By Author [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Title [ A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z |  Other Symbols ]
  By Language
all Classics books content using ISYS

Download this book: [ ASCII ]

Look for this book on Amazon

We have new books nearly every day.
If you would like a news letter once a week or once a month
fill out this form and we will give you a summary of the books for that week or month by email.

Title: Dancers in the Dark
Author: Speare, Dorothy
Language: English
As this book started as an ASCII text book there are no pictures available.
Copyright Status: Not copyrighted in the United States. If you live elsewhere check the laws of your country before downloading this ebook. See comments about copyright issues at end of book.

*** Start of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "Dancers in the Dark" ***

This book is indexed by ISYS Web Indexing system to allow the reader find any word or number within the document.

Canada team at http://www.pgdpcanada.net

                                 IN THE


                              NEW     YORK
                        GEORGE H. DORAN COMPANY

                            COPYRIGHT, 1922,
                       BY GEORGE H. DORAN COMPANY


                           THE GIRLS OF TODAY

                              IN THE DARK


Joy Nelson came into the room that she was sharing with two other girls,
at half-past four in the morning. She was tired. She had been dancing
steadily all night; her new silver slippers were killing her; and she
was not accustomed to being up late. She could hardly wait to take her
slippers off and get ready to sleep for a few hours.

Her room-mates, however, looked as if repose were the last thought they
would allow to enter their jazz-surrounded heads. They were sitting on
the bed, smoking. She had pretended not to see them, until she realized
that they were not in the least bit embarrassed. They had even offered
her a cigarette!

“My word, you look shot,” said Jerry. Jerry was a fascinating girl, Joy
had decided. She was not pretty—she was more than that. She had what
the erudite youth of the day would describe vividly as “something about
her.” Her dark hair was bobbed, and she had green eyes and a red mouth.
Her nose turned up, her scintillant face was splashed with freckles;
decidedly, she was not pretty; but she was fascinating. One never could
tell what she was going to do next. Joy had seen her openly chewing gum
in the Kappa Beta living-room. One of the chaperones had lifted her
eyebrows. Jerry never missed a demonstration. In less time than it took
to lift the eyebrow of censure, she had surrounded herself with a mob of
laughing, delighted boys, and exacted a penny from each of them for the
privilege of a chew at her gum. There was never a dull moment, with
Jerry around.

Sarah was another sort. She had burst upon Joy in a flash of colour that
rioted away analytical estimation. Such eyes, lips, cheeks—and
wonderfully marcelled hair. Later, when Sarah’s tools were set out on
the one bureau, revelation had forced analysis. Yes, Sarah was
undoubtedly a Woman of the World. She oozed sophistication at every
pore. As crowning touch, she even had a gold cigarette case!

“Well, I _feel_ shot,” Joy said now in answer to Jerry’s comment. “This
is my first Prom, you know.”

“So you have remarked, several times,” drawled Sarah. “Let me give you a
tip, my dear—I wouldn’t admit anything like that so freely. Numbers,”
continued the highly-coloured one, “are dangerous. Now, as for me—I
wouldn’t admit that this was my first or my thirty-first.”

“The last number is more your speed, old girl,” said Jerry.

“But what is one to say?” Joy asked, stepping out of her dress.
“Everyone is just lovely to me when I tell ’em it’s my first.”

The two on the bed exchanged glances. Jerry blew out a cloud of smoke.
“That’s one way of starting a conversation,” she said generously.

Joy sat down on the floor and pulled off her silver slippers. Once
freed, her feet hurt more than ever.

“Wait till you get callouses all over your feet,” said Jerry. “Enough
steady all-night dancing does it. After that, you don’t mind anything.”

Sarah considered the tip of her cigarette. “I wonder if those wrecks
have dusted themselves off and gone home yet,” she murmured. “We’ve
roosted here long enough.”

“I’ll go out and potter around.” Jerry put out her cigarette, threw it
in the wastebasket, and was gone from the room in one fell swoop.

“The men have almost all gone home,” Joy volunteered. “I was late coming
up, because I looked for the chaperones to say good-night, but I
couldn’t find any of them.”

Sarah smiled. “I guess you couldn’t. They pull in at midnight. This life
would be too much for them if they didn’t.”

“They pull in at midnight! Well, what are they for?”

“My dear, I’ve often wondered.” She flicked her ash daintily on to Joy’s
cot. Jerry came bounding back into the room.

“They’ve gone, Sally! We can get away all right!” and she proceeded to
pull on her evening coat.

“Why?” Joy stammered her amazement.

“We’re going riding,” Jerry explained. “We had to wait until our men had
gone, because we’re going with some others.”

“There’s just one thing!” Sarah had not stirred from her perch on the
bed. “Are they too stewed for us to go with them, or are they only
edged? I’d like to know before we start. I haven’t any desire to drive
over a hundred miles with a couple of boiled owls. Remember that time at
Yale, Jerry——”

“I know—my back teeth are loose yet. Some smash. But this time they’re
taking a Freshman along who’s been kept sober for the occasion, so
you’re safe.”

“Oh, in that case,” Sarah descended from the bed and allowed Jerry to
press her into her evening wrap. “Good-bye, my dear—we’ll see you in
the morning.”

As she watched them depart, Joy almost forgot how tired she was.
Half-past four in the morning—and they were going riding. She limped
over to the bureau and looked down at Sarah’s tools. She had never seen
girls like these. They did not seem to care what they did. And the way
they talked—you could not pick out any one thing, but it did not sound
_nice_, somehow.

But Jerry was fascinating—and one was never bored. Perhaps that was why
they were all right. She turned off the light and felt her way back to
her cot over a succession of wardrobe trunks and hat boxes.

Once in bed, sleep was impossible with the whirl of new events playing
in kaleidoscopic glitter across a mind that was not used to so much
colour and certainly not much glitter. Her first Prom. How thrilled she
had been when Tom had asked her. Of course, there was no thrill to Tom,
as she had known him all her life. But since she lived in a typical New
England town where the always increasing numbers of boys were weary of
trying to balance themselves against the always increasing numbers of
girls, it was somewhat of an honour for him to single her out from all
the rest. She had never been outside of Foxhollow Corners before. This
was not as strange as it would have been had she come from any part of
the country but New England. She had simply never made the occasion; nor
had the occasion been made for her to go. Most providentially, there had
been a very good boarding school in Foxhollow Corners, at which she had
been a day pupil. And during the war there had been too much
Red-Crossing to do, too much to keep her nose to the grindstone at
Foxhollow Corners, to think of the travel that the enterprise of service
might have meant to her. And this was her first Prom, and all the girls
at home were green, simply green. Tom had taken some of them in times
past and probably would continue to vary his program thus. “Don’t
encourage the girls too much,” was his motto.

The first day of Prom had passed in a shimmer. The girls were, for the
most part, strange, exotic creatures—something of Sarah’s vintage—but
the men were of varied types. It was odd, Joy reflected, that such
different boys should all, or nearly all, ask the same type of girl.
There was one man—one particular man—Joy was at the age where there
always had to be one particular man in her dreams—and this man seemed
to have stepped right out of them made to order. In the first place, he
was the best looking man she had ever seen—tall and very dark, with
eyes that, when he smiled, grew tender. Tom had said that he was “a big
man in college,” a star at football, and a “regular all-around prince.”
His name was Jack Barnett, and although he had no girl at Prom, all the
girls seemed to know him. He had cut in on Joy several times, and she
still tingled from the thrill of it. Every girl knows the taking-stock
preliminary to sleep after a dance. “Did he mean that? Or was he only
handing a line. Did I show too much that I liked him? And is it his move
now, or mine?” Joy lost herself in a dream that the football hero had
cut in on her again and wouldn’t let anyone else dance with her.

She was awakened by a queer thumping noise. Pushing open her eyes,
through a just-alive-to-the-world haze she saw Jerry doing handsprings
about the room. Determined not to appear surprised at anything more, she
sat up in bed and surveyed her with a thin glaze of calmness.

“Ow!” said Jerry conversationally, as she knocked up against a trunk and
came to a full stop. Then, sitting up and rubbing her elbows: “Oh,
hello; you awake? Hope I didn’t disturb you, or anything. I’m waking
myself up; I’ve found this is the best way to keep me going, when I
haven’t had any sleep.”

“Do you mean to say that you haven’t had any sleep at all?”

“Right the first time! We just got back—had a blow-out, of course, and
now it’s too late to take in any classes!” Jerry began to change her
raiment. “Look at that——” and she pointed to the bed. Sarah lay on it,
evening coat and all, just as she had fallen.

“Why,” said Joy, “she almost looks as if she had fallen asleep before
she landed there.”

Jerry executed a pas seul, stepping through a hatbox with careless ease.
“You hit your head on the nail that time! She always passes out that
way—got no more starch in her throat—she’ll have to come out of it,
too, because our little playmates who are blowing us to this Prom will
be here soon, and they’ll get noisy if we don’t put in a swift
appearance.” She came up to the still figure on the bed, and shook it.
Joy admired the vivid red of her cheeks. There was no artificiality
about Jerry. Her face was fairly blazing; and what was more remarkable
after a sleepless night, her eyes were very bright. On second
inspection, they were even shiny. After a prolonged shaking, Sarah fell
limp from her hands.

“Why! She acts as if she were dead,” said Joy.

“Dead!” exclaimed Jerry with a short laugh. “Dead or—Sal Saunders! I’d
like to wring your neck—maybe that would bring a squawk!”

There was a faint stir. “That you, Jerry?”

“Yes, it’s me, and you’ve got to get off the downy. Do you expect me to
ring for the cracked ice, or what?”

Sarah rose to a sitting posture and started to flop back, but Jerry’s
arm shot forward and propped her up.

“Where do you think you are,” Jerry continued; “in New York? We’ve got
to get down in ten minutes! Go and stick your head under the shower.”
She pushed her out of the door. Returning, her gleaming eye lit on Joy.
“It’s enough to make me weep, to see you. Why, you look just as well as
you did last night.”

Joy pulled on her stockings without replying, as appropriate repartee
did not occur to her at the moment.

“You know,” Jerry continued, running a comb through her hair, “you’re
one of the best looking girls I’ve seen for I’d hate to say how many
years—but the trouble is, you don’t put yourself together with any
enthusiasm—you don’t drape yourself accordingly. Looks don’t count
nowadays unless you’ve got push, too.”

“Just what do you mean?” Joy was almost completely at a loss.

“Use ’em! Use your face, eyes—your hair—your figure—you’ve got good
clothes, too—you just need a little _push_, that’s all!”

Joy went to look at herself in the mirror. Her beauty was not tangible,
and she had never made an inventory of its assets and liabilities. It
was not so much her hair, which had started to be light brown and
rippled into purest gold, the inimitable shade that less fortunately
endowed women are prone to be catty about, or her complexion which
needed none of Sarah’s artifices, as it was her eyes and the expression
they lent her face. It seemed as if her name had marked her; her eyes,
the colour of summer skies with the laughter of the sun caught up in
them, bathed her face in radiance.

Most pretty girls never tire of admiring what the mirror gives back to
them, but Joy had not had enough admiration in her life to assure her of
the necessary self-appreciation. She put an experimental hand on Sarah’s
tools. There was blue shadowing to go beneath the eyes, and sticky black
stuff to make one’s lashes look like an advertisement of

“Don’t put on any of that stuff now!” said Jerry. “Wait till evening,
and I’ll help you.”

Joy began to comb her hair, singing lightly one of the songs the
orchestra had played the evening before.

              “I was so _young_—you were so _beautiful_—
                I knew you couldn’t be true-ue—
              Each time I looked at you my heart grew sad—
                ’Twas then I realized why men go mad—
              You made me give you all the love I had—”

She stopped, suddenly aware of the other girl’s riveted attention.
Jerry’s careless, carefree attitude had slipped away entirely, as she
stood listening, her eyes lancets of concentration, her upper teeth
pulling in her under lip.

“Where have you studied singing?” she demanded, her voice an imperative

“Just a little—at the school I went to,” said Joy. “Why, what’s the
matter? I——”

“Your mother must have sung, then, or someone in the family. It’s the
sort of voice that sounds as if it had been bred in the family for
generations—it has, hasn’t it?”

“Yes, and gotten a little stale in being handed down,” said Joy
uncertainly. She was not sure whether Jerry was making fun of her or
not. People who thought they could sing were awful bores, and she had no
intention of being that sort of a bore.

“I mean it. How long since you’ve done anything with it?”

“I’ve never done anything with it.” Joy was a little impatient by this
time. “My teacher was the kind who said ‘Can anything improve upon God?’
So you can get an idea of how hard I worked.”

“Sing something—don’t muffle it up the way you were doing.”

Sarah created a hiatus by stumbling in at that moment. She seemed to be
fairly awake by this time, but cross and unlike her usual self. On
Jerry’s good-natured “Brace up, old girl,” she turned and almost
snarled; “Just because I haven’t got an asbestos lining like _some

“That’s your error, old dear,” Jerry retorted. “Stepped through your
hat, a while back; guess I’ll take a reef in it while you slap on your

“I don’t like this college, anyway.” Sarah had moved to the bureau. Her
face was positively gray until she started work on it. “I think the way
they treat you—the way they do things——”

“Oh, what can you expect?” mumbled Jerry, her mouth full of thread.
“They live so far away, up here in the woods, not near any city or burg
large enough to call a town—naturally they want to play around a
little, when they import some girls here!”

“Perhaps you think,” said Sarah suddenly, “that that freshman down there
isn’t going to drop a few leading remarks when our little comrades
come—unless we’re there first!” She turned to Joy. “You’re ready—won’t
you go down and talk to them—tell ’em we’re coming right along?”

“I’d be glad to!” and Joy made a swift exit. She was already conscious
that she liked Jerry and did not like Sarah. This, she told herself, was
not because Jerry had liked her voice—there was something about Jerry.
But it would be awful for her to take her voice seriously. She wouldn’t
be a real girl any longer—a girl like these Prom specimens, a few of
whom were floating around the halls now, pale and sleepy, with Magic
Curlers in their hair—hard to recognise as the overpowering beings of
last night.

She passed on down to the first floor, where things were a little more
animated. A talking machine was playing and several men were sitting
around in more or less expectant attitudes. Tom was not there, nor were
the two “little comrades” of her roommates. Embarrassed, she was about
to retreat, when one of the men detached himself from a group at the end
of the room and came over to her. It was Jack Barnett.

“I was hoping I would get a chance to see you this morning.”

She was speechless with delight. If he could have known that he had been
her last waking thought! It is as well that man cannot follow the
intensely-flickering dreams and fancies of maidenhood. The two stood and
looked at each other in a charmed silence.

“Well?” he challenged.

“You took the words out of my mouth when I saw you; what more can I
say?” she retorted with a laugh.

She was very lovely. His eyes dwelt upon her with minute appreciation,
as they automatically moved off to a corner. She only dared to look at
him from beneath the protective fringe of lowered lashes, lest his eyes
catch hers and hold them until she would have to tear them away by
force. She laughed aloud.

“What are you laughing at, you funny girl?” he demanded.

“Oh, nothing. I was only wondering if—if it was wrong to _hold eyes_.”

“Not half as wrong as some other things,” he smiled.

There they were. Two sentences, and they were skimming on the thin ice
of conversation towards topics youth loves to discuss “broad-mindedly
and impersonally.” Joy hesitated, and drew back.

“Are you sleepy from last night? You don’t look a bit tired.”

“Oh, I’m not. It’ll take several steady nights of this to put me under.”
He stretched his impressive length, which she regarded with respect.

“You’re one of these men—who the clinging vines say are ‘so big and
strong and yet so kind and gentle’—aren’t you?”

“Kind—and—gentle?” he laughed. “No one ever told me that.”

This time he compelled her to look at him, and under his smiling eyes
she suddenly shivered. An irrelevant thought had drifted in—that, when
people were as wonderful as he, they always seemed to get everything
they wanted, and—they always were wanting something else. But the
thought wandered out again at his next words.

“You are the prettiest girl I have ever seen. No—don’t speak! What do
_you_ know about it? Last night I suspected—this morning, I know.
Morning’s the acid test, you see.”

There was a clatter on the stairs and Jerry bounced into the room. She
was chewing gum again. After her came Sarah, evenly pink and white,
superbly arrayed, and walking with the carriage of an empress.

Jerry walked into the group of men, chewing in long, steady rolls. “Gum,
gum, nothing but gum,” she chanted, then looked at them piteously.
“Nothing for breakfast but gum! Can’t anyone bring coffee and rolls to
the gum-chewer? Anyone?”

“Not unless you let me hold your gum while you have breakfast,” one
romantic youth threw at her.

Joy watched with breathless interest.

“I have never seen such a girl!”

“She’s a marvel,” conceded Barnett. “Gets younger all the time—and I
gather she isn’t as young as she looks.”

The appearance of Tom in the doorway cut short further revelations.

“I have a feeling that I’m going to trail you to-day,” Barnett said,
rising. “And as for to-night at Prom—words are futile!”

His eyes caressed her. It was no moment for Tom to join them. She felt
as if something within her were singing. And Tom came over to her—Tom,
with his chubby red face and eyes that could never look tenderly at

“Well, Joy, what’s doing along the Rialto?”

“N-nothing much, so early in the day; what does one expect at this
hour?” she managed to bring out, hoping that Tom did not notice anything
unusual in her manner.

“You’ve made a dent on Jack Barnett—I can see those.” He gave her a
look of appraisal. “Hang it, Joy, I knew you’d put a crimp in all the
gold diggers and hundredth anniversaries around.”

“Speaking of hundredth anniversaries, my roommates—they’re—well, I’ve
never seen anything like them before.”

He looked over to where Sarah was sitting with her hand on the
coat-sleeve of a dazzled youth, gazing up at him with her shadowed,
speaking eyes. Then his eyes wandered to where Jerry was singing a song
for her breakfast—

                 “Come to my home in the sewer
                   Said the cock-roach to his mate—
                 Where the air is so foul and impew-er
                   And the swimming’s simply great!”

“That’s because this is your first Prom,” he said.

The day passed in swift confusion of events and men, and chattering
girls, and efforts to chatter at least as much and as entertainingly as
the others did, if not more. In the afternoon they danced at the
different fraternity houses; and wherever they went, Jack Barnett
followed, to cut in on Joy, and to thrill her with his tenderly smiling
eyes. It was a mammoth achievement to be rushed by the big man of
college; and Tom was gloatingly impressed.

“You’ve got Jack Barnett going! I guess my taste isn’t so bad—eh, what,

“Oh—he probably rushes a new girl every day,” she responded, over the
leaps and bounds of her heart, which was making itself known to her in a
strange, deliciously-disturbing way.

“Not a chance!” Tom disqualified her statement; “he’s some picker,
Barnett is—it’s not very often he gives a girl any time at all—and
when he does, she has to be a wonder!”

When the girls finally went upstairs to dress for Prom, Joy found that
even her roommates were impressed.

“You certainly have got Jack Barnett going,” drawled Sarah. The words
were almost the same as Tom’s, but her voice brought an entirely
different connotation.

Jerry pirouetted around Joy. “I like to see the blasé old Barnett, who
thinks he knows it all, on the trail of a new one!”

She came to a pause as Joy pulled out her Prom dress and laid it on the
bed. It was a fairy-like mass of fluffy-white tulle, which Joy had saved
for the big night. Jerry pounced on it and held it up.

“Will you let me add some touches to you to-night?” she demanded. “I
want to see Jack’s jaw drop and watch him stagger back as you come
breezing down the stairs! I want to see you overwhelm him!”

“I—I would just _love_ to overwhelm him,” said Joy, with a shaky little

“You’ll need some colour, I’ll say,” Jerry added; “you’re pale

She was rather pale, and somehow she felt weak and worn out. And her
heart kept right on pounding in this extraordinary manner——

“Hurry up with your old tools, Sal,” Jerry commanded. “I’m going to make
Joy into such a riot she’ll knock ’em all cold.”

While Sarah completed the vital matter of fixing her face, Jerry did
things to Joy’s dress. First, she pulled out the baby sleeves that
adorned it. Then she put it on Joy, and took down the back until Joy’s
back was conspicuous by its presence.

“Jerry——” her victim remonstrated—“there’s nothing holding me up but
these straps—what if they should give way?”

“Court plaster,” mumbled the oracle, her mouth full of pins, and
proceeded to rummage forth a supply from one of the boxes scattered
about the room. “That’ll keep your dress stuck on whether the straps
stay or leave.”

When Jerry had quite finished with her, Joy looked in vain for telltale
signs of alteration. “Why, Jerry! Jerry—anyone would think——” she
looked again at the “creation” into which her sweet, simple and girlish
gown had been evolved—” anyone would think you were—a regular

Jerry’s red lips curved into a grin. Ordinarily, when Jerry laughed, one
thought of the wine of good-fellowship, and the spirit of youth that
knows no age, but this time one was uncomfortably conscious of the
redness and wideness of her lips, which seemed to stretch into the grin
of a street urchin. There was a gamin echo to her short, faint laugh, as
she threw the sewing things back into their box.

“I used to do—a lot of sewing. Come on and let me daub your face up.”

The intoxication of make-up is an insidious vintage known to more girls
than mere man can ever believe. Few are they who, having seen themselves
glorified by the art of rabbit’s foot and cunning pencil, which presents
those too-familiar features in a new, glowing charm, can resist waving
the fairy wand again and yet again, until experiment becomes deep-seated
habit. Joy did not know, as Jerry set to work upon her, how she was
going to come to depend on the fairy wand. As she worked, Jerry threw
out words of wisdom.

“The whole point is to get everything so _you_ think it’s slightly
underdone. It never will be. And otherwise someone always spots it, and
then you never get credit for anything.”

When she was completed, Jerry pushed her to the mirror and then stood,
hands on hips, surveying her work. Joy was dumb. From the chill white of
her dress came the warm white of her shoulders, skilfully dusted with
some Phantom powder; and from all this neutral colour flashed the
vividness of her face. Her cheeks were a rich rose; the blue of her eyes
was darkened and intensified, her lashes sweeping over them, black and
long. Her lips were a blazing scarlet, shaped in a perfect Cupid’s bow.
They fascinated her. She could not look at her hair, nor her eyes, nor
her dress, very long; she had to look at those lips. They seemed almost
sinful. It didn’t seem right that lips should be so red.

“Well, Angel of Joy—have you fallen in love with yourself?” Jerry

Joy wet her lips, then remembered that they were painted, and was
completely at a loss. “I—I certainly look—much better. But somehow I
don’t like the idea.”

“Why not?” Sarah snapped, rubbing off a little of her bloom on one side.
She did not appear to be especially pleased with Joy’s transformation.

“Well—somehow—you know, bad women and everything use paint and this
stuff so much——”

“They put it on raw,” panted Jerry, who now in one short moment had
slipped on her scanty evening dress and was jumping into her stockings.
“Nine-tenths of the rest of us try to be artistic about it.”

“But you—_you_ don’t use it, do you, Jerry?”

Again the gamin grin, as Jerry stamped on her slippers and raked her
hair through with a comb. “No, it’s not my style. But I used to do—a
lot of making-up.”

They made Joy walk downstairs ahead of them, as they “wanted to see her
pulverize Jack.” And pulverize him she did. He was standing over by the
mantel-piece as they came into the living-room, and his suddenly-fired
eyes seemed to leap out and engulf her. She was not conscious of anyone
else in the room, as she came forward shakily, a little smile quivering
on her scarlet lips. His eyes were devouring her from the tip of her
silver toe to the top of her golden hair. He took one step toward

And then Tom came dashing up to break the spell.

“For the lova fried tripe, what have you done to yourself, Joy?”

His amazement was scarcely complimentary. Jerry giggled, and Sarah
tittered. Joy tossed her head, and held her coat out to him. He
enveloped her in it with an almost indecent haste, and they left for the
gym, she feeling Jack Barnett’s glance still hot upon her.

On the way over, Tom sputtered a little; but when she descended upon
him, in the gym, all objections vanished in unwilling admiration. She
was so distractingly lovely that he could no longer cavil at such means
to such an end.

For the first time in her life, Joy realized that she was beautiful; and
as had been the case with womankind from time immemorial, that knowledge
gave her power. She not only knew that she was beautiful; she knew that
she was by far the most beautiful girl there. She knew this by sidelong
glances the other girls cast at her, by the things she saw being
murmured behind ostrich-feather fans; by the critically indignant way in
which the matrons were regarding her. Up to this time she had never been
able to elicit more than a friendly beam. She smiled beguilingly at the
men she had met before, and they clustered about her; and always new
ones who wanted to meet her, were being brought up. Prom began in a
blaze of glory; she was achieving the envied distinction of being able
to dance hardly a step without someone cutting in; and almost always she
was surrounded by a group disputing as to who had cut in first. Boys who
had scarcely noticed her before now besieged her with attentions,
informing her with undergraduate modesty that they were “giving her a
rush.” One of them asked her to the next house-party; several asked her
to ball games; and many wanted to know where she lived and if she ever
ran down to New York or Boston, and if so, when would she have a whirl
with them?

She accepted everything indiscriminately. This at last was Life. She was
a real belle—the kind one reads about in novels; the only kind that was
ever interesting as a heroine. And through it all, her blood was
thumping in her veins in queer little jerks and starts—waiting for the
hero. He had been standing against the wall with the other
stags—looking at her continually—and as yet he had danced with no one.
She felt as if she had to talk with him, to hear his voice and see his
smiling, tender eyes bent on her, before she was really awake. All this
excitement was making her feel as if she were moving in a dream—except
that her feet hurt her in a most undream-like fashion.

And now a disturbing thing happened. A man who had danced with her a
great deal, she remembered, both that afternoon and the evening before,
cut in on her. His name was Jim Dalton; he was a good looking boy of
medium height, with blond, wavy hair plastered back in an attempt to
make it look straight, and clear blue eyes that had a disconcerting
habit of looking frankly into one’s own. Joy had rather liked him until
she had learned that he was that unpardonable thing, a man who was “no
one around college.” He was a nonentity—at least, he did not shine in
any branch of college activities. Joy was too new to college ways to
realize that there was nothing deplorable in this; that in so large a
college there had to be the back-bone, the unknown quantities who made
up “the college type”; she only knew that even Tom, because of his
bustling, busy ways, was an important and committee’d man; and she was
being rushed by _the_ big man of college; and the Jim Daltons didn’t

So when he cut in on her, she merely smiled mechanically, and as
mechanically allowed her weary feet to be guided into a little corner
away from the thickest press of the stags.

“What have they done to you?” he demanded, looking at her make-up and
through it until she would have blushed if she could have.

“What do you mean?” she said coldly.

“I mean that I can’t dance with you and put my arm around you without
touching your bare skin. I mean that you are painted and rouged until
you look like a typical model showing off some new undress creation.
There isn’t a single natural thing left about you.”

“Why! how dare you——” came stuttering from her red lips.

“I say all this,” he continued doggedly, “because when you first came up
here you were different. You didn’t look like the sort who gets herself
up this way. You didn’t need to. With a lot of girls it’s the only way
they can make any impression at all.”

She stopped dancing, and stepped back from the circle of his arm. “Will
you please take me back to Tom? I don’t care to dance with you any
longer, if that’s the way you feel about me.”

Great was the dignity of her delivery, but her under lip quivered as she
stood there. His eyes softened. There was something very piteous in the
quivering of that painted lip.

“Very well—but I shan’t beg your pardon or take back anything I’ve
said. Thank heaven this Prom ends to-morrow!”

It was a disagreeable incident. Joy didn’t see how he could have been so
unpleasant about her appearance, when everyone else was so exceedingly
pleasant. And then Jack Barnett came striding across the floor, and took
her from the arms of the boy she was dancing with—and they floated off
together, and Joy forgot everything else.

“I thought this morning that you were the prettiest girl I’d ever seen,”
he was whispering in her ear. “Now I know you’re the prettiest I ever
want to see!”

They were near the orchestra at this point, and the saxophone was
blaring extra loud; but Joy could hear only a sweet singing, somewhere

“If they make ’em any prettier than you—I don’t want to see ’em. It
would finish me! You’re ripping me all to pieces as it is.” His grasp
tightened and grew hot on her bare skin. “Do you know you’re ripping me
all to pieces?”

“What’s that?” she asked, still lost in the wonder and thrill of his
admiration. They were near a door, and he stopped dancing. “I can see
you’re tired,” he said. “They’ve kept you dancing every minute—most
popular girl in the room—let’s go down to the swimming-pool and sit
this out.”

She hesitated. “Tom won’t know where I am.”

“Oh, Tom!” He relegated that subject to oblivion with princely
carelessness. “Look here, if we start dancing again, someone’s bound to
cut in on me right off—and I want to talk to you!”

She followed him as he led the way downstairs to the dark, scented
stillness that was the college swimming-pool in more unromantic times.
Here and there along the sides she could see the glowing ends of
cigarettes; but Barnett led her down to the end of the pool, where they
were far from everyone, and found a sofa underneath some leafy thing
that he told her was one of the many potted palms strewn around the
place. They sat down. He sat very near her.

“How old are you?” he wanted to know. “No, don’t tell me—you might be
any age. Yesterday, you might have been eighteen. To-night, you are
twenty-five—at least that. By gad, I like a girl to vary!”

Somehow in the darkness his hand found hers. It was moist, hot; the
sensation was very disagreeable; but Joy did not take hers away. She
could not think quickly about anything at all—

“You—I never met anyone like you.” His voice was coming hurried,
breathless; there was something in the contact of her hand that utterly
changed the tone of it. “You—you’re ripping me all to pieces to-night!”

Before she could realize what was happening, he had his arms around her
and had pressed her to him in the moist, warm darkness. She knew he was
searching for her lips.

Joy closed her eyes in the palpitant blackness; his kiss would be
mysterious, wonderful.

But when it came, it was neither mysterious nor wonderful. Cold with the
shock, she tried to wrench herself free from the hideous reality of the
thing; but he was holding her so tightly that she was powerless to move.
She gasped for breath to speak, but he pressed her to him more closely
than ever, and kissed her again and again.

When he finally released her, her breath was coming in painful sobs.
“What’s the matter?” he said thickly. “Don’t you like me any more?”

“I—I—you’ve been drinking!”

She tried to cover her face there in the dark, to hide the shattering of
her idol; but his hands caught hers and held them away so that he could
find her lips again. In all her sheltered life, Joy had never known what
it was to be afraid. But now she felt a chill, bewildering fear. She was
absolutely helpless. Something her father had once said, came back to
her as she gasped there in the darkness: “A girl should never be where
the situation does not protect her.” She was where the situation
protected her. All around there were others—within good hearing

“If you don’t let me go,” she panted, “I shall scream so that everyone
can hear——”

His grasp relaxed for a moment and she pulled herself free and ran away
from him through the darkness—down the way that they had come, past the
glowing cigarette ends, and gay little murmurs of conversation, until
she came to the door and light. There she did not stop to take breath,
but fled on up the stairs.

“Oh, there you are, Joy!” Tom was at the door, and hailed her as she
came into the gym. “Where have you been? Fixing your hair, I know. I
told you it’d come down that new way. Come on—this is the supper dance.
Say, what’s the matter? You look as if you’d seen a ghost.”

She laughed, and was appalled at the ease with which the laugh came to
her lips. “What time is it, Tom?”

“Oh, only a little after midnight.”

Only a little after midnight—and she had to dance and smile until
morning. She was exhausted. Her silver slippers were stabbing her feet
in long jabs which went quivering all through her body. And the sweet
singing in her heart had gone. Joy had had little experience with men,
the youths in Foxhollow Corners preferring to try their hand at more
willing material when amorously inclined. She had made of herself and
all she did a temple, kept for the Unknown God who would surely come
some day. And from almost the first moment, she had been sure that Jack
Barnett was The One. She had fitted the mantle of her dreams upon him,
and then he had turned and rent the mantle. She had not known men could
be like that.

As she danced with different men and smiled and talked automatically in
answer to their sallies, she found herself inspecting them with a new
and fearful curiosity. Were all men like that? The thought was
revolting, but could not be dismissed. Even in the days of chivalry,
when a maiden in distress was the first to be protected—even then there
was said to be but one Perfect Knight.

In one of the spaces, when Tom danced with her, he said, “Barnett’s
getting stewed as fast as he can pour ’em down. That’s the worst of not
having a girl to Prom—got to drown your sorrows some way.”

She followed his gaze to the door, where Barnett was leaning up against
the wall and talking somewhat unsteadily to a group of stags. His eyes
met hers; even at that distance they were bloodshot, terrible. His eyes
that had been so tender—and now—now, as they looked at her with a
fierce intensity, they made her think of a dog before whom red meat is
dangled. Under his look she felt the dripping ice of horror’s

“Tom!” she cried suddenly. “I can’t—I just can’t!”

“Can’t what, Joy?” In surprise he looked down at her face, which was so
white that the spots of rouge flared out like little danger signals.

“I—I can’t stay at the Prom a minute longer.” Then, with growing
resolve, “I really am all in, Tom. You see, I’m not used to it, and my
feet are _killing_ me, and—I’m so awfully tired that if I dance any
longer I won’t get any fun out of it!”

She did indeed look tragically tired, and Tom was all self-reproach for
not seeing it coming. They went to the fraternity booth and she said
good-night to the matrons, who looked mildly surprised. Barnett was
still standing at the door as they approached it and broke away from the
stags with a lurch.

“Not going _now_, are you?” he demanded.

Joy insensibly retreated until Tom was between them. “Yes. I’m leaving
now. Good night”; and she walked out.

Once in the cool night air, with Tom by her side keeping a comfortable
silence, she felt free and almost happy. It was something to have left
Jack Barnett—and soon she would have those silver slippers off.

The fraternity house was dark and empty. It was an effort to climb the
steps—her last silver-slipper effort, she told herself. She watched Tom
go back down the road, then sat down and pulled off her slippers. She
couldn’t have kept them on another minute. Then slowly, painfully, she
went in and upstairs.

The room was a wilderness of clothes and hairbrushes, powderboxes and
wardrobe-trunk-drawers scattered here and there at inconsequential
places, and she had hard work to guide her sore feet to the bureau. Her
buoyant cheeks, waving twin flags of crimson joy while all the rest of
her betrayed the weariness in which she was steeped, drew her first
attention. That rouge must be wiped off—as the rest of the evening
could not be. She took a limp handkerchief that trailed whiteness amid
the disorder of the tools on the bureau, and scrubbed one cheek with
concentrated energy. And as the handkerchief marched in its path of
elimination, she heard the door swing open behind her.

She looked in the mirror, her hand frozen to her cheek; then became
rigid with the shrieks and shrieks of terror that were so many and so
fearful that they choked together in a hideous little rattle before they
reached her throat. For Jack Barnett stood on the threshold. To her
fevered fright, he towered as vast and menacing as the prehistoric man
who swung a club and took what he wanted always. His eyes were swimming
in red; his lips had lost the fine-chiseled lines into which they had
been schooled by sobriety and civilisation, and sagged loosely back from
his teeth.

“Ah-h!” Again that queer little rattle, that could not even come up in
her throat. But what did it matter, whether or no she could cry aloud?
They were alone; the fraternity house was dark and empty. The nearest
help was half a mile away at the Prom, where jazz was shrieking its
deafening stimulus.

He lurched forward into the room; she turned to confront him. He was
talking in a thick, rough voice that sounded as if all thought but the
actual effort of speech had left him. “Surprised, see me? . . . we’re
going to . . . finish . . . now! Girls—sh’d never start anything . . .
can’t finish!”

Still she could bring no sound in her throat. He stumbled over a box,
kicked it aside, and said “Damn!” He was almost upon her; and she could
not move, nor cry out, although what help was there in either?

Then, suddenly, a whirlwind seemed to strike the room. A figure shot in
from the black hole that was the door. . . . There was but a moment of
clashing, a moment full of the sound of flesh in sharp impact, of sinews
cracking—and then the magnificence of Jack Barnett’s body was hurled
from its massive menace and lay, a thing of sodden incompetence, spilled
over a wardrobe-trunk drawer and some corsets. Jim Dalton stood over
him, breathing fast, his tie riding under one ear, his usually
well-subdued hair going off on several tangents.

There was a swift pause in the room. Then speech poured from Joy’s
relaxed throat. “Is he—is he dead?” she quavered. “What did you do to
him? He’s so—so big!”

“But drunk,” Jim responded, looking down at the incoherence stretched on
the floor. “He’s only knocked out. Now to get him out of here.”

That brought her back to the situation. “Oh—and you—how did you know
that I—that he——”

“I saw you leave the gym; I—was watching you. And I saw Barnett follow.
I had a hunch—and so I went after him. He waited down by the corner
till Tom left you—and then went on up to the house. I didn’t say
anything to him, because I thought maybe he was going out to the
fraternity kitchen to get something to eat—but when I blew in he’d come
upstairs here—so I came too.” He bent over Barnett for a perfunctory
look. “He’s all right; he’ll sleep it off now, and won’t remember a
thing about it in the morning.”

“How can I thank you ever——” Joy’s voice faltered weakly. She had
become so faint that she could scarcely stand, even with both hands
clinging to the bureau top.

“You can thank me—by not forgetting—what nearly happened!” he said, in
a low, even voice. “By remembering it—in connection with everything

Then he looked at her, as if for the first time since he had entered the
room, and grinned irrepressibly: “Excuse me—but you certainly do look
funny, with one side of your face so red and one side so white.”

She wheeled to the mirror, and confronted her uncompleted task. Terror
had struck her white as the sheets on her little cot. The splotch of
rouge on one cheek, gave a ludicrous, clown-like effect. She laughed
shakily. It seemed impossible in the face of her comic appearance and
Jim Dalton’s matter-of-fact manner, that but five minutes ago tragedy
and ruin had been stalking in upon her. When she turned again, Jim had
drawn Barnett up onto his shoulder, and was moving from the room.

“I’ll get him to the Delta-Delta house somehow,” he said in muffled
tones—“and anyway, he’ll reach downstairs without being seen.”

The door was closed, and Joy sunk to the floor, whither she had been
impending for several moments. In twenty-four hours she had run the
gamut of emotions. She had gone through fearsome revelation of what can
seem like love to a girl and spell something different indeed to a man.
She had seen how the thrills of innocence that scarcely knows why it is
thrilling, are as tinder to the flame of desire kindled by that same
innocence. She had enveloped man in the white mist of maiden’s
dreams—and then the mist had been torn away, leaving reality so
terrible that she felt she must go mad if she could not forget. Yet Jim
Dalton had told her not to forget . . . to remember it—in connection
with everything else! What had he meant? As if she could forget. . . .
Love was an idle dream; the reality, a hideousness that could not be

There was really nothing left in life—except to laugh and be gay!

It was half-past six before the orchestra played “The End of a Perfect
Day,” and hilarious groups began to straggle toward the fraternity
houses. The sun was trying to break through the heavy mists that hung
over the valley. Jerry halted her group on the crest of Chapel Hill to
enjoy the beauty of the country below; and while everyone gazed at the
valley wreathed in delicate mist split with traceries of gold, Jerry
looked wistfully down the long slope to the Kappa Beta house. In this
life, one has to restrain one’s impulses at times—but the question that
always seems to be coming up is, is this one of those times? Jerry
decided not, and shaking off her slippers, beat one of the track
athletes down the hill.

Having thus ended Prom, Jerry did not stop to wait for the others to
come and have breakfast on the fraternity porch. No anticlimaxes for
her. She dashed in the house, and up the stairs; but when she opened the
door to her room, she paused and whistled. Joy was putting the last
stages of a brisk morning make-up together, in front of the mirror.

“Well—take a slant at Foxhollow Corners, New England,” Jerry announced,
coming in and regarding Joy with increased respect. “I wondered where
you’d gone—of all good lines to pull!”

Joy met her respect with the quiet pride of a good pupil under the
approval of his master. “Are they starting breakfast?”

Jerry sank down on the bed. “Good or not—I bite—to leave Prom early,
get everyone missing you and all the more keen to see you, meanwhile
getting some sleep while the rest of us jazz away the morning hours! And
now, when all the beauty of America looks and feels like a
dish-rag—when rouge shows up like poison-ivy in the glorious morning
hours—when even I don’t care to go through the let-down of breakfast
with my pep trickling away—to sail down like this!”

“Does my skirt sag?” Joy asked.

“No. Does anything look worse than Prom-shot evening dresses at
breakfast? And now you sail down in a little sporting model—why did I
need to do anything to you?”

“Well,” said Joy defensively, “I woke up and couldn’t sleep, and I knew
you’d all be coming in soon, and I didn’t want to miss any more of it
than I had to. That’s all there is to it.”

Jerry had whisked herself into her pajamas by this time, and now stopped
to look at Joy, hands on her hips, very much as she had last night.
“Your first Prom—and you live in Foxhollow Corners,” she said slowly.
“And you look like that—and have pep like that—and can sing enough so
that you ought to go somewhere really good and take a jab at it. Joy,
tell me—what in the name of the Seven Sutherland Sisters, is the thing
that keeps you in Foxhollow Corners?”

Joy stopped on the threshold. “Why—I don’t know. I really—don’t know.”

“Is it a man?”

“No. There are no men—to speak of.”

“Well—come back here a minute and let me tell you something that’s been
percolating through my Sarah Brum ever since I heard you sing way last
night—you won’t miss much for a second or so, these breakfast parties
are always long ones especially when the stags are edged——”

The mention of edged stags brought Joy back into the room.

“Look here, Joy, I like you. I don’t usually like girls, either. I don’t
like Sal much, and I live with her most of the time. But I like you.
Look here—I want you to think over leaving Foxhollow Corners. Sal and I
have an apartment down in Boston. I know a good teacher there who would
trot you through anything you needed. You don’t look like the type of
girl who puts in a lifetime of watchful waiting in the home town. Think
it over.”

“You mean think over coming to Boston——”

“And living with us. I’ll give you my address before we kiss this
brain-factory good-bye, and then you can let me know—at any time,

A shadow fell across the door. It was Sarah, who, completely jazzed out,
came in with hardly a look, much less a salutation, for the two girls.

“Hello, Sal,” said Jerry comfortably. “I’m asking Joy to come down to
Boston and live with us.”

Sarah wheeled with an incredibly swift motion, and looked first to one
girl, then to the other. Then she spoke. “Oh—indeed!” she drawled; and
the echo of her voice lingered forever in the air.


In a house that was a mass of Mid-Victorian odds and ends, retrospection
of the dizzy whirl of Prom was unsettling. Nailed-down carpets, red
velvet furniture with lace tidies, antimacassars and ponderous
what-nots, cast a veil over jazz, jazzy flirtation, and jazzy routine of
life—the sort of veil that enhances while deadening the sharpness of
what it is thrown over. Time seemed to have halted some sixteen years
ago in the Nelson household and rested with stationary breath among the
old family portraits, with the death of Joy’s mother—a lovely, radiant
mother, so everyone said, who would have been a sympathetic and
understanding companion to her daughter during her girlhood.

Outside his business, which was very successful, Mr. Nelson lived in the
gallant days of ’80’s and ’90’s, when the ordered world shone with smug
serenity. He sat in his study and read back into Victorian times every
evening. Joy had early learned to regard him as a figure remotely and
theoretically pleasant, like Oliver Wendell Holmes or William James—a
figure to be acknowledged and respected, but with whom she had little in

The only really beautiful thing in the house that time could not turn
bizarre, was the grand piano that Joy’s mother had left behind. It stood
in one corner of the high-ceilinged, wax-floored parlour, and Joy had
played on it and sung with it ever since she had been so small that she
had to be lifted on to the stool and held there while her baby fingers
struck the loving keys and she crooned strange, tuneless accompaniments.
Her mother had been a singer who had forgotten her voice when she met
George Nelson . . . and Joy had been told that she was the latest of
generations of wonderful voices. They rang in her mind and soul at
times—hauntingly sweet, sweetly insistent. She was the heir of all the
ages! All the beauty of their dead song was merged into her—what was
she going to do with these riches? But when the voices became too
insistent, Joy had always drawn back. She was queerly ashamed of “having
a voice.” In Foxhollow Corners, people who did that sort of thing too
much “got boring.” She wanted to be a real girl, to do the things real
girls did, and to have a Prince Charming waiting at the end of the
golden trail of girlhood.

And now the Prince Charming was no more. He was struck from her vision
with rude completeness. There were moments when she mourned the loss of
her ideal as a maiden mourns the loss of her innocence; but for the most
part the vivid colouring of Prom shut out its dark hours. She had had a
wonderful time at breakfast. Tom had gone to bed, and the stags were
just starting on their second wind. They had piled into an automobile
and gone rattling about the country, loudly singing “snappy” bits of
ragtime in close harmony, waking everyone “in time for their morning’s
work.” If Prince Charmings had gone from the world, there still was left
the satisfactory substitute of high-hearted youth who would have a good
time even if romance had died.

To come back to Foxhollow Corners was razing the mountain of delight
that had been mounting higher and higher ever since she had left
Foxhollow Corners. The girls were all so uninteresting. After Jerry’s
plangency, they only contributed to the flatness of things. All they did
was to embroider or go to the movies, or walk down town to see what was
going on, under cover of a sundae. And those of the men who were not
away all the year at college, had been put in their place by Tom as “a
buncha fruits.”

And above all, there was nothing to do—absolutely nothing to do if you
didn’t do it with the other girls. Joy played ragtime on the scandalized
grand piano, and thought over Jerry’s words. . . . Life with Jerry, and
studying singing from a real teacher! It was a thought with which to
toy. Of course, when it came right down to it, she could not go. Jerry
and Sarah were too different—the New Englander in her cried out against
their careless ways, and shrank from the thought of being uprooted from
her native soil. And when the New Englander would give way to the French
strain that was her mother’s ancestors, and her blood danced in her
veins at the thought of liberation from Foxhollow Corners—there was
always the chilling consideration of what her father would have to say
on the subject. He regarded her as something that could be put away or
taken out at leisure—and for him to find that she was outside the
limits he had given her, might prove revolutionary.

And then one morning at breakfast while she was fidgeting over her
prunes, her father himself threw the bomb of revolution across the

“Joy, my child, I have been made executor of a will.”

Joy looked up vaguely from her prunestones.

“An old friend who may, or may not, have known that it would be
inconvenient for me to go to California at this time. Yes, the estate is
in California—I shall have to leave the first of the month.”

“How long will you be gone?” Joy asked, and a little fever of excitement
began to burn within her.

“I’m sure I cannot prophesy—these affairs are sometimes indefinite in
the extreme.” He frowned over his soft-boiled egg, and the fever within
her quickened, as she began to vision the possibilities of this

“Were you—were you thinking of taking me with you?” she asked, with no
desire warming her voice.

“It would not be particularly desirable. I know that fathers do take
their daughters unchaperoned upon trips with them, but I should prefer
not to have you with me. I may have to be travelling constantly”—he
heaved a sigh—“and I would not know where or with whom to leave you.
Yet that question faces me here as well. I could not leave you alone in
this house. And there are no relations nearer than your New York

Joy’s blood was pounding. The New Englander in her rejoiced that she was
not to be torn from her own shores to Pacific sea lines; and the gay
little French strain sang that here was her chance that might never be
heaped so invitingly before her again! She opened her mouth to speak,
but the prunestones in front of her balked the phrase trembling upon her
lips. They looked so solid—so unchanging. How could she taste the
savour of opportunity, surrounded by prunestones?

And while she hesitated—a little whistle of ragtime in the street
outside caught her ear and tickled it. It was only a few bars of
syncopated lure—but it dislodged the speech trembling in her throat.

“Father—I don’t see why I—why I couldn’t go to Boston and study music
for a little while. You know I have had no one since Miss Bessie—and I
do think it would be nice to polish off my singing with some real Boston
teachers—don’t you? I could just go down when you went away—and then
decide what to do, when you came back.”

It was out; and now her fever was mingled with chills. Why had she even
proposed such a thing? Her father with bent brows was looking through
his egg—beyond.

“Your mother studied singing in Boston,” he said at last, in a voice so
calm that Joy’s mouth hung open, emotion suspended; “she lived at a
Students’ Club. I suppose that is what you would do.”

“I suppose—I suppose it is!” Joy echoed, while the New Englander within
her whispered: “Of course it is!” and the venturesome French blood sang:
“See how far you’ve come with him—go a little farther and tell him
about Jerry!”

But, lost in the marvel of his consideration of her project, she dared
not venture further.

As far as Mr. Nelson was concerned, the subject was settled. Joy was to
go down to Boston for a month or two, and he wrote to the Students’ Club
where her mother had stayed, for a room for her. Her mother’s old
teacher could not be located, and nothing daunted by this nor the fact
that it was late in the season to find any teacher, he procured a name
and address from “Miss Bessie,” Joy’s old teacher at the school.

And so suddenly, mechanically, things had been decided, from a fragment
of ragtime whistled on the street. Joy was to leave Foxhollow Corners,
New England—arrangements went forward without her aid or volition. Her
father received notice from the Students’ Club that it was crowded, but
that she would be well taken care of at one of their annexes. It was a
letter that left him calm in the assurance that Joy would be well
chaperoned; a letter that plunged Joy into gloom. The days leaped ahead
with preparation to the day of her scheduled departure. It was early in
June; she did not want to leave Foxhollow Corners, when she came right
down to it. A little while longer, and the boys would be home from
college, the gay season of Foxhollow Corners would be ushered in—but
her ticket had been bought, her father superintending every detail; and
he even rode with her as far as Boston.

She arrived at the Students’ Club Annex late in the afternoon. She
thought it was rather a dingy looking place, as she established her
things in the faded green room which the lady-who-ran-things informed
her she was very lucky to get—and the girls she passed in the
none-too-fragrant hallway, certainly lacked tang.

Then when she was left alone in the room, adventure suddenly pricked
her. At last she was in Boston—all by herself—responsible to no
one—well, practically to no one——. And she had Jerry’s address in her

She was tired after her journey—but the fever of enterprise was burning
high within her now. And while it burned—she’d better act!

She left the Students’ Club Annex with footsteps that repudiated the
ground in their swift urge. What she had been fitfully dreaming of for
so long, was now close at hand.

Jerry’s address was on the other side of the town. After a struggle with
the street-car system, she landed in front of a Beacon Street apartment
house near the city limits, and was informed by the elevator boy that
Jerry lived on the sixth floor. Details of a strange journey lower one
from fever pitch, and as Joy stood staring at the door of the apartment,
after she had pressed the bell, she was tempted to turn and run. She was
certainly a fool—yes, a fool, to come here. Why, Jerry would have
forgotten all about her by now. Why hadn’t she considered that before?

