vegetating among the trees
and grass-parks that the late Lady Balnillo had husbanded so carefully
for him. As to his very much younger brother, who had been incessantly
absent from his native land, his existence was practically forgotten.
But because the Government's Secret Intelligence Department on the
east coast had remembered it at last with some suspicion, Flemington
had been sent to Montrose with directions to send his reports to its
agent in Perth. And Flemington had bettered his orders in landing
himself at Balnillo.

As Archie heard a steady tread approaching, he shrank farther back
under the stair. He could only distinguish a middle-sized male figure
which might belong to anyone, and he followed it with straining eyes
to within a few feet of the lamp. Here it paused, and, skirting the
light patch, stepped out into the middle of the way.

He scarcely breathed. He was not sure yet, though the man had come
nearer by half the street; but the height matched his expectation, and
the avoidance of the solitary light proved the desire for secrecy in
the person before him. As the man moved on he slipped from his shelter
and followed him, keeping just enough distance between them to allow
him to see the way he went.

The two figures passed up the High Street, one behind the other,
Flemington shrinking close to the walls and drawing a little nearer.
Before they had gone a hundred yards, his unconscious guide turned
suddenly into one of those narrow covered-in alleys, or closes, as
they are called, which started at right angles from the main street.

Archie dived in after him as unconcernedly as he would have dived into
the mouth of hell, had his interests taken him that way. These closes,
characteristic of Scottish towns to this day, were so long, and
burrowed under so many sightless-looking windows and doors, to emerge
in unexpected places, that he admired James's knowledge of the short
cuts of Montrose, though it seemed to him no more than natural. The
place for which he conceived him to be making was a house in the New
Wynd nicknamed the 'Happy Land,' and kept by a well-known widow for
purposes which made its insignificance an advantage. It was used, as
he had heard, by the Jacobite community, because the frequent visitors
who entered after dusk passed in without more comment from the
townspeople than could be expressed in a lifted eyebrow or a sly
nudge. It was a disconcerting moment, even to him, when the man in
front of him stopped, and what he had taken for the distant glimmer of
an open space revealed itself as a patch of whitewash with a door in
it. The close was a cul-de-sac.

Flemington stood motionless as the other knocked at the door. Flight
was undesirable, for James might give chase, and capture would mean
the end of a piece of work of which he was justly proud. He guessed
himself to be the fleeter-footed of the two, but he knew nothing of
the town's byways, and other night-birds besides Logie might join in.
But his bold wit did not desert him, for he gave a loud drunken shout,
as like those he had heard at the North Port as he could make it, and
lurched across the close. Its other inmate turned towards him, and as
he did so Archie shouted again, and, stumbling against him, subsided
upon the paved floor.

The door beyond them opened a little, showing a portion of a scared
face and a hand which held a light.

"Guid sakes! what'll be wrang?" inquired a tremulous female voice.

The man was standing over Archie, pushing him with his foot. His
answer may have reassured the questioner, but it had a different
effect upon the heap on the ground.

"Hoot, woman! don't be a fool! It's me--Ferrier!"



THE door opened a little further.

"Here," said Ferrier to the woman, "go up and bring me the roll of
unwritten paper from the table."

"You'll no be coming in?"

"Not now. Maybe in another hour or more."

"But wha's yon?" said she.

"Lord! woman, have you lived all these years in Montrose and never
seen a drunken man?" exclaimed he impatiently. "Shut the door, I'm
telling you, and get what I want. He will not trouble you. He's past
troubling anybody."

She obeyed, and Archie heard a bolt shot on the inside.

Though he had been startled on discovering his mistake, he now felt
comforted by it, for, being unknown to Ferrier, he was much safer with
him than he would have been with James. He raised his head and tried
to get an idea of his companion's face, but the darkness of the close
was too great to let him distinguish his features. He had discovered
where he lived by accident, but though a description of the man was in
the little box now reposing on the tester of his bed at Balnillo, he
did not know him by sight. These things were going through his mind as
the woman returned from her lodger's errand, and the door had just
been made fast again when there was a step at the close's mouth and
another man came quickly in, stopping short as he found it occupied.

Ferrier coughed.

"Ferrier?" said James's voice softly. "What is this?" he asked as his
foot came in contact with Archie.

"It's a drunken brute who came roaring in here a minute syne and fell
head over heels at my door," replied the other. "The town is full of
them to-night."

He stooped down and took Flemington by the shoulder.

"Up you get!" he cried, shaking him.

Archie breathed heavily and let his whole weight hang on Ferrier's

"Haud awa' frae me, lassie!" he expostulated thickly.

Logie laughed.

"He must be far gone indeed to take you for a lass," he observed.

Ferrier gave Archie a stronger shake.

"A'll no gang hame wantin' Annie!" continued Flemington, whose humour
was beginning to find some pleasure in the situation.

The raw vernacular that he had mastered with absolute success in
childhood was at his tongue's end still.

"Come, come," said James.

Ferrier moved forward, but Archie had reached out a limp hand and
taken him by the ankle.

"Annie!" he muttered, "ma bonnie, bonnie Annie!"

Ferrier, who had nearly fallen forward, tried to strike out with his
foot, but Archie's grip, nerveless yet clinging as a limpet, held him

"A' tell ye, a'll nae gang hame wantin' Annie!" he repeated more

"He has me by the foot, damn him!" said Ferrier.

James swore quietly but distinctly.

"Annie! _Annie!_" roared Archie, making the silent close echo again.

"Great heavens!" exclaimed the exasperated James, "we shall have the
whole town out of bed if this goes on! Shake him off, man, and let us
be going."

He bent down as he spoke and groping in the darkness, found
Flemington's heels. He seized them and began to drag him backwards as
a man drags a fighting dog. He had a grip of iron.

The effect of the sudden pull on Ferrier was to make him lose his
balance. He staggered against the side of the close, calling to Logie
to desist.

Archie still held on with back-boneless tenacity; but as the scrape of
flint and steel cut the darkness, he knew that he had carried his
superfluous pleasantries too far. He dared not loose Ferrier's ankle
and roll to the wall, lest the action should prove him to be more
wideawake and less intoxicated than he seemed. He could only bury his
face in his sleeve.

His next sensation was a violent stab of burning pain in his wrist
that made him draw it back with a groan.

"I knew that would mend matters," said James grimly, as he blew out
the tiny twist of ignited tow and replaced it and the steel box in his
pocket. "Come away--this sot has wasted our time long enough. He can
sleep off his liquor as well here as anywhere else."

"You've helped to sober him," said Ferrier, as the two men went out of
the close.

Flemington sat up. The burn stung him dreadfully, for the saltpetre in
which the tow had been dipped added to the smart. But there was no
time to be lost, so he rose and followed again.

Ferrier and Logie went off up the High Street, and turned down an
offshoot of it which Archie guessed to be the New Wynd, because it
answered to its position in his map of the town. He dashed to the
corner and watched them by the one light which illuminated the narrow
street till he could see them no longer. Then he flitted after them, a
soft-footed shadow, and withdrew under a friendly 'stairhead,' as he
had done at the North Port. A little farther on he could distinguish
the two ascending an outside stair to a squat building, and he heard
the sound of their knuckles on wood. Another minute and they were

The two captains were let into a small room in the back premises of
'The Happy Land' by a slatternly-looking woman, who disappeared when
she had given them a light. Pens and ink lay upon the table and the
smoke of lamps had blackened the ceiling. It was a wretched place, and
the sound of rough voices came now and again from other parts of the
house. James drew up a chair, and Ferrier also sat down, tossing the
roll of paper to his companion.

"A young man called Flemington is at Balnillo painting my brother's
portrait," said Logie. "It's a pity that I have not something of his
gift for drawing."

"Flemington----?" said the other. "There is a widow Flemington who
lives a mile or so this side of the Perthshire border; but that is the
only part of the country I do not know."

"This is her grandson. She lived at St. Germain, and her husband was
with King James. He is a strange lad--a fine lad too. My brother seems
mightily taken up with him."

"Where is your plan?" asked Ferrier.

James took out a small pocket-book and laid it on the table; then he
smoothed out the roll of paper, drew the points of the compass on it,
and began to copy from the rough sketches and signs which covered the
leaf of his little book.

Ferrier watched him in silence.

"I could not do that were it to save my life," he said at last.

"I learned something, campaigning by the walls of Dantzig," replied

Ferrier watched the growing of the hasty map with admiration. His own
talents for organization and tactics had given this obscure landowner
the position he held in the Prince's haphazard army, but the
professional soldier was invaluable to him. He sat wondering how he
could have got on without James.

"See," said Logie, pushing the paper to him, "here lies the _Venture_
off Ferryden, at the south side of the river, and here is Inchbrayock
Island. That English captain is a fool, or he would have landed some
men there. You and I will land on it, Ferrier. And now," he went on,
"the man is twice a fool, for, though he has taken the guns from the
fort and put them on board one of the unrigged ships, he has left her
beside the quay. This point that I have marked with a cross is where
she is moored. It would be idle not to make use of such folly! Why,
man, if we can carry through the work I have in my mind, we shall blow
the _Venture_ out of the water! Three nights I have skulked round the
harbour, and now I think that every close and every kennel that opens
its mouth upon it is in my head. And the island is the key to

Logie's eyes shone in the dim room like the eyes of some animal
watching in a cave.

"We must get possession of the ship at the quay-side," continued he.
"Then we will take a couple of the town guns and land them on
Inchbrayock. A hundred men from Brechin should be sufficient."

"It must be done at night," said the other.

"At night," said James, getting up and putting his hands on the back
of his chair. "And now, as soon as possible, we must go down to the
harbour and look carefully at the position of everything."

Ferrier stood up and stretched himself, as men so often will when they
are turning over some unacknowledged intention.

James took up the roll of paper, glanced at it and threw it down

"I see it as though it had come by inspiration!" he cried. "I see that
we have a blockhead to deal with, and when heaven sends such an
advantage to His Highness, it is not you nor I, Ferrier, who will balk
its design. You will not hang back?"

He looked at his friend as though he were ready to spring at him. But
Ferrier went on with his own train of thought. He was a slower man
than Logie, but if he lacked his fire, he lacked none of his

"You are right," he said. "A man is a fool who leaves what he has
captured on the farther side of the river, who thinks, having taken
his enemy's guns from a fort, that he can let it stand empty. He has
done these follies because he knows that there are no troops in

"Ay, but there are troops in Brechin!" burst out James.

"There are troops in Brechin," repeated Ferrier slowly, "and they must
be got quietly into the town. I wish there were not eight miles of
road between the two."

"I have not forgotten that," said James, "and to-night I mean to
remain here till daylight and then return home by the side of the
Basin. I will make my way along its shore and judge whether it be
possible for you to bring your men by that route. If you can get them
out of Brechin by the river-bank and so on along the side of the Esk,
you will avoid the road and I will be waiting for you at the fort."

Logie had come round the little table and stood by his friend, waiting
for him to speak.

"I will go with you," said Ferrier. "We can part below Balnillo, and
I, too, will go back to Brechin by the river. I must know every step
before I attempt to bring them in the dark. There must be no delays
when the time comes."

James drew a long sigh of relief. He had never doubted his companion's
zeal, but his heart had been on fire with the project he carried in
it, and Ferrier's complete acceptance of it was balm to his spirit. He
was a man who spared himself nothing, mentally or physically.

He folded the roll of paper and gave it to Ferrier.

"Keep it," said he. "Now we must go to the harbour."



WHEN the men had disappeared into the house, Archie remained under his
stairhead considering. He had been told in his instructions to
discover two things--whether Logie was in touch with Ferrier, and
whether 'The Happy Land' was frequented by the pair. Though Ferrier
was in command of the small Jacobite force in Brechin, it was
suspected that he spent an unknown quantity of his time in Montrose.

To the first of these questions he had already mastered the answer; it
only remained for him to be absolutely certain that the house in front
of him was 'The Happy Land.' He could not swear that he was in the New
Wynd, though he was morally certain of it, but there were marks upon
the house which would be proof of its identity. There would be a
little hole, covered by an inside sliding panel, in the door of 'The
Happy Land,' through which its inmates could see anyone who ascended
the stair without being seen themselves, and there would be the
remains of an ancient 'risp,' or tirling-pin, at one side of it.

Archie ran lightly across the street, crept up the staircase, and
passed his palm over the wood. Yes, there was the hole, two inches
deep in the solid door. He put in his finger and felt the panel in the
farther side. Then he searched along the wall till his hand came in
contact with the jagged edge of the ancient risp. There was no ring on
it, for it had long been disused, but it hung there still--a useless
and maimed veteran, put out of action.

He returned to his post satisfied. His discoveries had earned him the
right to go home, but he did not mean to do so. How he was going to
get back into Balnillo House, unseen, he did not know, and had not, so
far, troubled himself to imagine. Perhaps he might have to stop out
all night. He hoped not, but he was not going to meet trouble
half-way. The house would be locked, the household--with the exception
of the errant James--abed, and his own room was not upon the
ground-floor. However, these were matters for later consideration, and
he would remain where he was for a time. For all he knew, Ferrier and
Logie might combine business with pleasure by staying in 'The Happy
Land' till morning; but they were just as likely to come out within
measurable time, and then he could see where they went. He was quite
happy, as he was everywhere.

He fell to thinking of other things: of his host, with his thin, neat
legs and velvet coat; of that 'riding the circuit' upon which the old
man valued himself so much. In his mind's eye he figured him astride
of his floundering nag at the edge of some uninviting bog in an access
of precise dismay. That was how he would have wished to paint him. His
powers of detachment were such that he became fascinated by the idea,
and awoke from it with a start to hear the footsteps of Logie and
Ferrier coming down the stairway opposite.

They did not retrace their way up the Wynd, but went on to its end and
turned into a street leading southwards, whilst Archie slipped along
in their wake. At last they reached a wilderness of sheds and lumber,
above which stood a windmill on a little eminence, and the strong
smell of sea and tar proclaimed the region of the harbour. A light
shone clear and large across the dark space of water, touching the
moving ripples, and this Archie guessed to be the riding-light of the
_Venture_, which lay like a sullen watch-dog under Ferryden village.

He had to go very warily, for the pair in front stopped often and
stood talking in low voices, but the bales and coils of rope and heaps
of timber with which the quays were strewn gave him cover. He could
not get close enough to them to hear what they said, but their figures
were much plainer against the background of water than they had been
in the streets, and he noted how often Logie would stretch out his
arm, pointing to the solitary light across the strait.

There was scarcely any illumination on this side of it, and the
unrigged shipping lay in darkness as Ferrier and his friend went along
the quay and seated themselves on a windlass. Archie, drawing closer,
could hear the rustle as the former unrolled James's map. The soldier
took out his flint and steel and struck a light, covering it with his
hand, and both men bent their heads over the paper. Archie's wrist
smarted afresh as he saw it; his sleeve had rubbed the burn, and he
could feel the oozing blood.

He crouched behind them, peering through the medley of ropes and
tackle which hung on the windlass. By standing up he could have
touched the two men. He had no idea what it was that they were
studying, but his sharp wits told him that it must be a map of some
kind, something which might concern the English ship across the
waterway. He longed to get it. His confidence in his own luck was one
of the qualities that had served him best, and his confidence in his
own speed was great and, moreover, well-placed. He knew that he had
twelve years of advantage over James, and, from the sound of Ferrier's
voice, he judged that he had the same, or more, over him.

The temptation of chance overmastered him. He raised himself
noiselessly, leaned over the intervening tackle, and made a bold
snatch at the map, which Ferrier held whilst James was occupied with
the lighted twist of tow.

But his luck was to fail him this time. Logie moved his hand, knocking
it against Flemington's, and the light caught the paper's edge. A soft
puff of sea-wind was coming in from over the strait, and in one moment
the sheet was ablaze. Archie snatched back his hand and fled; but the
glare of the burning paper had been bright enough to show Logie a
man's wrist, on which there was a fresh, bleeding mark.

The bright flare of the paper only intensified the darkness for the
two astounded men, and though each was instantly on his feet and
running in the direction of the retreating footsteps, Archie had
threaded the maze of amphibious obstacles and was plunging between the
sheds into the street before either of them could get clear of the
pitfalls of the quay.

He tore on, not knowing whither he went. His start had been a good
one, but as he paused to listen, which he did when he had gone some
way, he could hear them following. The town was so quiet that he met
nobody, and he pressed on, trusting to luck for his direction.

Through the empty streets he went at the top of his speed, launched on
the flood of chance, and steering as best he could for the north end
of the town. Finally, an unexpected turning brought him within a few
yards of the North Port. He waited close to the spot where he had
first taken shelter, and listened; then, hearing nothing, he struck
out at a brisk walk for the country, and was soon clear of Montrose.

He sat down by the wayside to rest. He had had a more sensational
night than he expected, and though his spirits were still good, his
ill-luck in missing the paper he had risked so much to obtain had
cooled them a little, and by the light of this disappointment he
looked rather ruefully on his poor prospects of getting to bed. It was
past midnight, and there seemed nothing to do but to return to
Balnillo and to make himself as comfortable as he could in one of the
many out-buildings which the yard by its back-door contained. The
household rose early, and at the unlocking of that door he must manage
to slip in and gain his bedroom.

He rose, plodded home, and stole into the courtyard, where, searching
in an outhouse, he found an endurable couch on a heap of straw. On
this he spread his coat like a blanket, crawling under it, and, with a
calmness born of perfect health and perfect nerves, was soon asleep.

When dawn broke it found him wakeful. He had not rested well, for his
burnt wrist was very sore, and the straw seemed to find it out and to
prick the wound, no matter how he might dispose his hand. He propped
himself against the wall by the open outhouse-window, whence he could
see the back door of Balnillo and watch for the moment of its first
opening. It would be neck or nothing then, for he must enter boldly,
trusting to hit on a lucky moment.

At last the growing light began to define details of the house,
tracing them out on its great mass with an invisible pencil, and he
thought he heard a movement within. The stable-clock struck six, and
high above he could see the sun touching the slates and the stone
angles of the chimney-stacks with the first fresh ethereal beam of a
pure October morning. He inhaled its breath lovingly, and with it
there fell from him the heaviness of his uneasy night. All was well,
he told himself. His sensuous joy in the world, his love of life and
its hazards and energies came back upon him, strong, clean, and
ecstatic, and the sounds of a bolt withdrawn made him rise to his

A maidservant came out carrying a lantern, whose beam burned with
feeble pretentiousness in the coming sunlight. She set it down by the
threshold and went past his retreat to the stable. No doubt she was
going to call the men. When she had gone by he slipped out, and in a
dozen paces was inside the house.

Another minute and he was in his room.

He looked with some amusement at the rough effigy of himself which he
had made in the bed overnight, and when he had flung the cushion back
to its place he got out of his clothes and lay down, sinking into the
cool luxury of the sheets with a sigh of pleasure. But he had no
desire to sleep, and when a servant came to wake him half an hour
later he was ready to get up. He rose, dressed, wrote out the detailed
description of his night's discoveries, and put the document in his
pocket to await its chance of transmission.

A message was brought to him from Lord Balnillo as he left his room,
which begged his guest to excuse his company at breakfast. He had been
long astir, and busy with his correspondence; at eleven o'clock he
would be ready for his sitting, if that were agreeable to Mr.

As Mr. Flemington realized how easily he might have met the judge as
he ran through the shuttered passage, his belief in the luck that had
used him so scurvily last night returned.

There was no sign of James as Archie sat down to his meal, though a
second place was set at the table, and as he did not want to ask
embarrassing questions, he made no inquiry about him. Besides which,
being immoderately hungry, he was too well occupied to trouble about

He went out upon the terrace when he had finished. The warm greyness
of the autumn morning was lifting from the earth and it was still
early enough for long shadows to lie cool on the westward side of the
timber. As they shortened, the crystal of the dew was catching shafts
from the sun, and the parks seemed to lie waiting till the energy of
the young day should let loose the forces of life from under the
mystery of its spangled veil. Where the gean-trees glowed carmine and
orange, touches of quickening fire shot through the interstices of
their branches, and coloured like a tress of trailing forget-me-not,
the South Esk wound into the Basin of Montrose, where the tide, ebbing
beyond the town, was leaving its wet sands as a feasting-ground for
all sorts of roving birds whose crying voices came faintly to Archie,
mellowed by distance.

Truly this was a fascinating place, with its changing element of
distant water, its great plain lines of pasture, its ordered vistas of
foliage! The passion for beauty lay deep below the tossing, driving
impulses of Flemington's nature, and it rose up now as he stood on the
yew-edged terraces of Balnillo and gazed before him. For the moment
everything in his mind was swallowed up but the abstract, fundamental
desire for perfection, which is, when all is said and done, humanity's
mainspring, its incessant though often erring guide, whose perverted
behests we call sin, whose legitimate ones we call virtue; whose very
existence is a guarantee of immortality.

The world, this crystalline morning, was so beautiful to Archie that
he ached with the uncomprehended longing to identify himself with
perfection; to cast his body down upon the light-pervaded earth and to
be one with it, to fling his soul into the heights and depths of the
limitless encompassing ether, to be drawn into the heart of God's
material manifestation on earth--the sun. He understood nothing of
what he felt, neither the discomfort of his imprisonment of flesh, nor
the rapturous, tentative, wing-sweeps of the spirit within it. He left
the garden terrace and went off towards the Basin, with the touch of
that elemental flood of truth into which he had been plunged for a
moment fresh on his soul. The whole universe and its contents seemed
to him good--and not only good, but of consummate interest--humanity
was fascinating. His failure to snatch the map from Ferrier's hand
last night only made him smile. In the perfection of this transcendent
creation all was, and must be, well!

His thoughts, woven of the same radiant appreciation, flew to James,
whose personality appealed to him so strongly. The gentle blood which
ran in the veins of the pair of brothers ran closer to the surface in
the younger one; and a steadfast, unostentatious gallantry of heart
seemed to be the atmosphere in which he breathed. He was one of those
whose presence in a room would always be the strongest force in it,
whether he spoke or was silent, and his voice had the tone of
something sounding over great and hidden depths. It was not necessary
to talk to him to know that he had lived a life of vicissitude, and
Archie, all unsuspected, in the watches of last night had seen a side
of him which did not show at Balnillo. His grim resourcefulness in
small things was illustrated by the raw spot on the young man's wrist.
That episode pleased Flemington's imagination--though it might have
pleased him even better had the victim been someone else; but he bore
James no malice for it, and the picture of the man haunting the dark
quays, strewn with romantic, sea-going lumber, and scheming for the
cause at his heart, whilst the light from the hostile ship trailed the
water beside him, charmed his active fancy.

But it was not only his fancy that was at work. He knew that the
compelling atmosphere of Logie had not been created by mere fancy,
because there was something larger than himself, and larger than
anything he could understand, about the soldier. And feeling, as he
was apt to do, every little change in the mental climate surrounding
him he had guessed that Logie liked him. The thought added to the
exultation produced in him by the glory of the pure morning; and he
suddenly fell from his height as he remembered afresh that he was here
to cheat him.

It was with a shock that he heard Skirling Wattie's pipes as he
reached the Montrose road, and saw the beggar's outlandish cart
approaching, evidently on its return journey to Montrose. His heart
beat against the report that lay in his pocket awaiting the
opportunity that Fate was bringing nearer every moment. There was
nobody to be seen as the beggar drew up beside him. The insolent
joviality that pervaded the man, his almost indecent oddness--things
which had pleased Archie yesterday struck cold on him now. He had no
wish to stay talking to him, and he gave him the paper without a word
more than the injunction to have it despatched.

He left him, hurrying across the Montrose road and making for the
place where the ground began to fall away to the Basin. He sat down on
the scrubby waste land by a broom-bush, whose dry, burst pods hung
like tattered black flags in the brush of green; their acrid smell was
coming out as the sun mounted higher. Below him the marshy ground ran
out to meet the water; and eastward the uncovered mud and wet sand,
bared by the tide ebbing beyond Montrose, stretched along its shores
to the town.

The fall of the broom-covered bank was steep enough to hide anyone
coming up from the lower levels, and he listened to the movements of
somebody who was approaching, and to the crackling noise of the bushes
as they were thrust apart.

The sound stopped; and Archie, leaning forward, saw James standing
half-way up the ascent, with his back turned towards him, looking out
across the flats. He knew what his thoughts were. He drew his right
sleeve lower. So long as he did not stretch out his arm the mark could
not be seen.

He did not want to appear as if he were watching Logie, so he made a
slight sound, and the other turned quickly and faced him, hidden from
the waist downwards in the broom. Then his crooked lip moved, and he
came up the bank and threw himself down beside Flemington.



JAMES did not look as if he had been up all night, though he had spent
the most part of it on foot with Ferrier. The refreshment of morning
had bathed him too, but he was still harassed in mind by some of the
occurrences of the last few hours. Last night he had seen the mark on
the wrist stretched suddenly between himself and his friend, and had
understood its significance. It was the mark that he had put there. As
the two men listened to the flying footsteps that mystified them by
their doublings in the darkness, it had dawned upon them that the
intruder skulking behind the windlass and the tipsy reveller prone in
the close were one and the same person. The drunkard was a very daring
spy, as sober as themselves.

"You are out betimes," said Archie, with friendly innocence.

"I often am," replied James simply.

Archie pulled up a blade of grass and began to chew it meditatively.

"I see your long night has done you good," began Logie. "There were
many things I should have liked to ask you, yesterday evening, but you
went away so early that I could not."

Silence dropped upon the two: upon Logie, because his companion's
manner last night had hinted at remembrances buried in regret and
painful to dig up; on Flemington, because he knew the value of that
impression, and because he would fain put off the moment when the more
complete deception of the man whose sympathetic attitude he divined
and whose generosity of soul was so obvious, must begin. He did not
want to come to close quarters with James. He had hunted him and been
hunted by him, but he had not yet been obliged to lie to him by word
of mouth; and he had no desire to do so, here and now, in cold blood
and in the face of all this beauty and peace.

"I could not but be interested in what you said," continued the other.
"You did not tell us whether you had been at St. Germain yourself."

"Never!" replied Archie. "I was sent to Scotland at eight years old,
and I have been here ever since."

He had taken the plunge now, for he had been backwards and forwards to
France several times in the last few years, since he had begun to work
for King George, employed in watching the movements of suspicious
persons between one country and the other.

He looked down on the ground.

The more he hesitated to speak, the more he knew that he would impress
James. He understood the delicacy of his companion's feeling by
instinct. It was not only dissimulation which bade him act thus, it
was the real embarrassment and discomfort which were creeping on him
under the eyes of the honourable soldier; all the same, he hoped that
his reluctant silence would save him.

"You think me impertinent," said Logie, "but do not be afraid that I
mean to pry. I know how hard life can be and how anxious, nowadays.
There is so much loss and trouble--God knows what may happen to this
tormented country! But trouble does not seem natural when a man is
young and light-hearted, as you are."

Archie was collecting materials wherewith to screen himself from his
companion's sympathy. It would be easy to tell him some rigmarole of
early suffering, of want endured for the cause which had lain dormant,
yet living, since the unsuccessful rising of the '15, of the devotion
to it of the parents he had scarcely known, of the bitterness of their
exile, but somehow he could not force himself to do it. He remembered
those parents principally as vague people who were ceaselessly playing
cards, and whose quarrels had terrified him when he was small. His
real interest in life had begun when he arrived at Ardguys and made
the acquaintance of his grandmother, whose fascination he had felt, in
common with most other male creatures. He had had a joyous youth, and
he knew it. He had run the pastures, climbed the trees, fished the
Kilpie burn, and known every country pleasure dear to boyhood. If he
had been solitary, he had yet been perfectly happy. He had gone to
Edinburgh at seventeen, at his own ardent wish, to learn painting, not
as a profession, but as a pastime. His prospects were comfortable, for
Madam Flemington had made him her heir, and she had relations settled
in England who were always ready to bid him welcome when he crossed
the border. Life had been consistently pleasant, and had grown
exciting since the beginning of his work for Government. He wished to
Heaven he had not met James this morning.

But to Logie, Archie was merely a youth of undoubted good breeding
struggling bravely for his bread in an almost menial profession, and
he honoured him for what he deemed his courage. There was no need to
seek a reason for his poverty after hearing his words last night. His
voice, when he spoke of his father's death in exile, had implied all
that was necessary to establish a claim on James's generous and rather
bigoted heart. For him, there were only two kinds of men, those who
were for the Stuarts and those who were not. People were very reticent
about their political feelings in those days; some from pure caution
and some because these lay so deep under mountains of personal loss
and misfortune.

"I dare not look back," said Archie, at last, "I have to live by my
trade and fight the world with my brush. You live by sticking your
sword into its entrails and I by painting its face a better colour
than Nature chose for it, and I think yours is the pleasanter calling
of the two. But I am grateful to mine, all the same, and now it has
procured me the acquaintance of his lordship and the pleasure of being
where I am. I need not tell you that I find myself in clover."

"I am heartily glad of it," said James.

"Indeed, so am I," rejoined Archie, pleased at having turned the
conversation so deftly, "for you cannot think what strange things
happen to a man who has no recognized place in the minds of
respectable people."

James rolled over on his chest, leaning on his elbows, and looked up
at his companion sitting just above him with his dark, silky head
clear cut against the background of green bush. The young man's words
seemed to trip out and pirouette with impudent jauntiness in their
hearer's face. Logie did not know that Archie's management of these
puppets was a part of his charm. His detached points of view were
restful to a man like James, one continually preoccupied by large
issues. It was difficult to think of responsibilities in Archie's

"You might never imagine how much I am admired below stairs!" said the
latter. "While I painted a lady in the south, I was expected to eat
with the servants, and the attentions of a kitchen-girl all but cost
me my life. I found a challenge, offering me the choice of weapons in
the most approved manner, under my dish of porridge. It came from a

"What did you do?" asked James, astounded.

"I chose warming-pans," said Archie, "and that ended the matter."

James laughed aloud, but there was bitterness in his mirth. And this
was a man born at St. Germain!

"We laugh," said he, "but such a life could have been no laughing
matter to you."

"But I assure you it was! What else could I do?"

"You could have left the place----" began James. Then he stopped
short, remembering that beggars cannot be choosers.

His expression was not lost on Archie, who saw that the boat he had
steered so carefully into the shallows was drawing out to deep water
again, and that he had used his luxuriant imagination to small
purpose. He had so little self-consciousness that to keep James's
interest upon himself was no temptation to him, though it might have
been to some men. He cast about for something wherewith to blot his
own figure from the picture.

"And you," he said, gravely, "you who think so much of my discomforts,
and who have actually wielded the sword while I have merely threatened
to wield the warming-pan--you must have seen stranger things than the

"I?" said James, looking fixedly out to where the town steeple threw
its reflection on the wet sand--"yes. I have seen things that I hope
you will never see. It is not for me to speak ill of war, I who have
turned to it for consolation as a man may turn to his religion. But
war is not waged against men alone in some countries. I have seen it
when it is waged against women and little children, when it is
slaughter, not war. I have seen mothers--young, beautiful
women--fighting like wild beasts for the poor babes that cowered
behind their skirts, and I have seen their bodies afterwards. It would
be best to forget--but who can forget?"

Archie sat still, with eyes from which all levity had vanished. He had
known vaguely that James had fought under Marshal Lacy in the War of
the Polish Succession, in the bloody campaign against the Turks, and
again in Finland. The ironic futility of things in general struck him,
for it was absurd to think that this man, seared by war and wise in
the realities of events whose rumours shook Europe, one who had looked
upon death daily in company with men like Peter Lacy, should come home
to be hunted down back streets by a travelling painter. He
contemplated his companion with renewed interest; no wonder he was
ruthless in small things. He was decidedly the most fascinating person
he had known.

"And you went to these things _for consolation_--so you said?"

"For consolation. For a thing that does not exist," said the other

He paused and turned to his companion with an expression that
horrified the young man and paralyzed his curiosity. The power in his
face seemed to have given way, revealing, for a moment, a
defencelessness like the defencelessness of a child looking upon the
dark; and it told Archie that there was something that even Logie
dreaded and that that something was memory.

The deep places he had guessed in James's soul were deep indeed, and
again Flemington was struck with humility, for his own unimportance in
contrast with this experienced man seemed little less than pitiful.
The feeling closed his lips, and he looked round at the shortening
shadows and into the stir of coming sunlight as a man looks round for
a door through which to escape from impending stress. He, who was
always ready to go forward, recoiled because of what he foresaw in
himself. His self-confidence was ebbing, for he was afraid of how much
he might be turned out of his way by the influence on him of Logie. He
wished that he could force their talk into a different channel, but
his ready wits for once would not answer the call.

Something not understood by him was moving James to expression, as
reserved men are compelled towards it at times. Perhaps the bygone
youth in him rose up in response to the youth at his side. The many
years dividing him from his brother, the judge, had never consciously
troubled him in their intercourse, but the tremendous divergence in
their respective characters had thrown him back upon himself. Archie
seemed to have the power of turning a key that Balnillo had never

"But I am putting you out of conceit with the world," cried James
abruptly; "let no one do that. Take all you can, Flemington! I did--I
took it all. Love, roystering, good company, good wine, good play--all
came to me, and I had my bellyful! There were merry times in Holland
with the Scots Brigade. It was the best part of my life, and I went to
it young. I was sixteen the day I stood up on parade for the first

"I have often had a mind to invade Holland," observed Archie, grasping
eagerly at the impersonal part of the subject; "it would be paradise
to one of my trade. The very thought of a windmill weaves a picture
for me, and those strange, striped flowers the Dutchmen raise--I
cannot think of their names now--I would give much to see them
growing. You must have seen them in every variety and hue."

"Ay, I saw the tulips," said James, in a strange voice.

"The Dutchmen can paint them too," said Archie hurriedly.

"What devil makes you talk of tulips?" cried James. "Fate painted the
tulips for me. Oh, Flemington, Flemington! In every country, in every
march, in every fight, among dead and dying, and among dancers and the
music they danced to, I have seen nothing but those gaudy
flowers--beds of them growing like a woven carpet, and Diane among

No feminine figure had come into the background against which stood
Archie's conception of Logie.

"Diane?" he exclaimed involuntarily.

James did not seem to hear him.

"Her eyes were like yours," he went on. "When I saw you come into the
light of the house two evenings since, I thought of her."

Neither spoke for a few moments; then James went on again:

"Fourteen years since the day I saw her last! She looked out at me
from the window with her eyes full of tears. The window was filled
with flowers--she loved them. The tulips were there again--crimson
tulips--with her white face behind them."

Flemington listened with parted lips. His personal feelings, his
shrinking dread of being drawn into the confidence of the man whom it
was his business to betray, were swallowed by a wave of interest.

"I was no more than a boy, with my head full of cards and women and
horses, and every devilry under heaven, when I went to the house among
the canals. The Conte de Montdelys had built it, for he lived in
Holland a part of the year to grow his tulips. He was a rich man--a
hard, old, pinched Frenchman--but his passion was tulip-growing, and
their cultivation was a new thing. It was a great sight to see the
gardens he had planned at the water's edge, with every colour
reflected from the beds, and the green-shuttered house in the middle.
Even the young men of the Brigade were glad to spend an afternoon
looking upon the show, and the Conte would invite now one, now
another. He loved to strut about exhibiting his gardens. Diane was his
daughter--my poor Diane! Flemington, do I weary you?"

"No, no, indeed!" cried Archie, who had been lost, wandering in an
enchanted labyrinth of bloom and colour as he listened. The image of
the house rising from among its waterways was as vivid to him as if he
had seen it with bodily eyes.

"She was so young," said the soldier, "so gentle, so little suited to
such as I. But she loved me--God knows why--and she was brave--brave
to the end, as she lay dying by the roadside . . . and sending me her
love. . . ."

He stopped and turned away; Archie could say nothing, for his throat
had grown thick. Logie's unconscious gift of filling his words with
drama--a gift which is most often given to those who suspect it
least--wrought on him.

James looked round, staring steadily and blindly over his companion's

"I took her away," he went on, as though describing another man's
experiences; "there was no choice, for the Conte would not tolerate
me. I was a Protestant, and I was poor, and there was a rich Spaniard
whom he favoured. So we went. We were married in Breda, and for a year
we lived in peace. Such days--such days! The Conte made no sign, and I
thought, in my folly, he would let us alone. It seemed as though we
had gained paradise at last; but I did not know him--Montdelys."

"Then the boy was born. When he was two months old I was obliged to
come back to Scotland; it was a matter concerning money which could
not be delayed, for my little fortune had to be made doubly secure
now, and I got leave from my regiment. I could not take Diane and the
child, and I left them at Breda--safe, as I thought. At twenty-three
we do not know men, not the endless treachery of them. Flemington,
when God calls us all to judgment, there will be no mercy for

Archie's eyes, fixed on the other pair, whose keen grey light was
blurred with pain, dropped. He breathed hard, and his nostrils

"You seem to me as young as I was then. May God preserve you from
man's treachery. He did not preserve me," said James.

"I do not know how Montdelys knew that she was defenceless," continued
he, "but I think there must have been some spy of his watching us. As
soon as I had left Holland he sent to her to say he was ill, probably
dying, and that he had forgiven all. He longed for the sight of the
boy, and he asked her to bring him that he might see his grandchild;
she was to make her home with him while I was absent, and he would
send word to me to join them on my return. Diane sent me the good news
and went, fearing nothing, to find herself a prisoner.

"And all this time he had been working--he and the Spaniard--to get
the Pope to annul our marriage, and they had succeeded. What they said
to her, what they did, I know not, and never shall know, but they
could not shake Diane. I was on my way back to Holland when she
managed to escape with the boy. Storms in the North Sea delayed me,
but I was not disturbed, knowing her to be safe. I did not know when I
landed at last that she was dead. . . . She swam the canal,
Flemington, with the child tied on her shoulders, and the
brother-officer of mine--a man in my own company, whom she had
contrived to communicate with--was waiting for her with a carriage. My
regiment had moved to Bergen-op-Zoom, and he meant to take her there.
He had arranged it with the wife of my colonel, who was to give her
shelter till I arrived, and could protect her myself. They had gone
more than half-way to Bergen when they were overtaken, early in the
morning. She was shot, Flemington. The bullet was meant for
Carmichael, the man who was with her, but it struck Diane. . . . They
laid her on the grass at the roadside and she died, holding
Carmichael's hand, and sending--sending----"

He stopped.