Just as she was turning to make a dash for the stairway, the door opened
a crack and a tossed head peered cautiously around it. “Who—Joy
Nelson!” The door swung open to reveal Jerry in purple satin kimono and
pink mules. “Joy Nelson! My God, I’m glad to see you! Come in here!” She
pulled her inside, and banged the door. “How long have you been in
Boston? You don’t know how I’ve kicked myself that I let you go off
without getting your address—just like me——” She was leading her
through the long, narrow hall, and they now came into a tiny little
reception room, daintily furnished in rose and gilt, but without the
fragile, uncomfortable chairs that usually go with such a setting. Jerry
installed Joy on the luxurious sofa, and then switched on the lights, as
rose silk curtains were lowered over all the windows.

“I’m glad you remembered me,” said Joy.

“Remember you? Didn’t I tell you you were the only girl I ever liked.
That’s quite a declaration of devotion, if you know me——But now tell
me everything. How long have you been down here, etc.?”

“I came to-day. Father had to go to California—and he let me come down
here to study singing. I felt lonely over at the Students’ Club place,
so I thought I’d come and see you.”

“Come and see me!” Jerry echoed. “I asked you to come and stay with us!
You mean to say you’ve eased yourself down as far as Boston and then are
planning to stay at some Students’ dive? What did I tell you to think

Adventure was knocking at Joy’s pulses. “Oh—why—I never thought you
were serious,” she faltered. “Because we don’t know each other very
well—and everything——”

“What’s and everything?” Jerry asked. “Why board at a bum place where
you can have only certain hours to practice and have to live by rules
with a lot of lame ducks—I know the kind of girls in those places,
their idea of jazz is Drink to Me Only With Thine Eyes—when you can
come here with us?”

There was a silence. Joy had not told her real reason. Of course, Jerry
had not said so, but Joy felt certain that there was no chaperone in
this apartment. And that was what would make it impossible for her
father ever to give his consent to her staying there. . . .

“Of course I’m selfish in this,” said Jerry, “even if it seems to sound
that I’m just looking at it from your side. But just Sal alone here with
me is getting on my nerves. Not to slam her unnecessarily, but—three is
a lot better than two.”

Joy thought: Father was en route to California. And suddenly she knew
she had been thinking about this, beneath everything else, all along.
Not that she meant to deceive father. But he was on his way to
California, and it would take about six days for a letter to reach him,
and how could he forbid at long distance, anyway—especially when things
might be represented quite nicely? The New Englander in her had left in
disgust. And the Southerner in her was laughing—_she_ had been thinking
this out all along!!!

“I—I’ll tell you what I’ll do, Jerry,” she said. “I’ll stay here with
you a little while—if you really want me—just a little while—and I’ll
pay you the money that father gives me for my board.”

“Sal and I get pretty rocky sometimes,” said Jerry reflectively; “a
regular income will fit in O. K. But a little while has got to stretch
out, Joy.”

Before she realized that things had been decided, she was being
transported down the hall, with Jerry telling her that she could send
for her luggage. “You don’t mind having the maid’s room, do you? It’s
just called the maid’s room—we never have been known to have a maid—we
chew on delicatessen delicacies when we don’t bum our meals.”

The maid’s room was striking to incoherency. It had started out with
some uncompromising black walnut furniture which had certainly been
compromised. The room had been recklessly done over in swift black and
white effects, behind which the solid furniture pieces lurked and
frowned. Just as Jerry dashed over to lift the black and white striped
shades, a bell rang loudly and she struck a despairing pose: “And me not
fully out of bed yet!” she wailed.

“Where’s Sarah?” Joy questioned.

“Sal? Asleep,—this is one of the days when we stoke up energy for the
times to come.” The bell rang again. “Oh, what periwinkle has the nerve
at this hour——”

“I’ll go,” and Joy started through the hall again. But Jerry pushed her
aside as they reached the reception room.

“I might as well slide it open first as last,” she said, and marched
down to the door, purple kimono flying in the breeze, pink mules
clicking on the hardwood floor. She jerked open the door, and two young
men almost fell in.

“Shiver your timbers, Jerry! If you aren’t always up to the meanest
tricks,” complained the first to recover, a pink-faced youth with an
expansive grin and inquisitive, cocky ears. “Here I lean up against your
door—only solid thing I’ve met to-day that would stand up against
me—and Packy leans on _me_,—and then you come and take it right
away—take away our only—only and sole means of support!”

Packy, a tall, gangly stripling with a roving eye, looked past Jerry to
where Joy was standing, while chanting solemnly: “How are we, Jerry? We
thought we’d drop by—drop in—for a few minutes’ bicker. Twinky has
been inhalin’ ’em down right an’ left, an’ things are gettin’ a bit
sticky over at the hall——Wait till I slip you the glad tale! Who’s the

“Friend of mine, come to live here,” said Jerry shortly. “Joy, these are
two gay young college boys. You can tell that just to look at ’em.”

Packy and Twinky, by this time abreast of Joy, were looking at her in
about the most open admiration she had ever seen. “What’d you say her
name was? Joy?” questioned Packy. “One of the best I’ve heard in a long
time. Has she got any other good names?”

They breezed into the nearest room which opened from the hall—a room
which took Joy a matter of weeks before she had assimilated every last
luxurious and clever detail. In the first place, the room was so large
as to be startling in an apartment. The beautiful grand piano in the
corner gave her a quick start of pleasure. But despite the piano, the
room was distinctly not a music room. Remove the piano, Joy thought, and
it looked as if one had walked into a men’s club. The huge fireplace,
the capacious lounge in front of it, the comfortable chairs, the smoking
sets, the magazines on the table, the card tables pushed against the
wall—she found herself commenting inwardly that there was only lacking
a billiard table.

Twinky sat down on the lounge, while Packy helped himself to a
cigarette. “Doggone, Jerry, I wish you’d treat yourself to a new
thingumawhich,” he complained, “that purple jiggum is so old it’s

“Silk generally shines, young sweetheart,” retorted Jerry, also taking a
cigarette and inhaling thirstily as she sat down, giving the purple
jiggum a jerk.

“Well, I’m sick of it anyhow. I’d set you up to a new one if it wouldn’t
look so naughty.”

Jerry’s thin nostrils twitched sardonically. “When you drop in on me
like this, you can’t expect to find a Paris knock-out,” she observed. “I
never keep anyone waiting, anyhow. Well—why this little call?”

“It’s Twink, the drunken idiot. Twink, tell your tale.”

They looked over to the lounge. A gentle snore was their response.

“There, what did I tell you?” demanded Packy.

“You’ve told us nothing,” Jerry snapped, taking another cigarette,
having exhausted her first in a few long pulls. “It wouldn’t be a bad
idea to get to the story, while you were about it.”

“Well, you know it’s nighing unto Commencement over in Cambridge. You
know, Class Day and all that sort of thing. Of course I realise that our
Harvard parties are mere incidents in a crowded life to you, but you at
least know it’s existent—what?”

“Go on, Packy,” spat out Jerry, with some smoke; “quit trying to impress
Joy with your English. If I had that line, I’d bury it instead of airing

“Well,” pursued Packy, equably: “Twink’s family are all parked here for
the great event. And what does Twink do, but do what you see he has
done. Ergo, etcetera. I got him away from the enveloping wet, and
brought him over here to shake it. You can see ’twon’t take long. But
there is nowhere in all Cambridge he can hide from that family, and the
hotels in Boston are such darn public places. It isn’t as if Twink
wasn’t well known.”

“H’m,” said Jerry. “Of course if you think my friend and I enjoy having
one of those dissolute college boys parked on our lounge sleeping it

“Twink will make it all right with you,” he interposed; “and I’ll make
it righter yet. You wait and see!”

“Waiting’s the worst thing I do,” Jerry responded; “but I don’t
care—it’s a deal. You can sit here and watch by his bedside. Joy and I
have got to dress.”

“Joy doesn’t need to dress. She can sit here and hold my hand, can’t
you, Joy?”

Joy refused this entreaty, and she and Jerry left him among the
magazines. In the hallway Jerry shot her a swift glance.

“Nice start-off your visit’s getting,” she said. “But we take things as
they come; life’s too complicated any other way.”

Joy laughed. “There’s a lot in what you say. I never thought of it that
way before—but that’s a pretty good philosophy of life.”

She went to telephone the Students’ Club. She had taken the momentous
step; already things were beginning to whirl; and the guilty feeling in
her excitement was growing fainter. Jerry was like one of Barrie’s
characters—a law unto herself. A week of this—a week only—would be an
unforgettable experience!

Much later, she went back into the living-room to find Jerry in a vivid
green georgette, giving Packy a manicure across one of the little card
tables. Twinky was sitting up, looking a little the worse for wear,
throwing in a word of conversation now and then.

“Here comes the houri back again,” said Packy, waving one shining-nailed
hand at her. “I’ve fallen in love with you, Joy. You don’t mind, do

“He really has, you know,” said Twink. “He’s been handing Jerry a noise
about it ever since I can remember.”

“Is it a fact you’ve come to Boston to study singing?” Packy inquired.

“Sing us a song, will you?”

“Go ahead, Joy,” said Jerry, putting away the manicure tools. “It’ll
keep ’em quiet, anyway.”

Joy went over to the piano. “What kind of songs do you like?”

“Slushy ones,” said Twink promptly, to which Packy echoed: “Yes; the
kind you can sit back and dream about.”

Joy played a few chords. The piano responded to her touch almost like a
human being. Jerry evidently had kept it in tune, and the action suited
her. She noticed these details automatically, as her voice floated out
in an old college song. Her voice was rich with a promise that made one
yearn for its fulfillment; but Joy did not even know enough about
singing to know her faults, or to care. There were three verses, and
when she had ended, there was a little silence in the room. Twink was
the first to speak. “Some voice,” he said comfortably. “Got Melba and
all the rest of the what-do-you-call-’ems trilling for help ’sfar’s I’m

“You usually have to pay good money and sit in a stiff-backed chair to
hear anything like that,” Packy contributed.

Jerry jumped up, tossing back her hair, which had fallen around her
eyes. “You two have got to go now. I must talk to Joy—and Twink’s
family will be sending out a search-warrant. So long!”

“All right for you,” complained Packy, going over to the piano as Twink
obediently climbed forth from the recesses of the lounge. He stood
looking down at Joy’s lovely white face, his leisurely eyelids not quite
so far down over his eyes as was their habit. “I told you I’d fallen in
love with you,” he said swiftly, “and I thought I meant it then, but now
I realise I’ve never really meant anything before. I’ve fallen for you
so hard that it’s no idle jest. You did it, you know. You should never
sing like that to a fellow.”

Joy looked up at him with parted lips through which no words came. This
was what one called “slinging a line.” But didn’t he do it well!

“You’ve got to see me soon,” he said. “You’ve got to go to the
Harvard-Yale baseball game first. After that—there’ll be lots of other
things. I’ll call you up.”

They were gone, and she turned to Jerry with comment which crumbled as
she saw Jerry’s intent attitude. She was standing by the fireplace with
her foot on the fender, her freckles puckered into concentration.

“Of course you must realize the voice you have,” she said slowly. “It’s
gold—gold clear through. Raw gold, of course—but gold. It’s the kind
of voice which, if I had, I would go through hell’s seventy furies to
train and refine until I was at the pinnacle of my possibility—which
means the top of the world. You’ve got everything to put you there.” She
stopped with a sigh. “We’ll turn in now, and talk it over to-morrow.”

“Sarah?” Joy questioned as they went down the hall.

“Sal? She’ll sleep right through till to-morrow—she’s been run pretty
ragged lately.”

The morrow found Joy more at home in her new quarters, as her luggage
had come and she was refreshed by sleep that was not disturbed until
late in the morning. Sarah appeared in her kimono, her hair in a
dead-looking braid, while Jerry and Joy were picking up a sketchy
breakfast in the kitchenette. Jerry had explained the big club-room—the
partition between an already large living-room and the dining-room had
been removed. Hence there was no dining-room, and as Jerry said, they
didn’t really need one. When they were home, they ate in the kitchen,
and as for having guests: “most men hate to eat formally, anyway. They
like to come out in the kitchen, and then we have chafing-dish parties
or sent-up spreads in the living-room.”

Sarah expressed a moderate amount of pleasure at seeing Joy, permitting
a line or so to cross her brow at the same time. Her attention was
diverted as she seemed on the point of making additional remarks, by
Jerry’s information: “Packy was here last night, by the way.”

“Packy was here? Why didn’t you wake me?”

“Oh, I forgot to. He didn’t bring it back to my memory, either. He saw
Joy first.”

Sarah’s look was not amiable. She turned and left the kitchen, muttering
something about dressing.

“Oh, Jerry, what did you say that for?” Joy demanded. “Is she in love
with him?”

“In love with Packy?” Jerry laughed noisily. “Don’t strain yourself so,
Joy. That girl never was in love with anything. She’s somewhat dashed
about Packy because he’s the ideal playmate—lots of income and a
thoughtful disposition—the combination gets rarer all the time.”

The doorbell interrupted them. “I hope no more blades to sleep off a
jag,” said Jerry as they went down the hall. “This is no hotel.”

But it was a special messenger boy to whom they opened the door, who
extended two boxes to Joy and a receipt book to Jerry. Jerry signed in a
blurred scribble and the two darted to the living-room with the boxes,
one of which was addressed to Jerry, and one, to Joy’s surprise, marked
with her name. Jerry made short work of hers, tearing it open in one
swift motion. All Jerry’s motions were swift—whether she exhausted a
cigarette in less time than some people take in lighting, or leaped into
her clothes. She held up before her one of the most beautiful negligées
Joy had ever seen—a shimmering purple brocaded satin, with folds of
chiffon floating away from it.

“I knew Packy’d do that,” said Jerry; “but I must say it’s quick work.
What’s your little keepsake?”

“Joy’s little keepsake” was a huge mass of American Beauties, with a
note which read: “I suppose you’re used to this sort of thing, but I
feel gay just to add myself onto the crowd. From—the only man who ever
loved you the way I do.”

“Mine has Twink’s card, with ‘Part Payment for Hotel Bill’ written on
it,” said Jerry. “This is what I meant, Joy, when I said Packy was

Joy could not help being thrilled—despite the fact that she thought she
never could be thrilled again. It was the first time in her life she had
received American Beauties, and the accompanying note was in tune with
the roses.

“Sal will be fretful,” said Jerry; “we’d best get under way before she
comes out.”

“Why, where are we going?”

“To find you a singing teacher. Put on your hat and fade away quietly
with me.”

There was a pause while Joy put the roses in the umbrella stand, and
then the two stole out of the flat and down to the car line.

“Father has the address of a teacher I was to go to, you know,” said

Jerry threw up her hands, whereat a car stopped and they got on before
she could speak. Then she exploded: “Getting the right kind of a singing
teacher is more important than a safe doctor! An address that you don’t
know anything about may be all right, but the chances are that the
person isn’t as good as the one I’ve got lined out for you.”

“You have one all picked out, then?”

“Well, you can try him. Pa Graham is considered pretty good, but you’ll
have to see for yourself. _Any_ teacher may be all right for a voice
that’s just a voice. But your voice isn’t going to be just a voice. It’s
going to be pearls and tears and bliss and agony and all that stuff—if
you start on the right road and no one hammers that quality out of you.”

Presently they descended from the car and walked through Beacon Street
past innumerable tall, narrowly-wedged-in brown stone houses to one near
Dartmouth Street. They were admitted to a tiny waiting room by a colored
man-servant, and waited fifteen minutes before a haughty young lady,
who, Jerry had whispered, was the occasional accompanist, informed them
that Mr. Graham could see them now.

A high, wide room, with busts and pictures and beautiful rugs; two
pianos; and Pa Graham standing at one end. The picture was one that Joy
was to see so often that it would become a part of her. Just now the
picture dissolved as Pa came forward with an old-fashioned bow. A little
man, with high forehead and silvery hair well kept on his still gallant
head; piercing light eyes which might once have been blue; a little old
man who smiled when he bowed. Joy could not respond to the smile; she
was going through her first attack of stage fright.

“So you have brought me someone, Jerry,” he was saying in a resonant
voice that sounded oddly younger than he. “She is young and beautiful;
that adds greatly; others may contradict me at leisure. But let us hear
what she can do; after all, one cannot sing with golden hair and azure
eyes, although sometimes it comes near to it.” He whirled upon her.
“What did you bring?”

Scarlet, she opened her music roll and brought forth the two arias that
she had attempted under Miss Bessie’s instruction: “Depuis le Jour,”
from Louise, and “Plus Grand Dans Son Obscurité,” from the Queen of

“Always they bring grand opera—no matter if they are sixteen or sixty.
H’m—one is for a lyric, one for dramatic. Well, I take it you are a
soprano, anyway; let us hope so, at least. Come and sing; best get it
over with. I am discouraged already. With that face, one cannot expect
much else.”

Joy felt what little spirit she had left oozing away. “How could anyone
learn anything from a man who said he was discouraged before she had set
free a single note?”

The accompanist, with a resigned look that spoke of the thousands of
beautiful airs she must have heard suffering, whipped the Louise air to
the rack of one of the pianos. This piano was on a raised platform, and
Pa Graham motioned to Joy to go and stand by it. As she stumbled up the
steps, he went off to the darkness of the other end of the room, and
Jerry sat down near by with a reassuring wink.

               “Depuis le jour où je me suis donnée . . .
                         L’âme encore grisée
                     De ton premier—baiser!”

Poor Louise with her “soul yet drunk from thy first kiss.” A shiver ran
through the words that should have been ecstatic. Joy knew that Louise
didn’t know what she was talking about. Then she pulled herself
together, floating a long, soft high note that left the air palpitant
and hushed. She ought to try to be Louise—but somehow she couldn’t,
with that man off in the shadows, and Jerry sitting so near, and such a
cross accompanist, and such unpleasant memories disturbing the thought
of her song.

As far as interpretive value went, the song was a failure. But the
lovely floated high notes, and the golden middle register, led the song
through to its soaring climax. Then on the whispered repetition, “je
tremble délicieusement,” Joy broke down. She simply could not bring
forth another note. The accompanist put in a few chords and stopped: Pa
Graham came out of the shadows and walked up to Joy. He took her face in
his hands and turned it gently to the window.

“Life and work—those are all you need, my child,” he said. “You are
going to learn to sing so that the tears will flow or the smiles will
dance, at your will.”

“Then you’re no longer discouraged, Pa?” Jerry demanded triumphantly
from her seat.

“I do not know her well enough to say that. The greater a voice, the
more work there is to do, to reach the perfection that voice demands.
And there is one thing, Louise——Oh, yes, child, I’ll make you into a
Louise, and many other things—it is not from lack of voices that there
are so few great singers—it is because so few are willing to pay the
price—the heartbreak of the years of toil and self-denial.”

Jerry rose, pulling out a box of cigarettes. It had been a great
self-restraint on her part not to light up before. “Then you think it
would be worth it for her to try?”

“Worth it!” He turned almost fiercely to Joy. “It’s not worth it if the
years of labor will not seem pleasure—if you do not enjoy every step
along the way.”

Joy felt heady with excitement. Enjoy it? Well—she had never thought so
before; but with the wail of a wronged Louise air still in her ears, the
magical atmosphere of music, busts, pictures, and the eager faces around
her, the voices of her heritage tore her soul with their insistence.
Almost as if she were mesmerised, she heard the words leave her lips:
“I—would—enjoy—every step along the way.”

And then, with the familiar puffing of Jerry’s cigarette, things seemed
to quiet down. The accompanist, wearing a slightly altered demeanour,
left the room, and Joy and Pa came down from the platform.

“Your voice is young, of course,” said Pa, “and tender. But it will
grow. It is bigger to start with than most, but do not be deceived by
its volume and think you are a dramatic soprano. You are a lyric; and
you shall learn to sing colorature in golden, matched tones. Just now
you have no nasal resonance—and not much point. Don’t believe you can
run a scale. But your legato is not bad, your high notes are good. Come
to-morrow at this time for your first lesson.”

He bowed them out, and they stood in the little waiting room while Jerry
finished her cigarette and threw it away. They did not speak until they
were on a street car bound for home. Then Joy asked Jerry what a lyric
soprano was.

“Dunno’s I can explain,” said Jerry; “a lyric soprano sings most of the
snappy opera—I’ll say you’re in luck. Of course you can do Louise, as
he said, and Manon and all the Puccini stuff, and one of your type will
sing Rigoletto and Traviata thrown in. Never Aida—that’s for a dramatic
and would tear your lungs out. And colorature is super-runs and
super-trills—like Melba and Galli-Curci. Do you follow me? If not, I’ll
fill in the blanks.”

“Jerry,” she asked timidly, after some minutes had gone by; “how do you
know about him? I—I wish you’d tell me a little about yourself.”

Jerry’s red lips took a downward quirk. When she spoke, it was in a
queer voice that sagged and paused. “I will, Joy—sometime when I feel
like it. I—I really—am going to. I’ll tell you about Pa now, though.
He was a big teacher in New York a few years ago, and only came to
Boston to retire. He says coming to Boston in itself is retiring—but he
still takes a few pupils. He couldn’t live unless he did—it’s been his
life for so long, and he’s so bound up in music. I met him first in New
York through a friend of mine who was studying with him. I even studied
with him myself, until——Oh, yes, I used to do—a lot of singing.”

What had Jerry said at Prom that was faintly reminiscent of this last?
“I used to do—a lot of sewing.” And then again: “I used to do—a lot of
making-up.” Jerry was what one might call a girl of mystery. The thought
was pleasantly exciting. Joy speculated, and silence stayed between them
until they descended from the street car in front of the apartment
house. A dashing blue Marmon was poised in the road, with Sarah and a
youth in the front seat—Sarah now resplendent, cheeks flaring pink
under an alluring veil, and dressed in a way to make men look at her and
women look at her clothes. She shrieked to them:

“Wigs and Davy just went up to leave a note saying we’d come back—come
on—we’re going down the Cape somewhere for luncheon and somewhere else
for dinner and somewhere else to dance!”

Joy did not have time to write her father that day—and only barely time
the following noon. She found herself started on a round of gaiety which
she had never pictured in her most riotous moments, a routine such as
she had never dreamed existed outside of fiction—with Jerry and Sarah
it was just one youth after another, with an abundance over and to
spare, although this abundance was never spared. Continually they
streaked around, always making up new things to do, with an airy
disregard of selection of hours by day or night. The men who made all
this possible were nearly all college boys but not nearly all Harvard.
There were New Haven men who “ran up,” and Joy was constantly meeting
men from the smaller colleges who had met Jerry and Sarah at
house-parties and never failed to call them up when they were in town.
There was also another, smaller class, non-college men who seemed to be
“men about town.” Joy did not like them as well as the college youths.
They lacked the humour for the most part that the college boys possessed
to superfluity, and their idea of a good time travelled along fixed and
set lines.

Joy welcomed everything with an eager excitement that wore her out more
than the steep hours that were taken for granted by Jerry and Sarah. She
had been sleeping in Foxhollow Corners all her life—storing up her
energy for youth’s playtime; playtime which might never have come if her
father had not taken the initiative; playtime which might never have
come if somebody had not whistled ragtime on the street. If she was
white and tired, she applied Sarah’s rouge with a liberal hand and drank
a “prescription” of Sarah’s from the cellarette in the club-room. Jerry
objected to these “prescriptions,” but since she drank more than either
of them, her word did not carry much weight. Jerry drank as she smoked;
thirstily, and in long pulls, like a man who needed it, while Sarah
drank and smoked daintily, as a girl does to be devilish.

When finally the answer to her hurried morning’s scrawl came from
California, she was thrown into a guilty joy. Evidently her father had
not read her letter with care. She had scribbled somewhat incoherently,
it was true, of her change in address to the “rooms of two older girls”
whom she had met before—but she had honestly not intended that he
should misinterpret, or to scrawl so hastily that he would overlook the
salient points in the matter. But the fact remained that he had merely
made a note of her changed address, as if she had been placed in another
Students’ Annex, and then proceeded to the business of the letter, which
came to the information that complications would postpone his return for
possibly a month longer. Adjuring her to let him know constantly of her
health and progress, he was her affectionate father.

There was no seesawing of decisions, no teetering from one course to
another when she read that letter. Beneath her relief she might feel
guilty, but it was the triumphant guilt as of the stout lady who takes
chocolate while sighing “I ought not to take this!” She would stay—for
a month longer. And then—then she would see!

Strangely enough, Packy did not appear for a long time after that first
day. He called up promptly, and as Jerry had expressed it, “reneged” on
his invitation to the ball game. He had invited a girl, Class Day, and
it seems, he explained, that one had to take one’s Class Day girl to the
game. “Perhaps it’s just as well, though,” he said, “because when I see
you, I want to see you, and not necessarily in a howling mob where I
might forget and pound you in the frenzy of the moment. I’d much rather
pound my Class Day girl!”

When Joy told Jerry, she turned up her snub nose. “I thought he’d give
you a rain-check on that. It’s their Commencement game, you
see—families thick all round—maybe he got faint at the thought.”

“What do you mean?” Joy had demanded.

Jerry shrugged her shoulders and took another cigarette. “Merely that
never in all my intercollegiate activity, have I been asked to a
Commencement, or any affair where all the proud families have come to
gaze on their angel sons—and neither has Sal—and he probably thought
you followed suit!”

Nevertheless, in spite of Packy’s “rain-check,” hardly a day passed
without some reminder from him whether it was more flowers or tickets to
some show, with always a scrawly note enclosed. Sarah waxed acidulous at
these times, but Jerry remained amused.

Her lessons she attended regularly, and found herself an increasing
eagerness to do so. There was some sort of fascination in going to the
studio and having Pa do things to her voice. Before two weeks had passed
it was hard to believe that she had not always been interested in song.
Not that there was much song about it. The scales and exercises that Pa
made her go through were horrible to her, as they plainly showed the
imperfections in her voice. She pled for songs, and he gave her old
Italian airs which required even, smooth perfection of tone and
discouraged her deeply. And then it was impossible for her to run up and
down a scale with any degree of swiftness, and this inability made her
almost weep at times.

“Colorature!” she said bitterly to Jerry, one time when Jerry had come
in and found her sitting in despair at the piano, her head in her hands.
“When I can’t run up and down eight notes without sliding!”

“You’ve got to begin slowly,” said Jerry. “_Walk_ up and down the scale,
and when you’ve got it evenly matched and pointed, you’ll run like
everything! Good God, Joy, if you get so down-in-the-mouth over a little
scale work, what will you do when you get on a trill? I prophesy a
nervous decline!”

“But when I hear of Tetrazzini—studied seven months or so——”

“That’s a thing you don’t hear about very many. And anyway, Pa mentioned
colorature to you in an unguarded moment. With a lyric, it’s not born,
but acquired—these stories about voices that are discovered one day and
conquer the world the next, make me laugh.”

One day late in July, Packy finally called her up. He said he wanted to
see her at once—to take her to a dance that night, down on the
seashore. It happened that both Sarah and Jerry were going out and as
Joy for once had not arranged to accompany them, she gladly accepted.
Jerry put a few skilful touches to a deep midnight blue satin of Joy’s,
and when Joy had supplied her rouge—she had some of her own by this
time—the effect was entrancing. Sarah would not wait to greet Packy,
still cherishing resentment at his desertion, and so Joy was left alone
before he arrived.

He greeted her as if there had been no lapse of time in between, and
they went down in the elevator to a waiting closed car.

“Where are we going?” she asked him as he began to fuss with the

“Down to one of those summer-hotel dances, where I’m staying. It may be
pretty stiff and boring, after Jerry’s parties; but on the other hand
the novelty might appeal to you, and I’ve got rather an urge to see you
in that sort of a place.”

“It won’t bore me,” said Joy; “you’re not a boring type.”

He laughed. “It’s awful to be in love with you and not know a thing
about you. Of course I know you’re Jerry’s pal, and a singer—how did
you happen to connect up with Jerry, anyway? Of course, she’s an
international character, but——”

“But what?” Joy combatted. “I met her at a Prom. Then when I came to
Boston—I looked her up. Staying with her is lots more fun than a
boarding-house. Sarah and I don’t get on very well together—but I don’t
see her much.”

“H’m.” There was a pause. “H’m—I don’t know just how to take you now.
Maybe you like being an enigma. Do you?”

“I suppose every girl likes being _told_ she is an enigma.”

“Well, you are one. I never had any trouble sizing up a girl
before—maybe I can’t size you up because I’m in love with you.”

“I wish,” said Joy, irritated, “that you would stop talking about love
so—so fluently. I object to taking its name in vain just to make

He screeched the horn derisively. “What do you want to talk about?
Politics? What do other men talk to you about? The weather? Besides, I
really am in love with you. Lord knows I’ve said it enough—and written
it—and said it with flowers—I thought I’d paved the way quite neatly!”

“If you think you’re—in love with me—well, you just plain don’t know
what love is.”

“Well, do you?” She was silent. “I’ve got my own little working idea
that’s large enough for me. I’d show you some of it right now if I
didn’t have to drive this car.”

“That isn’t love!” she cried sharply.

“Maybe not the whole of it. I see your point. There are many girls that
could get me going without falling for ’em. Sal’s that kind. But there’s
something more with you—I’m really interested in you as a person,
besides wanting to kiss you and all that.”

“Well, I’m glad you’re interested in me as a person, because you’re not
going to kiss me and all that,” Joy retorted.

“Oh yes, I am. Don’t fool yourself.”

“Oh, no, you’re not. Don’t fool yourself.”

The conversation resolved itself into a spirited argument along this
theme with variations. An old theme, but one which never fails to keep
the debaters keyed to a white-hot pitch of concentration. In this case
Joy and Packy were so intent that they nearly passed the Ocean House,
the long line of automobiles parked on the shore-drive arresting their
attention just in time.

“Well, we can continue this in our next,” said Packy as they climbed

Joy had never been in a summer hotel, a fact that she did not tell
Packy. There was an assortment of all ages in the ball room, with a
predominance of the “younger set.” Pretty girls with healthily-flushed
or tanned faces and sunburnt necks which ended before their evening
gowns began, spoke to Packy as they whirled by on the arms of equally
tanned youths, and looked wonderingly at Joy, whose white skin
proclaimed her no member of the summer band. She watched the dancers
over his shoulder. The young girls all seemed so wholesome—as innocent
and adorable as kittens——

“You’re not peeved, are you, Joy?” asked Packy. “You haven’t spoken a
word since we got on the floor.”

“I was thinking about something else,” she said—marking the close
scrutiny bent on her by an older woman sitting on the side lines. She
was rather an attractive woman—but her eyes were chill, and they rested
on Joy as if there was something wrong with her. It was the Boston
frigidity she had heard so much about, she supposed.

The music stopped, and he led her across the floor. “The girls are
losing an eye on you,” he said, “so I might as well satisfy them first
as last.” They went to a corner where two sunburned couples were seeing
which could hang out of the window the farthest, and he effected a
somewhat informal introduction.

“Come in out of the night, Betty Grey,” he added as one of the girls was
still hanging over the sill and shrieking back that she had won—“here’s
a singer—you’re always saying you never meet any interesting people.”

The waving feet righted themselves, and a brown, eager face turned to
Joy. “Oh, are you _really_ a singer?” Betty cried breathlessly. “That’s
what’s been the dream of my life—to be a singer—but I can’t even keep
on the key! What do you sing?”

“Nothing, yet,” said Joy; “I’m just studying.”

“You ought to hear her sing,” put in Packy. “She’s got everyone I ever
heard surrounded.”

Betty fairly wriggled with excitement. “I _must_ hear you! When will you
sing for me?”

Joy had no time to expostulate, as the music struck up again and Packy
whirled her off.

“Betty’s a crazy kid,” said Packy paternally. “Seems to me a girl
between sixteen and eighteen has got absolutely no sense at all. I like
’em when they’ve had enough experience to—well, to be interesting.”

“How much experience does it take to make a girl interesting?” Joy

“Well, it takes a large order, for me. You’ve interested me so far, but
the rest, like our little argument, remains to be proved!”

“I’ve noticed,” said Joy, “that nowadays it’s the girl who always has to
be interesting and ‘prove something’—the man’s duty seems mainly to sit
by and be amused. If she can amuse him, he sticks around; if not, he
drifts on to the next and resumes his attitude of expectant passivity.
Am I right?”

“I’ll hand it to you for the line of Noah Webster’s specials, anyway,”
he drawled. “Didn’t you know little girls shouldn’t use such long

“Well, I don’t care, it’s true! I’ve noticed it everywhere I’ve ever
been, except at Jerry’s. You—even you—have changed a little since we
got down here.”

The smile left his face. “That’s what I get for trying to treat you as
if you’d never seen Jerry’s.”

“Why—what on earth do you mean?”

Before her amazed directness he turned away his face. “I can’t
understand you at all,” he muttered.

At the end of that dance, Betty came running up to her, a different man
in tow. “You _must_ meet my brother Grant,” she panted; “and he wants to
meet you, too!”

Laughing, the two shook hands, and Joy found herself looking into eyes
of the richest blue she had ever seen. Betty’s brother was very tall,
very brown, and either very quiet or temporarily overcome. And at the
very first survey, Joy decided that he was by far the nicest looking man
she had met since she came to Boston.

“She sings, and everything,” chanted Betty, “and Packy brought her, and
he’s danced every dance with her so far, and it’s only fair he should
dance a little with some of the rest of us, don’t you think? Come on,

Packy, looking volumes, moved off with Betty. Left alone, the two looked
at each other and laughed. “That’s the way she always is,” explained
Grant. “Mind if we sit this out? I’ve been sailing all day, and was
dragged here under protest.”

They sat out on the porch, under the stars, and talked of various
indifferent things. He discovered that she had not been there before,
and insisted on taking her down the Promenade to the beach. There they
sat on the sand and talked again upon indifferent things. It was calm
and cool with the water sipping in front of them and the music from the
hotel faintly behind them. Joy found herself liking Grant Grey very much
indeed for so short an acquaintance. There was something so boyish and
straightforward about him, a something that was decidedly different from
the men she had been meeting at Jerry’s. Even if they were only college
boys, they had a great deal of slangy sophistication that “Grant” did
not possess. Then, too, the way he treated her was less—the only
fitting word she could think of was _hectic_—than the way she had been
treated lately. His grave respect and quiet talk of sailing, boats and
similar neutral subjects were especially welcome after the argument with
Packy on the way down in the car. And when he did abruptly shift the
conversation to personalities, it was done in such a way that she did
not mind.

“You know—I never thought before that I’d enjoy talking to a girl so

“I’ve enjoyed it, too,” she replied; and then they were both silent,
looking ahead of them at the indifferent waters. Neither knew exactly
what to make of the magnetic current that seemed to flow from one to the
other, even in the simplest sentences that they spoke.

“I know now when it was,” said Grant finally, after a little silence had
been growing.

“When what was?”

“When I felt the way I do, about you. When I first saw you come into the
room with Packy.”

Joy felt herself growing warm. How had things come as far as this—in
half an hour? She rose, and shook the sand from her skirts. “We must go
in. I don’t know how many dances we’ve missed. I never lost track of the
time so before.”

“Neither did I——” said the boy beside her as they faltered back over
the way they had come.

At the door they encountered Packy, who had hailed them with reserved
cordiality. “Where in blazes have you two been? The dance was over
fifteen minutes ago and I’ve been looking for you ever since.”

They had not even noticed that the music had stopped. “All my fault,
Packy,” said Grant. “I took her down to see the Promenade.”

And then the two stood looking at each other. “When may I see you
again?” he asked.

Joy had been hoping for those words, but now that they had come, she was
incoherent with relief. “I—why——” she stammered. Packy intervened
while she hesitated.

“You’ve got your nerve, Grant—I’ll hand it to you. But I brought Joy
down here—dost follow the trend of my remarks?”

Grant paid no attention to him. “So that’s your name—Joy? It—fits

“Let’s discuss names for awhile,” said Packy acidly. “We’ve nothing to
do but ease back to Boston, and it’s only one-fifteen.”

“You have to go back to Boston at this hour?” cried Grant, incredulous.

“Certainly. Why not?” Joy was a little amused, thinking of the hours
Jerry and Sarah accepted as a matter of course.

He towered over her, acute distress in every line of his face.

“Come on,” said Packy. “It’s only an hour’s run, Grant—less, at this
time of night.”

He followed them to the automobile, still objecting to their ride. Joy
got in the car and held out her hand. “Good-bye,” she said softly. He
took her hand, forgetting to release it as he whispered: “Tell me your
telephone number—quick!”

Packy was going around to get in at the other side, and in a heartbeat
she had whispered the number. When Packy was installed, they had every
appearance of finishing a casual leavetaking.

Once off, Packy refused to sulk unduly over the evening, instead taking
a jocose attitude which was much more trying. “Well, Joy, I might have
known you were like all the rest. Don’t you think, though, that you were
crowding things—to run off on a nice little party like that with
someone else, the first time I take you anywhere? And after all that
whiffle all the way down about how _I_ couldn’t get away with it——”

Joy was stunned. She paused and weighed her words, searching for
thoughts that would reach his point of view. “Coming down, you talked in
a way that made me doubt whether I would ever go out with you again.
Now, you are merely clinching my determination.”

To her stupefaction, he immediately grew humble. “Oh, Joy, I’ll swallow
everything I said. You—you can’t blame me, though. I—I know so little
about you—and I’m so crazy about you. Doesn’t that make absolutely no

“Why should it?” she asked wearily.

“That fellow Grant Grey isn’t lingering in your mind, is he? He’s all
right, but O, so stiff, Joy. Typical Bostonese family—mother’s the
Gorgon of the beach. Now listen—Joy—I may be crazy about you, but I’m
willing to wait if there’s any danger about mixing the drinks. Yes, I’ll
wait. I won’t say any more to-night—you can sleep all the rest of the
way home, providing you don’t snore. A girl ought never to get so tired
as you and Jerry and Sal—bound to snore when you get that way—nothing
more unromantic.”

Joy counted every mile, she was so anxious to get back home and into her
black walnut bed. When they finally drew up in front of the apartment
house, she gave a sigh of relief. Packy laughed:

“I don’t blame you,” he said. “I’ve been rotten to-night, Joy—but next
time I’m absolutely the genuine blue-ribbon Pomeranian. I told you—I
can wait any reasonable length of time.”

He left her at the door of the apartment, and she flew in, eager to talk
the evening over with Jerry. But they also had evidently motored afar
for their party, and had not come in yet. She went to the cellarette and
poured herself out a small “prescription,” making a wry face as she did
so. Not long ago she would have recoiled at the idea of taking liquor.
Now, ever since Sarah had first shown her how some drinks would brace
her if she felt dead, and others would send her off to sleep if she had
time to sleep some unexpected hour and couldn’t, she had come to look
upon alcohol as a friend in need. Her father would think this horrible.
And what would the family portraits think?—The thought trickled away as
the liquor went down her throat, and she reviewed the events of the
evening. Packy had been a great disappointment, adding to her growing
cynicism about men. But were all men so—materialistic? She poured
herself another glass, reaching for a more suitable phrase. Not
materialistic, necessarily; rather, “of the earth, earthy.” Were
they—all? She thought of Grant Grey, seeing again the clear eyes that
seemed a reflection of his young boy’s soul. No, not all men were like
Packy. A wave of feeling swept over her, so strong that she was left
trembling. She must see Grant again—soon!

The wave passed, leaving her limp, a questioning almost of terror
knocking at her pulse. _How could she feel so, about a man she had just


” Look at that sailboat,” said Grant Grey.

“Yes,” said Joy contentedly.

The two were sitting on the piazza of the Grey’s summer home, which
fronted the beach.

It had not been Grant who had finally called Joy up, but Betty, all
thrills and eagerness. She asked Joy to come down for the week-end—“and
Grant wants you to come, too!” she added, as if that settled it.

It had.

Sarah was frankly envious, Jerry rejoiced, at her invitation.

“You’ll get some rest,” said Jerry; “you never do here.”

“I wish _we_ could get away,” Sarah grumbled; “I get so sick of summer
in the city.”

“Why don’t you go somewhere for a few weeks?”

Jerry shrugged her shoulders, and knocked the ashes off her cigarette.
“No funds, as the banks tell me constantly. I have to stick around town
and do a little work once in awhile.”


Jerry laughed. “It’s time I took in washing on the side again. I am not
a young lady of independent means.”

Sarah gave forth a groan. “Oh, dear, Jerry, are you going to start

“Must, my lady, the situation spells must, if I am to continue to buy
our delicatessen breakfasts. At times, food seems scarcely worth while
to me.”

“It seems to me,” said Joy, “that we are pretty extravagant for people
having no visible income.”

“How?” demanded Sarah. “We hardly ever buy any meals except

“But look at the stuff we drink and pass around—so far as I can see,
keeping the cellarette filled is as expensive as running a free bar——”

“Little one,” Jerry drawled, “our cellarette is endowed. Some day when I
have a lot of time I’ll take you around to the wine closet and tell you
the names of who has contributed to which. To send a case of spirits to
a young lady was ever a delicate mark of attention. We had a wonderful
collection this spring, and before the first of July—don’t you remember
the cases and cases of supplies that were pouring in around then? We
have to go easy on those Prohibition allotments, though. The donors
collect on them every once in so often.”

Joy realized that she was learning something new every day. She
travelled down to the Grey’s in a rather sombre frame of mind. Her
father had returned home and she had just escaped his descending upon
her on the way by business necessity which had made him haste on through
and write her, wishing her to return as soon as she could. She had
written him that she was at a critical period in voice-placing and did
not want to leave her teacher just now, especially when she was so lucky
as to have him in Boston during the summer. It was true, she was going
through a critical period in voice placing. In spite of her irregular
hours, under Pa Graham’s magical touch and through the scales she
practised regularly, her voice was coming forth in a way that now
bewildered her, now filled her with an exultant sense of power. But the
moments of exultation were few and far between. It was baffling to let
loose one pure, golden note, and while yet tingling from the joy of it,
to follow it with half a dozen that were edgy, or swallowed, or had a
thread in them—there seemed to be no end to the variety of ways one
could defeat tone production. She had just achieved sufficient grasp in
the art of singing to know how little she knew, and instead of
discouraging her as it might have at first, she was lured on and
stimulated to further endeavour. She was right not to leave Pa,—but she
knew that was not the real reason she had signified her wish to remain
in Boston. Was it this boy—this boy whom she had seen only once? She
ought to know by this time how transient her fancies were. But this was
so different from her other affair. She knew more about men now.

Betty met her at the station in a little runabout, and had driven away
the flurry in Joy’s brain with her eager chatter. Grant had been
intending to come to the station, too, she informed her; but at the last
minute Mrs. Grey had found a number of things for him to do. Grant
humoured mother a lot. Betty didn’t believe in it; encourage mothers too
much, and they’ll expect everything of you.

It had been a shock to meet Mrs. Grey. She was the woman who surveyed
Joy so critically the night of the dance. A tall, large woman, with
independent demeanor, marcelled white hair and snapping eyes still
almost as blue as Grant’s. She was gracious, but far from cordial. Very
little appeared to escape the scrutiny of those eyes, and she made Joy
feel exceedingly uncomfortable. Joy remembered what Packy had said:
“Mother’s the Gorgon of the beach;” she decided that Packy had great
descriptive powers. Mrs. Grey inspired the “what-have-I-done-anyway”
feeling in one. Mr. Grey was only a shade more approachable. He seemed
to consider Joy Betty’s age, to be talked to as such at convenient
moments, and ignored as such most of the time.

Immediately upon arriving, Joy had had to dress for dinner, which was an
absurdly formal meal for a beach house, and then after dinner the whole
family had gone for a moonlight sail. She had no moment alone with
Grant, and both were silent most of the evening, acutely conscious of
each other’s presence, while Betty chattered and Mr. and Mrs. Grey
admired the light effects of the moon on the water, and spoke of art and
science and other impersonally interesting subjects to which none of the
three young people listened.

Betty came in while Joy was undressing, her eyes dancing with
excitement. “Joy—mother thinks Grant’s crazy about you—I heard her
tell father. Do you think so? It would be so screaming! He never gets
that way!”

“I think so? Why, Betty——”

“Well—can’t you always tell when a man’s crazy about you? I can!”

Joy laughed hysterically. “Maybe I haven’t had as much experience as
you, Betty,” she suggested.

After Betty had gone, something happened that terrified her. For no
concrete reason she burst into tears, and the more she cried, the more
hysterical she became at the thought that she was crying with no
apparent reason. Of course, she was very much excited. And her nerves
were pretty raw, and she had not had the usual “prescription” with which
to deaden them. But it couldn’t be because she had no recourse to
alcohol that she felt this way. That was the way only awful people got,
and after they had been drinking for years and years and years! She
finally fell into a tear-tinted slumber, from which she awoke barely in
time for breakfast.

And now she and Grant found themselves miraculously left alone. Betty
had gone to play tennis with some friends, and to Joy’s stupefaction,
Mr. and Mrs. Grey had motored up to town together. And so the two sat on
the piazza, still wrapped in an anticipatory silence.

They watched the sailboat out of sight, then Grant turned to her. “I
say—let’s get away from everything. Let’s take the roadster and some
lunch and go way off into the country—will you?”

There are few perfect days in life that stand out golden, untarnished,
with no flaws or worrisome little details to bar the way of loving
memory; but that Saturday was one for Joy. As they rode far into the
country, past orchards and immaculate white New England farmhouses, the
hours seemed to be resting motionless, while they talked aimlessly and
with long, happy silences, shyly sitting as near together as they dared.
Time, as well as everything else, had gone away and left them alone.

They ate beside a pebble-hindered brook, with tall trees gossiping above
them. There were not even mosquitoes to hum their way through the
rainbow haze in which the two were lingering. A large and elaborate
repast had been put up for them, but Joy could not eat. He, too, seemed
to find difficulty in raising any enthusiasm over the luncheon, and
looked at her instead. Finally they gravely repacked the almost
unimpaired repast, then looked at each other over the basket. Because
they were young and American, they laughed.

“It’s too hot to eat now,” said Grant, recovering hastily; “we’ll take
out the basket again later, when we get hungry.”

“That’s what I thought, too,” said Joy, with dancing eyes.

It was so peaceful by the brook; she had not realised how the hectic
life in the apartment had been wearing upon her. She closed her eyes
with a little shiver of ecstasy. “Let’s stay here a little while,” she
said. “It’s nice under the trees.”

“I was just going to suggest that,” said Grant. “We think the same in
almost everything, don’t we?”

How many millions of lovers have “thought the same”—lovers are
distanced in tastes, likes and dislikes, ideas and ideals, as the poles
are distanced one from the other!

“Yes,” said Joy dreamily. By now they had passed into the “you and I”
stage. They drifted into what they thought was a discussion of modern
education; but he was telling her about his years at Harvard. He had
just graduated; Packy’s class.

“But Packy and I never ran together much,” he said. “Packy is a
natural-born fusser; I’ve always been more or less of a woman-hater.”

“They say woman-haters are really the most romantic,” said Joy lightly.

“Well, they usually have the highest ideals; that’s what makes ’em
dislike most women. I had almost impossibly high ideals; so high that I
was getting afraid I’d never meet her.”

Silence. A twig fell from a tree, and the two started.

“I said,” said Grant, looking up at a patch of sky through the branches
while Joy plucked a blade of grass into tiny bits; “I said—I _was_
getting afraid I’d never meet her.”

A throbbing stillness in the woods; then Joy spoke breathlessly.
“So—was I,” she said.

A blue-jay shrieked discordantly from near by, and with a hitch, they
resumed more general subjects. Somehow, when one talks about ideals, one
always gets personal.

“Girls nowadays don’t encourage men to look up to them,” said Grant.
“There isn’t the respect there used to be—and the girls don’t seem to
miss it.”

“Some girls miss it,” said Joy; “but what can they do about it? If they
object, and try to bring back past conditions, they are labelled
old-fashioned, slow, stiff,—and let alone. Respect and what men
consider a good time can no longer be combined.”

“That’s the girls’ side, I suppose. But a man’s position is hard, too.
No man wants to fall in love with a girl who is unattractive to other
men. Probably you would call that sheep-like, but it’s something we
can’t help. And the popular girls nowadays, the girls that men run
after, are spoiled by that very quality that makes them popular. Betty
says I’m awfully stuffy—but most of them seem to me
hard—flippant—and—well, unreserved. Do you see what I mean?”

“Yes,” said Joy, amazed at his putting into words the half-formed
thoughts that had been sifting through her brain ever since she had
begun to observe boys and girls together, which had been at an early
age, as with most small-town girls.

“It seems,” Grant went on, “it seems almost as if girls were trying to
break down every difference that exists between them and men—smoking
and drinking are only two examples——”

She winced. Vaguely conscious of her unrest, he turned to her with an
impulsive gesture. “The only reason I’m saying all this is because it’s
so wonderful to find a girl like _you_ nowadays——”

“Oh, I don’t think things are as bad as all that!” she said. He sensed
her withdrawal, and they left the Modern Girl to return to Modern

They started back when the sun began to gleam redly through the trees.
The way seemed shorter than coming, and they talked more, whirling
through a world of fiery golden sun. Before they had even thought of
opening the luncheon basket, they were back at the beach house where
Betty with an accusing face awaited them on the piazza.

“We’re back,” said Joy. The sun had gone, and everything seemed suddenly
grey and flat.

Betty came dashing down to them. “Do you call this nice, to go off and
leave me for a whole day?” she demanded, pouting. “Lucky mother and
father haven’t got back yet. And now you’ll have to hurry like
everything to get ready for the dance!”

They realized that she was in evening dress.

“Oh, yes, there’s a dance to-night,” said Grant intelligently.

“There usually is, Saturday nights at the club house,” Betty retorted
with fine sarcasm appreciated by no one but herself. “I’m not going to
wait for you two—here comes my man now and there’s a wonderful
orchestra!” She waved to her “man,” a gentleman about town, possibly all
of seventeen, who was boiling up the driveway in a racer, and ran off to
meet him.

Joy and Grant looked at each other. “I had forgotten all about the
dance,” said Grant.

“Let’s not go!” It was Joy who spoke impulsively. “I—I dance so much up
in town—and it’s so beautiful just here, by the sea——”

But the golden day had faded, the perfect moment passed. “We ought to
go,” Grant considered. “Mother would think Betty and I weren’t
entertaining you very well. Besides, there are some duty dances I’ve got
to work off, that mother’s been after me about for a long time.”

Joy bowed her head. What was this feeling of impending distress—it must
be only that the sun had set!

“We’ll get dressed,” said Grant, “and then we can decide whether it’s
too late to go or not.” He met her eyes with a twinkle in his. “I
dress—very slowly!”

“I’ve torn my evening gown—and it will take me a long time to mend it!”
Joy returned with a laugh, and they separated.

Joy dressed as slowly as she dared. Her head was aching—two days now
without her prescription. Was that why she felt so depressed? She had
brought the same blue evening dress, and when the work was over, even to
her anxious eyes she had never shone more gorgeously. The only question
was color. Her face was temporarily red from driving in the wind; but
she knew it wouldn’t stay, and it would leave her pale and dragged
looking, as she had been lately most of the time. Which was preferable;
to put on some rouge and run the risk of looking conspicuously painted
until the wind-burn died down, or to omit the rouge and face the
certainty of looking ghastly later?—She put on some rouge.

When she finally went down, about nine o’clock, Grant was on the piazza.
She stood in the doorway and looked at him, as he came towards her. Why
couldn’t all boys be like Grant—Grant, with reverence and purity
shining in those clear blue eyes——

“I was hoping you’d wear that dress,” he was saying. “It’s the one you
wore the first time I ever saw you——”

The first time already seemed impossible ages away.

“That’s why I wore it,” said Joy, in a matter-of-fact tone.

Neither kept the other in doubt by word or look. They looked now—and
then, because they were human, they went and ate a fairly good meal from
the lunch basket. Now there was no excuse for not starting to the
dance—but still they lingered.

“I never heard you sing, you know,” said Grant. “Can’t you sing after
eating—or will you sing to me before we go?”

They went into the music room, where Joy had already sounded out the
piano. “Singing right after a meal gives me an excuse for not doing it
well,” she smiled, but her fingers trembled as she played a few chords.
What if he shouldn’t like it? That would be something she could not
bear. Unconsciously music was already a part of herself. It would be so
hard to sing to him—the hardest singing she had ever done! “I’ll sing a
song called ‘The Unrealized Ideal,’” she said.

To most singers it is a handicap to play for themselves, but for Joy, to
whom playing was as natural and spontaneous as breathing, it was only an
added delight. She could almost hear her heart trembling as she
modulated into the song.

The accompaniment stole out—a sound as of little bells chiming from far
away—and then Joy’s voice, muted and shaky, but all the more poignant
for that reason——

                 “My only love is always near
                   In country or in town
                 It seems that he must feel, must hear
                   The rustle of my gown.

                 “I foot it after him, so young
                   My locks are tied in haste—
                 And one is o’er my shoulder flung
                   And hangs below my waist.

                 “He runs before me in the meads
                   And down the world-worn track
                 He leads me on—but as he leads
                   He never glances back.

                 “Yet still his voice is in my dreams
                   To witch me o’er and o’er
                 That wooing voice! Ah, me—it seems
                   Less near me than before.”

A pause—a little wistful interlude of tinkling notes in a minor key.

                  “Lightly I speed while hope is high
                    And youth beguiles the race
                  I follow—follow still—but I
                    Shall never see his face.”

Grant had risen and had come over to her, his eyes blazing.

“You have never sung that to Packy, have you? Joy——”

“No—I haven’t ever sung it to anybody.”

“Somehow—I couldn’t have borne it, if you had, Joy——”

A cool voice from the doorway smote in upon their throbbing hearts.
“Dear me! Have you two not gone to the dance yet?”

Mrs. Grey came forward into the room, her chill eyes dwelling first on
Grant, then upon Joy, lingering on her face where the mixed colours
strove for supremacy. “It was a great pity Mr. Grey and I were delayed
in town.” She turned to Joy. “So you’re a—singer! I rather thought
you—expressed yourself in some way.” Her eyes still rested with
emphasis upon Joy’s colour; it was almost as if she wished Grant to
follow her gaze and see what she saw. But Grant was not looking at Joy
with his mother’s eyes. “What are you going to do with your voice?”

Joy took a deep breath. “I am going to study for opera.” It was the
first time she had admitted it, even to herself. Once the statement was
out, she contemplated it with delight.

“Oh, indeed. A professional—with all that that entails.” The bleak
words fell between Joy and Grant; and although neither dreamed it then,
with the rose flush of the vanished day still upon them, they stayed
between them.

Almost without words, it was determined that they start at once for the
dance. Grant remarked that he and Joy would walk up the beach. A
snowbound glance from the blue eyes, and the two left the house, with
the understanding that they would meet Mr. and Mrs. Grey over there.

The tide had gone out, leaving long stretches of hard sand. The moon was
up, full and round, staring down upon them with friendly curiosity.

“I always used to wonder why people raved so about the moon,” said
Grant. A little farther on, and they were out of sight of the house, on
a lonely stretch of beach and sky. “Joy, when you sang, I felt—I can’t
explain how I felt. It’s wonderful, it’s—you.”

Somehow they came to a pause on the sands looking out on the moon’s
arclight reflection on the water.

“I—I once read some of Shelley—in college,” and Grant looked down at
her, suddenly scarlet——

                  “See the mountains kiss high heaven
                    And the wavelets kiss the sea
                  What is all this kissing worth
                    If thou kiss not me?”

Almost a gasp in the murmuring ocean air—and then their lips met,
brushing shyly, in a frightened thistledown of contact.

“Joy—I worship you.” His trembling whisper in her ear. “I love you—I
love you so! Joy——”

This time they clung together, half frightened at the passion that
surged to their lips.

And then a long interval without words—until they found themselves
sitting on the sand, she with her head on his shoulder, he stroking her

“You have the prettiest hair I’ve ever seen. Everything about you is the
most wonderful I’ve ever seen. Your eyes, your voice, your lips—”
Another interval. “Joy—I never knew what it was to feel like this.
You—you’re the only girl I’ve ever kissed.”

“I didn’t know a man existed, who could say that,” said Joy with a happy
laugh which died away on his next words.

“And I didn’t know there were girls like you—until I met you. For I am
the first with you—am I not?”

“I’ve been kissed before—once.”

An intake of breath. Then, before she could continue: “Don’t tell me
about it, Joy, dear—” a pause to accustom oneself to the unfamiliar
“dear”—“don’t tell me about it—I’d rather not hear any more. I’ll make
you forget him—just once isn’t much——”

After a month of whiles, they walked slowly up the beach. Their
conversation was incoherent, but adequate.

“The dance will be almost over—what does it matter to _us_—isn’t it
all strange and wonderful—your mother will think we were drowned——”

They came into the club house with unmistakably luminous faces. There is
something about young love that stands starkly revealed, and they were
as patent as if they had been hung with sandwich-man signs.

At times life seems to move in a quick succession of scenes until the
scenes begin to seem unreal, and one feels apart from the drama of
events, watching impersonally while life plays on with oneself. So Joy
felt, as she saw Packy at the far corner of the room, and so she watched
with impartial interest as he looked at them, first carelessly, then in
swift incredulity, then with a face that grew thunderous, as, hands in
pockets, he strode across to where they were about to join the dancers.

“Hello, Joy,” he said shortly. “Doesn’t take you a long time to change
running mates, does it?”

“My goodness, look at Packy, entirely surrounded by a frown,” she tossed
back at him—how easily Jerry’s line came to one’s lips.

“Is that all you’ve got to say?” he demanded, blocking their way as they
started again to join the dancers.

Joy remembered a saying of Jerry’s which seemed peculiarly pat at this
moment: “A girl never has the right amount of men. If she has few, it’s
boring; if she has many, they get in the way and cramp her style.” She
laughed. Packy was really a grotesque figure, with his glowering face
and childish remarks. “You make me feel like a dancing school, with all
this talk of changing partners,” she observed, and turned to Grant. She
was amazed at the transformation. Grant’s lips were drawn back over his
teeth, his eyes glittering.

“Would you mind stating what business it is of yours, who Joy goes to a
dance with?” he asked, in a voice as chill and cold as Mrs. Grey’s
herself; a voice with the ring of generations of Boston ancestors behind

It was the end of the dance; and Joy now realized, in a sort of detached
horror, that they were becoming conspicuous. Grant and Packy were facing
each other in the same tense, bristly pose that dogs assume before a
pitched battle; faces were turning their way; she could see Mrs. Grey
rising, in impotent protest, across the room——

A voice assailed her memory. “Is it really you, Miss Nelson?” Standing
close at hand, his eyes upon their little group in grave attention, was
a good-looking boy of medium height, with blond, wavy hair that had been
plastered back in an attempt to make it look straight—At her look of
vague recognition, he stepped nearer, said to Grant and Packy in an
undertone: “Couldn’t you talk it over just as well out-doors?” then
smiled at Joy, and in a normal, bread-and-butter voice that seemed to
have the effect of suddenly bringing everything back to an everyday
basis, said: “You don’t remember me, do you? I met you at Prom this
spring—my name’s Dalton.”

“Mr. Dalton—of course!” she exclaimed. “I remember you very well—” she
stopped, and twinkled. The echo of his blunt lecture seemed for a moment
to hang in the air. She turned to introduce him to Grant and Packy; but
Packy had gone. The scene was over, and she relaxed.

“I’ll cut in later,” said Jim Dalton, and moved away. The music had
started again, the orchestra-leader announcing that this was “the last
dance.” In Grant’s arms she floated off to the strains of “I Love You

“Hope that fellow who said he’d cut in, will have sense enough not to do
it on the last dance,” he growled, clasping her almost fiercely to him.

“If that fellow hadn’t come up just then, I don’t know what might have
happened,” Joy suggested.

“Damn Packy! Forgive me, Joy; but don’t you think Packy rates a damn or
two? Of all the cake-eating parlour pythons——”

“Your mother was watching us. In fact, she still is. That was an awful
scene to make, Grant.”

“Scene! Asking him one question. It was nothing to what I wanted to do.
At that, though, he faded away pretty quick. Joy you dance like—like
nothing at all.”

“So do you!” she thrilled up at him; and they drifted rapturously past
Mrs. Grey, whose eyes, freshly iced, followed them everywhere.

Jim Dalton did not cut in until the very last encore. Grant relinquished
Joy, then went revengefully to cut in on Betty, who looked far from
delighted to be interrupted in the midst of “I Love You Truly” by a

“I want to thank you for coming up when you did,” Joy said.

“It was nothing; I wanted to see you. How have you been? You look——”

“I look—what?”

“It’s not easy to describe the change. I would hardly have known you if
I hadn’t overheard one of those two young men—ah—mentioning your

Joy’s lips twitched. “Do I look like ‘a typical model showing off some
undress creation’?” She was as surprised as he at the ease with which
she remembered his words. Certainly, being with Jerry sharpened one’s

“No. Of course not. You look older, for one thing—and——”


“And as if—well, as if you were—unsettled in your mind—looking for
something you hadn’t found.”

“Everyone—always is looking for something they haven’t found—don’t you
think so?” she countered, watching Grant from the corner of her eye,
while her heart beat a painful tattoo of triumph against her side. She
had—found what she had always been looking for! Girlhood’s tentative
dream was victorious certainty.

“I haven’t asked you how you happened to be around these parts?”

She told him she was studying music in Boston, and living with Jerry.
This he received in a silence which became so long that she did not know
what thread he was taking up when he finally demanded:

“Did you mean that?”

“Mean what?”

“That you were living with Jerry. Were you serious?” Receiving an
affirmative answer, he fell back again into a silence which lasted until
Grant cut back at the end of the dance.

They rode home with Betty and her “man,” thus escaping Mrs. Grey, and
Joy and Betty went upstairs before Mr. and Mrs. Grey returned. Betty was
full of thrills. She confided to Joy that she “had found someone
harmonious, even to dancing, at last.” He was her escort of the evening,
and they were engaged.

“Engaged!” Joy exclaimed. “You, at your age—you don’t want to be
married at sixteen, do you?”

“Of course not!” Betty tossed her head. “My goodness, Joy, I’ve been
engaged three times already—being engaged and getting married have got
nothing to do with each other!”

Saying which, she departed, leaving Joy undecided whether to laugh or be
horrified. Decidedly, there was more to these naïve, sunburned kittens
than met the eye of the innocent bystander.

Sunday breakfast at the Greys’ was a late affair, and the table was not
fully assembled until eleven. Joy dreaded meeting Mrs. Grey’s scrutiny
again; she even shrank from seeing Grant, for in the morning sun she
blushed at the memory of things under the white heat of the moon, and
longed for another moon with no glaring day intervening; but finally she
could not longer postpone it. Mrs. Grey was presiding at the table,
immaculate and unruffled as ever, not a hair of her marcel straying from
its designated path. She enquired meticulously if Joy had slept well,
then talked past Joy on one side and Grant and Betty on the other, to
Mr. Grey at the head. Joy and Grant met each other’s eyes for one
glowing moment, then devoted their attention to their plates. After all,
it was the first real meal they had had since yesterday morning.
Conversation flitted its way about as noncommittally as a
feather-duster, ignoring the vital corners. It was Mr. Grey who grew
expansive after his soft-boiled eggs and toast.

“In my day,” he remarked with a chuckle, “we didn’t choose a club-house
dance in which to pick a fight. We chose some vacant lot.”

“We weren’t fighting,” said Grant curtly.

Mrs. Grey allowed her sea blue eyes, cold and sparkling as salt water,
to rest on Joy for one pungent moment. The air tingled with omission.
She spoke finally, as she rose from the table: “We shall hope to hear
you sing later in the day, Miss Nelson.”

A stupid, hot Sunday, composed of working through the Sunday papers,
sitting on the piazza talking about weather probabilities, and keeping
maids perspiring to bring cooling drinks. Grant and Joy had no excuse to
slip away, with the events of the day before stalking in the minds if
not the words of the Greys, and the stubborn fact that Joy was nominally
Betty’s guest. Betty remarked that it was a pity church attendance had
gone out of style; it did fill in part of Sunday, anyway. She had
suggested golf, which Joy did not play, and tennis, which Joy had
expressed a willingness to watch; and everyone had unanimously declared
that it was too hot to go down on the beach in the blaze of the sun.
Motoring was voted down, since on Sunday “there was such a fearful
rabble in the road,” and the day groaned away in an agony of repressions
for Grant and Joy.

Towards evening, as it grew cooler, some callers arrived, and Betty
pointed out that now was the time for Joy to sing. So Joy sang—not the
“Unrealized Ideal” this time, but some little French songs which evoked
polite murmurs of appreciation from the guests who were of the type that
know nothing about music and care less, but know that it is the thing to
appreciate it. And then Betty, rolling her eyes in a manner she
considered romantic, requested “Last Night.”

The room with its conventional puppets of listeners faded away; Joy was
only conscious of one intent brown face. What if all day they had been
and still were hedged about by tiresome details; she could speak to him
if there were thousands listening. Oh, to make love with one’s voice:

                “I think of you in the daytime
                  I dream of you by night
                I wake and would you were here, love
                  And tears are blinding my sight.
                I hear a low breath in the lime-tree
                  The wind is floating through
                And oh, the night, my darling,
                  Is sighing, sighing for you, for you.”

Her emotion was mastering her, so that her voice came forth in bursts of
gorgeous tone or died away in a tremulous whisper; but it carried a
quality that made her listeners look uncomfortable, as conventional
people tend to do when they feel that their emotions are being aroused
in a public place.

She ended, and there was a small moment of recapitulation before the
polite murmurs started again. She left the piano and crossed to
Grant—veiled under the general chatter, it was the first moment they
had to speak to each other.

“I sang to you,” she said; and the Chinese masks which they had both
been assuming all day, made easier by the breath-taking weather and the
environment, fell away from them as they looked at each other.

“You must always sing to me, Joy—your singing’s you—and I can’t bear
to have anyone else even get a part of you.”

She smiled up at him, seeing only the worship of the idea. The callers
stayed to a “simple” Sunday supper of three courses and “on the sides,”
then left the Grey family to settle down to a repletely quiet Sunday
evening. Not so Betty; she announced that “Mr. Cortland” was coming to
take her riding, and Joy and Grant could come along too. Mrs. Grey made
a few quiet remarks about the ordinary people who rode Sunday evenings,
but “Mr. Cortland,” Betty’s newly-acquired fiancé, arrived about that
time, and the four set off without even a pretense of asking Mr. and
Mrs. Grey to accompany them. They went in “Mr. Cortland’s” racer, which
necessitated three-in-one seat and one-on-the-floor, always a piquant

“No use taking a larger car,” said the fiancé, in a
bored-man-of-the-world tone: “everyone would scrap as to who wouldn’t
drive, and I’d have to, and I can’t drive with one arm—I can only

“Oh, Nick, you do tear off the worst line,” trilled Betty. “Come
on—take the Jerusalem road—of course we’ll go to Nantasket. I want to
ride in the roller-coasters!”

Grant turned and looked up at Betty. “You’re not going to Nantasket
to-night,” he said. “I suppose you want to ride the merry-go-round too,
and dance in the Palm Garden! Where do you get your lowbrow tastes?”

Betty played a tune on Nick’s shoulder. “Drive straight to the border,”
she told him in a sepulchral voice, then to Grant: “Stuffy old thing!
I’ve been cooped in all day till I could _scream_—, thank goodness, we
can forget it’s Sunday at Paragon Park!”

What was there about visiting an amusement park on Sunday to call forth
such dignity from Grant? It was almost like his mother might have
spoken—Joy anxiously intervened before the brother-and-sister
controversy became too distressing: “It’s Mr. Cortland’s car, so we
can’t help where they go;—but we can sit and wait for them.”

So they sat in the car outside Paragon Park, while Betty went in to try
her fiancé’s endurance on the roller-coaster and in eating pop-corn. The
time raced by as swiftly as their heart-beats; they had a whole day to
catch up with, Grant said. “Our whole lives, too, Grant,” Joy whispered
against his lips.

“To think that we never knew each other—before!”

“But—loving this way is much more beautiful! If we had known each other
always—love would have made no more impression than a—a candle lighted
in a room blazing with electricity. But what a difference—when the
candle is lit in the darkness!”

“Joy, how can you say such wonderful things? You say them
all—everything that I can only feel, you say—or sing! How can a girl
like you ever be satisfied with me?”

“Don’t, Grant—that’s blasphemy! Or something!”

“I can’t bear to think of you going away to-morrow. We’ve seen each
other so little. I’ll be coming up to Boston every day, though.”

“Every day!—Every single day? Could—could we honestly keep that up?”

“Silly girl. . . . Now you make me feel almost up to your level. Do you
realize how much we’ll have to see of each other before we dare spring
an engagement on my people?”

“Oh . . . I had forgotten all about . . . people and things,” she
mumbled and the exalted rhythm of her heart-beat sagged ever so little.
Mrs. Grey had such adequately discouraging eyes. . . .


” Pa,” said Joy, “would you let me sing Louise
to-day?—I—feel—just—like it!”

It was nine o’clock of a Monday morning; Joy had ridden up to town on an
early train and gone straight to her lesson. She had burst into the
studio, cheeks aflame, singing almost before she entered. Her scales had
gone well; her tones were carrying more point, and were delivered with a
resonance that made the windows vibrate. Pa was looking exhilarated; his
old eyes were almost shining.

“We shall make a Louise out of you!” he said now for the first time
since that first day. “As well as a tender Mimi and a piteous Butterfly
and a heart-torn Gilda! But not yet. There is no use in toying with
those airs for quite a while.”

“But I want to show you,” said Joy. “Please let me, Pa—I may never be
in Louise’s mood again!”

Pa threw up his hands and the accompanist played the two opening
measures. Joy abandoned herself to the ecstasy of the song . . . so
recently—she had been there herself. When the last blissful echo had
died away, she threw back her head and looked at Pa in triumph. He
looked back at her, and shook his head.

“Of course, you must remember that mood,” he said, “so that some day you
may sing it, and set people to dreaming of their first love. But you
must be able to take your moods out of your pocket, and hold them in
your hand. Do you see, my dear? If you give yourself up to the mood, it
gets out of hand—When one is thrilled oneself, one is rarely thrilling
one’s audience. Mind! Mind over all—or the result is artistic chaos.”

“I don’t want to sing so that people will think of my mind—” Joy
objected, rebellious. “No; but you must have yourself under control or
you cannot control your audience. Be blissful, or passionate, or
dreaming; but plan it out first; don’t rely upon the moment’s mood for
spurts of inspiration.”

She left the studio, her spirits more dashed than a newly-engaged girl’s
should have been over such a matter. The singer’s road was so long, so
hard—so nerve-racking—She whiled away the trolley journey to the
apartment in finding adjectives, none of which were sufficiently
comprehensive. Yet, remembering the way her scales had soared—and the
windows vibrated—the exultant sense of power that had been hers—the
voices within her were more contented lately, she liked to fancy—Yes,
music drew one on even while one despaired.

The apartment seemed changed. Had Jerry been house-cleaning in her
absence? There was more furniture in the hall than usual, furniture that
belonged in the reception room; and everything shone as if it had been
newly scrubbed. Ordinarily, while the apartment was not really untidy,
it bore an air of very light housekeeping. Joy poked her head inside the
reception room, and dropped the suitcase at what she saw.

A strange woman sitting on the comfortable sofa—a woman with very
blonde hair and a figure which would have been expansive if given a
chance by her potent corsets. An earringed, bejewelled woman, with dark,
hard hollows for eyes in a face whose pink and white layers gave her
skin an ironed-out look which trembled into telltale wrinkles and
creases in the neck. Jerry was standing before her—a changed Jerry in a
bright, bizarre gown of some rough green silk which clung to her like a
wet bathing-suit—her hair pulled back straight and confined by a ribbon
of the same bright silk—jade earrings lilting from her ears. Her face
was rouged; her lips a splotch of scarlet. She swayed lithely as Joy
stared, spellbound, and was saying, in a silken, rustling voice which
reminded Joy oddly of the dress she wore: “I am sure you will enjoy the
little frock, Mrs. Bowman. Florence Fay was in Saturday, and I am
creating one for her that is very similar.”

Joy felt her jaw dropping, and closed it with a click that made Jerry
turn swiftly on the toes of the cream-coloured sandals she wore on her
bare feet. “Mrs. Bowman” followed her glance, and lifted a jewelled
lorgnette to stare at Joy. “One of your models, Madame?” she asked, in a
voice as thick and flabby as her eyelids.

Jerry nodded languidly, with a swift, impinging wink at Joy.

“She’s just my colouring—better than the other,” the doughy voice went
on. Joy reacted from the blow by staggering back a step and tripping
over the suitcase. “I’d like to see her in some negligées—I’m looking
for just the right kind and I must say it’s hard to suit me in them.”

“Let me see,” Jerry wafted her hand to her forehead. “You do not wish
light colours, I take it.”

“You know I don’t.” The voice became stickily peevish, although the face
did not alter its bland, open look. “My figure is impossible in light
colors, you know that quite well.”

“Of course you are at your best in dark, which brings out your hair to a
vividness,” Jerry murmured. “I have in mind something all made up, which
is distinctly your negligée from the first moment one looks at it. But
should I even show it to you?” Her hands interrogated, “Florence Fay saw
it, and said she was almost sure she would want it for the bedroom scene
in ‘Making a Night of It,’ her new fall vehicle.”

“Oh—h, I _must_ see it!” Mrs. Bowman appealed, her neck working with
emotion. “I _must_, Madame Géry!”

Jerry shrugged her shoulders, a quick, theatrical gesture that threw her
gown into all sorts of new ripples and cadences. “Well, possibly there
is no harm in _showing_ it to you,” she conceded. “Pardon me for one
swift moment—” and she curved out into the hall, gathering Joy after
her. “Joy,” she whispered, a goblin grin disturbing her blobby lips,
“Joy—do you mind going and putting on that purple negligée Packy and
Twink sent, and coming back here to show her how she won’t look? Sorry,
but you peeked yourself into this!”

Joy went back to Jerry’s room fighting a wild desire to laugh
hysterically and completely. Would there ever be an end to the surprises
of this apartment? Sarah was sitting on the bed, hugging a decidedly
cross expression. A large, creamy pasteboard box which she had evidently
just done up, judging from the papers and string scattered about the
room, was lying beside her.

“Will you please tell me,” said Joy, “how long since Jerry has turned

“Oh, you’re back,” said Sarah brilliantly. “Have a good time? Is that
sunburn or rouge?”

Joy went to the closet for the negligée without replying. “That” was
nothing more or less than a hectic flush which had been on her ever
since Grant had left her on the train that morning. The ecstatic
distress of their first parting had keyed her up to almost fever pitch.
Her pulses had been pounding, her blood had mounted to her face, and
even the coldwater spray of that singing lesson had not succeeded in
bringing her back to normal. Her lips parted now in dramatic
recollection, as she slipped into the gorgeous purple brocade of Twink’s
settlement. It was beyond belief that there could be such rapture—

“I thought Jerry’d better play that off, too,” said Sarah. “She’s never
worn it, and she ought to be able to stick old Mrs. Messy in deep for

Joy snapped the clasp that held the thing together, and went down the
hall again. It was a wonderful negligée—it would make even “Mrs. Messy”
look like a fresh young twig of a girl. For although not yet a gnarled
old bough, one might call her considerable of a branch. How did models
walk? She took her cue from Jerry’s modulated ambulations, and swayed
into the reception room. “Mrs. Messy’s” lorgnette surveyed her.

“That negligée,” the voice soughed, “is mine. I have to have it. I
couldn’t even consider anything else—after seeing it.”

Jerry’s hands fluttered. “But, my dear Mrs. Bowman, Florence Fay——”

“I tell you I must have it! I’ll pay you twice as much as she would!”

“The works of art that I put out,” said Jerry smoothly, “as works of
art, contain in their price no relation to material or cost of labour.
My years of study and design, of creating lesser works of art—they set
the price. Mrs. Bowman, I do not change my values. For you, or for
Florence Fay, they remain the same. And since Miss Fay did not
absolutely reserve it, I might let you take it—although it is against
my custom to disappoint my patrons in a gown they have partially
optioned. The negligée is three hundred and fifty dollars, as it now

Joy’s pose almost disintegrated at this. Although not the type of girl
who generally indulges in such remarks, she longed to ask Jerry if that
included her too. But Mrs. Bowman showed no sign of shock.

“Have it done up at once, and have the two boxes carried out to my car,”
she said in thick satisfaction.

When the door finally closed on Mrs. Bowman and the two boxes which
Sarah carried uncordially to the car, Joy turned to Jerry, who was
smoking swiftly:

“So this is what you meant, when you said you were going to take in
washing on the side!”

Jerry pulled off her green bandeau. “You pinned it on the wall that
time—It’s my only regular calling now. I hold these receptions four
times a year—in all of the four off-season intervals, when the stores
are marking down—the mid-summer sales are on now, you know—and the
newly and oozily rich, like our friend Mrs. Bowman, don’t want to demean
themselves by going to markdowns—yet want to go right on spending. It
gives ’em a thrill to come here to private exhibits of ‘advance models,’
where they get individual attention from a jazzy person who looks like a
double life. Isn’t my make-up temperamental?” And she waved her sandals.

“Jerry, I think you’re—wonderful. Were you—were you ever an actress?”

The downward quirk to Jerry’s mouth again. “No. I could have been,
couldn’t I?”

Joy was amazed at the depth of her disappointment. She had been
cherishing the exciting belief that that was Jerry’s “past,” for so

“I like designing and sewing things together,” said Jerry; “it’s the
only kind of work I _do_ like. If I liked it better than having a good
time, I’d do it all the year around. As it is, whenever I see a dress of
good material marked down because of lack of style, I buy it—the same
with remnants of materials. Then from time to time I get an idea on a
way to change the dress so it will look like Irene Castle improved on. I
cut it all over, probably—drape it on Sal, who does an imitation of
Mrs. Jarley’s Wax Works while I polish it off. So when the time comes
for me to call it a week and I phone announcements to my
patrons—telling each of ’em I’m especially calling _them_ instead of
sending ’em a printed slip—I have quite a little collection of
made-over mark-downs to parade. Sal shows ’em off well, too—that girl’s
got style—but if she ever was cast on a desert island without a
rouge-box and a marcel-iron and a few other little things I’d hate to
look at her. Put her in clothes, and she crashes through. An old friend
of mine used to say, and it’s true any way you look at it: ‘Without
clothes, you can’t get very far.’”

“But how about that purple negligée?”

“That was pure profiteering. I got into the mood of roasting the old
marshmallow; the negligée was handy, you dropped in—Say, tell me about
the visit. I haven’t half looked at you yet.”

They were in the living room, and Joy without answering went over to the
cellarette. With a leap, Jerry was there before her. “Listen here,
Joy—you’ve been without it for several days now. Don’t you think it’s a
good time to begin to stop?”

“Why? You drink three times as much as I do——”

“I’m hopeless. You’re not. You’ve just started in, and you can

Joy considered the lights and shadows of the glass in her hand. “I
wonder—if it’s really doing me any harm.” She drank it reflectively,
while Jerry went back to her seat with a shrug. “I—I cried a long time,
the first night down at the seashore. Jerry, do you suppose this had
anything to do with it?”

Jerry shrugged her shoulders again. Having made her appeal, she
evidently did not intend either to repeat or reinforce it. There was a
brief silence between the two, broken by Joy, who suddenly found that
she must pour forth the story of the week-end just passed; such glowing
wonder could not be bottled up within her. Jerry listened, first smoking
at her usual gait, but as the story wore on sitting with a fresh
cigarette unlit between her teeth. When Joy’s narration finally came to
an end, she bit into the cigarette.

“Well?” said Joy. It was the first time she had ever approached Jerry
with a serious matter, the first time men had entered their conversation
as anything but incidentals to a good time, and she did not know how a
hint of permanency would hit her.

“Well?” Jerry repeated. “What do you want me to say?”

“Say?” Joy’s look of breathless bliss crumbled as a toy balloon under a
pin prick. “Why—why, nothing, if you don’t want to. I’m sorry—if I
bored you about it. But you see—I owe him to you, in a way. Because I
never would have met Packy if I hadn’t come here, and I never would have
met him if it hadn’t been for Packy—I didn’t mean to bore you.”

Jerry lit another cigarette. “Look here, Joy, I don’t want to be a
thrill-dispeller or anything, but I can’t put on a quiver I don’t feel.
This thing may turn out all right, but at present quoting it sounds to
me like a bad case of beach and moon. The whole thing has dusted along
with that summer swiftness we all read about.”

“Oh, we realize it’s been swift,” said Joy, “and just to test ourselves,
we’re not going to see each other until Wednesday, when I am going to
meet him at the Copley for dinner.”

“Wednesday,” Joy murmured. “And to-day’s Monday. Oh, well, absence at
this stage of the game only makes you keener—you should have stayed
down there a week!”

“Bon soir—a week down there! I couldn’t stand that—not with his

“I gather from what you said that his mother is a riot. Is he anything
like her?”

“Of course not—” Joy began indignantly, but the rise of recollection
checked denial. Grant ossifying at the idea of Paragon Park on
Sunday. . . . But anyone might do that. She rose, gathering conviction
about her as a Shakespearean actor whips his cloak about him before an
exit on a sounding phrase. “I can’t talk about it any more, Jerry. But
when you know, you know.”

And so for a day or two, things remained as static as unexploded
dynamite. Joy received a letter over which she wept ecstatic tears;
Jerry shrugged her shoulders at both the tears and the ecstasy.

On Wednesday evening, Joy came to her for inspection, sheathed in
defiance. “Do I look all right?”

Jerry was doing up a “little model” in one of her long cream paste-board
boxes. She snapped the string around and tied it without replying. Then
she said: “For the love of mud put on a veil or something to take the
edge off those eyes. It isn’t fair to hit a place like the Copley
looking like you do.”

“One should never wear a veil after six in the evening,” Joy retorted.
“So I even _look_ as if I were in love, do I?”

“You look—something,” said Jerry. “I haven’t got time to decide
what—Bring him back afterwards; Sal and I are going down to Sonntaug
with Baldy and his gang, so you’ll have it all to yourself.”

Joy thought, as she trolleyed to the door of the Copley, that Jerry was
peculiarly unresponsive about the wonderful turn things had taken. The
two days’ separation had made her nervous, and Jerry’s attitude did not
tend to make her less so. But she forgot her nervousness in the warm
tide of anticipation sweeping over her that she had not dared to allow

In coming through the swinging doors, the first person she saw was Jim
Dalton, in the act of checking his hat. His recognition was as swift as
hers, and he came forward to meet her. “I was just thinking about you,”
he said without background. “I was wondering whereabouts Jerry’s
apartment was, because I wanted to look you up.”

“How long are you going to be in town?” she asked perfunctorily, as they
moved up the “Peacock Alley” of Boston, the long narrow way of chairs
and sofas facing each other, with a few stuffy people seated thereon,
all glaring at one another.

“I’m working here now, so I expect to be here right along. May I come
and see you?”

“I don’t know.” She could not tell him about Grant—But what other
excuse was there?” “I—I really don’t know—you see, I’m so awfully busy
all the time.”

She had forgotten how keen his eyes were. They were now boring into hers
until she cast hers down. “I am coming up sometime, if I may,” he said,
“and if I can’t see you, I’ll see Jerry, and talk about you with her.”

They had come to a halt by an empty sofa, and now, as Joy looked at him
in a hope that if she looked long enough she could think of something to
say, Grant came swiftly up to them from the lobby.

“Good evening, Joy,” he said quietly.

“Oh—Grant—have you met Mr. Dalton—” There was no particular reason
for being confused, and showing it, but she was and did. Grant’s
demeanor, while not rude, bordered on the glacial as he bowed, then
stood waiting for Jim to go. Jim looked from one to the other, a swift,
earnest look.

“I’ll see you again, Miss Nelson,” he said, and with a negligent nod to
Grant, was gone.

The two went into the dining room in silence. It was only after they had
ordered, that Grant spoke.

“Who is that fellow, Joy—where did you meet him and what did he mean
when he said he’d see you again?”

Joy put down the roll she had been fingering. In the first keen
disappointment over the flatness of their meeting, his words bit like
acid. “I met him at a Prom this spring,” she said, striving to keep a
pleasant and normal tone. “The only other time I have seen him was at
the dance last week. I ran into him by accident here. That is all.”

The waiter brought their first course, and Grant began to talk of
impersonal matters. Why, oh, why, had they chosen such a place as this
for their first meeting? Joy thought. He had not once looked at her—the
way he had always looked at her, before.

When the waiter had taken their plates away, they met each other’s eyes
steadily for almost the first time that evening, and Grant’s face
softened. “You look rather tired to-night, Joy darling,” he said.
“Whatever on earth have you been doing to yourself? You work too hard on
your singing.”

“Oh, no, Grant—I’ve been neglecting it really—I’ll have to work much
harder to get it where I want it——”

“You sing well enough for me already—and after you belong to me, you’ll
not have to peg away at it any more.” He attacked his salad; the subject
was closed as far as he was concerned.

She was gazing at him wide-eyed. “You mean you wouldn’t want me to—oh,
of course—you—wouldn’t.” She moved her fork in and about her salad
aimlessly. Her mother had forgotten her voice—when she had met the man
she loved. She had forgotten it, in the rapture of _belonging_ to
him—that phrase had such an unpleasant sound. And the generations
before her mother had forgotten their voices for those they loved. She
was the result; and all the repression of generations lay within
her—simmering. She gave Grant a sudden alive, direct glance. This was
the man she loved and she had not forgotten her voice. How could this
be? He must teach her—teach her to forget—and not make her so vaguely
unhappy over such immaterialities as Jim Dalton.

“Hi, Joy! Cheerio, old dear!” She jerked her head up from contemplation
of nothing to see Davy Carter and Wigs Smith, Jerry’s and Sarah’s most
competent playmates, with some other youths, hailing her boisterously
while passing to a table close by. She managed a smile from her
abstraction, and fell to pushing her fork about again.

“You seem to have an unlimited supply of casual young men
acquaintances,” came from across the table in a voice that weirdly
reminded Joy of Mrs. Grey’s chill blue eyes.

“Grant, what a silly attitude to take!” she exploded. “There are
nineteen years in which you have not known me. It certainly would be
strange if in that time I had met no other men——”

She realized just that fatal fraction of an inch too late, that she had
said the wrong thing, and stopped, leaving the appeal in mid air, where
it stayed. His face had queerly altered, and the air tingled with

“Let’s go,” he said finally, in an even tone; “that is, if you do not
care to eat any more.”

She had eaten practically nothing throughout the dinner; but it was so
different from the day when they had both lost their appetites!

As they came through the dining room, Joy collided with a
showily-dressed woman who was entering with a large, greasy-looking man.
There had been sufficient room for them both to pass, but Joy’s mind had
been far away. The woman drew back and raised a monocle upon her.

“Oh—it is one of Madame Géry’s models!” rolled out an unforgettably
doughy voice. “How fortunate—will you tell Madame Géry, my dear, that I
am coming Saturday instead of to-morrow?”

Joy nodded and made her escape, walking swiftly, battling an insane
desire to shriek with laughter and startle the inmates of the Copley out
of their stodgy repose. Grant kept his silence on ice as they left the
hotel and he signaled for a taxi. When he helped her into the machine
that finally drew up, Joy burst forth with the hysterical giggles she
had been fighting.

“Will you please stop laughing long enough to tell me your address?”
Grant asked, in the same tone with which he told the driver where to go,
when she gasped out the number. What nonsense—Grant knew her address.
Everything was getting to be nonsense—

They rode for some minutes with no sound but Joy’s laughter. Grant spoke
at last. “Did I hear right? Did that—that woman say you were—a model?
Is that true, Joy?”

“No—yes,—that is,—well, I was once in a manner of speaking—” She
went off again into what sounded like perfect carillons of laughter.

“Joy—can’t you control yourself any better than this—don’t you know
how you are hurting me?”

She was suddenly quiet. “You are hurting me, too, Grant. I don’t know
what’s happened—but something has—and everything is so awful that I
can’t seem to believe that it used to be so wonderful.” She started to
sob in pitiful little hiccoughs. He made no move to comfort her, but
stared ahead of him in the taxi.

“You’re right, Joy—something has happened. I saw Packy this week—and
he said certain things about you that made me pound the everlasting
daylight out of him. Knowing you—and everything that had passed between
us—naturally I called him a liar and rammed his words back in his

Joy had stopped sobbing; her hysterics were shocked out of her. “What
did he say about me?” she cried sharply. “What did he say about me?”

“He told me—what kind of girls you were living with and the kind of
life you led—from man to man instead of from hand to mouth is the way
he put it——”

The numbness of utter bewilderment possessed her. In a choked silence
she listened to his voice droning over the rattle of the taxi.

“And then—I come to meet you—and find you talking with a man—who
seems to think he knows you pretty well—a man who as good as told Packy
and me what to do with ourselves, the other night down at the dance, as
if he owned you—and then a bunch of would-be speeds that I happen to
know are no living good, hail you as a boon companion—call out to you
in a way no girl should be spoken to in a public dining-room——”

“Where the Cabots speak only to Lowells, and the Lowells speak only to
God!” Joy murmured. A nebular recklessness, as if she were moving in a
dream, had settled upon her. “Go on—you haven’t reached the part where
I became a model!”

“Joy, for God’s sake, don’t make this any worse by being flippant. You
must be frank with me for once and tell me what to think. I never asked
any questions about you—but now I have the right to know.”

Their taxi came to a scrunching stop in front of the apartment house,
and there was an enforced silence while he paid the man and they
journeyed up to Jerry’s apartment. In the living-room they faced each
other, pale and vibrant.

“You say, ‘be frank with me _for once_,’” Joy panted; “I’ve never told
you anything about my life, it is true; but that’s only because there
wasn’t—time. I’ll tell you the story of my life now—just as fast as I
can. But first—oh, Grant—don’t you love me any more—not the smallest

“I—I don’t know what I love, Joy. Help me—help me to get back to where
we were two days ago!”

Standing there, his eyes imploring her, he looked like a pathetic little
boy. Joy’s tenderness came back suddenly, with a rush. “Grant,
dear—what’s all this about, anyway?” and she took a step toward him.

And then as the gravitation of two bodies who like to speak of such
affairs as of the heart or soul, hung imminent—a breath more, and the
questioning would have rested in each other’s arms—Grant stumbled over
something on the floor. There was a sound of glass shattering to shivery
bits,—and the gravitation shattered. He stooped to reclaim the damage
he had chanced to wreak—and straightened up again. They were standing
by the sofa. On the floor by the head of the sofa was a bottle, a bottle
of unmistakable denomination, surrounded by three friendly looking
glasses that gave forth the impression of having lived through much. It
was one of those glasses, strayed from its brothers, that Grant had
rendered incapable of further service.

There was a busy silence in the room. Joy found herself thinking dryly
that it must have been Sarah who had left those there; Jerry would never
have been quite so more than careless. Grant slowly turned and looked
about him—at the clubroom furnishings—and back down at the bottle with
those three evil witches of glasses:

“Joy,” he said, his breath making patchwork of his voice; “tell me what
Packy meant—tell me what he meant!”

“I don’t know _what_ he meant!” she cried. “You have to tell me just
what he said——It’s true I am living here with two girls who are
neither Cabots nor Lowells——”

“That’s—quite—evident.” His eyes were again visiting different pungent
details of the room. “And how in the name of all that’s fitting—did you
happen to come here?”

She wanted to beat her fists against the air—against the wall that was
rising between them. She tried to speak, but the full tide of what she
had to say clogged her utterance. “I—why—I can’t explain—at a moment
like this! At a moment like this! There’s too much to tell!”

He was moving away from her—moving away down the room. With the sharp
needle-prick of incredulity she watched him go.

“Joy”—his voice was a long way off, like the echo of a vanished
heart-beat—“I—must—think. I’ve—got—to—think.”

Still incredulous, she stood motionless, watching.

“I’ve got to—think!”

And she was alone in the big living-room.


” What kind of girls you were living with and what kind of a life you
lead—from man to man instead of hand to mouth——”

Joy had turned the words over in her whirling brain all night. One thing
alone was certain; she must see Packy, find out what he meant—what
Packy had insinuated about herself in particular—what he knew, about
Sarah and Jerry——

Jerry came in about ten o’clock in her favourite purple satin and pink
mules, first poking a freckled nose around the door to see if she was
awake. “Didn’t disturb you last night because I thought if there was any
sleep to be had, you ought to have it,” she announced.

She regarded Jerry from beneath tired eyelids, with a sick feeling of
disloyalty. Jerry was the best friend she had; she knew that;—and yet,
she knew just as surely that she could not picture Grant meeting her.
What could Packy have meant——Watching Jerry’s unconscious face, she
could not bring herself to repeat Packy’s quoted words—to tell Jerry
anything of what had passed.

“Why don’t you try and sleep some more?” Jerry was saying, after a keen
scrutiny of her. “You look dead, and you’ve got nothing on hand this
A.M.—it’s just as well to hang off when you can.”

Joy fell back into bed, and Jerry pulled down the black and
white-striped shades before tiptoeing out. From the first moment that
she had known Jerry, she had liked her. Jerry had never been anything to
Joy but an unselfish, true friend. If it had not been for Jerry, the
glory of music that Pa was unfolding to her would never have been hers.
If it had not been for Jerry, she would never have met Grant—never have
known. . . . But now—now, what did she owe Jerry? Grant had said, he
had to—think. How long—how long would he—think?

She had had only a few hours of fitful slumber—something that Jerry had
divined with one solicitous glance. Jerry had gone out and left her
without trying to talk, which might fully have awakened her. What had
Packy meant? She sank into a comatose state from which, contrary to the
will of her weary brain, she fell into a heavy sleep.

About four o’clock, she woke with a raging headache. Jerry had closed
the windows, as the room faced on a court and was noisy in the daytime,
and the air was envelopingly turgid. She dressed slowly, realizing as
she became more awake that she had not really eaten for more than
twenty-four hours. To ransack the kitchen at this time of the day was
hopeless, she knew. There was no solution but to walk down to the
nearest dairy lunch, which was quite a distance.

Hatted for the street, she passed through the hall, giving a fleeting
look to the living-room before leaving the apartment. Sarah and Jerry
were “rolling the bones” on the floor, with Wigs and Davy and several
other youths in full cry.

“Honey, what am them?”

“Oh, babe—what will the harvest be?”

“Shine out, little seven!”

“Root, hog, or die!”

Wigs caught sight of Joy as she was about to leave, and sang out: “Oh,
Jo-oy! What d’you mean, going to dinner at the Copley with Boston’s
Best? We saw you getting gay in there with Whosis—sitting up just like
you were at a funeral and all that!”

“Come on in!” invited Davy. “Chance to make your everlasting
fortune—never saw good coin change hands so fast——”

She made her escape hastily. _What had Packy meant!_ The kind of life
she led—from man to man instead of from hand to mouth——At the Dairy
lunch, over some poached eggs, she reflected that it was rather hand to
mouth to-day.

It was nearing evening as she paid her check and started to walk back.
There could be no explanation of Packy’s words except that he had
deliberately lied. Yet that did not sound like Packy. Fast and flippant
he undoubtedly was, but she could not picture him lying about a girl.

Suddenly, as she approached the apartment house, her heart came up in
her mouth. Surely that was Packy’s car in front—and Packy himself in
the act of stepping into it. She waved her veil at him wildly. If he
should drive away now just as the solution to her questionings presented
itself——But he saw her, and jumped out again as she came up to him.

“Joy! What doggone good luck. Jerry said she didn’t know where you’d
gone or when you’d come back——”

“I think it’s good luck, too,” she said quietly. “I have a lot of
questions to ask you.”

A window banged six stories up, and Jerry shrieked above them: “That
you, Joy? Come on up—there’s somebody to see you!”

“That blond ninny who bumped into Grant and me at the dance that night,”
Packy elucidated.

Jim Dalton! Life was too full of complications. She had as much as told
him so—“I told him I was too busy to see him,” said Joy.

“Come on—we’ll go riding,” said Packy, and called up to Jerry—“Joy’s
coming riding with me—better tell her company not to wait.”

“Where are you going?” Jerry cried, hanging her head farther out of the

“Where are we going?” Joy repeated, as he hesitated.

“Down the Shore Road a ways!” he answered finally, and Jerry’s face

“Hang Jerry—she acts like a regular old chaperone,” he grumbled as he
helped her in the car.

“According to what you think of me, I need one,” she retorted. They were
well under way before he replied, in a cool, even tone:

“Pretty crude, Joy—that’s not like you. I suppose Holy Boy Grant has
been spilling a lot of chatter in your shell-pink ear.”

“Then you _did_ say something to him! Packy—how could you do such a

The small, pitiful voice evoked a quick glance from him. “How couldn’t
I, you’d better say. May I remark in passing that he certainly didn’t
leave the ground long untrampled. Came up late last night, did he? I had
to nurse myself along a bit before I staggered about and got under way.”

A mile flashed by them while Joy thought desperately: His profile bent
over the wheel looked hard and even cruel. He had admitted talking to
Grant as calmly as he would have admitted sending her a box of candy. He
seemed to be in a repressed state below the level of which anything
might be lurking.

“I—I want to know—just what you told him,” she said at last, after
coining and discarding many different methods of putting the question.

“What did he tell you?” Packy countered, eyes on the road ahead.

“He told me—he told me that you told him—that I led a man-to-man

“Yes, and for once you overdid the thing,” he said smoothly. “I told
you, I could wait any reasonable length of time; but I wasn’t corked up
to the extent of standing by and smirking while you paraded Old Maid
Grant around under my nose. You ought to have had more sense of
proportion, Joy, than to go outside your line like that. And jealousy,
my dear girl, is a little item you absolutely glanced over.”

“What do you mean?” cried Joy, the wind tearing the words out of her
mouth almost before they came. “What right have I given you to be

“That’s absolutely ruled out as beside the point.” Still that level
voice, although the speed of the car had increased to a breathless,
horrible race that left no room for analysis. “You’ve got me so I don’t
know whether I’m drinking booze or water—and I don’t propose to have
you meanwhile carrying on a nice, pink-and-white little time with our
mutual friend Grant. It gets me—see?”

“But—I don’t see yet why you were cad enough to go and tell him such
lies about me——”

“Lies!” His lips twisted back from his teeth in silent mirth. “That’s
what he said. The funny part of the whole thing is that I told the

“You can’t mean what you’re saying. You must have been drinking before
you came to-day——”

“Now listen, Joy—you had me buzzing for awhile there—I didn’t know
exactly where to place you. Of course, living with Jerry and Sal gave me
a fairly good idea——”

“Idea _of what_?” she screamed. “_That’s what_ I want to know—that’s
what I’ve been asking you. What did you say, when you told Grant what
kind of girls I was living with?”

“I was about to say,” his even tones went on, “that you pulled the
innocent gag fairly well, but a little too frequent. I can stand just
about as much, Joy—after which, off come the brakes and away we skid!”
He turned and looked at her swiftly. His eyes were bloodshot, and they
glittered. She shuddered and shrank away from him to the farthest corner
of the car. The last time she had seen eyes with that look in them—it
had been at Prom—Jack Barnett, standing unsteadily against the wall.
Miles whirled past—while she cowered against the door of the car and
thought with such intensity that her hands and feet felt as if they were
turned to ice. He was drunk. She should have known before they started.
What could she say, to persuade him to turn back—and failing that, what
was there she could do?

A veering turn into a crossroad brought a protest. “What are we leaving
the Shore Road for? Is this the way back?”

“This is not the way back. I’m not going to take you back until I’m good
and ready—and the devil only knows when that’ll be!”

Her agonised scream vibrated above the roar of the motor. “Packy! Take
me back! You must! You——”

“Save—your—breath!” was jolted back to her, and then he laughed—a
long laugh that began and ended in his throat.

No more time to think, now—she knew what she must do. Her hands crept
out to the knob of the door. Mechanically she looked back and saw a car
in the distance—a car that she was dimly conscious had been following
them for some time. She could open the door in one second, jump out in
another—and before Packy could get back to her, the other car would be
upon them——

She turned the knob; Packy saw her at the same minute. With a growl he
lurched towards her and seized her by one arm. She struggled violently,
and he took his hand from the steering wheel and pulled her back into
the seat again.