"And the child?" said Archie at last.

"Carmichael brought him to Bergen, with his mother. He did not live.
The bullet had grazed his poor little body as he lay in her arms, and
the exposure did the rest. They are buried at Bergen."

Again Archie was speechless.

"I killed the Spaniard," said James. "I could not reach Montdelys; he
was too old to be able to settle his differences in the world of men."

Archie did not know what to do. He longed with a bitter longing to
show his companion something of what he felt, to give him some sign of
the passion of sympathy which had shaken him as he listened; but his
tongue was tied fast by the blighting knowledge of his true position,
and to approach, by so much as a step, seemed only to blacken his soul
and to load it yet more heavily with a treachery as vile as that which
had undone James.

"I could not endure Holland afterwards," continued Logie; "once I had
looked on that Spanish hound's dead body my work was done. I left the
Scots Brigade and took service with Russia, and I joined Peter Lacy,
who was on his way to fight in Poland. Fighting was all I wanted, and
God knows I had it. I did not want to be killed, but to kill. Then I
grew weary of that, but I still stayed with Lacy, and followed him to
fight the Turks. We outlive trouble in time, Flemington; we outlive
it, though we cannot outlive memory. We outlast it--that is a better
word. I have outlasted, perhaps outlived. I can turn and look back
upon myself as though I were another being. It is only when some
chance word or circumstance brings my youth back in detail that I can
scarce bear it. You have brought it back, Flemington, and this morning
I am face to face with it again."

"It does not sound as if you had outlived it," said the young man.

"Life is made of many things," said James; "whether we have lost our
all or not, we have to plough on to the end, and it is best to plough
on merrily. Lacy never complained of me as a companion in the long
time we were together, for I was on his staff, and I took all that
came to me, as I have done always. There were some mad fellows among
us, and I was no saner than they! But life is quiet enough here in the
year since I came home to my good brother."

The mention of Lord Balnillo made Flemington start.

"Gad!" he exclaimed, rising, thankful for escape, "and I am to begin
the portrait this morning, and have set out none of my colours!"

"And I have gone breakfastless," said Logie with a smile, "and worse
than that, I have spoilt the sunshine for you with my tongue, that
should have been silent."

"No, no!" burst out Flemington rather hoarsely. "Don't think of that!
If you only knew----"

He stood, unable to finish his sentence or to utter one word of
comfort without plunging deeper into self-abhorrence.

"I must go," he stammered. "I must leave you and run."

James laid a detaining hand on him.

"Listen, Flemington," he said. "Listen before you go. We have learnt
something of each other, you and I. Promise me that if ever you should
find yourself in such a position as the one you spoke of--if you
should come to such a strait as that--if a little help could make you
free, you will come to me as if I were your brother. Your eyes are so
like Diane's--you might well be hers."

Archie stood before him, dumb, as James held out his hand.

He grasped it for a moment, and then turned from him in a tumult of
horror and despair.



IT was on the following day that Lord Balnillo stood in front of a
three-quarter length canvas in the improvised studio; Archie had begun
to put on the colour that morning, and the judge had come quietly
upstairs to study the first dawnings of his own countenance alone.
From the midst of a chaos of paint his features were beginning to
appear, like the sun through a fog. He had brought a small hand-glass
with him, tucked away under his velvet coat where it could not be
seen, and he now produced it and began to compare his face with the
one before him. Flemington was a quick worker, and though he had been
given only two sittings, there was enough on the canvas to prompt the
gratified smile on the old man's lips. He looked alternately at his
reflection and at the judicial figure on the easel; Archie had a
tactful brush. But though Balnillo was pleased, he could not help
sighing, for he wished fervently that his ankles had been included in
the picture. He stooped and ran his hand lovingly down his silk
stockings. Then he took up the glass again and began to compose his
expression into the rather more lofty one with which Flemington had
supplied him.

In the full swing of his occupation he turned round to find the
painter standing in the doorway, but he was just too late to catch the
sudden flash of amusement that played across Archie's face as he saw
what the judge was doing. Balnillo thrust the glass out of sight and
confronted his guest.

"I thought you had gone for a stroll, sir," he said rather stiffly.

"My lord," exclaimed Flemington, "I have been searching for you
everywhere. I've come, with infinite regret, to tell you that I must
return to Ardguys at once."

Balnillo's jaw dropped.

"I have just met a messenger on the road," said the other; "he has
brought news that my grandmother is taken ill, and I must hurry home.
It is most unfortunate, most disappointing; but go I must."

"Tut, tut, tut!" exclaimed the old man, clicking his tongue against
his teeth and forgetting to hope, as politeness decreed he should,
that the matter was not serious.

"It is a heart-attack," said Archie.

"Tut, tut," said Balnillo again. "I am most distressed to hear it; I
am indeed."

"I _may_ be able to come back and finish the picture later."

"I hope so. I sincerely hope so. I was just studying the admirable
likeness when you came in," said Balnillo, who would have given a
great deal to know how much of his posturing Flemington had seen.

"Ah, my lord!" cried Archie, "a poor devil like me has no chance with
you! I saw the mirror in your hand. We painters use a piece of
looking-glass to correct our drawing, but it is few of our sitters who
know that trick."

Guilty dismay was chased by relief across Balnillo's countenance.

"You are too clever for me!" laughed Flemington. "How did you learn
it, may I ask?"

But Balnillo had got his presence of mind back.

"Casually, Mr. Flemington, casually--as one learns many things, if one
keeps one's ears open," said he.

A couple of hours later Archie was on his way home. He had left one
horse, still disabled, in the judge's stable, and he was riding the
other into Brechin, where he would get a fresh one to take him on.
Balnillo had persuaded him to leave his belongings where they were
until he knew what chance there was of an early return. He had parted
from Archie with reluctance. Although the portrait was the old man's
principal interest, its maker counted for much with him; for it was
some time since his ideas had been made to move as they always moved
in Flemington's presence. The judge got much pleasure out of his own
curiosity; and the element of the unexpected--that fascinating factor
which had been introduced into domestic life--was a continual joy.
Balnillo had missed it more than he knew since he had become a
completely rural character.

Archie saw the Basin of Montrose drop behind him as he rode away with
a stir of mixed feelings. The net that Logie had, in all ignorance,
spread for him had entangled his feet. He had never conceived a like
situation, and it startled him to discover that a difficulty, nowhere
touching the tangible, could be so potent, so disastrous. He felt like
a man who has been tripped up and who suddenly finds himself on the
ground. He had risen and fled.

The position had become intolerable. He told himself in his impetuous
way that it was more than he could bear; and now, every bit of luck he
had turned to account, every precaution he had taken, all the
ingenuity he had used to land himself in the hostile camp, were to go
for nothing, because some look in his face, some droop of the eyes,
had reminded another man of his own past, and had let loose in him an
overwhelming impulse to expression.

"Remember what I told you yesterday," had been James's last words as
Flemington put his foot in the stirrup. "There must be no more

It was that high-coloured flower of his own imagination, the picture
of himself in the servants' hall, that had finally accomplished his
defeat. How could he betray the man who was ready to share his purse
with him?

And, putting the matter of the purse aside, his painter's imagination
was set alight. The glow of the tulips and the strange house by the
winding water, the slim vision of Diane de Montdelys, the gallant
background of the Scots Brigade, the grave at Bergen-op-Zoom--these
things were like a mirage behind the figure of James. The power of
seeing things picturesquely is a gift that can turn into a curse, and
that power worked on his emotional and imaginative side now. And
furthermore, beyond what might be called the ornamental part of his
difficulty, he realized that friendship with James, had he been free
to offer or to accept it, would have been a lifelong prize.

They had spent the preceding day together after the sitting was over,
and though Logie had opened his heart no more, and their talk had been
of the common interests of men's lives, it had strengthened Archie's
resolve to end the situation and to save himself while there was yet
time. There was nothing for it but flight. He had told the judge that
he would try to return, but he did not mean to enter the gates of
Balnillo again, not while the country was seething with Prince
Charlie's plots; perhaps never. He would remember James all his life,
but he hoped that their ways might never cross again. And, behind
that, there was regret; regret for the friend who might have been his,
who, in his secret heart, would be his always.

He could, even now, hardly realize that he had been actually turned
from his purpose. It seemed to him incredible. But there was one thing
more incredible still, and that was that he could raise his hand to
strike again at the man who had been stricken so terribly, and with
the same weapon of betrayal. It would be as if James lay wounded on a
battle-field and he should come by to stab him anew. The blow he
should deal him would have nothing to do with the past, but Archie
felt that James had so connected him in mind with the memory of the
woman he resembled--had, by that one burst of confidence, given him so
much part in the sacred kingdom of remembrance wherein she dwelt--that
it would be almost as if something from out of the past had struck at
him across her grave.

Archie sighed, weary and sick with Fate's ironic jests. There were
some things he could not do.

The two men had avoided politics. Though Flemington's insinuations had
conveyed to the brothers that he was like-minded with themselves, the
Prince's name was not mentioned. There was so much brewing in James's
brain that the very birds of the air must not hear. Sorry as he was
when Flemington met him with the news of his unexpected recall, he had
decided that it was well the young man should go. When this time of
stress was over, when--and if--the cause he served should prevail, he
would seek out Archie. The "if" was very clear to James, for he had
seen enough of men and causes, of troops and campaigns and the
practical difficulties of great movements, to know that he was
spending himself in what might well be a forlorn hope. But none the
less was he determined to see it through, for his heart was deep in
it, and besides that, he had the temperament that is attracted by
forlorn hopes.

He was a reticent man, in spite of the opening of that page in his
life which he had laid before Flemington; and reticent characters are
often those most prone to rare and unexpected bouts of
self-revelation. But when the impulse is past, and the load ever
present with them has been lightened for a moment, they will thrust it
yet farther back behind the door of their lips, and give the key a
double turn. He had enjoined Flemington to come to him as he would
come to a brother for assistance, and it had seemed to Archie that
life would have little more to offer had it only given him a brother
like James. A cloud was on his spirit as he neared Brechin.

When he left the inn and would have paid the landlord, he thrust his
hand into his pocket to discover a thin sealed packet at the bottom of
it; he drew it out, and found to his surprise that, though his name
was on it, it was unopened, and that he had never seen it before.
While he turned it over something told him that the unknown
handwriting it bore was that of James Logie. The coat he wore had hung
in the hall at Balnillo since the preceding night, and the packet must
have been slipped into it before he started.

As he rode along he broke the seal. The paper it contained had neither
beginning nor signature, yet he knew that his guess was right.

"You will be surprised at finding this," he read, "but I wish you to
read it when there are some miles between us. In these disturbed days
it is not possible to tell when we may meet again. Should you return,
I may be here or I may be gone God knows where, and for reasons of
which I need not speak, my brother may be the last man to know where I
am. But for the sake of all I spoke of yesterday, I ask you to believe
that I am your friend. Do not forget that, in any strait, I am at your
back. Because it is true, I give you these two directions: a message
carried to Rob Smith's Tavern in the Castle Wynd at Stirling will
reach me eventually, wheresoever I am. Nearer home you may hear of me
also. There is a little house on the Muir of Pert, the only house on
the north side of the Muir, a mile west of the fir-wood. The man who
lives there is in constant touch with me. If you should find yourself
in urgent need, I will send you the sum of one hundred pounds through

"Flemington, you will make no hesitation in the matter. You will take
it for the sake of one I have spoken of to none but you, these years
and years past."

And now he had to go home and to tell Madam Flemington that he had
wantonly thrown away all the advantages gained in the last three days,
that he had tossed them to the wind for a mere sentimental scruple! So
far he had never quarrelled with his occupation; but now, because it
had brought him up against a soldier of fortune whose existence he had
been unaware of a few weeks ago, he had sacrificed it and played a
sorry trick on his own prospects at the same time. He was trusted and
valued by his own party, and, in spite of his youth, had given it
excellent service again and again. He could hardly expect the
determined woman who had made him what he was to see eye to eye with

Christian Flemington had kept her supremacy over her grandson.
Parental authority was a much stronger thing in the mid-eighteenth
century than it is now, and she stood in the position of a parent to
him. His French blood and her long residence in France had made their
relationship something like that of a French mother and son, and she
had all his confidence in his young man's scrapes, for she recognized
phases of life that are apt to be ignored by English parents in
dealing with their children. She had cut him loose from her
apron-strings early, but she had moulded him with infinite care before
she let him go. There was a touch of genius in Archie, a flicker of
what she called the _feu sacré_, and she had kept it burning before
her own shrine. The fine unscrupulousness that was her main
characteristic, her manner of breasting the tide of circumstance full
sail, awed and charmed him. For all his boldness and initiative, his
devil-may-care independence of will, and his originality in the
conduct of his affairs, he had never freed his inner self from her
thrall, and she held him by the strong impression she had made on his
imagination years and years ago. She had set her mark upon the plastic
character of the little boy whom she had beaten for painting Mr.
Duthie's gate-post. That was an episode which he had never forgotten,
which he always thought of with a smile; and while he remembered the
sting of her cane, he also remembered her masterly routing of his
enemy before she applied it. She had punished him with the
thoroughness that was hers, but she had never allowed the minister to
know what she had done. Technically she had been on the side of the
angels, but in reality she had stood by the culprit. In spirit they
had resented Mr. Duthie together.

He slept at Forfar that night, and pushed on again next morning; and
as he saw the old house across the dip, and heard the purl of the burn
at the end of his journey, something in his heart failed him. The
liquid whisper of the water through the fine, rushlike grass spoke to
him of childhood and of the time when there was no world but Ardguys,
no monarch but Madam Flemington. He seemed to feel her influence
coming out to meet him at every step his horse took. How could he tell
his news? How could he explain what he had done? They had never
touched on ethical questions, he and she.

As he came up the muddy road between the ash-trees he felt the chilly
throe, the intense spiritual discomfort, that attends our plunges from
one atmosphere into another. It is the penalty of those who live their
lives with every nerve and fibre, who take fervent part in the lives
of other people, to suffer acutely in the struggle to loose themselves
from an environment they have just quitted, and to meet an impending
one without distress. But it is no disproportionate price to pay for
learning life as a whole. Also, it is the only price accepted.

He put his horse into the stable and went to the garden, being told
that Madam Flemington was there. The day was warm and bright, and as
he swung the gate to behind him he saw her sitting on a seat at the
angle of the farther wall. She rose at the click of the latch, and
came up the grass path to meet him between a line of espalier
apple-trees and a row of phlox on which October had still left a few
red and white blossoms.

The eighteen years that had gone by since the episode of the manse
gate-post had not done much to change her appearance. The shrinking
and obliterating of personality which comes with the passing of middle
life had not begun its work on her, and at sixty-one she was more
imposing than ever. She had grown a great deal stouter, but the
distribution of flesh had been even, and she carried her bulk with a
kind of self-conscious triumph, as a ship carries her canvas. A brown
silk mantle woven with a pattern of flower-bouquets was round her
shoulders, and she held its thick folds together with one hand; in the
other she carried the book she had been reading. Her hair was as
abundant as ever, and had grown no whiter. The sun struck on its
silver, and red flashes came from the rubies in her ears.

She said nothing as Archie approached, but her eyes spoke inquiry and
a shadow of softness flickered over so slightly round her broad lips.
She was pleased to see him, but the shadow was caused less by her
affection for him than by her appreciation of the charming figure he
presented, seen thus suddenly and advancing with so much grace of
movement in the sunlight. She stopped short when he was within a few
steps of her, and, dropping her book upon the ground without troubling
to see where it fell, held out her hand for him to kiss. He touched it
with his lips, and then, thrusting his arm into the phlox-bushes, drew
out the volume that had landed among them. From between the leaves
dropped a folded paper, on which he recognized his own handwriting.

"This is a surprise," said Madam Flemington, looking her grandson up
and down.

"I have ridden. My baggage is left at Balnillo."

The moment of explanation would have to come, but his desire was to
put it off as long as possible.

"There is your letter between the pages of my book," said she. "It
came to me this morning, and I was reading it again. It gave me
immense pleasure, Archie. I suppose you have come to search for the
clothes you mentioned. I am glad to see you, my dear; but it is a long
ride to take for a few pairs of stockings."

"You should see Balnillo's hose!" exclaimed Flemington hurriedly.
"I'll be bound the old buck's spindle-shanks cost him as much as his
estate. If he had as many legs as a centipede he would have them all
in silk."

"And not a petticoat about the place?"

"None nearer than the kitchen."

"He should have stayed in Edinburgh," said Madam Flemington, laughing.

She loved Archie's society.

"I hear that this Captain Logie is one of the most dangerous rebels in
Scotland," she went on. "If you can lay him by the heels it is a
service that will not be forgotten. So far you have done mighty well,

They had reached the gate, and she laid her hand on his arm.

"Turn back," she said. "I must consult you. I suppose that now you
will be kept for some time at Balnillo? That nest of treason,
Montrose, will give you occupation, and you must stretch out the
portrait to match your convenience. I am going to take advantage of it
too. I shall go to Edinburgh while you are away."

"To Edinburgh?" exclaimed Flemington.

"Why not, pray?"

"But you leave Ardguys so seldom. It is years----"

"The more reason I should go now," interrupted she. "Among other
things, I must see my man of business, and I have decided to do it
now. I shall be more useful to you in Edinburgh, too. I have been too
long out of personal touch with those who can advance your interests.
I had a letter from Edinburgh yesterday; you are better thought of
there than you suspect, Archie. I did not realize how important a
scoundrel this man Logie is, nor what your despatch to Montrose

He was silent, looking on the ground.

She knew every turn of Archie's manner, every inflection of his voice.
There was a gathering sign of opposition on his face--the phantom of
some mood that must not be allowed to gain an instant's strength. It
flashed on her that he had not returned merely to fetch his clothes.
There was something wrong. She knew that at this moment he was afraid
of her, he who was afraid of nothing else.

She stopped in the path and drew herself up, considering where she
should strike. Never, never had she failed to bring him to his
bearings. There was only one fitting place for him, and that was in
the hollow of her hand.

"Grandmother, I shall not go back to Balnillo," said he vehemently.

If the earth had risen up under her feet Madam Flemington could not
have been more astonished. She stood immovable, looking at him, whilst
an inward voice, flying through her mind like a snatch of broken
sound, told her that she must keep her head. She made no feeble
mistake in that moment, for she saw the vital importance of the
conflict impending between them with clear eyes. She knew her back to
be nearer the wall than it had been yet. Her mind was as agile as her
body was by nature indolent, and it was always ready to turn in any
direction and look any foe squarely in the face. She was startled, but
she could not be shaken.

"I've left Balnillo for good," said he again. "I cannot go back--I
will not!"

"You--_will not?_" said Christian, half closing her eyes. The pupils
had contracted, and looked like tiny black beads set in a narrow
glitter of grey. "Is that what you have come home to say to _me?_"

"It is impossible!" he cried, turning away and flinging out his arms.
"It is more than I can do! I will not go man-hunting after Logie. I
will go anywhere else, do anything else, but not that!"

"There is nothing else for you to do."

"Then I will come back here."

"That you will not," said Christian.

He drew in his breath as if he had been struck.

"What are you that you should betray me, and yet think to force
yourself on me without my resenting it? What do you think I am that I
should suffer it?"

She laughed.

"I have not betrayed you," said he in a husky voice.

The loyal worship he had given her unquestioning through the long
dependence and the small but poignant vicissitudes of childhood came
back on him like a returning tide and doubled the cruelty of her
words. She was the one person against whom he felt unable to defend
himself. He loved her truly, and the thought of absolute separation
from her came over him like a chill.

"I did not think you could speak to me in this way. It is terrible!"
he said. His dark eyes were full of pain. He spoke as simply as a
little boy.

Satisfaction stole back to her. She had not lost her hold on him,
would not lose it. Another woman might have flung an affectionate word
into the balance to give the final clip to the scale, but she never
thought of doing that; neither impulse nor calculation suggested it,
because affection was not the weapon she was accustomed to trust. Her
faith was in the heavy hand. Her generalship was good enough to tell
her the exact moment of wavering in the enemy in front, the magic
instant for a fresh attack.

"You are a bitter disappointment," she said. "Life has brought me
many, but you are the greatest. I have had to go without some
necessities in my time, and I now shall have to go without you. But I
can do it, and I will."

"You mean that you will turn from me altogether?"

"Am I not plain enough? I can be plainer if you like. You shall go out
of this house and go where you will. I do not care where you go. But
you are forgetting that I have some curiosity. I wish to understand
what has happened to you since you wrote your letter. That is
excusable, surely."

"It is Logie," said he. "He has made it impossible for me. I cannot
cheat a man who has given me all his confidence."

"He gave you his confidence?" cried Madam Flemington. "Heavens! He is
well served, that stage-puppet Prince, when his servants confide in
the first stranger they meet! Captain Logie must be a man of honour!"

"He is," said Archie. "It was his own private confidence he gave me. I
heard his own history from his own lips, and, knowing it, I cannot go
on deceiving him. I like him too much."

Madam Flemington was confounded. The difficulty seemed so strangely
puerile. A whim, a fancy, was to ruin the work of years and turn
everything upside down. On the top, she was exasperated with Archie,
but underneath, it was worse. She found her influence and her power at
stake, and her slave was being wrested from her, in spite of every
interest which had bound them together. She loved him with a jealous,
untender love that was dependent on outward circumstances, and she was
proud of him. She had smiled at his devotion to her as she would have
smiled with gratified comprehension at the fidelity of a favourite
dog, understanding the creature's justifiable feeling, and knowing how
creditable it was to its intelligence.

"What has all this to do with your duty?" she demanded.

"My duty is too hard," he cried. "I cannot do it, grandmother!"

"_Too hard!_" she exclaimed. "Pah! you weary me--you disgust me. I am
sick of you, Archie!"

His lip quivered, and he met her eyes with a mist of dazed trouble in
his own. A black curtain seemed to be falling between them.

"I told him every absurdity I could imagine," said he. "I made him
believe that I was dependent upon my work for my daily bread. I did
not think he would take my lies as he did. His kindness was so
great--so generous! Grandmother, he would have had me promise to go to
him for help. How can I spy upon him and cheat him after that?"

He stopped. He could not tell her more, for he knew that the mention
of the hundred pounds would but make her more angry; the details of
what Logie had written could be given to no one. He was only waiting
for an opportunity to destroy the paper he carried.

"We have to do with principles, not men," said Madam Flemington. "He
is a rebel to his King. If I thought you were so much as dreaming of
going over to those worthless Stuarts, I would never see you nor speak
to you again. I would sooner see you dead. Is _that_ what is in your

"There is nothing farther from my thoughts," said he. "I can have no
part with rebels. I am a Whig, and I shall always be a Whig. I have
told you the plain truth."

"And now _I_ will tell you the plain truth," said Madam Flemington.
"While I am alive you will not enter Ardguys. When you cut yourself
off from me you will do so finally. I will have no half-measures as I
have no half-sentiments. I have bred you up to support King George's
interests against the whole band of paupers at St. Germain, that you
may pay a part of the debt of injury they laid upon me and mine. Mary
Beatrice took my son from me. You do not know what you have to thank
her for, Archie, but I will tell you now! You have to thank her that
your mother was a girl of the people--of the streets--a slut taken
into the palace out of charity. She was forced on my son by the Queen
and her favourite, Lady Despard. That was how they rewarded us, my
husband and me, for our fidelity! He was in his grave, and knew
nothing, but I was there. I am here still, and I remember still!"

The little muscles round her strong lips were quivering.

Archie had never seen Madam Flemington so much disturbed, and it was
something of a shock to him to find that the power he had known always
as self-dependent, aloof, unruffled, could be at the mercy of so much

"Lady Despard was one of that Irish rabble that followed King James
along with better people, a woman given over to prayers and
confessions and priests. She is dead, thank God! It was she who took
your mother out of the gutter, where she sang from door to door,
meaning to make a nun of her, for her voice was remarkable, and she
and her priests would have trained her for a convent choir. But the
girl had no stomach for a nunnery; the backstairs of the palace
pleased her better, and the Queen took her into her household, and
would have her sing to her in her own chamber. She was handsome, too,
and she hid the devil that was in her from the women. The men knew her
better, and the Chevalier and your father knew her best of all. But at
last Lady Despard got wind of it. They dared not turn her into the
streets for fear of the priests, and to save her own son the Queen
sacrificed mine."

She stopped, looking to see the effect of her words. Archie was very

"Is my true name Flemington?" he asked abruptly.

"You are my own flesh and blood," said she, "or you would not be
standing here. Their fear was that the Chevalier would marry her
privately, but they got him out of the way, and your father seduced
the girl. Then, to make the Chevalier doubly safe, they forced him to
make her his wife--he who was only nineteen! They did it secretly, but
when the marriage was known, I would not receive her, and I left the
court and went to Rouen. I have lived ever since in the hope of seeing
the Stuarts swept from the earth. Your father is gone, and you are all
I have left, but you shall go too if you join yourself to them."

"I shall not do that," said he.

"Do you understand now what it costs me to see you turn back?" said
Madam Flemington.

The mantle had slipped from her shoulders, and her white hands,
crossed at the wrists, lay with the fingers along her arms. She stood
trying to dissect the component parts of his trouble and to fashion
something out of them on which she might make a new attack. Forces
outside her own understanding were at work in him which were strong
enough to take the fine edge of humiliation off the history she had
just told him; she guessed their presence, unseen though they were,
and her acute practical mind was searching for them. She was like an
astronomer whose telescope is turned on the tract of sky in which, as
his science tells him, some unknown body will arise.

She had always taken his pride of race for granted, as she took her
own. The influx of the base blood of the "slut" had been a
mortification unspeakable, but to Madam Flemington, the actual
treachery practised on her had not been the crowning insult. The thing
was bad, but the manner of its doing was worse, for the Queen and Lady
Despard had used young Flemington as though he had been of no account.
The Flemingtons had served James Stuart whole-heartedly, taking his
evil fortunes as though they had been their own; they had done it of
their own free will, high-handedly. But Mary Beatrice and her
favourite had treated Christian and her son as slaves, chattels to be
sacrificed to the needs of their owner. There was enough nobility in
Christian to see that part of the business as its blackest spot.

She had kept the knowledge of it from Archie, because she had the
instinct common to all savage creatures (and Christian's affinity with
savage creatures was a close one) for the concealment of desperate
wounds. Her silks, her ruby earrings, her physical indolence, her
white hands, all the refinements that had accrued to her in her
world-loving life, all that went to make the outward presentment of
the woman, was the mere ornamental covering of the savage in her. That
savage watched Archie now.

Madam Flemington was removed by two generations from Archie, and there
was a gulf of evolution between them, unrealized by either. Their
conscious ideals might be identical; but their unconscious ideals,
those that count with nations and with individuals, were different.
And the same trouble, one that might be accepted and acknowledged by
each, must affect each differently. The old regard a tragedy through
its influences on the past, and the young through its influences on
the future. To Archie, Madam Flemington's revelation was an
insignificant thing compared to the horror that was upon him now. It
was done and it could not be undone, and he was himself, with his life
before him, in spite of it. It was like the withered leaf of a
poisonous plant, a thing rendered innocuous by the processes of
nature. What process of nature could make his agony innocuous? The
word 'treachery' had become a nightmare to him, and on every side he
was fated to hear it.

Its full meaning had only been brought home to him two days ago, and
now the hateful thing was being pressed on him by one who had suffered
from it bitterly. What could he say to her? How was he to make her see
as he saw? His difficulty was a sentimental one, and one that she
would not recognize.

Archie was not logical. He had still not much feeling about having
deceived Lord Balnillo, whose hospitality he had accepted and enjoyed,
but, as he had said, he could not go "man-hunting" after James, who
had offered him a brother's help, whose heart he had seen, whose life
had already been cut in two by the baneful thing. There was little
room in Archie's soul for anything but the shadow of that nightmare of
treachery, and the shadow was creeping towards him. Had his mother
been a grand-duchess of spotless reputation, what could her virtue or
her blue blood avail him in his present distress? She was nothing to
him, that "slut" who had brought him forth; he owed her no allegiance,
bore her no grudge. The living woman to whom he owed all stood before
him beloved, admired, cutting him to the heart.

He assented silently; but Christian understood that, though he looked
as if she had carried her point, his looks were the only really
unreliable part of him. She knew that he was that curious thing--a man
who could keep his true self separate from his moods. It had taken her
years to learn that, but she had learnt it at last.

For once she was, like other people, baffled by his naturalness. It
was plain that he suffered, yet she could not tell how she was to
mould the hard stuff hidden below his suffering. But she must work
with the heavy hand.

"You will leave here to-morrow," she said; "you shall not stay here to
shirk your duty"; and again the pupils of her eyes contracted as she
said it.

"I will go now," said he.



"DOAG," said the beggar, addressing the yellow cur, "you an' me'll
need to be speerin' aboot this. Whiles, it's no sae easy tellin'
havers frae truth."

Though Skirling Wattie was on good terms with the whole of his team,
the member of it whom he singled out for complete confidence, whom he
regarded as an employer might regard the foreman of a working gang,
was the yellow cur. The abuse he poured over the heads of his servants
was meant more as incentive than as rebuke, and he fed them well,
sharing his substance honestly with them, and looking to them for
arduous service in return. They were a faithful, intelligent lot,
good-tempered, but for one of the collies, and the accepted
predominance of the yellow cur was merely one more illustration of the
triumph of personality. His golden eyes, clear, like unclouded amber,
contrasted with the thick and vulgar yellow of his close coat, and the
contrast was like that between spirit and flesh. He was a strong,
untiring creature, with blunt jaws and legs that seemed to be made of
steel, and it was characteristic of him that he seldom laid down but
at night, and would stand turned in his traces as though waiting for
orders, looking towards his master as the latter sang or piped, whilst
his comrades, extended in the dust, took advantage of the halt.

The party was drawn up under the lee of a low wall by the grassy side
of the Brechin road, and its grotesqueness seemed greater than ever
because of its entirely unsuitable background.

The wall encircled the site of an ancient building called Magdalen
Chapel, which had long been ruined, and now only survived in one
detached fragment and in the half-obliterated traces of its
foundations. Round it the tangled grass rose, and a forest of withered
hemlock that had nearly choked out the nettles, stood up, traced like
lacework against the line of hills beyond the Basin. In summer its
powdery white threw an evanescent grace over the spot. The place was a
haunt of Skirling Wattie's, for it was a convenient half-way house
between Montrose and Brechin, and the trees about it gave a comforting
shelter from both sun and rain.

The tailboard of the cart was turned to the wall so that the piper
could lean his broad back against it, and there being not a dozen
inches between the bottom of his cart and the ground, he was hidden
from anyone who might chance to be in the chapel precincts. The
projecting stone which made a stile for those who entered the
enclosure was just level with his shoulder, and he had laid his pipes
on it while he sat with folded arms and considered the situation. He
had just been begging at a farm, and he had heard a rumour there that
Archie Flemington was gone from Balnillo, and had been seen in
Brechin, riding westwards, on the preceding morning. The beggar had
got a letter for him behind his sliding boards which had to be
delivered without delay.

"Doag," said he again, "we'll awa' to auld Davie's."

Skirling Wattie distrusted rumour, for the inexactitudes of human
observation and human tongues are better known to a man who lives by
his wits than to anybody else. He was not going to accept this news
without sifting it. To Balnillo he would go to find out whether the
report was true. The only drawback was that "auld Davie," as he called
the judge, abhorred and disapproved of beggars, and he did not know
how he might stay in the place long enough to find out what he wanted.
He was a privileged person at most houses, from the sea on the east to
Forfar on the west, but Lord Balnillo would none of him. Nevertheless,
he turned the wheels of his chariot in his direction.

He wondered, as he went along, why he had not seen Archie by the way;
but Archie had not left Balnillo by the Brechin road, being anxious to
avoid him. What was the use of receiving instructions that he could
not bring himself to carry out? The last person he wished to meet was
the beggar.

Wattie turned into the Balnillo gates and went up the avenue towards
the stable. His pipes were silent, and the fallen leaves muffled the
sound of his wheels. He knew about the mishap that had brought
Flemington as a guest to the judge, and about the portrait he was
painting, for tidings of all the happenings in the house reached the
mill sooner or later. That source of gossip was invaluable to him.
But, though the miller had confirmed the report that Flemington had
gone, he had been unable to tell him his exact destination.

He drove into the stable yard and found it empty but for a man who was
chopping wood. The latter paused between his strokes as he saw who had

"A'm seekin' his lordship," began Wattie, by way of discovering how
the land lay.

"Then ye'll no find him," replied the woodman, who was none other than
the elder, Andrew Robieson, and who, like his master, disapproved
consistently of the beggar. He was a sly old man, and he did not think
it necessary to tell the intruder that the judge, though not in the
house, was within hearing of the pipes. It was his boast that he "left
a' to Providence," but he was not above an occasional shaping of
events to suit himself.

The beggar rolled up to the back-door at the brisk pace he reserved
for public occasions. A shriek of delight came from the kitchen window
as the blast of his pipes buzzed and droned across the yard. The tune
of the 'East Nauk of Fife' filled the place. A couple of maidservants
came out and stood giggling as Wattie acknowledged their presence by a
wag of the head that spoke gallantry, patronage, ribaldry--anything
that a privileged old rogue can convey to young womanhood blooming
near the soil. A groom came out of the stable and joined the group.

The feet of the girls were tapping the ground. The beggar's expression
grew more genially provocative, and his eyeballs rolled more
recklessly as he blew and blew; his time was perfect. The groom, who
was dancing, began to compose steps on his own account. Suddenly there
was a whirl of petticoats, and he had seized one of the girls round
the middle.

They spun and counter-spun; now loosing each other for the more
serious business of each one's individual steps, now enlacing again,
seeming flung together by some resistless elemental wind. The man's
gaze, while he danced alone, was fixed on his own feet as though he
were chiding them, admiring them, directing them through niceties
which only himself could appreciate. His partner's hair came down and
fell in a loop of dull copper-colour over her back. She was a
finely-made girl, and each curve of her body seemed to be surging
against the agitated sheath of her clothes. The odd-woman-out circled
round the pair like a fragment thrown off by the spin of some
travelling meteor. The passion for dancing that is even now part of
the life of Angus had caught all three, let loose upon them by the
piper's handling of sound and rhythm.

In the full tide of their intoxication, a door in the high wall of the
yard opened and Lord Balnillo came through it. The fragment broke from
its erratic orbit and fled into the house with a scream; the meteor, a
whirling twin-star, rushed on, unseeing. The piper, who saw well
enough, played strong and loud; not the king himself could have
stopped him in the middle of a strathspey. The yellow dog, on his feet
among his reposing companions, showed a narrow white line between his
lips, and the hackles rose upon his plebeian neck.

"Silence!" cried Lord Balnillo. But the rest of his words were drowned
by the yell of the pipes.

As the dancers drew asunder again, they saw him and stopped. His wrath
was centred on the beggar, and man and maid slunk away unrebuked.

Wattie finished his tune conscientiously. To Balnillo, impotent in the
hurricane of braying reeds, each note that kept him dumb was a new
insult, and he could see the knowledge of that fact in the piper's
face. As the music ceased, the beggar swept off his bonnet, displaying
his disreputable bald head, and bowed like the sovereign of some
jovial and misgoverned kingdom. The yellow dog's attitude forbade
Balnillo's nearer approach.

"Go!" shouted the judge, pointing a shaking forefinger into space.
"Out with you instantly! Is my house to be turned into a house of call
for every thief and vagabond in Scotland? Have I not forbidden you my
gates? Begone from here immediately, or I will send for my men to
cudgel you out!"

But he leaped back, for he had taken a step forward in his excitement,
and the yellow cur's teeth were bare.

"A'm seekin' the painter-laddie," said the beggar, giving the dog a
good-humoured cuff.

"Away with you!" cried the other, unheeding. "You are a plague to the
neighbourhood. I will have you put in Montrose jail! To-morrow, I
promise you, you will find yourself where you cannot make gentlemen's
houses into pandemoniums with your noise."

"A'd like Brechin better," rejoined the beggar; "it's couthier in

Balnillo was a humane man, and he prided himself, as all the world
knew, on some improvements he had suggested in the Montrose prison. He
was speechless.

"Ay," continued Wattie, "a'm thinkin' you've sent mony a better man
than mysel' to the tolbooth. But, dod! a'm no mindin' that. A'm asking
ye, _whaur's the painter-lad?_"

One of Balnillo's fatal qualities was his power of turning in
mid-career of wrath or eloquence to daily with side-issues.

He swallowed the fury rising to his lips.

"What! Mr. Flemington?" he stammered. "What do you want of Mr.

"Is yon what they ca' him? Well, a'm no seekin' onything o' him. It's
him that's seekin' me."

Astonishment put everything else out of Balnillo's mind. He glared at
the intruder, his lips pursed, his fingers working.

"He tell't me to come in-by to the muckle hoose and speer for him,"
said the other. "There was a sang he was needin'. He was seekin' to
lairn it, for he liket it fine, an' he tell't me to come awa' to the
hoose and lairn him. Dod! maybe he's forgotten. Callants like him's
whiles sweer to mind what they say, but auld stocks like you an' me's
got mair sense."

"I do not believe a word of it," protested Balnillo.

"Hoots! ye'll hae to try, or the puir lad 'll no get his sang,"
exclaimed Skirling Wattie, smiling broadly. "Just you cry on him to
come down the stair, an' we'll awa' ahint the back o' yon wa', an'
a'll lairn him the music! It's this way."

He unscrewed the chanter and blew a few piercing notes. The sound flew
into the judge's face like the impact of a shower of pebbles. He
clapped his hands to his ears.

"I tell you Mr. Flemington is not here!" he bawled, raising his voice
above the din. "He is gone. He is at Ardguys by this time."

"Man, is yon true? Ye're no leein'?" exclaimed Wattie, dropping his

"Is yon the way to speak to his lordship?" said the deep voice of
Andrew Robieson, who had come up silently, his arms full of wood,
behind the beggar's cart.

"Turn this vagabond away!" exclaimed Balnillo, almost beside himself.
"Send for the men; bring a horsewhip from the stable! Impudent rogue!
Go, Robieson--quick, man!"

But Wattie's switch was in his hand, and the dogs were already
turning; before the elder had time to reach the stables, he had passed
out under the clock and was disappearing between the trees of the
avenue. He had learned what he wished to know, and the farther side of
Brechin would be the best place for him for the next few days. He
reflected that fortune had favoured him in keeping Captain Logie out
of the way. There would have been no parleying with Captain Logie.




ARCHIE rode along in a dream. He had gone straight out of the garden,
taken his horse from the stable, and ridden back to Forfar, following
the blind resolution to escape from Ardguys before he should have time
to realize what it was costing him. He had changed horses at the
posting-house, and turned his face along the way he had come. Through
his pain and perplexity the only thing that stood fast was his
determination not to return to Balnillo. "I will go now," he had said
to Madam Flemington, and he had gone without another word, keeping his
very thoughts within the walled circle of his resolution, lest they
should turn to look at familiar things that might thrust out hands
full of old memories to hold him back.

In the middle of his careless life he found himself cut adrift without
warning from those associations that he now began to feel he had
valued too little, taken for granted too much.

Balnillo was impossible for him, and in consequence he was to be a
stranger in his own home. Madam Flemington had made no concession and
had put no term to his banishment, and though he could not believe
that such a state of things could last, and that one sudden impulse of
hers could hurl him out of her life for ever, she, who had lived for
him, had told him that she would "do without him." Then, as he assured
himself of this, from that dim recess wherein a latent truth hides
until some outside light flashes upon its lair, came the realization
that she had not lived for him alone. She had lived for him that she
might make him into the instrument she desired, a weapon fashioned to
her hand, wherewith she might return blow for blow.

All at once the thought made him spiritually sick, and the glory and
desirableness of life seemed to fade. He could not see through its
dark places, dark where all had been sunshine. He had been a boy
yesterday, a man only by virtue of his astounding courage and
resource, but he was awakening from boyhood, and manhood was hard. His
education had begun, and he could not value the education of pain--the
soundest, the most costly one there is--any more than any of us do
whilst it lasts. He did not think, any more than any of us think, that
perhaps when we come to lie on our death-beds we shall know that, of
all the privileges of the life behind us, the greatest has been the
privilege of having suffered and fought.

All he knew was that his heart ached, that he had disappointed and
estranged the person he loved best, and had lost, at any rate
temporarily, the home that had been so dear. But hope would not desert
him, in spite of everything. Madam Flemington had gone very wide of
the mark in suspecting him of any leaning towards the Stuarts, and she
would soon understand how little intention he had of turning rebel.
There was still work for him to do. He had been given a free hand in
details, and he would go to Brechin for the night; to-morrow he must
decide what to do. Possibly he would ask to be transferred to some
other place. But nothing that heaven or earth could offer him should
make him betray Logie.

Madam Flemington had seen him go, in ignorance of whether he had gone
in obedience or in revolt. Perhaps she imagined that her arguments and
the hateful story she had laid bare to him had prevailed, and that he
was returning to his unfinished portrait. In the excitement of his
interview with her, he had not told her anything but that he refused
definitely to spy upon James any more.

He had started for Ardguys so early, and had been there such a short
time, that he was back in Forfar by noon. There he left his horse,
and, mounting another, set off for Brechin. He was within sight of its
ancient round tower, grey among the yellowing trees above the South
Esk, when close to his left hand there rose the shrill screech of a
pipe, cutting into his abstraction of mind like a sharp stab of pain.
It was so loud and sudden that the horse leaped to the farther side of
the road, snorting, and Flemington, sitting loosely, nearly lost his
seat. He pulled up the astonished animal, and peered into a thicket of
alder growing by the wayside. The ground was marshy, and the stunted
trees were set close, but, dividing their branches, he saw behind
their screen an open patch in the midst of which was Skirling Wattie's
cart. His jovial face seemed to illuminate the spot.

"Dod!" exclaimed the piper, "ye was near doon! A'd no seek to change
wi' you. A'm safer wi' ma' doags than you wi' yon horse. What ailed ye
that ye gae'd awa' frae Balnillo?"

"Private matters," said Archie shortly.

"Aweel, they private matters was no far frae putting me i' the
tolbooth. What gar'd ye no tell me ye was gaein'?"

"Have you got a letter for me?" said Flemington, as Wattie began to
draw up his sliding-board.

"Ay, there's ane. But just wait you, ma lad, till a tell ye what a was
sayin' to auld Davie----"

"Never mind what you said to Lord Balnillo," broke in Flemington; "I
want my letter."

He slipped from the saddle and looped the rein over his arm.

"Dinna bring yon brute near me!" cried Wattie, as horse and man began
to crush through the alders. "A'm fell feared o' they unchancy

Archie made an impatient sound and threw the rein over a stump. He
approached the cart, and the yellow dog, who was for once lying down,
opened his wary golden eyes, watching each movement that brought the
intruder nearer to his master without raising his head.

"You are not often on this side of Brechin," said Archie, as the
beggar handed him the packet.

"Fegs, na!" returned Wattie, "but auld Davie an' his tolbooth's on the
ither side o't an' it's no safe yonder. It's yersel' I hae to thank
for that, Mr. Flemington. A didna ken whaur ye was, sae a gae'd up to
the muckle hoose to speer for ye. The auld stock came doon himsel'.
Dod! the doag gar'd him loup an' the pipes gar'd him skelloch. But he
tell't me whaur ye was."

"Plague take you! did you go there asking for me?" cried Archie.

"What was a to dae? A tell't Davie ye was needin' me to lairn ye a
sang! 'The painter-lad was seekin' me,' says I, 'an' he tell't me to
come in-by.'"

Flemington's annoyance deepened. He did not know what the zeal of this
insufferable rascal had led him to say or do in his name, and he had
the rueful sense that the tangle he had paid such a heavy price to
escape from was complicating round him. The officious familiarity of
the piper exasperated him, and he resented Government's choice of such
a tool. He put the letter in his pocket, and began to back out of the
thicket. He would read his instructions by himself.

"Hey! ye're no awa', man?" cried Wattie.

"I have no time to waste," said Flemington, his foot in the stirrup.

"But ye've no tell't me whaur ye're gaein'!"


Archie called the word over his shoulder, and started off at a trot,
which he kept up until he had left the alder-bushes some way behind

Then he broke the seal of his letter, and found that he was to convey
the substance of each report that he sent in, not only to His
Majesty's intelligence officer at Perth, but to Captain Hall, of the
English ship _Venture_, that was lying under Ferryden. He was to
proceed at once to the vessel, to which further instructions for him
would be sent in a couple of days' time.

He pocketed the letter and drew a breath of relief, blessing the
encounter that he had just cursed, for a road of escape from his
present difficulty began to open before him. He must take to his own
feet on the other side of Brechin, and go straight to the _Venture_.
He would be close to Montrose, in communication with it, though not
within the precincts of the town, and safe from the chance of running
against Logie. Balnillo and his brother would not know what had become
of him, and Christian Flemington would be cured of her suspicions by
the simple testimony of his whereabouts.

He would treat the two days that he had spent at the judge's house as
if they had dropped out of his life, and merely report his late
presence in Montrose to the captain of the sloop. He would describe
his watching of the two men who came out of 'The Happy Land,' and how
he had followed them to the harbour through the darkness; how he had
seen them stop opposite the ship's light as they discussed their
plans; how he had tried to secure the paper they held. He would tell
the captain that he believed some design against the ship to be on
foot, but he would not let Logie's name pass his lips; and he would
deny any knowledge of the identity of either man, lest the mention of
Ferrier should confirm the suspicions of those who guessed he was
working with James. When he had reported himself to Perth from the
ship, he would no longer be brought into contact with Skirling Wattie,
which at that moment struck him as an advantage.

The evenings had begun to close in early. As he crossed the Esk bridge
and walked out of Brechin, the dusk was enwrapping its parapet like a
veil. He hurried on, and struck out along the road that would lead him
to Ferryden by the southern shore of the Basin. His way ran up a long
ascent, and when he stood at the top of the hill the outline of the
moon's disc was rising, faint behind the thin cloudy bank that rested
on the sea beyond Montrose. There was just enough daylight left to
show him the Basin lying between him and the broken line of the town's
twinkling lights under the muffled moon.

It was quite dark when he stood at last within hail of the _Venture_.
As he went along the bank at the Esk's mouth, he could see before him
the cluster of houses that formed Ferryden village, and the North Sea
beyond it, a formless void in the night, with the tide far out. Though
the moon was well up, the cloud-bank had risen with her, and taken all
sharpness out of the atmosphere.

At his left hand the water crawled slithering at the foot of the
sloping bank, like a dark, full-fed snake, and not thirty yards out,
just where it broadened, stretching to the quays of Montrose, the
vessel lay at anchor, a stationary blot on the slow movement.
Upstream, between her and the Basin, the wedge-shaped island of
Inchbrayock split the mass of water into two portions.

Flemington halted, taking in the dark scene, which he had contemplated
from its reverse side only a few nights ago. Then he went down to the
water and put his hands round his mouth.

"_Venture_ ahoy!" he shouted.

There was no movement on the ship. He waited, and then called again,
with the same result. Through an open porthole came a man's laugh,
sudden, as though provoked by some unexpected jest. The water was deep
here, and the ship lay so near that every word was carried across it
to the shore.

The laugh exasperated him. He threw all the power of his lungs into
another shout.

"Who goes there?" said a voice.

"Friend," replied Archie; and, fearing to be asked for a countersign,
he called quickly, "Despatches for Captain Hall."

"Captain Hall is ashore," announced a second voice, "and no one boards
us till he returns."

The _Venture_ was near enough to the bank for Archie to hear some
derisive comment, the words of which he could not completely
distinguish. A suppressed laugh followed.

"Damn it!" he cried, "am I to be kept here all night?"

"Like enough, if you mean to wait for the captain."

This reply came from the open porthole, in which the light was
obliterated by the head of the man who spoke.

There was a sound as of someone pulling him back by the heels, and the
port was an eye of light again.

Flemington turned and went up the bank, and as he reached the top and
sprang on to the path he ran into a short, stoutish figure which was
beginning to descend. An impatient expletive burst from it.

"You needn't hurry, sir," said Archie, as the other hailed the vessel
querulously; "you are not likely to get on board?"

"What? what? Not board my own ship?"

Flemington was a good deal taken aback. He could not see much in the
clouded night, but no impression of authority seemed to emanate from
the indistinguishable person beside him.

"Ten thousand pardons, sir!" exclaimed the young man. "You are Captain
Hall? I have information for you, and am sent by His Majesty's
intelligence officer in Perth to report myself to you. Flemington is
my name."

For a minute the little man said nothing, and Archie felt rather than
saw his fidgety movements. He seemed to be hesitating.

A boat was being put off from the ship. She lay so near to them that a
mere push from her side brought the craft almost into the bank.

"It is so dark that I must show you my credentials on board," said
Archie, taking Captain Hall's acquiescence for granted.

He heard his companion drawing in his breath nervously through his
teeth. No opposition was made as he stepped into the boat.

When he stood on deck beside Hall the ship was quiet and the sounds of
laughter were silent. He had the feeling that everyone on board had
got out of the way on purpose as he followed the captain down the
companion to his cabin. As the latter opened the door the light within
revealed him plainly for the first time.

He was a small ginger-haired man, whose furtive eyes were set very
close to a thin-bridged, aquiline nose; his gait was remarkable
because he trotted rather than walked; his restless fingers rubbed one
another as he spoke. He looked peevish and a little dissipated, and
his manner conveyed the idea that he felt himself to have no business
where he was. As Archie remarked that, he told himself that it was a
characteristic he had never yet seen in a seaman. His dress was
careless, and a wine-stain on his cravat caught his companion's eye.
He had the personality of a rabbit.

Hall did not sit down, but stood at the farther side of the table
looking with a kind of grudging intentness at his guest, and
Flemington was inclined to laugh, in spite of the heavy heart he had
carried all day. The other moved about with undecided steps. When at
last he sat down, just under the swinging lamp, Archie was certain
that, though he could be called sober, he had been drinking.

"Your business, sir," he began, in a husky voice. "I must tell you
that I am fatigued. I had hoped to go to bed in peace."

He paused, leaning back, and surveyed Flemington with injured

"There is no reason that you should not," replied Archie boldly. "I
have had a devilish hard day myself. Give me a corner to lie in
to-night, and I will give you the details of my report quickly."

He saw that he would meet with no opposition from Hall, whose one idea
was to spare himself effort, and that his own quarters on board the
_Venture_ were sure. No doubt long practice had enabled the man to
look less muddled than he felt. He sat down opposite to him.

The other put out his hand, as though to ward him off.

"I have no leisure for business to-night," he said. "This is not the
time for it."

"All the same, I have orders from Perth to report myself to you, as I
have told you already," said Archie. "If you will listen, I will try
to make myself clear without troubling you to read anything. I have
information to give which you should hear at once."

"I tell you that I cannot attend to you," said Hall.

"I shall not keep you long. You do not realize that it is important,

"Am I to be dictated to?" exclaimed the other, raising his voice.
"This is my own ship, Mr. Flem--Fling--Fl----"

The name presented so much difficulty to Hall that it died away in a
tangled murmur, and Archie saw that to try to make him understand
anything important in his present state would be labour lost.

"Well, sir," said he, "I will tell you at once that I suspect an
attack on you is brewing in Montrose. I believe that it may happen at
any moment. Having delivered myself of that, I had best leave you."

The word "attack" found its way to the captain's brain.

"It's impossible!" he exclaimed crossly. "Why, plague on't, I've got
all the town guns! Nonsense, sir--no'sense! Come, I will call for a
bottle of wine, 'n you can go. There's an empty bunk, I s'pose."

The order was given and the wine was brought. Archie noticed that the
man who set the bottle and the two glasses on the table threw a casual
look at Hall's hand, which shook as he helped his guest. He had eaten
little since morning, and drunk less. Now that he had attained his
object, and found himself in temporary shelter and temporary peace, be
realized how glad he was of the wine. When, after a single glassful,
he rose to follow the sailor who came to show him his bunk, he turned
to bid good-night to Hall. The light hanging above the captain's head
revealed every line, every contour of his face with merciless candour;
and Flemington could see that no lover, counting the minutes till he
should be left with his mistress, had ever longed more eagerly to be
alone with her than this man longed to be alone with the bottle before

Archie threw himself thankfully into his bunk. There was evidently
room for him on the ship, for there was no trace of another occupant
in the little cabin; nevertheless, it looked untidy and unswept. The
port close to which he lay was on the starboard side of the vessel,
and looked across the strait towards the town. The lamps were nearly
all extinguished on the quays, and only here and there a yellow spot
of light made a faint ladder in the water. The pleasant trickling
sound outside was soothing, with its impersonal, monotonous whisper.
He wondered how long Hall would sit bemusing himself at the table, and
what the discipline of a ship commanded by this curiously ineffective
personality could be. To-morrow he must make out his story to the
little man. He could not reproach himself with having postponed his
report, for he knew that Hall's brain, which might possibly be clearer
in the morning, was incapable of taking in any but the simplest
impressions to-night.

Tired as he was, he did not sleep for a long time. The scenes of the
past few days ran through his head one after another--now they
appeared unreal, now almost visible to his eyes. Sometimes the space
of time they covered seemed age-long, sometimes a passing flash. This
was Saturday night, and all the events that had culminated in the
disjointing of his life had been crowded into it since Monday. On
Monday he had not suspected what lay in himself. He would have gibed
had he been told that another man's personality, a page out of another
man's history, could play such havoc with his own interests.

He wondered what James was doing. Was he--now--over there in the
darkness, looking across the rolling, sea-bound water straight to the
spot on which he lay? Would he--could space be obliterated and night
illumined--look up to find his steady eyes upon him? He lay quiet,
marvelling, speculating. Then Logie, the shadowy town, the burning
autumn-trees of Balnillo, the tulips round the house in far-away
Holland, fell away from his mind, and in their place was the familiar
background of Ardguys, the Ardguys of his childhood, with the
silver-haired figure of Madam Flemington confronting him; that
terrible, unsparing presence wrapped about with something greater and
more arresting than mere beauty; the quality that had wrought on him
since he was a little lad. He turned about with a convulsive breath
that was almost a sob.

Then, at last, he slept soundly, to be awakened just at dawn by the
roar of a gun, followed by a rattle of small shot, and the frantic
hurrying of feet overhead.



WHEN Archie lay and pictured James on the other side of the water his
vision was a true one, but, while he saw him on the quay among the
sheds and windlasses, he had set him in the wrong place.

James stood at the point of the bay formed by the Basin of Montrose,
at the inner and landward side of the town, not far from the empty
fort from which Hall had taken the guns. The sands at his feet were
bare, for the tide was out, and the salt, wet smell of the oozing weed
blew round him on the faint wind. He was waiting for Ferrier.

They had chosen this night, as at this hour the ebbing water would
make it possible for the hundred men of Ferrier's regiment to keep
clear of the roads, and to make their way from Brechin on the secluded
shore of the Basin. Logie had not been there long when he heard the
soft sound of coming feet, and the occasional knocking of shoes
against stone. As an increasing shadow took shape, he struck his hand
twice against his thigh, and the shadow grew still. He struck again,
and in another minute Ferrier was beside him; the soldiers who
followed halted behind their leader. The two men said little to each
other, but moved on side by side, and the small company wound up the
rising slope of the shore to the deserted fort and gathered at its

James and his friend went on a little way and stood looking east down
the townward shore of the strait past the huddled houses massed
together at this end of Montrose. The water slid to the sea, and
halfway down the long quay in front of them was moored the unrigged
barque that held the town guns--the four-pounders and six-pounders
that had pointed their muzzles for so many years from the fort walls
towards the thundering bar.

Hall had not concerned himself to bring the vessel into his own
immediate neighbourhood, nor even to put a few dozen yards of water
between her and the shore. He knew that no organized rebel force
existed within nine miles of where she lay, and that the Jacobites
among the townsmen could not attempt any hostile movement unaided. He
had eighty men on board the _Venture_ with him, and from them he had
taken a small guard which was left in charge of the barque. Every two
or three days he would send a party from the sloop to patrol the
streets of Montrose, and to impress disloyally inclined people. His
own investigations of the place had not been great, for, though he
went ashore a good deal, it cannot be said that King George's
interests were much furthered by his doings when he got there.

When Logie and Ferrier had posted a handful of men in the empty fort,
they went on towards the barque's moorings followed by the rest, and
leaving a few to guard the mouth of each street that opened on the
quay. The whole world was abed behind the darkened windows and the
grim stone walls that brooded like blind faces over the stealthy band
passing below. When they reached the spot where the ferry-boat lay
that plied between Montrose and the south shore of the strait, two men
went down to the landing-stage, and, detaching her chains, got her
ready to push off. Then, with no more delay, the friends pressed on to
the main business of their expedition. As they neared the barque, a
faint shine forward where her bows pointed seaward suggested that
someone on board was waking, so, judging it best to make the attack
before an alarm could be given, the two captains ran on with their
men, and were climbing over the bulwarks and tumbling on to her deck
before Captain Hall's guard, who were playing cards round a lantern,
had time to collect their senses.

The three players sprang to their feet, and one of them sent a loud
cry ringing into the darkness before he sprawled senseless, with his
head laid open by the butt-end of Ferrier's pistol. In this
unlooked-for onslaught, that had come upon them as suddenly as the
swoop of a squall in a treacherous sea, they struck blindly about,
stumbling into the arms of the swarming, unrecognized figures that had
poured in on their security out of the peaceful night. James had
kicked over the lantern, and the cards lay scattered about under foot,
white spots in the dimness. The bank of cloud was thinning a little
round the moon, and the angles of the objects on deck began to be more
clearly blocked out. One of the three, who had contrived to wrench
himself from his assailant's hold, sprang away and raced towards the
after-part of the ship, where, with the carelessness of security, he
had left his musket. Three successive shots was the signal for help
from the _Venture_ in case of emergency, and he made a gallant effort
to get free to send this sign of distress across the strait. But he
was headed back and overpowered before he could carry out his
intention. One of his companions was lying as if dead on the deck, and
the other, who had been cajoled to silence by the suggestive caress of
a pistol at the back of his ear, was having his arms bound behind him
with his own belt.

Not a shot had been fired. Except for that one cry from the man who
lay so still at their feet, no sound but the scuffling and cursing on
the barque disturbed the quiet. Ferrier's men hustled their prisoners
below into the cabin, where they were gagged and secured and left
under the charge of a couple of soldiers. No roving citizen troubled
the neighbourhood at this hour, for the fly-by-nights of Montrose
looked farther inland for their entertainment, and the fisher-folk,
who were the principal dwellers in the poor houses skirting the quays,
slept sound, and recked little of who might be quarrelling out of
doors so long as they lay warm within them. The barque was some way
up-stream from the general throng of shipping--apart, and, as Hall had
thought, the more safe for that, for his calculations had taken no
count of an enemy who might come from anywhere but the town. He had
never dreamed of the silent band which had been yielded up by the
misty stretches of the Basin.

James leaned over the vessel's side towards the _Venture_, and thought
of Captain Hall. He had seen him in a tavern of the town, and had been
as little impressed by his looks as was Flemington. He had noticed the
uncertain eye, the restless fingers, the trotting gait, and had held
him lightly as a force; for he knew as well as most men know who have
knocked about this world that character--none other--is the hammer
that drives home every nail into the framework of achievement.

But he had no time to spend in speculations, for his interest was
centred in the ferry-boat that was now slipping noiselessly towards
them on the current, guided down-stream by the couple of soldiers who
had unmoored her. As she reached the barque a rope was tossed down to
her, and she was made fast. The stolen guns were hauled from their
storage, and a six-pounder lowered, with its ammunition, into the
great tub that scarcely heaved on the slow swirl of the river; and
whilst the work was going on, Ferrier and James stepped ashore to the
quay, and walked each a short way along it, watching for any movement
or for the chance of surprise. There was nothing: only, from far out
beyond the shipping, a soft rush, so low that it seemed to be part of
the atmosphere itself, told that the tide was on the turn.

In the enshrouding night the boat was loaded, and a dozen or so of the
little company pushed off with their spoil. Ferrier went with them,
and Logie, who was to follow with the second gun, watched the craft
making her way into obscurity, like some slow black river monster
pushing blindly out into space.

The scheme he had been putting together since the arrival of the
_Venture_ was taking reality at last, and though he could stand with
folded arms on the bulwark looking calmly at the departing boat, the
fire in his heart burned hot. Custom had inured him to risks of every
kind, and if his keenness of enterprise was the same as it had been in
youth, the excitement of youth had evaporated. It was the depths that
stirred in Logie, seldom the surface. Like Archie Flemington, he loved
life, but he loved it differently. Flemington loved it consciously,
joyously, pictorially; James loved it desperately--so desperately that
his spirit had survived the shock which had robbed it of its glory,
for him. He was like a faithful lover whose mistress has been scarred
by smallpox.

He could throw himself heart and soul into the Stuart cause, its
details and necessities--all that his support of it entailed upon him,
because it had, so to speak, given him his second wind in the race of
life. Though he was an adventurer by nature, he differed from the
average adventurer in that he sought nothing for himself. He did not
conform to the average adventuring type. He was too overwhelmingly
masculine to be a dangler about women, though since the shipwreck of
his youth he had more than once followed in the train of some
complaisant goddess, and had reaped all the benefits of her notice; he
was no snatcher at casual advantages, but a man to whom service in any
interest meant solid effort and unsparing sacrifice. Also he was one
who seldom looked back. He had done so once lately, and the act had
shaken him to the heart. Perhaps he would do so oftener when he had
wrought out the permanent need of action that lay at the foundation of
his nature.

When the boat had come back, silent on the outflowing river, and had
taken her second load, he lowered himself into the stern as her head
was pulled round again towards Inchbrayock.

The scheme fashioned by the two men for the capture of the vessel
depended for its success on their possession of this island. As soon
as they should land on it, they were to entrench the two guns, one on
its south-eastern side, as near to the _Venture_ as possible, and the
other on its northern shore, facing the quays. By this means the small
party would command, not only the ship, but the whole breadth of the
river and its landing-places, and would be able to stop communication
between Captain Hall and the town. Heavy undergrowth covered a fair
portion of Inchbrayock, and the only buildings upon it--if buildings
they could be called--were the walls of an old graveyard and the
stones and crosses they encircled. Though the island lay at a
convenient part of the strait, no bridge connected it with Montrose,
and those who wished to cross the Esk at that point were obliged to
use the ferry. The channel dividing its southern shore from the
mainland being comparatively narrow, a row of gigantic stepping-stones
carried wayfarers dry-shod across its bed, for at low tide there was a
mere streak of water curling serpent-wise through the mud.

When the guns were got safely into position on the island it was
decided that Ferrier was to return to the barque and take the
remaining four-pounders with all despatch to a piece of rising ground
called Dial Hill, that overlooked the mass of shipping opposite

He did not expect to meet with much opposition, should news of his
action be carried to the town, for its main sympathies were with his
side, and the force on the Government vessel would be prevented from
coming over the strait to oppose him until he was settled on his
eminence by the powerful dissuaders he had left behind him on
Inchbrayock. He was to begin firing from Dial Hill at dawn, and James,
who was near enough to the _Venture_ to see any movement that might
take place on her, was to be ready with his fire and with his small
party of marksmen to check any offensive force despatched from the
ship to the quays. Hall would thus be cut off from the town by the
fire from Inchbrayock, on the one hand, and, should he attempt a
landing nearer to the watermouth, by the guns on Dial Hill, on the

James had placed himself advantageously. The thicket of elder and
thorn which had engulfed one end of the burial-ground made excellent
concealment, and in front of him was the solid wall, through a gap in
which he had turned the muzzle of his six-pounder. He sat on the stump
of a thorn-tree, his head in his hands, waiting, as he knew he would
have to wait, for some time yet, till the first round from Dial Hill
should be the signal for his own attack. The moon had made her journey
by this hour, and while she had been caught in her course through the
zenith in the web of cloud and mist that thickened the sky, she was
now descending towards her rest through a clear stretch; she swung, as
though suspended above the Basin, tilted on her back, and a little
yellower as she neared the earth, a dying, witch-like thing, halfway
through her second quarter. James, looking up, could see her between
the arms of the crosses and the leaning stones.

The strangeness of the place arrested his thoughts and turned them
into unusual tracks, for, though far from being an unimaginative man,
he was little given to deliberate contemplation. The distant inland
water under the lighted half disc was pale, and a faintness seemed to
lie upon the earth in this hour between night and morning. His
thoughts went to the only dwellers on Inchbrayock, those who were
lying under his feet--seamen, for the most part, and fisher-folk, who
had known the fury of the North Sea that was now beginning to crawl in
and to surround them in their little township with its insidious arms,
encircling in death the bodies that had escaped it in life. Some of
them had been far afield, farther than he had ever been, in spite of
all his campaigns, but they had come in over the bar to lie here in
the jaws of the outflowing river by their native town. He wondered
whether he should do the same; times were so uncertain now that he
might well take the road into the world again. The question of where
his bones should lie was a matter of no great interest to him, and
though there was a vague restfulness in the notion of coming at last
to the slopes and shadows of Balnillo, he knew that the wideness of
the world was his natural home. Then he thought of Bergen-op-Zoom.
. . .

After a while he raised his head again, roused, not by the streak of
light that was growing upon the east, but by a shot that shattered the
silence and sent the echoes rolling out from Dial Hill.



ARCHIE sprang up, unable, for a moment, to remember where he was. He
was almost in darkness, for the port looked northward, and the pale
light barely glimmered through it, but he could just see a spurt of
white leap into the air midway across the channel, where a second shot
had struck the water. As he rushed on deck a puff of smoke was
dispersing above Dial Hill. Then another cloud rolled from the bushes
on the nearest point of Inchbrayock Island, and he felt the _Venture_
shiver and move in her moorings. Captain Hall's voice was rising above
the scuffling and running that was going on all over the ship, and the
dragging about of heavy objects was making the decks shake.

He went below and begun to hustle on his clothes, for the morning air
struck chill and he felt the need of being ready for action of some
kind. In a few minutes he came up warily and crept round to the port
side, taking what cover he could. Then a roar burst from the side of
the _Venture_ as she opened fire.

He stood, not knowing what to do with himself. It was dreadful to him
to have to be inactive whilst his blood rose with the excitement round
him. No one on the vessel remembered his existence; he was like a
stray dog in a market-place, thrust aside by every passer brushing by
on the business of life.

It was soon evident that, though the guns on the hill commanded the
_Venture_, their shot was falling short of her. As the sun heaved up
from beyond the bar, the quays over the water could be seen filling
with people, and the town bells began to ring. An increasing crowd
swarmed upon the landing-stage of the ferry, but the boat herself had
been brought by James to the shore of Inchbrayock, and nobody was
likely to cross the water whilst the island and the high ground
seaward of the town was held by the invisible enemy which had come
upon them from heaven knew where. Captain Hall was turning his
attention exclusively on Inchbrayock, and Flemington, who had got
nearer to the place where he stood, gathered from what he could hear
that the man on Dial Hill was wasting his ammunition on a target that
was out of range. A shot from the vessel had torn up a shower of earth
in the bank that sloped from the thicket to the river-mud, and another
had struck one of the gravestones on the island, splitting it in two;
but the fire went on steadily from the dense tangle where the
churchyard wall no doubt concealed earthworks that had risen behind it
in the dark hours. This, then, was the outcome of James's
night-wanderings with Ferrier.

Archie contemplated Captain Hall where he stood in a little group of
men. He looked even less of a personage in the morning light than he
had done in the cabin, and the young man suspected that he had gone to
bed in his clothes. This reminded him that he himself was unwashed,
unshaven, and very hungry. Whatsoever the issue of the attack might
be, there was no use in remaining starved and dirty, and he determined
to go below to forage and to find some means of washing. There was no
one to gainsay him at this time of stress, and he walked into Hall's
cabin reflecting that he might safely steal anything he could carry
from the ship, if he were so minded, and slip overboard across the
narrow arm to the bank with nothing worse than a wetting.

Whilst he was attending to his own necessities, the booming went on
overhead, and at last a shout from above sent him racing up from the
welcome food he had contrived to secure. The wall on Inchbrayock was
shattered in two or three places and the unseen gun was silent. The
cannonade from Dial Hill had stopped, but a train of figures was
hurrying across from the northern shore of the island, taking shelter
among the bushes and stones. A boat was being lowered from the
_Venture_, for the tide, now sweeping in, had covered the mud, making
a landing possible. Men were crowding into her, and as Flemington got
round to his former place of observation she was being pushed off.

Hall, who was standing alone, caught sight of him and came towards
him; his face looked swollen and puffy, and his eyes were bloodshot.

"We have been attacked," he began--"attacked most unexpectedly!"

"I had the honour to report that possibility to you last night, sir,"
replied Flemington, with a trifle of insolence in his manner.

An angry look shot out of Hall's rabbit eyes. "What could you possibly
have known about such a thing?" he cried. "What reason had you for
making such a statement?"

"I had a great many," said Archie, "but you informed me that you had
no leisure to listen to any of them until this morning. Perhaps you
are at leisure now?"

"You are a damned impudent scoundrel!" cried the other, noticing
Flemington's expression, which amply justified these words, "but you
had better take care! There is nothing to prevent me from putting you
under arrest."

"Nothing but the orders I carry in my pocket," replied Archie. "They
are likely enough to deter you."

The other opened his mouth to speak, but before he could do so a shot
crashed into the fore part of the ship, and a hail of bullets ripped
out from the thicket on the island; the boat, which was half-way
between the _Venture_ and Inchbrayock, spun round, and two of the
rowers fell forward over their oars. Hall left Archie standing where
he was.

The gun that the ship's gunners believed themselves to have disabled
had opened fire again, after a silence that had been, perhaps, but a
lure to draw a sortie from her; and as it was mere destruction for the
boat to attempt a landing in the face of the shot, she had orders to
put back.

The position in which he was placed was now becoming clear to Hall. He
was cut off from communication with the quays by the guns safely
entrenched on the island, and those on Dial Hill, though out of range
for the moment, would prevent him from moving nearer to the watermouth
or making an attempt to get out to sea. He could not tell what was
happening in the town opposite, and he had no means of finding out,
for the whole of the cannon that he had been mad enough to leave by
the shore was in the enemy's possession, and would remain so unless
the townspeople should rise in the Government interest for their
recapture. This he was well aware they would not do.

His resentment against his luck, and the tale-bearing voice within,
which told him that he had nothing to thank for it but his own
carelessness, grew more insistent as his head grew clearer. He had
been jerked out of sleep, heavy-headed, and with a brain still dulled
by drink, but the morning freshness worked on him, and the sun warmed
his senses into activity. The sight of Flemington, clean, impertinent,
and entirely comprehensive of the circumstances, drove him mad; and it
drove him still madder to know that Archie understood why he had been
unwilling to see his report last night.

Hall's abilities were a little superior to his looks. So far he had
served his country, not conspicuously, but without disaster, and had
he been able to keep himself as sober as most people contrived to be
in those intemperate days, he might have gone on his course with the
same tepid success. He was one who liked the distractions of towns,
and he bemoaned the fate that had sent him to anchor in a dull creek
of the East Coast, where the taverns held nothing but faces whose
unconcealed dislike forbade conviviality, and where even the light
women looked upon his uniform askance. He was not a lively comrade at
the best of times, and here, where he was thrown upon the sole society
of his officers, with whom he was not popular, he was growing more
morose and more careless as his habits of stealthy excess grew upon
him. Archie, with his quick judgment of his fellow-men, had measured
him accurately, and he knew it. In the midst of the morning's disaster
the presence of the interloper, his flippant civility of word and
insolence of manner, made his sluggish blood boil.

It was plain that the party on the island must be dislodged before
anything could be done to save the situation, and Hall now decided to
land as large a force as he could spare upon the mainland. By marching
it along the road to Ferryden he would give the impression that some
attempt was to be made to cross the strait nearer to the coast, and to
land it between Dial Hill and the sea. Behind Ferryden village a rough
track turned sharply southward up the bank, and this they were to
take; they would be completely hidden from Inchbrayock once they had
got over the crest of the land, and they were to double back with all
speed along the mainland under shelter of the ridge, and to go for
about a mile parallel with the Basin. When they had got well to the
westward side of the island, they were to wheel down to the Basin's
shore at a spot where a grove of trees edged the brink; for here, in a
sheltering turn of backwater among the trunks and roots, a few boats
were moored for the convenience of those who wished to cross straight
to Montrose by water instead of taking the usual path by the
stepping-stones over Inchbrayock Island.

They were to embark at this place, and, hugging the shore, under cover
of its irregularities, to approach Inchbrayock from the west. If they
should succeed in landing unseen, they would surprise the enemy at the
further side of the graveyard whilst his attention was turned on the
_Venture_. The officer to be sent in command of the party believed it
could be done, because the length of the island would intervene to
hide their manoeuvres from the town, where the citizens, crowding on
the quays, would be only too ready to direct the notice of the rebels
to their approach.

As the boat put off from the ship Archie slipped into it; he seemed to
have lost his definite place in the scheme of things during the last
twenty-four hours; he was nobody's servant, nobody's master, nobody's
concern; and in spite of his bold reply to Hall's threat of arrest, he
knew quite well that though the captain would stop short of such a
measure, he might order him below at any moment; the only wonder was
that he had not done so already. He did not know into what hands he
might fall, should Hall be obliged to surrender, and this contingency
appeared to be growing likely. By tacking himself on to the
landing-party he would at least have the chance of action, and though,
having been careful to keep out of Hall's sight, he had not been able
to discover their destination, he had determined to land with the men.

After they had disembarked, he went boldly up to the officer in charge
of the party and asked for permission to go with it, and when this was
accorded with some surprise, he fell into step. As they tramped along
towards Ferryden, he managed to pick up something of the work in hand
from the man next to him. His only fear was of the chance of running
against Logie; nevertheless, he made up his mind to trust to luck to
save him from that, because he believed that Logie, as a professional
soldier, would be in command of the guns on the hill. It was from Dial
Hill that the tactical details of the attack could best be directed,
and if either of the conspirators were upon the island, Archie was
convinced it would be Ferrier.

They soon reached Ferryden. The sun was clear and brave in the salt
air over the sea, and a flock of gulls was screaming out beyond the
bar, dipping, hovering, swinging sideways against the light breeze,
now this way, now that way, their wanton voices full of mockery, as
though the derisive spirits imprisoned in the ocean had become
articulate, and were crying out on the land. The village looked
distrustfully at the approach of the small company, and some of the
fisher-wives dragged their children indoors as if they thought to see
them kidnapped. Such men as were hanging about watched them with
sullen eyes as they turned in between the houses and made for the
higher ground.

The boom of the _Venture's_ guns came to them from time to time, and
once they heard a great shout rise from the quays, but they could see
nothing because of the intervening swell of the land. They passed a
farm and a few scattered cottages; but these were empty, for their
inmates had gone to the likeliest places they could find for a view of
what was happening in the harbour.

Presently they went down to the Basin, straggling by twos and threes.
At the water's edge a colony of beeches stood naked and leafless,
their heads listed over westward by the winds that swept up the
river's mouth. They were crowded thick about the creek down which
Flemington and his companions came, and at their feet, tied to the
gnarled elbows of the great roots beneath which the water had eaten
deep into the bank, lay three or four boats with their oars piled
inside them. The beech-mast of years had sunk into the soil, giving a
curious mixture of heaviness and elasticity to the earth as it was
trodden; a water-rat drew a lead-coloured ripple along the
transparency, below which the undulations of the bottom lay like a
bird's-eye view of some miniature world. The quiet of this hidden
landing-place echoed to the clank of the rowlocks as the heavy oars
were shipped, and two boatloads slid out between the stems.