It all happened in one of those seconds of eternity. While they
struggled, the car, still going at white-hot speed without a hand at the
wheel, careened from the road and was stopped by a tree.

A jarring crash which made one aware of every little bone and ligament
shivering one’s body; the eerie sensation of flying through space;

                 *        *        *        *        *

Pain—nothing but pain—and floating in a dizzy white world full of
needles that pricked and hummed—a strange white world in which there
was no time to open one’s eyes and look, because of the pain. Agony so
fearful that it seemed as if the very universe must be
cracking—everything above and beyond must be coming to an end—and yet
the white world hummed on, and the needles sang.

Always pain—agony so deep that when it became less, the memory of it
threw her into agony again.

Joy opened her arms and looked around. The white world was gone—she
could see familiar pieces of black walnut furniture. And with the white
world and humming needles had gone her pain, leaving her so weak she
felt as if she scarcely could open her eyes.

Jerry was sitting at the foot of the bed—a pale Jerry, with eyes large
and black as inkwells, her freckles standing out in bold relief. Joy was
childishly pleased to have sound travel forth from her mouth: “Jerry?”

Jerry jumped up and came to the side of the bed. “Joy! Hullo, old girl!”

Before her wide, relieved grin Joy essayed a colorless smile which
merely dragged her face into little white wrinkles. “Some—smash, wasn’t
it?” she quavered, anxious to show that she was in possession of her
senses. “How long have I been this way?”

“Too darn long,” said Jerry sternly. “Rotten company when you’re
unconscious, I’ll say that for you, Joy. Well, got to call up the
doctor—I said I’d let him know when you were ready to sit up and eat.”

“Eat!” Joy murmured in objection; but Jerry was gone. It was too much
trouble to lie and think. She fell asleep.

When she awoke, Jerry was standing by her bedside rattling a spoon in a
glass of milk. “Do you think it’s any bouquet to a doctor to fall
asleep, and stay that way all the time he’s here?” she demanded merrily.
“Anyway, he says to all outward appearances you aren’t dying yet. He’ll
be around again to-morrow A.M.”

Joy paused in drinking. “What—happened, Jerry? You haven’t told me

Jerry’s teeth shut down on each other. “I’ll tell you the whole darn
tale to-morrow. To-day you’d go to sleep in the middle of it.” She
pulled down the blinds and in the darkness of the room, Joy fell into a
thick, dreamless space from which she brought herself up with a start.
It was morning; chinks of glory were pouring in through the blinds; and
all at once she felt hungry and almost vigorous. Jerry was asleep on the
chair by the foot of the bed, but as Joy stirred, her eyes popped open
and she bounced up.

“What ho!” she exclaimed, dashing for the door. “You have the look of a
real breakfast in your eye!”

Joy did not talk much until the “real breakfast” was downed. Then she
leaned back on her pillows expectantly. “Now, Jerry—please tell
me—everything that happened. I gather from investigation that none of
my bones are broken—but what did happen to me? How did I get back here?
And what happened to Packy?”

Jerry pulled out her cigarette case. “Mind if I have at it? The doc
would kill me for doing this here, but I’m so fuzzy since this
happened——Packy, allow me to snort, got off nobly with a bump on the
eye. The nasty little garter snake! You see, Joy, Jim Dalton and I were
pursuing you in a taxi at ten dollars per sneeze, all the way.”

“Jim Dalton!”

“Right. He horned in on the craps, and by the way, after a round or two
he began taking away everybody’s cash, so the taxi bill might not have
made him as sad as it would have made me—and pretty soon Sal and Wigs
and the gang faded off down town to get a club sandwich, but I stuck
around and so did this Dalton bird. He had never played about with me at
all, so I took a somersault when he began to mention you in an offhand
way. Said he had seen you a couple of onces, and wanted to again

“I told him I was too busy to see him,” Joy interpolated, trying to
struggle to a sitting posture. Jerry raised a restraining hand.

“Take it from one who has flown about on the four winds, Joy—he’s all
right. He played a hunch to come up that night, and he might have saved
your life for all you know.”

Joy fell back on the pillows. “Oh, all right—but go on.”

Jerry smiled. “Don’t interrupt and I’ll spill it fast——Just at that
moment dear little Packy blew in on one of the stiffest breaths I’ve
come near since the first of July. Wanted to know where you were, why
you weren’t there, etcetera, and I told him to go to and stay put. He
paced out banging the door in good old ten-twenty-thirty style, and
Dalton passed the remark that he’d seen the angel messing around you
before and didn’t like the way he parted his hair. I took a glim out of
the window with some small idea of drowning Packy’s pretty car with a
bucket of varnish there happened to be handy, when you breezed up and
stood talking to him with all the life in the world. I knew there was a
nice speedy wind out which would muffle Packy’s breath, so I hove up the
window and bade you come in out of the wet. But no—you would go
a-riding, and I was all for letting you go, but Dalton got a taxi while
I was still bandying words with you, and told me to put on my old grey
bonnet and trot along with him. I trotted!” She took a long breath.
“God, Joy, that was a ride! I had netted the info that you were going
out on the Shore Road, but there was always the chance you’d change your
minds, and we had one whirl getting you into view! Some joy-ride—cheery
for me no end—with Dalton bickering along with himself to the effect
that he wouldn’t let that fellow take you out alone with as enthusiastic
a breath as he was exhibiting—my only recreation was making up five
different stories which I told the taxi-boy, about the car we were
streaking after—which made him put on all speed and sizzle along,

“I saw your car,” said Joy, “or else I wouldn’t have tried to jump.”

“Oh—so that’s what brought about the smash!”

Jerry whistled. “Joy, when I saw the car hit the tree——No matter; and
we certainly paid Packy off. We picked you up—or rather Jim did—and
put you in the taxi—and Packy was rolling about with only an eye gone
wrong—so Jim put him to sleep beside his car, which was all in, too,
from the looks of it; and came back home—leaving Packy to his own
devices, as the saying is. Not a peep has been heard from him; he must
have come to and slapped the car into shape, or there’d at least have
been a squib in the papers.”

“Now you’ve gotten to me,” said Joy.

Jerry suddenly sobered, dropping the light tone she had been using to
gild the narrative. “You’ve had a little—concussion of the brain. I
don’t know whether the doctor wanted me to tell you or not—but he says
you’ll be all right in a couple of weeks, so I don’t see why you
shouldn’t have the straight facts.”

“Concussion.” Joy considered her state. “Oh, yes—that’s what football
athletes are always getting, aren’t they?”

“That’s right—the idea’s the same,” said Jerry. “You tackled a tree,
instead of a person.” There was a slight pause, and Jerry said briskly:
“Mr. Grant Grey has called up once or twice. I told him you were ill,
but I guess he thinks it’s only a stall.”

“Oh—Grant——” She dismissed the subject as a triviality that could be
attended to at any time. “My father, Jerry—you haven’t let him know
about me, have you?”

“No, I didn’t. I would have, if the doctor had given me any reason to;
but he said that you would be all right and if you by any chance should
start sliding, it wouldn’t be sudden—your father could be reached in
time. I sort of thought you wouldn’t want him to know.”

“I wonder—what would have happened.” Joy tried to imagine her father’s
arrival in the apartment; his meeting with Sarah and Jerry; his hearing
the no doubt picturesque recital of her accident that Jerry would
render. The arrival of the doctor put a stop to this conjecture, which
was not a sufficiently pleasant line of thought to be reopened at any
other time.

The days of convalescence that followed were long, with somber
colouring. She missed her music; Grant did not call up again; the days
had dreadful emptinesses that called out for Grant . . . or for her
music. Sarah was almost unbearable to live with. Before, the
incompatibility of the two had not been so noticeable, when Joy had been
out or busy with her music most of the day; in the evenings, if they
were together, there were always men around to distract their attention.
But now Joy’s enforced stay in the house, threw them together a little
more often; just that little more that is too much. Sarah made no bones
of the fact that she nourished deep rancour against Joy for her
accident, which she considered “all Joy’s fault, anyway.” As a result of
the accident, Packy presumably would not put in an appearance at the
apartment again; thus ran Sarah’s grievance, which she poured upon Joy
instead of sympathy. It did not seem as if Sarah cherished a genuine
affection for any human being, man or woman; and the more one knew of
her, the more horrified one became at the hard, glassy surface which
appeared to be impenetrable.

But there was Jerry who, an untiring nurse and a companion who never
failed in interest, stayed constantly with Joy, turning down all
invitations with an iron hand. The uneasiness that had always been
there, moulded into form by Packy and Grant, was glazed over for a time.
All Joy’s knowledge of and regard for Jerry spoke more coherently than
unsubstantiated inference.

The two weeks set by the doctor had not quite passed when, one
afternoon, Joy tired of lying in bed. She felt perfectly well; there was
no reason why she shouldn’t get up and walk as far as the living-room.
She did not admit to herself that the cellarette was her real objective;
but it had been a long time since she had taken a prescription. Sarah
was out on one of her eternal tea dates; Jerry had vanished somewhere.
She slipped into her little blue crepe kimono and pattered down the
hallway, exultant in the power to walk so much and so healthily.

She swung around the door of the living-room and in before she saw that
someone was already there—Jerry, talking to Jim Dalton. They were both
standing at the door, so that she almost rushed into them, then stood
still in surprise.

Girls in fiction or plays who are surprised in negligée are always
“distractingly lovely” in silks or satins, with hair becomingly flowing.
But real girls in negligée, unless they know they are going to be
inspected, are quite a different matter. Joy’s hair was strained back in
tight braids from a face which, without rouge, was as thinly white as
skim-milk. The ribbons of her night gown had had their colour laundered
out of them; her kimono was—well, it was a kimono, not a negligée, nor
lingerie, nor a tea gown. All this, and more, her thoughts touched upon
in the first still moment.

Jim was the first to find his voice. “I’m glad to see you’re able to be
around, Miss Nelson,” he said calmly. “You won’t have to go back; I was
just leaving.”

Jerry went down the hall to the door with him, while Joy went into the
living-room and sank down on the lounge. It was uncanny, the way that
man had understood her, had spoken in a matter-of-fact voice and relaxed
her, and left without making a point of leaving. She realized, as she
lay among the pillows, that she could not have reached her room again
with any degree of certainty; he had tactfully forestalled her; very
thoughtful, for a man.

Jerry came back into the room, smoking in a desultory manner. “I didn’t
think I’d tell you, Joy, because I know you don’t like him—but that boy
has been here every blooming day since you’ve been sick, to find out how
you were at first-hand—while your Grant has stalled at phone distance.
I hate to say anything about a man I’ve never met, Joy, but Grant
listens to me like a flat tire.”

Joy giggled nervously.

“It isn’t easy for Jim to come, either,” Jerry added. “He takes the trip
way out here after he gets through working every day.”

“It’s none of Jim Dalton’s business,” said Joy. “He doesn’t have to
come; I wish he wouldn’t. I barely know him, and he keeps turning up and
acting as if he were my father or something.”

“Or something!” Jerry repeated derisively. “No—you’ve got a wrong slant
on him. Of course, if you look at it that way, he _is_ being a bit
outside the works—but when you think it over, the knights of old they
talk about who beat it to the rescue of dames in distress, didn’t always
stop to decide whether it was any of their business.”

A bitter resentment swept over Joy—resentment that it had been Jim
Dalton and not Grant who had followed them on that ride; that it had
been Jim and not Grant who had come to see how she was. “Jerry!” she
cried suddenly. “Did you know that Grant had left me?”

Jerry had been watching her smoke rings space themselves to the ceiling,
but turned swiftly. At her look of blank interrogation, Joy repeated:
“Grant has left me! I—I don’t think he’s ever coming back!” Then she
stopped, with a tearing intake of breath.

There was an interval while Jerry’s smoke rings turned to curlicues and
gargoyles, and Jerry remained seemingly lost in admiration of her skill.
Finally, Jerry spoke.

“Of course, Joy, I don’t know the facts of the case—but he’ll come
back. I’d stake ten to one on it. He’ll come back—I tell you he will!”

“I’m waiting——!” said Joy.

And she waited—through a week that turned hope to hopelessness. She
dared not leave the apartment for fear the telephone would ring. She
told herself that he was not coming; yet she sat in the living-room, a
book on her lap, or sat at the piano touching keys into strange
harmonies . . . waiting.

Gradually life began to resume its accustomed gait at the apartment.
Jerry had curtailed all parties during Joy’s convalescence, but now was
off again. It was nearing fall; people were coming back into town; the
telephone jangled constantly. Joy lacked the energy to join any of these
parties, and the evenings were very lonely; as she had not gone back to
Pa Graham’s as yet, her days also were long and purposeless.

And so a week had passed on leaden wheels. And one evening about
ten-thirty when she heard a babble of voices in the living-room, she
made up her mind to dress and annex herself to the crowd.

The music of popping corks and carefree laughter assailed her ears as
she came into the room. There were three men, not counting one that
Sarah had taken to a comfortable, cosy corner and to whom she was archly
whispering. Jerry was standing by the piano, looking over some popular
songs with a short, chunky youth who could make the keys jingle in
strange, barbaric dissonances that made up an irresistible syncopation
which seemed to intoxicate more than the contents of the cellarette. The
ever-present Wigs and Davy hailed Joy, pressed a “tall one” upon her,
and sat her on the sofa.

“I knew you couldn’t stand Boston’s Best for a steady diet,” said Wigs.
“You struck the right time, too, Joy; Jerry’s gotten herself quite
tightly edged to-night, a thing that never happens as you know, and
since we’ve got the wine and women, she’s going to favour us with song.”

The chunky boy at the piano was shaking out some bars of eerie ragtime.
Jerry turned, swaying, hands on hips. Her eyes were shining with almost
polished rays; they wandered over the room in an impersonal,
professional smile. It was doubtful if she saw Joy at all. Her lips
parted in an avid, gamin grin, and hardly opening her teeth, she jutted
forth the words of the song:

              “I wanted some men and I sought them
              I made myself up like a doll
              The other girls, oh, how I fought them!
              They handed it to me for gall—
              I wanted some men and I’ve got them
              Turned down five bids for dinner last night
              But somehow they’re not what I thought them
              And somehow I know it’s not right.”

The fiery, vivid personality that was Jerry’s leaped out through
scarcely a motion as she sang, insolently, through her teeth, her red
lips always curved into that goblin grin. She was swinging into the
chorus now, a chorus of dizzying syncopation the notes of which she
followed not at all, speaking the words with a little drag at
inconsequential moments—

                “Ten men down—and more to go—
                Other girls get them—if you are slow—
                This life is short
                So don’t get caught
                You’ve got to have strings to your bow!”

“No sense to words of any popular songs nowadays,” complained Davy. “But
Jerry puts ’em over—she’s the Queen of the Cabaret Artists.”

Joy had never heard Jerry sing before, except from a distance at the
Prom. It was a rich voice, thick and uneven and even harsh in places;
but she had “put it over.” She did not need any voice at all, with that
audacity and insolence. There was loud applause, mingled with the
popping of more corks. The chunky youth deserted the piano, complaining
that it was “devilish dry work.” Jerry came over to the lounge.

“Hello, Joy,” she said lightly. “Come to join the happy family? Everyone
was bored as blazes to-night until we started opening them up, and now
everyone thinks they’re bright as the morning sun, which is still a long
ways off from to-night, I’ll tell anyone.” She teetered slightly
standing before them. Jerry “tightly edged,” was fascinating as ever,
but not a pleasant sight.

“I can make up words as good as that old song,” said Sarah from her
corner. Her head had slid to her companion’s shoulder, but she bobbed it
up as she sang:

       “Mazie had a man an’ he left her flat
       If she’d had more than one he’d not had nerve to do that.”

“Fine! Let’s all make up pop’lar songs,” cried Davy, thumping out a
staccato time with his feet and humming some blue lines of uncertain

“Pop-u-lar songs,” corrected Wigs, with academic zeal. “’Shamed of you,
Davy, ignoring your shyllables that way.”

“None of your business whether I cut silbles when I see ’em or not,”
Davy retorted. “Always was ’ristocratic. Can’t help way was made——”

“Should help cruelty to inan-imate objexsh. Poor little shyllables can’t
hit back.” Wigs became tearful over his chivalry in defending helpless
objects. Davy remained gay, taking a glass Jerry had just filled, from
her hands while chanting—

           “O my name’s July an’ I gotta thirst
           O babe, share de whiskey or you shore will burst.”

“Some poet!” said Jerry, and tipped the contents of the glass on to his
collar, as he started to lift it to his lips. She poured herself another
glass, while he rose and tore off the dripping mass that had been his
collar, shrieking another stanza:

            “De whiskey am frisky in its lawful place
            Babe, leave some for me or I’ll slap your face.”

“Shay—whaddyouthinkthisish—blooming musical comedy?” And Wigs wept

Sarah’s little comrade in the corner was announcing that Sarah had
“passed out”; the chunky pianist stopped drinking long enough to say
that Sal was a rumhound and never knew when to stop; there seemed to be
no end to Wigs’ flow of tears; Davy was chanting a new verse in which he
could only get as far as “O Babe——” and then he would have to begin
over. Jerry was laughing stridently at Davy between gulps of port wine.
It was the worst to see Jerry so——But Sarah was the farthest
along—she lay back on her cushions now without motion, her hair that
was usually so exquisitely arranged, loose in loops about her face, her
mouth sagging open ever so slightly.

Watching the sight before her, Joy felt a nauseation that she had ever
touched liquor herself. Wigs’ tears reminded her sickeningly of her own.
She had been living in a daze; but the daze had worn off. To-night was
the finishing touch. Packy may have been despicable, but his words about
Jerry and Sarah at this moment seemed to be justified.

She rose and left, ignoring Davy’s pleas for her to stay, and the fact
that her departure threw Wigs into a fresh fit of tears. Jerry was still
remarking that the evening was young and tender—and Joy had no doubt
but that they would all drink until they were unable to move.

In the morning she got up early and packed her things—a decision born
of the night hours, which did not change its colour in the rays of the
sun. She was going home. Her visit had stretched itself far beyond its
first designated limits. Her father could not understand why she had not
come long since. She would go back to the Mid-Victorian house and face
the family portraits—feel the protection of the four walls of the
ancestral mansion around her—enjoy the peace and security of the little

A thought held her up, as she was folding a sweater. What of her
singing? To leave Boston would be to leave Pa Graham. She had been
subconsciously assuming that her music would always go on, but—how?

In a very few minutes she had dressed for the street and was hurrying
out of the apartment. No one was stirring, but it was nine o clock, and
she knew Pa would be in his studio. If she could only get there before
his first lesson——

There is something about the personal quality of singing, and the
reverence the teacher inspires as the embodiment of that great art, that
draws the confidence. If singing teachers could tell half the stories of
the lives of their pupils!

Pa was alone playing in the great studio, and came forward with
delighted welcome: “Back again, my prima donna! Are you ready and eager
for work once more?” Before her white wistfulness he paused. She stood
looking around the room, at the busts of Mendelssohn and Beethoven; at
the shrine to “Patti—the thing that happened once” in the far corner;
at the photograph of Sembrich of the golden voice supreme, with loving
greetings to Pa written across the face; the piles of music on the
pianos——A sob arose to her lips. “Oh, Pa!” she said. “If you could
only understand! Everything—has left me!” Days of waiting, of patient
tears, brought a swift little rush of words: “I haven’t even a
heart—any more.”

Pa took her hand gently and led her to a chair. Then he stood before
her, stroking his short little beard, his old eyes very soft under his
bent brows.

“Child—your heart may break—it’s the way of young hearts every once in
a while—but there is one great soul that will remain true as long as
you are true, and that is the soul of music. An older and wiser spirit
than mine has said: ‘All passes; Art alone endures.’ With you, all else
may pass, but the soul of music will unite itself with your own, always
weaving its tendrils more closely into your being. Just now it may seem
a cold comfort in your desolation—but it is a thing that ripens as the
years go on—always faithful—_always providing you are faithful_.”

A quick little silence in the room. Joy lifted her head. “I want to,
Pa—I want to turn to my music, so much—but how can I—do anything more
with it—when I feel as if everything in my heart was burned and dead!”

He smiled. “Youth is tragic—every once in a while. Look you, Joy—you
came this morning half determined to tell me you weren’t coming to me
again—but you are. What would you do, else? Your impulse to love, let
us say, has been awakened, then—diverted. Note, I do not say snuffed
out, for that is an impossible thing. The impulse is still there—and if
you turn it to music, spending it royally in terms of energy and power
in work at your art, instead of in terms of love, you will be content,
and you will become one of the greatest artists the world has known. You
will interpret life to hundreds of thousands, through the transmutation
of your life into work. ‘All passes; Art alone endures.’” He took a few
quick turns about the room, then brought himself up with a jerk. “I do
not want you to sing to-day; you have been with tears too recently;
besides, I have a lesson. Go away, and think over what I have said. You
will have some decisions to make. For if you come back to me, there will
be no more half-toned effort such as the desultory summer work we have

“Desultory summer work,” Joy gasped. “Why, I practised regularly——”

“Practice! An hour and a half a day. That is the most you can do with
your voice. But there must be hours of silent study. No matter what one
may say of Geraldine Farrar now, she was, is and will remain a very
great artist. It does not drop on one like the gentle rain from Heaven,
after a few years of hour-and-a-half practice. That girl worked ten
hours a day in her years of study. Lilli Lehmann said she never had such
a worker. You have the voice—yes. Now you require solfège, through
harmony and counterpoint, French, Italian and German complete, other
languages to pronounce—you are but at the threshold of your toil. Oh,
when I see you before me, with practically everything to learn, the days
don’t seem long enough—the years don’t seem long enough!” He quieted
down and looked at her. A great deal had descended upon her at once, but
she felt no sense of oppression at the program outlined; rather, she
felt as if energy were pouring in upon her, energy to accomplish
anything he said. She rose, inhaling a long breath as she did to sing
on, feeling her ribs swell out, with the sense of power that it never
failed to give her.

“It’s true, Pa—I did come in here half with the idea of leaving you. I
didn’t know what I would do. But you have decided me. There’s no need of
my thinking over what you said. I’ve decided now. You never told me all
this before, about how I would have to work, because I wasn’t ready for
it—isn’t that so? I am now—and thank you.”

His eyes glinted beneath his brows. “I’ll not let you decide here. Go
away as I told you, and then come back. At Jerry’s, your atmosphere will
not be so—musical, and you can make an unbiased decision.”

“No—I want to decide now—before I go back to Jerry’s——”

“You speak as if Jerry might influence you the other way. Jerry loves to
mind her business with strict impartiality, but if she ever overstepped
her limits she would only urge you to strive as she might have. That
girl has the makings of a diseuse of the first water.”

She left the studio in the gilded bubble of youth’s ambition. All the
voices and urges within her seemed this morning to have crystallized
themselves into one refrain: “_No work is too hard if it reaches towards
perfection!_” How could she have thought she could leave Pa?

She had forgotten—Jerry, Jerry, the mystery—about whom Pa seemed to
know more than she, Joy, who lived with her.

What could she do? What was she to think? Where could she turn, in this

Jerry was sitting in her room—a pale, seedy-looking Jerry in the
familiar purple kimono, staring dully at the half-packed trunk. She did
not turn as Joy came in.

“So you’ve—decided to go,” she said in a funny, hard little voice that
wavered at the end.

All the resentment and doubt that had been torturing Joy, was dispelled
by the sight of that desolate figure and those few wry little words.
“Jerry!” she cried. “I—I thought about it this morning—but I—I

Jerry’s lashes flickered, but she remained sitting in the same position,
knees drawn against her chin, pink mules flapping in front of her. “It
never wandered into my bean until just now, when I came in and
saw——But I’ve been boiling the idea down—and I think you’d better.”


“You aren’t happy here; I—I guess you never have been. I’ve never done
anything but harm to you from the first moment I knew you. God knows I
didn’t mean to, but it seems my good intentions always make the
smoothest kind of boulevards for the joy-riders in hell.”

Jerry broke the silence that followed her last speech. “Joy—I’ve never
told you about myself. Get comfortable now, because I’m going to ladle
out the whole story.”

Joy was at the threshold of the Blue Room, of what she had always wanted
to know. And now that she was so near, she drew back. “Oh, no,
Jerry—please don’t tell me anything you’d rather not talk about—and
you’ve often said you’d rather not talk about that——”

“I also said I’d tell you sometime when I felt like it. Now gets the
vote. I should have told you right at the start—but I didn’t, because I
didn’t want to go into it. Now I’ve got to.”

“Well, if you must tell me—I’m comfortable,” said Joy in a small voice,
sitting down on one of the black walnut chairs which had been remodeled
with black-and-white-striped cushions.


” To begin at the pop of the pistol—I was born in New York—over on the
East Side, where people live like flies. You’ve never been there, have
you?” Joy shook her head. “Then you probably won’t believe some of the
things I’m going to tell you. I was one of ten—and we all lived in two
rooms.” Jerry’s voice seemed to have grown dull, and she stared away
from Joy as she talked. “When you toss it over in your mind—it’s pretty
brutalizing, living that way—it tends to turn humans into worse than
animals—for humans can make themselves as much lower than animals as
they can higher—that’s one of the things I’ve learned so far in life.”

“You don’t mean _ten people_—in two rooms?” Joy gasped.

Jerry shrugged her shoulders. “That’s exactly what I do mean. Not only
that, but we took two boarders in our rooms because my father was always
out of work.”

Joy’s eyes were huge disks of horror; already she had shrunk into her
chair looking at Jerry as if she had suddenly dropped in from Mars.
Jerry was continuing rapidly:

“I sold newspapers as soon as I was able to take in the pennies. I wore
a grey sweater and a pair of bloomers, and talked to everybody who
bought a paper of me, whether they slung a line back or not.” She gave a
long, quivering sigh. “I don’t intend to go into details about my life
from the ground floor up——But get this clear, Joy: _I never knew what
it was to be innocent_, not since I can remember. And I’m not throwing
out any cross lines when I say that it wasn’t my fault or my own
choosing. I—never had any other slant on it offered to me. My life, as
I have said, was like that of an alley cat, and it couldn’t be
translated to you any other way.”

“I don’t understand,” said Joy faintly.

“You wouldn’t. You were having milk fed to you when I was picking up
beer-leavings. That’s the best way I can put it to you.”

There was a pause while Jerry studied her pink mules and searched for
words in which to clothe what she wanted to say. Finally, with a swift
frown, she plunged into narrative again, obviously leaving a hiatus.

“When I was thirteen, I got a job as messenger girl for Charlette et
Cie. Happened to have drifted up the Avenue to see if I could get some
man to buy my whole load of papers—saw the sign, Girl Wanted, and
tacked inside. There were a bunch of others waiting that dressed the
part a little better—I had on the grey sweater and bloomers—but I told
the dame that was doing the interviewing that I’d carry their old
bundles for less than any other applicant. This underbidding tickled the
old girl somehow, and before I knew it, I was one of Charlette’s regular
messenger-girls at five dollars per.

“My getting rich quick was the cause of a split between me and the
family. I shut my mitt on my income—and the result was the throwing of
a few flat-irons and other little parties, which ended in the fact that
one night I didn’t come back and I’ve never been back since. I hadn’t
ever bet much on the family—and there was a new boarder I didn’t like.”

“What do you mean, Jerry,” Joy interposed; “you couldn’t live—not
_live_ on five dollars a week?”

“I could and did. I took a room at a dollar a week. It was a hall
bedroom, the kind you don’t even read about. No light, and squirming all
over. I used to——Never mind—I got along all right—and the family
never came after me; I guess one more or less didn’t make such a hell of
a difference.

“Excuse me, Joy! You look paralyzed or something. I was inhaling the
dollar-a-week air again——Cheer up—I’m whirling off the slum stuff as
swift as it can go—but you’ve really got to hear some of this, so you
can understand every little thing.”

“Go—on,” Joy articulated with difficulty.

“My next two years I spent carrying bundles for Charlette’s and
incidentally hanging around the place before and after hours, talking to
the models every chance I could get, absorbing the main truths about
what clothes can do to you and what you can do to clothes. My errands
took me into the workrooms and fitting-rooms, and I began to make my own
clothes and what I admitted was improving on Charlette designs in doing
so. Watching the models and hearing them talk had given me an idea of
what colour and line could do.

“I think I was at my worst at fifteen. I tossed a mean make-up and
looked probably older than I do now. I had no morals and a bunch of bad
ideas. Some of the models were all right, but those weren’t the ones who
shot their mouths off. About the only rule I went by was to look out for

“Along about then, I struck for recognition—I was working twelve hours
a day and only pulling down seven a week—and they graduated me into the

“That’s the way my rise in the world began—that and changing to a
sub-let room in an apartment uptown. I was five years more at
Charlette’s; and at the end of that time I was one of their
designers—what I had been working for, all that time.” She closed her
eyes as if they hurt. “I’d been working on the same old twelve-hour
average, but it was a change and higher pay, and I lapped up the work, I
was so crazy about it. There seemed a sort of poetry to it—even when I
started as a cutter, baster, fitter and spent days over the sewing
machine—a poetry that grew as I pushed myself into the designing end
and put the right thing on the right person.”

“Like Mrs. Messy,” Joy said, with a little hysterical giggle. She had
lost her look of breathless horror, and was listening with minute

“Well—there were a lot of people like her around, of course—there
always are, in a big designing shop—and I learned how to put things on
them, too—as you’ve seen.” The two girls smiled at each other. The air
had become less tense. It was almost in relief that Jerry continued:

“I always worked overtime, at first because I knew that was the way to
get ahead, then later from habit as well as my burning to get to the
top. I saved my money, too, and was the original glued-to-a-nickel
fiend. Men dropped out of my life pretty much in those five years. I was
too busy getting ahead.

“Before I go on and get to the heart-throb—I’ll give you a general
snapshot of me at the age of twenty. I made myself up every A.M. as
peppily as if I were going to tread the boards. I wore my hair in the
last gasp from Paris. I cut my clothes as snappy as I could get away
with, which was some, you can gather. And I looked like a misprint. As
for the rest—I was hard as a city pavement, tough as gum, and looked on
men as a necessary evil.”

“That wasn’t your fault!” Joy interpolated swiftly. Jerry shrugged her
shoulders by way of answer, but gave a faint nod, before going on.

“Then one day a man walked into Charlette’s who—I’ve never lined this
out to a soul, Joy; but I’ll try to hold my words in when I talk about
him. You know, or of course you don’t, the type of man likely to float
around Charlette’s. Husbands, or sapheads. Mostly both. But this day—a
man came in with his sister, who was having us do her wedding dress.

“She was Mabel Lancaster. Of course you know who she is.”

“I’m afraid I don’t,” Joy admitted. “The name sounds vaguely familiar,
but most nice names sound that way to me——”

“Well, New Yorkers would know; it’s an old family, not much ready cash;
and she tied up to Eustace Drew, also old family, and a lot of ready
cash. The papers were full of blurbs about it at the time. I had thrown
a lot of thought over her dress, and it was good, by the way—but
Fanchon spread a noise about having done it herself. Fanchon was the old
girl who had first interviewed me when I came in for messenger girl. Her
real name was Mrs. O’Brien, but never mind.

“I was out front shadowing Fanchon O’Brien with a telephone message when
he came, not trailing after his sister with a dragged-in-look or
tripping along with all the zest in the world—just the in-between
effect that I had often remarked no man ever got in Charlette’s Louis
Somebody salon. Joy, he—well, he’s tall, and big, and he’s got brown
hair, sort of choppy, with a pinch of red in it. And his eyes are blue
as yours, only they’re breezy and full of zip—and then they can look at
you with a little half-smile——”

She caught herself up. “Tell me when, I blow, Joy! I knew I would.”

Joy laughed. “I love it when you ‘blow,’ Jerry! I’ve often wondered if
you ever—could! Go on—quick!”

“Well—he didn’t look at me at all. Fanchon took them into the theatre
salon, and I sneaked after them, pretending I was busy at something or
other. Mabel Lancaster was saying that she wanted to look at some
evening gowns for her trousseau, and Fanchon nailed me to rustle the
dear models along. I did so, and then stood at the end of the salon and
kept my eyes pasted on the back of his head. I was hard in love with him
then—with the back of his head and the way he turned and smiled and
said things to his sister. The back of a man’s head is an awful test—it
can register, or not register, so many things. Try it and see some time!

“Finally I came down the theatre to a seat almost behind them. Fanchon
had gone back in the workroom to see about the wedding dress, and thanks
to Charlette having the theatre salon in semitones, they didn’t notice
me, although they never wasted an eye on surrounding human scenery

“‘Those models fascinate me, Phil,’ she was saying. ‘What an empty show
their life must be! Or is it? What do you think?’ ‘I’ve known some of
their kind,’ he answered, ‘and I can assure you that their chief concern
is what they put on or leave off their backs. Poor little rats! Not much
“honour and truth and a sure intent” among them!’

She laughed. ‘You’re always talking about “honour and truth and a sure
intent,”’ she said. ‘You’re so romantic, Phil—anyone would think you
were getting married instead of me!’

“Then he wasn’t married! That was my first thought, as I faded away back
to Fanchon. But later on, the things he said began to sink in. ‘Poor
little rats!’ He had said that in the same tone that he had looked
through me. Every time I thought of it I wanted to go and burn myself up
and then crawl out and fly away a new bird, like a Pegasus or a Phœnix,
or whatever the old thing is. I knew I was a poor little rat—that he’d
call me the same thing if he ever had a good look at me. And the worst
thing was that I didn’t have a clue on how not to be a poor little
rat—not a clue, except for those three things he had named—‘honour and
truth and a sure intent.’ The first two and me weren’t speaking. That
last—well, I thought I did have a sure intent. To get to the top on
designing for Charlette—to get so that I would be the acknowledged
head, second only to the old girl Charlette herself, who spent most of
her time hanging in on the Paris exhibits—that was my aim; and then I
was going to spread and have a good time. Not a bad aim, as aims go. The
trouble with everyone nowadays is, everyone wants to get to the top and
have a good time every step of the way too.”

She paused to take breath.

“Do you mean,” said Joy, “that you—you really fell in love with


They were silent for a moment, and then Joy whispered an old, old
question—and one that of late had been pricking her with uncertainty.

“Jerry—how did you—know? How could you be so—sure?”

“How does one know?” Jerry repeated. “That’s something that crashes in
to different make-ups in different ways, Joy. With me—it came like a
pistol shot. Just as sudden, and as unwelcome.

“I thought about him on an average of every day, after that. You see, no
one had ever spilled it to me before that there might be something
lacking in my get-up. I always believed that you can get to anything you
want if you want it hard enough to work for nothing but that. Look where
I had landed by tearing my eyes out with work while other girls watched
the clock and beat it early for movie dates—from the East Side newsie
in grey sweater and bloomers to a Fifth Avenue designer in a Charlette
model—at twenty. And so I began to believe that if I wanted Phil
Lancaster hard enough, I could get him. There was this hitch to it,
though; I knew how to work for what I wanted, before. Now I was in the
dark. The only right thing I knew was that I was wrong—and that I
didn’t want to see him again until I was right.

“Then the war came along. When I read his name in the Plattsburg lists,
I decided that I’d better go over to France and see what I could do
about it, too. I had a stock-taking of myself, and decided—Y. M. C. A.
entertainment was my line. When I was a newsie, I used to sing in the
bars for a nickel, and I was always quick at catching on to popular
songs. I got one of the fitters at Charlette’s who could rustle the
ebonies, and we went over a bunch of stuff. My voice was big and I had
pep—but they told me I had no training—no repertoire—that I’d better
study singing, and also get some practical professional experience.

“That’s how I connected up with Pa Graham. One of the designers had a
friend who sang at Rector’s, and was studying for musical comedy.
Singing teachers are the worst lottery there is, but the alley cat fell
on her feet again. That girl took me to Pa—she was the only
musical-comedy special he had. He didn’t have much time, but when I told
him I wanted to get to France, and sang for him, he fixed it.”

“Wait a minute,” said Joy. “Where did you practice, and when? Just tell
me that.”

“Oh, about that time I changed my living quarters to a two-room-and-bath
arrangement up on West 111th. They were furnished, and a bum piano
thrown in. I didn’t care how bum it was, as it took all I could do to
pick out notes with one finger. This was a blurb or so more than I’d
been paying, which with my lessons meant that I was putting by a half of
one percent, of my regular speed, even with a raise I got along in

“Then Fanchon came to me confidentially one day and offered to sell some
of her stock in the firm—war times were getting stiff. I can tell you I
stood still and shivered in my silk socks. Charlette’s stock was
closed-corporation stuff and it had been one of my largest ideas to get
some of it salted down. Only the old guard had their mitts on it, and I
didn’t know when I was going to be trusted with a block. I made her out
a cheque in quick order. A stockholder! They couldn’t kick me out now, I
doped it.”

She was silent for a moment of reflection, seeming to choose between the
thoughts that were crowding about her, while Joy held her breath in hope
that she would plunge ahead without choosing.

“I wanted to get some percentage on my lessons, and some of the
professional experience they talked about, so pretty soon I looked
around for a cabaret job and got one—through the girl at Rector’s, who
knew the manager at Hanley’s. It wasn’t bad. I wouldn’t have done
anything else with my evenings but sleep—and six hours’ sleep always
did me, from habit I guess. I came on at seven-thirty and eleven-five,
two songs each time.

“That was some life—practice early in the A.M., get to Charlette’s at
nine, work all day, Hanley’s in the evening, Pa Graham Sundays. That man
has got a soul in him for every art in music, and he showed me how to
succeed in my line while he was trying to make me into a diseuse. He
made me go and hear Yvette Guilbert, and told me that’s what I should
aim for—to be the American Yvette. But I had my own little idea of what
I wanted to do, and to try diseusing in war times wasn’t it.

“And all this time I steered clear of men. It wasn’t so easy now that I
was at Hanley’s, but being at work most of the time helped me, that and
the thought of Phil Lancaster—it was funny the way he and the things he
said stuck in my mind. ‘Honour and truth and a sure intent’—I had all
of that now, the way I looked at it. You remember war times,
Joy—everybody wanting to do something for somebody—air just reeking
with idealism—all I wanted was to get over there and be some good. And
after the war, Phil Lancaster, if he was still alive. Things would be
different after the war, I thought. And I figured it that the experience
of being over there would purify me as you read of its purifying
people’s souls. For by that time I saw what the first years of my life
had done to me. I don’t blame myself yet for being born an alley cat and
living with and in scum for the first fifteen years of my life. I wasn’t
taught any differently, and in spite of everything I taught myself and
pulled myself out of the scum. No, I didn’t blame myself—I only wanted
to better myself—and I thought that this Y stuff, overseas, would do a
lot towards wiping away the scum that seeps in under the skin, when
you’re buried in it, and sticks afterwards when you wash off the outside

“It was in October of 1917 that the top of everything was knocked off
for me. I was at Hanley’s singing some fool song about ‘My Little
Service Flag Having Seven Stars,’ and it was about eleven-fifteen—when
suddenly I saw him—Phil Lancaster. Sitting alone at a table by the
wall. He was looking at me, _he was looking at me_! He was in the
uniform of a Captain of Infantry, and if I hadn’t been remembering him
every day ever since he had come into Charlette’s, I wouldn’t have known
him, he was so changed and tired. But he was looking at me! I faded up
and closed out—all my wind gone. Shut down on encores. Couldn’t pipe
another note. He had looked at me—well, as if he was noticing me hot.

“While I was still standing in the reception hallway, one of the waiters
blew in with a note for me. I never saved it—just like me to lose
it—but he asked if I couldn’t come out and have something to eat with
him, describing his location. Now, we’re not allowed to go out and sit
at the tables at Hanley’s. People could come back in the reception hall,
and talk to us there, but that was all. My first idea was to reel a note
back to him telling him that, and trust he would take the hint. But no!
I didn’t dare let that go. Supposing he didn’t come across—after all
those months—no, I couldn’t trust to it that he would tumble, or even
want to. I gave the waiter a note saying I would join him presently, and
scrubbed off most of my make-up, just leaving what I thought was a good
veneer for close-range work. I had worn a big hat that flopped all
around my face, and with my coat on and the lid flopping and the make-up
toned down, I didn’t look much like myself. I took a sneak out the side
and then breezed in front, told a waiter who didn’t know me I was
joining a friend, and fox-trotted up to his table with all the starch in
the world.

“And all the way I had been saying to myself: Jerry, you’ve had to fight
for everything you’ve got so far—and you’ve got to fight for this, but
you’ve been given the chance to fight!

“I sat down opposite him and grinned. He came out of a trance and looked
at me. ‘Oh, hello!’ he said. ‘Are you sure you’re the same one who has
seven stars on her service flag?’ ‘Seven is my limit,’ I said. ‘Is that
a fixed resolve? Because I was seriously considering asking you if you
would break over and add an eighth.’

“I took a minute off to look at him. Yes, he had the appearance of
having downed a few drinks. There was a lot more, too—he certainly had
been riding the sad sea waves! ‘Where do you get it, you officer guys?’
I asked him. He didn’t answer—he was lamping me. ‘On the stage up
there, you seemed quite wicked. Now, you are a disappointment. I can
never be taken up for conduct unbecoming an officer, with you at my

“I opened my mouth and nearly fell in it. Then I managed to get out that
I’d better leave, so he could try someone else. He said ‘No—I want
_you_. You look as though you had enough joy of living to cheer up even
a dead one—and that’s what I am, or the next thing to it.’

“I suggested that if he wanted me to trot out any joy of living stuff,
we had better leave that place and come on up to my apartment. I had
some there—a small but good assortment. I had outgrown my taste for
beer, but still wolfed down the Demon Rum—and I couldn’t sit in
Hanley’s much longer without being recognized. He paid the check and we
were off without even waiting for the change. Now I knew he’d been
drinking. It’s a long way from Hanley’s to West 111th, in case you don’t
know—in a taxi—although only about twenty minutes in the Subway. We
got in a meter-wagon and started off through the white lights. My heart
was travelling quicker than the meter.

“‘It’s sort of unusual for an officer to be alone in New York, isn’t
it?’ I said, and he pulled a laugh that would have been funny if it
hadn’t been so pitiful. ‘Alone? I’m the loneliest man in New York.’ Then
he set himself off and told me what was rotting in the State of Denmark.
His girl had knocked him one by quietly side-stepping around the corner
and getting sewed up to a French artillery officer. This had just burst
in upon him when he had heaved in from Upton that P.M.—after leaving
her last week with all the encouragement in the world. It had made him
simply silly—he’d been sampling everything he could get hold of, and
was quite poppo by now, as I could see.

“That girl was probably a good girl, but she hadn’t played fair, to do a
thing like that. And when you don’t play fair, you let yourself in for a
lot of responsibility. Here was her responsibility—shifted to me—and I
was her opposite. I hadn’t been good, according to her standards, but I
had always played fair.

“I gathered, as we bumped along through Columbus Circle, that she had
been about the only thing that had been keeping him treading water, just
now. He’d been made a Captain at Plattsburg, and he hadn’t felt he was
up to such a position; and at Upton he was feeling it more and more. He
told me about two young officers who’d shot themselves because they were
going crazy with their cares and responsibilities. It was a tough thing
for some of those young kids, to feel that they had whole companies of
men under them to answer for, when up to now they had never answered for
anything but the dog. He said if he hadn’t been older than those kids he
now would be tempted to do the same thing; that he never felt nearer to

“It all seemed like a dream, Joy—bumping along in a taxi beside the man
I’d been in love with for so long—and he spreading his tale of woe. It
couldn’t have happened any other time but war times. If he thought about
telling me this stuff at all, he thought I was the grade of intelligence
that would peacefully let it slide by. I got that fact, and began to
think in quick flashes. Ever since I had watched the back of his head,
back in Charlette’s, I had fixed it in my mind so that he could have
walked over me in golf shoes and I would have sat up and begged for
more. I wanted to get hold of that girl and feel my fingernails meet in
her throat. As for Phil—the more he talked about it, the gloomier an
atmosphere he cast.

“We got to my apartment and as I opened up some joy getter, he passed
the remark that I did myself pretty well for a cabaret singer. Then he
slumped right down again, and got so low he couldn’t even drink. ‘It’s
no use,’ he said; ‘in my frame of mind, Uncle Sam’s army is better off
without me, and God knows there’s no one else in this universe who would
care!’ When men say that, you always know they mean a girl. They never
seem to think of their families in that connection.

“I went over to where he was looking at my wine, and said: ‘You’re
drunk. To snuff yourself out would brand you a coward in the eyes of the
world and God, too. Besides which, I won’t let you.’ He ripped off a
nasty laugh at that. ‘This is really almost amusing—to be sitting
listening to a cabaret girl tell me _she_ won’t let me “snuff myself
out!”’ He took my hand, and hung onto it. ‘Then you do want me for the
eighth star!’ A man never plain holds your hand, it seems—it’s just a
starter. ‘Listen here,’ I said. ‘I may be a cabaret girl, but I’m not
several other little things you seem to think I am. I’ve got “honour and
truth and a sure intent,” which is more than you’ll have if you follow
up your intent with me!’

“He dropped my hand like a hot potato and squared off to take a look at
me. ‘Did you say honour and truth and——?’ ‘I did,’ said I. ‘So come to
and stay there.’ ‘I never made a mistake like this before,’ he said. ‘I
think I had better go.’

“I can tell you it made me feel pretty sick. If I could have stopped
caring for him the way I’d started—but I couldn’t—I’d sort of fixed
everything on him and there it hung. And here he was going to the
sausages, and wanted me to help him fry himself. I was knocked cold. I
hadn’t really got what he had doped me out to be—until he said he’d
better go.

“I lost my head then. ‘Sit down,’ I said. ‘Sit down and let me tell you
something. You’ve never seen me before. Well, I have you—in at
Charlette’s last February—I heard you talking to your sister about
“honour and truth and a sure intent.” That was the first look-in I’d
ever had on the subject. You were the first real man that I had ever
come within shouting distance of, who sprung such stuff, and those words
sunk in till they got sewed in me. All the more so because I was—and
am—in love with a man who’d never look straight at me till I made
myself over, and I figured it that somehow those words might be the
combination that would fix me up for him. I always remembered you and
what you said, and I’ve been trying to get all those three things. And
then when you turned up to-night I was as happy as a fool, thinking I’d
be with a real man and he’d give some more dope on how to be a real
girl—then you talk about ending it all, like any thirty-center up
against a dark pocket, and take me for Mazie-off-the-streets thrown in!’

“He didn’t say anything for a few minutes—turned away from me and did a
walk over to the piano. There was a bunch of French stuff on it that Pa
was trying to get soaked into me, and a book of Yvette Guilbert’s. Then
he turned around and I saw he’d lost most of his edge. ‘I want to beg
your pardon,’ he said. ‘I’ve never been so ashamed of myself in all my
life. But I shan’t curse myself for writing that note to you—no matter
what prompted me to do so. Of all girls in New York—to stumble on one
who remembered something I said—something that she thought was doing
her good!

“I saw he’d gone sober, and I put away the cup that cheers too loud. He
came up to me and looked me over—not hot this time, but impersonal. ‘So
you’re in love with someone—who—won’t look straight at you?’ He
squinted his eyes up and took in the general effect, the way I do when I
stand off and look at a model draped in a half-built creation. ‘War
times are not so busy but what I’d like to play Pygmalion for you.’
‘What kind of a game is that?’ I said.

“He laughed, and gave me a close-up of the Pygmalion-Galatea affair. I
didn’t mind if I had pulled a bone—there he was, as keen and peepy as
if he hadn’t been talking about putting a bullet through his brains a
while ago and glimming me as cool and impersonal as if he hadn’t hauled
my hand around a minute back. The main thing was that I’d given him a
jolt—and he’d lost his edge.

“When he left that night, he’d given me a list of books to wade through.
The newspapers had always been my literature—them, and people. But he
told me it would Galatea me some to follow the books for awhile. And he
also said he’d come up to the apartment again in two weeks—he only got
every other week-end off, usually—and see how I was working it.

“After he went maybe I didn’t turn cart-wheels around the apartment till
the people underneath rapped on their ceiling with a broomstick, as they
had nothing to do around that time but sleep, and when people get that
way their mind runs on one track and you have to humour ’em. So I turned
in and thought till it was time to get up. You can always tell when it’s
time to get up—you’re just ready for a real sleep by then. I felt I had
done a good night’s work. By a trick shake of the dice he had landed
with me—and getting interested in my ‘case,’ as I had reeled it off to
him, had pulled him out of a pocket.

“I quit Hanley’s after that. I needed the evenings for getting those
books down. No matter what way I figured, there wasn’t any other time to
do it. He hadn’t supposed I did anything but sing, in which case I would
have had lots of time for his books. Every day of that two weeks was
just another day until he should come again, and when he did——He
looked so much better already that you couldn’t believe it was the same
man. First thing he did was to apologize again for the way he’d been the
other night. Said he’d never been so limp before and never would be
again, thanks to me. Then we slung a line of chatter about the books I
had surrounded, and he asked me was I getting along any better with that
man. I said no, I didn’t see much progress—which was the truth. He
said, well, he’d give me some Mid-Victorian stuff to dive into for next
time, and one book would do me. It was Tennyson’s ‘Idylls of the
King’—and believe me, Joy, it let in a whole new flood of light. I’d
never heard anything like it. When I got to the end of Guinevere I was
sobbing as I hadn’t since I was a kid and had had my bunch of papers
pinched from me. Joy, that book simply burst on me like dynamite. I’d
never heard of ideas like those before. If you read that when you’re in
love, it’ll either make you fall out with a thump or fall in harder than
ever. I fell in harder than ever. Could I wait until he came again? To
talk over the ‘Idylls of the King’ with _him_?”

Jerry spread out her hands, then looked at them and laughed suddenly.
“The action sags from now on, Joy. Because _he never turned up again_.”

“What?” cried Joy.

“He never showed up. I never have seen him since. I waited that
evening—God, Joy, I hope you don’t know what it is to wait like that
for a man who doesn’t come—when you’ve been waiting for days for that
evening—and then he doesn’t come—even when it gets too late,
hoping——And then the waiting afterwards—to hear some
explanation—some reason—watching the mail, jumping at the phone—oh, I
can’t go over it all again!”

“Perhaps he sailed for France,” Joy said.