Archie, who was unarmed, had borrowed one of the officer's pistols,
not so much with the intention of using it as from the wish for a
plausible pretext for joining the party. At any time his love of
adventure would welcome such an opportunity, and at this moment he did
not care what might happen to him. He seemed to have no chance of
being true to anybody, and it was being revealed to him that, in these
circumstances, life was scarcely endurable. He had never thought about
it before, and he could think of nothing else now. It was some small
comfort to know that, should his last half-hour of life be spent on
Inchbrayock, Madam Flemington would at least understand that she had
wronged him in suspecting him of being a turncoat. If only James could
know that he had not betrayed him--or, rather, that his report was in
the hands of that accursed beggar before they met among the
broom-bushes! Yet, what if he did know it? Would his loathing of the
spy under the roof-tree of his brother's house be any the less? He
would never understand--never know. And yet he had been true to him in
his heart, and the fact that he had now no roof-tree of his own proved

They slipped in under the bank of the island and disembarked silently.
The higher ground in the middle of it crossed their front like the
line of an incoming wave, hiding all that was going on on its farther
side. They were to advance straight over it, and to rush down upon the
thicket where the gun was entrenched with its muzzle towards the
_Venture_. There was to be no working round the north shore, lest the
hundreds of eyes on the quays should catch sight of them, and a
hundred tongues give the alarm to the rebels. They were to attack at
once, only waiting for the sound of another shot to locate the exact
place for which they were to make. They stood drawn up, waiting for
the order.

Archie dropped behind the others. His heart had begun to sink. He had
assured himself over and over again that Logie must be on Dial Hill;
yet as each moment brought him nearer to contact with the enemy, he
felt cold misgiving stealing on him. What if his guesses had been
wrong? He knew that he had been a fool to run the risk he had taken.
Chance is such a smiling, happy-go-lucky deity when we see her afar
off; but when we are well on our steady plod towards her, and the
distance lessens between us, it is often all that we can do to meet
her eyes--their expression has changed. Archie's willingness to take
risks was unfailing and temperamental, and he had taken this one in
the usual spirit, but so much had happened lately to shake his
confidence in life and in himself that his high heart was beating
slower. Never had he dreaded anything as much as he dreaded James's
knowledge of the truth; yet the most agonizing part of it all was that
James could not know the whole truth, nor understand it, even if he
knew it. Archie's reading of the other man's character was accurate
enough to tell him that no knowledge of facts could make Logie
understand the part he had played.

Sick at heart, he stood back from the party, watching it gather before
the officer. He did not belong to it; no one troubled his head about
him, and the men's backs were towards him. He stole away, sheltered by
a little hillock, and ran, bent almost double, to the southern shore
of the island. He would creep round it and get as near as possible to
the thicket. If he could conceal himself, he might be able to see the
enemy and the enemy's commander, and to discover the truth while there
was yet time for flight. He glanced over his shoulder to see if the
officer had noticed his absence, and being reassured, he pressed on.
He knew that anyone who thought about him at all would take him for a
coward, but he did not reckon that. The dread of meeting James
possessed him.

Sheep were often brought over to graze the island, and their tracks
ran like network among the bushes. He trod softly in and out, anxious
to get forward before the next sound of the gun should let loose the
invading-party upon the rebels. He passed the end of the
stepping-stones which crossed the Esk's bed to the mainland; they were
now nearly submerged by the tide rising in the river. He had not known
of their existence, and as he noticed them with surprise, a shot shook
the air, and though the thicket, now not far before him, blocked his
view of the _Venture's_ hull, he saw the tops of her masts tremble,
and knew that she had been struck.

Before him, the track took a sharp turn round a bend of the shore,
which cut the path like a little promontory, so that he could see
nothing beyond it, and here he paused. In another few minutes the
island would be in confusion from the attack, and he might discover
nothing. He set his teeth and stepped round the corner.

The track widened out and then plunged into the fringe of the thicket.
A man was kneeling on one knee with his back to Flemington; his hands
were shading his eyes, and he was peering along a tunnel-shaped gap in
the branches, through which could be seen a patch of river and the
damaged bows of the _Venture_.

Archie's instinct was to retreat, but before he could do so, the man
jumped up and faced him. His heart leaped to his mouth, for it was

     *   *   *   *   *

Logie stood staring at him. Then he made a great effort to pick up the
connecting-link of recollection that he felt sure he must have
dropped. He had been so much absorbed in the business in hand that he
found it impossible for a moment to estimate the significance of any
outside matter. Though he was confounded and disturbed by the
unlooked-for apparition of the painter, the idea of hostility never
entered his mind.

"Flemington?" he exclaimed, stepping towards him.

But the other man's expression was so strange that he stopped,
conscious of vague disaster. What had the intruder come to tell him?
As he stood, Flemington murmured something he could not distinguish,
then turned quickly in his tracks.

Logie leaped after him, and seized him by the shoulder before he had
time to double round the bend.

"Let me go!" cried Archie, his chest heaving; "let me go, man!"

But James's grip tightened; he was a strong man, and he almost dragged
him over. As he held him, he caught sight of the Government pistol in
his belt. It was one that the officer who had lent it to Flemington
had taken from the ship.

He jerked Archie violently round and made a snatch at the weapon, and
the younger man, all but thrown off his balance, thrust his arm
convulsively into the air. His sleeve shot back, laying bare a round,
red spot outside the brown, sinewy wrist.

Then there flashed retrospectively before James's eye that same wound,
bright in the blaze of the flaming paper; and with it there flashed

His impulse was to draw his own pistol, and to shoot the spy dead, but
Archie recovered his balance, and was grappling with him so that he
could not get his arm free. The strength of the slim, light young man
astonished him. He was as agile as a weasel, but James found in him,
added to his activity, a force that nearly matched his own.

There was no possible doubt of Logie's complete enlightenment, though
he kept his crooked mouth shut and uttered no word. His eyes wore an
expression not solely due to the violent struggle going on; they were
terrible, and they woke the frantic instinct of self-preservation in
Flemington. He knew that James was straining to get out his own
pistol, and he hung on him and gripped him for dear life. As they
swayed and swung to and fro, trampling the bents, there rose from
behind the graveyard a yell that gathered and broke over the sound of
their own quick breaths like a submerging flood, and the bullets began
to whistle over the rising ground.

Archie saw a change come into James's eyes; then he found himself
staggering, hurled with swift and tremendous force from his
antagonist. He was flung headlong against the jutting bend round which
he had come, and his forehead struck it heavily; then, rolling down to
the track at its foot, he lay stunned and still.



AS James Logie dashed back to his men to meet this unexpected attack,
he left Flemington lying with his face to the bank and his back
towards the river; he was so close to the edge of the island that his
hair rested on the wet sand permeated by the returning tide coming up
the Esk. James's whole mind had gone back like a released spring to
its natural preoccupation, and he almost forgot him before he had time
to join the brisk affray that was going on.

But though Archie lay where he fell, and was as still as a heap of
driftwood, it was only a few minutes before he came to himself.
Perhaps the chill of the damp sand under his head helped to revive
him; perhaps the violence of the blow had been broken by the sod
against which he had been hurled. He stirred and raised himself,
dazed, but listening to the confused sounds of fighting that rang over
Inchbrayock. His head hurt him, and instinctively he grubbed up a
handful of the cold, wet sand and held it to his brow. His wits had
not gone far, for there had been no long break in his consciousness,
and he got on his feet and looked round for the best means of escape.

James knew all. That was plain enough; and on the issue of the
skirmish his own liberty would depend if he did not get clear of the
island at once. He went back round the bend, and looking up the shore
he saw a couple of the stepping-stones which were only half covered by
the tide. In the middle of the channel they had disappeared already,
but at either edge they lay visible, like the two ends of a partly
submerged chain. Blood was trickling down his face, but he washed it
off, and made hastily for the crossing, wading in.

The Esk was not wide just there, though it was far deeper than he had
fancied it, and he stumbled along, churning up the mud into an opaque
swirl through which he could not see the bottom. He climbed the
further bank, wasting no time in looking behind him, and never stopped
until he stood, panting and dizzy, on the high ridge of land from
which he could overlook Inchbrayock and the harbour and town. He was a
good deal exhausted, for his head throbbed like a boiling pot, and his
hands were shaking. He lay down in a patch of whins, remembering that
he was on the sky-line. He meant to see which way the fortunes of war
were going to turn before deciding what to do with himself. Thanks to
chance, his business with Captain Hall was not finished, nor even
begun; but as things seemed at present, Captain Hall might be a
prisoner before the leisure which had been the subject of his own
gibes that morning should arrive. The vessel's guns had roared out
again as he struggled up the steep, but there had been silence on the
island, and even the rattle of musketry had now stopped. Something
decisive must have taken place, though he could not guess what it was,
and he was too far away to distinguish more than the moving figures in
the graveyard.

He was high enough to see the curve of the watery horizon, for
Ferryden village was some way below him. His view was only interrupted
by a group of firs that stood like an outpost between him and the
land's end. He lay among his friendly whin-bushes, staring down on the
strait. If James were victorious he knew that there would soon be a
hue and cry on his own tracks; but though alive to the desirableness
of a good start in these circumstances, he felt that he could not run
while there remained any chance of laying the whole of his report
before Captain Hall. He thought, from what he had seen of the man,
that the less he was reckoned with by his superiors the better, but it
was not his business to consider that. As he turned these things over
in his mind his eyes were attracted to Dial Hill, upon which the
sudden sign of a new turn of events could be read.

He could see the group of men with the guns below the flagstaff which
crowned its summit, and what now attracted his attention was a dark
object that had been run up the ropes, its irregular outline flapping
and flying against the sky as it was drawn frantically up and down.

Flemington was blessed with long sight, and he was certain that the
two sharp-cut ends that waved like streamers as the dark object dipped
and rose, were the sleeves of a man's coat. He saw a figure detach
itself from the rest and run towards the seaward edge of the eminence.
Ferrier--for he supposed now that Ferrier was on the hill--must be
signalling out to sea with this makeshift flag.

He half raised himself from his lair. The cold grey-green of the ocean
spread along the world's edge, broken by tiny streaks of foam as the
wind began to freshen, and beyond the fir-trees, seen through their
stems, the reason of the activity on Dial Hill slid into sight.

A ship was coming up the coast not a couple of miles out, and as
Flemington watched her she stood in landward, as though attracted out
of her course by the signals and the sound of firing in Montrose
harbour. She was too far off for him to distinguish her colours, but
he knew enough about shipping to be certain that she was a French

He dropped back into his place; whilst these sensational matters were
going forward he did not suppose that anyone would think of pursuing
him. The fact that the rebels were signalling her in suggested that
the stranger might not be unexpected, and in all probability she
carried French supplies and Jacobite troops. The likelihood of an
interview with Captain Hall grew more remote.

The frigate drew closer; soon she was hidden from him by the jutting
out of the land. Another shot broke from the _Venture_, but the quick
reply from the island took all doubt of the issue of the conflict from
Archie's mind. James was in full possession of the place, and the
surprise must have been a failure.

Archie watched eagerly to see the ship arrive in the river-mouth. It
was evident that Hall, from his position under the south shore of the
strait, had not seen her yet. Presently she rounded the land and
appeared to the hundreds of eyes on the quays, a gallant, silent,
winged creature, a vivid apparition against the band of sea beyond the
opening channel of the Esk, swept towards the town as though by some
unseen impulse of fate. The shout that went up as she came into view
rose to where Archie lay on the hillside.

The tide was now running high, and she passed in under Dial Hill. Her
deck was covered with troops, and the waving of hats and the cheers of
the townspeople, who were pouring along the further side of the
harbour, made the truth plain to the solitary watcher among the whins.
The _Venture_ sent a shot to meet her that fell just in front of her
bows, but although it was followed by a second, that cut her rigging,
no great harm was done, and she answered with a broadside that echoed
off the walls of the town till the strait was in a roar. It had no
time to subside before James's gun on Inchbrayock began again.

Flemington could see that Hall's surrender could only be a matter of
time; the new-comer would soon be landing her troops out of his range,
and, having done so, would be certain to attack the _Venture_ from the
Ferryden side of the river. Half of Hall's men were on the island,
which was in possession of the rebels, his vessel was damaged and in
no condition to escape to sea, even had there been no hostile craft in
his way and no Dial Hill to stand threatening between him and the

The time had come for Archie to think of his own plight and of his own
prospects. He was adrift again, cut off even from the disorderly ship
that had sheltered him last night, and from the unlucky sot who
commanded her. His best plan would be to take the news of Hall's
capture to Edinburgh, for it would be madness for him to think of
going to Perth, whilst his identity as a Government agent would be
published by Ferrier and Logie all over that part of the country. He
was cast down as he sat with his hand to his aching head, and now that
it had resulted in that fatal meeting, his own folly in going to the
island seemed incredible.

His luck had been so good all his life, and after the many years that
he had trusted her, the jade had turned on him! He had been too
high-handed with her, that was the explanation of it! He had asked too
much. He had been over-confident in her, over-confident in himself.
Flemington was neither vain nor conceited, being too heartily
interested in outside things to take very personal points of view; he
merely went straight on, with the joy of life lighting his progress.
But now he had put the crown on his foolhardiness. He had had so many
good things--strength, health, wits, charm; the stage of his stirring
life whereon to use them, and behind that stage the peaceful
background of the home he loved, filled with the presence of the being
he most admired and revered on earth.

But new lights had broken in on him of late. Troublous lights, playing
from behind a curtain that hid unknown things. Suddenly he had turned
and followed them, impelled by uncomprehended forces in himself, and
it seemed that in consequence all around him had shifted,
disintegrated, leaving him stranded. Once more as he watched, his
anxious eyes on the scene below him, his heart full of his own
perplexities, a last roar of shot filled the harbour, and then, on the
_Venture_, he saw the flag hauled down.

He rose and looked about him, telling himself that he must get as far
from the neighbourhood of Montrose as he could in the shortest
possible time. Sixty miles of land stretched between him and
Edinburgh, and the only thing for him to do was to start by way of the
nearest seaport from which he could sail for Leith. He was a very
different figure from the well-appointed young man who had ridden away
from Ardguys only yesterday, for he was soaked to above the knees from
wading in the Esk; blood had dripped on his coat from the cut on his
forehead, and his hair at the back was clogged with sand. Excitement
had kept him from thinking how cold he was, and he had not known that
he was shivering; but he knew it as he stood in the teeth of the fresh
wind. He laughed in spite of his plight; it was so odd to think of
starting for Edinburgh from a whin-bush.

He turned southwards, determining to go forward till he should strike
the road leading to the seaport of Aberbrothock; by sticking to the
high ground he would soon come to it at the inland end of the Basin,
and by it he might reach Aberbrothock by nightfall, and thence take
sail in the morning. This was the best plan he could devise, though he
did not care to contemplate the miles he would have to trudge. He knew
that the broken coast took a great inward curve, and that by this
means he would be avoiding its ins and outs, and he wished that he did
not feel so giddy and so little able to face his difficulties. He
remembered that the money he had on him made a respectable sum, and
realized that the less worth robbing he looked, the more likely he
would be to get to his journey's end in safety. He stepped out with an
effort; southward he must go, and for some time to come Angus must
know him no more.



WHEN Skirling Wattie had delivered his letter to Flemington on the
foregoing day, he watched the young man out of sight with disgust, and
cursed him for a high-handed jackanapes. He was not used to be treated
in such a fashion. There was that about Archie which took his fancy,
for the suggestion of stir and movement that went everywhere with
Flemington pleased him, and roused his unfailing curiosity. The
beggar's most pleasant characteristic was his interest in everybody
and everything; his worst, the unseasonable brutality with which he
gratified it.

A livelihood gained by his own powers of cajolery and persistence had
left him without a spark of respect for his kind. He would have been a
man of prowess had his limbs been intact--and destiny, in robbing his
body of activity, had transferred that quality to his brains. His huge
shoulders and broad fists, the arrogant male glare of his roving eye,
might well hint at the wisdom of providence in keeping his sphere of
action to the narrow limits of a go-cart. Those who look for
likenesses between people and animals would be reminded by him of a
wild boar; and it was almost shocking to anyone with a sense of
fitness to hear the mellow and touching voice, rich with the
indescribable quiver of pathos and tragedy, that proceeded from his
bristly jaws when he sang. The world that it conjured up before
imaginative listeners was a world of twilight; of stars that drew a
trail of tear-dimmed lustre about the ancient haunted places of the
country; stars that had shone on battlefields and on the partings of
lovers; that had looked on the raids of the border, and had stood over
the dark border-towers among the peat. It was a strange truth that, in
the voice of this coarse and humble vagabond, lay the whole
distinctive spirit of the national poetry of Scotland.

In the last few months his employment had added new zest to his life,
for it was not only the pay he received for his occasional carrying of
letters that was welcome to him; his bold and guileful soul delighted
in the occupation for its own sake. He was something of a student of
human nature, as all those who live by their wits must be of
necessity; and the small services he was called upon to give brought
him into contact with new varieties of men. Archie was new to him,
and, in the beggar's opinion, immeasurably more amusing than anyone he
had seen yet. In modern parlance he would be called 'a sportsman,'
this low-bred old ruffian who had lost his legs, and who was left to
the mercy of his own ingenuity and to the efforts of the five dumb
animals which supplemented his loss. He had--all honour to him--kept
his love of life and its chances through his misfortune; and though he
did not know it himself, it was his recognition of the same spirit in
Flemington that made him appreciate the young man.

His services to the state had not been important up to the present
time. A few letters carried, a little information collected, had been
the extent of his usefulness. But, though he was not in their regular
employ, the authorities were keeping a favourable eye on him, for he
had so far proved himself capable, close-mouthed, and a very miracle
of local knowledge.

He sat in his cart looking resentfully after Flemington between the
stems of the alders and the lattice of their golden-brown leaves, and,
though the one word tossed over the rider's shoulders did not tell him
much, he determined he would not lose sight of Archie if he could help
it. "Brechin" might mean anything from a night's lodging to a
lengthened stay, but he would follow him as far as he dared and set
about discovering his movements. Skirling Wattie had friends in
Brechin, as he had in most places round about, and certain bolt-holes
of his own wherein he could always find shelter for himself and his
dogs; but he did not mean to trust himself nearer than these refuges
to Lord Balnillo, at any rate, not for a few days. Chance had relieved
him of the letter for which he was responsible sooner than he
expected, and at present he was a free man. He roused his team, tucked
his pipes into their corner of the cart, and, guiding himself
carefully between the trees, issued from the thicket like some ribald
vision of goblinry escaped from the world of folk-lore.

He turned towards Brechin, and set off for the town at a brisk trot,
the yellow dog straining at his harness, and his comrades taking their
pace from him. Every inch of the road was known to Wattie, every tree
and tuft, every rut and hole; and as there were plenty of these last,
he bumped and swung along in a way that would have dislocated the
bones of a lighter person. The violent roughness of his progress was
what served him for exercise and kept him in health. There were not
many houses near the highway, but the children playing round the doors
of the few he passed hailed him with shouts, and he answered them, as
he answered everyone, with his familiar wag of the head.

When he entered Brechin and rolled past the high, circular shaft of
its round tower, the world made way for him with a grin, and when it
was not agile enough to please him, he heralded himself with a shrill
note from the chanter, which he had unscrewed from his pipes. Business
was business with him. He meant to lie in the town to-night, but he
was anxious to get on to Flemington's tracks before the scent was

He drove to the Swan inn and entered the yard, and there he had the
satisfaction of seeing Archie's horse being rubbed down with a wisp of
straw. Its rider, he made out, had left the inn on foot half an hour
earlier, so, with this meagre clue, he sought the streets and the
company of the idlers haunting their thievish corners, to whom the
passing stranger and what might be made out of him were the best
interests of the day. By the time the light was failing he had traced
Flemington down to the river, where he had been last seen crossing the
bridge. The beggar was a good deal surprised; he could not imagine
what was carrying Archie away from the place.

In the dusk he descended the steep streets running down to the Esk,
and, slackening his pace, took out a short, stout pair of crutches
that he kept beside him, using them as brakes on either side of the
cart. People who saw Wattie for the first time would stand,
spell-bound, to watch the incredible spectacle of his passage through
a town, but, to the inhabitants of Brechin, he was too familiar a
sight for anything but the natural widening of the mouth that his
advent would produce from pure force of habit.

The lights lit here and there were beginning to repeat themselves in
the water, and men were returning to their houses after the day's work
as he stopped his cart and sent out that surest of all attractions,
the first notes of 'The Tod,' into the gathering mists of the
river-side. By ones and twos, the details of a sympathetic audience
drew together round him as his voice rose over the sliding rush of the
Esk. Idlers on the bridge leaned over the grey arches as the sound
came to them above the tongue of the little rapid that babbled as it
lost itself in the shadow of the woods downstream.

Then the pipes took up their tune. Jests and roars of laughter oiled
the springs of generosity, and the good prospects of supper and a bed
began to smile upon the beggar. When darkness set in, he turned his
wheels towards a shed that a publican had put at his disposal for the
night, and he and his dogs laid themselves down to rest in its
comfortable straw. The yellow cur, relieved from his harness, stole
closer and closer to his master and lay with his jowl against the
pipes. Presently Wattie's dirty hand went out and sought the coarse
head of his servant.

"Doag," he was muttering, as he went to sleep.

Perhaps in all the grim, grey little Scottish town, no living creature
closed its eyes more contentedly than the poor cur whose head was
pillowed in paradise because of the touch that was on it.

Morning found man and dogs out betimes and migrating to the heart of
the town. Wattie was one who liked to get an early draught from the
fountain-head of news, to be beforehand, so to speak, with his day.
The Swan inn was his goal, and he had not got up the hill towards it
when his practised eye, wise in other men's movements, saw that the
world was hurrying along, drawn by some magnet stronger than its
legitimate work. The women were running out of their houses too. As he
toiled up the steep incline, a figure burst from the mouth of a wynd
and came flying down the middle of the narrow way.

"Hey! what ails ye, man? What's 'ahind ye?" he cried, stopping his
cart and spreading out his arms as though to embrace the approaching

The other paused. He was a pale, foolish-looking youth, whose progress
seemed as little responsible as that of a discharged missile.

"There's fechtin'!" he yelled, apparently addressing the air in


"Ay, there's fechtin' at Montrose this hour syne! Div ye no hear them,
ye deef muckle swine?" continued the youth, rendered abusive by

The two stared in each other's faces as those do who listen. Dull and
distant, a muffled boom drove in from the coast. A second throb
followed it.

The youth dropped his raised hands and fled on.

Wattie turned his dogs, and set off down the hill without more delay.
Here was the reason that Archie had left the town! It was in
expectation of this present disturbance on the coast that he had
slipped out of Brechin by the less frequented road round the Basin.

He scurried down the hill, scattering the children playing in the
kennel with loud imprecations and threats. He sped over the bridge,
and was soon climbing the rise on the farther side of the Esk. If
there was fighting going on, he would make shift to see it, and
Montrose would be visible from most of his road. Soon he would get a
view of the distant harbour, and would see the smoke of the guns whose
throats continued to trouble the air. Also, he would get forward
unmolested, for there would be the width of the Basin between himself
and Lord Balnillo.

He breathed his team when he reached the top of the hill; for he was a
scientific driver, and he had some way to go. He cast a glance down at
the place he had left, rejoicing that no one had followed him out of
it. When he was on his own errands he did not like company,
preferring, like most independent characters, to develop his
intentions in the perfect freedom of silence.

When he drew near enough to distinguish the _Venture_, a dark spot
under the lee of Ferryden, he saw the white puffs of smoke bursting
from her, and the answering clouds rising from the island. There had
been no time to hear the rumours of the morning before he met the pale
young man, or he would have learned that a body of Prince Charles's
men under Ferrier had left Brechin last night whilst he lay sound
asleep in the straw among his dogs. He could not imagine where the
assailants had come from who were pounding at the ship from

The fields sloped away from him to the water, leaving an uninterrupted
view. He pressed on to the cross-roads at which he must turn along the
Basin's shore. From there on, the conformation of the land, and the
frequent clumps of trees, would shut out both town and harbour from
his sight until he came parallel with the island.

He halted at the turning for a last look at the town. The firing had
ceased, which reconciled him a little to the eclipse of the distant
spectacle; then he drove on again, unconscious of the sight he was to
miss. For, unsuspected by him, as by the crowd thronging the quays of
Montrose, the French frigate was creeping up the coast, and she made
her appearance in the river-mouth just as Wattie began the tamer stage
of his journey.

The yellow cur and his companions toiled along at their steady trot,
their red tongues hanging. The broadside from the French ship rang
inland, and the beggar groaned, urging them with curses and chosen
abuse. His intimate knowledge of the neighbourhood led him to steer
for the identical spot on which Flemington, crouched in his whin-bush,
had looked down on the affray, and he hoped devoutly that he might
reach that point of vantage while there was still something to be seen
from it. Silence had settled on the strait once more.

Not far in front a man was coming into sight, the first creature
Wattie had seen since leaving Brechin, whose face was turned from the
coast. He seemed a person of irresolute mind, as well as of
vacillating feet, for every few yards he would stop, hesitating,
before resuming his way. The beggar cursed him heartily for a
drunkard, for, though he had a lively sympathy with backsliders of
that kind, he knew that accurate information was the last thing to be
expected from them. Before the wayfarers had halved the distance
between them the man stopped, and sitting down by the tumbledown stone
dyke at the roadside, dropped his head in his hands. As the cart
passed him a few minutes later, he raised a ghastly face, and Skirling
Wattie pulled up astounded, with a loud and profane exclamation, as he
recognized Flemington.

Though Archie had been glad to escape from the beggar yesterday, he
was now thankful to see anyone who might pass for a friend. He tried
to smile, but his eyes closed again, and he put out his hand towards
the dyke.

"I'm so devilish giddy," he said.

Wattie looked at the cut on his head and the stains of blood on his

"Ye've gotten a rare dunt," he observed.

Archie, who seemed to himself to be slipping off the rounded edge of
the world, made no reply.

The other sat eyeing him with perplexity and some impatience. He did
not know what he wanted most--to get to Montrose, or to get news out
of Flemington. The dogs lay down in the mud. Flemington kept his hand
to his eyes for a minute, and then lifted his head again.

"The ship has surrendered," he said, speaking with difficulty; "I have
been on the high ground watching. She struck her flag. A French

He stopped again. The road on which he sat was whirling down into
illimitable space.

The other took in his plight. His coat, torn in his struggle with
Logie, was full of whin-prickles, and the wet mud was caked on his
legs. His soft, silky hair was flattened on his forehead.

"Ye've been fechtin' yersel', ma lad," said Wattie. "Whaur hae ye

"There's a rebel force on Inchbrayock," said Archie, with another
effort; "I have been on the island. Yes, I've been fighting. A man
recognized me--a man I saw at--on the road by Balnillo. They will be
hunting me soon, and I have papers on me they must not find, and
money--all the money I have. God knows how I am to get away! I must
get to Aberbrothock."

"What was ye sayin' aboot the French?"

In broken sentences, and between his fits of giddiness, Archie
explained the situation in the harbour, and the beggar listened, his
bristly brows knit, his bonnet thrust back on his bald head; and his
own best course of action grew clear to him. Montrose would soon be
full of rebel soldiers, and though these might be generous audiences
when merry with wine and loose upon the streets, their presence would
make him no safer from Lord Balnillo. Wattie knew that the judge's
loyalty was beginning to be suspected, and that he might well have
friends among the Prince's officers, whose arrival might attract him
to the town. And to serve Archie would be a good recommendation for
himself with his employers, to say nothing of any private gratitude
that the young man might feel.

"Bide you whaur ye are!" he exclaimed, rousing his dogs. "Lad, a'll
hae to ca' ye oot o' this, an' dod! we'll need a' our time!"

Not far from them a spring was trickling from the fields, dropping in
a spurt through the damp mosses between the unpointed stones of the
dyke. The obedient dogs drew their master close to it, and he filled a
battered pannikin that he took from among his small collection of
necessities in the bottom of the cart. He returned with the water, and
when Archie had bathed his head in its icy coldness, he drew a
whisky-bottle from its snug lair under the bagpipes, and forced him to
drink. It was half full, for the friendly publican had replenished his
store before they parted on the foregoing night. As the liquid warmed
his stomach, Archie raised his head slowly.

"I believe I can walk now," he said at last.

"Ye'll need to try," observed Wattie dryly. "Ye'll no can ride wi' me.
Come awa', Maister Flemington. Will a gi' ye a skelloch o' the pipes
to help ye alang?"

"In God's name, no!" cried Archie, whose head was splitting.

He struggled on to his feet. The whisky was beginning to overcome the
giddiness, and he knew that every minute spent on the highroad was a

The beggar was determined to go to Aberbrothock with Archie; he did
not consider him in a fit state to be left alone, and he counselled
him to leave the road at once, and to cut diagonally across the high
ground, whilst he himself, debarred by his wheels from going across
country, drove back to the cross roads, and took the one to the coast.
By doing this the pair would meet, Flemington having taken one side of
the triangle, while Wattie had traversed the other two. They were to
await each other at a spot indicated by the latter, where a bit of
moor encroached on the way.

As Wattie turned again to retrace his road, he watched his friend
toiling painfully up the slanting ground among the uneven tussocks of
grass with some anxiety. Archie laboured along, pausing now and again
to rest, but he managed to gain the summit of the ridge. Wattie saw
his figure shorten from the feet up as he crossed the sky-line, till
his head and shoulders dropped out of sight like the topsails of a
ship over a clear horizon; he was disappointed at having missed the
sight of so much good fighting. Archie's account had been rather
incoherent, but he gathered that the rebels were in possession of the
harbour, and that a French ship had come in in the middle of the
affray full of rebel troops. He shouted the information to the few
people he met.

He turned southward at the cross roads. Behind him lay the panorama of
the Basin and the spread of the rolling country; Brechin, the Esk, the
woods of Monrummon Moor, stretching out to Forfar, and, northward, the
Grampians, lying with their long shoulders in the autumn light. His
beat for begging was down there across the water and round about the
country between town and town; but though his activities were in that
direction, he knew Aberbrothock and the coast well, for he had been
born in a fishing-village in one of its creeks, and had spent his
early years at sea. He would be able to put Archie in the way of a
passage to Leith without much trouble and without unnecessary
explanations; Archie had money on him, and could be trusted to pay his

He was the first to reach the trysting-place, and he drew up, glad to
give his team a rest; at last he saw Archie coming along with the
slow, careful gait of a man who is obliged to consider each step of
his way separately in order to get on at all.

"Sit ye doon," he exclaimed, as they met.

"If once I sit down I am lost," said Archie. "Come on."

He started along the road with the same dogged step, the beggar
keeping alongside. They had gone about half a mile when Flemington
clutched at a wayside bush and then slid to the ground in a heap.

Wattie pulled up, dismayed, and scanned their surroundings. To let him
lie there by the road was out of the question. He could not tell how
much his head had been injured, but he knew enough to be sure that
exposure and cold might bring a serious illness on a man in his state;
he did not understand that the whisky he had given Archie was the
worst possible thing for him. To the beggar, it was the sovereign
remedy for all trouble of mind or body.

He cursed his own circumscribed energies; there was no one in sight.
The nearest habitation was a little farmhouse on the skirts of the
moor with one tiny window in its gable-end making a dark spot, high
under the roof.

Wattie turned his wheels reluctantly towards it. Unwilling though he
was to draw attention to his companion, there was no choice.



THOUGH Skirling Wattie seldom occupied the same bed on many
consecutive nights, his various resting-places had so great a family
likeness that he could not always remember where he was when he
chanced to wake in the small hours. Sheds, barns, stables harboured
him in the cold months when luck was good; loanings, old quarries,
whin-patches, the alder clump beyond Brechin, or the wall-side at
Magdalen Chapel, in the summer.

To-night he lay in the barn abutting on the tiny farmhouse at which he
had sought shelter for Archie. He had met with a half-hearted
reception from the woman who came to the door. Her man was away, she
told him, and she was unwilling to admit strangers in his absence. She
had never seen Wattie before, and it was plain that she did not like
his looks. He induced her at last, with the greatest difficulty, to
give shelter in her barn to the comrade whom he described as lying in
extremity at the roadside. Finally, she despatched her son, a youth of
fifteen, to accompany the beggar, and to help to bring the sufferer

Cold water revived Archie again, and he reached the barn with the
assistance of the lad, who, better disposed than his mother, cut a
bundle of dry heather, which he spread in a corner for his comfort.
The woman looked with silent surprise at her undesired guest; she had
thought to see a fellow-traveller of different condition in company
with the masterful old blackguard in the cart. Her glances and her
expressive silence made Wattie uneasy, but there was no help for their
plight whilst Flemington could scarcely stand.

The beggar had spent the rest of that day in the barn. He was not
suffered to enter the farm, nor was he offered any food; but he had
enough store by him from what he had collected in Brechin for his own
needs and those of his team. Archie's only requirement was the bowl of
water that his companion had obtained from the boy. He lay alternately
dozing and tossing on his pile of heather. His body was chilled for
his high boots had been full of the Esk water, and Wattie had
hesitated to draw them off, lest he should be unable to get them on
again after their soaking.

Night fell on the barn at last. Wattie slept sound, with the yellow
cur's muzzle against his shoulder; but he awoke towards midnight, for
Archie's feverish voice was coming from the corner in which he lay. He
inclined his ear, attracted by the recurrent name of Logie which ran
through the disconnected babblings, rising again and again like some
half-drowned object carried along a swift stream. The darkness made
every word seem more distinct.

"Listen to me!" cried Flemington. "Logie! Logie! you do not understand
. . . it is safe . . . it is burnt! Nobody shall know it from me.
. . . I cannot take your money, Logie . . . I will tell you
everything, but you will not understand. . . ."

The beggar was holding his breath.

"I did not guess it was Inchbrayock . . . I thought it would not be
Inchbrayock! Logie, I will say nothing . . . but I will tell you all.
For God's sake, Logie, . . . I swear it is true! . . . Listen. . . ."

Skirling Wattie could hear him struggling as though he were fighting
for his life.

"Not to Ardguys . . . I cannot go back to Ardguys! I shall never tell
. . . never, never tell . . . but I shall know where you are! They
shall never know. _Ah!_" cried Archie, raising his voice like a man in
distress calling for help, "it is you, Logie! . . . My God, let me

The beggar dragged himself nearer. The fragment of moon did no more
than turn the chinks and cracks of the barn to a dull grey, and he
could hardly see the outline of his companion.

The nightmares that were tormenting Archie pointed to something that
must have happened before he came by his hurt, and the injury and the
chill had produced these light-headed wanderings; there were troubles
boiling in his mind that he had kept behind his teeth so long as his
tongue was under control. Wattie wondered what was all this talk of
Lord Balnillo's brother. It seemed as if there were some secret
between this man, suspected, as he well knew, of being an active
rebel, and Flemington. Had it been light, Wattie would have tried to
get at the papers that Archie had spoken of as being on him when they
met, for these might give him some clue to the mystery. He sat in the
dark leaning against the wall of the barn, his arms tightly folded
across his great chest, his lips pursed, his gaze bent on the restless
figure that he could just distinguish.

All at once Archie sat up.

"Where are you?" he asked in a high, strained voice.

"A'm here," replied the beggar.

"Is it you, Logie?" exclaimed Flemington.

"It's mysel'."

Wattie smoothed the roughness out of his accent as best he could. The
other seemed to be hovering on the brink of consciousness. He sank

"It is not Logie," he said; "but you can tell him----"

Wattie leaned forward and laid his broad palm firmly and very gently
on his shoulder.

"What'll a' tell him?" said he.

Flemington turned towards him and groped about with his hot hand.

"Tell him from me that he can trust me," he said in a hoarse, earnest

The beggar's touch seemed to quiet him. He lay still, murmuring
indistinctly between snatches of silence. Once again he sat up,
groping about.

"You will not forget?" he said.

"Na, na," replied Wattie.

He pushed him gently back, patting him now and again as a nurse might
pat a restless child, and Archie grew calmer. The hand quieted him.
Rough, dirty, guileful, profane as he was, without scruple or
conscience or anything but the desire to do the best for himself,
Skirling Wattie had got, lodged in body or spirit, or in whatsoever
part of man the uncomprehended force dwells, that personal magnetism
which is independent alike of grace and of virtue, which can exist in
a soil that is barren of either. It may have been that which the
yellow cur, with the clear vision belonging to some animals,
recognized and adored; seeing not only the coarse and jovial reprobate
who was his master, but the shadow of the mysterious power that had
touched him.

The dog, awakened by Archie's cry, found that the beggar had moved,
and drew closer to his side. Flemington dozed off again, and Wattie
sat thinking; he longed to stir him up, that he might have the chance
of hearing more of his rambling talk. But he refrained, not from
humane feeling, but from the fear that the talker, if he were tampered
with, might be too ill to be moved on the morrow. Sleep was his best
chance, and Wattie had made up his mind that if it were possible to
move him, he would prevail on the boy to get a beast from the nearest
place that boasted anything which could carry him to Aberbrothock. He
knew that Flemington could pay for it, and he would direct him to a
small inn in that place whose landlord, besides being a retired
smuggler, was a distant kinsman of his own. The matter of a passage to
Leith could be arranged through the same source for a consideration.
Archie should take his chance by himself.

He realized with some bitterness the bright opportunities that can be
lost upon a being who has no legs to speak of; for he could easily
have relieved him of what money he carried had he been an able-bodied
man. It was not that he lacked the force for such deeds, but that
honesty was wantonly thrust upon him because his comings and goings
were so conspicuous. Notoriety takes heavy toll; and he had about the
same chance as the king of being conveniently mislaid. He would have
given a good deal for a sight of the papers that Archie carried, and
though the darkness interfered with him now, he promised himself that
he would see them if the morning light should find him still
delirious. He could not make out how ill he was; and in spite of his
curiosity, he was not prepared to befriend him with the chance of his
growing worse. To have him dying upon his hands would be a burden too
great to endure, even should it lead to no awkward questionings. He
would get rid of him to-morrow, whether his curiosity were satisfied
or not: he had heard enough to make him suspect very strongly that
Flemington was in the pay of the rebels as well as in that of the
King. It was a situation that he, personally, could very well
understand. But the night turned, and Archie grew more peaceful as the
hours went by. He had one or two bouts of talking, but they were
incoherent and fitful, and his mind appeared now to be straying among
different phantoms. There was no more about Logie, and Wattie could
only make out the word 'Ardguys,' which he knew as the name of a place
beyond Forfar; and as he had discovered in Brechin that Flemington
lived somewhere in those parts, he guessed that his thoughts were
roving about his home. His breathing grew less laboured, and the
watcher could hear at last that he slept. The moon dropped, and with
her going the crevices lost their greyness and the barn grew black.
The beggar, who was a healthy sleeper, laid himself down again, and in
the middle of his cogitations passed into oblivion.