“I thought of that, of course. But he had told me that another thing
that made him so sick was being stuck permanently on this side as far as
he could see. I thought too, he might have been transferred to another
camp. But whatever happened, to go off without a word—without a word,
for two years——When I thought it over long enough, though, I
understood. I was nothing but an incident in his life—and with soldiers
in war times, incidents flared up and then passed off in double quick
order. Something had happened so that it wasn’t convenient for him to
come around any more—probably he got a new interest—and why should he
bother to let me know? First place, there probably wasn’t any
excuse—just a bare statement of fact——Second place, I was nothing but
a cabaret singer—why should he go out of his way to observe any of the
fine hairs of convention for me? And so on!” Jerry’s teeth clicked.

“Oh, Jerry, I know there’s something more to this. I _know_ there must
be some awfully good excuse.”

Jerry shrugged her shoulders almost out of the purple kimono. “I thought
so at first. It took me quite a while to see that after all, it was a
pretty simple case. When I finally came to my senses, the first thing I
did was to knock the ‘Idylls of the King’ about the room a bit. Then the
very next day in at Charlette’s I keeled over while shooting my mouth
off at a cutter, and though I didn’t actually go out, a lot of little
black specks swam around and everything looked worse than it might have
if I’d fainted in a clean break. I didn’t need any pill-fiend to tell me
it was overwork—the effect of years—I knew it myself, had known it for
aforesaid years. I had to quit Charlette’s, but I kept the stock. The
dividends from that make my only steady income, now, and as you’ve
noticed, I can’t keep to it.

“Somehow, that day when I came to and kicked the ‘Idylls of the King’
about, something had snapped. I guess you can call it my sure intent. I
didn’t want to go on at Charlette’s. I didn’t want to work anywhere. I’d
worked all my life, I’d never had a speaking acquaintance with much of
anything but work and filth, and I felt it was time to give a farewell
bow to each. My sure intent beat it then and there—and the only thing
it left me was just as sure an intent to get as good a time as possible
out of the rest of my life before I got so old that I’d have to put the
snaffle on everything.

“Still, it was war times, and if you can go back into the Dark Ages of a
year ago, you can remember everybody wanted to do something for somebody
else then. I signed up with the Y—but not to go across. My physical
examination wouldn’t admit of that; so I signed up for duty over here.

‘I went and said good-bye to Pa, and he gave me a few tips I didn’t need
about not singing DeBussy to the doughboys. Then I went on my little
See-America-First expedition. It was more fun than I’d ever had, and the
Y people I was thrown with taught me a lot. Some of them were wonders,
others were such frosts that you wondered how even the hall could stand
it, let alone the audience in the hall. I put it over, as my songs were
snappy and my work had cabaret pep; by the same token I let myself in
for a lot of criticism, but since the criticism never came from the
soldiers, I didn’t care and I wouldn’t change my methods.

“You’ve probably heard me cartooned as an international character;
anyway, that’s what I’m called. This touring of the camps was what
started me. I had more freedom with the men than I would have if I’d
been in France, and the college-boy type was what looked good to me. The
reason I liked them both then and now—it’s truer now than it ever
was—is that they had just as sure an intent as I for having as good a
time as possible while they lasted, and I liked their ways of going
about it. They liked me, too, because I was easy to be with and they
could feel just as free as if they were among themselves.

“I suppose that’s the keynote of my relations with men; they can act
just as if they were among themselves. I smoke with them, drink more
than they do and hold it better; I tell ’em stories and sing ’em songs;
they can be as free as possible, and yet with the added pep in the
thought that after all, I _am_ a girl.

“At the end of the summer of 1918, I broke into pieces for a fact, and
the Y put me out for a rest. I think they breathed easier when I was
out, anyway. Before I was in trim again, the armistice was signed. I was
some relieved. As I saw it, the decks were cleared for me. I’d done more
work up to twenty than some people do in a lifetime; for a year I’d
worked for my country; and now I was going to have an everlasting good
time while my pep held out.

“What was the use of any other sure intent? I knew I could never care
again for anybody. I hadn’t seen him or heard of him. So what was the
use of anything—except having a good time? Sometimes I’ve wondered if
he could see me—now—would he like me any better—even if I am polished
off some from the cabaret singer he knew. But what was the use of taking
the ‘Idylls of the King’ to heart, when he wasn’t there to see me? If
he’d left me any other way——Men are like that; they break away clean;
girls make a jagged break, or leak away. He’d gone; and when you stop to
think of it, he was about the only nail I had to hold me down. So what
was the use? And away I popped.

“When the colleges started their parties again, I made my début into
society. I stood it all right, too. The way girls who had been brought
up in front families acted, made it possible for me to get away with my
varnished-over East-Side-plus Charlette style. I was only a little more
so than they were, and that little more so made me a little more popular
than they were.

“I decided to slip my things over to Boston and settle there. You can’t
blaze around at all hours the way you can in New York, but I can always
think of things to do no matter what the material is, and I was sick of
New York. It had got me once and I was afraid it would again. And every
time I went by Charlette’s I felt a pull—but I swore I wouldn’t go back
there. Boston was the nearest all colleges except Yale and Princeton,
and the numbers of little comrades I had in the other colleges, and
Harvard and Tech being right there, cinched the matter. I get to Yale
and Princeton when I want to just the same, and go over to New York when
I feel like it, which isn’t often.

“I met Sal at a Cornell house party, and afterwards ran into her around
a good deal. When I moved to Boston we agreed to hit it off in this
apartment. She comes from a little New Hampshire town, was the village
belle, wore spit curls, rhinestone combs and all that sort of thing till
some underdone Dartmouth freshman took her to Winter Carnival and she
saw she’d found her lifework. She contributed the black walnut pieces
that stick out in this room in spite of my black-and-white efforts. I
wanted to start right, so I got everything we needed. Some of the things
were donated, but even so, what we bought took all my capital except my
stocks, besides whatever few little onions she slipped into count.
Perhaps you’ve gathered there’s not too much love oozing between me and
Sal. I wanted someone to live with; you can see most girls wouldn’t do;
Sal’s the answer. As for the rest about Sal—she can tell you if she
wants to; I’ve told you just as much as touches me and makes it my

Jerry stopped and drew a long breath, much as she had earlier in the
story. “And so you’ve got my life history salted down, Joy. It’s not as
black as the ebonies nor as white as the ivories; I should say the
composite picture would be a nice medium grey, like the sweater I used
to sport.”

Joy had scarcely seemed to be listening for some time now. “But,
Jerry—you don’t still care for that man?”

Jerry’s mouth grew pale. “I do. I could never care for anyone else.”

“But how can you, when he has gone off and left you?”

“Grant has gone off and left you. Do you still care for him?”

Joy considered, and into her cheeks crept a startled flush. “Why—why—I
don’t think I know.”

“Well, then you never felt the way I do. When you’ve lived with a thing
like that for years—oh, it’s so blame all wrong! If I had been a man I
could have gone out and hunted for the person I cared for—_made_ her
give me at least a chance! But what can a girl do but wait and hope and
wonder—and _wait_!” She caught herself up. “H’m—almost turned on the
faucet then, all right. Well, Joy, I’ve spread the story for you. The
present status Sal and I hold is shifty to locate—but we notice we
never meet any fond relatives of our little friends. And so I see now
that it was a raw deal on you in a way, coming to live with us. It puts
you in our light. We’re not ashamed of it, for that’s the way we’re
going to live while we last—but this morning I’ve been thinking things
over, and for the first time I’ve got your side of the matter and so I
think it’s the best thing, for you to go.”

“I was at Pa’s this morning——” Joy began.

“There, he’s one can tell you I’m not much good. I went to him to get
back into shape after my work in the Y, and when I had been there only a
couple of times he told me it wasn’t worth it for me to go on. He said I
drank much too much, and smoked more than that, and he’d been watching
me long enough to see I’d never shake off either. So that ended.”

“I was at Pa’s this morning,” Joy continued as if there had been no
interruption, “and what he said made me decide to stay here—that is, if
you still want me.”

There was a little, breathing pause. Then Jerry spoke in a detached
tone. “Nothing I’ve said has made you change your mind?”

“Why, Jerry—what you’ve told—has made everything _right_! Oh, I was
horrified at first—it all seemed so awful—but to have come out of it
all as you did! Jerry—you’re—you’re _valiant_. I’ve always thought of
that word in connection with you—_valiant_.” Joy’s voice was clothed in
radiant relief. She looked at Jerry with a tenderness she dared not
express—one could not imagine being tender to Jerry.

“I’m not valiant.” Jerry rose, and the pink mules sounded their way to
the door. She stood with one finger on the knob, and with her hair
roughed up about her face, her kimono sliding from the slim angles of
her shoulders, she looked like a great butterfly, undecided whether to
hover or dart away. “I tell you, Joy, I’m not good for you; I can see
that now. I’m not fourteen-karat bad—but I’m an _Excitement-Eater_.
That’s _a new style girl_, and the style is getting popular. I live on
excitement—I feed on it. I can’t live without it. I scatter it around
me—all Excitement-Eaters do. And for you, a little goes a long
way—it’s taken me longer than it should have to discover that. I’m not
good for you. And that’s that.”

“Pa decided me this morning,” Joy repeated; “and that’s that. You can
eat your old excitement all you want—I’m going to eat music—and
languages—and music——Your story just clinches my resolve to stay. Oh,
Jerry, you _are_ valiant. I can see you standing up there with your chin
out telling that man you weren’t Mazie-off-the-street——”

“Valiant! Knock off that word, will you? It gives me the willies.
Valiant! When there’ve been times I’ve wished I _had_ been Mazie—then
I’d have had _something_—and might have kept him a little longer!”

“You’re only talking now!” cried Joy; but the door was swinging, and a
vanishing flutter of purple silk was her only response.


Joy’s decision for steadfast endeavour, having once been made, did not
waver. In the days that followed she began to feel a calm content;
content that she had never known before. All the restlessness, the fits
of uneasiness and depression that had been hers, had vanished in the
light of a concrete objective; Pa’s talk had miraculously swept away the
cobwebs in her brain. There was always the dull ache of Grant’s
continued silence; but as the days wore on, it became more and more

Pa sent her home for two weeks’ rest before she started in on the
program he had mapped out for her, and fourteen days spent in the little
town made her the more eager to begin work. Her father, after his first
welcome and expression of delight at her progress, was as preoccupied as
ever, the surprise incident upon Joy’s exposition of why she must return
to Boston and start a more extensive (and expensive) course of study,
jolting him only temporarily. After all, he knew that other girls went
away to school, and he knew that his wife would have desired this for

Joy no longer felt guilty over his misunderstanding her place of
residence. She had paid the penalty of deceit in hardening experience;
more than the penalty in losing Grant. From now on, she was proceeding
with her eyes opened. That she was to continue living with Jerry did not
mean what her advent to the apartment had meant; it meant that the
apartment was now the best background for her labours, with a piano hers
to practice upon at all hours, and a ménage that was run to suit three
girls instead of thirty, as was the case at the Annex.

The little town was preoccupied. The girls, after their first effusion
of greeting, were as preoccupied as ever in trying to bring the rotation
of the three or four boys in town their way. Joy was different, anyway,
now that she was doing that singing stuff. She wouldn’t sing popular
songs, and that highbrow stuff was awfully boring. She wouldn’t go to
the movies, or bring her sewing over and gossip, so what _could_ one do
with her?

Tom was working for the summer at the Foxhollow Corners bank, of which
his father was president and he in turn expected to be some day, as he
informed Joy in the first three minutes of his first call. He had
another year at college, and in his conversation strayed collegewards.

“Remember Jack Barnett, Joy? Well, he’s married. Pulled it off the other
day, I guess—just got the cards. They used to say he was engaged to
some home-town specimen that he never dared to take to any of the house
parties, and this looks as if there was some truth in it.”

Joy made no comment. Tom babbled on of college affairs. He was the type
of youth who took it for granted that the girl whom he was favouring
with his company would be enthralled with every detail of happenings
that touched upon him. With this genus, the girl’s only requisite is
silence that bespeaks the listening ear. Joy made no remarks until the
end of his call, then she said casually: “Did you ever know Jim Dalton
well in college?”

“Oh, not very. He ran with a different crowd.” It was a familiar college
tone; not insulting; merely relegating Jim to the oblivion where he

“I’ve seen him several times—he’s working in Boston.”

“Oh, he’s all right—I guess his friends like him well enough.”

More praising with faint damns! But Joy did not absorb the mandate of
the busy college man, as she would have last spring. She laughed amiably
as she sped Tom on his way. She was still laughing as she came into the
hall and passed her father, who was coming in from his evening smoke.

“What are you laughing at, my dear?” Mr. Nelson inquired, pausing for a
moment although he had an excellent book of the vintage of ’61 awaiting
him in the library.

“Myself, mostly!” she replied, and went on into the music room, walking
slowly over the tacked-down carpet to her beloved grand piano. How
standards of college changed after college, and how futilely provincial
were they who still saw life through those standards! Jim Dalton was far
from the nonentity class in which she had placed him last spring. If
only Grant had been like Jim——

Her fingers found the accompaniment of little bells, chiming from far
away—and she was murmuring the words—

                      “My only love is always near
                        In country or in town——”

She broke off with a little sob, and her hands stayed without motion on
the soundless keys. “The Unrealized Ideal!” And so it was.

                  “Lightly I speed while hope is high
                    And youth beguiles the race
                  I follow—follow still—but I
                    Shall never see his face.”

“_Grant!_” she cried, then shivered as the sound travelled around the
room, through the tidies and antimacassars, over to the what-not and
glass candlesticks, and back again to her.

How could it all have been so dear—how could she have been so
tremblingly ecstatic? How could it all be ended—leaving everything as
flat and grey as the beach after the sun had been wet-blanketed by the
sea mist, on that day of centuries?——But after the sun had gone—the
moon had come up. She raised her head and started playing again; and
this time it was an old Italian air over which she had been working.

The little town had no place for her; it was preoccupied. And so she
came back at the end of two weeks, ready to plunge into work, actually
longing for the feverish round of the apartment to swirl about her while
she worked. _While she worked._

Pa found her a French woman and Italian professor for instructors, and
he himself taught her the elements of music. “I don’t always like to
bother with this myself,” he said, “but I want you to get it right—see
the poetry and fascination of it—not have it dinned into you in a
cut-and-dried way that only makes you aware of the toilsome mathematics
of the thing.”

She threw herself into her study with an intense concentration that left
her no energy for anything else—that left her almost no time to listen
to the telephone and door bell, and watch the mail . . . for she still
was in that vague expectancy. Surely he would not be forever gone,
without a word save the fitful telephoning during her illness. She
watched Jerry’s gaiety and wondered if beneath, Jerry also was hiding
expectancy—if she still hoped that any day she might hear some
word. . . . She could see Jerry reverting to the newsie in grey sweater
and bloomers, kicking “The Idylls of the King” about the room. Jerry was
not to be blamed. “The Idylls” were long out of date; and where was
there a Perfect Knight?

Late one afternoon, Jerry burst in upon her while she was indulging in a
little light reading: “How to Listen to an Orchestra.”

“Joy, if you study any more you’ll get eye-trouble, and whoever heard of
a singer getting away with wearing glasses? We’ve absolutely got to have
another girl to-night—it’ll do you good to get out! How can you stand
this perpetual-motion-of-the-brain!”

Joy laughed. “Sorry, Jerry, but I couldn’t. Don’t tempt me.”

“Well—you really ought to get out—it isn’t because we’ve _got_ to have
another girl that I wanted you. As it happens, there’s another
available. Félicie Durant is back in town.”

Joy had heard Jerry and Sarah speak of Félicie Durant once or twice, and
the name had left an impression, being about the only girl’s name they
had ever taken the breath to mention.

“I’ll tell you what,” said Jerry; “you nail on your lid right now and
we’ll wiggle over to Félicie’s. You’ve got to have some exercise, and
there’s much more chance of my getting Félicie to go to-night by a
personal interview than if I popped the project over the phone. Come

Jerry was wearing a rumpled lavender linen dress of simple lines. She
watched with an amused eye, as Joy changed into dark things for street

“You certainly are getting Bostonian,” she jeered. “It’s balmy out if it
_is_ fall, and I for one am not going to stifle if other people are
sporting advance-model velvet lids!” And crushing a saucy yellow straw
down over her eyes without bothering to pat her hair into position on
either side, an indispensable rite with most girls in the major
operation of putting on a hat, she dragged Joy forth before Joy could
add a veil and white kid gloves to her costume.

“This is no afternoon-tea call,” she said, hailing a Brighton-bound
street car. “Félicie’s not that kind of a girl—not that she’s my kind,
either, except the way that girl swallows excitement down whole would do
credit to even my digestion.”

“What is she like?” Joy asked, as they joined the circle of
strap-hanging women that crowded the street car full of doggedly sitting

“She’s a jellyfish,” replied Jerry, treading on the toes of the man in
front of her who spread his newspaper as a defensive sheath between him
and the women before him. “She’s got the spine and determination of a
jellyfish. Lives out here with her old great-aunt or something——But
wait till you see her.”

They disembarked over in Brighton where rows of apartment houses
duplicated themselves, and rang the bell at one of faded yellow brick.
The door swung open, and Joy followed Jerry to the right on the first
floor, where an open door awaited them.

“I’m in the kitchen,” cried a voice whose echoes carried hauntingly
silver. “Come on down!”

A first glimpse of Félicie Durant was unforgettable. Large brown velvet
eyes trimmed with elaborate fringes of lashes that curled up at the end,
giving her face a look of starry oblivion to mundane matters; a face
whose daintily regular features were brought out by a skin as smooth as
the surface of a pearl, with a cobwebby maze of ringlets dark as her
eyes, drifting around and away from her temples. All this Joy saw in one
delighted instant. Then the lips, scarlet and full almost to pouting,
parted in a smile of welcome, and Félicie waved a soapy hand at the two

“Don’t come too near me—I’m washing the dog!”

Sure enough. There was the kitchen tub—and a little shivering white
thing being drowned in suds. It was hard to connect Félicie with washing
a dog, however little and white he might be.

“Good for you, old girl,” said Jerry. “Those poodles look like dirty
dish-rags if they’re not put into Lux twice a day. Félicie, this is Joy
Nelson, and you can see she did you the justice of dressing for a nice
formal call.”

“Wait till I rinse him out and then I’ll shake hands,” Félicie panted.
Sharing her breathlessness, the two watched while she first rinsed, then
wrung out the animated mop, and put it down on the floor with an order
to “go to it.” The mop whisked itself out of sight.

“He runs all around and rolls in all the rugs and gets dry all by
himself,” she explained proudly.

“Is that hard on the rugs, or isn’t it? I just asked,” said Jerry.

The fringes flustered; the dark eyes drooped. “Why, I—I never—thought
of that!” Félicie admitted. “But”—she brightened—“this is a furnished
apartment, mostly, and the rugs are the old landlord’s. So it’s quite
all right after all!”

“Does ‘the old landlord’ know you keep a dog?”

“Well—but you would hardly call Fizz a dog, now, would you?” she
triumphed. “Come on in my room while I put on some clothes. She pulled
off and carefully hung up the kitchen apron which had been protecting
her somewhat gossamer attire from the wear and tear attendant on canine
ablutions, and ran before them to a speckless white boudoir that had the
air of not having quite recovered from its last cleaning. In spite of
Félicie’s activities, that was also the way the kitchen had looked.
Jerry’s apartment always appeared to be waiting for its next cleaning.

“I have a new picture of Greg,” said Félicie, disappearing into a
closet. “There on the dressing table.”

A large photograph of a man with sleek, dark hair parted in the middle
and watered back; a face whose good looking conformity could have been
singled out as “a college type” —framed in ivory which carried out the
scheme of the dressing table’s dainty appurtenances.

“It’s good,” said Jerry. “Still in love with him?”

A muffled but none the less sure-fire assent came from the closet. She
evidently was the kind of girl who dressed in the closet if there were
other girls in the room.

“Then why the devil won’t you marry him?” Jerry exploded, slamming the
picture down with a force that made the ivory manicure set start
shimmying. She turned to Joy. “Félicie’s in love with Greg; he’s crazy
as a fool about her; and she won’t even get engaged, much less marry

“Now, Jerry, you know perfectly well you wouldn’t either,” said Félicie,
and again her voice trailed silver, as she came out of the closet.

“Oh, you pretty—pretty—_Thing_!” thought Joy. A white gown of foaming
lace swirled about her, from which the darkness of her eyes and hair and
the redness of her lips gleamed. Her figure now was unexpectedly rounded
and full, proportioned so beautifully that the breath-taking entirely of
the vision inspired Joy to classic simile. As she buttoned herself into
her dress, she looked as Venus rising from the foam would have done well
to look.

“I’m twenty years old,” Félicie was continuing; “and for a girl at my
age to marry would be _sacrifice_, _human sacrifice_. If girls marry
nowadays at twenty, they’re either afraid they’ve got their only chance,
or they haven’t the cash to hold out, or they’re just plain fools. And
you know, Jerry, I’m not any one of those.”

“Go on,” said Jerry. “Joy’ll be interested to hear your theories.”

Félicie appealed to Joy. “Don’t you think so, too?”

Her loveliness stirred none of the animosity in Joy that pretty women
too often arouse in one another. Joy smiled back at her. “Don’t you
think each case is different?”

“Well, take mine. I care more for Greg than anyone. But think if I
should marry him now! Why—I’m only twenty. I’ve got at least four good
years before me of fun and excitement, the best years of my life and
looks, and why should I devote them to being domestic? After I’m
married, I can never have the kind of a good time I have now. I may be
fonder of Greg than anyone—but I’m fond of other men, too! I like the
excitement of each new man, more than—more than——”

“More than marrying Greg,” Jerry supplied.

She nodded in relief. “Yes, that’s it, and the way I look at it is, it’s
better to get it all out of my system before I marry than after, don’t
you think so?”

“You never will that way.” Jerry spoke curtly. “Haven’t you read that
appetite grows on what feeds it?” She lit a cigarette. Félicie’s eyes
roved to her fine lace curtains in resignation before she went on.

“It isn’t as if I weren’t sure that Greg will stick for several years at
least. Why, he never looks at another girl. And it isn’t as if I were
the sort of girl who would expect to go right on adding up men after I
marry. No, when I marry I in going to have a home and children, and I’m
not going to marry until I’m ready for them.”

“It sounds reasonable,” said Joy, fascinated.

“And when I marry I want to live neatly,” said Félicie, with a
comfortable glance around the glistening room. “And _neatly_ to me means
_enough money_. Greg isn’t making enough for that yet—and while I live
here with auntie I have enough. I wish, Jerry, you wouldn’t always pick
on me about him.”

“I hate to see a waste of good material,” Jerry murmured.

“That’s what it would be, if I married,” she retorted, her voice again
carrying high lights. “A girl stands to lose _everything_ by an early
marriage—her looks, her youth, and her _fun_! Can you imagine me with
the yowl of a baby for my only excitement? It’s not a bit like you to
take this stand!”

Joy stole a look at Jerry, but her face was wreathed in smoke as she
answered in lazy tones: “Well, come off the platform, old dear. I was
only heaving a couple of sobs for Greg—that boy has a few brains that
weren’t put in cold storage at Yale. Of course, _I’m_ glad you’re still
on my side of the wall. Came around to make you shove aside anything
you’ve started going for to-night and tack yourself on to a dizzy

“I have a date for to-night, but he’s not a new man,” she ruminated. “Is
it a good party?”

“I said, dizzy! A bunch of Williams men—they’ve cornered the world’s
best jazz-fiends to beat a nasty measure—down at Croft Inn. Private
party—we’ll have the whole place to ourselves. There are one or two
other girls coming, some subdebs from Boston who are going to climb the
waterspout or something, but they told me to get another girl. Like the
noise of it?”

“I should say so! I was only going in town to dance with him alone. Give
me a crowd every time! What’ll you wear?”

“Evening dress stuff, they say, which means the girls will and the men
won’t.” She threw her cigarette stub at the wastebasket, and after a few
waverings which Félicie watched tensely, it went in. “Well—we’ve got to
go along. We’ll be around for you to-night, some time. Be ready!”

“Good-bye, Miss Durant,” said Joy, taking a last comprehensive look at
the massed loveliness before her. She half wished that she were going
that night. To see it drawn up in battle array!

“We must have a movie date some time,” Félicie smiled, but her smile was
changed to a shriek as she followed them down the hall. “You didn’t
close the door, and he got out! Oh, _Fizz_!”

She captured him in the lower entry and held him carefully away from the
lace of her dress, his red tongue dangling, his little eyes peering
pinkly from beneath his drying bangs, as she again speeded them on their

“Well, what did you think of the human jellyfish?” Jerry asked, as they
made for their regular “taxi,” a Subway prepayment car.

“Jerry—I think she’s the loveliest thing I’ve ever seen. But I don’t in
the least get why she’s like a jellyfish.”

“Listen. If you’ve ever seen the animal, you know it’s flabby and yet
you can’t pull it apart. That’s what she is.”

“I don’t know. Her arguments were pretty good; they’ve started me

“Well, all I’ve got to say is this: I never saw anyone fill the flowing
bowl—and drink it and have it left. And I don’t think she can pull it
off any more than anyone else.”

Joy was a little more weary of work than she cared to admit, and found a
welcome diversion in watching Jerry and Sarah prepare for the evening.
Even the familiar spectacle of Sarah whitewashing her neck, back,
shoulders and arms with liquid powder, was amusing. When they left,
wrapping about themselves with conscious sumptuousness new evening
cloaks that Jerry had recently evolved, she could not circumvent a sigh.
After all—she was going from one extreme to the other.

She went to the piano and started playing the score of Faust, as Pa was
now working her through the rôle of Marguerite. “Old fashioned, but it
will teach you much,” he had said. It was all within her increased
powers of vocalisation except the trill in the Jewel Song. When she sang
and played exultantly through the score, she felt lifted to a zenith of
mauve heights which trembled in ecstasy of tone—until her next lesson.
She played now, supporting an even lusciousness of tone—

          “Je voudrais bien savoir quel était ce jeune homme
          Si c’est un grand’seigneur, et comment il se nomme.”

The piano under her hands transmuted itself into a great orchestra; the
walls of the room widened to the huge stage of the Metropolitan; and
she, Marguerite, was standing with clasped hands savouring the wonder of
love at first sight. She was glad that she was more slender than most of
the vocalists who could essay the rôle; and no wig would be needed to
cover her own golden hair.

The sharp ringing of the door bell cut in upon her dream, and stage and
great orchestra vanished together with Marguerite-who-needed-no-wig. She
went to the door with a feeling of irritation. Who——

A tall, brown figure, somewhat leaner and older looking. Eyes that were

“_Grant!_” she cried.

With no more thought than a snowflake takes to melt, she was in his
arms, and their lips met in a kiss that stopped and sighed, then began

“We’d better close the door,” said Grant. In the little pause while he
preserved appearances by shutting them in the apartment, she put herself
away from him, a little breathless, her hair slipping down about her

“_What made me do that?_” she trembled; he was turning to her again, and
she drew away farther and kept the distance between them while leaving
the hall.

“Joy——” The living room gained, he had come up to her again and was
stroking her hair. “I’ve thought everything all out—oh, I’ve thought of
nothing else—and everything’s clear in my mind now. Darling—I want you
to marry me just as soon as you can.”

She stared up at him without meaning, her brain a tumult of horror about
which revolved the question: “_What made me do that?_”

“I’ve thought it all out—and now I know—I was a fool to judge you by
anything but my own love. I—want you, Joy.”

She jerked her head, and his caressing fingers tore her hair. “Go away,
Grant, go and sit down far away from me—so we can talk this

“Impartially! What’s there to talk out—impartially? Joy—I don’t know
what I was thinking of, that night. To even question you—after what we
had been, to each other——It’s all come clear to me, in these weeks of
being without you.”

“Let me hope for your sake—that it won’t take as long for you to get
other facts in life clear to you—as it did, this!”

“I called you up before—and they said you were ill. Of course I knew
that just meant you wouldn’t see me. So I waited—and took a chance on
coming unannounced.”

“I _was_—ill. I would have seen you—I waited for you, after I was

“Joy! You were really ill? Why didn’t you send for me?”

“Why would I have had to? Others—came without being sent for.”

With a hissing intake of breath she drew away from him again, putting
the table between them.

“Why, Joy, what’s the matter, dear? You’re acting as if I were a wild

She moved to the piano and sat on the bench before it. “No, Grant—I’m
merely—protecting myself against myself. When I saw you so
suddenly—after I thought I’d never see you again;—sit down there a
minute—I’ve got to get all this straight.”

He obeyed with a frown. “I don’t understand.”

“Neither—did—I. But now I do! Now I do!” She threw back her head, and
looked at him impersonally. “Grant, you’ve come back too late. I’ve
learned to do without you.”

He made an impatient motion as if to brush her words away. “Do you
expect me to believe that—after what happened a minute ago?”

“That—is what helped me to see! I don’t think—I ever was really in
love with you. It was infatuation—blind infatuation—or else—how could
I have done—what I did just now! I haven’t missed you—except when I
was idle; and when girls are idle they always have to be in love, or
missing someone, or moping because they haven’t got anybody to
miss—that’s the way girls seem to be made!”

“You only missed me—when you were idle,” he repeated as if it were the
statement of a theorem he could not prove.

“Yes, and then I missed only _you_! I didn’t miss your spirit, your soul
to mingle with my own—and so you see, I didn’t have the real, true
longing for you!”

“Then you _did_ long for me!” He had left his seat and come to her; but
she held up wavering hands.

“Passion—dressed up! I wonder how many people know it from love—before
it is too late!”

“Joy, you’re morbid. It doesn’t do to analyze things so. You’ve been
brooding here all evening over your old music; no wonder you see in such
a light. When you marry me, everything will straighten out, and you
won’t get yourself all wrought up over the piano all the time.”

“I see what you mean—and that’s another thing. If I married you now, I
would have to give up my music.”

“Oh, not entirely, of course. You would always have it as a lovely gift,
to take up now and then—but not as a god to slave before and give
everything to——I’ve watched you, Joy, and that’s the way you are. I
wouldn’t respect a man much, who let his wife peg on at the thing in a
professional way, when he could take care of her himself.”

Joy laughed, almost stonily. “Apart from the fact that I don’t love
you—I’m not ready to marry _anyone_ yet. Since I’ve last—seen you,
I’ve made my decision. And I’m only standing on the threshold of my
work! And I never—never could be happy to give it up now—even if I was
in love——A girl waits for the man she loves to establish himself in
his line of work, waits until he has gotten to the place where her
partnership is possible. But judging by you, a man wouldn’t wait for
me—wouldn’t wait until I got my head above water, and then let me carry
on my work after marriage, as he carries on his.”

“Women who advance such arguments are liable to forget that their
business after marriage should be quite different from before,” he said
in a low tone.

She looked at him with unembarrassed eyes. “Supposing I recognised that.
Supposing I said, I will be Domesticity itself after I am married. But I
still require you to wait several years for me—as I must attain the
perfection for which I am aiming, or my soul will always yearn after it,
and I will never be content? What then?”

He did not speak. She turned and played a few chords on the piano. “I’m
nineteen years old—nearly twenty. Say you wait three years and a half
for me—until I’m twenty-three. Would you do that?”

“Joy, you’re talking perfect rot. To wait over three years—to waste the
best years of our life we might be having together——”

“Stop a minute. I will be only twenty-three then. You will be only
twenty-five. That is an age at which most young people nowadays think
themselves lucky to start—and so would you if you didn’t have your own
little inherited income through no effort of your own. Only three years
and a half, Grant! Would you do it?”

“You know perfectly well you’re asking too much for any man. Be
reasonable, Joy. What has gotten into you to make you talk like this? It
seems to me that after I have fought out my problem, and come to you
like this, there might be a little something expected of you.”

She smiled, faintly amused. “Since you had decided, you thought there
was no more to it—but you see, Grant, all that time I was going through
experiences and thoughts—that have made me see that as far as I’m
concerned—_there’s no more to it_.” She rose, her gesture spelling
dismissal. “So you wouldn’t wait—three years and a half, or whatever it
might be. I think that shows, Grant, that your love was about the same
as mine.”

Mesmerized by the finality of her tone, he started to the door, but
stopped halfway. “Am I to believe—that you are always going to take
this stand—be this way?”

“Please do believe it. I am not drunk with music—I shall always take
this stand with you—because, you see, I don’t really love you, and I
suppose that—makes all the difference!”

He gained the door, and stood looking back. She was regarding him with
parted lips, cheeks darkly flushed, a little pulse beating in her
temple, her hair blanketing her shoulders in folds of gold. “And
please,” she articulated in a thin thread of sound—“please forget
me—very quickly!”

“Forget you——” The words escaped him in a sort of wonder. They stood
motionless, eyes fixed upon one another, and into the faces of each
there stole an impatient bewilderment. They had leaped to the peaks of
poetry and youth’s dreams for a few lambent hours, and now the peaks
were far away again. Veiled in the clouds of awakened scepticism and
analysis, the peaks were higher than before, and their aspect had
forever changed.

A tremor passed in the air between them. Knifing across it came the stab
of the doorbell—anticlimax of everyday routine cutting the wheels of
drama from under. Few can stand the swift descent. Joy hesitated, then
came forward. Grant hastily captured his hat, which had rolled to the
hall floor some time ago, and stood brushing off the dust of which there
was a disgraceful amount.

As the door swung open both fell back in different reactions. Jim Dalton
stood on the threshold.

“Good evening, Miss Nelson,” he smiled. “I——” His glance travelled
past her to Grant.

“This seems to be Miss Nelson’s evening at home,” Grant said evenly.
“Good-bye, Joy.”

She watched him signal for the elevator, still brushing the dust from
his hat. Grant would probably be a masculine replica of his mother when
he was her age——

Jim did not speak until the elevator had sunk from sight. “I
was—passing by—and saw the sixth story light on—so I took the chance
of interrupting a party.”

“There was no party, as you see,” Joy answered. Her resentment against
this man had long since died—had died with her regard for Grant—and
instead she felt something she told herself was not quite positive
enough to be pleasure. “Do come in; I think it was very nice of you to
take this chance. You see,” she continued as she led the way to the
living room for the second time in that half hour, “you see. I have had
no chance—to thank you for anything.”

“I hate to be thanked,” he said quickly. “There’s no more futile feeling
than teetering on one’s toes through anything like that—it makes one
feel like such a fool—and then simpering, ‘Oh, please don’t mention
it!’ Oh, please, Miss Nelson, don’t make me say that!”

He was talking away from the subject, and she made no further attempt to
express her gratitude; words on anything touching that night came with
difficulty. He was not looking at her with such persistency that she
remembered that her hair was still flowing down her back, scattering
hairpins hither and yon. She anchored her arms to her sides against the
involuntary hands-flying-to-hair-motion. That would spell a
self-conscious guilt. No, she would leave it that way, and he would
think she was wearing it unconfined because she had just washed it, or
thought it was good for it, or _something_.

“I am going to say something very frank now,” he began, transferring his
gaze to her. This time her hands almost did fly to her hair. _Was he
going to speak of it?_ He continued: “I want to tell you that I know you
don’t like me, and never have, and this dropping-in to-night is going to
be my positively last appearance. To tell the truth—I wasn’t just
passing here at all; I came out on purpose. I had to see you again—to
see if you were really all right now—I haven’t seen you since your
convalescence, you know. But now that I have—and you’re looking better
than I’ve ever seen you—I’m not going to bother you any more by popping

Joy laughed, which rather spoilt the effect of his speech. “You talk as
though you were in the habit of shadowing me!”

“Well—once or twice I did take that upon myself—and I know what you
must have thought of my officiousness. I didn’t have the right, which I
have now assumed really does belong to someone.”

“You mean—Grant? Oh, no.” She brushed the subject aside. “I never
disliked you, Jim; I just hadn’t made room for you in my mind.”

She did not realize that the change in his face was partly due to the
fact that she had called him by his first name; she was so accustomed to
slipping into colloquial terms on short acquaintance, since she had been
with Jerry.

“You mean—that you have ‘made room for me in your mind’—now?”

“Why—yes. I didn’t know it, but I have. The reason I didn’t know
it—was probably because I never think of you as a man. I think of you
as a friend—who once was a friend indeed to me.”

He did not speak for a short space.

“There are very few girls whom I should care to have as friends. Most
girls simply can’t achieve the atmosphere, the uncoloured give-and-take
of friendship,—but I have always felt that you would be different.”

“Don’t put it all on the girl!” Joy laughed. “There are men with whom it
is just as impossible to establish an—an uncoloured atmosphere.”

“Maybe they have been led to think that’s the only atmosphere that can
exist between a man and a girl, by their experience with girls.”

“I wonder why it is,” she mused, “that sooner or later the blame always
comes back to us.”

“Well, I’m glad to hear you defend your sex; girls so often think it’s a
good line to be witty about girls. When ever I hear a girl say she
doesn’t like other girls, I look for something wrong with her.”

“You’re _always_ lecturing!” she cried. “Ever since I first met you,
you’ve lectured about something!”

He laughed. “I certainly take a long way around saying that I would like
you as a friend!”

“I said the same thing myself, a long while ago; so let’s stop arguing
about friendship between man and woman, and be it!”

Their minds were not on their argument. Joy was thinking how rushed, or
distracted, “or something,” she must have always been, not to notice
before how good looking he was. But of course he wasn’t tall, and tall
men were “her type.” “He’s a blond, and I’m a blonde,” she told herself.
“We’re not the ‘opposites that attract,’ but we can be good friends,
just the same.”

If he could have read her thoughts, he would have used them as further
proof for his argument; but since one of Joy’s greatest assets was the
power of preserving a sweet, listening attitude no matter what went on
beneath, he was kept busy, thinking up general subjects to discuss with
this anomaly among the girls, one who did not take the initiative in

When he rose to go, they felt as if they were very old friends already,
having matched opinions, likes and dislikes for nearly an hour.

“Remember, this isn’t your last appearance,” said Joy.

“Remember!——You’re musical, aren’t you? You told me at that dance that
you were studying music here in town. Well—what do you say we take in
some concerts together? And the Symphony—that’ll be fun if only to
watch the audience. Would you care?”

“I’m awfully afraid I shan’t know enough to appreciate the Symphony,”
she hesitated. “But I know it would be a good thing for me, and I’ll go
with you if you’ll promise not to know too much about it.”

“If you could see me! I go—and sit through it—and sometimes I feel
like jumping out of my seat—but most of the time I’m vaguely bored.
We’ll go together, and maybe combined we can get what we should out of

After he had gone, she went back and sang through the score of
Marguerite as if she had had no interruption a little over an hour and a
half ago. A little over an hour and a half—had so short a time passed
since she had seen Grant, had decided so much, had let so much go out of
her life? She could not evoke even a shiver over the blotting out of
that vista of her dreams, nothing but a little impatient frown. Things
had no right to get so dead, after having been so alive.

Lovely girl, that Félicie Durant; even if Jerry did call her a
jellyfish. Her arguments were clear—to marry now when she had four good
years before her which marriage could not replace——Her voice hesitated
on a measure. It sounded almost like her argument with Grant—three
years and a half from her life at this time, which marriage could not

“Oh, but that’s different,” and her voice caught up with the piano
accompaniment and spun heart-satisfying melody—

                        “Je ris—de me voir
                        Si belle—en ce miroir——”


“Say, Joy, can’t you practice your trilling with the door shut?”

Sarah and Joy had met in the kitchenette, about four-thirty in the
afternoon. Their encounters were always a matter of routine, and to-day
they both happened to strike the same time to search for “afternoon
tea.” Sarah had just come to light, and was yawning about in a wrinkled
kimono, her hair done up in curlers, her face pettishly grey. There was
something positively undressed about Sarah’s face at times like these.
Joy had been uptown all day, first at Pa’s, then at her French and
Italian lessons. Returning, she had been practicing a trill exercise,
not aware that Sarah was arising a little later than usual.

“I’m sorry,” she said now, and chewed a cold English muffin—the kind
one buys at the corner delicatessen. “I usually close the door when I
practice, anyway. I didn’t think anyone was home.”

“It certainly is nerve-racking to live in the house with a singer,”
Sarah complained. She had caught sight of her face in a mirror, which
added to the drag of her voice. “Of course I know you have to practice
and all that, Joy, but now that your voice has gotten so much bigger it
carries everywhere—simply everywhere!”

“Glad to hear it, that’s what I’m after,” snapped Joy, and bit into
another discouraged muffin. “It’s hard enough to work all the time
without being picked on for it. To hear you talk, you’d think I sang all

“Now you’re getting cross. I suppose singers have to be temperamental,
though.” Receiving no response to this, Sarah twirled her infinitesimal
braid and tried again: “It’s funny to see you try to be so earnest. No
girl with the looks you know you have can stand the strain of the
student’s life without weakening and breaking away once in a while. And
you can’t tell me that you and that Jim Dalton go to concerts every time
you leave here.”

“We never have gotten along well together, have we, Sarah? I think the
best way for us to do is not to talk when we’re around each other,
unless we can’t avoid it.”

Sarah stared at Joy, incredulous that the mist over the animosity of the
two had at last blown away.

“I mean it,” said Joy, “I need every bit of my energy for my work. I
can’t waste any of it on you. I’m sure you feel the same way about me.
So, let’s not—waste any energy.”

Sarah, regarding her beneath incendiary brows, was just taking on
energy. “It’s true we’ve never gotten on together. It started the first
day you came and put Packy away in your reticule. You walked away with
him, reticule and all. Packy was one of the best playmates I ever
had—his hand and his pocket-book had well oiled connections. And now
through you he’s queered himself, and will never blow around here

“I always felt Packy was at the bottom of it. But I don’t care. I’ve
done my next-best to get along with you, and you too have made somewhat
of an effort, but we can’t get along—so let’s not waste any more

She walked out of the kitchenette, trembling. After a day of
unmitigated, although varied, work, her nerves were rigid, and had given
away at the first little jab.

So far, the fall had been one of steady labour, punctuated only by
Sarah’s jeers and by the music to which she had listened with Jim.
Galli-Curci had come, a marvel and a thrill.

And then, a little after that, they went to hear Frieda Hempel. If
Galli-Curci’s voice was silver, Hempel’s was a rainbow shot with colours
that danced or remained steadfast at will. Joy was powerless to compare
the shimmering of her Proch’s Variations with the crystal joy of
Galli-Curci in the same song. And the roguish dance of her “Fêtes
Galantes,” where by winking she upset the Bostonians to such an extent
that they made her repeat it. The stark tragedy of “The Linden Tree,”
and “Home, Sweet Home,” at the end. Galli-Curci had played it for
herself, and sung it gingerly, with such changes that Jim remarked: “Do
you like ‘Home Sweet Home au naturel or maître d’hôtel?’” “I don’t like
it at all,” Joy had said; “I wish people wouldn’t keep singing it—it’ll
fly to pieces any minute, it’s so used up.” But when Frieda Hempel sang
it, it took the aspect of a new song—new in its charm, old in its
universal appeal——Joy looked around her at the faces turned to the
blue-velvet figure pouring forth the hackneyed words; there was not a
face that did not have a tense, strained expression—hardly a person who
was not winking back a tear or letting them come unashamed. “Home, Sweet
Home,” at which the critics groaned. . . .

She and Jim did not look at each other until they were making their way
out. Then Jim spoke. “Made you think—that the only important thing in
life—was something we both are missing—didn’t it?”

“Oh, to move people like that!” said Joy.

The fall concerts set her to work more furiously than ever. She had not
had the opportunity to compare her voice with others, to gain a proper
perspective, before. Pa remarked that she was actually becoming musical
in leaps and bounds; every week now showed a gain in voice, technique
and musical understanding.

But little incidents like Sarah pricked; and when one was bending every
part of one’s self to work, one had to be perfectly frank about elbowing
little incidents aside. So she justified herself, the remainder of that
day, for taking the stand on which she had walked out of the
kitchenette. Sarah went out for the evening before Jerry had come back
to the apartment, and did not come to tell Joy where she was going
before she started, as had been the desultory custom. Joy was relieved.
Then Sarah had accepted her suggestion. It would really be better for
both of them.

The next morning she was out before there were any signs of life in the
apartment, which was quite customary. She stayed long uptown, as she
attended an afternoon concert and then ate dinner alone at a cafeteria
on Huntington Avenue. It was late when she finally let herself into the
apartment. Jerry darted at her in the hall—a wild looking Jerry, hair
roughed up until her head was one bristle.

‘Joy—for God’s sake—I thought you’d never come back. _Do you know
where Sal is?_”

“Why, no, of course not. She hasn’t been with me. What’s the mat——”

“When did you see her last?”

“Why—yesterday afternoon.”

“She didn’t say where she was going?”

“No. I didn’t see her when she went out. What——”

“You didn’t even see her?” Jerry collapsed on the hall table, leaning
against it with every sagging muscle, her freckles starting out
hurriedly on her white face. “Listen—When I got in this A.M. I looked
in her room to see if she was in yet. She wasn’t. It was pretty late,
but I didn’t think anything about it and went to bed and slept like a
fool. Went there when I woke up at nine-thirty and—she wasn’t there.
Bed, room, everything just the same way it was last night. Her American
Beauty evening dress the only one of her clothes gone—I looked last
night to see what she’d worn, and that was missing—and now—it still
is. _Where is she?_”

“You are sure she hadn’t come in—and gone out again——”

“In her American Beauty evening dress? That would mean she came in at
three A.M. the soonest she could have come and I not heard her—and
gotten up at nine at the latest she could have and I not heard her—and
gone out in evening dress and not come back yet! It’s nearly nine now.”

Joy considered, putting down her music roll. “You don’t know who she
went out with last night?”

Jerry shook her head. “If I’d only been home when she started——”

The shriek of the telephone scared them both out of their positions.
“You answer,” said Joy, and together they shivered to the closet down
the hall in whose privacy they had their telephone conversations. Jerry
lifted up the receiver. “Hello, oh, hello, Davy. She isn’t here just
now. Oh, that’s all right, we _were_ going to that dance to-night. Do
you know by any chance who Sal went out with last night? You do?” She
wound the telephone cord around one finger and then watched it tighten
as she pulled until the finger grew livid. “Oh, will they be around at
the dance to-night? Oh, well—you needn’t bother. Oh, all right, only I
haven’t put on my gingham yet, so don’t make the poor kid race all the
way. See you later.”

She slammed down the receiver and turned to Joy. “That was Davy—he and
Wigs were taking us to that Tech dance to-night, you know. He called up
to say they were sending a Freshman who has a car, over to get us—they
have to bone for some nine o’clock exam to-morrow till the last minute.
Come on into my room till I get into something.”

“But what—who——” stuttered Joy as she followed her into the
wilderness of clothes that was Jerry’s room, and watched her pull a
glittering green sequin dress from the collection—“What did he tell you

“He said he knew that Sal was going to the Toast and Jam last
night—there was some big celebration there—with Crawf Harris and
Dum-Dum Barnes, because they had asked him to come along too with a girl
he had a date with, but he had theatre tickets and so they didn’t——”

“And now what are you going to do?”

Jerry raked her hair smooth with two military brushes, her latest idea.
“Do? Why, go to that dance and get those damn little rounders to tell me
what went on, where they left Sal, and so on—and believe me, there’ll
have to be some fluent explaining!”

“I don’t understand.” Joy moved about around the debris of the room, too
nervous to sit down. “But I—I can’t stay here, Jerry, while you——”
She vanished from the room. When she returned some minutes later, she
wore hat and coat. Jerry, who was swiftly puckering up a split in a silk
stocking made by putting her foot in it too abruptly, jerked an
inquiring eyebrow. “What in——”

“Jerry—I know you can look after yourself and do everything and always
have; but nevertheless there are times—if we are unlucky enough to have
those times—when a man is absolutely necessary—a man we can trust. I
think this is one of those times—and I’ve telephoned Jim Dalton to come
out here as quickly as possible.”

Jerry nodded. “I’m glad you did. It—it does look like one of those
times—and Wigs and Davy wouldn’t be even up to zero on a proposition
like this.”

The two girls sat waiting in a silence broken only once or twice.

“Of course—it may come to nothing.” This from Jerry. “There must be all
sorts of reasons——”

“Oh, there must be reasons. But——” Joy could not throw off the horror
that was settling upon her. “But—where else could she be, and why? She
has no other girl friends—oh, _Jerry_! Why, of course—there’s Félicie

“I called her up at noontime,” Jerry droned. “She hadn’t seen her for a
week or so.”

The bell rang finally.

“Bet it’s the freshman; freshmen always are early”; from Jerry.

But it was Jim. Just the sight of him made Joy a little more calm. He
was the sort of person to whom one turned naturally; he gave out that
“quiet strength” which is too often imposed upon to carry the burdens of
others. A few swift questions, more or less hysterical answers, and the
story was before him. A moment, and Jerry found the generalship taken
away from her as Jim gave orders of procedure. He had not completed
mapping out their line of action when the freshman arrived, a freshman
who looked rather stunned to find instead of the described pair of girls
in evening dress, a girl in street clothes, with a man, and one lone
girl with pale face, fiery eyes, and bobbed hair, who was wrapped in a
velvet cloak from which protruded a peacock fan—a girl who treated him,
doggone it! like a regular chauffeur. She might at least have come in
front with him and left the two street-clads by themselves; but no, they
all sat in back, whispering until he hauled his car into place at the
end of a moderately long line in a narrow Boston street. Then, and then
only, did the girl with the bobbed hair condescend to speak to him.

“Do you happen to be familiar with Dum-Dum Barnes and Crawf Harris?”

“Not too familiar,” he replied cautiously. “They’re Seniors.” Then, as
they made no move to disembark: “Aren’t you coming in?”

“That’s as might be,” drawled that bobbed-haired girl. “You can go in
and see if Crawf and Dum-Dum are there. If they are, you can tell ’em to
come out here Q. E. D.—if not, come out and tell _us_ Q. E. D. As for
Wigs and Davy—if they’ve got there yet, why, you can tell ’em I’m
located here.”

He went off, muttering “Gotcha,” more than ever convinced that she
thought he was a chauffeur. When he returned five minutes later, the
three were in the same rigid expectancy in which he had left them, with
that continued stillness which denotes an uninterrupted absence of
conversation. The freshman cleared his throat. Decidedly there was
something very cagey about this whole affair.