When he awoke the place was light, and Archie was looking at him with
intelligent eyes; they were hollow, and there were dark shadows below
them, but they were the eyes of a man in full possession of his wits.

"We must get out of this place," he said. "I have been standing up,
but my knees seem so heavy I can hardly walk. My bones ache, Wattie; I
believe there is fever in me, but I must get on. Damn it, man, we are
a sorry pair to be cast on the world like this! I fear I took terrible
liberties with your whisky yesterday."

It was a still, misty morning when the beggar, having harnessed his
dogs, went out to look for the boy. When he was gone, Flemington
fumbled with his shaking fingers for the different packets that he
carried. All were there safely--his letters, his money. He trusted
nobody, and he did not like having to trust the beggar.

His feverish head and the ague in his bones told him that he could
scarcely hope to get to Aberbrothock on foot. His boots were still
wet, and a bruise on his hip that he had got in falling yesterday had
begun to make itself felt. He propped himself against the wall and
reached out for the water beside him.

Wattie had been some time away when the barn door opened and the
farm-woman appeared on the threshold, considering him with suspicious

He dragged himself to his feet and bowed as though he were standing
upon an Aubusson carpet instead of upon a pallet of withered heather.
The action seemed to confirm her distrust.

"Madam," said he, "I have to thank you for a night's shelter and for
this excellent refreshment. You are too good. I drink to you."

He raised the broken delf bowl with the drain of water that remained
in it. Being conscious of inhospitality, she was not sure how much
irony lay in his words, and his face told her nothing.

"It's the last ye'll get here," said she.

The more she looked at Flemington the more she was impressed by his
undesirability as a guest. She was one of those to whom anything
uncommon seemed a menace.

"Madam, I notice that you dislike me--why?"

"Wha are ye?" she inquired after a pause, during which he faced her,
smiling, his eyebrows raised.

"We are two noblemen, travelling for pleasure," said he.

She crossed her arms, snorting.

"Heuch!" she exclaimed contemptuously. "A' wish ma gudeman was hame.
He'd sort the pair o' ye!"

"If you think we have any design on your virtue," he continued, "I beg
you to dismiss the idea. I assure you, you are safe with us. We are
persons of the greatest delicacy, and my friend is a musician of the
first rank. I myself am what you see--your humble servant and

"Ye're a leear and a Frenchman!" cried she.

Her eyes blazed. A little more provocation, and she might have
attacked him. At this moment Wattie's cart drove into the yard behind
her, axle deep in the sea of mud and manure that filled the place. She
turned upon the new-comer. She could not deal with Archie, but the
beggar was a foe she could understand, and she advanced, a whirl of
abuse, upon him. The yellow dog's growling rose, battling with her
strident tones, and Archie, seeing the mischief his tongue had
wrought, limped out, fearful of what might happen.

"Stand awa' frae the doag, wumman! He'll hae the legs o' ye roogit aff
yer henches gin he get's a haud o' ye!" roared Wattie, as the yellow
body leaped and bounded in the traces.

Amid a hurricane of snarling and shouts he contrived, by plying his
stick, to turn the animals and to get them out of the yard.

Archie followed him, but before he did so he paused to turn to his
enemy, who had taken shelter in the doorway of the barn. He could not
take off his hat to her because he had no hat to take off, having lost
it on Inchbrayock Island, but he blew a kiss from the points of his
fingers with an air that almost made her choke. Wattie, looking back
over his shoulder, called angrily to him. He could not understand what
he had done to the woman to move her to such a tempest of wrath, but
he told himself that, in undertaking to escort Archie, he had made a
leap in the dark. He would direct him to his cousin's house of
entertainment in Aberbrothock, and return to his own haunts without

At the nearest point of road the boy was standing by a sorry-looking
nag that he held by the ear.

A few minutes later they had parted, and the boy, made happy by the
coin he had been given, was returning to the farm, while the beggar,
who had also reaped some profit in the last twenty-four hours, watched
his late companion disappearing down the road. When he was out of
sight he turned his own wheels in the direction of Brechin, and set
off at a sober pace for that friendly town. He was singing to himself
as he went, first because he owned the price of another bottle of
whisky; secondly, because he was delighted to be rid of Flemington;
and thirdly, because an inspiring idea had come to him.

His dogs, by the time they drew him into Brechin, would have done two
heavy days' work, and would deserve the comparative holiday he meant
to give them. He would spend to-morrow in the town with his pipes in
the company of that congenial circle always ready to spring from the
gutter on his appearance. Then, after a good night's rest, and when he
should have collected a trifle, he would go on to Forfar and learn for
certain whether Archie lived at Ardguys and who might be found there
in his absence.

His idea was to arrive at the house with the last tidings of the young
man; to give an account of the attack on the _Venture_, its surrender,
Flemington's injury, and his own part in befriending him. It took some
time, in those days of slow communication, for public news to travel
so much as across a county, but even should the tale of the ship have
reached Ardguys, the news of Archie could scarcely have preceded him.
He hoped to find someone--for preference an anxious mother, who would
be sensible of how much he had done for her son. There would be fresh
profit there.

And not only profit. There was something else for which the beggar
hoped, though profit was his main object. He pictured some tender,
emotional lady from whose unsuspicious heart he might draw scraps of
information that would fit into his own theories. He would try the
effect of Logie's name, and there would be no harm in taking a general
survey of Flemington's surroundings and picking up any small facts
about him that he could collect.

His own belief in Archie's double dealing grew stronger as he jogged
along; no doubt that shrewd and unaccountable young man was driving a
stiff trade. There was little question in his mind that the contents
of the letter he had put into his hands by the alder-clump had been
sold to Captain James Logie, and that its immediate result had been
the taking of the ship. He had learned from Archie's ravings that
there had been a question of money between himself and Logie. The part
that he could make nothing of was the suggestion, conveyed by Archie
in the night, that he and the judge's brother had been fighting. "Let
me go, Logie!" he had cried out in the darkness, and the blow on his
forehead, which was bleeding when he found him, proved recent

But though he could not explain these puzzles, nor make them tally
with his belief, his theory remained. Flemington was in league with
Logie. For the present he determined to keep his suspicions to



THREE days afterwards Wattie sat at the gates of Ardguys and looked
between the pale yellow ash-trees at the house. There was nobody about
at the moment to forbid his entrance, and he drove quietly in at a
foot's pace and approached the door. The sun shone with the clear
lightness of autumn, and the leaves, which had almost finished the
fitful process of falling, lay gathered in heaps by the gate, for
Madam Flemington liked order. On the steep pitch of the ancient slate
roof a few pigeons, white and grey, sat in pairs or walked about with
spasmodic dignity. The whole made a picture, high in tone, like a
water-colour, and the clean etched lines of the stripped branches gave
it a sharp delicacy and threw up the tall, light walls. All these
things were lost upon the beggar.

He had informed himself in Forfar. He knew that the place was owned
and lived in by a lady of the name of Flemington, who was the
grandmother of the young man from whom he had lately parted. He had
learned nothing of her character and politics because of the seclusion
in which she lived, and he stared about him on every side and scanned
the house for any small sign that might give him a clue to the tastes
or occupations of its inhabitant. Whilst he was so engaged the
front-door opened and the sound sent all the pigeons whirling from the
roof into the air in flashes of grey-blue and white. Madam Flemington
stood on the top step.

The beggar's hand went instinctively to his bonnet. He was a little
taken aback--why, he did not know--and he instantly abandoned his plan
of an emotional description of Archie's plight. She stood quite still,
looking down at him.

Her luxuriant silver hair was covered by a three-cornered piece of
black lace that was tied in a knot under her chin, and she wore the
'calash,' or hood, with which the ladies of those days protected their
headdresses when they went out. A short furred cloak was round her.

She considered Wattie with astonishment. Then she beckoned to him to

"Who and what are you?" she asked, laying her hand on the railing that
encircled the landing of the steps.

That question was so seldom put to him that it struck him unawares,
like a stone from behind a hedge. He hesitated.

"A've got news for yer leddyship," he began.

"I asked your name," said Madam Flemington.

"Wattie Caird," replied he. "Skirling Wattie, they ca' me."

The countryside and its inhabitants did not appeal to Christian, but
this amazing intruder was like no one she had ever seen before. She
guessed that he was a beggar, and she brushed aside his announcement
of news as merely a method of attracting attention.

"You are one of the few persons in these parts who can afford to keep
a coach," she remarked.

A broad smile overspread his ribald countenance, like the sun
irradiating a public-house.

"Dod, ma leddy, a'd think shame to visit ye on fut," said he, with a
wag of his head.

"You have better reasons than that," she replied rather grimly.

"Aye, aye, they're baith awa'," said he, looking at the place where
his legs should have been. "A'm an ill sicht for the soutars!"

She threw back her head and laughed a little.

She had seen no one for months, with the exception of Archie, who was
so quick in mind and speech, and the humour of this vagabond on wheels
took her fancy. There was no whining servility about him, in spite of
his obvious profession.

The horrified face of a maidservant appeared for one moment at a
window, then vanished, struck back by the unblessed sight of her
mistress, that paralyzing, unapproachable power, jesting, apparently,
with Skirling Wattie, the lowest of the low. The girl was a native of
Forfar, the westernmost point of the beggar's travels, and she had
often seen him in the streets.

"You face life boldly," said Madam Flemington.

"An' what for no? Fegs, greetin' fills naebody's kyte."*[*Stomach.]

She laughed again.

"You shall fill yours handsomely," said she; "go to the other door and
I will send orders to the women to attend to you."

"Aye, will I," he exclaimed, "but it wasna' just for a piece that a'
cam' a' the way frae the muir o' Rossie."

"From where?" said she.

"The muir o' Rossie," repeated he. "Ma leddy, it was awa' yonder at
the tail o' the muir that a' tell't Maister Flemington the road to

"Mr. Flemington?"

"Aye, yon lad Flemington--an' a deevil o' a lad he is to tak' the road
wi'! Ma leddy, there's been a pucklie fechtin' aboot Montrose, an' the
Prince's men hae gotten a haud o' King George's ship that's in by
Ferryden. As a' gaed doon to the toon, a' kaipit* [*Met.] wi'
Flemington i' the road. He'd gotten a clour on 's heed. He was
fechtin' doon aboot Inchbrayock, he tell't me."

"Fighting? With whom?" asked Madam Flemington, fixing her tiger's eyes
on him.

The beggar had watched her face narrowly while he spoke for the
slightest flicker of expression that might indicate the way her
feelings were turning.

"He was fechtin' wi' Captain Logie," he continued boldly, "a fell man
yon--ye'll ken him, yer leddyship?"

"By name," said Christian.

"A'm thinkin' it was frae him that he got the clour on 's heed. A'
gie'd him ma guid whisky bottle, an' a' got water to him frae a well.
A' ca'd him awa' frae the roadside--he didna ken wha would be aifter
him ye see--an' a' gar'd a clatterin' auld wife at the muir side gie's
a shelter yon nicht. A' didna' leave the callant, ma' leddy, till a'
got a shelt to him. He's to Edinburgh. A' tell't him wha 'd get him a
passage to Leith--a'm an Aberbrothock man, mysel', ye ken."

"And did he send you to me?"

"Aye, did he," said he, lying boldly.

There was no sign of emotion, none even of surprise, on her face. Her
heart had beaten hard as the beggar talked, and the weight of wrath
and pain that she had carried since she had parted with Archie began
to lighten. He had listened to her--he had not gone against her. How
deep her words had fallen into his heart she could not tell, but deep
enough to bring him to grips with the man who had made the rift
between them.

"Are you sure of what you say?" she asked quickly; "did you see them

"Na, na, but 'twas the lad himsel' that tell't me. He was on the

"He was on the ship?"

"Aye, was he. And he gae'd oot wi' the sodgers to deave they rebels
frae Inchbrayock. They got the ship, ma leddy, but they didna get him.
He escapit."

"Did you say he was much hurt?" said Madam Flemington.

"Hoots! ye needna' fash yersel', ma leddy! A' was feared for him i'
the nicht, but there wasna' muckle wrang wi' him when he gae'd awa',
or, dod, a' wouldna' hae left him!"

He had no mind to spoil his presentment of himself as Good Samaritan.

So far he had learnt nothing. He had spoken of the Prince's men as
rebels without a sign of displeasure showing on Madam Flemington's
face. Archie might be playing a double game and she might be doing the
same, but there was nothing to suggest it. She was magnificently
impersonal. She had not even shown the natural concern that he
expected with regard to her own flesh and blood.

"Go now," said she, waving her hand towards the back part of the
house; "you shall feed well, you and your dogs; and when you have
finished you can come to these steps again, and I will give you some
money. You have done well by me."

She re-entered the house and he drove away to the kitchen-door,

If Wattie hoped to discover anything more there about the lady and her
household, he was disappointed. The servants raised their chins in
refined disapproval of the vagrant upon whom their mistress had seen
fit to waste words under the very front windows of Ardguys. They
resolved that he should find the back-door, socially, a different
place, and only the awe in which they stood of Christian compelled
them to obey her to the letter. A crust or two would have interpreted
her wishes, had they dared to please themselves. But Madam Flemington
knew every resource of her larder and kitchen, for French housekeeping
and the frugality of her exiled years had taught her thrift. She would
measure precisely what had been given to her egregious guest, down to
the bones laid, by her order, before his dogs.

The beggar ate in silence, amid the brisk cracking made by five pairs
of busy jaws; the maids were in the stronghold of the kitchen, far
from the ungenteel sight of his coarse enjoyment. When he had
satisfied himself, he put the fragments into his leathern bag and went
round once more to the front of the house.

A window was open on the ground-floor, and Madam Flemington's large
white hand came over the sill holding a couple of crown pieces. She
was sitting on the window-seat within. Her cloak and the calash had
disappeared, and Wattie could see the fine poise of her head. She
dropped the coin into the cart as he drove below.

As he looked up he thought that if she had been imposing in her
outdoor garments she was a hundredfold more so without them. He was at
his ease with her, but he wondered at it, though he was accustomed to
being at his ease with everybody. A certain vanity rose in him, coarse
remnant of humanity as he was, before this magnificent woman, and when
he had received the silver, he turned about, facing her, and began to

He was used to the plebeian admiration of his own public, but a touch
of it from her would have a different flavour. He was vain of his
singing, and that vanity was the one piece of romance belonging to
him; it hung over his muddy soul as a weaving of honeysuckle may hang
over a dank pond. Had he understood Madam Flemington perfectly, he
might have sung 'The Tod,' but as he only understood her
superficially, he sang 'Logie Kirk.' He did not know how nearly the
extremities of the social scale can draw together in the primitive
humours of humanity. It is the ends of a line that can best be bent to
meet, not one end and the middle.

Yet, as 'Logie Kirk' rang out among the spectral ash-trees, she sat
still, astonished, her head erect, like some royal animal listening;
it moved her, though its sentiment had naught to do with her mood at
present, nor with her cast of mind at any time. But love and loss are
things that lay their shadows everywhere, and Madam Flemington had
lost much; moreover, she had been a woman framed for love, and she had
not wasted her gifts.

As his voice ceased, she rose and threw the window up higher.

"Go on," she said.

He paused, taking breath, for a couple of minutes. He knew songs to
suit all political creeds, but this time he would try one of the
Jacobite lays that were floating round the country; if it should
provoke some illuminating comment from her, he would have learned
something more about her, and incidentally about Archie, though it
struck him that he was not so sure of the unanimity of interest
between the grandmother and grandson which he had taken for granted
before seeing Madam Flemington.

His cunning eyes were rooted on her as he sang again.

    "My love stood at the loanin' side
        And held me by the hand,
     The bonniest lad that e'er did bide
        In a' this waefu' land;
     There's but ae bonnier to be seen
        Frae Pentland to the sea,
     And for his sake but yestereen
        I sent my love frae me.

    "I gie'd my love the white, white rose
        That's at my feyther's wa',
     It is the bonniest flower that grows
        Where ilka flower is braw;
     There's but ae brawer that I ken
        Frae Perth unto the main,
     And that's the flower o' Scotland's men
        That's fechtin' for his ain.

    "If I had kept whate'er was mine,
        As I had gie'd my best,
     My hairt were licht by day, and syne
        The nicht wad bring me rest;
     There is nae heavier hairt to find
        Frae Forfar toon to Ayr,
     As aye I sit me doon to mind
        On him I see nae mair.

    "Lad, gin ye fa' by Chairlie's side,
        To rid this land o' shame,
     There will na be a prouder bride
        Than her ye left at hame;
     But I will see ye whaur ye sleep
        Frae lowlands to the peat,
     And ilka nicht at mirk I'll creep
        To lay me at yer feet."

"You sing well," said Christian when he had stopped; "now go."

She inclined her head and turned from the window. As his broad back,
so grotesque in its strange nearness to the ground, passed out between
the gate-posts of Ardguys, she went over to the mantelpiece.

Her face was set, and she stood with clasped hands gazing into the
fireplace. She was deeply moved, but not by the song, which only
stirred her to bitterness, but by the searching tones of the beggar's
voice, that had smitten a way through which her feelings surged to and
from her heart. The thought that Archie had not utterly broken away
from her unnerved her by the very relief it brought. She had not known
till now how much she had suffered from what had passed between them.
Her power was not all gone. She was not quite alone. She would have
scorned to admit that she could not stand in complete isolation, and
she admitted nothing, even to herself. She only stood still, her
nerves quivering, making no outward sign.

Presently she rang a little hand-bell that was on the table.

The genteel-minded maid appeared.

"Mysie," said Madam Flemington, "in three days I shall go to



LORD BALNILLO looked out of his sedan chair as it emerged from the
darkness of a close on the northern slope of the Old Town of
Edinburgh. Far down in front of him, where the long alley stopped, a
light or two was seen reflected in the black water of the Nor' Loch
that lay between the ancient city and the ground on which the new one
was so soon to rise. The shuffling footfalls of his chairmen, echoing
off the sides of the covered entry, were drowned in the noise that was
going on a little way farther forward, where the close widened out
into a square courtyard. One side of this place was taken up by the
house of Lady Anne Maxwell, for which the judge was bound.

It had been raining, and Edinburgh was most noisomely dirty under
foot, so Balnillo's regard for his silk-clad legs and the buckled
shoes on his slim feet, had made him decide to be carried to his
kinswoman's party. He wore his favourite mouse colour, but the
waistcoat under his velvet coat was of primrose satin, and the lace
under his chin had cost him more than he liked to remember.

The courtyard sent up a glow of light into the atmosphere of the damp
evening, for the high houses towering round it rose black into the
sky, limiting the shine and concentrating it into one patch. From
above, it must have looked like a dimly illuminated well. It was full
of sedan chairs, footmen, lantern-carriers and caddies, and the
chattering, pushing, jesting, and oaths were keeping the inhabitants
of the neighbouring 'lands'--such of them as were awake, for Edinburgh
kept early hours in those days--from going to sleep.

The sedan chairs were set down at the door, for they could seldom be
carried into the low and narrow entrances of even the best town
houses, and here, at Lady Anne's, the staircase wound up inside a
circular tower projecting from the wall.

The caddies, or street-messengers of Edinburgh, that strange
brotherhood of useful, omniscient rascals, without whose services
nothing could prosper, ran in and out among the crowd in search of odd
jobs. Their eyes were everywhere, their ears heard everything, their
tongues carried news of every event. The caddies knew all that
happened in society, on the bench, in shops, in wynds, in churches,
and no traveller could be an hour in the town before they had made his
name and business common property. In an hour and a half his character
would have gone the same way. Their home by day was at the Market
Cross in the High Street, where they stood in gossiping groups until a
call let one of them loose upon somebody else's business. It was the
perpetual pursuit of other people's business that had made them what
they were.

A knot of caddies pressed round the door of Lady Anne Maxwell's house
as Lord Balnillo, sitting erect in order not to crease his clothes and
looking rather like an image carried in a procession, was kept at a
standstill whilst another guest was set down. Through the open window
of his chair there pressed a couple of inquisitive faces.

"Hey, lads!" cried a caddie, "it's Davie Balnillo back again!"

"Losh, it's himsel'! Aweel, ma lord, we're fine an' pleased to see ye!
Grange is awa' in ben the hoose. I'se warrant he doesna' ken wha's
ahint him!"

Balnillo nodded affably. The instant recognition pleased the old man,
for he had only reached Edinburgh in time to dress for his cousin's
party; also, Lord Grange was a friend of his, and he was glad to hear
that he was in front. As he looked complacently upon the crowd, his
chairmen suddenly stepped forward, almost throwing him out of his

A cry rose round him.

"Canny! Canny! ye Hieland deevils! Ye'll hae the pouthered wiggie o'
him swiggit aff his heed! Haud on, Davie; we'll no let ye cowp!"

Balnillo was rather annoyed, for he had been knocked smartly against
the window-frame, and a little cloud of powder had been shaken on his
velvet sleeve; but he knew that the one thing a man might not lose
before the caddies was his temper, if he did not want his rage, his
gestures, and all the humiliating details of his discomfiture to be
the town talk next day. He looked as bland as he could while he
resettled himself.

"It'll no be waur nor ridin' the circuit, ma lord?" inquired a voice.

A laugh went round the group, and the chair moved on and was set down
at its destination. Though the caddies' knowledge of the judge went as
far down as his foibles, the one thing that they did not happen to
know was the motive that had brought him to Edinburgh.

The doings in the harbour had disturbed Balnillo mightily; for, though
the success of Ferrier and James in taking the _Venture_ rejoiced him,
he was dismayed by what he had heard about Archie Flemington. His
brother had told him everything. When Captain Hall and his men had
been conveyed as prisoners to the town, and the ship had been taken
possession of by Prince Charles' agent in Montrose, Logie had gone
hastily to Balnillo to give the news to David, and to prepare for his
own departure to join the Stuart army. There was no longer any need
for secrecy on his part, and it had always been his intention to
declare himself openly as soon as he had done his work in Montrose.
The place was well protected, and, besides the town guns that he and
Ferrier had taken from Hall, there were the two armed vessels--both
now belonging to the Prince--lying in the harbour.

The arrival of the frigate with her supplies had turned Montrose from
a rebelliously-inclined town into a declared Jacobite stronghold. The
streets and taverns were full of Lord John Drummond's troops, the
citizens had given vent to their feelings upon the town bells,
bonfires blazed in the streets, and Prince Charlie's name was on every
lip; girls wore white roses on their breasts, and dreamed at night of
the fascinating young spark who had come to set Scotland alight. The
intense Jacobitism of Angus seemed to have culminated in the quiet

In all this outburst of loyalty and excitement the cautious Balnillo
did not know what to do. The risk of announcing his leanings publicly
was a greater one than he cared to take, for his stake in the country
and the land was considerable, and he was neither sanguine enough to
feel certain of the ultimate triumph of the Stuarts like the Montrose
people, nor generous enough to disregard all results like James. As he
told himself, after much deliberation, he was "best away."

He had heard from James of Archie's sudden appearance upon the island,
armed with a Government weapon and in company with the attacking force
from the ship, and had listened to James's grim denunciation of him as
a spy, his passionate regrets that he had not blown his brains out
there and then. James's bitterness had been so great that David told
himself he could scarcely recognize his quiet brother.

There was abundant reason for it, but Logie had seemed to be beside
himself. He had scarcely eaten or slept during the short time that he
had been with him, and his face had kept the judge's tongue still.
After his account of what had happened, Balnillo had not returned to
the subject again.

Step by step the judge had gone over all the circumstances of
Flemington's sudden emergence from the Den on that windy night, and
had seen how he had himself been cozened and flattered into the
business of the portrait which stood unfinished, in solitary and very
marked dignity, in the room with the north light. He was a man who
suspected some of his own weaknesses, though his knowledge did not
prevent him from giving way to them when he thought he could do so
safely, and he remembered the adroit bits of flattery that his guest
had strewn in his path, and how obligingly he had picked them up. He
was shrewd enough to see all that. He thought of the sudden departure
when Madam Flemington's mysterious illness had spirited Archie out of
the house at a moment's notice, and he saw how he had contrived to
imbue both himself and James with the idea that he shared their
political interests, without saying one definite word; he thought of
his sigh and the change in his voice as he spoke of his father's death
"in exile with his master."

These things stood up in a row before Balnillo, and ranged themselves
into a sinister whole. The plain truth of it was that he had
entertained a devil unawares.

There had been a great search for Flemington when the skirmish on
Inchbrayock was over. It was only ceasing when the French frigate swam
into the river-mouth like a huge water-bird, and James, plunged in the
struggle, was unable to spare a thought to the antagonist he had flung
from him at the first sound of the attack.

But when the firing had stopped, and the appearance of the foreign
ship made the issue of the conflict certain, he returned to the spot
where he had left Archie, and found him gone. He examined the sand for
some trace of the vanished man's feet, but the tide was now high in
the river, and his footprints had been swallowed by the incoming rush.
The stepping-stones were completely covered, and he knew that
these--great fragments of rock as they were--would now be lying under
enough water to drown a man who should miss his footing while the tide
surged through this narrow stretch of the Esk's bed. He guessed that
the spy had escaped by them, though a short time later the attempt
would have been impossible. He made a hasty search of the island, and,
finding no sign of Flemington, he returned with his men and the
prisoners they had taken, leaving the dead to be carried over later to
the town for burial. The boats were on the Montrose side of
Inchbrayock, and, their progress being hampered by the wounded, some
time was lost before he could spare a handful of followers to begin
the search for Flemington. He picked up a few volunteers upon the
quays, and despatched them immediately to cross the strait and to
search the southern shores of both the river and the Basin; but they
had barely started when Flemington and the beggar were nearing the
little farm on Rossie moor. Archie had spent so little time on the
open road, thanks to his companion's advice, that none of those whom
the pursuers met and questioned had seen him. Before dusk came on,
their zeal had flagged; and though one, quicker-witted than his
comrades, had suggested the moor as a likely goal for their quarry, he
had been overborne by their determination that the fugitive, a man who
had been described to them as coming from the other side of the
county, would make in that direction.

When James had gone to join the Stuart army on its march to England,
his brother, waiting until the Prince had left Holyrood, set forth for
Edinburgh. It would have been difficult for him to remain at home
within sound of the noisy rejoicings of Montrose without either
joining in the general exultation or holding himself conspicuously
aloof. Prudence and convenience pointed to the taking of a little
holiday, and his own inclination did not gainsay them.

He had not been in Edinburgh since his retirement, and the notion of
going there, once formed, grew more and more to his taste. A hundred
things in his old haunts drew him: gossip, the liberal tables of his
former colleagues, the latest modes in coats and cravats, the musical
assemblies at which he had himself performed upon the flute, the
scandals and anecdotes of the Parliament House and the society of
elegant women. He loved all these, though his trees and parks had
taken their places of late. He loved James too, and the year they had
spent together had been agreeable to him; but politics and family
affection--the latter of the general rather than the individual
kind--strong as their bonds were, could not bring the brothers into
true touch with each other. James was preoccupied, silent, restless,
and David had sometimes felt him to be inhuman in his lack of interest
in small things, and in his carelessness of all but the great events
of life. And now, as Balnillo stepped forth at Lady Anne Maxwell's
door, he was hugging himself at the prospect of his return to the
trimmings and embroideries of existence. He walked up the circular
staircase, and emerged into the candle-light of the long, low room in
which his cousin's guests were assembled.

Lady Anne was a youngish widow, with a good fortune and a devouring
passion for cards. She had all the means of indulging her taste, for
not only did she know every living being who went to the making of
Edinburgh society, but, unlike most of her neighbours, she owned the
whole of the house in which she lived, and, consequently, had space
wherein to entertain them. While nearly all the Edinburgh world dwelt
in its flat, and while many greater ladies than herself were contented
to receive their guests in their bedchambers, and to dance and drink
tea in rooms not much bigger than the boudoirs of their descendants,
Lady Anne could have received Prince Charles Edward himself in
suitable circumstances had she been so minded. But she was very far
from having any such aspiration, and had not set foot in Holyrood
while the Prince was there, for she was a staunch Whig. As she greeted
her cousin Balnillo, she was wondering how far certain rumours that
she had heard about him were true, and whether he also had been privy
to the taking of the sloop-of-war in Montrose harbour, for it was just
a week since the news of Logie's exploit had reached Edinburgh. One of
David's many reasons for coming to her party was his desire to make
his reappearance in the polite world in a markedly Whig house.

He stood talking to Lord Grange in the oak-panelled room half full of
people; through an open door another smaller apartment could be seen
crowded with tables and card-players. Lady Anne, all of whose guests
were arrived, had vanished into it, and the two judges stood side by
side. Lord Grange, who valued his reputation for sanctity above
rubies, did not play cards--at least, not openly--and Balnillo,
discovering new faces, as those must who have been over a year absent
from any community, was glad to have him at his elbow to answer
questions. Silks rustled, fans clicked, and the medley of noises in
the court below came up, though the windows were shut.

The candles, dim enough to our modern standards of lighting, shone
against the darkness of polished wood, and laughter and talk were
escaping, like running water out of a thicket, from a knot of people
gathered round a small, plump, aquiline-nosed woman. The group was at
the end of the room, and now and again an individual would detach
himself from it, to return, drawn by some jest that reached him ere he
had crossed the floor.

"Mrs. Cockburn's wit has not rusted this twelvemonth," observed Lord

"I marvel she has any left after nine years of housekeeping with her
straitlaced father-in-law," replied Balnillo in a preoccupied voice.

His eyes were elsewhere.

"Ah!" said Grange, pulling a righteous face.

The group round Mrs. Cockburn opened, and she caught sight of him for
the first time. She bowed and smiled civilly, showing her rather
prominent teeth, then, noticing Balnillo, she came over to the two
men. Her friends stepped apart to let her pass, watching her go with
that touch of proprietary pride which a small intimate society feels
in its more original members. It was evident that her least acts were
deemed worthy of observation.

As she greeted David, he turned round with a low bow.

"My lord, I thought you were buried!" she exclaimed.

"Dead and buried," droned Grange, for the sake of saying something.

"Not dead," exclaimed she, "else I had been in mourning!"

Balnillo bowed again, bringing his attention back with a jerk from the
direction in which it had been fixed.

"Come, my lord, what have you been doing all this long time?"

"I have been endeavouring to improve my estate, ma'am."

"And meanwhile you have left us to deteriorate. For shame, sir!"

"Edinburgh morals are safe in Lord Grange's hands," rejoined Balnillo,
with a sudden flash of slyness.

Mrs. Cockburn smiled behind her fan. There were odd stories afloat
about Grange. She looked appreciatively at Balnillo. He had not
changed, in spite of his country life; he was as dapper, as
ineffective, and as unexpected as ever. She preferred him infinitely
to Grange.

"Fie, Davie!" broke in the latter, with a leer; "you are an ungallant
dog! Here is Mrs. Cockburn wasting her words on you, and you do
nothing but ogle the lady yonder by the window."

Three pairs of eyes--the bright ones of Mrs. Cockburn, the rather
furtive ones of Balnillo, and the sanctimonious orbs of Lord
Grange--turned in one direction.

"Mrs. Cockburn is all knowledge, as she is all goodness," observed the
last named, pompously. "Pray, ma'am, tell us who is that lady?"



A SCONCE of candles beside a window-recess shed a collective
illumination from the wall, and Christian Flemington stood full in
their light, contemplating the company with superb detachment, and
pervaded by that air, which never left her, of facing the world,
unaided and unabashed, with such advantages as God had given her. Her
neck, still white and firm, was bare, for she wore no jewels but the
ruby earrings which shot blood-red sparks around her when she moved.
Long necks were in fashion in those days, and hers was rather short,
but the carriage of her head added enough to its length to do more
than equalize the difference. Her hair was like massed silver, and her
flesh--of which a good deal could be seen--rose like ivory above the
wine-colour of her silk gown, which flowed in spreading folds from her
waist to the ground. A Spanish fan with carved tortoiseshell sticks, a
thing of mellow browns and golds, was half closed between her fingers.
When she opened it, it displayed the picture of a bull-fight.

"That is Mrs. Flemington--Madam Flemington, as I am told many people
call her--I presume, because she came to Scotland from France. You
should know her, my lord," she added, addressing Balnillo; "you are
from Angus."

But Balnillo was speechless.

Grange, who was transferring a pinch of snuff from his box to his
nose, paused, his hand midway way between the two.

"Is she the widow of Andrew Flemington, who was in France with King

"The same," replied Mrs. Cockburn, tossing her head.

She had small sympathy with the Stuarts.

"I had not expected to see the lady here. Not that I know aught about
her views. We have a bare acquaintance, and she is like yourself, Lord
Balnillo--just arrived in Edinburgh when our young hero has left

"She has been a fine woman," said Lord Grange, his eye kindling.

"You may use the present tense, my lord," said Mrs. Cockburn.

"Aha!" sniggered Grange, who adhered to the time-honoured beliefs of
his sex, "you dare to show yourself generous!"

"I dare to show myself what I am, and that is more than all the world
can do," said she, looking at him very hard.

He shifted from foot to foot. At this moment the gallows, to which he
had condemned a few people in his time, struck him as a personal

"Ma'am," said he, swallowing his rage, "you must present Davie, or he
will lose what senses he has."

"Come, then, my lord, I will befriend you," said she, glad of the
chance to be rid of Grange.

Balnillo followed her, unable to escape had he wished to do so.

Christian was a woman who stood very still. She turned her head
without turning her body as Mrs. Cockburn approached with her request,
and Balnillo saw her calm acquiescence.

His breath had been almost taken away as he learned the identity of
the stranger. Here was the woman who knew everything about that
astounding young man, his late guest, whose alarming illness had
recalled him, who had lived at St. Germain with the exiled queen, yet
who was the grandmother of a most audacious Whig spy! There was no
trace of recent ill-health here. He had pictured some faint, feeble
shred of old womanhood, not the commanding creature whose grey eyes
were considering him as he advanced under cover of her leisurely
consent. She seemed to measure him carelessly as he stood before her.
He was torn asunder in mind, awestruck, dragged this way by his
surprised admiration, that way by his intense desire to wring from her
something about Flemington. Here was a chance, indeed! But Balnillo
felt his courage drown in the rising fear of being unable to profit by
that chance. Admiring bewilderment overcame every other feeling. He no
longer regretted the price he had paid for the lace on his cravat.

His name had roused Madam Flemington, though she gave no sign of the
thrill that went through her as it fell from Mrs. Cockburn's lips. As
David stood before her in the correct yet sober foppery of his
primrose and mouse-colour, she regretted that she was quite ignorant
of the pretext on which Archie had left his picture unfinished, nor
upon what terms he had parted with the judge. She had no reason for
supposing Balnillo to be aware of the young man's real character. He
had been fighting with James Logie, according to Skirling Wattie, yet
there seemed to be no enmity in the business, for here was his
brother, Lord Balnillo, assiduous in getting himself presented to her.
Mrs. Cockburn had put her request with a smiling hint at the effect
she had produced on his lordship. Christian glanced at David's
meticulous person and smiled, arrogantly civil, secretly anxious, and
remained silent, ready to follow his lead with caution.

The shrewd side of Balnillo was uppermost to-night, stimulated perhaps
by the sight of society and by the exhilarating sound of its voice. He
recovered his momentarily scattered wits and determined to approach
his new acquaintance with such direct and simple questions as might
seem to her to be the natural inquiries of a man interested in
Flemington, and innocent of any mystery concerning him. It was quite
possible--so he reasoned--that she was unaware of the details of what
had happened on Inchbrayock Island. Archie had fled, and the search
for him had produced no result; he was unlikely to have made for his
own home if he did not wish to be found, and he and Madam Flemington
might not have met since the affair of the _Venture_. It should be
his--Balnillo's--task to convince her of his ignorance.

His intense curiosity about Archie was almost stronger than his wrath
against him. Unlike James, whose bitterness was too deep for words,
whose soul was driven before the fury of his own feelings like a
restless ghost, David still looked back with a certain pleasant
excitement to Flemington's meteoric flash through the even atmosphere
of his daily life. He would dearly have liked to bring him to justice,
but he was anxious to hear a little more of him first.

He had a curious mixture of feelings about him. There was no vainer
man in Scotland than Balnillo, and if the mental half of his vanity
had suffered from the deception practised on it, the physical half was
yet preening itself in the sunny remembrance of the portrait at
home--the portrait of David Balnillo as he would fain have had the
world see him--the portrait, alas and alas! unfinished. He could not
feel quite as James felt, who had opened his purse, and, more--far
more than that--had laid open the most sacred page of his life before
Flemington. He had placed his personal safety in his hands, too,
though he counted that as a matter of less moment.

"Madam," said Balnillo, "to see you is to rejoice that you have
recovered from your serious illness."

"You are very obliging, my lord. I am quite well," replied Christian,
concealing a slight surprise at this remark.

"I am most happy in being presented to you," he continued. "What news
have you of my charming friend Mr. Flemington, may I ask?"

"When I heard your name, my lord, I determined to be acquainted with
you, if only to thank you for your kindness to my boy. He could not
say enough of yourself and your brother. I hope Captain Logie is well.
Is he with you this evening?"

The mention of James acted on David as he had designed that the
mention of Archie should act on Madam Flemington. These two people who
were playing at innocence were using the names of their relations to
scare the enemy as savage tribes use the terrific faces painted on
their shields. Balnillo, in beginning the attack, had forgotten his
own weak point, and he remembered that he could give no satisfactory
account of his brother at the present moment. But his cunning was
always at hand.

"I had half expected to see him here," said he, peering round the
room; "there was some talk of his coming. I arrived somewhat late, and
I have hardly spoken to anyone but my Lord Grange and Mrs. Cockburn.
The sight of yourself, ma'am, put other matters out of my head."

"Ah, sir," exclaimed Christian, "I fear that your ardour was all on
behalf of Archie! But I am accustomed to that."

She cast a look of indolent raillery at him, drawing back her head and
veiling her eyes, fiery and seductive still, with the momentary sweep
of their thick lashes.