“I—well, I can’t locate Crawf and Dum-Dum,” he said. “They’re Seniors,
you know; I don’t know them very well; and everyone’s dancing in the
dark in there, so I can’t make out. Wigs and Dave don’t seem to have
gotten there yet——”

“Then we’ll come in—I can see in the dark better than any other way,”
and one by one the three climbed from the car. The freckled faced girl
turned to him with a sudden, grandiloquent sweep. “Thank you very much
for the use of your car, sir. I shall mention you favourably in my next
letter to the _Transcript_.”

The three were gone, and the freshman, after a bewildered grunt, drove
off to the Copley, where a party of his own kind awaited him. Not for
him as yet the Tech fraternity dances.

As they entered the hall, Joy caught her breath. Never before had she
seen such a spectacle. Three wide rooms were given up to dancing—the
orchestra playing in the hall—sole illumination, the dim one that
filtered from the hall into two of the rooms, and as for the third, it
remained in blackness relieved only by ghostly dresses clasped to white
shirtfronts. The three stared from the doorway for a moment of silent
fascination. It was like some hazy, voluptuous dream—feverish music,
quickening the throbbing of desire—the little sigh of figures
interlocked, moving in time to the throb, in the dripping black velvet
of the dark. It was something one might have imagined in the days of

“Barbaric,” Joy murmured as she caught Jim’s eye and knew she was
flushing—flushing under the music, which quickened the uneven pulse of

“No—not barbaric,” said Jim. “Barbarians are—more direct.” He turned
to Jerry. “Do you see them yet?” She shook her head, eyes straining
after the dancers. “That freshman had no initiative. He ought to
have——” He strode over to the orchestra, spoke to the boy at the
piano. A few more bars, and the music stopped, the pianist tapping on
the drum for quiet.

“I am asked to announce,” he said shrilly, “that Mr. Barnes and Mr.
Harris are wanted in the hall.”

The music took up its beat, and the dancers in the dark, who had barely
stopped, began again.

“I should have thought of paging them, only I’m so rattled,” said Jerry.
“Thank God for Jim.”

He came back to them; through another opening into the hall charged two
lads with question and not much else on their wide young faces. Jerry
stepped forward and spread her fan in front of them, an excellent
substitute for buttonholing, as they drew up with a start.

“Hullo, Jerry,” said one. The other said nothing; he was presumably

“This is them,” said Jerry, with a jerk of the fan. “You two, this is
Miss Nelson and Mr. Dalton. And we want to know right now where Sal
Saunders is.”

Dum-Dum opened his mouth and closed it.

“Did—didn’t she get back?” Crawf demanded, jaw hanging loosely. “You
aren’t stringing us, Jerry? Trying to get a rise?”

“Nix!” Jerry snarled, her wide lips curling back from her teeth. “Where
did you leave her?”

Crawf looked at Dum-Dum, whose speechless countenance gave forth no
help. “Why—why—we—I——Haven’t you heard a word from her? Don’t you
know where she is?”

“We do not,” said Jim. “And you two, since you are the last two known to
be with her, are responsible.”

“Jesus!” said Dum-Dum, and collapsed upon the stairway.

“I’ll swear—I’ll swear—if she’s gotten into anything, it’s her own
fault!” Crawf’s sagged jaw did not close with this chivalrous utterance.

“Buzz on with the tale, you little gnat!” Jerry cried, threatening him
with her fan. He retreated, a few steps.

“I—I—well, we went down to the Toast and Jam.”

“We know that—go on.”

“And—and I suppose we did get pretty fuzzy. You know Sal—you know she
never can hold it. We told her to cut down, but you know how much effect
that has on her; pretty soon she was so blotto she was making eyes at a
couple of old boys in the corner. Isn’t that so, Dum-Dum? Wasn’t she

Dum-Dum nodded.

“The old boys got fresh and we were feeling good, so—well, I guess we
got mixed up pretty well. Well, then we thought we’d come away, in fact
the head waiter or some such stuff requested our departure, all of us,
so we eased out. Got out to the car and the old boys’ was next. Of
course Dum-Dum couldn’t start it.”

“The old boys’ car?”

“Nope; ours. Sal got sore right off—said we were doing it on purpose.
The old boys stayed in their car and watched the fun. Dum-Dum got under
the car, but that didn’t do any good. Finally I got under too. Dunno how
long we were fooling around there—my pocket lamp burnt out—but we
heard Sal talking. Thought she was talking to us, so we didn’t listen.
Then all of a sudden we heard some brakes grinding a tune, and Sal
yelling she’d never get back to town with us so she was going with them.
I rolled out from under and saw the tail-lights of the old boys’ car
spinning away.” He stopped and looked at them appealingly. “What could
we do? We couldn’t speed up and follow after. All we could do was sit
around and cuss Sal—which we did, complete. Then we worked on the car
some more till somehow Dum-Dum slipped a cog and fixed it.”

“Let me get this straight,” said Jim. “You take a girl down to a road
house, get her drunk, and then let her sail off with two strange men,
having no other objection than cussing?”

“What else could we do? We couldn’t get a taxi and follow them up—it
was no free garage.”

“But there were other cars, and owners who could be made to understand.”

“Whadyoumean, understand?” Crawf had been regarding Jim with increasing
objection. “Perhaps you’re in the habit of stealing cars from
understanding owners. I don’t get that way.”

“And seeing her go off, you thought no more of the matter—didn’t even
call up to-day to see if she had reached home safely.”

“We’re having exams——” began Dum-Dum defensively, still on the

“I’ll admit—it did occur to me to call up, but we’ve been so busy——”

“Busy dancing,” Jerry supplemented.

“And honestly, it never for a minute entered my head but what Sal would
get back; she’s a girl who takes darn good care of herself——”

“We are living in strange times indeed if a man thinks a girl can take
care of herself under such circumstances,” said Jim.

“What did the old boys look like?” Jerry snapped.

Again Crawf looked at Dum-Dum for aid, but Dum-Dum closed his eyes with
a weary air.

“I—I swear I don’t remember. They were about fifty—or maybe forty, or

“Or even seventy——” Jerry bit in.

“Hang it, no! They had teeth and hair and things. Grey hair or getting
grey—that sort of stuff. One of ’em wore glasses and one of ’em smoked
rotten cigars.”

Jim squared off, looking at them in unhurried, but imperative fashion.
“Have you two got your car here? Well, get your evening wraps and come
along with us while we use it. We’re going to the Toast and Jam—to see
if the people there know anything more, or can remember better than you,
about these two men. And on the way down you can try to call back a
better description of them.”

Jim was of compact build, although so thin that he had not an ounce of
flesh that could be trained down. There was something about him that
looked very forceful as he faced the two boys.

“I—we both have girls at this dance——” Crawf began, while Dum-Dum
looked wildly around from four corners of his eyes.

“Well, get two stags to take ’em, if you feel any responsibility about
’em—tell ’em anything—but come as quickly as you can.”

The two boys vanished through the opening.

“They’re still dancing in the dark,” said Joy monotonously.

Jim consulted his watch. “We’ve only been here a little over six

“I never saw anything like it—whole dances in the dark. Do they keep it
that way all evening?”

“Oh, no.” Jerry was weaving with her fan an accompaniment to the music,
unconsciously swaying back and forth in rhythm as she did so. “They turn
’em on after awhile. It gives you a new sensation, anyway——That’s good
jazz, I’ll tell anyone.”

That was it. Dancers in the dark—in search of a new sensation. Jerry
was beckoning to a man who had come out to speak to the orchestra. “Oh,
Fred,” she said, easily: “do me a favor? When Wigs and Davy see fit to
blow in, will you tell them that we got sick of waiting and have gone
out with Crawf and Dum-Dum?”

“I’ll do that little thing for you; but they’ll be fit to be tied,” Fred
responded with a grin. He stayed carrying on a light badinage with Jerry
until the two boys reappeared, coats over their arms, their broad, mild
countenances for once overrun with emotions, which were added to as Fred
thrust them parting darts about how Wigs and Davy would pay them out for
playing the fresh young Lochinvars.

The two boys sat in front, and the trio sat together in back as before.
Jerry was still humming the tune that the orchestra had been playing—

                 “All the knowledge learned at College
                 Still that don’t explain——”

Jerry had found time to wish that she might have been among the dancers;
Jerry, the excitement-eater. They had passed a movie palace letting out
crowds from its first show. Excitement-eaters all . . . who for want of
excitement of their own, had gone to swallow down excitement in
reels—of indiscriminate kinds. Indiscriminate excitement by
proxy—excitement that exhausted or stimulated, but created the appetite
for excitement at first hand.

Jerry stopped humming. “If only this hadn’t happened at the time of the
police-strike. But what can those Home Guard birds do?”

“It may not have to come to that,” said Jim.

They veered away from the city outskirts, and started pounding down the
State Road towards the South Shore. It was cold, and the boys in front
drove with sullen swiftness.

“I feel somehow—as if this were the end of the world,” said Joy
miserably. Such awful things are happening that the world’s just got to
topple over sometime—and to-night feels just like it.”

“I wonder what _is_ going to happen to the world,” said Jim. “Every year
since I can remember people have been saying we’ve been going from bad
to worse, and I used to think they were old fogies; but I can see the
descent myself, it’s getting so rapid—and I can’t be an old fogy—not
at twenty-four.”

“Funny how we’ve all gone back on the way we used to feel during the
war,” said Jerry. “It’s just as if the world had turned a double back

“Everyone admits that the world is turning around too fast, and that
everyone’s got their eyes turned in upon themselves too hard, but then
they go right on,” said Joy somewhat pointedly. The memory of Jerry’s
evident reluctance to leave the music was still repugnant.

The three lapsed into a silence supported by the sucking gasps of the
tires as they slid along over the well oiled highway. After fifteen
minutes had passed in quiet travel, their progress became slower, the
boys in front casting uncertain eyes up each side road they passed.

“What’s wrong?” Jim called to them.

“Why—I’ve forgotten just where we turn,” Crawf responded. “Sal pointed
out the way last night—we’d never been down before, you know——”

Dum-Dum put on the brakes and came to a stop. There was a lone man
wandering along the road, coming into the spotlight with which the front
lamps were cleaving ahead.

“Where do you turn off to get to the Toast and Jam?”

The wayfarer jerked his thumb. “Next to your right, an’ straight through
the cross roads. But you won’t find no toast nor no jam there!”

The echoes of his cackling appreciation of his own wit followed them
even through the cross roads.

The “Toast and Jam” proved to be a large, rambling white farmhouse,
nestled on a hill, with a dense thicket of automobiles flanking the
barn. Riotous music surged from the windows, and a man’s loud voice

“You girls stay out here,” said Jim, “Mr. Barnes will stay with you.”

“Not a prayer!” Jerry cried, leaping out. “I want to ask a few little
questions myself. If I don’t look in on this, what was the sense of my
cutting the dance?”

“True,” said Jim, and met Joy’s eyes for a moment as he helped her
descend. Jerry had joined the two boys, and Joy and Jim brought up the

“It’s just that if you saw anyone you knew here, they’d wonder what you
were doing in a place like this,” Jim said suddenly.

“They’d be here, too,” she retorted, “And although I may not have been
to this particular place, the first of the summer I thought I took in
every road house there was. Goodness knows that I long ago stopped
worrying about appearances!”

This was the sort of speech that would have made Grant’s hair rise, she
reflected, the minute she spoke; Grant would have thrown back some icy
remark that would only have goaded her on. But Jim looked down at her
without speaking, and something in his keen eyes made her feel very

They entered the Toast and Jam. A low-ceilinged white hallway through
which they looked in to a long, cozily gotten-up dining-room, with
tables thrust along the sides. A colored orchestra at one end with a
negro bawling out the words of the selection, and a piebald mass of
dancers, exercise of contact whipping their blood higher and higher, the
heat from the low-studded room growing with motion, so that they had to
cling but stickily; but they clung. An assortment of all ages, having a
preponderance of older men with more or less younger women whose general
get-ups were equivocal.

“Do you remember your waiter? And find whoever it was who requested you
to leave last night,” said Jim to Crawf, who slid into the dining room.
Jerry streaked after him, her fan waving in determination, and Jim
followed, with a request that Dum-Dum stay with Joy.

They waited in a silence that grew so appalling, with nothing to watch
but the shivering of the dancers to the syncopated shriek of the
orchestra, that Joy finally said in a tone as nearly ferocious as she
could make it: “Do they call you Dum-Dum after the bullet or because
you’re just plain _dumb_?” At his amazement, she hurled on; “It must be
because you’re dumb—otherwise I don’t understand—how you could have
been so careless—of a nice girl!”

He opened his mouth and closed it. His silence had suddenly changed
colour. It was almost as if he had; and she read it as easily as if he
had spoken. They were not so—careful—with Sarah as they might have
been with “nice” girls. Jerry had diagnosed it—the key of their
relationship with men was that the men acted as if they were among
themselves. There had been just that careless oblivion, that utter lack
of the protective instinct toward Sarah; and the idea of it was so
horribly perverted that she gave a little shiver.

“Aha, shimmying?” said Dum-Dum, finding speech at last. “Music too much
for you? Come on, let’s dance till the others get through.”

She looked at him so strangely that his inviting pose disintegrated and
he toppled back. “That’s—_the first thing I’ve heard you say_. Must I
take that—as the keynote to your character?”

He was regarding her with alarm and now spoke soothingly. “Oh all right;
but it’s darn good music!”

“_Good music!_” She checked herself. After all, silence was preferable
to talking in different tongues.

Jerry came back to them on feet that no longer lilted to the music, her
face sagging white against the painted masks of the girls on the floor.
Crawf followed with a defiant expression, and Jim came last.

“They don’t remember a thing,” said Jerry; “they’re perfect nitwits, the
whole nest of ’em. Every waiter spilled a different description—the
head waiter doesn’t even remember whether they were old or young.”

“It seems to be the custom here,” said Jim, “to forget things like

“But the cash you forked out would have tickled their memory if there
had been anything to tickle,” said Jerry.

“What can we do now?” Joy asked limply. Somehow she had felt that coming
down here would solve everything—that it was going to end up smoothly,
things would explain themselves and roll into place, just like the
ending of a story.

The five stood in an indecisive little group, looking at each other. A
waiter who had been darting his head around a corner to survey them at
intervals now darted himself around and approached them with a
velvet-covered but none the less insistent air. “If your party is not
coming inside——?”

They left as indecisively, and drove home in amazement. It had not
occurred to them that they would not be able to read the dark pages of
this affair. The sensation of utter futility is new to youth, and
momentarily stuns. Until they had followed up every avenue of
investigation left them, they had evaded the wings of horror that had
been hovering ahead. Now there was room for all that awfulness. They
spoke in low tones, the situation becoming more hopeless as they
discussed it. Jim said the publicity of the police was not to be
desired; Crawf and Dum-Dum, abject almost to cringing by now, said that
of course they would finance investigation through a private detective
agency, which proposition was speedily approved by Jerry. Joy sat in the
tentacles of a memory that added horror. _What were the last words she
had ever said to Sarah?_ A practical request to keep out of her life,
and she, Joy, would do the same. Under the calcium ray of this dreadful
evening’s events, her words were conceited, selfish,
ill-tempered—self-sufficient. If one only knew, when words were flying
around, that those were the last words that person would ever hear from
one’s mouth—how many things would remain unsaid!

A repressed goodnight to the two guilty youths, and leaving Jim, who was
to go straight to the detective office. She and Jerry went to Sarah’s
room of one accord, then wandered aimlessly through the empty-seeming
apartment before going to bed. . . .

“She’ll turn up,” said Jerry; but her voice hung fire.

She did not turn up. Days thickened into weeks, with the detective
bringing steady reports of investigation along a blank wall. Something
that he had said on undertaking the case quivered in Joy’s memory.

“A missing-girl proposition is almost hopeless, you know, when twelve
thousand disappear every year.”

“Twelve thousand a year—in this country!” she cried, and he nodded.

“So you see—it gets pretty difficult.”

It was a strange thing—this voidness that had been Sarah. When Sarah
had been there, their lives were as separate as if they had been two
strange boarders in the same boarding house. She had never found
anything in common with Sarah; she had never tried to. She had disliked
her, and not done her best to conceal this dislike. Now Sarah was gone,
and her absence made no ripple in Joy’s life. How could she miss her
absence, having never really felt her presence—having even suggested
that they ignore each other’s presence? But her going left Joy with a
queer feeling of self-hatred. Sarah had been a lonely figure, a drifter
on the churning waters of excitement; a drifter with nothing upon which
to cling, knowing no more than to keep her head above the rising tide.
And Joy had faithfully imitated the performance related of certain
people, who, some nineteen hundred years ago, had passed by on the other

Passing by on the other side was glossed over nowadays as: “It isn’t any
of my business.” Everyone did it about everyone. In this new analysis
she wondered—-if she had not been passing Jerry by on the other side
also. The answer rose automatically to her throat: “It isn’t any of my


It was after the Christmas holidays, which Joy had worked through with
no let-up save Christmas day at home with her father, that Pa announced
a change in schedule.

“You are working too steadily,” he said. “You never do anything else;
you will turn into a machine; then you will no longer be a girl, and the
warmth and glory of your appeal will be gone. Like that! Moreover, it
takes a fine shade of quality from your voice; I want you to use it as
an instrument, of course, but I think too much of how hard you have
worked, and how dull your skin and eyes are getting, when I hear you.”

“Do you really think I’m losing my quality?” Joy demanded.

He laughed. “There—do you see what you just said? That shows you are
turning into a little tuning fork, my dear. A _girl_ would have cried:
‘Are my skin and eyes _really_ dull?’ or at least looked in the mirror
in front of you.” Before her attitude of unrelaxed question, he grew
serious. “No, your quality is not as yet impaired in the slightest; and
you are soaring along so swiftly that I cannot believe you have been
with me for so few months. But a good teacher can see a fault pending
before it takes possession; and as I have so often remarked, I am a good
teacher. You need a change.”

“Are you going to send me home for a rest?” she asked in swift

“No. You are going to New York. Take some friends along with you if you
wish; stay at the Belmont, where all the _nice_ Bostonians stay when
they deign to turn their faces westward; go to the opera; go shopping;
in short, have not a rest, but a vacation.”

“New York!” she breathed. “Oh, Pa—do you really mean it?”

He nodded. “And I want you to sing for my baby.” He mentioned a name
that was a household word for glory of song, a name that shone high and
clear in the eminence where only the truly great stars remain, while
others tremble for a day and then are gone.

“Sing—for—her!” Joy gasped. “Oh, Pa, I couldn’t—not yet!”

“Little Joy—you will find as you go on, that the greatest ones will
always be the easiest and kindest before whom to sing. They know the
real elements, and can distinguish lack of training from lack of
endowment; and they know of how much value is encouragement, along the
weary ladder of the artist. I shall write her a letter, and she will
send you word at the Belmont when to come.”

As she thought it over, she could not remember when she had been so
excited. Jerry shared her anticipation, and announced that she was going
also; it was a good opportunity to select models for her next sale.

“We can get Félicie, too,” she said; “It’s about time she went over to
see Greg again.”

Neither voiced the mutual thought, that two of them going to New York
alone seemed incomplete. Félicie made a third—possibly a more
harmonious third than the other who had silently dropped from their

Félicie acceded to their plans, and Joy wrote her father for money for
the trip. His answering check and letter came when the three girls were
all in Jerry’s room, Jerry “toning up” several of Félicie’s costumes.
Joy read the letter with half her attention on Félicie’s bewitchingness
in a pale green velvet that shone dully like moonlight on an even lawn,
throwing out her colouring and features in rich relief. Suddenly a name
on the page caught her attention. She looked again and then read the
paragraph over slowly:

“I hope while you are in New York that you will see your cousin Mrs.
Eustace Drew, who was Mabel Lancaster. The Lancasters of whom you have
heard me speak; they were your mother’s cousins once removed, and we
have not kept up the relationship as she would have wished. I have
written Mabel that you are coming, and she will undoubtedly call on you
at the Belmont.”

She sat for a moment watching Jerry swirl the velvet on Félicie into
marvelous lines. Mabel Lancaster—who had come into Charlette’s for her
trousseau, with her brother, Phil Lancaster—of whom Jerry still thought
with unquenchable flame. Her first impulse was to show Jerry the letter,
share her surprise at this identification of New York cousins she had
heard her father mention so many times. Then she held herself back. What
if cousin Mabel would forget to call upon her—what if she wasn’t the
same one, after all—Joy had forgotten the married name Jerry had given.
So she tore the letter into tiny bits, and prepared for the trip with
excitement that grew to boiling point as she savoured the amazing
possibilities of the coincidence, if coincidence it was.

They took the midnight train, landing in New York in time for breakfast,
which they ate at Childs’ opposite the Belmont.

“Although even this place is getting too expensive,” Jerry grumbled.

They giggled all through the meal from sheer light-headedness at being
off together. The French waitress had brought them their griddle-cakes,
smiled at them in delight, and said as they left: “You act like all
young girls should—happy and gay.” This set them off with renewed
impetus, and after installing their luggage at the Belmont and as Jerry
said “spreading more around in the way of tips than we ate for our
breakfast,” they spent the morning going through the Fifth Avenue shops,
seeing all “the latest models” with an economical thoroughness that left
enraged saleswomen behind them. In the afternoon Félicie curled up for a

“I never sleep on sleepers, and if I don’t look my best, Greg will
notice it and say it’s because I’ve been running myself ragged in
Boston,” she explained, burrowing her head down under the covers, from
which came forth the muffled request: “Please don’t open any windows;
you know I can’t sleep where there’s too much air around; it distracts
my attention.”

Jerry had made arrangements for tea with two Princeton men, and Joy had
willingly consented to go with her. She was just in the mood for
squeezing the orange of her good time in New York dry.

They met the Princetonites in the lobby—two well-tailored youths, with
that sleek, parted-in-the-middle college expression. The taller of the
two, one Steve Mitchell, combed Joy up and down in one competent sweep
of the eyes, and annexed her, while the other, poetically called Harry
Hanigan, followed Jerry, who had done no more than greet them airily,
shove Joy at them just as airily, then make her way to the nearest door,
which fronted on the line of taxis.

“This place always acts as if it were the Methodist quarterly
conference,” Harry complained loudly. “Come on, Jerry; let’s put in a
little pep.”

He stepped with Jerry inside the swinging door, and pushed it, starting
off so fast they had to dart around with it in self-protection—or so it
seemed. A gentleman around forty, of a comfortable figure, had happened
to be entering the swinging doors on the other side, and he too was
forced to dart around for self-protection. But whereas his expression
was varied, Jerry and Harry seemed to be enjoying themselves. The pace
of the revolving doors increased; it almost looked as if the gentleman
of no longer comfortable proportions were running a marathon, while the
two-in-one on the other side sped over more merrily.

“Why—they’re doing it on _purpose_!” Joy exclaimed.

Her companions looked about them at the crowd of grinning bellboys
collecting, together with the scattering of guests who were pretending
not to watch while keeping tabs on every round. “I should think Harry’d
get sick of this; he’s done it in almost every hotel in New York,” he
said restfully, and waited. The pace slackened; soon the two wedged
themselves out of the pinwheel, and waited until, crimson-faced, the
third party in the proceedings flew out and bore down upon them.

“Awfully sorry, sir,” said Harry earnestly. “I got packed in with this
lady by mistake, and we were so confused we started whirling around—you
can see how that would be—and then I lost my head and lost count——”

The intent to kill was by no means abated in the eye of the flaming one.
With a hasty, “By George, Mary, we must catch the train; we’ve lost a
lot of time with this gentleman here!” Harry seized Jerry and drifted
through the revolving doors once more. No one went after them. Joy and
Steve found them by a taxi outside, Harry leaning up against it in a
Napoleonic attitude.

“Was that neat, or was it not?” he hailed them triumphantly. Steve
helped the girls into the taxi, pushed Harry inside, and said to the
man: “Drive to the Astor roof.”

“Where’s that?” the driver asked, turning a helpless expression upon

“Why,—you drive to the Hotel Astor, and then just keep on driving up to
the roof.” Steve spoke sweetly, considerately, as one might to a child,
then climbed in and banged the door.

“Just for that, he’ll go the long way around,” Harry complained, peering
out at the meter as they started off.

“You have such cheap ideas, Harry!” said Dave. “Jerry knows us, of
course; but I was going to make Miss Nelson think we were millionaires.”

“Never mind—we’ll make the waiters at the Astor think we’re
millionaires. Not in the obvious way! But by the good old method of gas.
What do you say—are you game, Jerry?”

“The waiters don’t listen the way they used to,” Jerry objected.

“Oh, you haven’t been around with us for some time! Look here; I—-I’ll
be the Western magnate; I’ve got a whacking black cigar I’ve been
keeping just for this. Jerry, you look as though you could have come
from most anywhere; you’ll be my wife, and I probably picked you up in
some mining camp while I was getting rich, or something. See? Act with
that as a background. We’re the recent rich, that want anything that’s
high-priced or has a fancy name. Get it?”

“And I,” Steve contributed, “will be a New York crest-rider—gay young
rounder—look down on you of course, but keen to wangle the contract out
of you through this social means.”

“Contract! Oh, yes, there’s got to be a contract!”

“Cer-tain-ly. A million dollar one. We’ve got to make this party as
doggy as possible. And Miss Nelson here can be my fiancée—I’ve dragged
her along to impress her with my importance—you’ll be typical New York
yearling, Miss Nelson, bored with anybody but your own set, bored with
business, furious at me for bringing you, try to get all the men at the
other tables to look at you, then turn ’em down with a haughty
stare—you know.”

Jerry stood up on the taxi, struggling with herself. “I am nothing if
not artistic,” she said; “and if I’m to be a
mining-camp-varnished-with-dollars-product, I shall look the part.”

“That’s one of your best points, Jerry,” approved Steve. “You do a thing
up right.”

She sat down again, barely in time before they drew up at the Astor and
poured forth. Joy caught her breath in an abortive laugh, as they
solemnly filed through the luxurious lobby, Jerry leading as usual. In a
few swift touches, Jerry had changed herself from the breezy mondaine
upon whom everything naturally looked right and leads to the harmony of
that elusive completeness that is style, to the woman who, with obvious’
means and as obvious a wish to look well, pathetically falls just short
of the mark. Her skirt sagged, ever so little, but still condemning
enough; the buttons on the coat of her duveteen suit were fitted loosely
in the wrong buttonholes; her hat was tilted back ingenuously, revealing
a wide expanse of forehead, and she had pinned her hair in here and
there so that the remains of its bobbed audacity had the appearance of
little ends that had messily strayed from their moorings. Her gloves
were partly unbuttoned, and one flapped as she walked. Even her walk had
changed—it was a businesslike stride, with “getting-there” written all
over her hastening back.

“Not a girl in a hundred would show she could look like that,” said
Steve, in critical approval, as he kept pace with Joy in behind. “No
wonder Jerry’s an institution that never fails.”

As they reached the roof Harry pulled out his cigar, a huge black affair
that he stuck in his mouth at an angle of forty-five degrees. With
cunning eye he marked out the head waiter and bore down upon him, thumbs
in his waist-coat pocket, twirling his fingers. “We want the best table
in the place,” he said, speaking through the cigar, at which the waiter
tried not to look. “No expense shall be spared!”

He swaggered as the waiter hastily led them to a corner table. Joy was
about to sink down, conscious that forks were being suspended in midair
all about them, when Jerry put in a word.

“I don’t like this table, Bill,” she said querulously. “I want to be out
in the middle where I can see everything that goes on, I do.”

“Waiter, did you hear my wife? What my wife says goes! Nothing’s too
good for her!” Harry turned fiercely upon the waiter, jerking his cigar
up and down in time to his words. The head waiter, all apologies,
conducted them to a more centrally located table, and beckoned to a
lesser menial, who helped install them. Jerry gave a bereft wail.

“Where’s the flowers! We haven’t got no flowers! Look, Bill, at that
table _there_ they got flowers!”

Her fingers pointed firmly to an adjoining table, all eyes of which were
already fixed upon them with that passionate interest that only
Americans display in the affairs of others.

“Now, Rosie, didn’t I tell you not to point at things with your
fingers?” Harry admonished in a penetrating lower tone.

“Well, a fork wasn’t handy; the man ain’t set the table yet,” Jerry

“Let us order,” interposed Steve in a suave, glossing-it-over tone, as
the waiter thrust the menu before them.

“Just rustle us the best tea on the premises, young feller,” said Harry
to the waiter, with a wave of the hand. “With all the fixin’s; see?”

Jerry interposed once more. “Say, Bill, I want a merring glass. Does
that come with the tea?”

“A meringue glacé,” said Steve smoothly to the by now distracted waiter.

“What kind does madame prefer?”

“Kind?” Jerry looked bewildered. “Is there different kinds? Can’t I just
have a plain merring glass?”

“A vanilla one, perhaps,” said Steve with a reassuring smile directed
first at her and then at the waiter. Then, as the waiter fluttered away,
leaving several around pouring water and adjusting the table, and others
poised near by with their ears cocked, Steve leaned across the table,
and addressed Harry in a loud, confidential tone:

“Rather a pleasant idea of yours, Mr.—er—Billings, to combine business
with afternoon tea.”

“Well, I hope your girl and my wife get to be real good friends,” said
Harry cordially. “I can remember when a million-dollar contract would
’a’ looked pretty big to me.”

“It is practically certain, then, that we have underbid the—the
Standard Oil Company on this?” Steve demanded.

“Lemme tell you, young man, underbiddin’ don’t always mean you get a
million-dollar contract. Not by a jugful!”

“Bill, remember there is ladies present!” from Jerry.

“Rosie, we’re talkin’ in business terms now, an’ you can chew on that
piece of bread the waiter handed you, till we get through. Now lemme
tell you, young man, the fact is, the underbiddin’ don’t cut so much ice
as my private an’ personal opinions. I get hunches, that’s what I do;
an’ hunches is what made Bill Billings what he is to-day, if I do say

Joy could only watch, all her energies concentrated on stifling the
mirth that their antics were inspiring. The waiter brought their tea and
Jerry’s “merring,” which Jerry devoured with the aid of a spoon, a knife
and fork, using her roll also as a pusher now and then. Harry drank tea
from his saucer and discoursed on the grudge he bore the Standard Oil;
they were a bunch of cheap skates, and they would be a bunch of
soreheads to-morrow when they learned that Mr. Mitchell had nailed this
contract. “For it is yours, young man, for the asking; and yours is a
firm I would trust a lot further than that.” The people of the next
table had given up all pretense of eating or talking to each other, and
the table back of Joy was also avidly silent. She could not see them,
but she could feel the tense attention, and sense the vibrations of
vision that centered on their table.

Tea being over, Harry grew more expansive. “You going to step round to
the minister’s soon, you two?” he beamed benevolently. “Better not waste
any time. I married Rosie when she was sixteen—Told her then to stick
to me and she’d wear diamonds. I notice you stuck, old girl?”

“Now, Bill, you stop!” Jerry simpered. The head waiter was presenting
the check. Several other waiters who had added to their sense of
well-being were lined up in back of the head waiter. Steve started to
take the bill, but Harry intervened.

“Pay my way’s my motto,” he said, whereat Steve lost his composure for
the first time and gulped while Harry drew his rather thin wallet from
his pocket and carefully counted out what looked like a small amount
which he laid on the salver with the check. Steve recovered himself and
filled in the awkward pause by saying:

“Yes, we intend to be married as soon as Miss Nelson can get her
trousseau together. It’s already taken a year—as fast as she gathers a
few little things together, why, they go out of style, and then she has
to start all over again. It’s such a fearful ordeal for the poor

They rose to go, Joy conscious of an acute sag in the waiter’s
expression as he took the salver and walked away with failing footsteps.
And then she turned and saw the table whose listening silence she had
been appreciating throughout that time. She stared in stupefaction. The
Lamkins; the Alfred Lamkins from Foxhollow Corners; pillars of the
church, two solid, well-buttressed souls, with four white-eyelashed,
shiny-nosed, unmarried daughters. All staring at Joy in that awful
delight experienced by small-town souls when they find their neighbours
doing something out of the ordinary.

“Why—there’s Joy Nelson!” said Mrs. Lamkin, in obviously manufactured

“So it is!” chorused the four white-eyelashed things. “Hello, Joy!”

It was plain that they expected her to stop and speak to them, exchange
the usual banal what-are-you-doing-in-the-big-city of the out-of-towner,
and present her companions. It was just as plain that she intended doing
nothing of the sort, and with a confused nod of acknowledgement, her
head down, she almost ran past them to the elevator.

“Did you see that waiter wilt at my twenty-five cent tip, and all the
others melt away?” Harry chortled as they went down.

“Who were those people, Joy?” Jerry demanded, pulling her hat down and
her hair out.

“People from home.”

“Home-town stuff!” Steve cried. “You’re compromised forever now, Joy;
you’ll have to marry me now!”

“That’s not as bad as this fall, in at the Knickerbocker,” said Harry
reminiscently. “I had the waiter sure I was the Prince of Wales and
Steve here an escaped nobleman from Russia, conferring together about
starting royalty over here, when up blows Dick Lindley and another poor
egg, calling us by name and requesting the loan of some cash to get back
to Princeton!”

The blithe youths left them at the Belmont. “We’ve been lowbrow this
afternoon; we’ll be highbrow to-night,” said Steve. “We’ve wangled
Harry’s mother’s box at the opera.”

“Can Félicie Durant and Greg Stevens come along?” Jerry asked.
“Félicie’s over with us, and I said we’d do something to-night with

“Félicie Durant can come anywhere with me where I can look at her,” said
Harry; “if she’ll keep her mouth shut. Still going around with Greg
Stevens, is she?”

“Greg Stevens—” Steve repeated; “not Princeton?”

“Nope—Yale—managed most of the teams there, and all that sort of
flutter. He’s all right, though. Don’t take more than an hour now, you

They found Félicie still sleeping in a breathlessly stuffy room, as she
had not even turned off the heat.

“Well, Joy, what do you think of our Princeton specialties?” Jerry
asked, turning on the lights and pulling the covers from Félicie’s face.

“Lovely. I can’t tell which one is talking when I close my eyes. But of
all places I’ve been to around Boston—why did I have to come to New
York to run into some home-towners!”

“That is one thing about New York—you’re always running into people you
know, in the wrong places. Wake up, Félicie! You’ve only got an hour to
get dressed, and we’ve a box at the opera!”

Félicie, after a struggle with herself, arose with an injured
expression. “I was awake all the time—you needn’t have spoken so loud.
I haven’t slept hardly a wink. Just as I was falling asleep someone
called Joy on the phone—Madame Somebody’s maid, or something, who said
Joy was to come at four to-morrow, she would send her car.”

It was characteristic of Félicie that she had not even recognised the
great name that brought Joy to a standstill and drew a whistle from

“Perhaps we’ll hear her to-night,” said Jerry. “Don’t lose your nerve,
Joy; you’ll sing circles around her some day. Go and run a tub and do
some scales—they won’t be heard over the tub if you close the door.”

“I hope you’re not running a tub for _me_,” Félicie objected; “too many
baths are bad for me, I’m funny that way.”

Strange anomaly—the Félicie who had everything about her as neat as a
bee-hive, but slept in sealed rooms and disagreed with baths!

An hour later they admitted they were fit to sit in anyone’s box at the
opera. Félicie was almost bewilderingly lovely in pale green velvet;
Jerry was audacious and stunning in low-cut purple with cerise ostrich
feathers; Joy wore a cloth-of-gold that Jerry had ripped from an old
model of hers and put together in a few simple lines.

“With your hair,” said Jerry, looking her over in professional pride,
“that get-up’s a knock out.”

Joy found herself wishing that Jim was going to see her, instead of the
Princeton youths.

“Wait till we hit the diamond horseshoe!” Jerry was saying. “Although
we’re probably higher up than that.”

“I wish I had some diamonds to wear,” Félicie sighed. “I do love
diamonds so.”

“If you’d give in to Greg, you might have one,” Jerry suggested.

“One about the size of a pin-point! I couldn’t stand that. Men don’t
half appreciate what it means to a girl to have a ring that she won’t
have to be ashamed of. When I get one, I want a good one, as long as
it’s a thing I’ll have to wear all my life.”

“Oh, so you’ve thought up another argument now for not getting married
for four years,” said Jerry.

“Now you’re picking on me again!”

The ring of the telephone announcing that their escorts awaited them
downstairs interrupted here, and they sailed down after a mere ten
minutes for last rites of re-powdering, going over one’s hair, and
general touching up.

Gregory Stevens was as dark as Félicie, scarcely more than an eager boy,
and very much in love, as Joy saw and could have seen if she had not
been told. They ate at the Belmont, and throughout dinner Félicie and
Greg carried on a low-toned conversation, refusing to be drawn into the
general chatter. They reached the opera late, and Joy lost herself in a
heaven of sound oblivious to the whispering all about her. The first
grand opera she had ever heard; small wonder that she could not come out
of her trance between the acts, to enjoy the sensation of being a
beautiful girl sitting in a box at the Opera. A little before the end
Harry pulled her back to the world of Excitement-Eaters by whispering:
“Come on, we don’t want to be caught in this mob; we’re going somewhere
to dance.”

Surprised dumb that they could leave the greatest of music quivering in
mid-air, she followed them as they streaked out and lost the time they
had gained in debate of where to go. Steve voted for the “Bré Cat;”
Jerry downed that with a sniff; “Princeton’s playground!”
“Weisenrebber’s,” Harry’s suggestion, was voted down as “too rough;”
Jerry declared she positively would not go to any of the hotels, she
could get the same thing in Boston. Steve groaned, and said he supposed
they’d have to fork out fifty dollars or so for a table at the Frolic;
Félicie and Greg cried out in swift protest that they wanted to go
somewhere quiet.

“I tell you what,” said Harry: “let’s slum uptown. There’s a place up
around Columbia with good music—Fennelly’s, or something. Come on,
we’re off!”

No one knowing enough about the place to object, they piled into a taxi
and worked their way uptown, Félicie and Greg following alone in
another. The first four were well established at the uptown dancing
palace before Félicie and Greg joined them. Félicie’s colour was
heightened almost to a dark purple flush; Greg was pale, his features
standing out sharply. They sat down at the table without a word, and
stared vaguely at the dancers.

“You two ought never to go to the opera,” said Harry sweetly. “It’s got
you all—wrought—up.”

“Not the opera,” said Greg, each word sheared off almost before it came.
“We’ve been discussing the modern girl.”

“I don’t want to talk about it any more,” Félicie’s pouting lips
twitched out. “I’m so nervous now I could just scream!”

“We’ve ordered for you,” said Steve as the waiter brought up some soft
drinks. “Do you think opera is as crazy as I do? Come on, Harry; let’s
do our favourite scene from Madame Butterfly. Ladies and gentlemen, this
is an actual transition from part of this famous opera.” He rose,
pouring some gingerale into a glass, singing solemnly: “Will you have
some more whiskey?”

“Thank you!” sang Harry in response, taking the glass and draining it.
They sat down looking for appreciation; but Joy and Jerry were regarding
the two who still sat without a flicker of attention to anything.

“Well, what is there about the modern girl that brings on this run-over
attitude?” Harry inquired, ignoring Steve’s warning eyebrows.

“The modern girl,” said Greg, “is selfish to cruelty. I think
that—carries the situation in a nutshell.”

“Is the modern girl any more selfish than the modern man?” said Joy
quickly, anxious to alleviate the mauve tints of Félicie’s face. “I
haven’t noticed it, if it’s so.”

“Oh, now we’re in for deep discussion!” Harry proclaimed joyously. “I do
love deep discussions in frivolous places!”

“From my point of view, the man as he is to-day is the result of the
modern girl,” said Greg, turning to Joy.

“If she is selfish, so selfish that she wishes to have everything, while
giving nothing in return, so selfish that she looks upon the world as
her debtor—she must mold the man’s attitude toward her. And men can no
longer regard her with the chivalry and reverence in which men held
women when women made the sacrifices that made the name of woman
something to be worshipped.”

“But we’re sick of being worshipped!” cried Félicie, whose silence had
been fading to lavender. “The viewpoint you have is the viewpoint of the
last century and so on—men dividing women into two classes—” She
stopped, and Jerry took up the sentence:

“Félicie wants to say—two classes—good and bad; good to be worshipped
and do all the work and have a generally poky time; bad to be despised,
but taken around and having the whirl their good little sisters missed.”

“And why boast that the old-fashioned distinction has disappeared?” Greg
thrust forth. “Nowadays the line has vanished. Good and bad comport
themselves alike. The ‘good’ girl—so-called—refuses to undertake any
of the responsibilities that for centuries have made her sheltered and
protected. She paints her face more recklessly than her sister on the
street. She aims to out-demi the demi-mondaine in her dress. She does
not disdain to use any weapon, no matter how blood-stained, to bring men
to her feet; and then she leaves them there. The old-fashioned girl gave
a man the mitten. This new girl never kills them off; she must have
strings to her bow; she keeps them dangling around her as long as is
humanly possible. And then she turns around and says: ‘Men aren’t as
chivalrous as they used to be!’” He looked around at them, with almost a
sneer. “No wonder things are happening nowadays that a few years ago you
couldn’t have believed possible!”

Joy, clutching at her throat, was conscious that her nails were biting
into the skin. She was back at her first Prom—last spring. She saw
herself standing in front of a mirror gazing in fascination at her white
shoulders, her blazing cheeks, her painted lips. Again she beard Jim
Dalton telling her what he thought of her appearance. Had she been in
some way responsible for what had happened? “You’re ripping me all to
pieces.” . . . The words leaped up at her from the stagnant channels of
that memory. She drew in her breath so sharply that it caught in her

“That’s a very fluent argument, Greg,” Harry was saying: “I’m surprised
and pleased to see an Eli whose brains weren’t lost under the training
table. All the same, I think you’re on the wrong tack. As Jerry says,
the old-fashioned girl was poky. I couldn’t stand her alone for five
minutes; she’d drive me to drink.”

“Maybe, but she wouldn’t drink with you,” grinned Steve.

“That’s just it, Harry!” said Joy. “An old-fashioned girl bores men
nowadays. So what stimulus have we for being old-fashioned?”

“It’s one of those vicious circles,” said Greg. “But the girls are
responsible in the first place—they can’t get away from it. They have
fooled the men into thinking they’re more attractive this way.”

“Well, they are,” Harry persisted. “I wouldn’t go back to the
Clinging-Vine Age for marbles. When I go to see a girl, I want to have a
good time with her—and as far as I can see, if the gallants in other
times ever did get to see a girl, all they did was sit and twiddle their

“You didn’t hear any complaints from anybody,” said Greg undaunted.
“Nobody realized they were having what we could now term a dull time. I
tell you things are getting too complicated. There are too many new
inventions for having good times. We just dash from one new sensation to
the next. When a man goes to see a girl nowadays, what do they do? Do
they sit in the parlor and talk, do they go out into the kitchen and
make fudge? They do not. They duck the family, and step into his or her
father’s Rolls-Royce or Ford and ride seven or seventy miles to the
nearest place that has the best dance music or they go to the movies,
during which they laugh and talk and say: ‘Why did we come? We could
have done this at home and not be bored by a rotten show;’ but they go
next time just the same; or if they stay home for once, they gather a
large bunch around them and turn on the home jazz variety. Is this true
or isn’t it?”

“Well, I fail to see how you can slide all that off on the girl,” said
Jerry. “What’s the use of all this moralizing stuff? You know you like a
good time as well as the rest of us. To crab at people who are enjoying
themselves is a sign of the aged.”

“Look at us to-night,” said Greg. “Here we are paying I-don’t-know-what
per couvert to sit in an uninteresting place and watch the world’s most
ordinary potpourri, the personnel of a public dance hall, canter around
on a bum floor——”

“And listen to you crab. I admit it’s awful,” said Jerry, rising. “Come
on, Harry. Greg probably won’t dance after his oration, but I intend to
see if it _is_ a bum floor.”

They slid away, and Greg looked at Félicie. The lines in his face
quivered into softness until he looked like a hungry, wistful child.
Félicie’s colour had died to a brilliant flash in either cheek; her
loveliness was almost aching in its intensity. “I’m sorry, Félicie,” he
said gently. “Shall we dance?”

Steve and Joy looked after them as they joined “the world’s most
ordinary-looking potpourri.” “He seems like a fine fellow,” said Steve;
“but what’s eating him, anyway? Won’t she marry him? He ought to be

“Well, he doesn’t seem to be,” said Joy rather shortly.

“All this haste to get married while you’re young is idiotic,” said
Steve, with an air of settling the subject. “If he says the modern girl
is selfish because she doesn’t want to let herself in for the cares and
risks of marriage until she has an everlasting good time out of her
youth, he’s talking rot. The modern girl’s got a sane argument, and it’s
the same one I’d use for myself. Marriage clips your wings, whether
you’re a man or a girl, and there’s no use getting into it before you’ve
had enough of high-flying!”

Joy said nothing. It was the same argument she had used for herself.
Marriage was not for her, until the wings of her power had grown so that
she could soar with that impediment. But Félicie’s case was different.
She was in love—supposedly. And Greg’s face——

“Come on and twirl a measure,” said Steve, “if you’re not above mingling
with the Too-Much-Perfumed.”

“Too-Much-Perfumed?” she echoed as they went out on the floor.

“Yes—I always think of that in these places—don’t you get the scent on
different couples as they whiff by us? I always think of the common herd
as perfuming themselves heavily. So, instead of calling ’em the Great
Unwashed, I call ’em the Too-Much-Perfumed.”

It was about two when they returned to the Belmont. The girls undressed
quickly, saying little. No one brought up the subject of Greg’s
harangue. Jerry said that she would sleep with Félicie, so that Joy
could have the single room and sleep as late as possible into the day.

“I know you’ve got to have sleep back of your voice,” she said, “so go
to it, old girl. I’ll make Félicie open one window.”

If only Jerry were not such an Excitement-Eater——

By four the next afternoon, Joy had nearly scared herself into a chill.
Félicie had gone down to Princeton for a party, but Jerry had remained
with her. First, her costume offered trouble. After three changes, she
was almost ready to start, when there was a heartsick moment of losing
her short gloves. Then a worse moment when she found a rip in them that
Jerry repaired with lightning skill. Hesitation over her music which Pa
had told her to take indiscriminately, since the great one would select
what she pleased to hear. It seemed such a lot to take in one music
roll. Finally Jerry bundled her off, going down with her to the door of
the waiting car, a dark green Cadillac, such as anyone,—well most
anyone—might have. She was driven to the door of a Park Avenue
apartment house, where the chauffeur instructed her to go to the top
floor. A little maid admitted her to a room beautifully appointed in
grey, relieved by sharp touches of black and the inevitable grand piano.
Music was piled on the piano in indeterminate heaps; some of it was even
trickling off to the floor. Another sheet fell as Joy came into the
room, and she went over to pick it up, restoring the others to place as
she did so.

“Ah, so we have a neat little housewife’s soul, in a singer!”

A full, perfectly poised voice, each word as flawless as if it had been
engraved on a cameo. Joy turned, crimson with embarrassment and
excitement, and straightway forgot both. The queen of music had a most
understanding smile. Moreover, she did not look like a diva. She was not
even large, as singers went, and certainly not of terrifying aspect. She
was dainty as a little wren, standing by the doorway in a grey teagown,
her head tipped to one side, her eyes—the eyes that looked so
awe-inspiring in her pictures—surrounded by a network of little

“Well,” she said, and came to take Joy’s hands; “have you nothing at all
to say to me—or must all be sung, as in op-era? Never mind—” and she
drew Joy to a sofa—“I once remember when I was younger than you, and
they sent me to sing for Patti. Oh, how I died! It was after a
performance, and Patti was in no charm to hear me. She was weary of
child-wonders. How well I remember that long time ago! She was in her
room at the hotel; there was a wood fire; she always had one go ahead of
her, turn off the steam, and have a fire built ready for her coming. I
sat in a tremble; and what I had brought to sing—at sixteen? The waltz
song from Romeo and Juliet! But no matter. She came in all wrapped
around with cloaks and hoods and shawls. How poisonous is the night air
to a singer, and all other things that lend joy and romance! Her table
was spread with her supper. I was to sing while she ate. She sat down,
giving me a look with those black eyes, while her maid unwound her from
the shawls. I was so unhappy! She pointed to the piano. ‘I do not know
why they want me to hear them sing,’ she said. ‘I know nothing, just
what I like or do not like, and how it sounds to me—I will listen not
for the things the critics discuss. But sing! And I will tell you what I

She looked at Joy, her eyes twinkling up again. “I was in a horror! I
shook, how I shook! And the noble Adelina saw that I could not do
anything, although the young man was waiting for me at the piano. She
arose from her clear soup, did Adelina, and went to look at what I had
brought. ‘Ah, it is the waltz!’ she said. ‘Have you heard Nellie Melba
sing this, child?’

“Nellie Melba was then dazzling the world. I had heard and rejoiced, as
had everyone. I could only nod. But Adelina went on. ‘In my time,’ she
said, ‘Nellie Melba’s voice would have been termed a light-opera voice.
You gasp? But listen how we were taught to run the descent of the
chromatic in this waltz.’”

She closed her eyes, her features sinking into a repose of prayer. “Oh,
those notes that came floating from that supreme woman! Golden,
perfectly matched, each one a pearl on the perfect string! She stopped
on the B flat, and laughed a little at my face. ‘Now I will show you,’
said she, ‘how Nellie Melba pours it forth!’ And that Adelina ran it up
and down in just the way I had heard Melba sing it many times. I cannot
tell you the difference. Still beautiful, but—it was as if she had
taken the bottom away from everything, that second time!”

“What did she say when you sang?” Joy asked eagerly, as she came to a

The little wren tossed her hands and shoulders, laughing lightly. “The
story ends there! I have gotten you to speak! Come—let us see what you
have brought. I hope a variety, for I like to choose!” She ran her
fingers lightly through the music-roll, pulling out “The Messiah,” to
Joy’s horror. She had not dreamed that the heroine of thirty operas, and
mistress of the concert stage, would even glance at oratorio.

“Behold what is complete in one,” she was saying. “We have everything
here, from the dramatics to the dynamics. Come, let us be off!”

“I didn’t suppose—this is the hardest thing I ever tried to do—” Joy
faltered, following her to the piano.

“No matter! You have saved yourself already, in saying ‘tried to do,’
instead of—‘done’!” She modulated into the pastoral symphony, still
talking: “This is so cruel! Nearly eighty pages while the soprano sits
like a rock! Many have no voice left when their time comes!”

She played for Joy to sing through the four first recitatives, then
without comment plunged into the “Come Unto Him,” followed by “Rejoice
Greatly,” and ending with “I Know That My Redeemer Liveth.”

Then she turned on the bench. “We all have fads, which we call
convictions,” she said quietly; “and mine is that this music we have
just done can show plainly as nothing else, what one has and what one
has learned. Now let us have some fun and do some op-era. What can you

“Pa hasn’t given me anything but Faust——”

“He wouldn’t; I am glad; for I know you have other airs, and I shall
wish to see what you have done without Pa, with your own brain and
soul-fire. Come, shall we do something so banal you shall have to lend
it your own self, lest we remember the hurdy-gurdy?”

Joy hesitated, as she had been about to suggest her beloved Louise.

“But-terfly!” cried the little wren, and tore a wail of beauty from the

So Joy sang Madame Butterfly . . . with a pulse beating in her voice
that made the great one turn on the last note and kiss her exultantly.

“When I have a new sensation with that song, I am won!” she cried. “And
you gave it—why, you little girl—with years before your maiden voice
grows into your woman’s voice—you had not only the longing of Butterfly
but the longing of all! Do you see what I mean? It is so that the
American shop girl could hear you sing it in Italian and weep!”

She became quiet, judicial. “Pa Graham is right. The greatest of
teachers are not always right—when the pupil has beauty which dazzles
and deafens the beholder—but Pa is right with you. You have everything,
everything and to spare, in equipment. Now it is the question of the
years of preparation. Many young girls start out as you, with high hopes
and encouragement. Many do not finish—of their own fault and choosing.
Are you of a steadfast mind?”

“I will let nothing come in my way,” said Joy breathlessly, “not even

“That is the thing that may end all. . . . And perhaps you may be glad
that all is over, if you love greatly.” She looked down at the gorgeous
rings on her fingers, and there was a little silence before she
continued. “But most loves are not the great loves of which we sing and
act; they are not the blazing altar-fires of which we dream; love comes
down to a hearth-fire, after marriage. And we who sing are not content
with hearth-fires. Remember that always, little one; _we who sing are
not content with hearth-fires_.”

The maid came into the far end of the room, spraying the air with water
from an atomizer. “My substitute for Adelina’s wood-fires,” the wren
said with a smile. “Steam dries you up in your throat—oh, it is
terrible! Bring the tea, will you, Aimée?” A pause, while she played
rippling cadenzas and frowned at the keys. Joy longed to ask her to
sing, but would not, when suddenly without apparent preparation or
setting, her voice floated out in a great, full note that swelled to the
power of the room until the very windows sang, and then quivered itself
into silence. Under the little white hands the keys wove a melody above
which the voice rang out, first dazzling with its fireworks, then
charming with its beauty. Joy, listening, thought it the most perfect
voice in the world, as it came close to being. It ended on a long high
note as small and clear as a thread of silver, that hung in the air and
charmed the echoes.

“It is an old Italian air,” she said, before Joy could speak. “I have
not sung it for a long time; no one sings it any more; the new music is
all different.”

“Thank you,” said Joy, reverently; “the memory of that will always spur
me on. And thank you for not singing before I did!”

Her laugh, as lovely a thing as one of her runs, rippled out, and she
turned to the wagon Aimée was wheeling into the room. “And now for tea.
Here is a splendid illustration of the hardships of the singer. We must
forswear life’s sweet things for the voice and the figure. Often I
think, when shall I taste that French pastry my friends always de-vour?”
She rolled her eyes, almost upsetting the teacup she was passing Joy.
“But no, I do not even know what it would seem like.”

Tea with lemon and without sugar; buttered toast; flat little sponge
cakes that tasted like sawdust.

“Once I let myself go and ate a caramel before a concert,” the little
wren related, between sips of tea. “Never shall I forget! I came out and
sang My Lovely Celia. I had not sung much in English, and they were
ready to notice anything. I sang on, ‘as lilies sweet, as soft as air,’
and when I came to soft—you know it is but a G, but a tiny, small,
floated thing—my voice stuck, I strangled, and the whole hall choked
for me! I could feel that caramel sticking to my cords!”

Tea was over, and Joy knew that she must go. She managed to express her
appreciation coherently, in spite of the fact that her hostess kissed
her again.

“When you return to New York, you must come here once more,” she said,
and put Joy’s music back into the roll for her. “And when you are
through with all your work, we will get you that hearing.”

Joy rode back to the Belmont holding her music-roll gingerly. It was
awesome, when you considered who had closed it. Would she ever want to
open it again. . . . The queen of music had spoken as though her success
were a matter of time. . . .

Jerry was sitting by the window, looking out into the darkness; a
desolate Jerry with her hair pulled back into a brush, leaving her white
face without shading.

“New York’s getting under my skin,” she said rapidly before Joy could
speak; “there’s no use, Joy; it spells Phil Lancaster to me, and a lot
of other things that do me no good to think about; I’ve got to get out
of here.”

Joy put down her music roll before coming nearer, and as Jerry’s eyes
fell on it, she jumped up, shaking her hair until it fell about her face
once more. “I’m a selfish fool! Tell me all about it—quick!”

Joy had nearly finished her thrilling story when Jerry interrupted her.
“Here’s a note they pushed under the door. I forgot to give it to you

It was a little hotel envelope containing the information that Mrs.
Eustace Drew had called and would call again at six-thirty. Joy looked
at her watch wildly. It was that now.

“Does ‘will call at six-thirty’ mean in person, or by telephone?” she
demanded. The telephone rang by way of answer, and a voice informed her
that “Mrs. Drew was in the lobby.”

“She might at least have spoken to me herself,” she grumbled, flying to
the mirror.

“Who?” said Jerry.

“My New York cousin. Things always come in bunches with me!”

Yes, Cousin Mabel certainly might have talked to her, if only to tell
her what to expect, she thought as she went down to attack the lobby
vaguely. But Cousin Mabel was standing by a pillar and came over to her

“Joy?” she asked with a smile its recipient recognised as genuine:
“Well, I think we should have known each other anywhere—or is it mere
fond vanity that tells me we look alike?”

Cousin Mabel was a pretty woman in her late twenties, a trifle faded
already, but very dainty and luxurious-looking wrapped in her sables.
She was of the same blond type as Joy, but her hair was already losing
its brightness and her eyes were grey rather than the radiant blue that
marked Joy’s greatest appeal. She was unvarnishedly pale, which made Joy
conscious of the dab of rouge on her cheeks. As she stood exchanging
amenities, Joy found herself contrasting Cousin Mabel’s style with
Jerry’s. Jerry was always put together perfectly, with just the right
amount of carelessness; but her style was the type that burst upon one.
Mabel undoubtedly had style; but it was so quiet that one had to look
many times to appreciate the small, perfect little details that made the
unobtrusive whole.

“I have been trying to get you for so long, my dear,” she was saying.
“But last night you were evidently making the most of being in New York;
also this afternoon. Is it too late for you to run up to dine informally
with us to-night? My big brother will be there, and my husband and one
or two others.”

Joy stood with gracelessly opened mouth. Mabel’s big brother——

“I didn’t know I had more cousins that I hadn’t heard about,” she said
heavily, thinking of no better way to bring back the subject.

“Oh, yes, there’s Phil! Older than I, and getting to be a more
hard-and-fast bachelor every year. It’s even difficult to get him to
dine with us, so you really must come to-night!” As Joy still hesitated,
plunging for another setting to bring about what she wished, Mabel went
on: “I know it’s awfully last minute-y, but it isn’t a dinner party, or
anything but just an informal gathering—and as long as we are

“Oh, I should love to,” said Joy, “but it would mean leaving the girl
with whom I came over, all alone——”

“Bring her too, then! That settles it!” Mabel laughed. “I’ll send the
car back for you at seven-fifteen. You’re a nice child, Joy!” She paused
in her exit, and lifted a black-gloved finger. “So you and she are
staying alone at an hotel in the wicked city. Dear me—these New England

Joy went slowly back to the room where Jerry stared out of the window at
a New York that had grown barren to her. She had made an
opportunity—given Jerry her fighting chance. And now she was
overwhelmed by misgivings. It did not seem possible that a love could
have endured so long upon so little. And how could Jerry hold her own in
the house of Mabel Lancaster Drew? She—Mabel—had all but raised her
eyebrows—at their being alone in New York together. What would she
think, when she saw Jerry—— But Joy put away that thought.

What should she tell Jerry? It was hard not to tell her the incredible
truth; it was the fair, square way that Jerry would have taken. But it
might be better for Jerry to be unprepared. She debated; and since she
could not decide, did not tell her. Jerry showed no enthusiasm at the
thought of dining with Joy’s cousins.

“You say you don’t know them at all, yet you’re passing up a wonderful
chance for us to go along to some awful little joint while Félicie isn’t
here to clamp down on dirty food!”

“We might as well get a meal paid for,” said Joy, watching Jerry’s
preparations with ill-concealed suspense. Jerry, always sensitive to
waves of feeling, dropped the bright green dinner gown she had taken up
and laughed. “Why did you make ’em throw me in with the invitation, Joy,
if you’re going to feel cross-eyed about my get-up?”

“Haven’t you brought anything—darker?” Joy asked feebly.

“Not in the dinner line. Never mind. Here’s a black velvet of

“It will hang on you in folds.”

“Oh, no, it won’t.” Jerry had wriggled in and out of the velvet, pinned
a few bunches in the luscious material, then sat down with her
sewing-kit in her favourite cross-legged position. Inside of six
minutes, she put away her thimble, stuck her needle on the outside of
the kit and threw it on the bed, and put on the velvet, which fell about
her in full, majestic lines, but looked as if it had been built for her.
Joy thought with a spurt of hope that she had never seen Jerry look so
well. The black toned her down; the velvet softened her. She felt
ashamed of her momentary qualms, and tried to make up for it by talking
effusively on the way over, and jesting about the way cars were being
sent for them. However, her efforts only evoked a puzzled look from
Jerry, who did not know Joy in a talkative vein.

The car drew up in front of a large red sandstone house just off Fifth
Avenue in the fifties, which brought a whistle from Jerry. “Say,
Joy—what are you getting us into? The nearest I’ve been to this sort of
stuff is the movies!”

It did not add to their composure to have a butler admit them, to be
elevatored to one floor to take off their wraps and elevatored to
another floor to meet Mabel. They were ushered into a drawing-room,
which seemed to Joy’s eyes full of people whose faces were obscured in
the candlelight which was the only illumination affected. Mabel came
forward to greet them, a little overplump without the coat and
glossing-over sables, but very attractive in warm rose, her only jewelry
a single pink pearl hanging at the end of a platinum and diamond chain.
Joy noticed these details automatically, her attention focussed on
Jerry, who, since she had entered the room, had taken on a manner
entirely foreign to her make-up as Joy knew it. She was the easy,
gracious grande dame from the lilt of her walk and assured poise to the
cultured cadences of the voice that Joy had often likened to rough
plush. She had slipped into it as readily as one slips into another

Joy could not know, as the East-Side gamin answered Mabel’s friendly
greeting with a few well-chosen words of appreciation at her inclusion
in the dinner, that poor little Jerry had assumed the atmosphere of the
successful designer at Charlette’s, when she was conferring with a
desirable patron. She only marvelled, then looked beyond. A man nearing
forty, and plumpness; a girl with a complexion of peachdown, pleasantly
irregular features, brown hair folded back straight without a crinkle or
wave from a high white forehead; and behind these two—a taller man,
whose face was above the range of the candlelight.

“Miss Dalrymple, Miss Nelson—and my husband, Mr. Drew—” The two who
barred the way fell apart, and Joy was facing the man who had given
Jerry the power to dream. “Phil, this is your new cousin.”

Weary blue eyes that settled on her without interest; a dark, beautiful
face with hard lines carving manliness into it and softer marks etching
bitternesses around the eyes and mouth; a man who, even Joy could sense,
had been too inquisitive of life and found nothing worthy of his young
curiosity. She fell aside and looked back at Jerry, still the grande
dame, exchanging greetings with the first two. Jerry was never pretty;
she could not sink to that level; and to-night she was at the height of
her fascination. No one could wear bobbed hair quite like Jerry; it
fluffed around her face, adding to the shimmering lights of expression;
those lights that always seemed dancing to the surface, yet which by not
being transmuted into speech and action, lent her subtlety, which is the
essence of charm.

She came through to them, stately, gracious, with always that moonshine
of charm flickering in her face. “My brother, Mr. Lancaster,” said Mabel
at her elbow. Jerry looked up—and vivid colour, moonbeams, grande dame
and all, were struck from her face as if an artist had wiped everything
from his painting but the formless features. A long moment she hung
thus, one thin hand which she had put out before lifting her head,
fluttering without volition. Then with a gasp almost heard in the
suspended quiet, she took shape again. Star-shine lurked itself into her
face, and she threw back her head, bringing on the grand dame again in
double-barreled force. Valiant! Joy thought; valiant! And stole a look
at him. There she had the great surprise of the evening. He was taking
Jerry’s hand, a bit lingeringly; smiling at her with interest—but
without recognition!

“You look very much like someone I met a long time ago,” he said.

“A very long time ago?” murmured Jerry in the richest of her plush

“Oh, very. At least two years—which means it was war times, and those
times seem hundreds of years behind us now.”

“There you go, Old Crow’s-feet!” Mabel was hanging on his arm and
smiling up at him. She brought the others into it with an explanatory
quirk: “These returned war heroes think everyone forgets pretty quickly,
but we don’t, do we?”

“Returned war hero!” Joy cried, her mind a suspended blank to be written
over with wonder. Jerry said nothing with fierce intensity of question.

“Why, yes,” said Mabel. “Stop nudging me, Phil, I will if I want to!—He
was over for a long time, and brought back millions of those little
citation ribbons which he gave me with instructions to bury—stop,

Another man-servant—did they have _two_ butlers?—announced dinner at
this moment, and Mabel gave Joy to her brother, leading the way with
Jerry and leaving her husband to the girl with the white forehead, who
so far had said nothing of any irrelevance, and so had made little
impression on the party.

As they settled themselves behind the fruit cocktails, Joy watched Phil
Lancaster, who kept his eyes fixed on Jerry across the table.

“Is—is the resemblance so very striking?” she probed gently.

“Not so very, after the first look.” He took his eyes away from Jerry
with a jolt and landed them on Joy for one perfunctory second. “Your
friend is quite a different type.” His eyes found Jerry again; and
Jerry’s short, thick lashes quivered as she raised her chin higher and
looked determinedly at Mabel, who was stretching out a large fund of
small talk.

“That girl with the brown hair and white forehead—is she another
cousin?” asked Joy, still quietly insistent that he should talk to her.

He drew his eyes back to Joy. “No; she’s a Bryn Mawr girl, one of
Mabel’s protégés. Mabel’s awfully keen on younger girls.”

“You don’t like ‘younger girls,’ do you?” His tone had been descriptive.

“Why—has Mabel been getting biographic?”

“No; she didn’t say anything about you to me; I just guessed. And as
long as I have guessed, I think you ought to tell me why.”

There was a pause as a third man in livery came between them with the
soup, an opportunity he enriched by looking at Jerry; then he said: “To
tell you why—would not make dinner conversation. But a young girl
flaunting her conscious beauty and youth does not interest me, any more
than I would give other than a passing look to a large coloured
advertisement on a billboard.”

“And how about older women?” she asked, letting his statement pass
without battle.

“Oh—they have either lost interest in life and are only pretending, or
their minds are one-track affairs.”

“My——” said Joy thoughtfully. “It must be awful to be a bachelor.”

They both laughed then, and Jerry looked across the table with an
answering gleam. His eyes caught hers for an intimate moment; then she
turned back to Mabel and he to Joy.

“I admit it sounded humourous,” he said. “But I told you, the rest would
not be dinner conversation.”

“When did you go across?” she asked abruptly. Her words carried across
the table, and Jerry’s polite attention to Mabel took on another tin.

“In the fall of ’17.”

So she had been right in her random suggestion! Mabel, hearing a
fragment of their conversation through Jerry’s silence, proudly
contributed the fact that Phil had just been promoted to the rank of
major when the armistice was signed. The girl with the white forehead
and Mabel’s husband were deep in a steady stream of discussion which
flowed on during the pauses of the rest of the dinner party.

So he did not remember Jerry. And yet he must, or why did he look at her
so? Many times she reviled fashion of ceremony, as courses were brought
on and taken off and dinner slowly rolled by with always the balancing
of his and Jerry’s gaze across the table, while he talked vaguely and
diffusely to Joy. It was when they were having coffee—Mabel had
declared the men were too few to be left alone—that he seemed to give
his attention to Joy for the first time. She had not been lessening her
contemplative gaze, and he suddenly broke into it. “I’m sorry—I’ve
rattled on so. I don’t know what’s in the air to-night—I’m not
generally talkative. Are you of those awful ones who ‘draw people out,’
young cousin?”

He was almost boyish now. She had been noting one or two grey hairs
sparkling in his ruddy crop.

“I don’t think—I’ve drawn you out at all,” she said, and her glance
travelled to Jerry. He did not look this time, but his eyes were well
distanced by now.

“I am glad you brought her with you,” he said simply.

The remark was so direct, after his circuitous discourse throughout the
meal, that she was left in surprise without a response. Mabel, sensitive
to Jerry’s aloofness, Phil’s apparent boredom and Joy’s non-registering
silence, rose and wafted them into the drawing room. “Eustace, you can
play the Victrola or do something entertaining while I show Joy the
babies,” she demanded. “She doesn’t know she has some more cousins to

They left the four, for another elevator trip. “You have—_children_?”
said Joy in awe.

Mabel nodded. “Three,” she said, with the first pride she had shown.

Three children—in as many years of marriage. Small wonder Mabel looked
a little faded, in spite of every aura wealth could cast. The nursery
was a long, wide room, into which they tiptoed, Mabel turning on the
light of a small rose-shaded lamp. Three little white beds, with tiny,
slumbering faces pressed hard against the pillows—faces beautiful with
the unearthly beauty of babyhood on which all of life’s beauty is yet to
be written. A moment while Joy gazed, and Mabel, going from one room to
another, murmured ecstatic nothings. Then Mabel turned off the light,
and they went to the door shivering in the cold from the open windows
that they had not felt while looking at the children.

On the other side of the door Joy stammered her enchantment of
eternity’s marvel. Mabel smiled, her hand on the knob, lingering as if
she could not bear to leave that hold upon the nursery.

“You will never know—until you have them,” she said. “The greatest
happiness in all the world, Joy. If only people realized! I myself
didn’t know. I thought I had come to the crown of my life when I
married. To have the love of the one you love—that is surely the
greatest honour and happiness that life can bring. But this—this brings
so infinitely much more—that you think you could only have barely
existed, before!” She relinquished the knob, turning it gently so that
the catch would hold. “All the happiness in the world, Joy, transmutes
itself into this great one. After all, everything speaks in terms of
love.” She laughed, half apologetically. “It’s true—we married people
pity everyone who doesn’t go and do likewise!”

Joy was thinking of the phrases she had heard bandied with such
assurance—yes, that she herself had bandied in her own mind; “the risks
and sacrifices of marriage,” “marriage clipping the wings.” In the
nursery—and now, with Mabel’s suddenly iridescent love spreading beauty
in her face—a career with all its gilt glory seemed very far away and
unreal. But they came back to a room which was echoing to great music
filtered through a sounding-box; and nursery and Mabel’s face sank away.
Different hearts, different loves—and what could one love one-half so
satisfying as music?

Eustace Drew and the college girl were selecting other records from the
cabinet—Jerry and Phil Lancaster were on the other side of the room,
beyond the candles, talking. Jerry was sitting on the window-seat; he
was standing looking down upon her, his back to the room. Joy
frantically wished that she were a pane in that window, then sat down
beside the college girl, who turned a smiling face to her with some
comment on the music. Joy answered it without impetus, and in the
ensuing conversation was surprised to find that Miss Dalrymple was
actually interesting on the subject. Besides being well-read, as Joy
innocently supposed all college girls to be, she was evidently
well-heard. She decided that Miss Dalrymple added up to a very
attractive girl. She wasn’t the type that a man would ask to a Prom to
cut a wide swath and impress the other fellows with looks and jazz, but
she was very attractive just the same. She had beauty of an unobtrusive
sort; her clothes were quietly right; and she had a responsive glow that
was most winning. Joy continued the conversation in an investigating
frame of mind. This girl must be several years older than she was. She
seemed older, in some few ways, but on the whole, so much younger. . . .

After a long conversation Joy again looked at the two at the end of the
room. It was so maddening to sit through an evening in ignorance of all
that was passing. Mabel followed her look.

“Your friend seems to have bewitched my brother, Joy,” she said lightly.
“She must be a sorceress, and cast a spell—he hasn’t even been polite
to a girl for so long.”

Joy stole a glance at her watch. Quarter of ten—it was surely already
too late to stay after a dinner in a butlered house such as this,—even
if Jerry did show no signs of desiring to leave the window seat. She was
stopped in her preliminary motions of departure by the insistence of the
Drews. Why, they were scarcely acquainted with their new cousin yet!
They did not even know what she was doing—what school she was
attending, or if she was just being a butterfly this year. Somehow, she
drew back from telling them about her studying and its aspirations. It
sounded so out of place in that atmosphere—so hectic after what she had
seen upstairs. So she evaded the subject with a careless, “Oh, I’m not
doing much of anything just now,” and this time succeeded in saying her
farewells uninterrupted. Somehow Jerry saw her rise, and strolled over
to them. Phil following with objecting footsteps. Jerry was palpably
nervous. What she had done in allowing herself to be monopolized in a
corner at such a small dinner-party where she had been a stranger, had
been in bad taste; but it was the sort of thing that was being done
continually by yearlings belonging to what is known as “the best
families,” and she had not sinned against precedent.

Mabel bade Joy an affectionate good-bye, adjuring her not to forget that
the next time she visited New York she must stay with her cousins, and
the Bryn Mawr girl shook hands warmly, hoping-to-see-her-again in a
really genuine tone. Joy found her voice returning a like remark in as
genuine a tone.

Eustace Drew joined Phil as they went to the door, and the two men rode
to the Belmont with Joy and Jerry in an easy volleying of general
conversation carried on mainly by Mr. Drew. Jerry, back in the gloom of
the car, was inscrutable; Phil more so. They left them at the elevator,
where the two girls turned to each other as the door closed and they
shot upwards.

“Anchor me down, Joy,” Jerry whispered; “anchor me down, or I’ll float

“Jerry! What was he saying?”

An interim while they got off at their floor, passed a maid in the
corridor, and gained their room. Jerry threw off her coat and went to
the mirror. “Can you believe it, Joy?” she asked, in luxurious wonder,
falling into all angles of pose; “he doesn’t know me! I’ve changed so
much he doesn’t know me!”

“What did he _say_?” Joy demanded. “I saw he didn’t know you!”

“Well, I’ve changed since then. Funny I hadn’t thought of it that way.
My hair’s bobbed now, of course—and I used to dress a lot more so, and
this black velvet changes me more yet—and my make-up was different——”

“Will you tell me what he said—or won’t you?”

She whirled around from the mirror, and with a jump, seated herself on
the bureau top. “After you went out, I slumped down on the window seat.
My legs had caved in—I couldn’t stand any longer. And he came over to
me and looked down at me—which he kept on doing, by the way. Joy, he
_likes_ to look at me. Did you notice it? Didn’t you? And then he
said—he said—‘Do you believe in love at first sight?’ I was knocked
loggy for a minute. Did I? Hadn’t I! Then I passed back to him: ‘Not
necessarily.’ ‘It is the only love which is formed without analysis,’ he
said, ‘and analysis is death to love.’ ‘Maybe, with some people,’ I
said. ‘You can’t generalize about those things—though I suppose love is
one of the things that is most generalized about.’

“‘Do you want me to come down to particulars?’ he said. ‘Or is it safer
to go on—generalizing?’” Jerry clenched her hands, smiling softly the
while. “I laughed at that. I had to laugh or yell—it was all so like
I’d been dreaming for so long—I can’t believe yet it’s all really
happened—and I said: ‘Please don’t put it up to me.’ ‘Let us both waive
the responsibility, then,’ he said. ‘If what I say sounds like sheer
madness, forget it. You look as if you could forget, and had forgotten,
much. But—I have fallen in love twice in my life. The second time was
this evening, when I saw you come walking down the room to meet me, a
spirit embodied from a dream.’ Joy, he said that! Was there ever
anything like it under Heaven?”

“No!” cried Joy, hysterical with conflicting emotions. “Go on!”

Jerry jumped down from the bureau to look into the mirror again. “Jerry,
your luck,” she cried to her triumphant reflection. “Your luck!” She
turned to Joy. “I was so scared I got to shaking. ‘A dream,’ I said.
‘Yes, that’s what it was, a dream all right.’ I thought it was, too.
‘You do not understand,’ he said. ‘How could I expect it—there will
never be another Brushwood Boy.’ That was one of the things he had given
me to read, Joy. I guess I registered a recognition on that, for he went

“‘Oh, you’ve read it? You remember the Brushwood boy saw a little girl
in the theatre, and afterwards he built an image of her in his dreams.
His image grew in his dreams to womanhood, and bye and bye he met her in
the flesh—a spirit embodied from the dream. Two years ago, in those
fleeting, hectic days of war, at a time when no dreams were being left
to me, I met a little girl who somehow brought me back to interest in
life and—dreams. Our relationship was of the most casual; I only saw
her a few times before I was suddenly put in command of a company that
was sailing. She was not the sort to mean anything in my life, and I
almost forgot her as herself. But her image stayed with me, always
growing in little ways. She herself was so unfinished an image—she was
of a type that could not change its atmosphere and environment—yet
there was that in her which made me build, until the image grew to
womanhood in my dreams. Am I boring you with details of a girl you never
knew? But you see—the image grew to womanhood—and then I met you in
the flesh, the embodiment of that dream.’ I hadn’t stopped shaking. ‘I
don’t understand, except that I remind you of someone you once knew,’ I
said. ‘Nor do I understand,’ he said. ‘It’s of the realm of—dreams.
It’s not to be believed. What is this that makes me sure you are the
complement to my existence, the one woman with everything I want, the
sum total of a man’s fatuous dream that is generally too impossible to
find realization?’ ‘You’d better not spread words around so,’ I said.
‘It isn’t wise to talk freely about anything you only know by sight. If
I were anyone else, I’d think you were crazy.’ He snapped me up on that.
‘If you were anyone else! I must descend to the supreme idiocy and
say—But you are you—and I knew you were when you came walking down the
room to-night.’ ‘You must be a Southern man,’ I said. ‘I’ve always heard
that they swung this line.’ He never blinked at that. ‘Do you feel
nothing?’ he said. ‘If you tell me you felt nothing when your eyes met
mine—if you did not feel that we had been a long time finding each
other—if you tell me that—why then,—I will start in and make you
realize what I know to be true.’”

She stopped, and ran to the window with a trembling laugh. “Look at old
New York—that I couldn’t look at this afternoon! Joy—to think of his
saying that! Asking me if I didn’t feel that we had been a long time
finding each other! Joy—I was so scared I’d slip a cog and come through
with some pithy talk! I spoke slow and thought twice between each word.
‘I—I really—these flashes that seem to go between two people—I never
analyze them—which you seem to be doing, after all.’

“By this time you’d come back, but he didn’t even turn though I kept my
off-eye alive on you. ‘That is—admission,’ he said, talking very low
now. ‘We have started at the end, and defeated all the weary
preliminaries.’ ‘Doesn’t it all amount to the same, though?’ I said;
‘for we’ll have to work back.’ ‘No, it’s not the same,’ he said, ‘for at
the end I do not greatly care to turn back for my sake. I shall for
yours, if you will; but I somehow feel, that to work back is something
for which you, too, do not greatly care.’”

“What did he mean?” Joy interrupted. “How could you follow all this,

“Follow what he says? I’d get his drift if he made love to me in Latin!
He was taking me at my face value, Joy—which wasn’t right, God
knows—and dropping the remark in passing that he wouldn’t expect me to
do the same thing with him, although he sort of thought that I would

“It’s so—so strange.”

“Strange! It’s—as he says—a dream! How did he happen to be your
cousin, anyway? Didn’t you ever know he was?”

Joy explained, and the two fell into a silent labyrinth of wonder. Jerry
walked restlessly about the room. “And he’s still unmarried, though
every woman that passed his way must have made a grab for him!”

“He looks to me like a man who has always had his way—with women,” said
Joy, trembling to break in upon Jerry’s exultation, but fearful memory
driving the words out of her. “What if he was—just bandying words,
Jerry? And thought you were too? Or didn’t care—what you thought? The
last kind I know——You admitted too much, right off like that, it seems
to me.”

Jerry laughed, running her fingers through her hair with a satisfied
sigh. “Don’t you think I’ve been through enough sieges of men and their
lines, in my life, not to be able to tell a real thing from a line? The
real thing just thumps out. You never can mistake it. A line can be
finely spun, but it can’t thump. The real thing and a line can have the
same words—that’s where we women get fooled—it’s manner and looks
you’ve got to watch.”

“He’s awfully cynical about women,” said Joy. “And his face, Jerry—it’s
so full of—so—experienced.”

“Can you imagine me getting along well with anyone who was—not?” Jerry
questioned; and then smiled again. Joy started. Her smile held in it an
echo of Mabel’s peculiar radiance. “Cynical! His face looks like a kid’s
who has asked for a stick of candy and been stuffed with the whole candy

She began to slide out of her clothes. “And he doesn’t know—that I’m
Galatea! Can you tie that?”

“You—don’t have to tell him,” and Joy watched her from the corner of
one eye as she brushed her hair. “He doesn’t care about working
back—he’s said so—you never have to tell him a—thing.”

Jerry shrugged her shoulders into the purple kimono. “He’s going to
lunch with me to-morrow. He’ll see me in broad daylight without candles
and the black velvet dress. It’ll be my turn to talk—in which case I
can’t keep up my stride, and will have to slide into the American
language. And I’m going to tell him—of course I’m going to tell him.
Don’t you see my really being both things—starting the dream, and
finishing it—makes it—better than ever? If he doesn’t see it that
way—— But he will! I can’t wait to tell him.”

Joy crawled into bed with misgivings which grew faint in the face of
Jerry’s firm faith. “It was just as we doped it, wasn’t it, Joy? You
said he went across—and I said that I was too small and casual a matter
for him to waste pains on—when it got inconvenient for him to do so.
They sent him over sooner than he expected—so he simply knocked out of
my life. But now! Those years were worth it—I’d go through ’em over
again if I were sure this was coming at the end.”

“And he thinks he’s started at the end,” said Joy, “and ‘defeated all
the weary preliminaries.’”

Jerry had snapped out the light, opened the windows and jumped into bed,
but her head reared up again at this. “You think he’s had an easy time
of it—compared to me—that I made it too easy for him, right off—don’t
you? I—I didn’t want to make it any harder for _myself_! And look at
his face, Joy—does he look as if _he_ had had an especially satisfying
time along the way—before he found me?”

“Forgive me, Jerry,” said Joy after a silence. “He was right, these
things should not be analyzed.”

But Jerry did not even hear her. “We have been a long time finding each
other. But the finding trims everything on heaven and earth tied
together, to a finish!”

And Joy was conscious of an overpowering loneliness. It was a barren
feeling; she had never really loved. She had not known Mabel’s radiance
or Jerry’s ecstatic fireworks, in the disturbing thrills that had been
hers in the past which now seemed so far removed it was as if it
belonged to another life. And now, with Jerry silent but not asleep by
her side, she felt suddenly, horribly alone. Jerry was her best friend,
and save for Jim, her only friend. Yet how that friendship sank into
insignificance now. Jerry’s world was full; all her world and life were
but one man; and Joy was outside. She lost herself in sleep, where she
dreamed that the only person remaining in her world who spelled anything
in life to her, had left her. She woke up sobbing bitterly, with “Jim!”
on her lips. All was toneless dark, that breathless hour of earliest
morning when vitality is at its lowest ebb yet sometimes the heart may
beat at its highest. Things are seen at that hour with uninfluenced
clarity of vision. And Joy gasped in the shock of the knowledge that was
rising within her. Jim Dalton was the only person left—who spelled
anything in life to her. Jerry was sleeping quietly; her tears fell
unconsoled. “Jim!” she sobbed again; and with his name trembling through
the black fringe of dawn, she fell asleep.


The next day was Saturday, and Félicie returned around noon just as
Jerry left Joy in a whirlwind of breathless anticipation. Félicie was
pale and sulky from dancing all night and having to come back to New
York the next morning.

“I missed a dance this afternoon and a wonderful one this evening,” she
crabbed, taking off her outer raiment and donning a kimono, before lying
on the bed to recuperate. At Joy’s question of why she hadn’t stayed the
house-party through, she batted an injured brown velvet orb. “How could
I, with Greg here and acting so awfully just because I wanted to go to
Princeton for one day. He needn’t think I’d give up every evening to
him—especially after the way he talked Thursday. I tell you, Joy, it’s
awful to be in love. I never did such an inconvenient thing as I did
when I fell in love with Greg.”

Joy stifled her laughter. “Did you have a good time?”

“Marvelous—simply marvelous. Princeton is the house-party girl’s Mecca.
It’s mean of Greg to act so—it isn’t as if I could be asked to
Princeton for many more years.”

Joy ran a scale, poising it neatly through the air and listening to the
smoothness of tone. In the morning sun, music was more alive and
satisfactory, even with no piano near. It was part of her—and little
fluctuations of feeling were to be ignored, when she knew that all her
being was absorbed in one great purpose. It had been silly of her to
grow sentimental just because she had been doused in the atmosphere of
sentiment. Inconsistently, she felt angry at Félicie.

“I can’t imagine being in love with a man and going off skating with a
dozen others.”

“Oh, Joy, if you’re going to take Jerry’s side I shall just pass out!”
wailed the lovely thing on the bed. “Being in love doesn’t stop you from
wanting something new once in awhile.”

“Nothing seems to prevent anyone nowadays from going after a new
sensation! Excitement-chasing! That’s what everyone’s doing!”

“It’s all very well for those who aren’t in love to theorize about what
those who are in love should do. For all Jerry’s talk, I can’t see her
giving up _her_ ‘excitement-chasing’ for any man. Can you?”

The thought was a new one. What would happen if Jerry was given the
opportunity to know this man so that the novelty would wear off? How
would the Excitement-Eater stand a sustained love? She was silent in
conjecture, and Félicie, too lazy to voice the triumph she felt, closed
her eyes and worked her face down into the pillow.

Joy and Jerry had tickets for an Æolian Hall concert that afternoon, and
now Joy went alone. The throngs always pressing ahead on the streets,
exhilarated her, and she watched the faces of the people that urged
themselves along; faces with success or failure written more or less
plainly upon them. Most women, she supposed, succeeded or failed by
proxy, as their husbands rose or fell in the foaming rapids of struggle.
But there would be no such vicarious state for her! She was plunging
directly into the rapids for herself, and some day she would walk in her
own success.

She returned to the hotel in a fine enthusiasm, humming under her
breath; the concert had been perfect. Her spirits were dashed, however,
by the empty room. Félicie had gone out with Greg; Jerry had not
returned. She would probably be alone until they assembled to take the
midnight; they had decided when they came over, to go back Saturday
night. To eat dinner all alone in New York! She was doing her hair
without enthusiasm when the telephone bell rang. It was Jerry’s voice,
eager and exultant: “That you, Joy? I’m downstairs—— Thought I was
going to desert you for dinner, did you? Just wanted to see if you were
back yet. Be right up.”

She finished setting in her hairpins with a lightening of spirits, as
the door rattled open and Jerry came dancing in.

“Was the concert good?” she cried. Spots of colour flaunted joy from
either cheek; her lips were tremulous, crinkled into softness; her eyes
were a battlefield of colour.

“Very good,” said Joy, and waited.

Jerry pulled off her hat and suit, and in her customary whirlwind was
making preparations for an evening toilette. “Put on your best calico,
Joy; we’re dining in state. Phil’s gone to get into his
cocktail-and-demitasse, too.”


“Yes, of course, Phil. Do you want to hear what happened, or don’t you?
Are you keeping still because I’m shooting off my mouth, or——”

“I want to hear,” Joy said; “and when people want to hear, they
generally keep still.”

And then it came, with the generosity that was Jerry’s.

“Well, it seems I always tell you everything from the pop of the pistol
on through. When we went down in the lobby, he asked me where I wanted
to go; and I said, ‘Hanley’s.’ He looked at me queerly on that. ‘What
made you pick that out?’ he wanted to know.”

She was caressing her hair with the military brushes, not raking it as
was her custom.

“‘Let’s walk over,’ I said. ‘I want to stop at a place on the Avenue.’
As we went down Forty-Second Street, I rained a loose line of chatter
along. I told you to-day would be my turn to talk. We got to Charlette’s
before I had stuck in any background. When I saw the good old
grey-silk-curtained windows, I began to get a bit shaky. But I turned to
him and said: ‘We got to the end—rather sudden, last night. Men don’t
like to work back, but you know—and intimated as much—that women are
different that way.’ He opened the door for me, looking sort of at sea,
and we came in. ‘All I ask of you,’ I said, ‘is to stand here and watch
me.’ ‘The last part is something I can never omit,’ he said.

“You know Charlette’s—never many customers floating around, but oh, how
they do bleed ’em when they come! I breezed forward, and the first
person I ran into was Fanchon O’Brien. She tucked me into her flesh
Georgette waist with a few motherly kisses, and the next minute somebody
had passed the glad word and cutters, basters, fitters and designers
came out and fell around me. I won’t go into details of Old Home Week at
Charlette’s. When I broke away, Phil followed me to the door and on the
other side I didn’t give him a chance to speak.

“‘Did you see all the poor little rats hailing me as a kindred soul?’ I
said. ‘I worked in that place from twelve years old up, from
messenger-girl to designer. I was a poor little rat when I started—but
when I finished, I was pretty proud of myself.’ I looked up at him, and
he was looking at me, sort of scowling, as if to make everything add up
right,—but not one bit _changed_. ‘I should think you would be proud,’
he said. ‘I am proud of you—I shall be prouder when I can realise it
more fully.’ He didn’t say anything till we got over to Hanley’s. Then
he took in the name again as we went in. ‘Hanley’s!’ he said.
‘Funny——’ He didn’t say anything more and I let him look at me till we
got put in our places by a waiter. Then I said: ‘You’ve forgotten what
was to me one of the most important points in the Brushwood Boy. The
little kid he met in the theatre who supplied the foundation of his
dreams—was the same person as the woman he found. The girl had grown
up; but she was the same one; she had been the kid.’

“Joy, he said nothing for two or three minutes steady, till the waiter
came and he told him to bring anything, but get out. Then he
said—‘I—see now! The valiance and potential beauty I saw in the spirit
of the little girl who brought me back to myself—the shining hardness
of the cabaret singer, whom I pitied as drawn in and around by her past
and inevitable future environment—I discarded that hardness, and all
that went with it, and built on the valiance and beauty. And you were
discarding and building in reality—as I, with all the idiotic finality
of a man, never thought you could!’

“Joy—I didn’t think I’d built. Before—he thought I was worse than I
was. Last night, seeing me ooze around his sister’s drawing room, he
thought I was better than I am. I began to tell him this, and he stopped

“When I first knew you—I knew you were better than I,’ he said. ‘As I
see you now, you have all but put yourself beyond me. I have led a life
of which I am ashamed; the dusty corners of which no one shall ever
know, or try to sweep out. You have led a life of which you can say you
are not ashamed; a life of striving against odds, from which you came
out on top; a life of which to be proud.

“Joy—I was ashamed at that. For since the war—you know how I’ve
been—Building, he thought! When I’d just been growing into the ways of
his world. Excitement-Eating! That was the main thing I’d been growing
on. I began to tell him—and he wouldn’t let me. ‘What has happened is
not mine now. It is for what is to be that I plead. With your future
mine, and mine yours, you can help me to forget the years we might not
have esteemed so lightly.’”

Jerry had finished, at the same time that she had snapped the last catch
together in her green evening gown—the same green sequin affair that
she had worn that terrible night they had looked for Sarah. . . .

“Well—and then what happened the rest of the afternoon?” Joy drew out
from lungs that had been deserted of breath.

“I’ve told you more than I shall ever tell anybody. The rest is
mine—that and—_this_!”

Jerry flaunted her left hand before her. On the third finger was a tiny
platinum circlet, so small that it had melted into the white of her hand
at a distance, as gold could not have done. “I’ve tried to thrust it
down your throat a thousand ways, but you would keep looking at my face
and a thousand other unimportant things!”

Joy sank back upon the bed, her whole being a rag of dumfounderment.

“Mrs. Philip Lancaster—and hurry up and put on some rouge! I don’t want
to keep my husband waiting!”

“But—but why—how—where——”

“We tossed the subject back and forth at luncheon. We figured we’d been
without each other long enough. After lunch we walked up to the nearest
jewelry store and got this ring. I wouldn’t let him get a big one, or
anything but this one. He’s poor, you know, Joy—the Lancasters are all
poor. That is, he calls it poor, but now that he’s got me he’s going to
work—you know he’s supposed to be a lawyer—and that combined with his
income and my little Charlette block ought to keep us passing the buck
along. We got married with a special license, at the Little Church
Around the Corner——” Jerry spoke with the calmness of excitement at
white heat—“and before going off on our honeymoon—we thought we’d take
you to our wedding dinner. You see, if it hadn’t been for you I’d have
still been excitement-eating—and he’d still be cynicing it around.”

The telephone rang, and Jerry darted to it. “Yes! Yes, this is Mrs.
Lancaster! Yes, we’re coming, Phil!” The name was all endearments shaped
in one. Jerry turned to hurry Joy with her last touches, and Joy, in a
state of coma almost bordering on collapse, followed Jerry’s eager
footsteps to the elevator and down into the lobby. Jerry’s husband was
waiting for them, fierily handsome in evening dress, and at least ten
years younger than he had seemed last night. Last night!—It seemed so
far away. Joy could not even stammer much, but Jerry and Phil did not
notice lack of anything, and swept her into the dining room.

“Let me see,” said Phil; “it’s the first time I’ve seen my wife in
evening dress.”

“Second!” said Jerry swiftly. “I wore one at Hanley’s, two years ago!”

“Oh, but that was a _costume_!”

Their words were stupid, inconsequential, in the face of Joy sitting
there. Their eyes were speaking to each other, saying so much that Joy
dared not look. And just last night——

“I wonder what Mabel will say,” she ventured. They paid to her remark
the tribute of polite inattention.

“I owe Jerry to you,” said Jerry’s husband; “but I don’t intend to pay

Of course—Jerry was leaving her now! Leaving her and the
apartment—alone! She considered this bleak fact, all through the
course. At last, breaking in upon the conversation of eyes, she said:
“What will you do with the apartment, Jerry?”

“Oh, I don’t know,” said Jerry. “The lease will be up in July. Why don’t
you stay in it till then? Phil and I are going to live in his apartment
here, until we get a house in the suburbs, so I shan’t be moving out my
stuff for some time.”

To stay in the apartment—with the ghost of Sarah in curl-papers and
wrapper whining through the kitchenette—and the purple kimono and pink
mules gone from everywhere. . . . She did not bring the thought to the
surface of the table. “You two in the suburbs!” she exclaimed instead,
in faint derision.

Jerry hardly smiled. People in love always lost their sense of humour,
but you wouldn’t think Jerry——

“Apartment life would merely be existing for us,” said Phil. “We are
going to live.”

Their eyes trembled together in close embrace. . . . Joy hurried through
her dessert; the others had made no pretense of eating. Their appetite
was as if they had just come in from luncheon. All three were regarding
the meal as a more or less disagreeable formality to be gotten through
with as quickly as possible. But when they had finished, they grew
embarrassed at their haste, and everyone tried to be jovial, lingering
over the coffee.

“Last night at this time,” said Phil, “I was telling our cousin just why
I didn’t like younger or older women.”

“And looking at Jerry,” added Joy.

“And looking at Jerry,” he said gravely, repeating the performance.

“If you don’t like younger or older women, where do I come in?” Jerry

“You don’t,” he told her; “you are neither young nor old; you are

At length they rose, and Joy went with Jerry while Jerry threw
everything into her suitcase and crushed it shut.

“It won’t be anything but so-long,” said Jerry; “I’ll be coming over to
Boston soon to get the rest of my wardrobe.”

“I’ll send it to you.”

“No—I’ll want to come. . . . Joy—you’ve been the only real girl friend
I ever had—and now you’ve given me everything that there is to hang
onto in this world.”

She said good-bye to them by the elevator downstairs, and watched them
vanish through the same revolving doors that Jerry had helped speed
around so merrily—was it only two days ago? They walked together as if
they were still in an expectant dream . . . in a sort of awed

Joy suddenly knew that, of all lots in life, the lot of the looker-on,
the passive spectator, was the hardest. To see worlds of glory pass,
which she had to tell herself were not for her. She packed her bag,
checked out and climbed on the midnight as soon as it was open. Félicie
came at the last minute, with Greg carrying her suitcase into the train
and then stopping for a prolonged farewell while the train was moving.
The three girls had engaged a section, one to sleep in the upper and two
on the lower, and she was astonished to find Joy alone in the lower with
the upper pushed back out of the way.

“Hello,” said Joy sourly. Félicie’s but-lately-kissed beauty was
annoying. . . . “Where’s Jerry?” Félicie demanded, crawling inside and
emptying her suitcase over Joy in the process.

“Married!” Joy snapped, and turned over to look out of the window at the
lights of New York they were leaving behind.

“_Married!_” Félicie sank down in the midst of the out-heaval of
hairpins and lingerie, cold cream jars and silk stockings. Then weakly
she articulated Jerry’s epitaph: “I always said that girl would do


Winter hung heavily on that year; February dragged itself to a close,
choked with December snowfall, and Spring looked bleak and far away.
Travelling even from New York to Boston was horrible, and Jerry did not
come for a long time.

Joy was alone in the apartment.

As she had foreseen, Sarah’s querulous voice wavered in the halls. And
in the kitchenette her kimono and curl papers tinted the atmosphere. And
everywhere the tap of the pink mules or the sound of the rough plush of
Jerry’s voice seemed to be trembling in echo’s echo. . . . She asked
Félicie to spend the night with her as often as she cared to; but
Félicie didn’t care to very often. It was not that she was not fond of
Joy, as she explained; but it was so much trouble to move herself and
all her things. Félicie liked everything drawn up around her in waxworks
precision of detail, just as she had arranged it at her home.

And so Joy lived in an enforced solitude while considering what she was
going to do. The heavy snowfalls were deadening to enterprise; the
easiest thing to do was to stay in the apartment, which was hers for the
present, instead of looking around for something else. Sitting alone at
the piano in the room which had so often sung with mirth, she found it
hard to realize that she was the only one left in Sarah’s and Jerry’s
flat. One little, two little, three little Indians! One had gone; and
then there were two. And now one more had gone; and there was only
one. . . .

She had not seen Jim Dalton for a long time. When he had called her up,
she had put him off with the excuse of work. She could not see him,
because she felt that she wanted to see him too much. But she told
herself with an easy surety that she was not in love with him; once back
with Pa Graham she had fallen into the magic of music once more, magic
that left no room for sentimentality, and that, she told herself, was
all that her lapse had been; sheer sentimentality. But since the idea
had occurred to her that she might suspect herself of being in love with
him, she was uneasy about seeing him. And surely preventative methods
were best!

Yet she longed to see him, to tell him every little detail of the
epoch-making trip to New York. Looking back she clung to her part in it,
and wanted Jim—wanted him to exult with her over the great one’s
approval. Who was it who said he travelled faster who travels alone?
There had to be someone to spur on the traveller—sometimes! And Jerry
had gone, and there was no one. Félicie was frankly bored with music.
And Jim of her own exclusion stayed away, although his telephone calls
did not diminish in number. . . .

One afternoon in March as she was walking down Boylston Street, she saw
Grant. He passed driving a car, the Grey’s runabout, and by his side was
a girl whose peachbloom face, even at a distance, was vaguely familiar.
As she stared, the girl waved, smiling, and said something to Grant,
whose eyes were on the traffic. He swerved and brought the car into the
curb, and Joy came to them as Miss Dalrymple, the Bryn Mawr girl, leaned
out expectantly.

“Miss Nelson!” she hailed her. “I didn’t know you were in Boston!” Joy
interrupted as she started to present Grant. “We’ve already met. I
didn’t know _you_ were in Boston, Miss Dalrymple.”

The college girl explained that she was visiting a friend in her
vacation, that it was her first visit in Boston, and that she liked it
_very much_. Her eyes dwelt on Grant in naïve compliment at this last,
and Grant smiled appreciatively in return.

Joy nearly smiled, herself. Six months ago, and one would have thought
she had ruined a life. Now Grant was looking better, and happier, than
she had ever seen him; and he was regarding her with offhand
friendliness. The girl at his side was really an exquisite thing, with
clear, eager eyes like his own. Joy knew that her own radiant eyes had
been dulled, first by the experience of disillusionment, and then by
monotonous routine. She knew that she was thin and pale from a life of
irregular restaurant eating; she knew that the exquisite young thing at
Grant’s side gained colour by comparison; and she was glad. This could
be a last picture that would wipe out all regret, in dreams of what
might have been.

Miss Dalrymple was all exclamations over Jerry’s marriage. “To think
that it happened the very next day, and there we sat never suspecting
what was going on! It’s the most romantic thing I ever knew!”

Mabel had written Joy twice; at first when she had been so upset over
the unconventionality that marked this Lancaster marriage, then later
when she had seen them together and lost her shock, in joy at finding
her brother in the heights she was beginning to fear would never be his.

“Mabel always said he was awfully romantic,” the college girl was
saying; “that explained his cynicism, for they say cynics are always
really romantic—that’s the way they hide it. But did you ever hear of
anything so sudden?”

Joy’s eyes caught Grant’s on that. “Not—that turned out so well,” she
said demurely.

Miss Dalrymple turned to Grant. “You know, Miss Nelson’s cousin had her
brother all picked out for me—when Miss Nelson walked in with the most
fascinating girl you ever saw, who walked right off with him.”