Balnillo threw out his chest like a pouter pigeon. He had not been so
happy for a long time. As he did so, she remembered Archie's account
of his silk legs, and his description of him as being "silly,
virtuous, and cunning all at once." Silly she could well believe him
to be; virtuous he might be; whether he was cunning or not, time would
show her. She did not mean to let him go until she had at least
attempted to hear more about James Logie.

"Madam," said he, "since seeing you I have forgotten Mr. Flemington.
Can I say more?"

So far she was completely puzzled as to how much he knew about Archie,
but it was beginning to enter her mind that her own illness, of which
she had just learned from him, had been the young man's pretext for
leaving his work when it was only begun. Why else had the judge
mentioned it? And who but Flemington could have put the idea into his

She determined to make a bold attack on possibilities.

"Archie was distracted by my illness, poor boy, and I fear that your
lordship's portrait suffered. But you will understand his anxiety when
I tell you that I am the only living relation that he has, and that
his devotion to me----"

"He needs no excuse!" cried David fervently.

She laid her hand upon his arm.

"I am still hardly myself," she said. "I cannot stand long. Fetch me a
chair, my lord."

He skipped across the floor and laid hold upon one just in time, for a
gentleman was on the point of claiming it. He carried it back with the
air of a conqueror.

"Apart--by the curtain, if you please," said Christian, waving her
hand. "We can speak more comfortably on the fringe of this rout of
chattering people."

He set the chair down in a quiet place by the wall, and she settled
herself upon it, leaning back, her shoulder turned from the company.
Balnillo's delight deepened.

"And the portrait, my lord. He did not tell me what arrangement had
been made for finishing it," said Christian, looking up at him as he
stood beside her.

She seemed to be completely unconcerned, and she spoke with a
leisurely dignity and ease that turned his ideas upside down. He could
make nothing of it. She appeared to court the subject of Archie and
the picture. He could only guess her to be innocent, and his warm
admiration helped his belief. At no moment since he knew the truth
from his brother's lips had Archie's character seemed so black as it
did now. David's indignation waxed as he grew more certain that
Flemington had deceived the noble woman to whom he owed so much, even
as he had deceived him. He was becoming so sure of it that he had no
desire to enlighten her. He longed to ask plainly where Archie was,
but he hesitated. Even the all-wise Mrs. Cockburn was ignorant of this
lady's political sympathies, and knew her only as the widow of a loyal
exile. What might--what would be her feelings if she were to see her
grandson in his real character?

Righteous anger smouldered under Balnillo's primrose waistcoat, and
his spasmodic shrewdness began to doze in the increasing warmth of his
chivalrous pity for this new and interesting victim of the engaging

"Mr. Flemington's concern was so great when he left my house that no
arrangement was made," said he. "I had not the heart to trouble him
with my unimportant affairs when so much was at stake."

Of the two cautious people who were feeling their way in the dark, it
was the judge who was the more mystified, for he had laid hold of a
definite idea, and it was the wrong one. Christian was merely putting
a bold face on a hazardous matter, and hoping to hear something of
Logie. She had not sought the introduction. David would have been the
butt of her amused scorn had she been free enough from anxiety to be
entertained. But she could not imagine on what footing matters really
stood, and she was becoming inclined to suspect the beggar's statement
that Flemington had been fighting with James. Her longing to see
Archie was great.

She loved him in her own way, though she had driven him from her in
her mortification and her furious pride. She had not believed that he
would really go there and then; that he, who had served her purposes
so gallantly all his life, would take her at her word. What was he
doing? Why had he gone to Edinburgh? Her own reason for coming had
been the hope of seeing him. She had been four days in the town now,
and she dared not make open inquiries for him, not knowing how far his
defection had gone. She had accused him of turning to the Stuarts, and
he had denied the accusation, not angrily, but with quiet firmness.
Two horrible possibilities had occurred to her: one, that he was with
the Prince, and might be already known to the Government as a rebel;
the other, that he had never reached Edinburgh--that his hurt had been
worse than the beggar supposed, and that he might be ill or dying,
perhaps dead. But it was only when she lay awake at night that she
imagined these things. In saner moments and by daylight she put them
from her. She was so well accustomed to being parted from him, and to
the knowledge that he was on risky business, that she would not allow
herself to be really disturbed. She assured herself that she must wait
and watch; and now she was glad to find herself acquainted with
Balnillo, who seemed to be the only clue in her hand. Mercifully, he
had all the appearance of being an old fool.

"I see that you are too modest to tell me anything of the picture,"
she began. "I hope it promised well. You should make a fine portrait,
and I believe that Archie could do you justice. He is at his best with
high types. Describe it to me."

David espied a vacant chair, and, drawing it towards him, sat down to
the subject with the same gusto that most men bring to their dinners.
He cleared his throat.

"I should have wished it to be full length," said he, "but Mr.
Flemington had no suitable canvas with him. I wore my robes, and he
was good enough to say that the crimson was appropriate and becoming
to me. Personally, I favour quiet colours, as you see, ma'am."

"I see that you have excellent taste."

He bowed, delighted.

"I remarked you as you came in," continued she, "and I asked myself
why these gentlemen looked so garish. Observe that one beside the door
of the card-room, my lord. I am sure that he chose his finery with
some care, yet he reminds me of a clown at a merrymaking."

"True, true--excellently true!"

"In my youth it was the man of the world who set the fashions; now it
is the tailor and the young sir fresh from his studies. What should
these persons know of the subject?"

Balnillo was in heaven; from force of habit he ran his hand down the
leg crossed upon his knee. The familiar inward curve of the slim silk
ankle between his fingers was like the touch of a tried and creditable
friend; it might almost be said that he turned to it for sympathy. He
would have liked to tell his ankle that to-night he had found a
perfection almost as great as its own.

Lord Grange, who had taken leave of his hostess and was departing,
paused to look at him.

"See," said he, taking an acquaintance by the elbow, "look yonder at
that doited Davie Balnillo."

"He is telling her about his riding of the circuit," said the other,

"The circuit never made him smile like that," replied Grange

An hour later Christian Flemington stood at the top of the circular
staircase. Below it, Balnillo was at the entrance-door, sending
everyone within reach of his voice in search of her sedan chair. When
it was discovered, he escorted her down and handed her into it, then,
according to the custom of the time, he prepared to attend its
progress to her lodgings in Hyndford's Close. The streets were even
dirtier and damper than before, but he was as anxious to walk from
Lady Anne's party as he had been determined to be carried to it. He
stepped along at the side of the chair, turning, when they passed a
light, to see the dignified silhouette of Madam Flemington's head as
it appeared in shadow against the farther window.

Speech was impossible as they went, for avoidance of the kennel and
the worse obstacles that strewed the city at that hour, before the
scavengers had gone their rounds, kept David busy. The only profit
that a man got by seeing his admired one home in Edinburgh in 1745 was
the honour and glory of it.

When she emerged from the chair in Hyndford's Close he insisted upon
mounting the staircase with her, though its narrowness compelled them
to go in single file; and when they stopped halfway up at the door in
the towering 'land,' he bade her good-night and descended again,
consoled for the parting by her permission that he should wait upon
her on the following day.

Christian was admitted and sailed into her little room. A light was in
it and Archie was standing at the foot of the bed.

Surprises had been rolling up round Madam Flemington all the evening;
surprise at meeting Balnillo, surprise at his attitude; and this
crowning surprise of all. She was bewildered, but the blessing of
unexpected relief fell on her. She went towards him, her hands
outstretched, and Flemington, who was looking at her with a
wistfulness she had never seen in him before, took them and held them

"Oh, Archie!" she exclaimed.

She could say no more.

They sat down at the wide hearth together, the shadow of the great
carved bed sprawling over the crowded space between the walls and over
Christian's swelling silks. Then he told her the history of the time
since they parted in Ardguys garden; of his boarding of the _Venture_;
of the fight with the rebels at Inchbrayock; of his meeting with
Wattie; of how he had reached Aberbrothock half dead, and had lain
sick for two days in an obscure tavern by the shore; how he had
finally sailed for Leith and had reached Edinburgh.

Christian heard him, her gaze fixed upon the fire. She had elicited
nothing about James Logie from Balnillo, and there was no word of him
in Archie's story. She longed to speak of him, but would not; she
longed to know if the beggar had told the truth in saying that the two
men had actually fought, but she asked nothing, for she knew that her
wisest part was to accept the essentials, considering them as the
whole. She would ask no questions.

Archie had come back. She had forbidden Ardguys to him and he had
evaded her ban by coming here. Yet he came, having proved himself
loyal, and she would ignore the rest.




APRIL is slow in Scotland, distrustful of her own identity, timid of
her own powers. Half dazed from the long winter sleep, she is often
bewildered, and cannot remember whether she belongs to winter or to

After the struggles and perplexities of the months that had elapsed
since Balnillo and Christian Flemington met in Edinburgh, she had come
slowly to herself amid storms of sleet. Beyond the Grampians, in the
North, her awakened eyes looked on a country whose heart had been
broken at Culloden. The ragged company that gathered round its Prince
on that Wednesday morning was dispersed among the fastnesses of the
hills, or lying dead and dying among the rushes and heather, whilst
Cumberland's soldiers finished their bloody business; the April snow
that had blown in the faces of the clansmen as they hurled their
unavailing valour on the Whig army had melted upon mounds of slain,
and in the struggle of an hour the hopes of half a century had
perished. Superior numbers, superior artillery, and superior
generalship, had done their work; when the English dragoons had
recovered themselves after the Highland charge, they pursued almost to
the gates of Inverness, returning again to the battlefield before
night should darken upon the carnage, to despatch the wounded wretches
who still breathed among their dead comrades.

The country smelt of blood; reeked of it. For miles and miles round
Inverness, where the search for fugitives was hottest, burnt hovels
and blackened walls made blots upon the tardy green of spring. Women
went about, white-faced and silent, trying to keep from their eyes the
self-betraying consciousness of hidden terrors; each striving to
forget the peat-stack on the moor where some hunted creature was
lying, the scrub in the hollow that sheltered some wounded body, the
cranny in the hill to which she must journey painfully after dark with
the crusts in her apron.

The shot still rattled out over the countryside where the search was
going on, and where, when it had been successful, a few maimed and
haggard men stood along some shieling wall in front of a platoon of
Cumberland's musketry. All down the shores of Loch Ness and among the
hills above the Nairn water south-west of Culloden, the dark rocks
raised their broken heads to the sky over God knows what agonies of
suffering and hunger. The carrion-crow was busy in the land. One-fifth
of Prince Charles's army was dead upon the battle-field, and the
church and tolbooth of Inverness were full of wounded prisoners, to
whom none--not even the surgeons of their own party--were suffered to

And so April passed, and May was near her passing. Cumberland lay at
Fort Augustus, to which place he had retired with Kingston's Horse and
eleven battalions of foot. The victorious army was the richer by much
spoil, and money was free; the Duke's camp was merry with festivities
and races, and in the midst of it he enjoyed a well-earned leisure,
enlivened by women and dice. He had performed his task of stamping out
the danger that threatened his family with admirable thoroughness, and
he had, besides, the comfortable prospect of a glorious return to
London, where he would be the hero of the general rejoicing that was
to follow. He was rooted at Fort Augustus, a rock of success and
convivial self-satisfaction in the flood of tears and anguish and
broken aspiration that had drowned half Scotland.

The Prince had begun his wanderings in the West, hiding among the
hills and corries of the islands, followed by a few faithful souls,
and with a price of thirty thousand pounds on his head, whilst
Cumberland's emissaries, chief among whom was John Campbell of Mamore,
Commandant of the West Highland garrisons, searched the country in
every direction. The rank and file of his army--such of his men as
were not dead or in prison--were scattered to the four winds; and
those officers who had escaped after Culloden were in hiding, too,
some despairing, some holding yet to the forlorn hope of raising his
standard anew when the evil day should be over. Among these last was
James Logie.

He had come unhurt through the battle. Complete indifference about
personal issues had wrapped him round in a protecting atmosphere, as
it seems to enwrap and protect the unconcerned among men. He had left
the field in company with the Prince and a few friends, with whom he
reached the Ford of Falie on the Nairn River. They had held a rapid
council at this place, Prince Charles desiring that the remnant of his
army should rendezvous at Ruthven, in Badenoch, whilst he made his way
to France; for his hopes were living still, and he still looked for
support and supplies from the French king. He had taken leave of his
companions at the ford, and had set off with half a dozen followers
for the coast.

Logie turned his face towards Angus. He had been a conspicuous figure
in the Prince's immediate circle, and he knew that he had no time to
lose if he was to cross the Grampians alive. He thirsted to get back,
and to test the temper of the east coast after the news of the
reverse; like his master, he was not beaten yet. He did not know what
had become of Ferrier and the Angus men, for he had been on the
Prince's staff; but the friends had met on the night before the
battle, and it was a compact between them, that, should the day go
against them, and should either or both survive the fight, they were
to make for the neighbourhood of Forfar, where they would be ready, in
case of necessity, to begin on their task of raising new levies for
the cause.

He had reached the Spey, and had gained Deeside in safety by the
shores of the Avon, crossing the Grampians near the sources of the

In the long winter that had passed since he joined the Prince in the
field, James had not forgotten Flemington. His own labours in Angus
and at the taking of the _Venture_, completely as they had filled his
mind in the autumn, had sunk back into the limbo of insignificant
things, but Archie was often in his thoughts, and some time before the
advance on Inverness he had heard with indescribable feelings that he
was intelligence officer to the Duke of Cumberland. The terrible thing
to Logie was that Archie's treachery seemed to have poisoned the
sacred places in his own past; when he turned back to it now, it was
as though the figure of the young man stood blocking his view, looking
at him with those eyes that were so like the eyes of Diane, and were
yet the eyes of a traitor.

He could not bear to think of that October morning by the Basin of
Montrose. Perhaps the story that a fatal impulse had made him lay bare
to his companion had been tossed about--a subject of ridicule on
Flemington's lips, its telling but one more proof to him of the folly
of men. He could scarcely believe that Archie would treat the record
of his anguish in such a way; but then, neither could he have believed
that the sympathy in Archie's face, the break in his voice, the
tension of his listening attitude, were only the stock-in-trade of a
practised spy. And yet this horror had been true. In spite of the
unhealed wound that he carried, in spite of the batterings of his
thirty-eight years, Logie had continued to love life, but now he had
begun to tell himself that he was sick of it.

And for another very practical reason his generous impulses and his
belief in Flemington had undone him. Perhaps if the young painter had
come to Balnillo announcing an ostentatious adherence to the Stuarts,
he might have hesitated before taking him at his own value; but his
apparent caution and his unwillingness to speak, and the words about
his father at St. Germain, which he had let fall with all the quiet
dignity of a man too upright to pass under false colours, had done
more to put the brothers on the wrong track than the most violent
protestations. Balnillo had been careful, in spite of his confidence
in his guest; but in the sympathy of his soul James had given
Flemington the means of future access to himself. Now the tavern in
the Castle Wynd at Stirling could be of use to him no longer, and he
knew that only the last extremity must find him in any of the secret
haunts known to him in the Muir of Pert.

Madam Flemington had never reopened the subject of James Logie with
Archie. In her wisdom she had left well alone. Installed in her little
lodging in Hyndford's Close, with her woman Mysie, she had made up her
mind to remain where she was. There was much to keep her in Edinburgh,
and she could not bring herself to leave the centre of information and
to bury herself again in the old white house among the ash-trees,
whilst every post and every horseman brought word of some new turn in
the country's fortunes.

News of the Highland army's retreat to Scotland, of the Battle of
Falkirk, of the despatch of the Duke of Cumberland to the North,
followed one another as the year went by, and still she stayed on.
With her emergence from the seclusion of the country came her
emergence from the seclusion she had made for herself; and on the
Duke's thirty hours' occupation of Holyrood, she threw off all
pretence of neutrality, and repaired with other Whig ladies to the
palace to pay her respects to the stout, ill-mannered young General
whose unbeguiling person followed so awkwardly upon the attractive
figure of his predecessor.

Now that Archie was restored to her, Christian found herself with
plenty of occupation. The contempt she had hitherto professed for
Edinburgh society seemed to have melted away, and every card-party,
every assembly and rout, knew her chair at its door, her arresting
presence in its midst. Madam Flemington's name was on a good many
tongues that winter. Many feared her, some maligned her, but no one
overlooked her. The fact that she was the widow of an exiled Jacobite
lent her an additional interest; and as the polite world set itself to
invent a motley choice of reasons for her adherence to the House of
Hanover--which it discovered before her reception by the Duke at
Holyrood made it public--it ended by stumbling on the old story of a
bygone liaison with Prince Charles's father. The idea was so much to
its taste that it was generally accepted; and Christian, unknown to
herself, became the cast-off and alienated mistress of that Prince
whom her party had begun to call 'The Old Pretender.' It was scarcely
a legend that would have conciliated her had it come to her ears, but,
as rumour is seldom on speaking terms with its victims, she was
ignorant of the interested whispers which followed her through the
wynds and up the staircases of the Old Town.

But the reflected halo of royalty, while it casts deep shadows,
reaches far. The character of royal light of love stood her in good
stead, even among those to whom her supposed former lover was an
abhorred spectre of Popery and political danger. The path that her own
personality would surely open for her in any community was illumined
and made smooth by the baleful interest that hangs about all kingly
irregularities, and there was that in her bearing which made people
think more of the royal and less of the irregular part of the
business. Also, among the Whigs, she was a brand plucked from the
burning, one who had turned from the wrong party to embrace the right.
Edinburgh, Whig at heart, in spite of its backslidings, admired Madam

And not only Edinburgh, but that curious fraction of it, David

The impression that Christian had made upon the judge had deepened as
the weeks went by. By the time he discovered her true principles, and
realized that she was no dupe of Archie's, but his partisan, he had
advanced so far in his acquaintance with her, had become so much her
servant, that he could not bring himself to draw back. She had dazzled
his wits and played on his vanity, and that vanity was not only warmed
and cosseted by her manner to him, not only was he delighted with
herself and her notice, but he had begun to find in his position of
favoured cavalier to one of the most prominent figures in society a
distinction that it would go hard with him to miss.

He had begun their conversation at Lady Anne Maxwell's party by the
mention of Archie Flemington, but his name had not come up between
them again, and when his enlightenment about her was complete, and the
talk which he heard in every house that he frequented revealed her in
her real colours, he had no further wish to discuss the man into whose
trap he had fallen.

David Balnillo's discoveries were extremely unpalatable to him. If
Christian had cherished his vanity, she had made it smart, too. No
man, least of all one like the self-appreciative judge, can find
without resentment that he has been, even indirectly, the dupe of a
person to whom he has attached himself; but when that person is a
woman, determined not to let him escape from her influence, the case
is not always desperate. For three unblessed days it was wellnigh
desperate with Balnillo, and he avoided her completely, but at the end
of that time a summons from her was brought to him that his
inclination for her company and the chance sight of Lord Grange
holding open the door of her chair forbade him to disobey. She had
worded her command as though she were conferring a favour;
nevertheless, after an hour's hesitation, David had taken his hat and
repaired to Hyndford's Close, dragging his dignity after him like a
dog on a leash.

If she guessed the reason of his absence from her side she made no
remark, receiving him as if she had just parted from him, with that
omission of greeting which implies so much. She had sent for him, she
said, because her man of business had given her a legal paper that she
would not sign without his advice. She looked him in the face as
fearlessly as ever, and her glance sparkled with its wonted fire. For
some tormented minutes he could not decide whether or no to charge her
with knowledge of the fraud that had been carried on under his roof,
but he had not the courage to do so. Also, he was acute enough to see
that she might well reply to his reproaches by reminding him that he
had only himself to thank for their acquaintance. She had not made the
advances; his own zeal had brought about their situation. He felt like
a fool, but he saw that in speaking he might look like one, which some
consider worse.

He left her, assuring himself that all was fair in love and politics;
that he could not, in common good breeding, withhold his help from her
in her legal difficulty; that, should wind of Archie's dealings with
him get abroad in the town, he would be saving appearances in avoiding
a rupture with the lady whose shadow he had been since he arrived in
Edinburgh, and that it was his duty as a well-wisher of Prince Charles
to keep open any channel that might yield information about
Flemington's movements. Whatsoever may have been the quality of his
reasons, their quantity was remarkable. He did not like the little
voice that whispered to him that he would not have dared to offer them
to James.

There was no further risk of a meeting with Archie, for within a few
days of the latter's appearance in Hyndford's Close he had been sent
to the Border with instructions to watch Jedburgh and the
neighbourhood of Liddesdale, through which the Prince's army had
passed on its march to England. Madam Flemington knew that the coast
was clear, and David had no suspicion that it had been otherwise. Very
few people in Edinburgh were aware of Flemington's visit to it; it was
an event of which even the caddies were ignorant.

And so Balnillo lingered on, putting off his return to Angus from week
to week. His mouse-coloured velvet began to show signs of wear and was
replaced by a suit of dark purple; his funds were dwindling a little,
for he was not a rich man, and a new set of verses about him was going
the round of the town. Then, with January, came the battle of Falkirk
and the siege of Stirling Castle, and the end of the month brought
Cumberland and the mustering of loyal Whigs to wait upon him at
Holyrood Palace.

David departed quietly. He had come to Edinburgh to avoid playing a
marked part in Angus, and he now returned to Angus to avoid playing a
marked part in Edinburgh. He was behaving like the last remaining king
in a game of draughts when he skips from square to square in the safe
corner of the board; but he did not know that Government had kept its
eye on all his doings during the time of his stay. Perhaps it was on
account of her usefulness in this and in other delicate matters that
Madam Flemington augured well for her grandson, for when the Whig army
crossed the Forth, Archie went with it as intelligence officer to the
Duke of Cumberland.



JULY spread a mantle of heather over the Grampians. In Glen Esk, the
rough road into the Lowlands, little better than a sheep-track, ran
down the shore of Loch Lee, to come out at last into the large spaces
at the foot of the hills. The greyness of the summer haze lay over
everything, and the short grass and the roots of bog-myrtle and thyme
smelt warm and heady, for the wind was still. The sun seemed to have
sucked up some of the heather-colour out of the earth; the lower
atmosphere was suffused with a dusty lilac where, high overhead, it
softened the contours of the scattered rocks. Amongst carpets of rush
and deep moss, dappled with wet patches, the ruddy stems of the
bog-asphodel raised slim, golden heads that drooped a little, as
though for faintness, in the scented warmth. An occasional bumble-bee
passed down wind, purposeful and ostentatious, like a respectable
citizen zealous on the business of life.

No one looking along the windings of the Glen, and drawing in the
ardent quietness of the summer warmth, would have supposed that fire
and sword had been through it so lately. Its vastness of outline hid
the ruined huts and black fragments of skeleton gable-ends that had
smoked up into the mountain stillness. Homeless women and children had
fled down its secret tracks; hunted men had given up their souls under
its heights. The rich plainland of Angus had sent its sons to fight
for the Prince in the North, and of those who survived to make their
way back to their homes, many had been overtaken by the pursuit that
had swept down behind them through the hills. No place had a darker
record than Glen Esk.

Archie Flemington rode down the Glen with his companion some little
way in front of the corporal and the three men who followed them. His
left arm was in a sling, for he had received a sabre-cut at Culloden;
also, he had been rolled on by his horse, which was killed under him,
and had broken a rib. His wound, though not serious had taken a long
time to heal, for the steel had cut into the arm bone; he looked thin,
too, for the winter had been a time of strenuous work.

One of the three private soldiers, the last of the small string of
horsemen, had a rope knotted into his reins, the other end of which
was secured round the middle of a short, thickset man who paced
sullenly along beside the horse. The prisoner's arms were bound at his
back, his reddish beard was unkempt, and his clothes ragged; he made a
sorry figure in the surrounding beauty.

Nearly two months had gone by since the Battle of Culloden, and the
search for fugitives was still going on in remote places. Cumberland,
who was on the point of leaving Fort Augustus for Edinburgh on his way
to London, had given orders for a last scouring of Glen Esk. The party
had almost reached its mouth, and its efforts had resulted only in the
capture of this one rebel; but, as there was some slight doubt of his
identity, and as the officer who rode beside Archie was one whose
conscience ranked a great way above his convenience, the red-bearded
man had fared better than many of those taken by Cumberland's
man-hunters. If he were the person they supposed him to be, he was an
Angus farmer distantly related to David Ferrier, and he was now being
brought to his own country for identification.

Captain Callandar, the officer in command, was a long, lean, bony man
with a dark face, a silent, hard-bitten fellow from Ligonier's
regiment. He and Archie had met very little before they started south
together, and they had scarcely progressed in acquaintance in the few
days during which they had ridden side by side. They had shared their
food on the bare turf by day, lain down within a few yards of each
other at night; they had gone through many of the same experiences in
the North, and they belonged to the same victorious army, yet they
knew little more of each other than when they started. But there was
no dislike between them, certainly none on Archie's side, and if the
other was a little critical of the foreign roll of his companion's
_r's_, he did not show it.

Archie's tongue had been quiet enough. He was riding listlessly along,
and, though he looked from side to side, taking in the details of what
he saw from force of habit, they seemed to give him no interest. He
puzzled Callandar a good deal, for he had proved to be totally
different from anything that he had expected. The soldier was apt to
study his fellow-men, when not entirely swallowed up by his duty, and
he had been rather pleased when he found that Cumberland's brilliant
intelligence officer was to accompany him down Glen Esk. He had heard
much about him. Archie's quick answers and racy talk had amused the
Duke, who, uncompanionable himself, felt the awkward man's amazement
at the readiness of others, and scraps of Flemington's sayings had
gone from lip to lip, hall-marked by his approval. Callandar was
taciturn and grave, but he was not stupid, and he had begun to wonder
what was amiss with his companion. He decided that his own society
must be uncongenial to him, and, being a very modest man, he did not
marvel at it.

But the sources of Archie's discomfort lay far, far deeper than any
passing irritation. It seemed to him now, as he reached the mouth of
the Glen, that there was nothing left in life to fear, because the
worst that could come upon him was looming ahead, waiting for him,
counting his horse's steps as he left the hills behind.

An apprehension, a mere suggestion of what might be remotely possible,
a skeleton that had shown its face to him in sleepless or overwrought
moments since Cumberland's victory, had become real. To most people
who are haunted by a particular dread, Fate plays one of the tricks
she loves so much. She is an expert boxer, and whilst each man stands
up to her in his long, defensive fight, his eye upon hers, guarding
himself from the blow he expects to receive in the face, she hits him
in the wind and he finds himself knocked out.

But she had dealt otherwise with Archie; for a week ago he had been
specially detailed to proceed to Angus to hunt for that important
rebel, Captain James Logie, who was believed to have made his way
southward to his native parts.

At Fort Augustus it was felt that Flemington was exactly the right man
to be entrusted with the business. He was familiar with the country he
had to search, he was a man of infinite resource and infinite
intelligence; and Cumberland meant to be pleasant in his harsh,
ungraceful manner, when he gave him his commission in person, with a
hint that he expected more from Mr. Flemington than he did from
anybody else. He was to accompany Captain Callandar and his three men.
The officer, having made a last sweep of Glen Esk, was to go on by
Brechin to Forfar, where he would be joined by another and larger
party of troops that was on its way down Glen Clova from Braemar, for
Cumberland was drafting small forces into Angus by way of the
Grampians, and the country was filling with them.

He had dealt drastically with Montrose. The rebellion in the town had
been suppressed, and the neighbourhood put under military law. This
bit of the east coast had played a part that was not forgotten by the
little German general, and he was determined that the hornet's nest he
had smoked out should not re-collect. Whilst James Logie was at large
there could be no security.

Of all the rebels in Scotland, Logie was the man whom Cumberland was
most desirous to get. The great nobles who had taken part in the
rising were large quarry indeed, but this commoner who had worked so
quietly in the eastern end of Angus, who had been on the Prince's
staff, who had the experience of many campaigns at his back, whose
ally was the notorious Ferrier, who had seized the harbour of Montrose
under the very guns of a Government sloop of war, was as dangerous as
any Highland chieftain, and the news that he had been allowed to get
back to his own haunts made the Whig generals curse. Though he might
be quiet for the moment, he would be ready to stir up the same
mischief on the first recrudescence of Stuart energy. It was not known
what had happened to Ferrier, for although he was a marked man and
would be a rich haul for anybody who could deliver him up to
Cumberland, he was considered a less important influence than James;
and Government had scarcely estimated his valuable services to the
Jacobites, which were every whit as great as those of his friend.

Lord Balnillo was a puzzle to the intelligence department. His name
had gone in to headquarters as that of a strongly suspected rebel; he
was James's brother; yet, while Archie had included him in the report
he had entrusted to the beggar, he had been able to say little that
was definite about him. The very definite information he had given
about James and Ferrier, the details of his pursuit of the two men and
his warning of the attack on the _Venture_, had mattered more to the
authorities than the politics of the peaceable old judge, and
Balnillo's subsequent conduct had been so little in accordance with
that of his brother that he was felt to be a source of small danger.
He had been no great power on the bench, where his character was so
easy that prisoners were known to think themselves lucky in appearing
before him. No one could quite account for his success in the law, and
the mention of his name in the legal circles of Edinburgh raised
nothing worse than a smile. He had taken no part in the rejoicing that
followed James's feat at Montrose, but had taken the opportunity of
leaving the neighbourhood, and during his long stay in Edinburgh he
had frequented Whig houses and had been the satellite of a conspicuous
Whig lady, one who had been received by Cumberland with some
distinction, the grandmother of the man who had denounced Logie. The
authorities decided to leave him alone.

When the hills were behind the riders and the levels of the country
had sunk and widened out on either hand, they crossed the North Esk,
which made a shallow curve by the village of Edzell. The bank rose on
its western side, and the shade of the trees was delightful to the
travellers, and particularly to the prisoner they carried with them.
As the horses snuffed at the water they could hardly be urged through
it, and Callandar and Archie dismounted on the farther shore and sat
on a boulder whilst they drank. They watched them as they drew the
draught up their long throats and raised their heads when satisfied,
to stare, with dripping muzzles, at distant nothings, after the
fashion of their kind. The prisoner's aching arms were unbound that he
might drink too.

"Egad, I have pitied that poor devil these last miles," said Archie,
as the man knelt at the brink and extended his stiffened arms into a

The other nodded. Theoretically he pitied him, but a rebel was a

"You have no bowels of compassion. They are not in your instructions,
Callandar. They should be served out, like ammunition."

Callandar turned his grave eyes on him.

"The idea displeases you?" said Archie.

"It would complicate our duty."

He spoke like a humourless man, but one side of his mouth twitched
downwards a little, and Flemington, who had the eye of a lynx for
another man's face, decided that the mere accident of habit had
prevented it from twitching up. He struck him as the most repressed
person he had ever seen.

"There would not be enough at headquarters to go round," observed

Callandar's mouth straightened, and, like the horses, he looked at
nothing. Criticism was another thing not in his instructions.

"They have drunk well," he said at last. "An hour will bring us to the
foot of Huntly Hill. We can halt and feed them at the top before we
turn off towards Brechin. You know this country better than I do."

"Wait a little," said Archie. "I am no rebel, and you may have mercy
on me with a clear conscience."

He had slipped his arm out of the sling and was resting it on his

"You are in pain?" exclaimed Callandar, astonished.

Archie laughed.

"Why, man, do you think I ride for pleasure with the top half of a
bone working east and the bottom half working west?"

"I thought----" began Callandar.

"You thought me churlish company, and maybe I have been so. But this
ride has been no holiday for me."

"I did not mean that. I would have said that I thought your wound was

"My flesh-wound is mended and so is my rib," said Flemington, "but
there are two handsome splinters hobnobbing above my elbow, and I can
tell you that they dance to the tune of my horse's jog."

Callandar's opinion of him rose. He had found him disappointing as a
companion, but Archie had hid his pain, and he understood people who
did that.

The Edzell villagers turned out to stare at them as they passed a
short time later, when they took the road again. After the riders left
its row of houses their way ran from the river-level through fields
that had begun to oust the moor, rising to the crest of Huntly Hill,
on the farther side of which the southern part of Angus spread its
partial cultivation down to the Basin of Montrose. Archie's discomfort
seemed to grow; he shifted his sling again and again, and Callandar
could see his mouth set in a hard line. Now and then an impatient
sound of pain broke from him. They rode on, silent, the long rise of
the hill barring their road like a wall, and the stems of the
fir-strip that crowned it beginning to turn to a dusky black against
the sky, which was cooling off for evening. Flemington's horse was a
slow walker, and he had begun to jog persistently. His rider, holding
him back, had fallen behind. Callandar rode on, preoccupied, and when,
roused from his thoughts, he turned his head, Archie waved him on,
shouting that he would follow more slowly, for the troopers moved at a
foot's pace because of their prisoner, and he stayed abreast of them.

As Callandar passed a green sea of invading bracken that had struggled
on to the road his jaw dropped and he pulled up. Behind the feathering
waves an individual was sitting in a wooden box on wheels, and four
dogs, harnessed to the rude vehicle, were lying on the ground in their
leathern traces. He noticed with astonishment that the man had lost
the lower parts of his legs.

"You'll be Captain Callandar," said Wattie, his twinkling eyes on the
other's uniform; "you're terrible late."

"What do you want?" said the officer, amazed.

The beggar peered through the fern and saw the knot of riders and
their prisoner coming along the road some little way behind.

"Whaur's yon lad Flemington?" he demanded.

"What do you want?" exclaimed Callandar again. "If you are a beggar
you have chosen a strange place to beg in."

For answer Wattie pulled up his sliding panel and took out two sealed
letters, holding them low in the shelter of the fern, as if the
midges, dancing their evening dance above the bracken-tops, should not
look upon them. Callandar saw that one of the letters bore his own

"Whisht," said the beggar, thrusting them back quickly, "come doon
here an' hae a crack wi' me."

As Callandar had been concerned exclusively with troops and fighting,
he knew little about the channels of information working in the
country, and it took him a moment to explain the situation to himself.
He dismounted under the fixed glare of the yellow dog. He was a man to
whom small obstacles were invisible when he had a purpose, and he
almost trod on the animal, without noticing the suppressed hostility
gathering about his heels. But, so long as his master's voice was
friendly, the cur was still, for his unwavering mind answered to its
every tone. Probably no spot in all Angus contained two such steadfast
living creatures as did this green place by the bracken when Callandar
and the yellow dog stood side by side.

The soldier tethered his horse and sat down on the moss. Wattie laid
the letters before him; the second was addressed to Archie. Callandar
broke the seal of the first and read it slowly through; then he sat
silent, examining the signature, which was the same that Flemington
had showed to the beggar on the day when he met him for the first
time, months ago, by the mill of Balnillo.

He was directed to advance no farther towards Brechin, but to keep
himself out of sight among the woods round Huntly Hill, and to watch
the Muir of Pert, for it was known that the rebel, James Logie, was
concealed somewhere between Brechin and the river. He was not upon the
Balnillo estate, which, with Balnillo House, had been searched from
end to end, but he was believed to be in the neighbourhood of the

"You know the contents of this?" asked Callandar, as he put away the
paper inside the breast of his coat.

"Dod, a ken it'll be aboot Logie. He's a fell man, yon. Have ye na got
Flemington wi' ye?"

Callandar looked upon his companion with disapproval. He had never
seen him, never heard of him before, and he felt his manner and his
way of speaking of his superiors to be an outrage upon discipline and
order, which were two things very near his heart.

He did not reply.

"Whaur's Flemington?" demanded the beggar again.

"You make very free with Mr. Flemington's name."

"Tuts!" exclaimed Wattie, ignoring the rebuke, "a've got ma orders the
same as yersel', an' a'm to gie yon thing to him an' to nae ither
body. Foo will a dae that if a dinna ken whaur he is?"

His argument was indisputable.

"Mr. Flemington will be with me in a moment," said Callandar stiffly.
"He is following."

The sound of horses' feet was nearing them upon the road, and
Callandar rose and beckoned to Archie to come on.

"Go to the top of the hill and halt until I join you," he told the
corporal as the men passed.

As Archie dismounted and saw who was behind the bracken, he recoiled.
It was to him as if all that he most loathed in the past came to meet
him in the beggar's face. Here, at the confines of the Lowland
country, the same hateful influences were waiting to engulf him. His
soul was weary within him.

He barely replied to Wattie's familiar greeting.

"Do you know this person?" inquired Callandar.

He assented.

"Ay, does he. Him and me's weel acquaint," said Wattie, closing an
eye. "Hae, tak' yon."

He held out the letter to Flemington.

The young man opened it slowly, turning his back to the cart, and his
brows drew together as he read.

His destiny did not mean him to escape. Logie had been marked down,
and the circle of his enemies was narrowing round him. Flemington was
to go no farther, and he was to remain with Callandar to await another
message that would be brought to their bivouac on Huntly Hill, before
approaching nearer to Brechin.

He stood aside, the paper in his hand. Here was the turning-point; he
was face to face with it at last. He could not take part in Logie's
capture; on that he was completely, unalterably determined. What would
be the end of it all for himself he could not think. Nothing was
clear, nothing plain, but the settled strength of his determination.
He looked into the mellowing light round him, and saw everything as
though it were unreal; the only reality was that he had chosen his
way. Heaven was pitiless, but it should not shake him. Far above him a
solitary bird was winging its way into the spaces beyond the hills;
the measured beat of its wings growing invisible as it grew smaller
and smaller and was finally lost to sight. He watched it, fascinated,
with the strange detachment of those whose senses and consciousness
are numbed by some crisis. What was it carrying away, that tiny thing
that was being swallowed by the vastness? His mind could only grasp
the idea of distance . . . of space. . . .

Callandar was at his elbow, and his voice broke on him as the voice of
someone awakening him from sleep.

"These are my orders," he was saying, as he held out his own letter;
"you know them, for I am informed here that they are the duplicate of

There was no escape. Callandar knew the exact contents of both papers.
Archie might have kept his own orders to himself, and have given him
to suppose that he was summoned to Forfar or Perth, and must leave
him; but that was impossible. He must either join in hunting Logie, or
leave the party on this side of Huntly Hill.

"We had better get on," said Callandar.

They mounted, and as they did so, Wattie also got under way. His team
was now reduced to four, for the terrier which had formerly run alone
in the lead had died about the new year.