“Then I owe Miss Nelson—a very great debt!” said Grant, with a smile
that broke in the middle as he looked at Joy and saw her amusement
shrieking from beneath the sheltered surface of polite friendliness. The
air was tingling with omissions, as Joy said her good-byes and left
them. Their status was plain—an affair well along in interest and

The girl with the skin of peachdown and the wide, untroubled eyes was
the logical mate for Grant Grey. Each could give the other as nearly all
that the other desired as was possible in an earthly union. It would be
one of those unions that seemed eminently _right_—and it would even
seem so to Mrs. Grey! Joy laughed aloud at that last thought. The
heart-caught-on-the-rebound sneer, on which so many girls inwardly feed
while apparently they are smilingly urbane to their former suitors’
flames, never even occurred to her. It was a perfect union, while the
union of her nature and Grant’s would always have been imperfect at

Inexplicably it made her feel the more lonely.

It was soon after that that a bulky letter arrived from her father, the
contents of which threw her into the laughter of misgiving. It seemed
that the Lamkins had returned from an extensive trip South and West, and
had spread throughout the length and breadth of Foxhollow Corners the
glorified account of Joy Nelson’s gallivanting around Noo York with
perfectly impossible people, to one of which she seemed to be engaged
“in a light way.” The rumour had swollen until it was reported that Joy
had been secretly married over in New York and had taken up her abode
there permanently. Of course her father had heard the last rumour first,
and with businesslike precision had sifted it through to the Lamkins and
heard their representations of the “facts.”

“I am disturbed,” he wrote, “and ask you for verification before I take
any steps in this matter. The town seems to be rolling tales of your New
York escapades as a sweet morsel under its tongue. You told me nothing
of any side of your New York visit that could be interpreted this way.
It is not possible for the child of your mother to have done anything
really wrong, but in New York you may have forgotten the obligations
that the name of Nelson puts upon you. After all, home people are the
ones that will mean your life, when you finish your studying and come
back to normal existence once more; and it does not do to antagonize
them as you so evidently have the Lamkins. It is a difficult thing for a
father to be sole guardian of a daughter; there are so many questions a
father alone cannot decide. I wish you would come home, and take up your
music here, perhaps in the church choir.”

He ended the letter with the thought that he might come to Boston soon,
as he had never yet seen her environment there.

Joy read the letter with mixed emotions which had culminated in the
rather shaky laughter. How could she explain to her father that what the
Lamkins had heard had been a mere prank played for the benefit of the
waiters and surrounding interested ones even as the Lamkins? It was the
sort of thing that he could never understand. And he spoke as though all
her fiercely eager study were to end in nothing—“a normal life once
more.” The church choir! She jumped up and poured forth a long cadenza,
which enveloped the room in an exultation of sound. At the close she
balanced two notes evenly, one against the other, tracing them up and
down—when all at once her throat began to flutter, effort ceased, and
she stood in rapt wonder, listening. Her first real trill was born.

The church choir!

It was that afternoon, while she was hesitating over a reply to her
father, that Jim called her on the phone.

“Do you realize how long it’s been since I’ve seen you, Joy?” he asked.

She did. “I’ve been so busy——” she faltered. “And now that Jerry is
gone, I can’t very well entertain in the apartment alone——”

“Then we can meet somewhere and go to dinner. Meet me at the Touraine,
at half-past six. I must see you, Joy.”

She went back to her letter in a more peaceful frame of mind. By now her
sentimental lapse was well over, and she would be glad to see Jim again.
After all, he was the only real friend she had. She finally pushed the
letter paper away from her. Jim would advise her as to how she would
reply. Somehow he always knew what to do.

When she drifted into the Touraine exactly five minutes late—Jerry and
Sarah had taught her that system—men hate to wait and yet one must
never be on time—Jim came forward to meet her, and she found herself
clinging to his hand for a longer space of time than is allotted to the
usual formal clasp. All her past loneliness rose about her and seemed to
choke her utterance, with something else that left her without speech.

“Let’s not eat here,” said Jim; “there’s something so public about this
place. Everyone just seems to come here to look everyone else over.”

Out in the evening air, speech returned to her, and they bridged the
time they had not seen each other by a few sentences while walking
through those strange cross-alleys that only Boston can boast until they
came to a cobble-stoned street that comprises part of the city’s modest
Chinatown, and “counted out” on the different restaurants facing them. A
façade of ornate gilt with curtained windows won the count, and they
were soon in a little stall away from the bright lights of the central

The order given, Joy told the complete story of the New York trip, with
the loneliness Jerry’s leaving her had brought. “What shall I do?” she
concluded. “If father comes down here, he’ll find me living alone in the
apartment—which he certainly would not like.”

“Joy, you know that you can’t stay in that place alone,” said Jim.
“That’s one reason why I insisted on seeing you to-night—I wanted to
find out your plans.”

“Jerry wants me to stay in it till July—and it’s so much easier for me
in every way—especially practicing—than if I boarded anywhere——”

Jim shook his head. “This Félicie Durant you speak of, who lives in
Brighton with her great-aunt—perhaps she could persuade her aunt to
rent Jerry’s apartment, and then keep you as a boarder. If you suggest
that scheme to her, she might think of offering to take you in with them
even if they didn’t care to move.”

“That is—a good suggestion,” she said uncertainly. She was in that
state of mind where she hated to take any steps, make any plans.

“If that fails, you’ll have to apply to the Students’ Union for lists of
recommendable places,” he added with quiet finality.

“Oh, is that what one does?” She felt foolishly incompetent. “How did
you know?”

“I’ve been making inquiries myself. I knew you were alone there, and
that you couldn’t stay that way.”

Joy felt an embracing peace, the peace of decision in which Jim always
enveloped her. “Jim,” she said suddenly, “what have I ever done—or
been, except a foolish girl—that you should be so good to me? At the
very first, you did—more than I can ever repay—and then you went
on—always helping me, in ways that really were help—and understanding
so well—sometimes better than I understand myself!”

Jim looked at her across the table, and the keen friendliness dropped
from his eyes, all at once; leaving them naked. Involuntarily Joy turned
away her face. When his voice came, it was quiet, with a new current
bearing it along.

“It is because I have understood so well—that I’ve never told you what
I must tell you now. The brakes won’t hold—I think I have loved you,
Joy, from the time your lip quivered when you told me to take you back
to Tom.”

A pause while the Chinese waiter took away their dishes. Of all moments
to bring in his tardy self!

Joy started to speak, to falter her way with lips suddenly tender, but
he was looking away from her now and beyond.

“I think you ought to know, Joy—that I love you more than anyone else
in this world. You—you mean life to me.”

There was no wild heart-beat trembling in her being as she heard his
words, nothing but peace and a great content. “Oh, Jim!” she said in a
little voice, then waited for his eyes to meet hers. . . . It had not
come within the halo of dreams nor in the area of the disturbing thrills
of youth—it came in a golden calm. Jim was the Perfect Knight, of whom
she had dreamed in the days when she supposed one had but to wait and
the knight would come a-riding; the Perfect Knight, with spotless shield
and shining armour. The shield was his spotless life, making him more
than worthy of her; the armour was the white strength of his soul and
his body with which he had defended her at all times, since the very

Then weirdly, unaccountably, across the even rhapsody of her meditation
came a voice from the chapels of memory; a voice full, perfectly poised,
with each word as flawless as if it had been engraved on a cameo.

“Love comes down to a hearth-fire, after marriage; and we who sing are
not content with hearth-fires. Remember that always, little one; _we who
sing are not content with hearth-fires_.”

Only that second of recollection before Jim’s eyes met hers, and Joy
chose her fate. She urged her eyes away from him, with a sick little
shiver; and keeping them fixed on some distant point, she said in a
voice so slight it almost slipped away before it struck the hearing:

“I—won’t,” he said, in a voice that did not alter. “I—I knew it
was—hopeless, Joy, before I spoke; and I shall not bother you about it
again; but I wanted you to know, while I was able to see you—you have
not let me see you for so long.”

“Jim—I’m so sorry——” she cried, against the destruction that was
descending upon her soul so lately filled with peace.

“Sorry! Sorry is—an awful little word. I didn’t want to make
you—sorry. I just wanted you to know—I would have been a conceited ass
indeed if I had thought you could—care for me.”

“It’s not that.”

The words were clipped out in an even, glassy tone, as hard as a
window-pane and as easy to break or see through. But the shutters were
down behind, for the one who most wanted to see. . . .

Jim did not bring the subject up again until they were at the door of
the apartment.

“Please don’t let anything I’ve said worry you, Joy. And—we still are
friends—aren’t we?”

“Oh, yes, Jim!” she cried, and then fell silent, ashamed.

“This world would indeed be an empty place for me—if anything should
happen to that friendship.”

He took her hand, and she knew in a bitter little rush how much she
wanted to have his arms around her—to feel again encompassing her the
peace that she had destroyed. Pale as the novice who goes to her vows,
she took her hand away and left him.

She sat at the piano, striving to drown the turbulence within her by a
glory of sound. With shaking, silver lips, she tried to form the words
of the Jewel Song—she should be able really to sing it now—for to-day
had come her first trill! “All passes; Art alone endures.” She was so
wise not to have allowed the sentiment of the moment to overpower her.
It was just such moments that were responsible for the “mute, inglorious
Pattis” of the world.

The trill came, neat and exquisite. Then haltingly—

                          “Je ris—de me voir—
                          Si belle—”

Her voice limped into silence. . . .

She left the piano. This loneliness was getting on her nerves. She would
see Félicie to-morrow. Yes, to-morrow was coming—and she could not wait
to have Pa hear that trill!

On hearing Joy’s proposition, Félicie consulted her great-aunt, but
neither of them wished to leave their eminently satisfactory lodgings in

“It’s awful for you to be alone, though, Joy,” she said. “Auntie
suggested that you come and stay with us—she’s deaf, you know, so she
won’t mind your practicing, if you don’t mind living in the little room
off the kitchen——I’d take you in with me, but there’s really no room,
the way everything’s fixed.”

Having decided to accept this enthusiastic invitation before it had been
issued, Joy surprised Félicie by being pleased with the offer of the
little room near the kitchen. “Of course, I’d pay board,” she said, “and
take my meals out.”

“Well, all right,” said Félicie, “only auntie will be annoyed if you
don’t eat with her. She’s lonely, now that I go out so much of the

They left the situation to be fought out with “auntie,” and Joy wrote
Jerry of her decision to leave the apartment as soon as she could get
her things together.

Jerry replied by bursting in upon Joy one morning in the first chill
days of April, while Joy was poaching a dejected egg in the kitchenette.
A new radiant Jerry, all softness and winsome, assured charm that is the
gain of those who are exorbitantly loved in return for their own great
love. She danced over the apartment in pretended high spirits at being
back, and then packed her clothes in a rush of concentration that
betrayed her haste.

“This is the first time I’ve been away from him—and I didn’t know I was
going to feel like this!” she confessed.

“There’s just one thing, though. You have no use for the wine-closet, I
take it?”

Joy had not taken a drink since the night she watched the effect of it
from the sofa, with Wigs and Davy babbling in her ear.

“Then,” said Jerry briskly, “we might just as well do a little
government-agent work.” At Joy’s look of astonishment: “Oh, I never
drink now. There’s—too much else to think about. Phil and I smoke
together—but that’s as far as we go. Seems funny when I think in idle
moments how I’ve taken it down all my life and now have just dropped it
off without—much—effort. But somehow, you don’t feel like the good old
stuff when you’re in love. There’s something about it——”

They took the liquor case by case to the bathroom where they became
carried away by an orgy of opening bottles and watching their contents
gurgle into the tub.

“We could bathe in champagne now, if we felt like it,” said Jerry
reflectively. “I’ve often thought I would, but I guess I was pretty well
doused on the inside when I had the little idea.”

Joy watched it gurgle down the pipe and thought of the inferno that
innocent-looking liquid could cause. . . . What it had caused in her own
experience. . . . In the lights and shades of the mixture tumbling to
the sewers where it belonged, she saw Jack Barnett’s face for a fleeting
horror, that shifted to Packy’s, quite as terrible. And she saw
Sarah. . . . And then they all blended together in a whirling mass, and
flickered away. The bathtub was empty. . . .

“I’ve got to admit,” Jerry was saying, in rather an artificial voice,
“that in spite of everything it makes me feel sort of ill to see all
that joy-getter spilling itself away in such a casual fashion.”

Joy looked at her, and saw that her mouth was slightly twisted, her eyes
bearing a strained expression. It had evidently been more of an effort
for her than Joy had realized.

That Jerry could have stopped drinking altogether! Even to her
inexperienced knowledge it seemed an impossibility. Jerry was staring
into the bathtub again, with the hungry look of the street-gamin. . . .
Joy turned away, and with her old-time quick sensitiveness, Jerry
laughed and joined her.

“I don’t deny it isn’t hard at times and harder at others, old girl,”
she said; “but there are things in everyone’s life that are hard not to
do, and all the same one simply can’t do ’em!”

The day was unlike their old times together. On the surface, both girls
were affectionate, and delighted to be with one another again; but below
the surface everywhere intruded the man who had come between their
friendship, changing everything irrevocably. Jerry was changed. For the
better, one could not doubt; but nevertheless she was not the Jerry that
Joy had known and loved. She was softer, with that new glow within her
lighting everything she did or said. Her speech already showed
meditation, her manner was more reposeful. Content and love were fast
enfolding her into serenity—and, Joy thought, who wanted a serene

Their conversation was strained, although voluble. Jerry’s bristled with
mention of Phil, directly or indirectly. This stimulated Joy’s desire to
talk of Jim; and the realization that she could not, that she had not
Jerry’s excuse or right, brought effort into her responses.

They telephoned Félicie, and Jerry took them both to the Copley for
dinner, over which they lingered. Félicie was wearing her usual look of
unbroken loveliness, and arrayed for a Sixty Club dance in Brookline.
Her attitude towards Jerry was frankly pitying, which abated none the
less when she saw that Jerry’s attitude duplicated hers.

“It’s all right to act as if you’d pulled the moon down to earth, for a
while,” she said tolerantly. “I know how these things come out. Pretty
soon this one-man stuff will get monotonous. Monotony! Sooner or later
you see it in all married life! And you’ll get monotonous to him, too!
Husbands always get so _husband-like_ when their wives begin getting
always the same!”

Jerry laughed. “Better take the plunge like a shot the way I did,
Félicie. Then you’ll have no time to think up objections. Monotony! The
way I used to live—the way you’re living now—is the real monotony.
Continually seeing one side only of large numbers of young men—one
party after another—oh well, there’s no use wasting my flow of English
on the subject.”

There was no use. A youth with an attitude of cultivated boredom and
repressed correctness, came in for her, and she left them “wishing she
could stay, but you see how it is.”

“She never looks eager,” said Joy; “you wouldn’t think she valued a good
time so highly.”

“No, not eager; just smug,” said Jerry tersely, and they talked of other

Jerry the excitement-eater was dead, that was plain. Joy had always
wished to see that side of her dispensed with. Then why did this change,
this miraculous, softening change, stir irritation within her, throw a
breach between them?

She could not fathom the reason until she took Jerry to the eleven
o’clock and told her good-bye. There, with a farewell look at Jerry’s
brilliant face, enhanced by the beloved freckles, it came to her in a
rush. She was jealous—jealous both ways! Before, she had been jealous
of Phil Lancaster only for taking Jerry from her; now, she was jealous
of Jerry herself, for the world in which she lived, the world upon which
Joy had turned her back. . . .

She did not sleep well that night. Disturbing thoughts pressed urgently
about her, and would not postpone their hearing.

It was a powerful force that had led Jerry to stop drinking, to drop her
Excitement-Eating ways without regret. To pit oneself against such a
force—to eliminate it from one’s life—was an undertaking at the
mysterious door of which Joy paused and shivered. . . .


” Oh, dear! What if it should rain? Can you imagine anything worse than
organdy in the rain? And yet if it doesn’t rain, can you imagine
anything worse than to have on dark silk, at Harvard Class Day, with
everyone else in organdy?”

Thus Félicie, flattening her imperial nose against the window pane, a
scowl menacing her untrodden brow, as the few clouds in the skies were
menacing the calm of the June day.

Joy had been with Félicie and her aunt throughout the spring, a troubled
spring of work and restlessness. The old wild longings that had once
shaken her did not return. There was instead a dull, sick emptiness,
which engulfed her work rather than allowing itself to be engulfed.

Few events had marked Joy’s calendar. Her father had made his
long-anticipated visit, and found himself pleased with her environment
as well as charmed by Pa Graham. Under Pa’s guidance Joy had worked
herself into a position from which she could map out her progress for
the next few years. “Nothing but death can stop me,” she told herself;
and the words grew into a sort of refrain that twinkled into her mind at
regular intervals, generally putting to rout some unwarranted flight of

Félicie had taken the spring at a pace that left faint smudges beneath
her eyes, and an ever-so-little receding of the tide of colour on the
cheeks that she boasted had never known a rouge-puff. It seemed as
though she had been wound up and could not stop. Evenings when there was
no excuse for going out, no especial festivity to attend, she would go
to the movies, eat down a few thrills, leave early and dance late.
Sometimes in the mornings, when her yawns were irrepressible, Joy would
ask her why she never let down.

“My dear, you can’t stop going—you lose your grip!” she said, wide-eyed
that the answer was not obvious.

“Losing your grip” was the one thing the Excitement-Eaters seemed to

Now, Félicie was chafing between a watermelon-coloured organdy and a
dark blue taffeta, both laid challengingly upon the bed.

“Why did I say I’d go, anyway?” she complained. “Of course, I want to
go. It’s interesting, even if there are millions of relations and
absolutely no cut-ins—but it isn’t worth it to have all this trouble
about deciding!”

“If everyone usually wears organdy, why not chance it? They’ll all be in
the same boat if it rains.”

This from Joy, as she combed her hair preparatory to donning organdy
herself. Hal Jennings, the Harvardite who was taking Félicie to Class
Day, had given her two tickets for the Stadium exercises and his club
spread, and Joy had accepted Félicie’s invitation to share the tickets.
She had never seen Harvard Class Day, and her anticipation was not
dimmed by Félicie’s grumping. Félicie was always like that if she had to
decide anything.

“Oh, I suppose so,” said Félicie, and retired to the closet to change;
“but you _know_ how it _looks_ in the rain!”

When they were duly arrayed in filmy pink and blue, they presented
themselves to Madame Durant for approval. She always liked to see
Félicie before she went out anywhere, to criticize or approve her
costume—usually to command changes, which was a sore trial to Félicie,
as refutation into an ear-trumpet is as futile as it is disagreeable.

Madame Durant approved their “simple dresses” at first, then when they
were ordered to “turn around,” remarked accusingly that she could see
right through them, and they must each put on another good, thick

Joy and Félicie exchanged glances of despair. If there is anything a
girl hates, it is a good, thick petticoat. But the ear-trumpet ruled,
and they retired to bolster themselves out. Since Joy had been
associated with Madame Durant, she had made allowances for many of
Félicie’s characteristics. When they were starting out of the door, the
penetrating voice that deaf people often acquire recalled them. Those
little light coats weren’t enough. They must take long, dark coats and
umbrellas. Félicie started to crumple, then remembered her starched
dress and compressed her emotion into a waver.

“It’s bad enough to go not knowing how the weather’s going to act, but
to go dressed _piebald_!”

But they muffled themselves up properly, and with a final interlude of
feeding the dog so that Madame Durant would not have it to do later,
they were off. Félicie had refused to enter a street car in light
things. “They’ll think we’re shop-girls just back from the Park, you
_know_ they will!” And so they had indulged in the formal luxury of a

“I suppose auntie was wise about those coats,” Félicie said; “but I do
hate to encourage her in anything.”

“It seems so strange to have an older woman supervise one’s clothes,”
said Joy. “I suppose that’s because my mother died when I was so little,
and father never wanted anyone to take her place—he wouldn’t even have
a housekeeper.”

“Most girls would have been pretty queer, living that way. You were
lucky to have come through it all right.”

“_But did I?_” Joy wondered, as Félicie turned to peer out of the window
at the smug blue sky. She had dismissed the subject.

“I’ve never been able to figure out why Harvard always gives such
pepless parties compared to other colleges. I’d never mention it to a
Harvard man, because you know it’s just as bad as discussing religion,
you never get _anywhere_—but why do you suppose it is?”

“Never having been to a Harvard affair——”

“I shall die to-night, simply pass out, that’s all. I’m sunk when I
think of it. I just will make Hal take me somewhere else, that’s all. In
the first place everyone brings a girl and you know that’s wrong. It
leaves absolutely no stags. That ruins everything right there.”

“Poor Harvard! Getting knocked for single-mindedness,” Joy murmured.

“That’s just what it is! At the Harvard-Yale game last fall, some Yale
men, friends of Greg’s, came over and cut in on me at the tea dance
afterwards—they really made the dance almost good—and the Harvard men
were simply furious! They’ve just got their minds set on straight

“Oh, well, you can’t generalize. All Harvard men can’t be so resourceful
that they enjoy having a whole dance with a girl.”

Before Félicie had this sifted down, the taxi-man drew up and informed
them that they would have to walk from there.

The little clouds that had threatened like a baby’s playful fist in the
sapphire laughter of the sky, were now striking blows of grey menace
into the blue.

“Didn’t I _know_ it would rain!” Félicie wailed. “Just _look_ at that
sky. _Why_ do they have the Stadium exercises out-doors?”

Scattered lines of people hurrying to the Stadium; hundreds and hundreds
of girls in all colours of organdy, with organdy hats—and spotless
white slippers. Complacent mothers; excited fathers, trying not to look
too proud; nondescript and sometimes awful people who would be lumped
under the gross head, Relations; all urging their way to the Stadium. It
seemed as if the world was at Harvard Class Day—the world, and its
Relations. As they were led to their cold stone seats by a brick-cheeked
youth who hid his admiration beneath a mask of “Harvard indifference,” a
treble voice lifted itself out of the crowd.

“Why, Joy Nelson! Yes, it is! Hullo, Joy! It’s me—see?”

It was Betty Grey, in black and white organdy combined in sophisticated
lines that made her look all of eighteen—Betty Grey, who threw herself
over to where Joy and Félicie were installing themselves, and hung a
charming wedge between two surging lines of people anxious to get to
their places.

“I haven’t seen you for such _ages_, I thought you were dead or
something! You know, how you always think people are dead or something,
when you don’t see them!”

A struggle ensued behind, which failed to dislodge her while she met
Félicie. “People seem to be pushing me, but they don’t mean it—I always
say, judge a crowd kindly—this is my first Class Day, and I’m terribly
excited! Have you been singing just lots this year?”

“Just lots,” Joy repeated gravely. “What have you been doing? And how

“Oh, Grant’s all right. I haven’t done anything but flunk English
History—there’s a girl visiting us who knows you and your cousin—oh
dear, it feels as if everyone in the world was pushing me! I’ll see you
later, what spread are you going to?”

And Betty Grey was swirled along out of sight.

“They’re starting,” said Félicie. “Look, all the classes march in.”

It was at that moment when Félicie forgot to look at the sky, that the
rain came down—and in no pathetic Boston drizzle; it gave itself out in
the quantities it had been holding back all day, generously making up
for lost time.

All over the Stadium people stood up and umbrellas snapped open,
spreading their inky mushroom caps over slim stems of organdy. “It’ll
only last a minute,” said someone, and the word was passed along until
the mushrooms bobbed to the repetition: “Only a minute—only a minute!”

“It’s going to be more than a minute,” said Joy, whose feet were getting
wet. “I’m going out until it stops.”

“Through all that crowd! I’d rather sit here, as long as we have

“Well, a cold doesn’t mean to you what it would to me. I’ll come back
when it holds up”; and Joy plunged forward into the flock that was
making its way to the nearest exit. Beneath the stone shelter of the
Stadium she found herself but little better off. The ground trampled by
hundreds of wet feet was soggy; dripping people shook themselves all
around her. She turned to seek a dryer place, and knocked into a young
man who was hastening by. They both drew back with apologies which faded
into silence on their lips. It was Packy.


“Why, hello, Packy.” She tried to speak naturally; he made no attempt,
and stood staring down at her until they became aware of the enraptured
gaze of two pink-organdied flappers, who were obviously regretting the
fact that they had so much hair mattressed over their ears.

“Joy—I’ve wanted to see you for a long time—where can we go, so I can
talk to you?”

They fell back to the lee of one of the entrances, where there was
comparative calm.

“I never had the nerve—to call up again, after that night—but I wanted
to see you—I’ve wanted to see you for a long time—to tell you what I
thought of myself for acting the way I did.”

Packy had grown in the months that had passed since she had seen him.
The gangly stripling with the restless, roving eye and the feet that
were always beating out a syllable of jazz, was gone, leaving only
reminiscences of himself. He had gathered composure, and his eyes had
lost their look of seeking excitement.

“What have you been doing this year, Packy?” she asked involuntarily.

“Oh, that’s neither here nor there. As a matter of fact, I’ve been

Working! Packy, the gilded one, with an income to keep him and his among
the polo-labourers and golf-toilers!

“But—well, I’ve written I don’t know how many letters to you, Joy—and
torn them up. Letters are rotten when you really want to say anything.”

They are distracted by a little girl, her organdy clinging to her in
sodden folds, her improbable complexion fast fading to incoherency, as
she came limping out of the rain to her mother who, firmly dry, had been
standing against a pillar.

“Oh, mother, the rain has shrunk my shoes all up—I can’t hardly

“_No_-ra! You were out there, all this time? You’ve always _heard_ about
people who didn’t know enough to come in when it rained!”

“That good lady,” said Packy, “has described me complete. Last fall, I
didn’t know enough to come in when it rained. I did know a few things,
though, Joy. Can you believe that I could never have been such a cad—if
I hadn’t been drunk?”

“I—can,” said Joy.

“I’ve thought it all over—I don’t know how many times—and I’ve thought
it out. To go in back of the fact that I misjudged you—I misjudged
Jerry and Sarah. Because we could act as freely at the apartment as
though we were at our club—because they were on their own—and because
you were with them, and on your own,—I thought—well, I didn’t quite
think so at that—until I was drunk—and then I didn’t think at all.”

Insensibly they had retreated still farther from the crowd, and now
stood in a muddy corner quite alone.

“I was in love with you, Joy, as much as I could ever be. I—I still am,
I guess. It—seems to feel that way. I was always trying to puzzle out
your status—just where you stood in the Jerry-Sarah household. But I
didn’t understand, and so I lost you.”

“You—you needn’t blame yourself so, for not understanding,” said Joy;
“almost anyone might have—I can see that now.”

“No—not any one who recognizes that we’re doing transitional stuff
these days. I was coasting around on last century’s roller skates. They
just hit the surface. Now they’re using ice skates, that go in a little.
Oh, I’ve thought this all out—and got _my_ ice skates!”

“What?” she faltered.

“Why, you know. We all know. Last century—no matter what men were—they
_were all that women had_—so they took them and made the best of it.
Now—no matter what the women of to-day are making of themselves—and a
lot of women don’t exactly know _what_ they’re making of
themselves—they’re all men have—and _we_’re certainly not going to
make the worst of it.”

Joy thought. This was a mean between the extremes of the discussion held
at Fennelly’s between Greg and the two Princeton men. “Then you think
it’s working around——”

“Yes—not in this generation, but eventually—things have got to work
round to a better basis. Bye and bye the world’ll get straightened
out—and it won’t go back to last century’s roller skates to do it,
either. It takes time, and costs a lot on the way—it cost me
you—anyway, it cost me an even chance for you.” He looked down at her
serious face and quoted lightly—

               “Might she have loved me? Just as well
               She might have hated me, who can tell.
               Where had I been now had the worst befell?

“Meanwhile—here we are sopping up the rain at Class Day—she and I!”

“Here I am keeping you from reuning with your class, you mean,” Joy
supplemented. “I must say good-bye and let you go back. I can’t tell you
how glad I am to have seen you now, Packy—to be able to remember you
like this——”

“Then—then I can’t see you again,” he stated, in a quiet voice.

“It—wouldn’t do much good—would it?”

He bowed. At a distance, it looked like a casual leavetaking between two
as casual acquaintances. “I—suppose not. Good-bye, Joy!” He took her
hand for the briefest fraction of a clasp, and left her.

People were jerking their way back through the entrances, and she joined
the fray. Out in the Stadium classes in gay costumes were walking into
the field; the rain was extending a few moments of leniency.

A fine drizzle started up with the air of permanency as the Ivy orator
finished his quips and Harvard-and-Its-Relations flocked from the
Stadium to the Yard. Joy wondered as she looked at the faces of the
girls passing by and then at their soiled-white-kid-feet, how many had
found heart to enjoy the exercises in concern for their apparel which
had to last through the dance that evening. Félicie had managed to keep
fairly dry, with the aid of her coat and umbrella, and was in average

They met Hal Jennings at his hall, where he was vibrating between ten
Relations, and joined the family board outdoors around a long table
sandwiched in with many others beneath an awning. The crowd pressing
about them was overpoweringly correct, and no one seemed to lose their
gaiety although the rain came through the awnings and the walking
underfoot was almost marshy by this time. Joy ate strawberries, her
teeth chattering with cold, and tried not to show that she was minding a
steady trickle down her back from a hole in the awning. She met several
nice looking boys who came up to greet Félicie, each of whom told Joy
that “it would have been an awfully pretty spread out here if it hadn’t
rained” and soon dashed back to their Relations.

“I wish you were going to stay to the dancing, and meet them when
they’re feeling right,” Félicie whispered. “Most of the Relations will
have gone by then.”

When Joy was able to beat a retreat politely, Félicie and Hal came to
the gate with her, and stood waving after her as she drove away in a
cab. Never had Félicie’s loveliness been so breath-taking. Little dark
rings of hair clung around her face, the damp air curling them into
tendrils no Permanent Wave could duplicate; her lips were parted in the
smile with which she could dazzle without bringing a wrinkle or cross
line into the pink and white perfection of her skin. It seemed almost
incredible that such wonder of nature could have so squandered itself on
one girl. . . .

Wearied by the events of the day, Joy went early to bed after giving
Madame Durant a sketch of the main events of the rain. Sleep came
reluctantly; she was thinking over Packy’s words. “No matter what the
women of to-day are making of themselves—they’re all we’ve got.” “Bye
and bye the world’ll get straightened out—it takes time—and costs a
lot on the way.” How Packy had changed from the casual, flippant,
“jazz-hound” of only last fall. To think about things so——She had made
an error common among girls—Because men of his type had never talked
seriously to her, she had supposed that they never thought seriously.

It was true; these days were, must be, but transitional.
Excitement-Eaters, dancers in the dark—all were part of the wheel of
progress that seems to go back at times before it turns forward again.
But “it takes time, and costs a lot on the way.”

It costs a lot, it costs a lot. Had she been asleep? She was still
repeating those words in the quiescent darkness of the room. What had
awakened her? The call of the telephone bell, a long shriek in the black
space of the night, answered her question. Still half dazed, she
stumbled to the door and into the hall. The telephone was on a little
table outside the kitchen. She made her way sat down. “Hello.”

“Hello. Is this Brighton 7560?”

It was a man’s voice speaking, speaking hurriedly, as if something
fearful was knocking behind every word, anxious to come out.

“Yes,” Joy steadied her voice. “Joy Nelson speaking.”

“Oh, Miss Nelson, is that you—Miss Nelson—I—we’ve had—this is Hal
Jennings speaking, Miss Nelson—I’m at the River Hill hospital—we’ve
had a—bad accident.”

The darkness swayed around Joy as blackness sways when one’s eyes are
closed and one presses one’s eyeballs. “Félicie—what of Félicie!” she
cried into the mouthpiece.

“She—she’s horribly hurt, Miss Nelson. We—we just brought her here. I
thought you’d be able to know—to notify——”

“Not—not _seriously_ hurt?” Joy gasped, pressing the receiver close to
her ear against the frenzy to throw it and its horror far from her.

“They don’t know yet—but they say they don’t think so. I—I’d come
right up here, if I were you, Miss Nelson.”

“I’ll be up as soon as I can get there!” she cried, and started to ring
off; but his voice arrested her.

“I ordered a taxi sent down for you—it’ll be there any time now.”

She put down the receiver and dashed back to her room, where she hurled
herself into her clothes, her brain a confusion of terrors which gave
way to compelled calm as she finished dressing and put on her hat. She
mustn’t lose her head. She mustn’t lose her head—no matter what had
happened. She mustn’t wake Madame Durant—when she saw the doctors, she
would know what to tell her, how best to soften the shock. She must
notify Greg, and she did not know his address. Learning it took going
through several of Félicie’s letters. Getting a sleepy Western Union
took more breathless moments. She finally sent the message: “Félicie
injured in accident, is at River Hill Hospital. Come at once. Joy
Nelson.” She glanced at her watch. It was three o’clock. Three o clock
in the morning, and a taxi was waiting outside!

The taxi-driver was an old Irishman with sideburns and a mouth which had
not gone shut since he had encountered the accident. She sat in front
with him and heard his story on the way. He had been going down the long
stretch of road in Wayland when he had encountered the wreck—car in the
ditch, young man with bloody face and one arm hanging loose, trying to
pull the young lady from beneath scatterings of glass that had been the
wind shield. The young man was so distraught-like he wouldn’t even have
heard a car go by, but he had pulled up and offered help. Together they
had taken away the glass embracing Félicie and carried her to the taxi.

“_Glass!_” cried Joy. “Did it—is her face——”

“I dunno, Miss. Couldn’t see much of it for blood.” And he resumed his
narration. The nearest hospital he knew was the River Hill, and they had
driven there. It was private, and it was not their custom to take
accident cases, but in the face of this piteous spectacle they could not
refuse admittance.

River Hill was on the outskirts of Brighton, and they had scaled the
hill almost before he finished the story. She paid him, with no time to
reflect that he had been paid in advance, no room for anything but the
horror of supposition, as she was admitted.

Hal Jennings was in the ante room off from the hall—his arm in a sling
and a bandage over one side of his face.

“Félicie!” Joy cried, without preface. “Was she cut? Did anything happen
to _her face_?”

“That’s what’s so terrible,” he said, looking away from her after his
first rush of relieved recognition. “My God, Miss Nelson,—it’s—it
looked as if it were cut to pieces.”

Félicie’s face! That glory and wonder of perfection—cut to pieces!
_What would be left?_ Her senses reeled.

“Where are the doctors? Where are they? I must see them. What do they

“They’re with her now. They’re coming down here—as soon as they

She looked at him, acknowledging his injuries for the first time. “You
weren’t hurt badly?”

“No.” He brushed his affairs aside. “What did you do—about notifying

“I didn’t wake Madame Durant. I wired her—her fiancé.”

“Her—fiancé!” He took a step back. “I didn’t know she was engaged.”

“She—isn’t,” mumbled Joy. “But it’s the man she loves and who loves her
and they intend to get married some day—what _do_ they call it

It was a ghostly place, a hospital at that hour of the morning. A nurse
dozed at the switchboard in the hall. The lights were subdued. Silence
was terrible.

“How—how did you happen to be out in Wayland, anyway?” she asked. “You
haven’t told me—anything.”

“Why—we left the dance about ten-thirty—Félicie was bored, and I’d had
enough of it—If we only had stayed!—and we motored out to the Red and
Black, where we ate and danced a while. We started back about
twelve-thirty. You know it’s a long way—we hadn’t been there much more
than an hour. Coming back we were both full of pep and decided to race
everything we saw. We didn’t see anything for a long time, and we were
afraid we weren’t going to get our chance, when turning into that
stretch of road up in Wayland we saw the tail light of a car at the
other end. I put on every bit of speed there was and we came along—I
don’t know how fast—as fast as the car can go—could go. It was a clear
stretch you see;—and then all at once the wheel went silly—just like
that! the steering gear broke—and before I knew even what had happened,
the car went into the ditch head foremost. I don’t know how long it was
after that I came to and shuffled around. It was sure fortunate that
that cab should have happened along.”

He was talking in little, weary jerks. For the first time Joy thought of
his side of the matter—His car smashed, and himself put out of active
business on his Class Day night—what interpretation would his parents
put on these unglossable facts?

“I’m sorry for you, Mr. Jennings,” she said. “Your people—it’s a

He acknowledged this with a nod that showed the subject had occurred to
him before. “Nothing really matters if Félicie comes out all right. All
the same—my people will never understand or believe how this came
about—or get over it.”

“Older people are that way,” said Joy.

“It won’t get into the papers, anyway—not from this hospital, thank
God! And I’ve bribed the cabman.”

A step in the halls, and a young man in white linen came to the door.

“Dr. Dexter!” said Hal. Joy was on one side of him, as he came to the
other. “Félicie—is she—how is she?”

“Félicie’s all right,” he said, and smiled meaninglessly at them. “Not a
bone broken, although she is bruised and shaken and pretty badly cut.
We’ve been taking some stitches—beautiful work——”

“But her face—her face,” cried Joy, “was her face cut? Tell us——”

“Her face—yes. It was cut rather badly. But it’s been sewed up now, and
with some novacain she will have an easy night.”

“But will she—will the cuts heal? Cuts do heal, don’t they?” Joy

“Oh, certainly, cuts heal. Of course, there’ll be a nasty scar pretty
much over the whole of her face——”

She blinked her eyes at the white-coated doctor who could say such
unthinkable things with brisk, unchanged readiness. “Félicie’s face
scarred. She was—she was the loveliest thing you ever saw. The
loveliest thing you ever saw.”

“I would suggest,” said the doctor, “that you both go home and get a
little sleep. Everything will be better in the morning. Perhaps you can
even see her then.”

“_See her!_” Hal Jennings echoed.

Joy looked at his face. Pity, of course—but strongest, the recoil of

Later, she could not force her troubled brain to sleep. Félicie of the
unforgettable loveliness—with her face puckered into scars—How would a
love that had been sorely tried already receive this hideousness? And
how—how to tell Madame Durant. . . .

When the yellow rays of a spotless morning scoured clean by yesterday’s
rainfall embraced her room, she rose and whipped up her flagging nerves
with a cold sponge. Before the world-conquering exhilaration of the
plunge could wear off, she poured a concise account of the accident into
the ear-trumpet, minimizing it to such an extent that Madame Durant
demanded why they hadn’t brought Félicie straight home.

“Her cuts are too many,” Joy explained, “but the important thing is
there are no bones broken, no serious injuries.”

The two reached the hospital at nine o’clock and waited an hour before
Madame Durant was allowed to go in and sit by Félicie’s bed for five
minutes. The old lady came down rather shaken. “She’s all bandaged up,”
she said, “and of course she can’t talk loud enough for me to hear.”
“But she’s doing splendidly,” amended the nurse who had accompanied her.

“May—may I go on now?” asked Joy.

The nurse hesitated. “I really wouldn’t—so soon after this call——”

“Then I’ll wait, if you’ll let me know when I can come.” So Joy waited
alone in the ante room, and answered Hal Jennings’ anxious inquiries
over the phone. . . .

Finally the nurse who smiled like an automaton came to the door and
beckoned. Joy looked at her watch. It was half past twelve; she had been
in the anteroom over three hours.

A long white bed with a long, white figure, the white coverlet lapping
itself around the gracious lines. Félicie’s hair in a loose, thick
braid, her tendrils sketching dark fancies over the pillow. A mass of
bandages, from which Félicie’s perfect lips escaped, unharmed. Félicie’s
brown velvet eyes peering oddly from recesses in the bandaging. “Joy”
—said the lips and her voice carried high lights scarcely dimmed by
pain—“you are a darling. Miss Clark, I _must_ have a glass of water!”

As the nurse vanished—“That was just to get her out. She’s always here.
She drives me wild!” A little pause; and the figure stirred.
“Joy—you’ll tell me, won’t you? My face—what’s going to come of it?
It’s so cut—and no one will tell me—how it’s going to look.”

“How can anyone know so soon?” said Joy with taut lips. The brown eyes
looked at her for a steadfast minute, over their horizon of bandaging.

“Never mind, Joy—I know. My face—oh, I can’t say it! But I know. I can
feel there isn’t even much of it left.”

“Cuts always feel worse than they are——”

“I could tell. By the way they looked when I said anything. My
eyes—were left whole.” Her voice was conversational. “Why wasn’t I—cut
_all_ to pieces while I was about it? I might just as well be dead.”

“Félicie, you mustn’t say such things!” Joy said weakly.

“I might—just as well be dead. You can’t deny it. What is left me? No
man could stand a face all gashed and sewed——”

“You don’t _know_ it’s going to be all——”

“Oh, yes—I do. . . . Don’t let Hal Jennings come in here—will you? I
know it wasn’t his fault—we would never have left the dance if I hadn’t
wanted some excitement—but he stands for—everything for which I’ve
always passed up Greg and the only things that matter. The—only
things—that matter! They all come under—love, Joy. And I passed Greg
up—and now it’s too late.”

An interlude while the nurse appeared and pleasantly hinted for Joy’s
departure, which brought about a paroxysm beneath the bandages,——

“I want her to stay! She’s got to stay! It isn’t as if I were really
sick! I wish I was, but you know I’m not! She’s got to stay! You can go
to your lunch now, or something! You know the doctor said I could see
people and be alone and things!”

And when the nurse departed, whether on a search for the doctor or her
lunch Joy did not know; “I hate her! Oh, my God, I wish I were dead!”

It was at that awful moment while Joy racked her bursting brain for what
to say that a knock came at the door.

“Don’t let them in. It’s another nurse, or something. I’m not well
enough to have a bath yet, and they keep talking about it.”

The knock was repeated, and the door flung open. Greg was in the
doorway; the boy in his face gone to manhood, his skin the color of
untarnished silver.

“They told me—_Félicie_!” and he crossed to the bed, his eyes
travelling over Joy as if she were the little rug that was on the floor.
“Félicie, my darling—thank God you’re here!”

“Greg!” the perfect lips articulated. “Greg—how did you come here?—Go

“Go away! When I’ve done nothing else but aim for your side since I
heard. . . . How are you feeling, dear? They told me downstairs that you
would be quite all right in a short time——”

“You don’t understand, Greg. They didn’t tell you—” the bandages
quivered. Joy interposed.

“Félicie, you really aren’t well enough—we’ll go now, and come back

“I want him to hear first! I want him to hear first! Greg,—my face is
cut to pieces. I shall never be beautiful again. I can say I was now,
because I’m—not—any more. I’ll be ugly—-horrible—do you hear? Now go
away! I never—never want to see you again!”

The brown eyes closed, the mouth relaxed, drawn down by little quivers
of agony. For one minute of heart’s horror Greg stood silent above the
bed. Over by the door Joy watched, breath caught in midair, as the boy
suddenly went on his knees beside the bed and fell to stroking her
prodigal hair.

“Why—sweetheart!” he said, in a crooning voice—almost like that of a
mother soothing a Bogey-terrified child—“what do you think a few little
cuts on the face amount to? You couldn’t be anything but beautiful if
you—tried! Your hair—it’s the most wonderful hair in the world! Your
form—that in itself would make a beauty out of most girls! Your eyes,
Félicie—and your—lips!”

And, his head bowed, he kissed the lips.

It was then that the nurse returned, armed with an official looking
interne. Miss Durant was to remain absolutely undisturbed, which was
certainly not her condition at present. . . . To-morrow she would be
better able to receive—strenuous callers. . . .

Joy and Greg left in a silence which lasted until they reached
out-of-doors. Then Greg spoke: “I’ll go in town and get settled
somewhere, then I’ll come back and camp around the place. They’ve got to
let me see her again to-day.”

“But do you think they will, when they said——”

“She’s got to hear me! There she is thinking—thinking a few little cuts
will make any difference to me——”

“It’s—it’s more than few little cuts, Greg.”

“Well—what if it is? She’s the girl I love. How could she think that I
would—that I could—stop caring for her—because she is the victim of a
hideous accident?”

Joy became conscious that she was looking at a very wonderful thing. A
man in the world she had been learning to view so cynically—a man who
was not made of such slim elements that he could cease to love. . . .
And so she made her discovery. _A man does not love a girl for what is
in her. He loves her for and with what is in him._ What could be greater
honour than to have the love of a man such as he?

He took her to the door of Félicie’s apartment, and she went in to
reassure Madame Durant with tales of how much Félicie had been able to
talk and how comfortable, comparatively, she was. It approached the time
to start in town for her lesson, and she gathered up her music from the
little upright, with loving hands. All passes; Art alone endures.

Then suddenly Joy cried: “_No—No!_” in such a rending voice that some
faint echo penetrated even to Madame Durant, who made her way into the
living-room in time to see Joy throw her music violently from her. It
scattered over the room, in a chaos of sheets, a wilderness of notes.

“Why, Joy!” the old lady said reprovingly, and reached for the
ear-trumpet to hear an explanation of this pettish behavior. But Joy,
with a strange, breathless look, dashed by her down the hall.

She went into her room and closed the door. It was a long afternoon.
Part of the time she would fall into a sleepy contemplation of the wall,
but between these blanks she thought. The only things that matter! They
all come under—love.

She had always known this. She had been building of herself a temple to
love, when blaspheming hands had shaken the temple, leaving love a thing
to be feared. She had shuddered away from love and turned to music. That
could not turn and rend her. . . . Then love had come, again, so bright
and pure a thing that she could not be afraid. But the bright blaze had
burned itself out, and then when nothing was left . . . there was music.
And the soul of music had united with her own soul as had been
predicted—weaving itself ever more closely into her being. Then love
had come again—and this time it had not burst upon her in the flame of
romance, the golden glory of dreams; instead, it had quietly encompassed
her until she knew—that it spelled all of life to her. Keeping pace
with music, it had woven itself ever more closely into her being. The
discovery had made her dismiss it—as if a thing that had had become a
part of her, could be dismissed. _But music was a part of her, too!_

Félicie had given up “the only things that matter,” and met her terrible
lesson. She, Joy, must cease wavering in the world of phantoms, of those
who put love aside, those to whom it does not come, and those who are
incapable of love.

It was towards evening that she telephoned Jim. A dreadful fear assailed
her while she was waiting for him to come to the wire. Supposing he were
sick! Supposing he wouldn’t be there—She had always regarded him as an
institution that never failed. She had heard of girls regarding men in
that way before—and how they had been surprised when they turned to the
institution, after a long time. In her overtired, overwrought condition,
his familiar voice brought a relief so great as to be almost hysterical.
She babbled out the story of Félicie’s calamity, and implored him to
come out. She implored him with unnecessary fervour. . . . When she had
rung off, she realized that she was overdoing things, and calmed down to
the extent of telephoning the hospital and getting Greg on the wire. He
informed her that as yet he had not been able to see Félicie.

“I brought bales of roses that they’ve surrounded her with in her bed,”
he said; “and she always likes things like that.”

“I’ll be up later;” and Joy relayed the latest bulletin to Madame
Durant, who had several times during the day arrayed herself in her
bonnet and cloak preparatory to another journey to the hospital, being
stopped each time by Joy’s assurances concerning the futility of another
visit that day.

“Why don’t you practice?” asked the old lady, now noting her
restlessness. “You haven’t practiced at all to-day—and I don’t know
what Félicie’d do, if she could see all that music spilled on the
parlour floor.”

Joy took the hint, and went to pick up her music. All the sweepingly
dramatic moments of life seem to have the inglorious aftermath of
picking up after oneself. It was a slow process, putting the sheets
together, sorting them. When she came to a favorite, or an intriguing
bit, she would sit on her feet and play on the glorified instrument that
her voice had now become, and amuse herself by letting her voice go off
in sky-rockets.

It was so that Jim’s ring found her—eyes a warm heliotrope, cheeks in
exultant flame, as singing well always left her. He dwelt on her
radiance a moment before he spoke.

“Joy, that’s ghastly about Félicie—but I’ve been thinking it over—and
I know this plastic surgery they used in the war can do something—they
say sometimes it makes people better looking than they were before they
had to have it done.”

“Plastic surgery!” Joy cried.

“Yes—Of course, Nature had done so much for Félicie that it might be
hard to improve upon what there was before in that case; but they can do
a lot. The doctors there have probably got that up their sleeves, and
are waiting to see how the cuts heal.”

“I must telephone Greg,” Joy flashed; but she paused a moment before
going down the hall. Madame Durant’s door was open, and if she saw that
Joy had finished her picking up, she might come into the parlor. Once
there, she was good for the evening, as Félicie had often warned her.

“Jim,” she said softly, “you’re always solving problems for me—aren’t

She came up to him, gingerly, and stopped while still a little distance
away. Although the fire of song was still spreading its flame within
her—she was very sure. But how did one say these things?

“Solve just one more for me, Jim—and then we’ll either be through—or
just beginning. If—if I needed you—and needed my music too—what—what
would be the answer?”

“I—I don’t know what you mean, Joy,” he said, all at once very white
and intent. “But any answer to a question like that would be—love. I
love you—all of you. Your voice, your music is a part of you and I love
that too. If—if you needed me—and needed music—you could have both.
It’s been done by others. Men are not so conceited nowadays that they
imagine they can mean everything to a woman. Does—does that help you in
your problems?”

“Yes, it does!” she cried, suddenly exultant, “Jim—I need you more than
my music, or anything else in this world! Music and love go hand in
hand—but now I know—that love always leads the way!”

She was in his arms; peace that she had never known was sighing its way
into all her being; and an ecstasy born of that peace, that transcended
all the beauty of music heard or dreamed.

                                THE END

                          Transcriber’s Notes

Obvious printing errors have been silently corrected.

Inconsistencies in hyphenation, spelling and punctuation have been

*** End of this Doctrine Publishing Corporation Digital Book "Dancers in the Dark" ***

Doctrine Publishing Corporation provides digitized public domain materials.
Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians.
This effort is time consuming and expensive, so in order to keep providing
this resource, we have taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties,
including placing technical restrictions on automated querying.

We also ask that you:

+ Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Doctrine Publishing
Corporation's ISYS search for use by individuals, and we request that you
use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes.

+ Refrain from automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort
to Doctrine Publishing's system: If you are conducting research on machine
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a
large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of
public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help.

+ Keep it legal -  Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for
ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because
we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States,
that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries.
Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we
can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is
allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Doctrine Publishing
ISYS search  means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world.
Copyright infringement liability can be quite severe.

About ISYS® Search Software
Established in 1988, ISYS Search Software is a global supplier of enterprise
search solutions for business and government.  The company's award-winning
software suite offers a broad range of search, navigation and discovery
solutions for desktop search, intranet search, SharePoint search and embedded
search applications.  ISYS has been deployed by thousands of organizations
operating in a variety of industries, including government, legal, law
enforcement, financial services, healthcare and recruitment.