He took up his switch, and the yellow cur and his companions whirled
him with a mighty tug on to the road. He had been waiting for some
time in the bracken for the expected horseman, and as the dogs had
enjoyed a long rest, they followed the horses at a steady trot.
Callandar and Flemington trotted too, and the cart soon fell behind.
Beyond the crest of Huntly Hill the Muir of Pert sloped eastwards
towards the coast, its edges resting upon the Esk, but before the road
began to ascend it forked in two, one part running upwards, and the
other breaking away west towards Brechin.

"Callandar, I am going to leave you," said Archie, pulling up his

"To leave?" exclaimed the other blankly. "In God's name, where are you

"Here is the shortest way to Brechin, and I shall take it. I must find
a surgeon to attend to this arm. There is no use for me to go on with
you when I can hardly sit in my saddle for pain."

"But your orders?" gasped Callandar.

"I will make that right. You must go on alone. Probably I shall join
you in a few days, but that will depend on what instructions I get
later. If you hear nothing from me you will understand that I am busy
out of sight. My hands may be full--that is, if the surgeon leaves me
with both of them. Good-bye, Callandar."

He turned his horse and left him. The other opened his mouth to shout
after him, ordering him to come back, but remembered that he had no
authority to do so. Flemington was independent of him; he belonged to
a different branch of the King's service, and although he had fought
at Culloden he was under different orders. He had merely accompanied
his party, and Callandar knew very well that, though his junior in
years, he was a much more important person than himself. The nature of
Archie's duties demanded that he should be given a free hand in his
movements, and no doubt he knew what he was about. But had he been
Callandar's subordinate, and had there been a surgeon round the
nearest corner, his arm might have dropped from his shoulder before
the officer would have permitted him to fall out of the little troop.
Callandar had never in all his service seen a man receive definite
orders only to disobey them openly.

He watched him go, petrified. His brain was a good one, but it worked
slowly, and Archie's decision and departure had been as sudden as a
thunderbolt. Also, there was contempt in his heart for his softness,
and he was sorry.

Archie turned round and saw him still looking after him. He sent back
a gibe to him.

"If you don't go on I will report you for neglect of duty!" he
shouted, laughing.



CALLANDAR rode up Huntly Hill. The rose-red of the blossoming briar
that decks all Angus with its rubies glowed in the failing sunlight,
and the scent of its leaf came in puffs from the wayside ditches; the
blurred heads of the meadow-sweet were being turned into clouds of
gold as the sun grew lower and the road climbed higher. In front the
trees began to mantle Huntly Hill.

He had just begun the ascent at a foot's pace when he heard the whirr
of the beggar's chariot-wheels behind him, then at his side, and he
turned in his saddle and looked down on his pursuer's bald crown.
Wattie had cast off his bonnet, and the light breeze springing up
lifted the fringe of his grizzled hair.

"Whaur awa's Flemington?" he cried, as he came up.

The other answered by another question; his thoughts had come back to
the red-haired prisoner at the top of the hill, and it struck him that
the man in the cart might recognize him.

"What's your name?" he asked abruptly.

"Wattie Caird."

"You belong to these parts?"

He nodded.

"Then come on; I have not done with you yet."

"A'm asking ye whaur's Flemington?"

If Callandar had pleased himself he would have driven Wattie down the
hill at the point of the sword, his persistence and his pestilent,
unashamed curiosity were so distasteful to him. But he had a second
use for him now. He was that uncommon thing, a disciplinarian with
tact, and by virtue of the combination in himself he understood that
the troopers in front of him, who had been looking forward eagerly to
getting their heads once more under a roof that night, would be
disgusted by the orders he was bringing. He had noticed the chanter
sticking out from under Wattie's leathern bag, and he thought that a
stirring tune or two might ease matters for them. He did not see his
way to dispensing with him at present, so he tolerated his company.

"Mr. Flemington has a bad wound," he answered. "He has gone to Brechin
to have it attended to."

"Whaur did he get it?"

"At Culloden Moor."

"They didna tell me onything aboot that."

"Who tells you anything about Mr. Flemington? What do you know about

"Heuch!" exclaimed Wattie, with contempt, "it's mysel' that should
tell them! A ken mair aboot Flemington than ony ither body--a ken fine
what's brocht yon lad here. He's seeking Logie, like a'body else, but
he kens fine he'll na get him--ay, does he!"

Callandar looked down from his tall horse upon the grotesque figure so
close to the ground. He was furious at the creature's assumption of

"You are a piper?" said he.

"The best in Scotland."

"Then keep your breath for piping and let other people's business be,"
he said sternly.

"Man, dinna fash. It's King Geordie's business and syne it's mine. Him
and me's billies. Ay, he's awa', is he, Flemington?"

Callandar quickened his horse's pace; he was not going to endure this
offensive talk. But Wattie urged on his dogs too, and followed hard on
his heels.

All through the winter, whilst the fortunes of Scotland were deciding
themselves in the North, he had been idle but for his piping and
singing, and he had had little to do with the higher matters on which
he had been engaged in the autumn, whilst the forces of the coming
storm were seething south of the Grampians. He had not set eyes on
Flemington since their parting by the farm on Rossie Moor, but many a
night, lying among his dogs, he had thought of Archie's voice calling
to Logie as he tossed and babbled in his broken dreams.

He had long since drawn his conclusion and made up his mind that he
admired Archie as a mighty clever fellow, but he was convinced that he
was more astute than anybody supposed, and it gave him great delight
to think that, probably, no one but himself had a notion of the part
Flemington was playing. Wattie was well aware of his advancement, for
his name was in everybody's mouth. He knew that he was on Cumberland's
staff, just as Logie was on the staff of the Prince, and he wagged his
head as he thought how Archie must have enriched himself at the
expense of both Whig and Jacobite. It was his opinion that, knowledge
being marketable, it was time that somebody else should enrich himself
too. He would have given a great deal to know whether Flemington, as a
well-known man, had continued his traffic with the other side, and as
he went up the hill beside the dark Whig officer he was turning the
question over in his mind.

He had kept his suspicions jealously to himself. Whilst Flemington was
far away in the North, and all men's eyes were looking across the
Grampians, he knew that he could command no attention, and he had
cursed because he believed his chance of profit to be lost. Archie had
gone out of range, and he could not reach him; yet he kept his
knowledge close, like a prudent man, in case the time should come when
he might use it. And now Flemington had returned, and he had been sent
out to meet him.

The way had grown steep, and as Callandar's horse began to stumble,
the soldier swung himself off the tired beast and walked beside him,
his hand on the mane.

Wattie was considering whether he should speak. If his information
were believed, it would be especially valuable at this time, when the
authorities were agog to catch Logie, and the reward for his services
must be considerable if there was any justice in the world. They would
never catch Logie, because Flemington was in league with him. Wattie
knew what many knew--that the rebel was believed to be somewhere about
the great Muir of Pert, now just in front of them, but so far as he
could make out, the only person who was aware of how the wind set with
Archie was himself.

What he had seen at the foot of Huntly Hill had astonished him till he
had read its meaning by the light of his own suspicions. Though he had
not been close enough to the two men to hear exactly what passed
between them when they parted, he had seen them part. He had seen
Callandar standing to look after the other as though uncertain how to
act, and he had heard Archie's derisive shout. There was no sign of a
quarrel between them, yet Callandar's face suggested they had
disagreed; there was perplexity in it and underlying disapproval. He
had seen his gesture of astonishment, and the way in which he had sat
looking after Flemington at the cross roads, reining back his horse,
which would have followed its companion, was eloquent to the beggar.
Callandar had not expected the young man to go.

Wattie did not know the nature of the orders he had brought, but he
knew that they referred to Logie. He understood that those who
received them were hastening to meet those who had despatched them,
and would be with them that night; and this proved to him how
important it was that the letters should be in the hand of the riders
before they advanced farther on their way. He had been directed to
wait on the northern side of Huntly Hill, and had been specially
charged to deliver them before Callandar crossed it. He told himself
that only a fool would fail to guess that they referred to this
particular place. But the illuminating part to Wattie was the speech
he had heard by the bracken: it was all that was needed to explain the
officer's stormy looks.

"These are my orders," Callandar had said, "but you know them, for I
am informed that they are the duplicate of yours."

Archie had disobeyed them, and Wattie was sure that he had gone,
because the risk of meeting Logie was too great to be run. Now was the
time for him to speak.

He had no nicety, but he had shrewdness in plenty. He was sudden and
persistent in his address, and divining the obstacles in Callandar's
mind, he charged them like a bull.

"Flemington 'll na let ye get Logie," said he.

He made his announcement with so much emphasis that the man walking
beside him was impressed in spite of his prejudices. He was annoyed
too. He turned on him angrily.

"Once and for all, what do you mean by this infernal talk about Mr.
Flemington?" he cried, stopping short. "You will either speak out, or
I will take it upon myself to make you. I have three men in the wood
up yonder who will be very willing to help me. I believe you to be a
meddlesome liar, and if I find that I am right you shall smart for

But the beggar needed no urging, and he was not in the least afraid of

"It's no me that's sweer to speak, it's yersel' that's sweer to
listen," said he, with some truth. "Dod, a've tell't ye afore an' a'm
telling ye again--_Flemington 'll no let ye get him!_ He's dancin' wi'
George, but he's takin' the tune frae Chairlie. Heuch! dinna tell me!
There's mony hae done the same afore an' 'll dae it yet!"

The officer was standing in the middle of the road, a picture of

"It's no the oxter of him that gars him gang," said Wattie, breaking
into the broad smile of one who is successfully letting the light of
reason into another's mind. "It's no his airm. Maybe it gies him a
pucklie twist, whiles, and maybe it doesna, but it's no that that gars
the like o' him greet. _He wouldna come up Huntly Hill wi' you, for he
ken't he was ower near Logie._ It's that, an' nae mair!"

Callandar began to think back. He had not heard one complaint from
Archie since the day they rode out of Fort Augustus together, and he
remembered his own astonishment at hearing he was in pain from his
wound. It seemed only to have become painful in the last couple of

"It is easy to make accusations," he said grimly, "but you will have
to prove them. What proof have you?"

"Is it pruifs ye're needin'? Fegs, a dinna gang aboot wi' them in ma
poke! A can tell ye ma pruifs fine, but maybe ye'll no listen."

He made as though to drive on.

Callandar stepped in front of the dogs, and stood in his path.

"You will speak out before I take another step," said he. "I will have
no shuffling. Come, out with what you know! I will stay here till I
get it."


HUNTLY HILL (_continued_)

CALLANDAR sat a little apart from his men on the fringe of the
fir-wood; on the other side of the clearing on which the party had
bivouacked Wattie formed the centre of a group. It was past sunset,
and the troop-horses, having been watered and fed, were picketed
together. Callandar's own horse snatched at the straggling
bramble-shoots behind a tree.

The officer sat on a log, his chin in his hand, pondering on the
amazing story that the beggar had divulged. It was impossible to know
what to make of it, but, in spite of himself, he was inclined to
believe it. He had questioned and cross-questioned him, but he had
been able to form no definite opinion. Wattie had described his
meeting with Archie on the day of the taking of the ship; he had told
him how he had accompanied him on his way, how he had been forced to
ask shelter for him at the farm, how he had lain and listened in the
darkness to his feverish wanderings and his appeals to Logie. If the
beggar's tale had been true, there seemed to be no doubt that the
intelligence officer whose services were so much valued by Cumberland,
had taken money from the rebels, though it seemed that he had
hesitated over the business. His conscience must have smitten him even
in his dreams. "I will say nothing, but I will tell you all!" he had
cried to Logie. "I shall know where you are, but they shall never
know!" In his delirium, he had taken the beggar for the man whose
fellow-conspirator he was proving himself to be, and when
consciousness was fighting to return, and he had sense enough to know
that he was not speaking to Logie, it was his companion's promise to
deliver a message of reassurance that had given him peace and sleep.
"Tell him that he can trust me," he had said. What puzzled Callandar
was the same thing that had puzzled Wattie: Why had these two men,
linked together by a hidden understanding, fought? Perhaps Flemington
had repented of the part he was playing, and had tried to cut himself
adrift. "Let me go!" he had exclaimed. It was all past Callandar's
comprehension. At one moment he was inclined to look on Wattie as an
understudy for the father of lies; at another, he asked himself how he
could have had courage to invent such a calumny--how he had dared to
choose a man for his victim who had reached the position that Archie
had gained. But he realized that, had Wattie been inventing, he would
hardly have invented the idea of a fight between Flemington and
Captain Logie. That little incongruous touch seemed to Callandar's
reasonable mind to support the truth of his companion's tongue.

And then there was Flemington's sudden departure. It did not look so
strange since he had heard what the beggar had to say. He began to
think of his own surprise at finding Archie in pain from a wound which
seemed to have troubled him little, so far, and to suspect that his
reliable wits had been stimulated to find a new use for his injured
arm by the sight of Huntly Hill combined with the news in his pocket.
His gorge rose at the thought that he had been riding all these days
side by side with a very prince among traitors. His face hardened. His
own duty was not plain to him, and that perturbed him so much that his
habitual outward self-repression gave way. He could not sit still
while he was driven by his perplexities. He sprang up, walking up and
down between the trees. Ought he to send a man straight off to Brechin
with a summary of the beggar's statement? He could not vouch for the
truth of his information, and there was every chance of it being
disregarded, and himself marked as the discoverer of a mare's nest.
There was scarcely anything more repugnant to Callandar than the
thought of himself in this character, and for that reason, if for no
other, he inclined to the risk; for he had the overwhelmingly
conscientious man's instinct for martyrdom.

His mind was made up. He took out his pocket-book and wrote what he
had to say in the fewest and shortest words. Then he called the
corporal, and, to his extreme astonishment, ordered him to ride to
Brechin. When the man had saddled his horse, he gave him the slip of
paper. He had no means of sealing it, here in the fir-wood, but the
messenger was a trusted man, one to whom he would have committed
anything with absolute conviction. He was sorry that he had to lose
him, for he could not tell how long he might be kept on the edge of
the Muir, nor how much country he would have to search with his tiny
force; but there was no help for it, and he trusted that the corporal
would be sent back to him before the morrow. He was the only person to
whom he could give the open letter. When the soldier had mounted,
Callandar accompanied him to the confines of the wood, giving him
instructions from the map he carried.

Wattie sat on the ground beside his cart; his back was against a
little raised bank. Where his feet should have been, the yellow dog
was stretched, asleep. As Callandar and his corporal disappeared among
the trees, he began to sing 'The Tod' in his rich voice, throwing an
atmosphere of dramatic slyness into the words that made his hearers
shout with delight at the end of each verse.

When he had finished the song, he was barely suffered to take breath
before being compelled to begin again; even the prisoner, who lay
resting, still bound, within sight of the soldiers, listened, laughing
into his red beard. But suddenly he stopped, rising to his feet:

    "A lang-leggit deevil wi' his hand upon the gate,
     An' aye the Guidwife cries to him----"

Wattie's voice fell, cutting the line short, for a rush of steps was
bursting through the trees--was close on them, dulled by the
pine-needles underfoot--sweeping over the stumps and the naked roots.
The beggar stared, clutching at the bank. His three companions sprang

The wood rang with shots, and one of the soldiers rolled over on his
face, gasping as he tried to rise, struggling and snatching at the
ground with convulsed fingers. The remaining two ran, one towards the
prisoner, and one towards the horses which were plunging against each
other in terror; the latter man dropped midway, with a bullet through
his head.

The swiftness of the undreamed-of misfortune struck panic into Wattie,
as he sat alone, helpless, incapable either of flight or of
resistance. One of his dogs was caught by the leaden hail and lay
fighting its life out a couple of paces from where he was left, a
defenceless thing in this sudden storm of death. Two of the remaining
three went rushing through the trees, yelping as the stampeding horses
added their share to the danger and riot. These had torn up their
heel-pegs, which, wrenched easily from a resistance made for the most
part of moss and pine-needles, swung and whipped at the ends of the
flying ropes behind the crazy animals as they dashed about. The
surviving trooper had contrived to catch his own horse, and was riding
for his life towards the road by which they had come from Edzell. The
only quiet thing besides the beggar was the yellow cur who stood at
his master's side, stiff and stubborn and ugly, the coarse hair rising
on his back.

Wattie's panic grew as the drumming of hoofs increased and the horses
dashed hither and thither. He was more afraid of them than of the
ragged enemy that had descended on the wood. The dead troopers lay
huddled, one on his face and the other on his side; the wounded dog's
last struggles had ceased. Half a dozen men were pursuing the horses
with outstretched arms, and Callandar's charger had broken loose with
its comrades, and was thundering this way and that, snorting and
leaping, with cocked ears and flying mane.

The beggar watched them with a horror which his dislike and fear of
horses made agonizing, the menace of these irresponsible creatures,
mad with excitement and terror, so heavy, so colossal when seen from
his own helpless nearness to the earth that was shaking under their
tread, paralyzed him. His impotence enwrapped him, tragic, horrible, a
nightmare woven of death's terrors; he could not escape; there was no
shelter from the thrashing hoofs, the gleaming iron of the shoes. The
cumbrous perspective of the great animals blocked out the sky with its
bulk as their rocking bodies went by, plunging, slipping, recovering
themselves within the cramped circle of the open space. He knew
nothing of what was happening, nor did he see that the prisoner stood
freed from his bonds. He knew James Logie by sight, and he knew
Ferrier, but, though both were standing by the red-bearded man, he
recognized neither. He had just enough wits left to understand that
Callandar's bivouac had been attacked, but he recked of nothing but
the thundering horses that were being chased to and fro as the circle
of men closed in. He felt sick as it narrowed and he could only
flatten himself, stupefied, against the bank. The last thing he saw
was the yellow coat of his dog, as the beast cowered and snapped,
keeping his post with desperate tenacity in the din.

The bank against which he crouched cut the clearing diagonally, and as
the men pressed in nearer round the horses, Callandar's charger broke
out of the circle followed by the two others. A cry from the direction
in which they galloped, and the sound of frantic nearing hoofs, told
that they had been headed back once more. The bank was high enough to
hide Wattie from them as they returned, but he could feel the earth
shake with their approach, which rang in his ears like the roar of
some dread, implacable fate. He could see nothing now, as he lay
half-blind with fear, but he was aware that his dog had leaped upon
the bank behind him, and he heard the well-known voice, hoarse and
brutal with defiant agony, just above his head. All the qualities that
have gone to make the dog the outcast of the East seemed to show in
the cur's attitude as he raised himself, an insignificant, common
beast, in the path of the great, noble, stampeding creatures. It was
the curse of his curship that in this moment of his life, when he
hurled all that was his in the world--his low-bred body--against the
danger that swooped on his master, he should take on no nobility of
aspect, nothing to picture forth the heart that smote against his
panting ribs. Another moment and the charger had leaped at the bank,
just above the spot where Skirling Wattie's grizzled head lay against
the sod.

The cur sprang up against the overwhelming bulk, the smiting hoofs,
the whirl of heel-ropes, and struck in mid-air by the horse's knee,
was sent rolling down the slope. As he fell there was a thud of
dislodged earth, and the charger, startled by the sudden apparition of
the prostrate figure below him, slipped on the bank, stumbled, sprang,
and checked by the flying rope, crashed forward, burying the beggar
under his weight.

James and Ferrier ran forward as the animal struggled to its feet,
unhurt; it tore past the men, who had broken their line as they
watched the fall. The three horses made off between the trees, and
Logie approached the beggar. He lay crushed and mangled, as quiet as
the dead troopers on the ground.

There was no mistaking Wattie's rigid stillness, and as James and
Ferrier, with the red-bearded man, approached him, they knew that he
would never rise to blow his pipes nor to fill the air with his voice
again. The yellow dog was stretched, panting, a couple of paces from
the grotesque body, which had now, for the first time, taken on
dignity. As Logie bent to examine him, and would have lifted him, the
cur dragged himself up; one of his hind-legs was broken, but he
crawled snarling to the beggar's side, and turned his maimed body to
face the men who should dare to lay a hand on Wattie. The drops poured
from his hanging tongue and his eye was alight with the dull flame of
pain. He would have torn Logie to bits if he could, as he trailed
himself up to shelter the dead man from his touch. He made a great
effort to get upon his legs and his jaws closed within an inch of
James's arm.

One of the men drew the pistol from his belt.

"Ay, shoot the brute," said another.

James held up his hand.

"The man is dead," said he, looking over his shoulder at his comrades.

"And you would be the same if yon dog could reach you," rejoined
Ferrier. "Let me shoot him. He will only die lying here."

"Let him be. His leg is broken, that is all."

The cur made another attempt to get his teeth into Logie, and almost

Ferrier raised his pistol again, but James thrust it back.

"The world needs a few such creatures as that in it," said he. "Lord!
Ferrier, what a heart there is in the poor brute!"

"Stand away from him, Logie, he is half mad."

"We must get away from this place," said James, unheeding, "or that
man who has ridden away will bring the whole country about our ears.
It has been a narrow escape for you, Gourlay," he said to the released
prisoner. "We must leave the old vagabond lying where he is."

"There is no burying him with that devil left alive!" cried Ferrier.
"I promise you I will not venture to touch him."

"My poor fellow," said James, turning to the dog, "it is of no use;
you cannot save him. God help you for the truest friend that a man
ever had!"

He pulled off his coat and approached him. The men stood round,
looking on in amazement as he flung it over the yellow body. The dog
yelled as Logie grasped and lifted him, holding him fast in his arms;
but his jaws were muffled in the coat, and the pain of the broken limb
was weakening his struggles.

Ferrier looked on with his hands on his hips. He admired the dog, but
did not always understand James.

"You are going to hamper yourself with him now?" he exclaimed.

"Give me the piper's bonnet," said the other. "There! push it into the
crook of my arm between the poor brute and me. It will make him go the
easier. You will need to scatter now. Leave the piper where he is. A
few inches of earth will do him no good. Ferrier, I am going. You and
I will have to lie low for awhile after this."

The cur had grown exhausted, and ceased to fight; he shivered and
snuffled feebly at the Kilmarnock bonnet, the knob of which made a red
spot against the shirt on James's broad breast. Ferrier and Gourlay
glanced after him as he went off between the trees. But as they had no
time to waste on the sight of his eccentricities, they disappeared in
different directions.

Dusk was beginning to fall on the wood and on the dead beggar as he
lay with his two silent comrades, looking towards the Grampians from
the top of Huntly Hill.



CALLANDAR watched his corporal riding away from the confines of the
wood. His eyes followed the horse as it disappeared into hollows and
threaded its way among lumps of rock. He stood for some time looking
out over the landscape, now growing cold with the loss of the sun, his
mind full of Flemington. Then he turned back with a sigh to retrace
his way. His original intention in bringing Wattie up the hill came
back to him, and he remembered that he had yet to discover whether he
could identify the red-bearded man. It was at this moment that the
fusillade from his halting-place burst upon him. He stopped,
listening, then ran forward into the wood, the map from which he had
been directing the corporal clutched in his hand.

He had gone some distance with the soldier, so he only reached the
place when the quick disaster was over to hear the hoof-beats of the
escaping horses dying out as they galloped down Huntly Hill. The smoke
of the firearms hung below the branches like a grey canopy, giving the
unreality of a vision to the spectacle before him. He could not see
the beggar's body, but the overturned cart was in full view, a
ridiculous object, with its wooden wheels raised, as though in
protest, to the sky. He looked in vain for a sign of his third man,
and at the sight of the uniform upon the two dead figures lying on the
ground he understood that he was alone. Of the three private soldiers
who had followed him down Glen Esk there was not one left with him.
Archie, the traitor, was gone, and only the red-bearded man remained.
He could see him in the group that was watching James Logie as he
captured the struggling dog.

Callandar ground his teeth; then he dropped on one knee and
contemplated the sight from behind the great circle of roots and earth
that a fallen tree had torn from the sod. Of all men living he was one
of the last who might be called a coward, but neither was he one of
those hot-heads who will plunge, to their own undoing and to that of
other people, into needless disaster. He would have gone grimly into
the hornet's nest before him, pistol in hand, leaving heaven to take
care of the result, had the smallest advantage to his king and country
been attainable thereby. His own death or capture would do no more
than prevent him from carrying news of what had happened to
headquarters, and he decided, with the promptness hidden behind his
taciturn demeanour, that his nearest duty was to identify James Logie,
if he were present. Callandar's duty was the only thing that he always
saw quickly.

From his shelter he marked the two Jacobite officers, and, as he knew
Ferrier very well from description, he soon made out the man he
wanted. James was changed since the time when he had first come across
Archie's path. His clothes were worn and stained, and the life of
wandering and concealment that he had led since he parted from the
Prince had set its mark on him. He had slept in as many strange places
of late as had the dead beggar at his feet; anxious watching and lack
of food and rest were levelling the outward man to something more
primitive and haggard than the gallant-looking gentleman of the days
before Culloden, yet there remained to him the atmosphere that could
never be obliterated, the personality that he could never lose until
the earth should lie on him. He was no better clothed than those who
surrounded him, but his pre-eminence was plain. The watcher devoured
him with his eyes as he turned from his comrades, carrying the dog.

As soon as he was out of sight, the rebels scattered quietly, and
Callandar crouched lower, praying fortune to prevent anyone from
passing his retreat. None approached him, and he was left with the
three dead men in possession of the wood.

He rose and looked at his silent comrades. It would be useless to
follow Logie, because, with so many of his companions dispersing at
this moment about the fringes of the Muir of Pert, he could hardly
hope to do so unobserved. There would be no chance of getting to close
quarters with him, which was Callandar's chief desire, for the mere
suspicion of a hostile presence would only make James shift his
hiding-place before the gathering troops could draw their cordon round
him. He abandoned the idea with regret, telling himself that he must
make a great effort to get to Brechin and to return with a mounted
force in time to take action in the morning. The success of his ambush
and his ignorance that he had been watched would keep Logie quiet for
the night.

He decided to take the only road that he knew, the one by which
Flemington had left him. The upper one entangled itself in the Muir,
and might lead him into some conclave of the enemy. He began to
descend in the shadows of the coming darkness that was drawing itself
like an insidious net over the spacious land. He had almost reached
the road, when a moving object not far from him made him stop. A man
was hurrying up the hill some little way to his right, treading
swiftly along, and, though his head was turned from Callandar, and he
was not near enough for him to distinguish his features, the sling
across his shoulder told him that it was Flemington.

Callandar stood still, staring after him. Archie's boldness took away
his breath. Here he was, returning on his tracks, and if he kept his
direction, he would have to pass within a few hundred yards of the
spot on which he knew that the companions he had left would be halted;
Callandar had pointed out the place to him as they approached the hill

Archie took a wider sweep as he neared the wood, and the soldier,
standing in the shadow of a rowan-tree, whose berries were already
beginning to colour for autumn, saw that he was making for the Muir,
and knew that the beggar was justified. One thing only could be
bringing him back. He had come, as Wattie had predicted, to warn

He had spoken wisdom, that dead vagabond, lying silent for ever among
the trees; he had assured him that Flemington would not suffer him to
take Logie. He knew him, and he had laughed at the idea of his wounded
arm turning him out of his road. "It's no the like o' that that gars
the like o' him greet," he had said; and he was right. Callandar,
watching the definite course of the figure through the dusk, was sure
that he was taking the simplest line to a retreat whose exact position
he knew. He turned and followed, running from cover to cover, his
former errand abandoned. It was strange that, in spite of all, a vague
gladness was in his heart, as he thought that Archie was not the soft
creature that he had pretended to be. There were generous things in
Callandar. Then his generous impulse turned back on him in bitterness,
for it occurred to him that Archie had been aware of what lay waiting
for them, and had saved himself from possible accident in time.

They went on till they reached the border of the Muir, Flemington
going as unconcernedly as if he were walking in the streets of
Brechin, though he kept wide of the spot on which he believed the
riders to have disposed themselves for the night. There was no one who
knew him in that part of the country, and he wore no uniform to make
him conspicuous in the eyes of any chance passer in this lonely
neighbourhood. As Callandar emerged from the straggling growth at the
Muir's edge, he saw him still in front going through the deep
thickness of the heather.

Callandar wished that he knew how far the Muir extended, and exactly
what lay on its farther side. His map was thrust into his coat, but it
was now far too dark for him to make use of it; the tall figure was
only just visible, and he redoubled his pace, gaining a little on it.
A small stationary light shone ahead, evidently the window of some
muirland hovel. There is nothing so difficult to decide as the
distance of a light at night, but he guessed that it was the goal
towards which Archie was leading. He went forward, till the young
man's voice hailing someone and the sound of knocking made him stop
and throw himself down in the heather. He thought he heard a door
shut. When all had been quiet for a minute he rose up, and,
approaching the house, took up his stand not a dozen yards from the

Perplexity came on him. He had been surprisingly successful in
pursuing Flemington unnoticed as far as this hovel, but he had yet to
find out who was inside it. Perhaps the person he had heard speaking
was Logie, but equally perhaps not. There was no sound of voices
within, though he heard movements; he dared not approach the
uncurtained window to look in, for the person whose step he heard was
evidently standing close to it. He would wait, listening for that
person to move away, and then would try his luck. He had spent perhaps
ten minutes thus occupied when, without a warning sound, the door
opened and Archie stood on the threshold, as still as though he were
made of marble. It was too dark for either man to see more than the
other's blurred outline.

Flemington looked out into the night.

"Come in, Callandar!" he called. "You are the very man I want!"

The soldier's astonishment was such that his feet seemed frozen to the
ground. He did not stir.

"Come!" cried Archie. "You have followed me so far that you surely
will not turn back at the last step. I need you urgently, man. Come

He held the door open.

Callandar entered, pushing past him, and found himself in a low, small
room, wretchedly furnished, with another at the back opening out of
it. Both were empty, and the light he had seen was standing on the

"There is no one here!" he exclaimed.

"No," said Flemington.

"Where is the man you were speaking to?"

"He is gone. The ill-mannered rogue would not wait to receive you."

"It was that rebel! It was Captain Logie!" cried Callandar.

"It was not Logie; you may take my word for that," replied Archie. He
sat down on the edge of the table and crossed his legs. "Try again,
Callandar," he said lightly.

Callandar's lips were drawn into an even line, but they were shaking.
The mortification of finding that Archie had been aware of his
presence, had pursued his way unconcerned, knowing that he followed,
had called him in as a man calls the serving-man he has left outside,
was hot in him. No wonder his own concealment had seemed so easy.

"You have sent him to warn Logie--that is what you have done!" he
cried. "You are a scoundrel--I know that!"

He stepped up to him, and would have laid hold of his collar, but the
sling stopped him.

"I have. Callandar, you are a genius."

As the other stood before him, speechless, Flemington rose up.

"You have got to arrest me," he said; "that is why I called you in. I
might have run out by the back of the house, like the man who is gone,
who went with my message almost before the door was shut. Look! I have
only one serviceable arm and no sword. I left it where I left my
horse. And here is my pistol; I will lay it on the table, so you will
have no trouble in taking me prisoner. You have not had your stalking
for nothing, after all, you mighty hunter before the Lord!"

"You mean to give yourself up--you, who have taken so much care to
save yourself?"

"I have meant to ever since I saw you under the rowan-tree watching
me, flattened against the trunk like a squirrel. I would as soon be
your prisoner as anyone else's--sooner, I think."

"I cannot understand you!" exclaimed Callandar, taking possession of
the weapon Archie had laid down.

"It is hard enough to understand oneself, but I do at last," said the
other. "Once I thought life easy, but mine has been mighty difficult
lately. From here on it will be quite simple. And there will not be
much more of it, I fancy."

"You are right there," said Callandar grimly.

"I can see straight before me now. I tell you life has grown simple."

"You lied at the cross roads."

"I did. How you looked after me as I went! Well, I have done what I
suppose no one has ever done before: I have threatened to report you
for neglecting your duty." He threw back his head and laughed. "And I
am obliged to tell you to arrest me now. O Callandar, who will correct
your backslidings when there is an end of me?"

The other did not smile as he looked at Flemington's laughing eyes,
soft and sparkling under the downward curve of his brows. Through his
anger, the pity of it all was smiting him, though he was so little
given to sentiment. Perhaps Archie's charm had told on him all the
time they had been together, though he had never decided whether he
liked him or not. And he looked so young when he laughed.

"What have you done?" he cried, pacing suddenly up and down the little
room. "You have run on destruction, Flemington; you have thrown your
life away. Why have you done this--you?"

"If a thing is worthless, there is nothing to do but throw it away."

Callandar watched him with pain in his eyes.

"What made you suspect me?" asked Archie. "You can tell me anything
now. There is only one end to this business. It will be the making of

"Pshaw!" exclaimed the other, turning away.

"Why did you follow me?" continued Archie.

Callandar was silent.

"Tell me this," he said at last: "What makes you give yourself up now,
without a struggle or a protest, when little more than two hours ago
you ran from what you knew was to come, there, at the foot of the
hill? Surely your friends would have spared _you!_"

"Now it is I who do not understand you," said Archie.

His companion stood in front of him, searching his face.

"Flemington, are you lying? On your soul, are you lying?"

"Of what use are lies to me now?" exclaimed Archie impatiently. "Truth
is a great luxury; believe me, I enjoy it."

"You knew nothing of what was waiting for us at the top of Huntly

"Nothing, as I live," said Archie.

"The beggar betrayed you," said Callandar. "When you were gone he told
me that you were in Logie's pay--that you would warn him. He was
right, Flemington."

"I am not in Logie's pay--I never was," broke in Archie.

"I did not know what to think," the soldier went on; "but I took him
up Huntly Hill with me, and when we had unsaddled, and the men were
lying under the trees, I sent the corporal to Brechin with the
information. I went with him to the edge of the wood, and when I came
back there was not a man left alive. Logie and Ferrier were there with
a horde of their rebels. They had come to rescue the prisoner, and he
was loose."

"Then he _was_ Ferrier's cousin!" exclaimed Flemington. "We were

"One of my men escaped," continued Callandar, "or I suppose so, for he
was gone. The beggar and the other two were killed, and the horses had

"So Wattie is dead," mused Flemington. "Gad, what a voice has gone
with him!"

"They did not see me, but I watched them; I saw him--Logie--he went
off quickly, and he took one of the beggar's dogs with him, snarling
and struggling, with his head smothered in his coat. Then I went down
the hill, meaning to make for Brechin, and I saw you coming back. I
knew what you were about, thanks to that beggar."

Neither spoke for a minute. Archie was still sitting on the table. He
had been looking on the ground, and he raised his eyes to his
companion's face.

Something stirred in him, perhaps at the thought of how he stood with
fate. He was not given to thinking about himself, but he might well do
so now.

"Callandar," he said, "I dare say you don't like me----" Then he broke
off, laughing. "How absurd!" he exclaimed. "Of course you hate me; it
is only right you should. But perhaps you will understand--I think you
will, if you will listen. I was thrown against Logie--no matter
how--but, unknowing what he did, he put his safety in my hands. He did
more. I had played upon his sympathy, and in the generosity of his
heart he came to my help as one true man might do to another. I was
not a true man, but he did not know that; he knew nothing of me but
that I stood in need, and he believed I was as honest as himself. He
thought I was with his own cause. That was what I wished him to
believe--had almost told him."

Callandar listened, the lines of his long face set.

"I had watched him and hunted him," continued Archie, "and my
information against him was already in the beggar's hands, on its way
to its mark. I could not bring myself to do more against him then.
What I did afterwards was done without mention of his name. You see,
Callandar, I have been true to nobody."

He paused, waiting for comment, but the other made none.

"After that I went to Edinburgh," he continued, "and he joined the
Prince. Then I went north with Cumberland. I was freed from my
difficulty until they sent me here to take him. The Duke gave me my
orders himself, and I had to go. That ride with you was hell,
Callandar, and when we met the beggar to-day I had to make my choice.
That was the turning-point for me. I could not go on."

"He said it was not your wound that turned you aside."

"He was a shrewd rascal," said Flemington. "I wish I could tell how he
knew so much about me."

"It was your own tongue: once you spent the night in a barn together
when you were light-headed from a blow, and you spoke all night of
Logie. You said enough to put him on your track. That is what he told
me as we went up Huntly Hill."

Archie shrugged his shoulders and rose up.

"Now, what are you going to do?" he said.

"I am going to take you to Brechin."

"Come, then," said Archie, "we shall finish our journey together after
all. It has been a hard day. I am glad it is over."

They went out together. As Callandar drew the door to behind them
Archie stood still.

"If I have dealt double with Logie, I will not do so with the king,"
said he. "This is the way out of my difficulty. Do you understand me,

The darkness hid the soldier's face.

Perhaps of all the people who had played their part in the tangle of
destiny, character, circumstance, or whatsoever influences had brought
Flemington to the point at which he stood, he was the one who
understood him best.



THE last months had been a time of great anxiety to Lord Balnillo. In
spite of his fine steering, and though he had escaped from
molestation, he was not comfortable as he saw the imprisonments and
confiscations that were going on; and the precariousness of all that
had been secure disturbed him and made him restless. He was unsettled,
too, by his long stay in Edinburgh, and he hankered afresh after the
town life in which he had spent so many of his years. His trees and
parks interested him still, but he looked on them, wondering how long
he would be allowed to keep them. He was lonely, and he missed James,
whom he had not seen since long before Culloden, the star of whose
destiny had led him out again into the world of chance.

He had the most upsetting scheme under consideration that a man of his
age can entertain. At sixty-four it is few people who think seriously
of changing their state, yet this was what David Balnillo had in mind;
for he had found so many good reasons for offering his hand to
Christian Flemington that he had decided at last to take that
portentous step. The greatest of these was the effect that an alliance
with the Whig lady would produce in the quarters from which he feared
trouble. His estate would be pretty safe if Madam Flemington reigned
over it.

It was pleasant to picture her magnificent presence at his table; her
company would rid country life of its dulness, and on the visits to
Edinburgh, which he was sure she would wish to make, the new Lady
Balnillo would turn their lodging into a bright spot in society. He
smoothed his silk stockings as he imagined the stir that his belated
romance would make. He would be the hero of it, and its heroine,
besides being a safeguard to his property, would be a credit to

There were some obstacles to his plan, and one of them was Archie; but
he believed that, with a little diplomacy, that particular difficulty
might be overcome. He would attack that side of the business in a very
straightforward manner. He would make Madam Flemington understand that
he was large-minded enough to look upon the episode in which he had
borne the part of victim in a reasonable yet airy spirit. In the game
in which their political differences had brought them face to face the
honours had been with the young man; he would admit that with a smile
and with the respect that one noble enemy accords to another. He would
assure her that bygones should be bygones, and that when he claimed
Archie as his grandson-in-law, he would do so without one grudging
backward glance at the circumstances in which they had first met. His
magnanimity seemed to him an almost touching thing, and he played with
the idea of his own apposite grace when, in some sly but genial
moment, he would suggest that the portrait upstairs should be

What had given the final touch to his determination was a message that
James had contrived to send him, which removed the last scruple from
his heart. His brother's danger had weighed upon David, and it was not
only its convenience to himself at this juncture which made him
receive it with relief. Logie was leaving the country for Holland, and
the next tidings of him would come from there, should he be lucky
enough to reach its shores alive.

Since the rescue of Gourlay the neighbourhood of the Muir of Pert--the
last of his haunts in which Logie could trust himself--had become
impossible for him, and he was now striving to get to a creek on the
coast below Peterhead. It was some time since a roof had been over
him, and the little cottage from which Flemington had despatched his
urgent warning stood empty. Its inmate had been his unsuspected
connection with the world since his time of wandering had begun; for
though his fatal mistake in discovering this link in his chain of
communication to Flemington had made him abjure its shelter, he had
had no choice for some time between the Muir and any other place.

The western end of the county swarmed with troops. Montrose was
subdued; the passes of the Grampians were watched; there remained only
this barren tract west of the river; and the warning brought to him
from a nameless source had implored him to abandon it before the
soldiery, which his informant assured him was collecting to sweep it
from end to end, should range itself on its borders.

Archie had withheld his name when he sent the dweller in the little
hovel speeding into the night. He was certain that in making it known
to James he would defeat his own ends, for Logie would scarcely be
disposed to trust his good faith, and might well look on the message
as a trick to drive him into some trap waiting for him between the
Muir and the sea.

James did not give his brother any details of his projected flight; he
merely bade him an indefinite good-bye. The game was up--even he was
obliged to admit that--and Ferrier, whose ardent spirit had been one
with his own since the beginning of all things, was already making for
a fishing village, from which he hoped to be smuggled out upon the
high seas. Nothing further could be gained in Angus for the Stuart
cause. The friends had spent themselves since April in their
endeavours to resuscitate the feeling in the country, but there was no
more money to be raised, no more men to be collected. They told
themselves that all they could do now was to wait in the hope of a day
when their services might be needed again. That day would find them
both ready, if they were above ground.

David knew that, had James been in Scotland, he would not have dared
to think of bringing Christian Flemington to Balnillo.

He had a feeling of adventure when he started from his own door for
Ardguys. The slight awe with which Christian still inspired him, even
when she was most gracious, was beginning to foreshadow itself, and he
knew that his bones would be mighty stiff on the morrow; there was no
riding of the circuit now to keep him in practice in the saddle. But
he was not going to give way to silly apprehensions, unsuited to his
age and position; he would give himself every chance in the way of
effect. The servant who rode after him carried a handsome riding-suit
for his master to don at Forfar before making the last stage of his
road. It grieved Balnillo to think how much of the elegance of his
well-turned legs must be unrevealed by his high boots. He was a
personable old gentleman, and his grey cob was worthy of carrying an
eligible wooer. He reached Ardguys, and dismounted under its walls on
the following afternoon.

He had sent no word in front of him. Christian rose when he was
ushered into her presence, and laid down the book in her hand,

"You are as unexpected as an earthquake," she exclaimed, as she saw
who was her visitor.

"But not as unwelcome?" said David.

"Far from it. Sit down, my lord. I had begun to forget that
civilization existed, and now I am reminded of it."

He bowed, delighted.

A few messages and compliments, a letter or two despatched by hand,
had been their only communications since the judge left Edinburgh, and
his spirits rose as he found that she seemed really pleased to see

"And what has brought you?" asked Christian, settling herself with the
luxurious deliberation of a cat into the large chair from which she
had risen. "Something good, certainly."

"The simple desire to see you, ma'am. Could anything be better?"

It was an excellent opening; but he had never, even in his youth, been
a man who ran full tilt upon anything. He had scarcely ever before
made so direct a speech.

She smiled, amused. There had been plenty of time for thought in her
solitude; but, though she had thought a good deal about him, she had
not a suspicion of his errand. She saw people purely in relation to
the uses she had for them, and, officially, she had pronounced him
harmless to the party in whose interests she had kept him at her side.
The circumstances were not those which further sentiment.

"I have spent this quiet time in remembering your kindnesses to me,"
he began, inspired by her smile.

"You call it a quiet time?" she interrupted. "I had not looked on it
in that way. Quiet for us, perhaps, but not for the country."

"True, true," said he, in the far-away tone in which some people seek
to let unprofitable subjects melt.

Now that the active part of the rebellion had become history, she had
no hesitation in speaking out from her solid place on the winning

"This wretched struggle is over, and we may be plain with one another,
Lord Balnillo," she continued. "You, at least, have had much to alarm

"I have been a peaceful servant of law and order all my life," said
he, "and as such I have conceived it my place to stand aloof. It has
been my duty to restrain violence of all kinds."

"But you have not restrained your belongings," she observed boldly.

He was so much taken aback that he said nothing.

"Well, my lord, it is one of my regrets that I have never seen Captain
Logie. At least you have to be proud of a gallant man," she went on,
with the same impulse that makes all humanity set a fallen child upon
its legs.

But Balnillo had a genius for scrambling to his feet.

"My brother has left the country in safety," he rejoined, with one of
those random flashes of sharpness that had stood him in such good
stead. His cunning was his guardian angel; for he did not know what
she knew--namely, that Archie had left Fort Augustus in pursuit of

"Indeed?" she said, silenced.

She was terribly disappointed, but she hid her feelings in barefaced

The judge drew his chair closer. Here was another opening, and his
very nervousness pushed him towards it.

"Ma'am," he began, clearing his throat, "I shall not despair of
presenting James to you. When the country is settled--if--in

"I imagine that Captain Logie will hardly trust himself in Scotland
either in my lifetime or in yours. We are old, you and I," she added,
the bitterness of her disappointment surging through her words.

She watched him to see whether this barbed truth pierced him; it
pierced herself as she hurled it.

"Maybe," said he; "but age has not kept me from the business I have
come upon. I have come to put a very particular matter before you."

She was still unsuspicious, but she grew impatient. He had wearied her
often in Edinburgh with tedious histories of himself, and she had
endured them then for reasons of policy; but she felt no need of doing
so here. It was borne in upon her, as it has been borne in upon many
of us, that a person who is acceptable in town may be unendurable in
the country. She had not thought of that as she welcomed him.

"Ma'am," he went on, intent on nothing but his affair, "I may surprise
you--I trust I shall not offend you. At least you will approve the
feelings of devotion, of respect, of admiration which have brought me
here. I have an ancient name, I have sufficient means--I am not
ill-looking, I believe----"

"Are you making me a proposal, my lord?"

She spoke with an accent of derision; the sting of it was sharp in her

"There is no place for ridicule, ma'am. I see nothing unsuitable in my
great regard for you."

He spoke with real dignity.

She had not suspected him of having any, personally, and she had
forgotten that an inherited stock of it was behind him. The rebuke
astonished her so much that she scarcely knew what reply to make.

"As I said, I believe I am not ill-looking," he repeated, with an air
that lost him his advantage. "I can offer you such a position as you
have a right to expect."

"You also offer me a brother-in-law whose destination may be the
scaffold," she said brutally; "do not forget that."

This was not to be denied, and for a moment he was put out. But it was
on these occasions that he shone.

"Let us dismiss family matters from our minds and think only of
ourselves," said he; "my brother is an outlaw, and as such is
unacceptable to you, and your grandson has every reason to be ashamed
to meet me. We can set these disadvantages, one against the other, and
agree to ignore them."

"I am not disposed to ignore Archie," said she.

"Well, ma'am, neither am I. I hope I am a large-minded man--indeed, no
one can sit on the bench for the time that I have sat on it and not
realize the frailty of all creatures----"

"My lord----" began Christian.

But it is something to have learned continuance of speech
professionally, and Balnillo was launched; also his own magnanimous
attitude had taken his fancy.

"I will remember nothing against him," said he. "I will forget his
treatment of my hospitality, and the discreditable uses to which he
put my roof."

"Sir!" broke in Christian.

"I will remember that, according to his lights, he was in the exercise
of his duty. Whatsoever may be my opinion of the profession to which
he was compelled, I will thrust it behind me with the things best

"That is enough, Lord Balnillo," cried Madam Flemington, rising.

"Sit, madam, sit. Do not disturb yourself! Understand me, that I will
allow every leniency. I will make every excuse! I will dwell, not on
the fact that he was a spy, but on his enviable relationship to

She stood in the middle of the room, threatening him with her eyes.
Some people tremble when roused to the pitch of anger that she had
reached; some gesticulate; Christian was still.

He had risen too.

"If you suppose that I could connect myself with a disloyal house you
are much mistaken," she said, controlling herself with an effort. "I
have no quarrel with your name, Lord Balnillo; it is old enough. My
quarrel is with the treason in which it has been dipped. But I am very
well content with my own. Since I have borne it, I have kept it clean
from any taint of rebellion."

"But I have been a peaceful man," he protested. "As I told you, the
law has been my profession. I have raised a hand against no one."

"Do you think I do not know you?" exclaimed she. "Do you suppose that
my ears were shut in the winter, and that I heard nothing in all the
months I spent in Edinburgh? What of that, Lord Balnillo?"

"You made no objection to me then, ma'am. I was made happy by being of
service to you."

She laughed scornfully.

"Let us be done with this," she said. "You have offered yourself to me
and I refuse the offer. I will add my thanks."

The last words were a masterpiece of insolent civility.

A gilt-framed glass hung on the wall, one of the possessions that she
had brought with her from France. David suddenly caught sight of his
own head reflected in it above the lace cravat for which he had paid
so much; the spectacle gathered up his recollections and his present
mortification, and fused them into one stab of hurt vanity.

"I see that you can make no further use of me," he said.


He walked out of the room. At the door he turned and bowed.

"If you will allow me, I will call for my horse myself," said he.

He went out of the house and she stood where she was, thinking of what
he had told her about his brother; she had set her heart upon Archie's
success in taking Logie, and now the man had left the country and his
chance was gone. The proposal to which she had just listened did not
matter to her one way or the other, though he had offended her by the
attitude he took up when making it. He was unimportant. It was of
Archie that she thought as she watched the judge and his servant ride
away between the ash-trees. They were crossing the Kilpie burn when
her maid came in, bringing a letter. The writing on it was strange to

"Who has brought this?" she asked as she opened it.

"Just a callant," replied the girl.

She read the letter, which was short. It was signed 'R. Callandar,
Captain,' and was written at Archie Flemington's request to tell her
that he was under arrest at Brechin on a charge of conspiring with the
king's enemies.

The writer added a sentence, unknown, as he explained, to Flemington.

"The matter is serious," he wrote, "the Duke of Cumberland is still in
Edinburgh. It might be well if you could see him. Make no delay, as we
await his orders."

She stood, turning cold, her eyes fixed on the maid.

"Eh--losh, mem!" whimpered Mysie, approaching her with her hands

Madam Flemington felt as though her brain refused to work. There
seemed to be nothing to drive it forward. The world stood still. The
walls, an imprisoning horror, shut her in from all movement, all
action, when action was needed. She had never felt Ardguys to be so
desperately far from the reach of humanity, herself so much cut off
from it, as now. And yet she must act. Her nearest channel of
communication was the judge, riding away.

"Fool!" she cried, seizing Mysie, "run--run! Send the boy after Lord
Balnillo. Tell him to run!"

The maid hesitated, staring at the pallor of her mistress's face.

"Eh, but, mem--sit you down!" she wailed.

Christian thrust her from her path as though she had been a piece of
furniture, and swept into the hall. A barefooted youth was outside by
the door. He stared at her, as Mysie had done. She took him by the

"Run! Go instantly after those horses! That is Lord Balnillo!" she
cried, pointing to the riders, who were mounting the rise beyond the
burn. "Tell him to return at once. Tell him he must come back!"

He shook off her grip and ran. He was a corner-boy from Brechin and he
had a taste for sensation.

Madam Flemington went back into her room. Mysie followed her,
whimpering still, and she pushed her outside and sank down in her
large chair. She could not watch the window, for fear of going mad.

She sat still and steady until she heard the thud of bare feet on the
stone steps, and then she hurried out.

"He tell't me he wadna bide," said the corner-boy breathlessly. "He
was vera well obliged to ye, he bad' me say, but he wadna bide."

Christian left him and shut herself into the room, alone. Callandar's
bald lines had overpowered her completely, leaving no place in her
brain for anything else. But now she saw her message from Lord
Balnillo's point of view, and anger and contempt flamed up again, even
in the midst of her trouble.

"The vanity of men! Ah, God, the vanity of men!" she cried, throwing
out her hands, as though to put the whole race of them from her.



THE Duke of Cumberland was at Holyrood House. He had come down from
the North by way of Stirling, and having spent some days in Edinburgh,
he was making his final arrangements to set out for England. He was
returning in the enviable character of conquering hero, and he knew
that a great reception awaited him in London, where every preparation
was being made to do him honour; he was thinking of these things as he
sat in one of the grim rooms of the ancient palace. There was not much
luxury here; and looking across the table at which he sat and out of
the window, he could see the dirty roofs of the Canongate--a very
different prospect from the one that would soon meet his eyes. He was
sick of Scotland.

Papers were littered on the table, and his secretary had just carried
away a bundle with him. He was alone, because he expected a lady to
whom he had promised an audience, but he was not awaiting her with the
feelings that he generally brought to such occasions. Cumberland had
received the visits of many women alone since leaving England, but his
guests were younger than the one whose approach he could now hear in
the anteroom outside. He drew his brows together, for he expected no
profit and some annoyance from the interview.

He rose as she was ushered in and went to the open fireplace, where he
stood awaiting her, drawn up to his full height, which was not great.
The huge iron dogs behind him and the high mantel-piece above his head
dwarfed him with their large lines. He was not an ill-looking young
man, though his hair, pulled back and tied after the fashion of the
day, showed off the receding contours that fell away from his temples,
and made his blue eyes look more prominent than they were.

He moved forward clumsily as Christian curtsied.

"Come in, madam, come in. Be seated. I have a few minutes only to give
you," he said, pointing to a chair on the farther side of the table.

She sat down opposite to him.

"I had the honour of being presented to your Royal Highness last
year," she said.

"I remember you well, ma'am," replied he shortly.

"It is in the hope of being remembered that I have come," said she.
"It is to ask you, Sir, to remember the services of my house to

"I remember them, ma'am; I forget nothing."

"I am asking you, in remembering, to forget one thing," said she. "I
shall not waste your Royal Highness's time and mine in beating about
bushes. I have travelled here from my home without resting, and it is
not for me to delay now."

He took up a pen that lay beside him, and put the quill between his

"Your Royal Highness knows why I have come," continued she, her eyes
falling from his own and fixing themselves on the pen in his mouth. He
removed it with his fat hand, and tossed it aside.

"There is absolute proof against Flemington," said he. "He accuses
himself. I presume you know that."

"I do. This man--Captain Logie--has some strange attraction for him
that I cannot understand, and did him some kindness that seems to have
turned his head. His regard for him was a purely personal one. It was
personal friendship that led him to--to the madness he has wrought.
His hands are clean of conspiracy. I have come all this way to assure
your Highness of that."

"It is possible," said Cumberland. "The result is the same. We have
lost the man whose existence above ground is a danger to the kingdom."

"I have come to ask you to take that difference of motive into
consideration," she went on. "Were the faintest shadow of conspiracy
proved, I should not dare to approach you; my request should not pass
my lips. I have been in correspondence with him during the whole of
the campaign, and I know that he served the king loyally. I beg your
Highness to remember that now. I speak of his motive because I know

"You are fortunate, then," he interrupted.

"Captain Callandar, to whom he gave himself up, wrote me two letters
at his request, one in which he announced his arrest, and one which I
received as I entered my coach to leave my door. Archie knows what is
before him," she added; "he has no hope of life and no knowledge of my
action in coming to your Highness. But he wished me to know the
truth--that he had conspired with no one. He is ready to suffer for
what he has done, but he will not have me ashamed of him. Look,

She pushed the letter over to him.

"His motives may go hang, madam," said Cumberland.

"Your Highness, if you have any regard for us who have served you,
read this!"

He rose and went back to the fireplace.

"There is no need, madam. I am not interested in the correspondence of

He was becoming impatient; he had spent enough time on this lady. She
was not young enough to give him any desire to detain her. She was an
uncommon-looking woman, certainly, but at her age that fact could
matter to nobody. He wondered, casually, whether the old stories about
her and Charles Edward's father were true. Women struck him only in
one light.

"You will not read this, your Royal Highness?" said Christian, with a
little tremor of voice.

"No, ma'am. I may tell you that my decision has not altered. The case
is not one that admits of any question."

"Your Highness," said Christian, rising, "I have never made an abject
appeal to anyone yet, and even now, though I make it to the son of my
king, I can hardly bring myself to utter it. I deplore my--my boy's
action from the bottom of my soul. I sent him from me--I parted from
him nearly a year ago because of this man Logie."

He faced round upon her and put his hands behind his back.

"What!" he exclaimed, "you knew of this? You have been keeping this
affair secret between you?"

"He went to Montrose on the track of Logie in November," said she; "he
was sent there to watch his movements before Prince Charles marched to
England, and he did so well that he contrived to settle himself under
Lord Balnillo's roof. In three days he returned to me. He had reported
on Logie's movements--I know that--your Highness's agents can produce
his report. But he returned to my house to tell me that, for some
fool's reason, some private question of sentiment, he would follow
Logie no longer. 'I will not go man-hunting after Logie'--those were
his words."

"Madam----" began Cumberland.

She put out her hand, and her gesture seemed to reverse their

"I told him to go--I told him that I would sooner see him dead than
that he should side with the Stuarts! He answered me that he could
have no part with rebels, and that his act concerned Logie alone. Then
he left me, and on his way to Brechin he received orders to go to the
Government ship in Montrose Harbour. Then the ship was attacked and

"It was Flemington's friend, Logie, who was at the bottom of that
business," said Cumberland.

"He met Logie and they fought," said Madam Flemington. "I know none of
the details, but I know that they fought. Then he went to Edinburgh."

"It is time that we finished with this!" exclaimed Cumberland. "No
good is served by it."

"I am near the end, your Highness," said Christian, and then paused,
unnerved by the too great suggestiveness of her words.

"These things are no concern of mine," he observed in the pause; "his
movements do not matter. And I may tell you, ma'am, that my leisure is
not unlimited."

It was nearing the close of the afternoon, and the sun stood like a
red ball over the mists of the Edinburgh smoke. Cumberland's business
was over for the day, and he was looking forward to dining that
evening with a carefully chosen handful of friends, male and female.

Her nerve was giving way against the stubborn detachment of the man.
She felt herself helpless, and her force ineffective. Life was
breaking up round her. The last man she had confronted had spurned her
in the end--through a mistake, it was true--but the opportunity had
been given him by her own loss of grip in the bewilderment of a
crisis. This one was spurning her too. But she went on.

"He performed his work faithfully from that day forward, as your Royal
Highness knew when you took him to the North. His services are better
known to you, Sir, than to anyone else. He gave himself up to Captain
Callandar as the last proof that he could take no part with the
rebels. He threw away his life."

"_That_, at least, is true," said the Duke, with a sneer. He was
becoming exasperated, and the emphasis which he put on the word 'that'
brought the slow blood to her face. She looked at him as though she
saw him across some mud-befouled stream. Even now her pride rose above
the despair in her heart. He was not sensitive, but her expression
stung him.

"I am accustomed to truth," she replied.

He turned his back. There was a silence.

"I came to ask for Archie's life," she said, in a toneless, steady
voice, "but I will go, asking nothing. Your Royal Highness has nothing
to give that he or I would stoop to take at your hands."

He stood doggedly, without turning, and he did not move until the
sound of her sweeping skirts had died away in the anteroom. Then he
went out, a short, stoutish figure passing along the dusty corridors
of Holyrood, and entered a room from which came the ring of men's

A party of officers in uniform got up as he came in. Some were playing
cards. He went up to one of the players and took those he held from
between his fingers.

"Give me your hand, Walden," said he, "and for God's sake get us a
bottle of wine. Damn me, but I hate old women! They should have their
tongues cut out."



THE houses of Brechin climb from the river up the slope, and a little
camp was spread upon the crest of ground above them, looking down over
the uneven pattern of walls, the rising smoke, and the woods that
cradled the Esk. Such of Cumberland's soldiery as had collected in
Angus was drawn together here, and as the country was settling down,
the camp was increased by detachments of horse and foot that arrived
daily from various directions. The Muir of Pert was bare, left to the
company of the roe-deer and the birds, for James had been traced to
the coast, and the hungry North Sea had swallowed his tracks.

The spot occupied by the tents of Callandar's troop was in the highest
corner of the camp, the one farthest from the town, and the long
northern light that lingered over the hill enveloped the camp sounds
and sights in a still, greenish clearness. There would be a bare few
hours of darkness.

Callandar was now in command of a small force consisting of a troop of
his own regiment which had lately marched in, and two of his men stood
sentry outside the tent in which Archie Flemington was sitting at an
improvised table writing a letter.

He had been a close prisoner since his arrest on the Muir of Pert, and
during the week that had elapsed, whilst correspondence about him and
orders concerning him had gone to and fro between Brechin and
Edinburgh, he had been exclusively under Callandar's charge. That
arrangement was the one concession made on his behalf among the many
that had been asked for by his friends. At his own request he was to
remain Callandar's prisoner till the end, and it was to be Callandar's
voice that would give the order for his release at sunrise to-morrow,
and Callandar's troopers whose hands would set him free.

The two men had spent much time together. Though the officer's
responsibility did not include the necessity of seeing much of his
prisoner, he had chosen to spend nearly all his leisure in Archie's
tent. They had drawn very near together, this incongruous pair, though
the chasm that lay between their respective temperaments had not been
bridged by words. They had sat together on many evenings, almost in
silence, playing cards until one of them grew drowsy, or some
officious cock crowed on the outskirts of the town. Of the incident
which had brought them into their present relationship, they spoke not
at all; but sometimes Archie had broken out into snatches of talk, and
Callandar had listened, with his grim smile playing about his mouth,
to his descriptions of the men and things amongst which his short life
had thrown him. As he looked across at his companion, who sat, his
eyes sparkling in the light of the lantern, his expression changing
with the shades of humour that ran over his words, like shadows over
growing corn, he would be brought up short against the thought of the
terrible incongruity to come--death. He could not think of Archie and
death. At times he would have given a great deal to pass on his
responsibility to some other man, and to turn his back on the place
that was to witness such a tragedy. In furthering Archie's wishes by
his own application for custody of him he had given him a great proof
of friendship--how great he was only to learn as the days went by.
Would to God it were over--so he would say to himself each night as he
left the tent. He had thought Archie soft when they parted at the
cross-roads, and he had been sorry. There was no need for sorrow on
that score; never had been. The sorrow to him now was that so gallant,
so brilliant a creature was to be cut off from the life of the world,
to go down into the darkness, leaving so many of its inhabitants
half-hearted, half-spirited, half alive, to crawl on in an existence
which only interested them inasmuch as it supplied their common needs.

His hostility against Logie ran above the level of the just antagonism
that a man feels for his country's enemy, and he questioned whether
his life were worth the price that Flemington was paying for it. The
hurried words that Archie had spoken about Logie as they left the
hovel together had told him little, and that little seemed to him
inadequate to explain the tremendous consequences that had followed.
What had Logie said or done that had power to turn him out of his way?
A man may meet many admirable characters among his enemies without
having his efforts paralyzed by the encounter. Flemington was not new
to his trade, and had been long enough in the secret service to know
its requirements. A certain unscrupulousness was necessarily among
them, yet why had his gorge only risen against it now? Callandar could
find no signs in him of the overwrought sensibility that seemed to
have prompted his revolt against his task. Logie had placed his safety
in Archie's hands, and it was in order to end that safety that the
young man had gone out; he had laid the trap and the quarry had fallen
into it. What else had he expected? It was not that Callandar could
not understand the scruple; what he could not understand was why a man
of Archie's occupation should suddenly be undone by it. Having
accepted his task, his duty had been plain. In theory, a rebel, to
Callandar was a rebel, no more, and Archie, by his deed, had played a
rebel's part; yet, in spite of that, the duty he must carry out on the
morrow was making his heart sink within him. One thing about Archie
stood out plain--he was not going to shirk his duty to his king and
yet take Government money. Whatsoever his doings, the prisoner who sat
in the tent over yonder would be lying under the earth to-morrow
because he was prepared to pay the last price for his scruple. No, he
was not soft.

Callandar would have died sooner than let him escape, yet his escape
would have made him glad.

Callandar came across the camp and passed between the two sentries
into Flemington's tent. The young man looked up from his writing.

"You are busy," said the officer.

"I have nearly done. There seems so much to do at the last," he added.

The other sat down on the bed and looked at him, filled with grief.
The lantern stood by Archie's hand. His head was bent into the circle
of light, and the yellow shine that fell upon it warmed his olive skin
and brought out the brown shades in his brows and hair. The changing
curves of his mouth were firm in the intensity of his occupation. He
had so much expression as a rule that people seldom thought about his
features but Callandar now noticed his long chin and the fine lines of
his nostril.

His pen scratched on for a few minutes; then he laid it down and
turned round.

"You have done me many kindnesses, Callandar," said he, "and now I am
going to ask you for another--the greatest of all. It is everything to
me that Captain Logie should get this letter. He is safe, I hope, over
the water, but I do not know where. Will you take charge of it?"

"I will," said the other--"yes."

The very name of Logie went against him.

"You will have to keep it some little time, I fear," continued Archie,
"but when the country has settled down you will be able to reach him
through Lord Balnillo. Promise me that, if you can compass it, he
shall get this."

"If it is to be done, I will do it."

"From you, that is enough," said Flemington, "I shall rest quietly."

He turned to his writing again.

Callandar sat still, looking round the tent vaguely for something to
distract his heavy thoughts. A card lay on the ground and he picked it
up. It was an ace, and the blank space of white round it was covered
with drawing. His own consideration had procured pens and books--all
that he could find to brighten the passing days for his prisoner. This
was the result of some impulse that had taken Flemington's artistic

It was a sketch of one of the sentries outside the tent door. The
figure was given in a few lines, dark against the light, and the
outline of the man's homely features had gained some quality of
suggestiveness and distinction by its passage through Archie's mind,
and by the way he had placed the head against the clouded atmosphere
made by the smoke rising from the camp. Through it, came a touched-in
vision of the horizon beyond the tents. He looked at it, seeing
something of its cleverness, and tossed it aside.

When Archie had ended his letter, he read it through:

"When this comes to your hands perhaps you will know what has become
of me," he had written, "and you will understand the truth. I ask you
to believe me, if only because these are the last words I shall ever
write. A man speaks the truth when it is a matter of hours with him.

"You know what brought me to Balnillo, but you do not know what sent
me from it. I went because I had no courage to stay. I was sent to
find out how deep you were concerned in the Stuart cause and to watch
your doings. I followed you that night in the town, and my wrist bears
the mark you set on it still. That morning I despatched my
confirmation of the Government's suspicions about you. Then I met you
and we sat by the Basin of Montrose. God knows I have never forgotten
the story you told me.

"Logie, I went because I could not strike you again. You had been
struck too hard in the past, and I could not do it. What I told you
about myself was untrue, but you believed it, and would have helped
me. How could I go on?

"Then, as I stood between the devil and the deep sea, my orders took
me to the _Venture_, and we met again on Inchbrayock. I had made sure
you would be on the hill. When I would have escaped from you, you held
me back, and as we struggled you knew me for what I was.

"You know the rest as well as I do, and you know where I was in the
campaign that followed. Last of all I was sent out with those who were
to take you on the Muir of Pert. I had no choice but to go--the choice
came at the cross-roads below Huntly Hill. It was I who sent the
warning to you from the little house on the Muir. You had directed me
there for a different purpose. I sent no name with my message, knowing
that if I did you might suspect me of a trick to entrap you again.
That is all. There remained only the consequences, and I shall be face
to face with them to-morrow.

"There is one thing more to say. Do not let yourself suppose that I am
paying for your life with mine. I might have escaped had I tried to do
so--it was my fault that I did not try. I had had enough of untruth,
and I could no longer take the king's money; I had served his cause
ill, and I could only pay for it. I have known two true men in my
life--you and the man who has promised that you shall receive this
letter. If you will think of me without bitterness, remember that I
should have been glad.


He folded the paper and rose, holding it out to Callandar.

"I am contented," said he; "go now, Callandar. You look worn out. I
believe this last night is trying you more than it tries me."

     *   *   *   *   *

It was some little time after daybreak that Callandar stood again at
the door of the tent under the kindling skies. Archie was waiting for
him and he came out. The eyes of the sentries never left them as they
went away together, followed by the small armed guard that was at
Callandar's heels.

The two walked a little apart, and when they reached the outskirts of
the camp they came to a field, an insignificant rough enclosure, in
which half a dozen soldiers were gathered, waiting. At the sight of
Callandar the sergeant who was in charge of them began to form them in
a line some paces from the wall.

Callandar and Flemington stopped. The light had grown clear, and the
smoke that was beginning to rise from the town thickened the air over
the roofs that could be seen from where they stood. The daily needs
and the daily avocations were beginning again for those below the
hill, while they were ceasing for ever for him who stood above in the
cool morning. In a few minutes the sun would get up; already there was
a sign of his coming in the eastward sky.

The two men turned to each other; they had nothing more to say. They
had settled every detail of this last act of their short
companionship, so that there should be no hesitation, no mistake,
nothing to be a lengthening of agony for one, nor an evil memory for
the other.

Archie held out his hand.

"When I look at you," he said.

"Yes," said Callandar.

"There are no words, Callandar. Words are nothing--but the last bit of
my life has been the better for you."

For once speech came quickly to the soldier.

"The rest of mine will be the better for you," he answered. "You said
once that you were not a true man. You lied."

Flemington was giving all to disprove the accusation of untruth, and
it was one of the last things he was to hear.

So, with these rough words--more precious to him than any that could
have been spoken--sounding in his ears, he walked away and stood
before the wall. The men were lined in front of him.

His eyes roved for a moment over the slope of the country, the town
roofs, the camp, then went to the distance. A solitary bird was
crossing the sky, and his look followed it as it had followed the one
he had seen when he made his choice at the foot of Huntly Hill. The
first had flown away, a vanishing speck, towards the shadows gathering
about the hills. This one was going into the sunrise. It was lost in
the light. . . .

"Fire!" said Callandar.

For Archie was looking at him with a smile.



JAMES LOGIE stood at the window of a house in a Dutch town. The
pollarded beech, whose boughs were trimmed in a close screen before
the walls, had shed its golden leaves and the canal waters were grey
under a cloudy sky. The long room was rather dark, and was growing
darker. By the chair that he had left lay a yellow cur.

He had been standing for some minutes reading a letter by the fading
light, and his back was towards the man who had brought it. The latter
stood watching him, stiff and tall, an object of suspicion to the dog.

As he came to the end, the hand that held the paper went down to
James's side. The silence in the room was unbroken for a space. When
he turned, Callandar saw his powerful shoulders against the dusk and
the jealous shadows of the beech-tree's mutilated arms.

"I can never thank you enough for bringing me this," said Logie. "My
debt to you is immeasurable."

"I did it for him--not for you."

Callandar spoke coldly, almost with antagonism.

"I can understand that," said James.

But something in his voice struck the other. Though he had moved as if
to leave him, he stopped, and going over to the window, drew a
playing-card from a pocket in his long coat.

"Look," he said, holding out the ace scrawled with the picture of the

James took it, and as he looked at it, his crooked lip was set
stiffly, lest it should tremble.

"It was in his tent when I went back there--afterwards," said

He took the card back, and put it in his pocket.

"Then it was you----" began James.

"He was my prisoner, sir."

James walked away again and stood at the window.

Callandar waited, silent.

"I must wish you a good-day, Captain Logie," he said at last, "I have
to leave Holland to-night."

James followed him down the staircase, and they parted at the outer
door. Callandar went away along the street, and James came back slowly
up the steep stairs, his hand on the railing of the carved banisters.
He could scarcely see his way.

The yellow dog came to meet him when he entered his room, and as his
master, still holding the letter, carried it again to the light, he
followed. Half-way across the floor he turned to sniff at an old
Kilmarnock bonnet that lay by the wainscot near the corner in which he

He put his nose against it, and then looked at Logie. Trust was in his
eyes and affection; but there was inquiry, too.

"My poor lad," said James, "we both remember."



Transcriber's Note

This transcription is based on images posted by the HathiTrust Digital
Library from a copy made available by the New York Public Library and
digitized by Google:


The following changes were made to the printed text:

-- No attempt was made to reproduce the convention of using opening
quotation marks along the left margin when quoting a letter. See pp.
31-35, p. 107, and pp. 341-43.

-- p. 14: by the abrupt departure of his accuser,--Changed the comma
after "accuser" to a period.

-- p. 22: Where is your postillion?--Changed "postillion" to
"postilion" for consistency.

-- p. 32: But I am telling you only effects whenyou are wanting
causes.--Changed "whenyou" to "when you".

-- p. 40: The author's note defining "Tod," originally at the bottom
of the page, has been moved to the end of the chapter in the
html-based versions of this transcription or placed in square brackets
next to the word in the text version.

-- p. 52: The wall which bounded the great Balnillo
grassparks--Changed "grassparks" to "grass-parks" for consistency.

-- p. 60: who had been inces santly absent--Changed "inces santly",
which was split between lines without a hyphen, to "incessantly".

-- p. 94: for his throat had grown thick--Added a period after

-- p. 97: I left the Scots' Brigade--Deleted the apostrophe after
"Scots" for consistency.

-- p. 104: the gallant background of the Scots' Brigade--Deleted the
apostrophe after "Scots" for consistency.

-- p. 104: the grave at Bergen op Zoom--Changed "Bergen op Zoom" to
"Bergen-op-Zoom" for consistency.

-- p. 145: I will give you the details of my report quickly.--Added a
closing quotation mark after "quickly."

-- p. 157: that overlooked the mass of shiping opposite
Ferryden.--Changed "shiping" to "shipping".

-- p. 175: was grapling with him so that he could not get his arm
free--Changed "grapling" to "grappling".

-- p. 190: The women were ruuning out of their houses too.--Changed
"ruuning" to "running".

-- p. 191: "There's fechtin!" . . . "Fechtin?" . . . "Ay, there's
fechtin . . ."--Added an apostrophe after "fechtin" for consistency.

-- p. 195: would make him no safer from Lord Balnillno.--Changed
"Balnillno" to "Balnillo".

-- p. 215: The author's notes defining "kyte" and "kaipit," originally
at the bottom of the page, have been moved to the end of the chapter
in the html-based versions of this transcription or placed in square
brackets next to the word in the text version.

-- p. 215: a' tell 't Maister Flemington the road to
Aberbrothock.--Deleted the space before the apostrophe in "tell 't"
for consistency.

-- p. 215: he tell 't me.--Deleted the space before the apostrophe in
"tell 't" for consistency.

-- p. 216: A' tell 't him wha 'd get him a passage to Leith--Deleted
the space before the apostrophe in "tell 't" for consistency.

-- p. 229: to begin the seaach for Flemington.--Changed "seaach" to

-- p. 231: another smaller appartment could be--Changed "appartment"
to "apartment".

-- p. 272: partial cultivation down to the Basin of Montrose--Added a
period after "Montrose".

-- p. 280: He had just began the ascent--Changed "began" to "begun".

-- p. 286: a've tell 't ye afore an' a'm telling ye again--Deleted the
space before the apostrophe in "tell 't" for consistency.

-- p. 288: on whicht he party had bivouacked--Changed "whicht he" to
"which the".

-- p. 291: he gave himt he slip of paper--Changed "himt he" to "him

-- p. 297: what a heart there is the poor brute!--Inserted the word
"in" between "is" and "the".

-- p. 311: Callander listened, the lines of his long face
set.--Changed "Callander" to "Callandar" for consistency.

-- p. 311: You see, Callander, I have been true to nobody.--Changed
"Callander" to "Callandar" for consistency.

-- p. 325: the Duke of Cumberlaid is still in Edinburgh.--Changed
"Cumberlaid" to "Cumberland".

-- p. 327: he could see the dirty roofs of the Cannongate--Changed
"Cannongate" to "Canongate".

-- p. 336: it was to be Calandar's voice--Changed "Calandar's" to

-- p. 342: but you believed it, and would have helped me?--Changed the
question mark at the end of the sentence to a period.

-- p. 347: Callandar spoke coldly, almost with antagonism--Added a
period at the end of the sentence.

Spellings deemed to be variants (e.g., "carring" and "East Nauk") were

*** End of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "Flemington" ***

Doctrine Publishing Corporation provides digitized public domain materials.
Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians.
This effort is time consuming and expensive, so in order to keep providing
this resource, we have taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties,
including placing technical restrictions on automated querying.

We also ask that you:

+ Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Doctrine Publishing
Corporation's ISYS search for use by individuals, and we request that you
use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes.

+ Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort
to Doctrine Publishing's system: If you are conducting research on machine
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a
large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of
public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help.

+ Keep it legal -  Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for
ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because
we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States,
that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries.
Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we
can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is
allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Doctrine Publishing
ISYS search  means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world.
Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe.

About ISYS® Search Software
Established in 1988, ISYS Search Software is a global supplier of enterprise
search solutions for business and government.  The company's award-winning
software suite offers a broad range of search, navigation and discovery
solutions for desktop search, intranet search, SharePoint search and embedded
search applications.  ISYS has been deployed by thousands of organizations
operating in a variety of industries, including government, legal, law
enforcement, financial services, healthcare and recruitment.